Oncogene (2001) 20, 7029 ± 7040
2001 Nature Publishing Group All rights reserved 0950 ± 9232/01 $15.00
ã
Induction of a TRAIL mediated suicide program by interferon alpha in primary eusion lymphoma
Ngoc L Toomey1,4, Vadim V Deyev2,4, Charles Wood3, Lawrence H Boise2, Duncan Scott1, Lei Hua Liu1, Lisa Cabral1, Eckhard R Podack2, Glen N Barber2 and William J Harrington Jr*,1
2
1Department of Medicine University of Miami School of Medicine, Miami, Florida, FL 33136, USA; Department of Microbiology and Immunology, University of Miami School of Medicine, Miami, Florida, FL 33136, USA; School of Biological Sciences, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Nebraska, NE 68588, USA
3
Gammaherpes viruses are often detected in lymphomas arising in immunocompromised patients. We have found that Azidothymidine (AZT) alone induces apoptosis in Epstein Barr Virus (EBV) positive Burkitt's lymphoma (BL) cells but requires interferon alpha (IFN-a) to induce apoptosis in Human Herpes Virus Type 8 (HHV-8) positive Primary Eusion Lymphomas (PEL). Our analysis of a series of AIDS lymphomas revealed that IFN-a selectively induced very high levels of the Death Receptor (DR) tumor necrosis factor-related apoptosisinducing ligand (TRAIL) in HHV-8 positive PEL lines and primary tumor cells whereas little or no induction was observed in primary EBV+ AIDS lymphomas and EBV7Burkitt's lines. AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis in PEL was blocked by stable overexpression of dominant negative Fas Associated Death Domain (FADD), decoy receptor 2 (DcR2), soluble TRAIL receptor fusion proteins (DR-4 and DR-5) and thymidine. Trimeric TRAIL (in place of IFN-a) similarly synergized with AZT to induce apoptosis in HHV-8 positive PEL cells. This is the ®rst demonstration that IFN-a induces functional TRAIL in a malignancy that can be exploited to eect a suicide program. This novel antiviral approach to Primary Eusion lymphomas is targeted and may represent a highly eective and relatively non-toxic therapy. Oncogene (2001) 20,
7029 ± 7040.
Virus (EBV) or Human Herpes Virus Type 8 (HHV-8) have been isolated from lymphomas found in immunosuppressed organ transplant recipients, children with hereditary immunode®ciencies and patients with acquired immunode®ciency (AIDS) (Swinnen, 1999; Goldsby and Carroll, 1998; Knowles, 1999). Many of these tumors can be categorized into distinct subtypes based on a variety of morphologic and molecular criteria. For example, AIDS associated large cell diuse or immunoblastic lymphomas (DLCL, IBL) are often EBV positive while AIDS associated Burkitt's lymphomas (BL) less frequently contain EBV (Gaidano et al., 1994). A recently de®ned subtype, AIDS related HHV-8 associated Primary Eusion Lymphoma (PEL) (Nador et al., 1996), usually occurs in the setting of severe immunode®ciency of advanced HIV infection. PELs dier from most AIDS lymphomas by their absence of a discernable primary tumor mass, infre-
- quent expression of
- B
- lymphocyte dierentiation
antigens, and lack of c-myc gene rearrangement (Mullaney et al., 2000; Gaidano et al., 2000; Demario and Liebowitz, 1998). In general, immunode®ciency related herpesvirus associated lymphomas are aggressive and poorly responsive to conventional chemotherapy (Swinnen, 2000; Levine, 2000).
Although AZT was originally developed as an anticancer agent, this thymidine nucleoside analog has demonstrated relatively little activity in solid tumors (Findenig et al., 1996). Interest in AZT was revived only when it was found to inhibit HIV reverse transcriptase (De Clercq, 1992). To exert this antiviral activity, AZT must be phosphorylated by cellular thymidine kinase (TK) (Arner et al., 1992). Our initial studies indicated that there were two distinctly dierent pro-apoptotic eects of AZT and Interferon alpha (IFN-a) in primary lymphoma cell lines derived from AIDS patients. EBV+ BL cells underwent apoptosis in the presence of AZT alone while HHV-8+ PELs required the addition of IFN-a to undergo signi®cant programmed cell death (Lee et al., 1999).
Keywords: human Herpes Virus Type 8; Epstein Barr virus; TRAIL; apoptosis; lymphoma; FADD
Introduction
Gammaherpes viruses are frequently associated with lymphoproliferative disease in immunocompromised individuals (Okano and Gross, 2000). Epstein-Barr
*Correspondence: WJ Harrington Jr, University of Miami School of Medicine/Sylvester Comprehensive Cancer Center, Room 3400 (D8- 4), 1475 NW 12th Avenue, Miami, Florida, FL 33136, USA; E-mail: [email protected]
Interferons have multiple activities involved in host defense including anti-proliferative and antiviral eects. It is known that the interferons, which are potently upregulated by viruses and double stranded RNA (dsRNA), can synthesize eectors of apoptosis such as
4These authors contributed equally to this work Received 14 May 2001; revised 17 July 2001; accepted 2 August 2001
Interferon induces TRAIL in primary effusion lymphoma
NL Toomey et al
7030
2'5' oligoadenylate synthetase (2' ± 5'A) which activates RNAseL and degrades viral mRNA (Player and Torrence, 1998). Interferon also induces synthesis of dsRNA activated protein kinase (PKR), which phosphorylates the translation initiator eIF-2-a and inhibits protein synthesis in the cell (Zamanian-Daryoush et al., 2000). Recently, interferons were also found to induce expression of the pro-apoptotic protein tumor necrosis factor-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL) in human dendritic cells and T lymphocytes which is capable of inducing apoptosis in TRAIL receptor expressing targets (Fanger et al., 1999; Grith et al., 1999; Balachandran et al., 2000).
These data demonstrate that IFN-a upregulates
TRAIL in Primary Eusion Lymphomas while AZT sensitizes these cells to TRAIL mediated apoptosis resulting in the activation of a suicide program in this cancer. The unique tumorcidal eect of AZT and IFN-a may have important applications for therapy of herpesvirus associated lymphoproliferative disease.
Results
AZT and IFN-a act synergistically to induce apoptosis in HHV-8+ PEL cells
IFN also potentiates the adaptive immune response through upregulation of major histocompatibility complexes (MHC) and activation of cytotoxic T cells (CTLs) and natural killer cells (NKs) (Mingari et al., 2000). CTLs can recognize and kill cells that present foreign peptides, in association with MHC, through the perforin/granzyme pathway (Barry et al., 2000). Another important mechanism of immune eector clearance of virally infected or cancerous cells is by transmission of an apoptotic signal through ligand binding to members of the tumor necrosis (TNF) family of receptors (Peter et al., 1997). The binding of ligands such as Fas-L or TRAIL to extracellular receptor domains (APO-1 (Fas/CD95), DR-5) results in recruitment of components of the death domain containing the adaptor molecule Fas associated death domain (FADD) and subsequent activation of FLICE (caspase 8) by autoproteolysis. Following recruitment and cleavage of procaspase 8, downstream caspases are activated, including caspase 3, resulting in apoptosis. TRAIL mediated signaling and apoptosis is blocked upon its binding to decoy receptors (DcR1, DcR2) which do not recruit FADD (Walczak and Krammer, 2000; Ashkenazi and Dixit, 1999; Bodmer et al., 2000). The role of DR-4 in apoptosis is unclear since its expression in FADD7/7 ®broblasts still results in cell death (Yeh et al., 1998). Signaling through other members of the TNF receptor family also may activate non-apoptotic processes such as in¯ammatory responses and lymphoid organogenesis (Magnusson and Vaux, 1999).
We have demonstrated that AZT and IFN-a have clinical activity against malignant herpesvirus associated lymphomas (Lee et al., 1999). To further investigate the apoptotic eects, we studied the HHV-8+ PEL lines, BC-3 and BCBL-1, as well as the EBV+ AIDS BL primary lines, BL-7 and BL-5. All lines were cultured for 48 h in the presence of medium, AZT (10 mg/ml) or IFN-a (1000 u/ml) alone, or AZT and IFN-a together. As shown in Figure 1a, AZT alone induced marked apoptosis in the EBV+Burkitt's lymphoma lines (BL-7, BL-5) while IFN-a did not induce apoptosis nor add to the cytopathic eect of AZT. In contrast, HHV-8+ PEL cells (BC-3, BCBL-1) only underwent marked apoptosis in the presence of both AZT and IFN-a (Figure 1a). Similar experiments revealed that other HHV-8+ PEL lines, BC-1 and BC-5, also required both AZT and IFN-a to undergo signi®cant apoptosis (data not shown). Therefore, a general property of HHV-8+ PEL cells was that AZT and IFN-a induced substantial apoptosis together but not separately. This cytotoxic eect was seen only in virus infected lymphomas as both agents had no eect on herpes virus negative BL cells (Ramos) (Figure 1b). Further experiments on another herpesvirus negative lymphoma cell line (BJAB) demonstrated that AZT, with or without IFN-a, induced little or no cytotoxic activity (data not shown).
To further investigate the mechanism of AZT and
IFN-a mediated apoptosis, we studied a series of lymphoma cell lines and primary lymphoma cells derived from AIDS patients. We report here that HHV-8+ PEL cell lines and primary tumor cells from a PEL patient express high levels of TRAIL when cultured with IFN-a. Despite the induction of TRAIL in PEL cells by IFN-a, apoptosis was only potentiated upon the addition of AZT. In PEL cells, AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis was blocked by expression of dominant negative FADD (FADD DN), decoy receptor 2 (DcR2), soluble TRAIL receptor fusion proteins and by the addition of thymidine. In contrast to HHV-8+ PEL, EBV+ AIDS BL lines and EBV7 BL lines did not express signi®cant amounts of TRAIL, nor undergo increased apoptosis in response to IFN-a.
IFN-a induces TRAIL in PEL cells
It has recently been shown that IFN-a mediates the expression of several pro-apoptotic genes and can
- induce cell death through
- a
- FADD dependent
mechanism (Balachandran et al., 2000). Since IFN-a potentiated apoptosis in PEL, we investigated its eect on the regulation of pro-apoptotic factors in IFN-a sensitive and resistant B cell lymphomas. Accordingly, BC-3 and BL-7 cells were treated for 8 h with AZT (10 mg/ml), IFN-a (1000 m/ml) or the chemotherapeutic agent etoposide (10 mg/ml). Total RNA was extracted and analysed for pro-apoptotic gene expression by ribonuclease protection assay (RPA). RPA analysis revealed that IFN-a induced markedly higher levels of TRAIL mRNA in the IFN- a sensitive PEL cells (BC-3) compared to the resistant
Oncogene
Interferon induces TRAIL in primary effusion lymphoma
NL Toomey et al
7031
EBV+ BL cells (BL-5) (Figure 2a, lanes 2 and 4 compared to lanes 7 and 9). In contrast, AZT and etoposide, at doses sucient to kill these cells, had no eect on TRAIL expression in either type of
ab
Figure 1 (a) AZT and IFN-a synergize to induce apoptosis in HHV-8+ PEL (BC-3, BCBL-1) while EBV+ BL cells (BL-5, BL-7) undergo apoptosis with AZT alone. BC-3 and BCBL-1 (HHV-8+ PEL's) and BL-5 and BL-7 (EBV+ BL's) were treated in medium (Panels A), AZT 10 mg/ml (Panels B), IFN-a 1000 u/ml (Panels C), or AZT 10 mg/ml plus IFN-a 1000 u/ml (Panels D) for 48 h. Cells were then analysed for apoptosis by PI annexin staining and FACs analysis. Upper and lower right quadrants are the apoptotic populations. (b) AZT and IFN-a are synergistically cytotoxic in HHV-8+ PEL but not EBV7 BL. PEL cells BCBL-1 and BC-3, EBV+ BL cells BL-5 and BL-7, and EBV7 Ramos cells were cultured for 48 h in medium (control), IFN-a 1000 u/ml, AZT 10 mg/ml, and IFN-a 1000 u/ml plus AZT 10 mg/ml. Cell viability was then determined by Trypan blue exclusion. Bars represent per cent viable cells
Oncogene
Interferon induces TRAIL in primary effusion lymphoma
NL Toomey et al
7032
lymphoma (Figure 2a, lanes 3 and 5 and lanes 8 and 10). We then investigated the eect of IFN-a on a larger panel of lymphoma lines including HHV-8+ PELs, EBV+ BLs (derived from HIV positive patients) and EBV7 BL lines. We found that IFN- a signi®cantly induced TRAIL mRNA only in the HHV-8+ PEL lines and primary tumor cells (BCBL- LN) derived from a patient with PEL, while little or no induction was noted either in EBV positive or negative BL lines. IFN-a also had no eect on the expression of two death receptors, DR-4 and DR-5, which are known to bind to TRAIL (Figure 2b). Further RPA experiments demonstrated that neither AZT nor IFN-a aected mRNA or protein surface expression levels of DR-4 or DR-5 in PEL cells (data not shown). FACS analysis demonstrated that IFN-a induced TRAIL protein surface expression in PEL cells but not in EBV+ BL cells (Figure 2c, panels 3 and 4 versus panels 1 and 2). Therefore, the ability of IFN-a to potentiate AZT mediated apoptosis in PEL correlated with its ability to induce the proapoptotic ligand TRAIL in these tumors.
ab
AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis in PEL is FADD dependent
TRAIL has been reported to induce apoptosis by binding its cognate receptors. Furthermore, TRAIL mediated apoptosis has recently been shown to be dependent upon signaling through the death adaptor protein FADD (Bodmer et al., 2000). To investigate the mechanism of IFN-a induced apoptosis we ®rst con®rmed that HHV-8+ PEL cells (BCBL-1) did express TRAIL receptors on their surface (DR-4 was more highly expressed than DR-5) (Figure 3a). BC-3 cells also expressed similar levels of DR-4 and DR-5 (data not shown). To study whether apoptosis induced by AZT and IFN-a in PEL involved a FADD dependent mechanism, we transfected the BCBL-1 line with a dominant negative construct of FADD that lacks a death eector domain (Bala-
c
AZT 10 mg/ml. Lane 4=BC-3 in IFN-a 1000 u/ml and AZT 10 mg/ml. Lane 5=BC-3 in etoposide 10 mg/ml. Lane 6=BL-5 in medium. Lane 7=BL-5 in IFN-a 1000 u/ml. Lane 8=BL-5 in AZT 10 mg/ml. Lane 9=BL-5 in IFN-a 1000 u/ml and AZT 10 mg/ml. Lane 10=BL-5 in etoposide 10 mg/ml. (b) IFN-a induces a high level of expression of TRAIL mRNA in HHV- 8+ PEL but not EBV+ BL and EBV7 BL. PEL lines and primary tumor isolates (BCBL-1, BC-3, BC-1, BCBL-LN, BC-2, BC-5), EBV+ BL (P3HR-1), EBV+AIDS BL lines (BL-8, SM-1, BL-5, BL-7), and EBV7 BL lines (Ramos, BJAB) were treated with media (C) or IFN-a 1000 u/ml (I) for 8 h. mRNA was extracted and assayed by ribonuclease protection assay for expression of DR-4, DR-5 and TRAIL. GAPDH expression was used as an internal control. (c) IFN-a induces TRAIL surface expression in HHV-8+ PEL but not EBV+ BL. EBV+ BL: BL- 5 and BL-7 cells (Panels 1 and 2) and HHV-8+ PEL cells: BCBL- 1 and BC-3 (Panels 3 and 4) were treated for 24 h with IFN-a 1000 u/ml or media and assayed for TRAIL expression by FACs analysis. Shaded area equals isotype control (mouse IgG1). Dotted line are cells treated with media and solid line are cells treated with IFN-a
Figure 2 (a) TRAIL mRNA is induced by IFN-a but not by AZT or Etoposide in HHV-8+ PEL. PEL cells (BC-3, Lanes 1 ± 5) and EBV+cells (BL-5, Lanes 6 ± 10) were treated in the following manner for 8 h and examined for TRAIL mRNA expression by ribonuclease protection assay. Lane 1=BC-3 in medium. Lane 2=BC-3 in IFN-a 1000 u/ml. Lane 3=BC-3 in
Oncogene
Interferon induces TRAIL in primary effusion lymphoma
NL Toomey et al
7033
chandran et al., 2000). After G418 selection, we derived several stably transfected subclones which
FADD protein (BCBL FADD DN) (Figure 3b). BCBL FADD DN cells were completely resistant to
- AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis but retained
- expressed
- a
- dominant negative mutation of the
- a
- d
bc
Figure 3 (a) HHV-8+ PEL cells express TRAIL receptors. PEL cells (BCBL-1) were grown in IMDM media enriched with 10% FCS and surface expression of DR-5 (dotted line) and DR-4 (solid line) was determined by FACs analysis. Shaded area is mouse isotype control (IgG1). (b) Transfection of BCBL-1 cells with FADD-DN. BCBL-1 cells were transfected with FADD-DN by electroporation. Subclones were derived after G418 selection. Subclones (BCBL-2A4, BCBL-3A3, BCBL-3B2, BCBL-3C2, and BCBL-1A2), BCBL-Neo (transfected with neo-resistance gene only), and BCBL-1 parental cells were assayed for expression of FADD and FADD-DN by Western blot. (c) BCBL-1 FADD-DN cells are resistant to AZT and IFN-a but sensitive to VP-16. BCBL-1, BCBL-1 Neo transfectants and BCBL-1 FADD-DN clones (BCBL-2A4, BCBL-3C2, BCBL-1A2) were treated for 48 h with medium, AZT 10 mg/ml, IFN-a 1000 u/ml, AZT 10 mg/ml plus IFN-a 1000 u/ml, or VP-16 10 mg/ml (for 24 h) and cell death was measured by Trypan blue exclusion. The ®gure is representative of 52 experiments. (d) BCBL-1 FADD-DN cells express TRAIL in response to IFN-a. BCBL-1A2 cells were treated with medium (C) or IFN-a (I) for 8 h and caspase 8, DR-4 and DR-5 expression levels were detected by RPA
Oncogene
Interferon induces TRAIL in primary effusion lymphoma
NL Toomey et al
7034
their sensitivity to etoposide (Figure 3c). To determine that resistant cells were not generated by the selection process, clones were also characterized for expression of anti-apoptotic proteins, Bcl-2 and Bcl-x and found to express similar low levels (compared to the parental BCBL-1 cells) of each protein (data not shown). BCBL-1 FADD DN cells also expressed similar levels of DR-4 and DR-5 and TRAIL mRNA when treated with IFN-a (Figure 3d). Therefore, our data indicates that apoptosis induced by AZT and IFN-a in HHV-8+ PEL is a FADD dependent process.
- a
- c
b
Figure 4 (a) Activation of caspases 3 and 8 by AZT and IFN-a in PEL cells is blocked by the caspase inhibitor DEVD and expression of FADD DN. PEL cells; BC-3 (top panel), BCBL-1 (middle panel) and BCBL-1A2 (FADD-DN cells) (lower panel) were cultured for 48 h in media (C), IFN-a 1000 u/ml (I), AZT 10 mg/ml (A), AZT 10 mg/ml plus IFN-a 1000 u/ml (A+I), AZT 10 mg/ml and IFN-a 1000 u/ml plus the caspase inhibitor DEVD 10 mM (A+I+D) and assayed by Western blot for caspase 3 and 8. The caspase 8 antibody used only detects the uncleaved pro-caspase form. (b) Soluble TRAIL receptors inhibit AZT and IFN-a mediated cytotoxicity in PEL cells. BCBL-1 (HHV-8+ PEL cells) were treated in triplicate with the following conditions: medium (Control); AZT 10 mg/ml+IFN-a 1000 u/ml; soluble DR-4 2 mg/ml+soluble DR-5 5 ng/ml; pre-treatment for 8 h with soluble DR- 4 2 mg/ml and soluble DR-5 5 ng/ml followed by treatment for 48 h with AZT 10 mg/ml+IFN-a 1000 u/ml; pre-treatment for 8 h with soluble DR-4 2 mg/ml+soluble DR-5 5 ng/ml+ZB4 1 mg/ml followed by treatment for 48 h with AZT 10 mg/ml and IFN-a 1000 u/ml; TRAIL 100 ng/ml; pre-treatment for 8 h with soluble DR-4 2 mg/ml+soluble DR-5 5 ng/ml followed by treatment for 48 h with TRAIL 100 ng/ml. Cytotoxicity was measured after 48 h by Trypan blue exclusion. (c) DcR2 expression in BCBL-1 blocks apoptosis induced by AZT and IFN-a. Top panel: Flow cytometry pro®les of DcR2 expression in transfected BCBL-1 cells (bold line) versus wild type (thin line). Dotted line is isotype control. Bottom panel: Wild type and BCBL-1 cells were treated with IFN-a 1000 u/ml, AZT 10 mg/ml or IFN-a 1000 u/ml plus AZT 10 mg/ml and viability was measured by Trypan blue exclusion
Oncogene
Interferon induces TRAIL in primary effusion lymphoma
NL Toomey et al
7035
combined with AZT in PEL cells. We found that in PEL cells, TRAIL and AZT caused a synergistic proapoptotic eect similar to that caused by IFN-a and AZT (Figure 5a, panel E compared to panel C). Similar to AZT and IFN-a, AZT and TRAIL were not cytotoxic to FADD DN BCBL-1 cells (Figure 5b). These data indicate that AZT enhances TRAIL mediated apoptosis in HHV-8+ PEL cells.
AZT and IFN-a induces cleavage of caspases 3 and 8 in PEL which is inhibited by soluble DR-4, DR-5 or DcR2
Apoptosis mediated through death receptor ligand pathways involves the recruitment of proteins forming the death inducing signaling complex (DISC) resulting in cleavage (activation) of procaspase 8 (FLICE) to its active form and subsequent activation of downstream pro-caspases (Kischkel et al., 1995; Medema et al., 1997). We therefore treated HHV-8+ PEL cells (BCBL-1 and BC-3) and BCBL-DN FADD transfectants (BCBL-1A2) with AZT, IFN-a, or AZT plus IFN-a and assayed for procaspase 8 cleavage. Treatment with either agent alone resulted in no cleavage of procaspase 8. However in BC-3 and BCBL-1 cells, AZT and IFN-a together activated procaspase 8 and procaspase 3 but did not in BCBL-1A2 (FADD DN) cells (Figure 4a, lane 4). We did note some cleavage of procaspase 3 in AZT treated BCBL-1 and BC-3 PEL cells which indicates that AZT alone does cause some degree of apoptosis in PEL cells (lane 3). Treatment with the caspase inhibitor DEVD abrogated AZT and IFN-a mediated cleavage of both procaspases in PEL cells (lane 5). Caspase inhibition of AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis with IETD, a speci®c caspase 8 inhibitor, was not possible since the inhibitor itself was toxic to PEL cells (data not shown). We then investigated whether inhibition of TRAIL with soluble TRAIL receptors DR-4 and DR-5 could block AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis. These experiments were also performed with ZB4, a blocking anti-Fas antibody. As demonstrated in Figure 4b, soluble DR-4 and DR-5 together inhibited AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis, albeit incompletely, while the addition of ZB4 had little eect on AZT and IFN-a apoptosis. In contrast, soluble receptors DR-4, DR-5 and ZB4 had no inhibitory eect on AZT mediated apoptosis in EBV+ BL cells (data not shown). Control experiments demonstrated that soluble DR-4 and DR-5 almost completely inhibited TRAIL mediated cell death (at a highly cytotoxic concentration of TRAIL [100 ng/ml]). To further con®rm that AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis occurs principally through TRAIL signaling, we transfected BCBL-1 cells with the decoy receptor for TRAIL (DcR2). Overexpression of DcR2 markedly abrogated the IFN-a component of AZT and IFN-a mediated apoptosis (Figure 4c).
ab
Figure 5 (a) TRAIL substitutes for IFN-a to potentiate apoptosis in AZT treated PEL cells. BCBL-1 cells were treated under the following conditions for 48 h and apoptosis was measured by Annexin/PI staining. Panel A=BCBL-1 cells in medium. Panel B=BCBL-1 cells in AZT 10 mg/ml. Panel C=BCBL-1 cells in AZT 10 mg/ml and IFN-a 1000 u/ml. Panel D=BCBL-1 cells treated with soluble TRAIL 10 ng/ml. Panel E=BCBL-1 cells treated with AZT 10 mg/ml plus soluble TRAIL 10 ng/ml. The per cent of apoptotic cells in each panel is shown in Panel F, (b) AZT potentiates TRAIL mediated cytotoxicity in BCBL-1. BCBL-1 and BCBL-1 FADD-DN (BCBL-1A2) were treated in media, AZT 10 mg/ml, AZT 10 mg/ml plus IFN-a 1000 u/ml, TRAIL 10 ng/ml, or AZT 10 mg/ml plus TRAIL 10 ng/ml for 48 h and per cent viability was determined by Trypan blue exclusion. Bars represent per cent viable cells. The data is representative of at least two experiments