Goes to the Polls 2020
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AMERICA Goes to the Polls 2020 Policy and Voter Turnout in the 2020 Election AMERICA GOES TO THE POLLS Last updated: 03/18/2021 A report on Voter Turnout and Election Policy in the 50 States for the 2020 Election – March 2021 NONPROFIT VOTE REPORT TEAM: George Pillsbury, Senior Policy Consultant Caroline Mak, Field & Research Coordinator Brian Miller, Executive Director America Goes to the Polls 2020 represents the 7th edition in our biennial series based on the final certified voter turnout collected by the U.S. Elections Project. The report provides the official state rankings in voter turnout and turnout growth compared to the last presidential election in 2016. This ranking provides clear insights into the impact of election policies on state-by-state voter turnout. www.nonprofitvote.org www.electproject.org Nonprofit VOTE partners with America’s nonprofits to help the people they serve participate and vote. We are the leading source of nonpartisan resources to help nonprofits integrate voter engagement into their ongoing activities and services. The U.S. Elections Project, founded and directed by Dr. Michael McDonald at the University of Florida, seeks to provide timely and accurate election statistics, electoral laws, research reports, and other useful information regarding the United States electoral system. In doing so, the project informs the people of the United States on how their electoral system works, how it may be improved, and how they can participate in it. It serves as the official source for national and state turnout rates for biennial national elections. Special thanks to the National Vote at Home Institute team for reviewing our findings for clarity and accuracy. Designed by Robert Calmer, Adgraphics911.com; Kimberley Carroll-Cox, Nonprofit VOTE TABLE OF CONTENTS 4 Introduction 5 Executive Summary HOW WE VOTED AS A NATION 7 2020 National Turnout 9 50 State Turnout Ranking – 2020 Election Voter Turnout HOW POLICIES DRIVE TURNOUT DIFFERENCES 11 Top 10 States vs Bottom 10 States 12 Top 10 Highest Growth in Turnout Since 2016 GROWTH OF MAIL AND EARLY VOTING 14 Early Voting - Mail Ballots and Early In-person 15 Vote at Home - Mail Ballots 17 Benefits of Vote at Home 18 Mail Ballot Usage Map GROWTH OF SAME DAY REGISTRATION 20 Same Day Registration 21 Same Day Registration States Map 22 Benefits of Same Day Registration and Other Policies That Increase Access to Registration COMPETITION AND THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE 24 Competition and the Electoral College 25 Alternative to the Electoral College 28 METHODOLOGY 30 APPENDIX INTRODUCTION The November 2020 election was historic. Faced with the ongoing pandemic, many states expanded access to mail ballots, as well as options for early in-person voting. A new generation of poll workers was recruited to work at socially distanced polling locations. Meanwhile, many states had already implemented new policies prior to the pandemic, like Same Day Registration, that would help after months of DMV closures and a backlog of outdated registrations. America rose to the challenge. And voters, with expanded options for voting, turned out in numbers not seen in over a century. We extend our gratitude to the many poll workers and election officials – including some of our own neighbors, co-workers, and family members – who made this election possible. Amid the story of record turnout nationwide is also a story of differences. At the core of this report is a state-by-state ranking of voter turnout in all 50 states and DC – from the lowest-turnout state at 55% to a record-shattering 80% in the highest-turnout state. This 50-state ranking provides a powerful tool for examining the impact of state election policies. States in the top 10 of the ranking have markedly different policies than states in the bottom 10. Same Day Voter Registration states and “Vote at Home” states that mail every registered voter their ballot were consistently at the top of the turnout rankings. Those at the bottom generally made both registration and use of mail ballots harder. The report also looks at the role of competition and the Electoral College in shaping turnout. By lifting up policies that have a proven, real-world track record of increasing voter turnout, we aim to provide a blueprint for policy makers, advocates, and all Americans who care about a healthy democracy. Despite our differences, or perhaps because of those differences,our democracy works better when more people participate and vote. Only then can our democracy truly represent the will of the people. So let’s draw on the lessons of 2020 to build a stronger, more inclusive democracy. Brian Miller, Executive Director Nonprofit VOTE 4 AmericaAmerica Goes to theGoes Polls to the2020 Polls: Executive 2020 Summary EXECUTIVE SUMMARY With high voter interest and a global pandemic, 2020 was a high point for mail ballots, early voting, and policies like same day voter registration that gave voters more and better choices to register and vote, helping fuel record voter turnout. KEY TAKEAWAYS For the first time ever, more people voted with mail ballots or early in-person than filled out a ballot at the polls on Election Day • 70% of voters voted with a mail ballot or early in-person vs 30% of voters who voted in person on Election Day. • A record 111 million voted with either a mail ballot or early in-person, more than double the number who voted in person on Election Day. • 28 States changed their policy to make it easier to use a mail ballot. National voter turnout at 67% of eligible voters was the highest in 120 years • It set the modern record for turnout since 1900 and the expansion of the electorate with women’s suffrage, the Voting Rights Act, and lowering the voting age to 18. • All 50 states increased their turnout over 2016. Despite the record national turnout, there are still wide differences in voter turnout between states that make it easier or harder to vote • Turnout in the top 10 states averaged 17 percentage points higher than the bottom 10. • All of the top 10 turnout states either sent all their voters a mail ballot, have Same Day Registration that allows voters to register or update their registration when they vote, or both. • Eight of the bottom 10 turnout states cut off voter registrationfour weeks before the election or required an excuse to use a mail ballot. 5 America Goes to the Polls 2020: Executive Summary States that sent mail ballots to all voters had an advantage in turnout • In the top 10 states for their voter turnout, half were states that proactively mailed ballots to all registered voters (a.k.a Vote at Home states). • In the top 10 states for increase in voter turnout over 2016, six mailed ballots to all voters for the first time in a presidential election. States with Same Day Registration also saw a big turnout advantage • Eight of the top 10 voter turnout states had Same Day Registration. • States with Same Day Registration had an average turnout five percentage points higher than states that did not. • With eight more states adding Same Day Registration since 2016, this was a landmark year for the growth in the number of states adopting this time-tested policy. • Nearly half of all states now offer Same Day Voter Registration. • Despite nearly doubling the number of states with Same Day Registration since 2016, we still see a consistent turnout advantage of at least five points higher than states without it. Competition and the Electoral College impact the state turnout • Competition is a big driver of voter turnout. When it comes to the presidential race, the Electoral College divides the country into battleground (competitive) and non-battleground states. • Voter turnout in the 36 non-battleground states was four percentage points lower than that of the battleground states. All but one of the bottom 10 states in turnout were non-battleground states. • The two major candidates made 98% of their limited campaign visits to these 14 battleground states and gave the bulk of their campaign money to these 14 battleground states. 6 AmericaAmerica Goes to Goes the Polls to the 2020 Polls: National 2020 Turnout NATIONAL TURNOUT 2020 had the highest turnout of eligible voters for a presidential election since 1900. National turnout over time - marks the modern record for turnout after major historic expansions. 80% 74% 1920 – Expands 1965 – Voting women’s right Rights Act to vote 70% 67% 1971 – Voting age lowered to 18 60% 50% 40% 1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 2020 Figure 1 Source: U.S. Elections Project Every state increased their turnout over 2016. Over 159,690,000 votes were cast, 23.8 million more than 2016. For the first time in recent history, 20 states had voter turnout over 70 percent. Minnesota led the way with 80% voter turnout. Source: U.S. Elections Project 7 The 50 State Ranking– 2020 Election Voter Turnout Voter turnout is calculated in each state as The total number of votes The number of people eligible to vote The number of people eligible to vote is determined by the Census data for the number of citizens 18 and over, then adjusted for those prohibited from voting due to a past conviction, depending on state law. Since the 1980s, the U.S. Elections Project has provided the official estimate of each state’s voter eligible population (VEP) as the most accurate method to meaningfully compare voter turnout between states. 8 America Goes to the Polls 2020: The 50 State Ranking STATE VOTER TURNOUT RANKINGS 2020 Percentage turnout of voting eligible population Rank Percentage Rank Percentage Percentage 2020 State Turnout 2020 State Turnout Rank State Turnout 1 Minnesota 80.0% 18 Maryland 71.1% 35 Kentucky 64.9% 2 Colorado 76.4% 19 Pennsylvania 71.0% 36 Louisiana 64.6% 3 Maine 76.3% 20 Delaware 70.7% 37 Wyoming 64.6% 4 Wisconsin 75.8% 21 Nebraska 69.9% 38 South Carolina 64.5% 5 Washington 75.7% 22 Utah 69.2% 39 North Dakota 64.5% 6 Oregon 75.5% 23 Alaska 68.8% 40 Dist.