535 7-13 January 2011 16 Pages Rs 30
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
#535 7-13 January 2011 16 pages Rs 30 Looking to the future Foggy winter morning in the Pokhara Valley KIRAN PANDAY 2 EDITORIAL 7-13 JANUARY 2011 #535 y now it must be clear to most Nepalis that UNMIN’s mission in Nepal is a done deal. Even the Maoists are only really Bpretending that with India on the Security Council, there is STOP WASTING TIME any possibility of another extension. So why bother? The fuss they are kicking up has nothing to do with a concern for the larger peace process. By calling for UNMIN to stay, which they well know is impossible in the current confi guration, they are hoping that they will at least be granted a residual mini-UNMIN, or at any rate a UN-related committee to take on some of UNMIN’s mandate. Whatever form this body takes, the Maoists will hope to use it as cover for their actions, and to buffer their ex-combatants from direct dealings with the Special Committee and its secretariat. At the very least, their dire predictions now will allow for ‘told you so’ pontifi cations later, and justifi cations for situations that the Maoists themselves will play a part in creating in the months to come. To wit, they are creating room to manouevre. The inability or refusal of the Maoists to take the diffi cult decisions that would eventuate in their ‘losing’ their military capability refl ects a deep insecurity about their ability to retain power in a democratic set-up. This is not surprising, given their ideological make-up, and the past and current reluctance to support radical change of Nepal’s mainstream political parties and the elite. But their continued reliance on the PLA is now a liability for both Maoists and non-Maoists. If the intention was never to wean themselves off the PLA and associated militias, Pushpa Kamal Dahal and Co. may have imagined they were pulling one over the Nepali public and the international community when they signed the Comprehensive Peace Accord. But if they still believe that they can capture the state and establish a dictatorship of the proletariat, they’ve pulled the wool over their own eyes. On the other hand, if they are sincere about becoming a democratic party that relies only on the ballot, and not the bullet, then they had bloody well get on with it. We’re all getting old waiting, never mind those wasted lives in the cantonments. KIRAN PANDAY ON THE WEB www.nepalitimes.com INSPIRING NEPALIS I went to Help Nepal’s web site. I come short due to a lack of training, LETTER TO THE EDITOR Congratulations!!! could not fi nd any document that says, exposure, inherent biases, etc. You all helped make our world more ‘Monitoring and Evaluation or Independent Soach I got a terrible shock when beautiful and we are proud of you. (‘Persons Evaluation Report’. Perhaps I did not I checked my email to fi nd of the Year’, #534). search hard enough. I’d be grateful if I agree that there is some HSSAN (Higher Secondary Ngima Tendup Sherpa someone posted a link to Help Nepal- motive behind all this. It could be the Schools Association Nepal) and specifi c M&E concerns or reports. subconscious need for fame or just a Kathmandu Metropolitan Police Happy to note that your esteemed On the other hand, if there has indeed defense mechanism like altruism. But, are planning to ban motorbikes magazine choose Dr. Mingmar G. Sherpa been no independent evaluation of Help hey, who cares? Just look at Bill Gates for 10+2 students. I couldn’t in ‘Persons of the Year’ for his exemplary Nepal’s work in the last 8 or 10 years, – he gives hundreds of millions of dollars believe my eyes. This is clearly a work in delivering healthcare services to then it’s hard to take it seriously as an to developing countries for various violation of our rights. remote, disadvantaged and rural people. His impact-making charity. One is free to like programs even while he has named the Will banning bikes for contributions have saved the lives of many Help Nepal as a Nepali-run and Nepali- foundation the Bill and Melinda Gates students really put an end to mothers and children there. This can be managed charity that appears to have its Foundation. At least it’s much better problems like road accidents, a model for other districts in the country. smile in the right place. But beyond that, than the actions of people like Mukesh traffi c jams and lack of discipline Congratulations! one need not take it as an exemplary Ambani, who is wasting billions on among college goers as HSSAN Heem S. Shakya charity of any sort. his ‘edifi ce’ while his Indian brethren and the traffi c police claim? The Rabindra Mishra should also stop are languishing in despicable poverty. city traffi c police are corrupt, SOME SUCCESS writing about Help Nepal. He founded Even in Nepal, we see so many rich incompetent and cannot do UML, in spite of myopic Jhalanath baje, has it. He should be applauded for it. His people donating generously to temple their jobs well. They would do been successful in retaining power (‘Ignored championing Help Nepal is nice but is construction and stuff. How about trying better to try and manage the Lessons’, Damakant Jayshi, #534). This is also full of danger for the charity’s growth. to make someone’s life better instead infamous traffi c jams of the city their success, not incompetence. You can’t fault a father for singing his of adding more adipose tissue to the than indulge in silly tactics like NC is sure to remain steadfast, (their daughter’s praises, though after a while, bellies of mahantas at Pashupati? So banning youths from riding bikes. masters in Delhi must have told them to this can be boring and irritating, and my personal opinion on all of this is Help I can understand some of the remain so) unless ordered to do otherwise. embarrassing to the daughter. Nepal is a wonderful project that needs reasons for the colleges and the In doing so they are also keeping the Maoist Mishra should instead now fi nd to be supported in every way possible. police wanting to stop students bajes at bay, and surely this is their success. unrelated but credible national and I recently started sponsoring a child from riding bikes. But those international professionals, preferably through Save the Children Nepal and I concerns have fairly simple The Maoist bajes are also being those who know a thing or two about will donate to Help Nepal as well. Good solutions. Colleges can stop successful, by the public display of dissent how rural education works, to make good Luck Help Nepal team! students from bunking classes to buy time to keep their radical cadres or bad public comments about Help Bibek Koirala by asking them to turn over their waiting and hoping for the dream that Nepal’s work. motorbike keys once they are cannot be realised. I am not sure what made Nepali inside the college and handing In the meantime, all of them and the Times sign on. I see Nepali Times’ the keys back to them once the minor parties are enjoying their allowances, partnership as a dangerous precedent. classes are over. Attendance perks and facilities. Good for them. Could it not have simply said ‘Help Nepal Weekly Internet Poll # 535 can be taken at the end of every K. K. Sharma is our Charity of the Year for 2011’ and left class. Students can be given it at that? Q. How do you feel about 2011? orientation about safe riding and WHITHER JOURNALISM? Mishra seems to have a mistaken Total votes: 1,662 traffi c rules. Very good initiative by HeNN to get the view of journalism’s public service There are many students like ball rolling on Nepalis helping Nepalis mission. Contrary to what he says, the me who are passionate about (‘Philanthropic Journalism’, Rabindra best public service that journalism can bikes and we don’t think there is Mishra, #534). Let’s hope the partnership do is to take a hard-nosed, skeptical and anything wrong with it. Putting with Nepali Times will spread the word questioning approach to everything that excessive control on students and more NRNs and Nepalis will start to anyone with power says or does so that will only provoke them more. contribute the cost of a beer a month. I am the public is not deceived by those who Gaurav Pandey going to donate my one year’s worth right purport to work for the public. Taking such now. Thanks to Rabindraji and HeNN. an approach consistently is diffi cult work Weekly Internet Poll # 536. To vote go to: www.nepalitimes.com Janak Dongol, Bangkok in itself, and many journalists in Nepal Q. Is UNMIN right to be leaving? Publisher: Kunda Dixit | Editor: Rabi Thapa Published by Himalmedia Pvt Ltd | Chief Operating Offi cer: Sunim Tamang | Hattiban, Godavari Road, Lalitpur | GPO Box 7251 Kathmandu [email protected] | www.nepalitimes.com | www.himalmedia.com | Tel: 01-5250333/845 Fax: +977-1-5251013 Design: Kiran Maharjan | Marketing: Arjun Karki, Surendra Sharma [email protected] | Advertorial/features: Ram Krishna Banjara | Subscription: Santosh Aryal [email protected] Printed at Jagadamba Press | 01-5250017-19 | www.jagadambapr.com OP-ED 3 7-13 JANUARY 2011 #535 Big Madhesi politics PLAIN SPEAKING Watch this space for future splits Prashant Jha among the Madhes parties s yet another Madhesi broader support base, and is president/chairman’s party bites the dust offering incentives to leaders working style.