Conversations on Transatlanticism and Europe (CEURO) Grant Agreement: 2017-2780/001-001 Edited By: Kolja Raube, Gustavo G
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 Jean Monnet Project Conversations on Transatlanticism and Europe (CEURO) Grant Agreement: 2017-2780/001-001 Edited by: Kolja Raube, Gustavo G. Müller, Michael Francis (KU Leuven) Lucas Henry, Neil Vander Most (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign) 2 Table of Contents General Introduction .................................................................................................................. 4 Part I - Perspectives on Transatlantic Relations ........................................................................ 6 Comparative Federalism in the United States and the European Union ................................ 7 Transatlantic Perspectives on Security and Defense ............................................................ 21 European and North American Perspectives on Refugees ................................................... 33 Transatlanticity and Contemporary Populism: European and American Perspectives ........ 47 Transatlantic Perspectives on the Welfare System .............................................................. 57 Part II - Transatlantic Radar ..................................................................................................... 80 NATO Burden Sharing Through the Lens of Former President Dwight D. Eisenhower .... 81 The Suez Canal Crisis: Leadership Dimension .................................................................... 88 Suez Crisis: Bipolarity of the Western Alliance in Divided World ..................................... 95 Does History repeat itself? Woodrow Wilson: A Portrait .................................................. 102 The transatlantic relationship and the rules-based international order ............................... 109 The Impact of West German Ostpolitik in the Transatlantic Relations ............................. 117 An Analytical Portrait of a Leader: Willy Brandt .............................................................. 124 Transatlantic Radar: The French Influence on the American Revolution ......................... 132 Al Gore: a portrait of leadership ........................................................................................ 140 American Invasion of Grenada: The Impact on Anglo-American Relations ..................... 148 Analytical portrait of leadership: Bill Clinton .................................................................... 155 Transatlanticity: disputes on Banana Wars ........................................................................ 164 Analytical portray of leadership: Cecilia Malmström (DG Trade) .................................... 172 3 General Introduction This e-volume is the product of a collective effort by students and for students. It explores transatlantic relations in an output of two-year collaboration project between the Centre of European Studies of the University of Leuven (Belgium) and the European Union Center at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign (United States). Conversation on Transatlanticism and Europe (CEURO) is a Jean Monnet Project under the Erasmus Plus Programme (grant agreement 2017-2780/001-001) of the European Commission. The CEURO project has fostered a bottom-up student exchange across the Atlantic while also allowing a space for multidisciplinary debate on historic issues of transatlantic relations and its current trends. The e-book brings co-authored and single authored contributions from masters-level students enrolled in the CEURO course from both universities. This course was co-organized by the partner centres and benefited from the input of professors from both sides of the Atlantic via live video conference link. The CEURO project is unique because it facilitates a transatlantic dialogue on diverse policy areas ranging from foreign policy and external action, to internal policy and social welfare systems. Students have considered topics beyond institutional and political affairs, and have delved into phenomena common to both Europe and North America, such as the rise of populism and disinformation. In essence, this e-Book covers some of the challenges of our time from the perspective of our students and with guidance of the teaching staff of KU Leuven and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, from disciplinary voices as varied as political science, history, linguistics, and ethnomusicology. It explores how transatlantic issues are often rooted in transoceanic history that underpin modern divergences and convergences in policy and political action. This e-Book is divided into two parts. The first part offers chapters which are co- authored by students from masters programmes in European Studies. These chapters cover broad challenges and phenomena and the interlinkages and disconnects between both sides of the Atlantic. Contemporary issues such as security and defence policy, social protection systems, the rise of populism, and the erosion of multilateralism encapsulate how different approaches have risen. Ultimately, this allows for transfers of ‘best-practices’ as well as a deeper understanding of each other’s cultures and heritage and its present-day influence. The final products found in this section can truly be seen as transatlantic collaboration: they were 4 conceived, researched, written, and edited jointly by the students, who present balanced analysis and perspective. The second part of this e-Book contains ‘transatlantic radars’, which act as profiles and comparative analyses of European and North American key figures and events throughout history. Essentially, these profiles of figures and events show how influences crossed the Atlantic through economic, social and political means. This part includes profiles of Woodrow Wilson and Willy Brandt, as well as European involvement in the American War of Independence, and the influence of the US in the decline of British colonial power during the Suez Crisis. On the one hand, the radars map the interactions of both European nation-states and the early decades of the United States. On the other hand, the radars enable a comparative analysis how leadership and critical junctures shaped the interconnections between Europe and North America. 5 Part I - Perspectives on Transatlantic Relations 6 CHAPTER 1 Comparative Federalism in the United States and the European Union Can the United States’ Federalization Experience Serve as a Template to the European Union? Alberto M. Burgos-Rivera & Yurii Chipko I. Introduction It is all but impossible to discuss the historical dimension of transatlanticism without mentioning the idea behind the powers on both sides of the Atlantic. Federalism - the concept of a balance of powers between the lower and higher levels of governance that provides a fair representation for the states that comprise a federation but give enough power to a central government so that it can maintain such order - is such an idea (Knuepling, 2016). Federalism is a product of the Enlightenment, the idea that was first successfully realized in America and a number of European states in the 18th and 19th century and became an irreplaceable component of those states’ political identities (ibid.). These historical origins make it necessary to analyse the development of federalism through comparing and contrasting both European and American experiences. Those experiences with federalism have both similarities (some aspects of the EU were clearly modelled on the US, such as the role of the ECJ) and differences (for instance, different general competences of the central governments). It is, therefore, crucial to understand the way Europe and the United States deal with the evolving idea of federalism if we want to understand the underlying political trends of the transatlantic relations. This chapter will analyse the trajectories of the federalist developments in the EU and the US, as well as focus on discussing and comparing how political changes impacted the parallel levels of understanding of federalism in Europe and the United States. We will do so in different parts: first, we will provide an analysis of the key literature on the developments of federalism in Europe and/or the United States. Examining different authors’ perspectives on federalism helps to understand the dominant view on it in the discipline of political science. Second, we will focus on the historical developments in the United States that trace the 7 evolution of federalism in practice in that country. Similarly, the third section of this chapter is devoted to the historical developments in the European Union that are different in timeline but parallel in the gradual change of the federal ideas. Next, we will discuss the findings of the previous sections and analyse the differences and similarities between the EU and the US regarding federalism. Finally, we will conclude the chapter by summarizing all of our findings in regard to the subject. II. Literature Review on Federalism and Federalization in the US and the EU Literature on federalism as well as the federalization of both the US and the EU is not at all new. Despite the EU’s recent creation, its increased political competencies through the passage of subsequent treaties has led academics to establish comparisons with the US’s federalization experience and whether or not is serves as a viable template for the EU to follow suit (e.g. Glencross, 2009a; 2009b; Young, 2017). In his contributing chapter on federalism in America, Europe, and Africa, Broscheck bases his definition of federalism as a particular species in which neither the federal nor the constitutional