A Thesis Prepared in Completion of Requirements for the Ph.D. Degree by Edward P
THE RELIGIOUS THOUGHT OF GEORGE TYRRELL. ROMAN CATHOLIC MODERNIST. A Thesis prepared in completion of requirements for the Ph.D. degree by Edward P. Turnbach, B.A., B.D. Presented in the Department of Systematic Theology, New College, University of Edinburgh, Scotland. March, 1942. ii. PREFACE. Modernism is, at least, one of the most im portant life and thought-tendencies which has ap peared in the Church since the Reformation—of which, in fact, it is a development and in rela tion to which it must be judged. In Roman Cath olic Modernism, George Tyrrell was a constructive and conservative critic, constructive in aim, con servative in method; and to many his views seemed to place religion in a truer perspective than any in which it had been presented in recent genera tions. He had, at once, that sense of tne past, in which Protestantism is so often lacking, and that of the present, in which Catholicism neces sarily fails; and so he -pled, as he himself said, "for a greater realization of the issues at stake than is common with our more lighthearted reform ers, and a greater sympathy with the instinctive (even if not intelligent) repugnances of those whose temples and altars seem doomed to a some what ruthless despoliation." Thus, as A. L. Lilley states, his writings as a whole are pro legomena to any future doctrine of revelation, and may be regarded, also, as A. R. Vidler as serts, as a reply to Liberal Protestantism. His ill. apologetic, therefore, is of the first conse quence, yet it is not an apologetic which can be exploited in the interests of the Catholic, perhaps, of any Church.
[Show full text]