USDA Biological Assessment on Brazilian Pepper P. Ichini
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
United States Department of Biological assessment for the proposed field Agriculture release of a Pseudophilothrips ichini Marketing and Regulatory (Thysanoptera: Phlaeothripidae) for classical Programs biological control of Brazilian peppertree, Animal and Plant Health Schinus terebinthifolia, (Anacardiaceae) in the Inspection Service contiguous United States. March 2017 Contents I. POLICY ...................................................................................................................................... 1 II. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED ACTION, P. ICHINI INFORMATION, AND HOST SPECIFICITY TESTING RESULTS ............................................................................................. 1 Proposed Action and Action Area .............................................................................................. 1 APHIS Process for Permitting of Weed Biological Control Organisms .................................... 2 1. Nature of the Problem ............................................................................................................. 3 2. Biological Control Agent Information .................................................................................. 10 3. Host Specificity Testing ........................................................................................................ 16 4. Other Issues ........................................................................................................................... 30 IV. LITERATURE CITED ......................................................................................................... 122 Appendix 1 133 Appendix 2 139 I. POLICY United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Departmental Regulation, Fish and Wildlife Policy No. 9500-4, dated August 22, 1983 and updated April 28, 2008, sets forth the purpose, policy, and responsibilities of USDA with respect to fish and wildlife. Agencies of the USDA will not fund or take any action that is likely to jeopardize the continued existence of threatened or endangered species or destroy any habitat necessary for their conservation. The USDA will coordinate with the Secretaries of the Department of the Interior and the Department of Commerce in the administration of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and animal and plant quarantine laws. II. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED ACTION, P. ICHINI INFORMATION, AND HOST SPECIFICITY TESTING RESULTS The purpose of this biological assessment (BA) is to assess the potential effects of the release of the thrips Pseudophilothrips ichini (Hood) (Thysanoptera: Phlaeothripidae), for classical biological control of Brazilian peppertree, Schinus terebinthifolia Raddi. (Sapindales: Anacardiaceae), in the contiguous United States, on species that are listed as endangered or threatened (listed), species proposed to be listed as endangered or threatened (proposed), and habitats designated or proposed to be designated as critical, in accordance with Section 7 of the ESA. In the contiguous United States, there is one plant that is federally listed in the family Anacardiaceae (Michaux's sumac (Rhus michauxii)), the same family as the target weed. Based on the host specificity of P. ichini reported in testing, field observations, and in the scientific literature, APHIS has determined that environmental release of P. ichini may affect, but is not likely to adversely affect Michaux's sumac or the Everglade snail kite and its critical habitat. APHIS has also determined that P. ichini may affect beneficially, the Florida panther, Key deer, Florida scrub-jay, gopher tortoise, Bartram’s hairstreak butterfly and its critical habitat, Florida leafwing butterfly and its critical habitat, Miami blue butterfly, Schaus swallowtail butterfly, beach jacquemontia, Everglades bully, Florida pineland crabgrass, pineland sandmat, and Florida prairie-clover. The USDA, Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) is requesting concurrence from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) on these determinations. Proposed Action and Action Area The USDA, APHIS, has the authority to regulate the release of biological control organisms in the United States under the Plant Protection Act of 2000. APHIS is proposing to issue permits for release of P. ichini into the contiguous United States. If approved by APHIS and participating states, releases will be made initially into the State of Florida. However, if P. ichini establishes, the insect could spread throughout the contiguous United States wherever host plants are available and the climate is suitable. Also, additional permits may be issued by APHIS after this initial release in Florida, such as Texas and California where Brazilian peppertree is a problem weed. Therefore, the action area is considered the contiguous United States. A permit is not 1 issued until APHIS conducts a National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) evaluation for the release of P. ichini. APHIS Process for Permitting of Weed Biological Control Organisms A Plant Protection and Quarantine (PPQ) Form 526 permit is required for both the importation and the interstate movement of weed biological control organisms intended for environmental release. Organisms released for use as biological controls of weeds may be arthropods, nematodes, or microbial pathogens. Permits for importation of these organisms generally require them to be received and maintained in biocontainment facilities. APHIS also issues permits for first-time environmental release from containment of nonindigenous weed biological control organisms. Further, APHIS issues permits for interstate redistribution of approved weed biological control organisms. A PPQ Form 526 permit is not needed for interstate movement when pathogens used for weed biological control are listed as an active ingredient in an EPA- registered product. Permits for first-time releases of nonindigenous weed biological control organisms are issued only after a scientific review of the potential effects of the release. RSPM No. 7, “Guidelines for Petition for First Release of Non-indigenous Phytophagous or Phytopathogenic Biological Control Agents” (NAPPO, 2015) describes the information that researchers must provide to APHIS before the release of new organisms can be permitted. Information requested includes aspects of the biology, regulatory status, distribution and economic impact of the target weed, and host specificity of the proposed biological control organism, its expected impact after release, and post-release monitoring plans. For first-time releases of weed biological control organisms, an advisory group composed of Federal regulators and researchers (known as the Technical Advisory Group for Biological Control Agents of Weeds (TAG)) provides assistance to APHIS (https://www.aphis.usda.gov/aphis/ourfocus/planthealth/import-information/permits/regulated- organism-and-soil-permits/biological-control-organism- permits/sa_tag/ct_technical_advisory_group_biological_control_agents_weeds ). The TAG evaluates the scientific information submitted by researchers requesting first-time environmental release of nonindigenous weed biological control organisms in the contiguous United States. The TAG makes recommendations to APHIS that are used as part of permitting decisions (7 CFR 330.202(a)). Once the TAG recommends release of an organism, APHIS proceeds with the preparation of an environmental evaluation of the release based on their assessment of those recommendations. For APHIS’ approval of new organisms proposed for release in the United States or its territories, compliance with environmental statutes (such as NEPA and ESA) is required (7 CFR 372.5(b)(4)). Interstate movement of weed biological control organisms for environmental release require permits from APHIS for the movement of the organism to the site of release. If the organism is widely established in the United States (within its potential range) and has not caused adverse effects, a permit may be issued for interstate movement for environmental release. If the requested organism is established only in part of its potential geographic range, permits may be 2 issued for release only in those States where establishment or prior releases are documented. If the organism is new to the requested destination State, a permit is not issued until an environmental evaluation is conducted. PPQ 526 permits are issued by APHIS after the applicant/permit holder agrees to the required conditions for receiving the permit. Conditions included in permits for environmental release require verification of identity and purity of the organisms. For both importation and interstate movement of approved weed biological control organisms, permit conditions may require that the species are reared in laboratory colonies, or their identification is verified by a qualified person, and that the organisms are free from contaminant species, such as hyperparasites or propagative parts of noxious weeds. These conditions are to ensure that unwanted organisms, whether contaminants or misidentified biological control organisms, are not spread to the destination location to cause unintended consequences. The following information regarding Brazilian peppertree, P. ichini, and the host specificity testing conducted is from two petitions submitted to the TAG (Wheeler et al., 2014; Overholt et al., 2015). 1. Nature of the Problem 1.1 History of introduction: Brazilian peppertree is one of the worst invasive species in Florida (Schmitz et al., 1997). Rodgers et al. (2012) estimate that approximately