Vital Movements: Feminist Aesthetics and Popular Culture 1920–1945

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Vital Movements: Feminist Aesthetics and Popular Culture 1920–1945 Vital Movements: Feminist Aesthetics and Popular Culture 1920–1945 by Jacqueline Rothstein A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of English University of Toronto © Copyright by Jacqueline Rothstein 2019 Vital Movements: Feminist Aesthetics and Popular Culture 1920–1945 Jacqueline Rothstein Doctor of Philosophy Department of English University of Toronto 2019 Abstract Vital Movements argues for the crucial importance of women’s physical movement to the aesthetics of American popular culture between 1920 and 1945. Tracking female bodies as they run up and down stairs, enter and exit rooms, and strut across spaces and places, my dissertation reveals an array of self-determining women, defiant in their mobility and their right to choose and take pleasure in a life outside the accepted roles of wife and mother. Aesthetic modernism’s institutionalization as the critical high-water mark of the period has largely rendered works that circulated in the commercial realms of Broadway, Hollywood, and Book-of-the-Month Clubs devoid of substance. Further, critical emphasis on language and discourse, according to dance critics, has caused us to ignore the expressive capacities of the body in motion. I argue that sustained attention to embodied movement forces a reconsideration of popular realist texts by revealing other ways they tell their stories, ways that are complex and layered in their own right. This method of engagement restores agency to the texts, lost, as Rita Felski has argued, in the emphasis on historical context, by rendering their capacity to solicit our “affective attachments.” Combining insights from middlebrow studies, “physical cultures” of the period, philosophies of movement, dance studies, and spatial theory, each chapter applies ii them to a different genre. Chapter one uses Edna Ferber and George S. Kaufman’s play Stage Door to establish women’s movement as the dissertation’s overall subject and to introduce the essential role played by work in the freedom and autonomy expressed by it. Chapter two focuses on resistance to norms of feminine embodiment and their relation to social and economic mobility in Dorothy Arzner’s film Dance, Girl, Dance. Stage directions and the inherent visuality of film attune readers to moving bodies before encountering the narrative forms of chapters three and four, which, respectively, connect moving bodies to unarticulated thoughts and desires in Zona Gale’s novel Miss Lulu Bett, and to personal growth and fulfillment in Mabel Dodge Luhan’s autobiography, Intimate Memories. Throughout bodies “speak” through movement, generating a realism richly attuned to the textures of women’s everyday lives. iii Acknowledgements Research and writing of this dissertation was facilitated by various awards and fellowships: grants from, respectively, the Centre for the Study of the United States and the Anne Tanenbaum Centre for Jewish Studies at the University of Toronto which allowed me to travel to archives in New York City and Madison, Wisconsin; the Shiff Graduate Enhancement Fund and the Earl and Renée Lyons Graduate Fund at the Anne Tanenbaum Centre for Jewish Studies; and a Doctoral Award from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council. I owe the Graduate English Department at the University of Toronto my appreciation for financial support in the form of a Viola Whitney Pratt Memorial Scholarship and yearly fellowships, and for the encouragement and guidance I received from the administration throughout all stages of the doctoral process. To the Wisconsin Historical Society my thanks for being so responsive and allowing me to quote from letters in the Zona Gale and Edna Ferber archives. My sincerest gratitude to Professor Andrea Most for her encouragement and mentorship, from project conception to completion. I cannot imagine a supervisor more generous with her time and intellect. I am also tremendously grateful to the other members of my thesis committee, Professors Michael Cobb and Denise Cruz, who were unfailingly patient and supportive when I was not infrequently tangled in the weeds of my argument, and who always pointed me in just the right direction to find my own way out. My thanks also to Professor Neal Dolan who provided counsel in the project’s early stages. iv I am indebted to Marie Campbell and Mark Lipton who read the dissertation at key moments and gave me both invaluable feedback and confidence that I had something to say that others would find interesting. Thank you to my parents, my siblings, and their partners, who restrained for the most part from asking me when I was going to finish and who always felt confident in my ability to do so. Last, but certainly not least, I thank my husband, Robert, and my sons, Ethan and Roan, for accompanying me on this long road with love and understanding—and, most importantly, a sense of humour. v Table of Contents Acknowledgements iv List of Figures vii Introduction 1 1 The Ins and Outs (and Ups and Downs) of Work in Edna Ferber and George S. Kaufman’s Stage Door 42 2 That Vital Oomph: Movement and Embodiment in Dorothy Arzner’s Dance, Girl, Dance 84 3 Moving Towards Selfhood in Zona Gale’s Miss Lulu Bett 134 4 The Feminist Movements of Mabel Dodge Luhan’s Intimate Memories 172 Conclusion 226 Bibliography 234 Copyright Acknowledgements 256 vi List of Figures 1. First and second rehearsal scenes of the American Ballet Company in Dance, Girl, Dance 131 2: Judy’s ballet steps and Bubbles’s “jitterbug” 131 3. Bubbles traverses the burlesque stage 131 4. Judy confronts the burlesque audience 132 5. Madame Basilova watches Judy dance and Judy watches the American Ballet Company ballerina dance 132 6. Bubbles captures the attention of the talent scout 132 7. Jean watches Charles, and other women, through her pocket book mirror in The Lady Eve. Jean puts out her foot to trip Charles 133 8. Charles falls while Jean glides 133 9. Villa Curonia, Florence 224 10. Yellow Salon, Villa Curonia 224 11. Interior, 23 Fifth Avenue, Greenwich Village 225 12. Los Gallos, Taos 225 vii Introduction It is an October evening, just before the dinner hour. The girls are coming home from matinees, from job-hunting, they are up and down the stairs, and presently they will be out again on dinner dates, playing the evening performances, seeing a movie. (593; Act 1 Scene 1) With these stage directions Edna Ferber and George S. Kaufman establish the scene of their 1936 Broadway comedy Stage Door. “Home” is the Footlights Club, a boarding house for “girls of the stage” located in the “West Fifties” of New York City. The Footlights Club is a space defined by the women who live there, their work, their desires, and as the above lines indicate, their movement. Coming home, they will soon be out again. The centrality of the stairs to the set establishes the women’s movements as substantive and significant. Not merely transitional, a way to reach the second “floor,” the stairs are a space in and of themselves, from and on which the women speak as well as move, as Susan Paige does when she utters the play’s first lines, a “quick Hi!,” before continuing “on up.” Material representations of energy and passion, the actresses’ movements express subjectivities built on the freedom to maneuver through their daily lives with relative autonomy due to the economic and domestic independence afforded by work and life on their own in the city. More than simply residents, the women who live at the Footlights Club form a community, evincing obvious comfort and pleasure in each other’s company as they celebrate roles cast, commiserate over their difficulty getting the 1 2 attention of producers, and lay about on a Sunday morning poring over newspapers, the remains of breakfast scattered around them. I begin with Stage Door’s boarding house because it both introduces the kinds of texts in my purview and the framework for their analysis. Spanning an era of relative liberalization in gender norms, bookended by the Nineteenth Amendment that granted women the right to vote in 1920 and the post-Second-World-War “culture of containment” that pushed them back into the home, my dissertation argues for the re- consideration of women-authored and directed texts largely overlooked and undervalued because they circulated in the commercial realms of Broadway theatres, Hollywood movies, and Book-of-the-Month clubs. Tracing the movement of female bodies in the above-mentioned Stage Door, Dorothy Arzner’s 1940 film Dance, Girl, Dance, Zona Gale’s 1920 novel Miss Lulu Bett, and Mabel Dodge Luhan’s four-volume autobiography, Intimate Memories, published between 1933 and 1937, I identify white female subjectivities germane to work, autonomy, and female community. Movement is central to our ability to perceive another’s “aliveness,” argues developmental psychologist Daniel Stern. “Without motion, we cannot read in or imagine mental activity underneath, or thoughts, emotion, or ‘will’” (10). Watched as they move, the women in my dissertation come “alive,” their aliveness functioning in turn as a measure of the “aliveness” of the texts themselves to contemporary study. Suspicions around unbridled mobility in women have often linked their mobility to promiscuity. “There is an ancient insistence in our culture that women ought to be pure and this involves not moving around,” Margaret Visser writes in The Way We Are (4). Women who move around, she suggests, would presumably not be at home for “roving” 3 men to return to. This inherent bias against women is, in Visser’s account, how we come to the image of the swinging stewardess. More relevant to this dissertation, it is also how we come to Stephen Crane’s Maggie, “girl of the streets.” The modern figure of the flanêur roaming the streets was decidedly male.
Recommended publications
  • WGSS Womenarehuman V7 N11 1978.Pdf (11.26Mb)
    W01\1EN ARE HUMAN WOMEN'S STUDIES LIBRARY THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY Volume 7 November 17, 1978 Number 11 REVIEWS other ways. She does not seem to in- Materials in the OSU Libraries about, tend to paint such a negative picture-- for and by women (the location is in- but negative it is. On the other hand, dicated above each number). To de- Goldsmith is aware of some of the pos- termine if a copy is available call 422-3900. sible psychological reasons behind the behavior of this rather bizarre person; the trouble is that she plays armchair psychiatrist too often. Then there is WOMEN'S Gilbert, Julie Goldsmith. Goldsmith's enormously annoying habit STUDIES Ferber, a biography. of repeating herself, and others, from PS3511 Garden City, New York, chapter to chapter and using incredibly E66Z8 G5 Doubleday & Co., 1978. pretentious language. She glibly uses "lagniappe"--a word I had to look up Edna Ferber's biography has been writ- in the dictionary--and frequently attri- ten by her great-niece, Julie Gilbert butes its use to others, as in this Goldsmith, who certainly seems to want sentence, allegedly spoken or written us to like Ferber, remember her for the by Kate Steichen, then an editor: many huge books she wrote, and gain " ••• At Doubleday we iust didn't take an insight into how Ferber lived on a any lagniappe or gravy from authors--let scale comparable to her books. These alone agents." My response to that books are huge in scope, and huge in comes from an old favorite line in the verbiage.
    [Show full text]
  • Willa Cather and American Arts Communities
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Dissertations, Theses, and Student Research: Department of English English, Department of 8-2004 At the Edge of the Circle: Willa Cather and American Arts Communities Andrew W. Jewell University of Nebraska - Lincoln Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/englishdiss Part of the English Language and Literature Commons Jewell, Andrew W., "At the Edge of the Circle: Willa Cather and American Arts Communities" (2004). Dissertations, Theses, and Student Research: Department of English. 15. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/englishdiss/15 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the English, Department of at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations, Theses, and Student Research: Department of English by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. AT THE EDGE OF THE CIRCLE: WILLA CATHER AND AMERICAN ARTS COMMUNITIES by Andrew W. Jewel1 A DISSERTATION Presented to the Faculty of The Graduate College at the University of Nebraska In Partial Fulfillment of Requirements For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Major: English Under the Supervision of Professor Susan J. Rosowski Lincoln, Nebraska August, 2004 DISSERTATION TITLE 1ather and Ameri.can Arts Communities Andrew W. Jewel 1 SUPERVISORY COMMITTEE: Approved Date Susan J. Rosowski Typed Name f7 Signature Kenneth M. Price Typed Name Signature Susan Be1 asco Typed Name Typed Nnme -- Signature Typed Nnme Signature Typed Name GRADUATE COLLEGE AT THE EDGE OF THE CIRCLE: WILLA CATHER AND AMERICAN ARTS COMMUNITIES Andrew Wade Jewell, Ph.D. University of Nebraska, 2004 Adviser: Susan J.
    [Show full text]
  • Papéis Normativos E Práticas Sociais
    Agnes Ayres (1898-194): Rodolfo Valentino e Agnes Ayres em “The Sheik” (1921) The Donovan Affair (1929) The Affairs of Anatol (1921) The Rubaiyat of a Scotch Highball Broken Hearted (1929) Cappy Ricks (1921) (1918) Bye, Bye, Buddy (1929) Too Much Speed (1921) Their Godson (1918) Into the Night (1928) The Love Special (1921) Sweets of the Sour (1918) The Lady of Victories (1928) Forbidden Fruit (1921) Coals for the Fire (1918) Eve's Love Letters (1927) The Furnace (1920) Their Anniversary Feast (1918) The Son of the Sheik (1926) Held by the Enemy (1920) A Four Cornered Triangle (1918) Morals for Men (1925) Go and Get It (1920) Seeking an Oversoul (1918) The Awful Truth (1925) The Inner Voice (1920) A Little Ouija Work (1918) Her Market Value (1925) A Modern Salome (1920) The Purple Dress (1918) Tomorrow's Love (1925) The Ghost of a Chance (1919) His Wife's Hero (1917) Worldly Goods (1924) Sacred Silence (1919) His Wife Got All the Credit (1917) The Story Without a Name (1924) The Gamblers (1919) He Had to Camouflage (1917) Detained (1924) In Honor's Web (1919) Paging Page Two (1917) The Guilty One (1924) The Buried Treasure (1919) A Family Flivver (1917) Bluff (1924) The Guardian of the Accolade (1919) The Renaissance at Charleroi (1917) When a Girl Loves (1924) A Stitch in Time (1919) The Bottom of the Well (1917) Don't Call It Love (1923) Shocks of Doom (1919) The Furnished Room (1917) The Ten Commandments (1923) The Girl Problem (1919) The Defeat of the City (1917) The Marriage Maker (1923) Transients in Arcadia (1918) Richard the Brazen (1917) Racing Hearts (1923) A Bird of Bagdad (1918) The Dazzling Miss Davison (1917) The Heart Raider (1923) Springtime à la Carte (1918) The Mirror (1917) A Daughter of Luxury (1922) Mammon and the Archer (1918) Hedda Gabler (1917) Clarence (1922) One Thousand Dollars (1918) The Debt (1917) Borderland (1922) The Girl and the Graft (1918) Mrs.
    [Show full text]
  • Dandies, Marginality and Modernism: Georgia O'keeffe, Marcel Duchamp and Other Cross- Dressers Author(S): Susan Fillin-Yeh Source: Oxford Art Journal, Vol
    Dandies, Marginality and Modernism: Georgia O'Keeffe, Marcel Duchamp and Other Cross- Dressers Author(s): Susan Fillin-Yeh Source: Oxford Art Journal, Vol. 18, No. 2 (1995), pp. 33-44 Published by: Oxford University Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1360551 . Accessed: 18/11/2014 15:10 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Oxford University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Oxford Art Journal. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 209.129.16.124 on Tue, 18 Nov 2014 15:10:13 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Dandies, Marginality and Modernism: Georgia O'Keeffe, Marcel Duchamp and other Cross-dressers SUSAN FILLIN-YEH Two photographs made at nearly the same time in borrowed his fashionable hat with its wonderful the 1920s, and in the same city, New York, offer the patterned headband from a friend, Grace Ewing, dandy's image to twentieth-century viewers. For, and it was Ewing who posed for the hands. studied singly and in their interrelationships, both Duchamp finished his creation by retouching Ray's Alfred Stieglitz's photograph of painter Georgia photograph, softening the lens' focus to exaggerate O'Keeffe dressed with uncompromising and elegant the shadowy, sultry image of a femmefatale'smyster- simplicity in an oversized man's hat, dark suit jacket ious and elusive mobility.
    [Show full text]
  • Edna Ferber Last
    EDNA FERBER’S WOMEN CHARACTERS, 1911 – 1930, AND THE REINTERPRETATION OF THE AMERICAN DREAM THROUGH A FEMALE LENS A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of The School of Continuing Studies And the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts In Liberal Studies By Anne Efman Abramson, B.A. Georgetown University Washington, D.C. April 30, 2010 EDNA FERBER’S WOMEN CHARACTERS, 1911 – 1930, AND THE REINTERPRETATION OF THE AMERICAN DREAM THROUGH A FEMALE LENS Anne E. Abramson, B.A. Mentor: Michael Collins, Ph. D. ABSTRACT Edna Ferber (1885‐1963) was a Pulitzer Prize‐winning author and one of the most popular writers of her time. Today, however, she is rarely read in schools or colleges, although her plays are still produced, and the films based on her novels, plays and short stories continue to be appreciated by classic film lovers. This thesis demonstrates how Edna Ferber created female characters in the early years of the twentieth century who struggled against the constraints of society’s traditional female roles, who were the first in their nontraditional professions, and who achieved their own version of the American Dream. Edna Ferber also revisited American history with stories that highlighted women’s contributions to America. This thesis first introduces Edna Ferber, her background and her early years drawing from Ferber’s two autobiographies, A Peculiar Treasure, 1939, and ii A Kind of Magic, 1963. Second, it discusses the New Woman at the turn of the century; the American Dream, historically and in relation to Ferber’s female characters; and Edna Ferber as a middlebrow modern writer whose literary output had powerful cultural agency.
    [Show full text]
  • Drake Plays 1927-2021.Xls
    Drake Plays 1927-2021.xls TITLE OF PLAY 1927-8 Dulcy SEASON You and I Tragedy of Nan Twelfth Night 1928-9 The Patsy SEASON The Passing of the Third Floor Back The Circle A Midsummer Night's Dream 1929-30 The Swan SEASON John Ferguson Tartuffe Emperor Jones 1930-1 He Who Gets Slapped SEASON Miss Lulu Bett The Magistrate Hedda Gabler 1931-2 The Royal Family SEASON Children of the Moon Berkeley Square Antigone 1932-3 The Perfect Alibi SEASON Death Takes a Holiday No More Frontier Arms and the Man Twelfth Night Dulcy 1933-4 Our Children SEASON The Bohemian Girl The Black Flamingo The Importance of Being Earnest Much Ado About Nothing The Three Cornered Moon 1934-5 You Never Can Tell SEASON The Patriarch Another Language The Criminal Code 1935-6 The Tavern SEASON Cradle Song Journey's End Good Hope Elizabeth the Queen 1936-7 Squaring the Circle SEASON The Joyous Season Drake Plays 1927-2021.xls Moor Born Noah Richard of Bordeaux 1937-8 Dracula SEASON Winterset Daugthers of Atreus Ladies of the Jury As You Like It 1938-9 The Bishop Misbehaves SEASON Enter Madame Spring Dance Mrs. Moonlight Caponsacchi 1939-40 Laburnam Grove SEASON The Ghost of Yankee Doodle Wuthering Heights Shadow and Substance Saint Joan 1940-1 The Return of the Vagabond SEASON Pride and Prejudice Wingless Victory Brief Music A Winter's Tale Alison's House 1941-2 Petrified Forest SEASON Journey to Jerusalem Stage Door My Heart's in the Highlands Thunder Rock 1942-3 The Eve of St.
    [Show full text]
  • Arguing Their World: the Representation of Major Social and Cultural Issues in Edna Ferber’S and Fannie Hurst’S Fiction, 1910-1935
    1 ARGUING THEIR WORLD: THE REPRESENTATION OF MAJOR SOCIAL AND CULTURAL ISSUES IN EDNA FERBER’S AND FANNIE HURST’S FICTION, 1910-1935 A dissertation presented By Kathryn Ruth Bloom to The Department of English In partial fulfillment of the reQuirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy In the field of English Northeastern University Boston, Massachusetts April 2018 2 ARGUING THEIR WORLD: THE REPRESENTATION OF MAJOR SOCIAL AND CULTURAL ISSUES IN EDNA FERBER’S AND FANNIE HURST’S FICTION, 1910-1935 A dissertation presented By Kathryn Ruth Bloom ABSTRACT OF DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the reQuirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in English in the College of Social Sciences and Humanities of Northeastern University April 2018 3 ABSTRACT BetWeen the early decades of the twentieth-century and mid-century, Edna Ferber and Fannie Hurst were popular and prolific authors of fiction about American society and culture. Almost a century ago, they were writing about race, immigration, economic disparity, drug addiction, and other issues our society is dealing with today with a reneWed sense of urgency. In spite of their extraordinary popularity, by the time they died within a feW months of each other in 1968, their reputations had fallen into eclipse. This dissertation focuses on Ferber’s and Hurst’s fiction published betWeen approximately 1910 and 1935, the years in Which both authors enjoyed the highest critical and popular esteem. Perhaps because these realistic narratives generally do not engage in the stylistic experimentation of the literary world around them, literary scholars came to undervalue their Work.
    [Show full text]
  • A History of Production
    A HISTORY OF PRODUCTION 2020-2021 2019-2020 2018-2019 Annie Stripped: Cry It Out, Ohio State The Humans 12 Angry Jurors Murders, The Empty Space Private Lies Avenue Q The Wolves The Good Person of Setzuan john proctor is the villain As It Is in Heaven Sweet Charity A Celebration of Women’s Voices in Musical Theatre 2017-2018 2016-2017 2015-2016 The Cradle Will Rock The Foreigner Reefer Madness Sense and Sensibility Upton Abbey Tartuffe The Women of Lockerbie A Piece of my Heart Expecting Isabel 9 to 5 Urinetown Hello, Dolly! 2014-2015 2013-2014 2012-2013 Working The Laramie Project: Ten Years Later The Miss Firecracker Contest Our Town The 25th Annual Putnam County The Drowsy Chaperone Machinal Spelling Bee Anna in the Tropics Guys and Dolls The Clean House She Stoops to Conquer The Lost Comedies of William Shakespeare 2011-2012 2010-2011 2009-2010 The Sweetest Swing in Baseball Biloxi Blues Antigone Little Shop of Horrors Grease Cabaret Picasso at the Lapin Agile Letters to Sala How I Learned to Drive Love’s Labour’s Lost It’s All Greek to Me Playhouse Creatures 2008-2009 2007-2008 2006-2007 Doubt Equus The Mousetrap They’re Playing Our Song Gypsy Annie Get Your Gun A Midsummer Night’s Dream The Importance of Being Earnest Rumors I Hate Hamlet Murder We Wrote Henry V 2005-2006 2004-2005 2003-2004 Starting Here, Starting Now Oscar and Felix Noises Off Pack of Lies Extremities 2 X Albee: “The Sandbox” and “The Zoo All My Sons Twelfth Night Story” Lend Me a Tenor A Day in Hollywood/A Night in the The Triumph of Love Ukraine Babes in Arms
    [Show full text]
  • Maroh 22, 1939) Eme Bong ­ Tudl0 Anndunoement .L
    THE LIBRARY SP AKS (Maroh 22, 1939) eme Bong ­ tudl0 AnnDunoement .L. - at's new in books? For the past eeks many new books have een comng from the presses. Examining the best new books we find the usual crop of historical fiction. Regional novels sellDlto be more bundant than usual, personal memoirs (interesting ones, too, ) supnly n~ titles for our readers. In passing I might mention Edith Bolling I1son 1s, "My Memoir" in which she aims to tell the truth concerning personal matters which have been distorted by the mis­ informed. )(ra. Wilson IS biography might be used as a forerunner for the group which I am to review briefly today. Events which Mrs. 11son watvhed personally served as the basis for the Europena situation of today. The end of the WOrld war, the Peace conference. are events hloh paved the way for the Europe of today. They paved the way for the whole group of books whlch we shall examine this morning. Heading the 11st 1s tlUeln Ka.mpf' by Adolf HitIer. hloh has been published 1n two unabridged American editions this spring. The one is published by He~ ~Qa-~'~l~-aaQ-~&P&~e~G¥ Reynal and Hitchcock by rrangement with Houghton Mifflin, holders of the oopyright in this oountry. The second edition is be1ng published by Stackpole Sons • The library has purohased the Reynal and Hi~choook ~ditlon. Mein Kampf '8 the sto~y of Hitler's career, hie aims, and his methods. It is the autobiography of the former painter who rose from obscurity to supreme power in Germany and who today has the world tTembllng on hi deoisions.
    [Show full text]
  • Canonicity and the American Public Library: the Case of American Women Writers
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Illinois Digital Environment for Access to Learning and... Canonicity and the American Public Library: The Case of American Women Writers Sarah Wadsworth Abstract Beginning with an overview of the debate over American women writers and the academic canon, this essay inventories four clusters of American women writers—domestic novelists, regionalists, mod- ernists, and writers of diverse ethnicities—within a representative sampling of small-town public libraries across the Midwest from the late nineteenth to the mid-twentieth century. The survey reveals some surprising disjunctures that run counter to trends in the academy. It also highlights the role publishers and bibliographers have played in establishing favored texts for a general readership and demon- strates that publishers of literary classics and bibliographies geared toward librarians have not always promoted the same texts as their academic counterparts. On the whole, it concludes, women writ- ers fared quite well in the hands of publishers and public libraries promoting “the classics” at the same time that they suffered at the hands of major textbook publishers and scholarly editors intent on defining “the canon.” At the 1981 Modern Language Association annual convention, a “New American Literary History” forum sponsored a special session on the topic “A New American Literature Anthology.” Led by Judith Fetterley and Joan Schulz of the MLA’s Commission on the Status of Women, the session sparked a lively dialogue on the neglect of women writers in Amer- ican literature. The commission had recently undertaken a study of the representation of works by women in standard classroom anthologies, and the results were discouraging.
    [Show full text]
  • “A Luncheon for Suffrage
    Revista de Estudios Norteamericanos, nº 16 (2012) Seville, Spain, ISSN 1133-309-X, 75-90 A LUNCHEON FOR SUFFRAGE: THEATRICAL CONTRIBUTIONS OF HETERODOXY TO THE ENFRANCHISEMENT OF THE AMERICAN WOMAN NOELIA HERNANDO REAL Universidad Complutense de Madrid [email protected] Received 27th September 2012 Accepted 14th January 2013 KEYWORDS: Heterodoxy; US woman suffrage; theater; Susan Glaspell; Charlotte Perkins Gilman; Marie Jenney Howe; Paula Jakobi; George Middleton; Mary Shaw. PALABRAS CLAVE: Heterodoxy; sufragio femenino en EEUU; teatro; Susan Glaspell; Charlotte Perkins Gilman; Marie Jenney Howe; Paula Jakobi; George Middleton; Mary Shaw. ABSTRACT: This article explores and discusses the intertextualities that are found in selected plays written in the circle of Heterodoxy in the 1910s, the Greenwich Village-based radical club for unorthodox women. The article examines some of the parallels that can be found in Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s Something to Vote For, George Middleton’s Back of the Ballot, Mary Jenney Howe’s An Anti-Suffrage Monologue and Telling the Truth at the White House, written in collaboration with Paula Jakobi, Mary Shaw’s The Parrot Cage and The Woman of It, and Susan Glaspell’s Trifles, Bernice, Chains of Dew and Woman’s Honor. The works are put in the context of the national movement for woman suffrage and focuses on the authors’ arguments for suffrage as well as on their formal choices, ranging from realism to expressionism, satire and parody. RESUMEN: El presente artículo explora y discute las intertextualidades que se encuentran en una selección de obras escritas en el círculo de Heterodoxy, el club para mujeres no-ortodoxas con base en Greenwich Village, en la década de 1910.
    [Show full text]
  • The Power of Place: Structure, Culture, and Continuities in U.S. Women's Movements
    The Power of Place: Structure, Culture, and Continuities in U.S. Women's Movements By Laura K. Nelson A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Kim Voss, Chair Professor Raka Ray Professor Robin Einhorn Fall 2014 Copyright 2014 by Laura K. Nelson 1 Abstract The Power of Place: Structure, Culture, and Continuities in U.S. Women's Movements by Laura K. Nelson Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology University of California, Berkeley Professor Kim Voss, Chair This dissertation challenges the widely accepted historical accounts of women's movements in the United States. Second-wave feminism, claim historians, was unique because of its development of radical feminism, defined by its insistence on changing consciousness, its focus on women being oppressed as a sex-class, and its efforts to emphasize the political nature of personal problems. I show that these features of second-wave radical feminism were not in fact unique but existed in almost identical forms during the first wave. Moreover, within each wave of feminism there were debates about the best way to fight women's oppression. As radical feminists were arguing that men as a sex-class oppress women as a sex-class, other feminists were claiming that the social system, not men, is to blame. This debate existed in both the first and second waves. Importantly, in both the first and the second wave there was a geographical dimension to these debates: women and organizations in Chicago argued that the social system was to blame while women and organizations in New York City argued that men were to blame.
    [Show full text]