Dont Just Vote, Select! Promise vs. Performance Report 2014 - 2019
Make an informed choice ? ? ? ?
Flip over to find out if
attended decisive parliamentary sessions regularly for played an active role in parliamentary proceedings for YOUR asked questions in parliament on pertinent issues for lived up to the promises made to YOU addressed the issues that are cared about by MP wisely utilised the annual allocation of funds for
1 Do you know Who your MP is?
GOPAL SHETTY, BJP
BORIVALI GAJANAN DAHISAR KIRTIKAR, KANDIVALI SHS MALAD ANDHERI (E&W), GOREGAON, N JUHU, JOGESHWARI (E&W), VILE PARLE (W)
NW NE
POONAM MAHAJAN, BJP
ANDHERI (E), BANDRA (E&W), CHUNA BHATI, NC KHAR (E&W), KURLA, KHERWADI, KIRIT TILAKNAGAR, SOMAIYA VIDYA VIHAR,
VILE PARLE (E&W) SC BJP
SANTACRUZ (E&W), BHANDUP, CHEMBUR, WHAT GHATKOPAR, GOVANDI, KANJUR MARG, KHINDI PADA DOES S MANKHURD, MULUND, TROMBAY, VIDYA VIHAR, AN MP VIKHROLI ARVIND SAWANT, SHS DO? BYCULLA, MASJID, CST AREA, BUNDER RAHUL SHEWALE, SHS CHARNI RD, MAZGAON, CHINCHPOKLI, MUMBADEVI, ANTOP HILL, MAHIM, CHURCHGATE, MUMBAI CENTRAL, CHEMBUR, CHUNA MATUNGA, COLABA, NAGPADA, BHATI, DADAR, NAINGAUM, PAREL, COTTON GREEN, OPERA HOUSE, DHARAVI, PRABHADEVI, CURREY RD, PAREL, DOCKYARD RD, REAY RD, ELPHINSTONE SION, TILAK ELPHINSTONE RD, SANDHURST RD, ROAD, GOVANDI, NAGAR, GIRGAUM, SEWRI, GTB NAGAR, TROMBAY, WADALA GRANT ROAD, TARDEO, KING’S CIRCLE, KALBHADEVI KH UMERKHADI, MARINE LINES, WORLI 2 3 Pri ry R s o si i i i s of MPs A Question of u s io s The Constitution of India defines what an MP is responsible for through its Why are Parlimentary Questions It is an MP’s way to get to know the impact of national policies on his constituency. It is their Union and Concurrent List. The list is rather voluminous, but the major areas are: asked by MPs Important? alternative to RTI and an equalizer between independent MPs and star members of a party!
DEFENSE FOREIGN RAILWAYS NATIONAL PORTS & AVIATION BANKING & SOCIAL Number of questions asked Total number of questions asked by MP in parliament AFFAIRS HIGHWAYS SHIPPING FINANCE SECURITY Top five ministries first 15 sessions May 2015 to Aug 2018.
National Average 270 questions
Data Source: loksabha.nic.in Source: Data MINISTRY NAME 10 QUESTIONS 100 QUESTIONS TRADE & HEAVY ENERGY LABOUR & PRIMARY & LAW, JUSTICE TAXATION HERITAGE COMMERCE INDUSTRIES & POWER EMPLOYMENT HIGHER & COURTS PRESERVATION HUMAN RESOURCE EDUCATION DEVELOPMENT
FINANCE
DEFENCE
AGRICULTURE AND S o ry R s o si i i i s of MPs FARMERS WELFARE 423 RAILWAYS GOPAL SHETTY While MPs are eligible to spend Rs. crore year on
local needs of their constituency (as part of the MPLAD scheme), their primary responsibilities are broader HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE national and policy issues. MPs are NOT the primary TOILETS, SANITATION ROADS & FOOTPATHS WATER SUPPLY FINANCE persons responsible for local needs such as: WASTE MANAGEMENT DRAINAGE GARDENS
RAILWAYS
AGRICULTURE AND Data from May 2014 - Aug 2018 FARMERS WELFARE GAJANAN KIRTIKAR 943 HOME AFFAIRS
INV ISIBLE 59% National Average 80% RAILWAYS
FINANCE
ENVIORNMENT & FORESTS H AND CLIMATE CHANGE E A L HT L EH IV CIVIL AVIATION A Y E L W H H T82% H I AGRICULTURE AND EH E R KIRIT SOMAIYA 429 H A Y E A E FARMERS WELFARE E LA L H A T 79% L T E L HT H T A YH Y HL L L I Y I T HOME AFFAIRS YV 79% L V H E 88%94% I E V W87% Y W E I R I 97% W DEFENCE R
E I E R
98% E ENVIORNMENT & FORESTS 98%
A 100% AND CLIMATE CHANGE WOMEN AND CHILDREN in Parliament DEVLOPMENT POONAM MAHAJAN 402 Why is attendance in parliament important? FINANCE Your MP's job is to represent you, he is your voice in parliament. RAILWAYS How will you be heard if he isn't there? Knowing his attendance in parliament is one way of knowing if your MP is worthy of your vote. FINANCE
Find out if he /she shows up. HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE GOPAL SHETTY KIRIT SOMAIYA RAHUL SHEWALE ARVIND SAWANT ARVIND SAWANT RAHUL SHEWALE KIRIT SOMAIYA POONAM MAHAJAN GOPAL SHETTY GAJANAN KIRTIKAR GAJANAN KIRTIKAR POONAM MAHAJAN HOME AFFAIRS
AGRICULTURE AND 7 37 0 0 Why is participation in debates RAHUL SHEWALE 774 FARMERS WELFARE 72 important? 11 P r i i io RAILWAYS It shows their active participation
14156 142 on various issues in parliament. in Debates FINANCE “Data range: 15 sessions between May 2014 and Aug 2018” AGRICULTURE AND
193 37.9 FARMERS WELFARE National Average64 Data Source: loksabha.nic.in HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE National Average(16 sessions)264 (15 sessions) 57 4 HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT ARVIND SAWANT 5
430
National Average 89% 10% Percentage over Percentage funds released MPLAD Breakdown: RTI accessed from collector’s office (City and Suburbs) (100%) (84%) (91%) (100%) (100%) (87%)
13 Cr 17.1 Cr 18.9 Cr 22.6 Cr 18.2 Cr 12.5 Cr E penditure E penditure E penditure E penditure
E penditure E penditure
se, as per our methodology, 1 Cr Released Released Cr 1 Released Cr 1 Released Cr 22. 20 Cr Released Cr 20 Released Cr 1 . Released Cr 1 7 percentage is not greater than 100%. percentage is not greater S i P r s S i *Note: In some cases the expenditure incurred is *Note: In some cases KIRIT SOMAIYA GOPAL SHETTY RAHUL SHEWALE ARVIND SAWANT GAJANAN KIRTIKAR POONAM MAHAJAN