DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT PANEL
Minutes
Meeting held in the Council Chambers, Main Street, Cambrai
Monday 31 October 2005, 10.00am
1. PRESENT
BJ Taylor (Presiding Member), IR Mann OAM, HE Knipe, DT Townsend, DJ Burgess, R Dawkins, R Mead, IK Bormann and GL Drinkwater
2. IN ATTENDANCE
Mr KL Goldstone, Environmental Services Manager Mr GD Parsons, Development Officer - Planning
3. COMMENCEMENT AND WELCOME 10.00AM
The Presiding Member declared the meeting open and welcomed all members.
4. APOLOGIES Nil.
5. CONFIRMATION OF PREVIOUS MINUTES
(Page 1782 – 26/9/2005)
1812/1 D Townsend moved that the minutes of the Mid Murray Council Development Assessment Panel Meeting held on 26 September 2005 be taken as read and confirmed subject to DT Townsend’s apology being recorded. Seconded I Mann. CARRIED.
6. DEVELOPMENT REPORT
1812/2 D Burgess moved that the report be received. Seconded I Bormann. CARRIED.
Development Assessment Panel 1812 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL
6. DEVELOPMENT REPORT CONT’D
BUSINESS ARISING FROM REPORT
6.8 Development Application 711/307/05 – RW & K Shulver
1813/1 D Burgess moved that in forming the opinion Development Application 711/307/05 is not seriously at variance with Council’s Development Plan, the Development Assessment Panel resolve the application be granted Provisional Development Plan Consent, with a 6.0 metre setback from the Pearson Street boundary (measured from the wall of the building as detailed in correspondence received from the applicants dated 13 October 2005) subject to the attachment of relevant conditions under delegated authority. Seconded I Bormann. CARRIED.
6.9 ElectraNet SA
10.25 AM Mr Myles Somers, Urban & Regional Planner – ElectraNet SA, addressed the Panel.
10.47 AM The meeting adjourned.
11.10 AM The meeting resumed.
1813/2 R Mead moved that the late correspondence from B & K Munday be received. Seconded D Burgess. CARRIED.
11.30 AM Mr Myles Somers left the meeting.
1813/3 I Mann moved that the Development Assessment Commission be advised that the Mid Murray Council Development Assessment Panel is of the view that the development application, submitted under Section 49(2) of the Development Act 1993, to establish an electricity substation over Allotment 17 of Filed Plan 157552, Tepko-Mt Torrens Road, Hundred of Tungkillo, is not seriously at variance with Council’s Development Plan and therefore warrants the granting of provisional development plan consent. Seconded R Dawkins. CARRIED.
Development Late Report
1813/4 R Dawkins moved that the late report be received. Seconded R Mead. CARRIED.
Development Assessment Panel 1813 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL
6. DEVELOPMENT REPORT CONT’D
6.10 Development Application 711/506/05 - Tincknell Nominees Pty Ltd
1814/1 R Dawkins moved that development application 711/506/05 is deemed seriously at variance with the land management agreement registered over the subject land, and in particular is at variance with Clause 4 under the heading ‘Materials and Finishes’ of the First Schedule. Further the development application is deemed seriously at variance with the Council Development Plan, and in particular the following Objectives and Principles of Development Control, and on both counts is refused:-
Council Wide Objective 15; Council Wide Principles of Development Control 33, 37 and 42.
Seconded R Mead. CARRIED.
7. LATE CORRESPONDENCE
Nil.
8. OTHER BUSINESS
Nil.
9. NEXT MEETING
To be held in the Meeting Room of the Mannum Council Offices, 49 Adelaide Road, Mannum on Monday, 19 December 2005, commencing at 10.00am.
10. CLOSURE
11.52 AM The Presiding Member declared the meeting closed.
……………………………………… PRESIDING MEMBER
……………………………………… DATE
Development Assessment Panel 1814 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.1 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RECEIVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/441/05 Date Received 15.09.2005 Name A & R Pym Description Dwelling Extensions Location Lot 1 of F6277, Tepko-Mount Torrens Road, Hundred of Tungkillo
Development No. 711/442/05 Date Received 13.09.2005 Name I Alexander Description Jetty Location Lot 71 of D53187, Section 163, Pelde Street, Punyelroo, Hundred of Fisher
Development No. 711/444/05 Date Received 13.09.2005 Name J & K Sharp Description Dwelling Location Lot 115 of F100107, Section 210, Government Road, Scotts Creek, Hundred of Eba
Development No. 711/445/05 Date Received 16.09.2005 Name KM & CF Gray Description Decking Location Part Allotment 14, Lot 36 of F203, South Punyelroo Shack Road, South Punyelroo, Hundred of Fisher
Development No. 711/446/05 Date Received 16.09.2005 Name B & B Heinicke Description Shed Extension Location Lot 1 of D55766, East Front Road, Younghusband, Hundred of Younghusband
Development No. 711/447/05 Date Received 16.09.2005 Name JA Barrett Description Shack Extension Location Part Allotment 14, Lot 3 of F203, South Punyelroo Shack Road, South Punyelroo, Hundred of Fisher
Development No. 711/448/05 Date Received 16.09.2005 Name R Hall Description Shed Location Lot 3 of F110105, Part Section Z, East Front Road, Hundred of Younghusband
Development No. 711/449/05 Date Received 19.09.2005 Name P & R Kelly Description Carport Location Lot 104 of F169853, Palmer Reservoir Road, Hundred of Tungkillo
Development No. 711/450/05 Date Received 16.09.2005 Name R Millington Description Floating Pontoon & Leisure Deck Location Part Allotment 11, Lot 23 of D33358, Section 193, Marks Landing Shack Road, Hundred of Nildottie
Development Assessment Panel 1815 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.1 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RECEIVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/451/05 Date Received 21.09.2005 Name RF Salisbury Description Upgrade of Jetty & Boat Mooring Location Lot 6 of D5508, Part Section 146, Purnong Road, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/453/05 Date Received 21.09.2005 Name G Hill Description Verandah Location Lot 91 of F216025, Section 560, Government Road, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/454/05 Date Received 22.09.2005 Name Mannum Slipway & Moorings Description Replacement Shed Location Lot 508 of FP208884, Part Section 1423, Bowhill Road, Hundred of Younghusband
Development No. 711/455/05 Date Received 23.09.2005 Name KD & PL Larner Description Shed Location Lot 3 of F202, Part Section 115, Swan Reach Mannum Road, Hundred of Fisher
Development No. 711/456/05 Date Received 23.09.2005 Name WS Barr Description Domestic Garage Location Lot 215 of F208591, Part Section 62, 20 Phillip Avenue, Swan Reach, Hundred of Nildottie
Development No. 711/457/05 Date Received 27.09.2005 Name AD & VM Marschall Description Dwelling Location Section 262, Government Road, Hundred of Cadell
Development No. 711/458/05 Date Received 27.09.2005 Name Mid Murray Council Description Two Cabins Location Section 906, Purnong Road, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/460/05 Date Received 28.09.2005 Name B Schache Description Shed Location Section 485, Flood Road, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/461/05 Date Received 28.09.2005 Name L Howie & Co Description Garage Extension Location Lot 7 of D63330, Part Section 314, Mannum Purnong Road, Mannum, Hundred of Ridley
Development Assessment Panel 1816 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.1 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RECEIVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/462/05 Date Received 28.09.2005 Name Captain Cook Cruises Description Disability Access Boardwalk/Ramp Location Section 273, Preiss Landing Road, Big Bend, Hundred of Ridley
Development No. 711/463/05 Date Received 28.09.2005 Name NO Zimmermann Description Implement Shed Location Lot 3 of D43343, Cambrai Truro Road, Sedan, Hundred of Jellicoe
Development No. 711/464/05 Date Received 28.09.2005 Name P Vlassco Description Dwelling Location Section 626, Government Road, Hundred of Cadell
Development No. 711/465/05 Date Received 29.09.2005 Name CD & JR Jarred Description Carport/Pergola Location Lot 51 of D50705, 32 Bretag Street, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/466/05 Date Received 30.09.2005 Name J Bailes Description Deck Extension Location Lot 15 of 20550, Part Section 429, Arnold Court, Hundred of Nildottie
Development No. 711/467/05 Date Received 30.09.2005 Name Paramount Developments Pty Ltd Description Verandah Location Lot 58 of F157593, 4 Adelaide Road, Hundred of Tungkillo
Development No. 711/468/05 Date Received 30.09.2005 Name B Metcalf Description Aircraft Hanger Location Lot 3 of 1454, Part Section 165, Schilling Road, Annadale, Hundred of Anna
Development No. 711/469/05 Date Received 30.09.2005 Name M & J Van Der Keyl Description Transportable Dwelling Location Lot 296 of D20855, 7 Merivale Street, Hundred of Skurray
Development No. 711/470/05 Date Received 04.10.2005 Name Softwoods Timberyards Pty Ltd Description Verandah Location Lot 60 of D64327, Piece 73, Government Road, Hundred of Younghusband
Development Assessment Panel 1817 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.1 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RECEIVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/471/05 Date Received 04.10.2005 Name A McShane Description Verandah Location Lot 149 of D120701, 12 Sixth Street, Morgan, Hundred of Eba
Development No. 711/472/05 Date Received 05.10.2005 Name Fairmont Homes Pty Ltd Description Dwelling Location Lot 104 of D62719, Section 466, Budarick Road, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/473/05 Date Received 05.10.2005 Name S Krahling Description Shed Location Lot 53 of D36193, Muller's Road, Black Hill, Hundred of Angas
Development No. 711/474/05 Date Received 05.10.2005 Name G Rogers Description Shed Location Lot 26 of D5793, Part Section 299, 21 Rob Loxton Road, Walker Flat, Hundred of Ridley
Development No. 711/475/05 Date Received 05.10.2005 Name Department for Environment & Heritage Description Removal of Retaining Wall & Associated Earthworks Location Lot 12 of D54900, Government Road, Hundred of Nildottie
Development No. 711/476/05 Date Received 05.10.2005 Name BAC Marshall Description Garage & Carport Location Lot 20 of D62821, Providence Drive, Bowhill, Hundred of Younghusband
Development No. 711/477/05 Date Received 05.10.2005 Name Selecta Homes Description Transportable Dwelling Location Lot 55, Section 358, Ramm Road, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/478/05 Date Received 05.10.2005 Name System Built Homes Description Dwelling Location Section 270, Government Road, Hundred of Eba
Development No. 711/479/05 Date Received 10.10.2005 Name G Smith & R Rogers Description Dwelling Location Lot 82 of D7839, Ramm Road, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss
Development Assessment Panel 1818 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.1 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RECEIVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/480/05 Date Received 06.10.2005 Name D & N Burt Description Pergola/Verandah Location Lot 5 of DP35935, Government Road, Western Flat, Hundred of Stuart
Development No. 711/481/05 Date Received 06.10.2005 Name S DiCicco Description Shed Location Lot 320, Part Section 250, Government Road, Zadows Landing, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/482/05 Date Received 07.10.2005 Name DR Stanton Description Two Semi Detached Dwellings Location Lot 102 of D63543, 7/9 Parker Street, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/483/05 Date Received 07.10.2005 Name KD Pickett & BJ Hermans Description Double Garage Location Section 376, Strachans Road, Cookes Hill, Hundred of Jutland
Development No. 711/484/05 Date Received 10.10.2005 Name Mr & Mrs E Heintzberger Description Overhead Walkway Location Lot A of F204111, Bond Street, Walker Flat, Hundred of Ridley
Development No. 711/485/05 Date Received 10.10.2005 Name D Kennedy Description Storage Shed Location Lot 37 of F157572, Hundred of Tungkillo
Development No. 711/486/05 Date Received 10.10.2005 Name D Bartlett Description Shed Location Lot 25 of F101168, Section 42, Page Drive, Hundred of Skurray
Development No. 711/487/05 Date Received 06.10.2005 Name AD & MJ Bradshaw Description Transportable Dwelling Location Section 481, Lovers Lane, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/488/05 Date Received 11.10.2005 Name N & J Bormann Description Storage Shed Location Lot 81 of D1091, William Street, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss
Development Assessment Panel 1819 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.1 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RECEIVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/489/05 Date Received 13.10.2005 Name A & DM Doyle Description Garden Shed Location Lot 18 of D62821, Providence Drive, Bowhill, Hundred of Younghusband
Development No. 711/490/05 Date Received 13.10.2005 Name Rocca's Home Improvements Description Domestic Verandah Location Lot 2 of DP44123, Eudunda Road, Truro, Hundred of Dutton
Development No. 711/491/05 Date Received 17.10.2005 Name G Salvemini Description Solid Annex Location Section 906, Purnong Road, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/492/05 Date Received 17.10.2005 Name G Salvemini Description Solid Annex Location Section 906, Purnong Road, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/493/05 Date Received 18.10.2005 Name E Saunders Description Garage Location Lot 82 of D7839, Ramm Road, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/494/05 Date Received 18.10.2005 Name CR & VA Zadow Description Garage Location Section 657, Martin Road, Wall Flat, Hundred of Finniss
Development No. 711/495/05 Date Received 17.10.2005 Name J & P Grear Description Dwelling Location Lot 4 of DP45771, Government Road, Hundred of Younghusband
Development No. 711/496/05 Date Received 18.10.2005 Name T Lansom & A Dewitt-Lansom Description Replacement Dwelling Location Section 546, Keyneton Estate Road, Keyneton, Hundred of Jellicoe
Development No. 711/497/05 Date Received 17.10.2005 Name Dahlitz Constructions Pty Ltd Description Garage Location Section 9, Government Road, Hundred of Beatty
Development Assessment Panel 1820 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.1 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS RECEIVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/498/05 Date Received 17.10.2005 Name RC & LC McPherson Description Dwelling Addition Location Lot 2 of D33358, Section 193, Marks Landing Shack Road, Marks Landing, Hundred of Nildottie
Development No. 711/499/05 Date Received 18.10.2005 Name RW Ashby Description Shed Location Lot 140 of F100107, Section 218, Government Road, Hundred of Eba
Development Assessment Panel 1821 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.2 LAND DIVISION APPLICATIONS RECEIVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/C031/05 Date Received 15.09.2005 Name S & W Gowling Description Land Division - Creation of seven additional allotments Location Lot 200 of D24686, East Front Road, Hundred of Younghusband
Development No. 711/D035/05 Date Received 16.09.2005 Name NR & CV Weber Description Land Division - Creation of one additional allotment Location Pieces 2 & 3, Government Road, Bowhill, Hundred of Bowhill
Development No. 711/D036/05 Date Received 27.09.2005 Name JK Keynes Description Land Division - Creation of one additional allotment Location Lot 629 of F209005, Government Road, Graetz Town, Hundred of Jellicoe
Development No. 711/D037/05 Date Received 10.10.2005 Name B Hayes Description Boundary Re-Alignment Location Sections 156 & 163, Herbig & Klose Roads, Hundred of Finniss
Development Assessment Panel 1822 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.3 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS APPROVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/597/02 Date Approved 16.09.05 Name DM & TA Dewhurst Location Section 174, Government Road, Hundred of Eba Description Transportable Dwelling Value $14,000.00
Development No. 711/515/04 Date Approved 14.10.05 Name ID & MJ Crafter Location Lot 56 of D53979, Section 582, Mannum Purnong Road, Caurnamont, Hundred of Ridley Description Twelve Month Extension of Time for 711/416/03 & Amendment to Original Plan Value $200,000.00
Development No. 711/549/04 Date Approved 30.09.05 Name R & J Cook Location Lot 161 of F100107, Section 217, Scotts Creek, Hundred of Eba Description Replacement Garage Value $9,958.00
Development No. 711/608/04 Date Approved 21.09.05 Name GA Kirk Location From Lot 70 through Council reserve between Lots 19 & 20 of F101168, Section 42, Page Drive, Riverbanks Estate, Hundred of Finniss Description Infrastructure for non-potable water supply to River Murray Value $800.00
Development No. 711/105/05 Date Approved 04.10.05 Name River Gum Homes Pty Ltd Location Lot 127 of D62821, Providence Drive, Bowhill, Hundred of Younghusband Description Dwelling Value $214,264.00
Development No. 711/190/05 Date Approved 29.09.05 Name GD & DK Lennell Location Part Allotment 1, Lot 12 of F8274, Section 260, Government Road, Brenda Park, Hundred of Eba Description Retaining Wall & Stabilisation of River Bank Value $12,000.00
Development No. 711/194/05 Date Approved 30.09.05 Name J Feltus Location Section 672, Keynes Road, Keyneton, Hundred of Jellicoe Description Storage Shed Value $15,000.00
Development Assessment Panel 1823 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.3 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS APPROVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/220/05 Date Approved 12.10.05 Name More for Less Pty Ltd Location Lot 1 of D60682, Punyelroo Road, Punyelroo, Hundred of Fisher Description Boat Shed Value $4,000.00
Development No. 711/237/05 Date Approved 30.09.05 Name GR & PA Waters Location Lot 55 of FP37451, Government Road, Hundred of Finniss Description Signage Value $500.00
Development No. 711/266/05 Date Approved 05.10.05 Name C & K Dayman Location Lot 11 of C11308, Section 236, Apold Court, Hundred of Cadell Description Dwelling Value $71,060.00
Development No. 711/277/05 Date Approved 22.09.05 Name M Ramsey Location Part Allotment 8, Lot 47 of D4980, Part Section 299, 89 Rob Loxton Road, Walker Flat, Hundred of Ridley Description Retaining Wall Upgrade Value $1,000.00
Development No. 711/283/05 Date Approved 05.10.05 Name LA Hausler Location Lot 86 of T120701, 27 Seventh Street, Morgan, Hundred of Eba Description Storage Shed Value $2,000.00
Development No. 711/290/05 Date Approved 20.09.05 Name TS Browne Location Lot 6 of D54187, Government Road, Hundred of Younghusband Description Shed Extension Value $1,000.00
Development No. 711/293/05 Date Approved 28.09.05 Name River Gum Homes Pty Ltd Location Lot 263, 11 Acland Street, Blanchetown, Hundred of Skurray Description Dwelling Value $59,907.00
Development No. 711/297/05 Date Approved 17.10.05 Name Mortow (No. 46) Pty Ltd Location Lot 9 of D57490, Government Road, Hundred of Stuart Description Upgrade of Existing Floating Landing Value $1,500.00
Development Assessment Panel 1824 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.3 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS APPROVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/303/05 Date Approved 20.09.05 Name GI & GL Rogers Location Lot 1 of F157760, Adelaide-Mannum Road, Hundred of Tungkillo Description Garage Value $6,000.00
Development No. 711/313/05 Date Approved 11.10.05 Name A Black Location Section 728, East Front Road, Hundred of Younghusband Description Garage Value $4,000.00
Development No. 711/316/05 Date Approved 17.10.05 Name G McVicar Location Part Allotment 4, Lot 105, Section 226, Government Road, Brenda Park, Hundred of Eba Description Dwelling Value $60,000.00
Development No. 711/318/05 Date Approved 17.10.05 Name Dahlitz Constructions Location Lot 50 of D29671, 5-7 Anzac Avenue, Swan Reach, Hundred of Nildottie Description Dwelling Extension & Shed Value $38,000.00
Development No. 711/325/05 Date Approved 14.10.05 Name Longridge Sarah Housing Group Pty Ltd Location Lot 61 of D62821, Schmidt Lane, Bowhill, Hundred of Younghusband Description Dwelling Value $125,241.00
Development No. 711/328/05 Date Approved 15.09.05 Name DA & HJ Buck Location Lot 97 of D62821, Lot 97, Providence Drive, Bowhill, Hundred of Younghusband Description Dwelling Extension Value $70,000.00
Development No. 711/330/05 Date Approved 27.09.05 Name M Walker Location Site 122,t Piece 233 of D61757, Providence Drive, Hundred of Younghusband Description Verandah Extension Value $6,300.00
Development Assessment Panel 1825 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.3 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS APPROVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/332/05 Date Approved 21.09.05 Name MA & KA Schache Location Lot 49 of F218712, Greenshields Road, Hundred of Younghusband Description Storage Shed Value $6,000.00
Development No. 711/337/05 Date Approved 21.09.05 Name M Bond Location Lot 7 of D54900, Section 280, Greenways Landing Shack Road, Greenways Landing, Hundred of Nildottie Description Shed Value $6,500.00
Development No. 711/350/05 Date Approved 13.10.05 Name Selecta Homes Pty Ltd Location Lot 220, 13 Egerton Street, Blanchetown, Hundred of Skurray Description Transportable Dwelling Value $52,918.00
Development No. 711/352/05 Date Approved 14.10.05 Name Rossdale Homes Pty Ltd Location Lot 23 of D48505, Railway Terrace, Truro, Hundred of Jellicoe Description Dwelling & Garage Value $158,000.00
Development No. 711/360/05 Date Approved 14.10.05 Name All Steel Transportables Location Lot 50 of D67, 1 Memorial Drive, Tungkillo, Hundred of Tungkillo Description Dwelling & Verandah Value $106,626.00
Development No. 711/364/05 Date Approved 29.09.05 Name S Rowe Location Part Allotment 2, Lot 46 of F8274, Government Road, Brenda Park, Hundred of Eba Description Shed Value $11,387.00
Development No. 711/365/05 Date Approved 21.09.05 Name RA McKenzie Location Lot 147, Section 193, Marks Landing Shack Road, Marks Shacks, Hundred of Nildottie Description Shed Value $3,000.00
Development Assessment Panel 1826 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.3 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS APPROVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/375/05 Date Approved 30.09.05 Name Selecta Homes Pty Ltd Location Lot 260 of F17009, Cemetary Road, Sanderston, Hundred of Angas Description Transportable Dwelling Value $37,624.00
Development No. 711/379/05 Date Approved 05.10.05 Name DN & DL Hartman Location Part Allotment 14, Lot 86 of F203, South Punyelroo Shack Road, South Punyelroo, Hundred of Fisher Description Boat/Storage Shed Value $2,500.00
Development No. 711/391/05 Date Approved 29.09.05 Name Valley Sheds Location Lot 8 of FP104790, Section 515/516, Government Road, Hundred of Hay Description Boat Shed Value $12,677.00
Development No. 711/401/05 Date Approved 10.10.05 Name P Von Bertouch Location Lot 8 of FP104790, Government Road, Blanchetown, Hundred of Hay Description Storage Shed Value $6,250.00
Development No. 711/416/05 Date Approved 11.10.05 Name G Crettenden Location Lot 140 of D62821, Providence Drive, Bowhill, Hundred of Younghusband Description Shed & Carport Value $6,000.00
Development No. 711/418/05 Date Approved 14.10.05 Name MR & FC Beck Location Lot 245, 11 Rider Street, Blanchetown, Hundred of Skurray Description Carport Value $3,500.00
Development No. 711/424/05 Date Approved 17.10.05 Name JM Johnstone Location Section 119, Government Road, Morgan, Hundred of Eba Description Garage & Transportable Building Value $14,000.00
Development No. 711/433/05 Date Approved 30.09.05 Name Y & V Reinders Location Lot 103 of D65737, Stoney Banks Road, Tungkillo, Hundred of Tungkillo Description Barn Value $12,400.00
Development Assessment Panel 1827 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.3 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS APPROVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/434/05 Date Approved 29.09.05 Name Barossa Garages & Homes Improvements Location Section 357, Black Hill Road, Black Hill, Hundred of Ridley Description Shed Value $5,919.00
Development No. 711/439/05 Date Approved 05.10.05 Name R & C Stoeckel Location Lots 177 & 178, Blanchetown Road, Swan Reach, Hundred of Nildottie Description Grain Shed Value $44,000.00
Development No. 711/449/05 Date Approved 30.09.05 Name P & R Kelly Location Lot 104 of F169853, Palmer Reservoir Road, Hundred of Tungkillo Description Carport Value $3,200.00
Development No. 711/453/05 Date Approved 30.09.05 Name G Hill Location Lot 91 of F216025, Section 560, Government Road, Hundred of Finniss Description Verandah Value $8,000.00
Development No. 711/455/05 Date Approved 23.09.05 Name KD & PL Larner Location Lot 3 of F202, Part Section 115, Swan Reach Mannum Road, Hundred of Fisher Description Shed Value $13,130.00
Development No. 711/456/05 Date Approved 30.09.05 Name WS Barr Location Lot 215 of F208591, Part Section 62, 20 Phillip Avenue, Swan Reach, Hundred of Nildottie Description Domestic Garage Value $500.00
Development No. 711/463/05 Date Approved 14.10.05 Name NO Zimmermann Location Lot 3 of D43343, Cambrai Truro Road, Sedan, Hundred of Jellicoe Description Implement Shed Value $12,000.00
Development Assessment Panel 1828 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.3 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS APPROVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/467/05 Date Approved 11.10.05 Name Paramount Developments Pty Ltd Location Lot 58 of F157593, 4 Adelaide Road, Hundred of Tungkillo Description Verandah Value $3,850.00
Development No. 711/473/05 Date Approved 11.10.05 Name S Krahling Location Lot 53 of D36193, Muller's Road, Black Hill, Hundred of Angas Description Shed Value $2,500.00
Development Assessment Panel 1829 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.4 LAND DIVISION APPLICATIONS APPROVED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/D060/04 Date Approved 28.09.05 Name MT Oldfield Location Sections 176 & 431, Billabong Road, Hundred of Burdett Description Land Division - Boundary Realignment in River Murray Zone, Primary Production Policy Area - Amended Plan 10/5/2005
Development No. 711/D016/05 Date Approved 11.10.05 Name MC Harriss Location Allotment Comprising Pieces 10 & 11 of DP67040 of Section 80 and Part Section 437, Claxton Road, Cadell Irrigation Area, Hundred of Cadell Description Land Division - Creation of one additional allotment in River Murray Zone, Primary Production Policy Area
Development No. 711/D025/05 Date Approved 11.10.05 Name H Graetz Location Section 344, Henschke Winery Road, Keyneton, Hundred of Jellicoe Description Land Division - Creation of one additional allotment
Development No. 711/D028/05 Date Approved 11.10.05 Name R Smith Location Section 322 and Allotment Comprising Pieces 1 and 2 in FP149495 of Part Section 322, Sedan Hill Road, Keyneton, Hundred of Jellicoe Description Land Division - Boundary Realignment
Development Assessment Panel 1830 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.5 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS REFUSED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Nil.
Development Assessment Panel 1831 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.6 LAND DIVISION REFUSED DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD 13 SEPTEMBER 2005 TO 18 OCTOBER 2005
Development No. 711/C033/05 Date Refused 11.10.2005 Name Gage Constructions Location Lot 102 of D63543, 7/9 Parker Street, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss Description Community Division into two community lots and common property Authority Council Reasoning Land Division Application 711/C033/05 is deemed to be seriously at variance with the Mid Murray Council Development Plan and in particular the following development control provisions and therefore warrants refusal:-
• Council Wide Objective 10; • Council Wide Principle of Development Control 11; • Council Wide Table MiMu/2; • Residential Zone Objective 1; and • Residential Zone Principle of Development Control 1.
Development No. 711/D019/05 Date Refused 11.10.2005 Name MT Oldfield Location Section 176, Billabong Road, Hundred of Burdett Description Land Division - Creation of one additional allotment in River Murray Zone, Primary Production Policy Area Authority Council Reasoning Land Division Application 711/D019/05 is deemed to be seriously at variance with the Mid Murray Council Development Plan and in particular the following development control provisions and therefore warrants refusal:-
• Council Wide Objectives 10, 32, 33 & 34; • Primary Production Policy Area Objective 20; • Primary Production Policy Area Principles of Development Control 1 and 26.
Development No. 711/D024/05 Date Refused 11.10.2005 Name M Ferguson Location Lot 4 of D4277, 47 Sickerdick Street, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss Description Land Division - Creation of one additional allotment Authority Council Reasoning Land Division Application 711/D024/05 is deemed to be seriously at variance with the Mid Murray Council Development Plan and in particular the following development control provisions and therefore warrants refusal:-
• Council Wide Objective 10; • Council Wide Table MiMu/2; and • Residential Zone Principle of Development Control 1.
Development Assessment Panel 1832 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.7 DEVELOPMENT STATISTICS
Reporting Officer: Kelvin Goldstone
The following table indicates statistics relating to development applications processed for the 2005 calendar year.
REPORTING PERIOD PROGRESSIVE TOTAL PROGRESSIVE TOTAL (CALENDAR YEAR – 2005) (PREVIOUS YEAR – 2004) TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT NUMBER VALUE NUMBER VALUE NUMBER VALUE Dwellings 10 $899,640.00 84 $7,575,886.00 52 $4,451,401.60
Dwelling 7 $132,850.00 106 $1,127,324.00 163 $1,448,253.00 Additions/Attachments (verandahs, carports etc)
Domestic Garages 20 $132,321.00 159 $896,887.80 37 $182,198.50
Farm Buildings (implement 3 $68,400.00 23 $333,100.74 13 $4,950,015.95 sheds, hay sheds, animal husbandry etc)
Other (community buildings, 6 $215,800.00 69 $1,867,269.00 50 $1,349,464.50 boat ramps, tanks, swimming pools etc)
Land Division 4 36 28
Total 50 $1,449,011.00 477 $11,800,467.54 343 $12,444,333.55
For Information Only.
Development Assessment Panel 1833 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.8 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION 711/307/05 – RW & K SHULVER
Reporting Officer: James Miller
Development No. 711/307/05 Applicant RW & K Shulver Subject Land Lot 47, 24 Randall Street, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss Proposal Dwelling
OVERVIEW
Members would recall that at the September meeting of the Development Assessment Panel the following resolution was adopted with respect to the above development application:-
1783/1 R Mead moved that the matter be deferred to enable inspection of the site prior to the next meeting and continued negotiation with applicants re achieving a 6 metre setback from the Pearson Street boundary. Seconded I Bormann. CARRIED.
Since the meeting the applicant has corresponded with Council in the form of a letter dated 13 October 2005. Within the correspondence the applicant advises of their willingness to achieve a 4.5 metre setback to the dwelling’s verandah/balcony. The revised plans will ensure a 6 metre setback to the dwelling wall itself.
For those members that inspected the site since the previous meeting, I am sure that you would have visualised the prominence such a double storey building would bring to the locality if located in close proximity to the street boundary.
It is my opinion that the site is large enough to accommodate the establishment of a detached dwelling without being on the doorstep of the Pearson Street boundary. The sheer enormity of the rear balcony prevents a greater setback than is currently the case and with some modifications carried out on the depth of that balcony I am confident a 6 metre setback distance to the dwelling’s verandah/balcony can be achieved.
For the reasons set out in the previous agenda item a recommendation of refusal is again listed for consideration.
RECOMMENDATION
moved that pursuant to Section 33(1)(a) of the Development Act, 1993 Development Application 711/307/05 is deemed to be seriously at variance with Council’s Development Plan, namely the following Objectives and Principles of Development Control, and is therefore refused:-
• Council Wide Objective 15; • Council Wide Principles of Development Control 33 & 44.
Seconded
Development Assessment Panel 1834 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT REPORT 6.9 ELECTRANET SA
Reporting Officer: James Miller
Applicant ElectraNet SA Subject Land Allotment 17 of Filed Plan 157552, Tepko-Mt Torrens Road, Hundred of Tungkillo Proposal Electricity Substation
Members are advised that Myles Somers, Urban & Regional Planner – ElectraNet SA, has been invited to attend the meeting at 10.30am to further explain the proposal and answer any questions members may have.
INTRODUCTION
Pursuant to Section 49(2) of the Development Act 1993 the Department for Transport, Energy and Infrastructure have submitted an application for Crown development on behalf of ElectraNet SA to establish a $30 million electricity substation on land located approximately 7 kilometres south of the township of Tungkillo.
The Development Assessment Commission is the relevant planning body for assessment purposes however Council has the ability to provide comment on the proposal prior to the Commission formulating a position on the matter.
A copy of the development application, prepared by Parsons Brinckerhoff Pty Ltd, is enclosed.
OVERVIEW
The proposal submitted to the Commission is comprehensive and explains in detail all aspects of the development and therefore I do not view it necessary to rehash what has already been covered as far as the description of the development and the nature of the locality is concerned.
Whilst the development application is deemed non-complying development within the Hills Policy Area of the Rural Zone, I concur with the assessment of the proposal against Council’s Development Plan undertaken by Parsons Brinckerhoff (4.1.2 - Consideration of Planning Issues, page 29).
It is therefore recommended that the Development Assessment Panel advise the Development Assessment Commission that the proposal of ElectraNet SA to establish an electricity substation is supported given it addresses environmental, economic and social concerns entailed within Council’s Development Plan.
RECOMMENDATION
moved that the Development Assessment Commission be advised that the development application, submitted under Section 49(2) of the Development Act 1993, to establish an electricity substation over Allotment 17 of Filed Plan 157552, Tepko-Mt Torrens Road, Hundred of Tungkillo, is not deemed to be seriously at variance with Council’s Development Plan and therefore warrants the granting of provisional development plan consent. Seconded
Kelvin Goldstone, MANAGER, ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
Development Assessment Panel 1835 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT LATE REPORT 6.10 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION 711/506/05 – TINCKNELL NOMINEES PTY LTD
Reporting Officer: James Miller
Development No. 711/506/05 Applicant Tincknell Nominees Pty Ltd Subject Land Section 358, Ramm Road, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss Proposal Temporary Storage Facility – Shipping Container
INTRODUCTION
The above development application has been submitted to Council for assessment purposes where provisional development plan consent is sought to place a shipping container on a temporary basis upon a proposed allotment contained within the Ramm rural living subdivision.
Relevant details of the proposal are attached.
SUBJECT LAND
As it currently stands, the subject land is identified as Section 358, Ramm Road, Mannum, Hundred of Finniss. Following the issuing of titles for stage two of the subdivision (which I understand is due to occur in early 2006) the subject land will be identified as Allotment 22, Ramm Road and shall comprise 2.04 hectares in area.
The subject land presently accommodates a series of rainwater tanks which were placed on site without development approval. No action has been taken against the prospective purchaser with respect to the placement of these tanks on site given the pending issuing of titles early next year.
Map MiMu/36 of the Council Development Plan depicts the proposed allotment to be located within a rural living zone.
Figure 1.1 identifies the subject land.
Figure 1.1
Development Assessment Panel 1836 Minutes 31 October 2005 MID MURRAY COUNCIL – DEVELOPMENT LATE REPORT 6.10 DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION 711/506/05 – TINCKNELL NOMINEES PTY LTD
DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL
Provisional development plan consent is sought for the placement of a 12 metre x 2.4 metre shipping container upon proposed allotment 22. The purpose for placing the container on site is to house a recently purchased tractor and associated equipment.
The applicant has provided an undertaking in his application that the container will be removed from site following the issuing of titles to stage two of the subdivision which will coincide with Council being able to issue development approval for the applicant’s proposed colourbond garage.
OVERVIEW
The applicant has been advised by Council staff on numerous occasions that the placement of a second hand shipping container on site, whether it be as a temporary measure or permanent, is a form of development that varies significantly from not only the Council Development Plan, but the recently registered land management agreement also.
The land management agreement entered into between the landowner and Council strictly prohibits second-hand dwellings and outbuildings upon the land. Clause 4 under the heading ‘Materials and Finishes’ of the First Schedule states:-
Second hand dwellings and outbuildings are prohibited.
Whether the use be permanent or temporary, the intent of the land management agreement is quite clear in that such structures are not contemplated within this precinct. It is imperative that a precedent is not set through the allowance of a proposal of this nature, particularly within a division that seeks to set and maintain a high standard of development.
It is my firm position that the Development Assessment Panel endorses the following recommendation.
RECOMMENDATION
moved that development application 711/506/05 is deemed seriously at variance with the land management agreement registered over the subject land, and in particular is at variance with Clause 4 under the heading ‘Materials and Finishes’ of the First Schedule. Further the development application is deemed seriously at variance with the Council Development Plan, and in particular the following Objectives and Principles of Development Control, and on both counts is refused:-
Council Wide Objective 15; Council Wide Principles of Development Control 33, 37 and 42.
Seconded
Kelvin Goldstone, MANAGER, ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES
Development Assessment Panel 1837 Minutes 31 October 2005