A Historical Reinterpretation of Mississippi Governor Ross R
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
九州産業大学国際文化学部紀要 第67号 37-86(2017) “But I Have to Be Confronted with Your Troops”: A Historical Reinterpretation of Mississippi Governor Ross R. Barnett’s Segregationist Defiance toward the John F. Kennedy Administration over the 1962 Desegregation Ordeal at the University of Mississippi Yasuhiro KATAGIRI* “Friends, I am a Mississippi segregationist. And I am proud of it.” ̶Mississippi governor-elect Ross R. Barnett, September 8, 19591 “Mr. President, please. Why don’t you . can’t you give an order up there to remove [James H.] Meredith [from the University of Mississippi campus]?” ̶Mississippi governor Ross R. Barnett, September 30, 19622 Ⅰ In the history of the American civil rights movement during the first half of the 1960s, one of the most dramatic and defining moments came about in the fall of 1962 when the segregationist Mississippi governor, Ross R. Barnett, staged a series of well-publicized̶but eventually failed̶attempts to deny the entrance of a prospective black student, James H. Meredith, to the University of Mississippi in Oxford, and thus to defy the federally mandated racial desegregation at the all- white state-operated educational institution, better known as Ole Miss. A little over eight years earlier, the U.S. Supreme Court had unanimously outlawed legally imposed racial segregation in public schools in its epoch-making Brown v. ― 37 ― Yasuhiro KATAGIRI ruling in May 1954.3 Upon hearing the High Court’s decision, Board of Education the enraged white politicians and officials in the Jim Crow American South initiated their massive resistance to the desegregation decree and the intensifying crusade for black civil rights.4 Those in Mississippi, to be sure, were no exception, and no public school in the state̶neither its elementary and secondary schools, nor its colleges and universities̶would become racially integrated until Meredith’s eventual success in desegregating Ole Miss (prior to his success, Meredith’s enrollment was physically blocked twice by Governor Barnett and once by Lieutenant Governor Paul B. Johnson Jr.). In the nation's capital, meanwhile, John F. Kennedy―for fourteen months between September 1962 and October 1963 during his suddenly curtailed presidency―had recorded many of his White House telephone conversations, having a recording device called a Dictaphone hooked up to a telephone in the Oval Office.5 Two decades after the president’s untimely death, in the early summer of 1983, the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library in Boston, Massachusetts, set out to open some portions of the Kennedy White House recordings to the general public. And among them were those telephone recordings related to the 1962 University of Mississippi desegregation crisis.6 Ever since then, historians and journalists alike have utilized the verbatim contents of the telephone conversations held between the Kennedy administration and the Barnett administration, and they have incorporated those contents into their historical narratives of the Ole Miss crisis in particular and America’s volatile civil rights years in general. As the once termed them, the disclosed New York Times presidential recordings relevant to the Ole Miss desegregation ordeal are surely qualified to be “History’s Raw Materials,” and they provide us with a fascinating glimpse of the Kennedy administration’s inner workings of trying to grapple with the problems of racial bigotry prevalent not only in Mississippi, but also in the entire American South, of the 1960s.7 Much has been narrated about the nature of the state-federal confrontation arising from the University of Mississippi crisis, but there still remains the widely held interpretation and representation̶or misinterpretation and misrepresentation, to be more precise̶that the showdown was fought between a confident and immovably determined president of the United ― 38 ― “But I Have to Be Confronted with Your Troops”: A Historical Reinterpretation of Mississippi Governor Ross R. Barnett’s Segregationist Defiance toward the John F. Kennedy Administration over the 1962 Desegregation Ordeal at the University of Mississippi States, and a shrewd and unyieldingly stiff-necked governor of an intransigent southern state. What the Ole Miss incident-related telephone conversations̶ “History’s Raw Materials”̶reveals and highlights, however, is a set of much different̶and oftentimes tormented̶faces and postures of the two contesting executives (and their respective advisors). Abounded in their verbal exchanges were the participants’ hesitations, agonies, and human frailties. While laying considerable emphasis on Mississippi's social and political climate of the day, which dictated the preservation of white supremacy as an overarching imperative, the author, in the following pages, revisits the substance of the secret telephone negotiations held between President Kennedy (as well as his younger brother, Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy) and Governor Barnett over the 1962 University of Mississippi desegregation ordeal. And in so doing, the author intends to offer a historical reinterpretation on what the both administrations were really up against in the face of the civil rights crisis. Ⅱ From a humble beginning on a small farm located in the hamlet of Standing Pine in Leake County, Mississippi, Ross Barnett, being the youngest of ten children, worked his way through local public schools and Mississippi College as a barber, janitor, and kitchenware salesperson. After working for two years as principal of Pontotoc High School in north Mississippi, he entered the University of Mississippi Law School. Upon graduation, Barnett began his law practice in Jackson in 1926 and subsequently became the senior partner of a large law firm in the state capital. Standing over six feet tall and being a man with “a mixture of flamboyance and down-to-earth seriousness,” the future Mississippi governor seldom failed in attracting and fascinating people around him with his “energy, rhetoric, and antics.”8 Following his unsuccessful runs for governor in 1951 and 1955, Barnett once again entered the gubernatorial race in 1959̶five years after the Supreme Court rendered the decision̶where all three major Brown candidates vigorously hammered down on racial segregation. Among those contenders, however, the candidate who “could crack the loudest segregation whip” was Barnett.9 Billing himself as a “vigorous segregationist” during his ― 39 ― Yasuhiro KATAGIRI gubernatorial campaign, Barnett pledged that he would “owe allegiance only to my God, my conscience, . and the good people of my native state” in striving to “maintain our heritage, our customs, . [and] segregation of the races.”10 After the election was over, on September 8, 1959, the very first postelection public appearance of the now governor-elect took place at a gathering sponsored by the Citizens’ Council̶the civil rights era’s most vocal and widespread private organization dedicated to the segregationist cause and anti- enterprises in the entire white South.11 Founded less than two months Brown after the decision in the Mississippi Delta county of Sunflower (the Brown home county of the state's all-powerful white supremacist, U.S. senator James O. Eastland), the Citizens' Council in Mississippi was particularly emphatic and influential.12 “Friends,” the elated governor-elect spoke to the appreciative white audience of nearly one thousand at the postelection gathering, “I am a Mississippi segregationist. And I am proud of it.”13 Mississippi governor-elect Ross R. Barnett making his very first postelection public appearance before a gathering sponsored by the segregationist Citizens’ Council at the Heidelberg Hotel in downtown Jackson, Mississippi, on September 8, 1959. Wearing a white carnation on his lapel to signify white Mississippians’ determination to preserve and protect the state’s racial status quo, Barnett told the appreciative audience that “mixing the races leads inevitably to the production of an inferior mongrel.” (In the author’s possession by courtesy of the late Erle E. Johnston Jr. of Forest, Mississippi, a former director of the Mississippi State Sovereignty Commission) On January 19, 1960, Barnett took his oath of office as Mississippi’s fifty-third governor. “You know and I know,” he took a solemn pledge in his inaugural address, “that we will maintain segregation in Mississippi at all costs.”14 As his ― 40 ― “But I Have to Be Confronted with Your Troops”: A Historical Reinterpretation of Mississippi Governor Ross R. Barnett’s Segregationist Defiance toward the John F. Kennedy Administration over the 1962 Desegregation Ordeal at the University of Mississippi predecessor, James P. Coleman, had promised in his inaugural address four years earlier, when Barnett assumed his official oath, “the separation of the races in Mississippi” was still “left intact.”15 And the new governor, who was destined to symbolize the American South’s harshest politics of segregationist defiance, was determined to keep it that way “at all costs.” Paralleling Barnett's unwavering resolve, no sooner had the 1960 state legislature been convened than the lawmakers flooded the legislative body with scores of bills designed to further strengthen Mississippi’s racial and racist policy. By the time the legislative session adjourned on May 11, twenty-one new segregationist bills had been approved and signed into law by the governor. Among those was House Bill No. 741, which provided that “the board of trustees of institutions of higher learning may, at their discretion, determine who will be