• f';~NISS N 0001-99100002 -9920

of the American Mathematical Society AugustAugust20042004 Volume 51, Number 7

The Status of the Classification of the Finite Simple Groups pagepag~ 736 Intimations of Infinity page 741 Interview with pagpagee 775151 Nashville Meeting~lceting page 849 Albuquerque Meeting page 851 Evanston Meeting papagege 8538 53

.."',,''. :;.1\• .. ~. ~''i'tfJf?~

CalculillingCalculating an Expansion£>.:pansion ConstantCOnS!<1Ill (see page 815) AMERICANAMERicAN MATHEMATICAL SOCIETYSociETY

THETHE FISKEFISKE SOCIETYSOCIETY The Thomas S. Fiske Society honorshonor5 individualsindi,idu;t!s who\\"00 provideproo."iJe for a gift to the AmericanAmeriQll Mathematicall\bthemuiaJ SocietySocier. inin theirtheir estateoute plans. The)'They UKuse plannedpbooed givinggt,-ing toto includeinclude thethe AMSMiS inin theirtheir ,,-ilb,wills, )ifelife lIuur:l.nceinsurance policies, orOr retirementretirement planspl.uu.. Such gitUgifts enwreensure thuthat the AMSMiS will",ill continue toto fulfillfidfi.lI,tlI its lIl.I5iionmission roto promote mathematicalmuhcman.:;t! research, advance:ldnnce thethe muhem:l.tKsmathematics profoaion,profession, supportwpporl educationeducuion atat allall Ineb,levels, and fosterfmter a\\":l.renosawareness and appreciation of mathematicsmuhem:l.tio well inlointo the future.fulure Thom:liThomas S,S. Fiske founded the AmericanAmeriC:l.n Mathematicall\hthematic;t! Societyhiety Inin 1888 10to foMerfoster oomndcslupcomradeship and share researchrel<::l.rch throughthrough mectin~meetings and publicationspublications. Fiske Societyhiet)' membersmembc" holdbold anan honotedhonored "laceplace in theIhe :l.nn;t!sannals of the Society andmd inin thethe m:l.thematic;t!mathematical community for building on thethe foundationfound:l.tion Startedstarted by Fiske.Fiske ForFor morcmore informationinform:l.tion see www.ams.org/giving-to-amswww.ams.org/gi,ing-to-ams oror eQflt:l.ctcontact LindaLmda Burke, DevelopmentDe"elopment Office, American.... merican MathematicalMalhen13tie;t! Society, 201201 CharlesCh:IIlcs Street,Street, Providence,l'ro,idcIlCC, RI 02904229402904-2294 USA;USA; telephone: 800800-321--4267-321 -4267 (U.S.(U.S. and CatUda).Canada), 401401-455-4000-455-4000 (w(world,,-ide);orldwide); fn:fax: 401 -331 -3842; eemail:mail: [email protected]\'[email protected].

-AMS~ ...... 'M SOOrn I www.ams.orgw..... w.:l.ms.org I International Journal of Mathematics and Mathematical Sciences

Managing Editor Website: http://ijmms.hindawi.com Lokenath Debnath IjMMS is a refereed math journal devoted to the publication of original research arti­ Associate Editors cles, research notes, and review articles, with emphasis on contributions to unsolved problems and open questions in Mathematics and Mathematical Sciences. The scope of George E. Andrews the journal includes all areas covered by the 2000 Mathematics Subject Classification Peter Bates scheme. Howard E. Bell Jerry L. Bona Authors are invited to submit original manuscripts to IjMMS. It is a condition of publi­ cation that manuscripts submitted to this journal have not been published and will not Huseyin Bor be published elsewhere. Authors should submit their manuscripts through the IjMMS Jonathan Borwein manuscript tracking system at http://www.mstracking.com/ijrnms/. Manuscripts can Felix E. Browder also be submitted bye-mail [email protected]. Only an acknowledgment Alfonso Castro from the editorial office officially establishes the date of receipt. The articles of IjMMS Monica Clapp are reviewed in Mathematical Reviews and Zentralblatt fur Mathematik. J. H. Dshalalow There are no page charges. The corresponding author will receive 25 free reprints with Ricardo Estrada covers. Institutional subscription rates for 2004 (4000± pages) are $995 for print only R. Finn or online only and $1194 for print and online. Contact [email protected] for more Narendra K. Govil details. Roger Grimshaw Peter j. Hilton Mourad Ismail Recently Published Articles Peter johnson • An Efficient Approach for Solving a Class of Nonlinear 2D Parabolic PDEs, Gerald F. jungck Dongjin Kim and Wlodek Proskurowski Shyam L. Kalla • Determinantal Generating Functions of Colored Spanning Forests, D. C. Kent Gregory M. Constantine and Marius G. Buliga Virginia Kiryakova • Multivariate Frechet Copulas and Conditional Value-at-Risk, Irena Lasiecka Werner Hurlimann Bob Lowen • Nonlinear Connections and Spinor Geometry, B. N. MandaI Sergiu 1. Vacaru and Nadejda A. Vicol Piotr Mikusinski • On a Trivial Zero Problem, Shaowei Zhang Sehie Park • On Embedding Properties of SD-Groups, Vahagn H. Mikaelian Feng Qi • On Explicit Reciprocity Law over Formal Groups, Shaowei Zhang Billy E. Rhoades • On Gromov's Theorem and L 2-Hodge Decomposition, Andrew Rosalsky Fu-Zhou Gong and Feng-Yu Wang james Serrin • On the Geometry of Riemannian Manifolds with a Lie Structure at Infinity, Ralph E. Showalter Bernd Ammann, Robert Lauter, and Victor Nistor Mariana Shubov • On Volterra Inequalities and Their Applications, Lechoslaw Hqcia Hari M. Srivastava Roger Temam WIN 07\'WI Hinda\vi Publishing Corporation, .flO Park Avenue, 15th Floor, #287 pInb, Ii F\. New York, NY 10022, USA; Fax 1-866-.f.f6-3294 (USA, toll-free) Ahme,d Zayed NEW f6 FORTHCOMING from Birkhiiuser

Frobenius Splitting Analysis of Dirac Systems Time-Frequency and .Methods in Geometry and and Computational Algebra Time-Scale Methods Representation Theory FABRIZIO COLOMBO, Politecnico di Milano, Milano, Italy; Adaptive Decompositions, Uncertainty IRENE SABADINI, Politecnico di Milano, Milano, Italy; Principles, and Sampling MICHEL BRION, Universite Grenoble 1- CNRS, St.-Martin FRANCISCUS SOMMEN, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium; d'Heres, France; and SHRAWAN KUMAR, University ofNorth and DANIELE C. STRUPPA, George Mason University, Fairfax, ~ JEFFREY A. HOGAN, University ofArkansas, Fayetteville, AK; Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC and JOSEPH D. LAKEY, New Mexico State University, This work is devoted to the analysis of systems of linear Las Cruces, NM The theory of Frobenius splittings has made a signifi­ partial differential equations with constant coefficients, This book develops several deep connections among cant impact in the study of the geometry of flag varieties focusing attention on null solutions of Dirac systems. wavelets and other time-frequency/time-scale tools, and representation theory. This work systematically In addition to their usual significance in physics, such sampling, and uncertainty principles. Emphasis is develops the theory and covers all its major develop­ solutions are important mathematically as an extension placed on results in which the advantages of adaptively ments. Key features include: concise, efficient exposi­ of the function theory of several complex variables. combining time-frequency and time scale-methods tion unfolds from basic introductory material on The term computational in the title emphasizes two can be seen precisely. The book is aimed at advanced Frobenius splittings-definitions, properties and main features of the book, namely, the heuristic use students and researchers in signal processing, harmonic examples-to cutting edge research; studies in detail of computers to discover results in some particular analysis, or mathematical physics, and those who the geometry of Schubert varieties, their syzygies, cases, and the application of Grabner bases as a have a particular interest in the interplay among these equivariant embeddings of reductive groups, Hilbert primary theoretical tool. The book may be used by disciplines. Schemes, canonical splittings, good filtrations, among graduate students and researchers interested in other topics; applies Frobenius splitting methods (hyper) , Clifford analysis, systems of 2004/APPROX. 400 PP./ 40 IllUS'/HARDCOVER/S69.95 (TENI) to algebraic geometry and various problems in repre­ partial differential equations with constant coefficients, ISBN 0-8176-4276-5 APPLIED AND NUMERICAL HARMONIC ANALYSIS sentation theory. The book is an excellent resource and mathematical physics. for and graduate students in algebraic geometry and representation theory of algebraic 2004/APPROX 342 PP., 6IllUS'/HARDCOVER/S79.95 (TENI) ISBN 0-8176-4255-2 Cornerstones groups. PROGRESS IN MATHEMATICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 39 2004/APPROX 284 PP'/HARDCOVER/S69.95 (TENI) of Real Analysis ISBN 0-8176-4191-2 ANTHONY W. KNAPP, State University ofNew York at Stony PROGRESS IN MATHEMATICS, VOL. 231 Variational Methods Brook, NY in Shape Optimization This work systematically develops the concepts and Geometric Mechanics on Problems tools of real analysis, whether pure, applied, aspiring, or established. It presents a comprehensive, global Riemannian Manifolds DORIN BUCUR, Universite de Metz, Metz, France; and treatment of the subject, emphasizing connections Applications to Partial Differential Equations GIUS~PPE BUTTAZZO, Universita di Pisa, Pisa, Italy between analysis and other branches of mathematics. OVIDIU CALIN, Eastern Michigan University, East Lansing, MI,' The study of shape optimization problems involves a Rich in examples as well as problems with hints and and DER-CHEN CHANG, Georgetown University, Washington, DC wide area of academic research and applications to the solutions, the book is ideal as a course text or refer­ Differential geometry techniques have very useful and real world. In this work, such problems are treated from ence for graduate students preparing for exams. Its important applications in partial differential equations classical and modern perspectives and target a broad broad scope and unique approach will appeal to profes­ and . This work presents a purely audience of graduate students in pure and applied sors and applied mathematicians in analytic areas as geometric treatment of problems in physics involving mathematics, as well as engineers requiring a solid well. quantum harmonic oscillators, quartic oscillators, mathematical basis for the solution of practical problems. 2004/APPROX 888 PP., 13IllUS'/HARDCOVER/S69.95 (TENI) minimal surfaces, and Schradinger's, Einstein's, and 2005/APPROX 340 PP., 10 IllUS'/HARDCOVER/S 109.00 (TENI) ISBN 0-8176-3250-6 Newton's equations, and others. Coverage introduces PROGRESS IN NONLINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS AND THEIR CORNERSTONES new geometric methods, which have the advantage of APPLICATIONS giving quantitative or at least qualitative descriptions Determining Spectra of operators, many of which cannot be treated by other Geometric Methods in Quantum Theory methods. in Algebra and 2004/APPROX 360 PP'/HARDCOVER/S89. 95(TENI) MICHAEL DEMUTH, Technical University of Clausthal, ISBN 0-8176-4354-0 Number Theory Clausthal-Zellerfeld, Germany; and MADDALY KRISHNA, Institute ofMathematical Sciences, Chennai, India APPLIED AND NUMERICAL HARMONIC ANALYSIS FEDOR BOGOMOLO~ , New York, NY; andYURI TSCHINKEL, Universitat Gottingen, Germany (eds.) The spectral theory of Schrodinger operators, in particular those with random potentials, is avery active This volume collects papers strongly influenced by field of research. This work provides awell-developed geometric ideas and intuition, covering such topics as exposition of criteria that are especially useful in moduli spaces, Shimura varieties, D-modules, p-adic determining the spectra of deterministic and random methods (motivic integration), and number theoretic Schrodinger operators occurring in quantum theory. applications (rational points). The collection gives Free iourrial saillple copies! Coverage also includes a series of applications to show a fine sample of modern results and problems in point spectrum and continuous spectrum in some Stay current with the latest research; visit ". algebraic and arithmetic geometry. models of random operators. .springerlink.com to view complimentary 2005/APPROX 350 PP., 10 IllUS'/HARDCOVER/S59.95 (TENI) 2005/APPROX 288 PP'/HARDCOVER/Sl15.00 (TENI) electronic'sample copies of Birkhauser journals. ISBN 0-8176-4349-4 PROGRESS IN MATHEMATICAL PHYSICS PROGRESS IN MATHEMATICS

CALL: 1-800-777-4643 • FAX: (201) 348-4505 E-MAIL: [email protected] • www.birkhauser.com Please mention promotion #Y9671 when ordering to guarantee prices, valid through 7/31/05. Birkhiiuser Prices are valid in the Americas only. For price and ordering information outside the Americas, Boston · Basel · please contact Birkhauser Verlag AG by E-mail: [email protected] 8/04 Promotion #Y9671 August 2004

Feature Articles 736 The Status of the Classification of the Finite Simple Groups ~ichaelAschbacher The classification of the finite simple groups is one of. the great theorems of recent mathematics. One of its principal participants reviews the result and current progress on understanding it.

741 Intimations of Infinity Kirk Weller, Anne Brown, Ed Dubinsky, ~ichael ~cDonald, and Cynthia Stenger The authors report on their research into student understanding of the concept of infinity. 751 Interview with Joseph Keller The distinguished applied talks to the Notices about his work and career.

Communication5 Commentary

762 WHAT IS...anExpander?' 733 Opinion PeterSarnak 734 Letters to the Editor 771 Happy 100th, ! 764 CountDown-ABook Review 772 Doctorate Degrees inMathematics Reviewed byDaniel Ullman EarnedbyBlacks, Hispanics/ 768 Gamma-ABook Review Latinos, and Native Americans: Reviewed byDan Segal A Look at the Numbers HerbertA. Medina 776 Has the Women-in-Mathematics ProblemBeen Solved? AllynJackson 784 WomeninAcademia: Are We Asking the Right Questions? Carolyn Gordon andBarbara Lee Keyfitz 787 Gromov Receives Nemm.ers Prize 789 2003 Annual Survey ofthe Mathematical Sciences (SecondReport) Ellen E. Kirkman, James HZ Maxwell, and ColleenA. Rose Notices Departments oftheAmericanMathematical ~ociety Mathematics People 802 Joyce Wins Adams Prize, PECASE Awards Announced, Ferran EDITOR: Andy Magid Sunyer i Balaguer Prize Awarded, Mathe Receives 2004 Prize ASSOCIATE EDITORS: for Achievement in Information-Based Complexity, Allgower Susanne C. Brenner, Bill Casselman (Graphics Editor), Wins , Prizes of the Mathematical Society ofJapan, Robert J. Daverman, Nathaniel Dean, Rick Durrett, Szpiro Receives Media Prize, Putnam Prizes Awarded, USA Susan Friedlander, Robion Kirby, Steven G. Krantz, Elliott H. Lieb, Mark Saul, Karen E. Smith, Audrey Mathematical Olympiad, American Academy ofArts and Terras, Lisa Traynor Sciences Elections. SENIOR WRITER and DEPUTY EDITOR: Allyn Jackson Mathematics Opportunities 805 MANAGING EDITOR: Sandra Frost Enhancing the Mathematical Sciences Workforce in the 27 st CONTRIBUTI NG WRITER: Elaine Kehoe Century, NSF Focused Research Groups, NSF Mathematical PRODUCTION ASSISTANT: Muriel Toupin Sciences Postdoctoral Research Fellowships, AMS Scholarships for "Math in Moscow", Call for Submissions for Sunyer i PRODUCTION: Marcia Almeida, Kyle Antonevich, Stephen Moye, Lori Nero, Karen Ouellette, Donna Balaguer Prize. Salter, Deborah Smith, Peter Sykes ADVERTISING SALES: Anne Newcomb Inside the AMS 807 Kevin Clancey Named MR Executive Editor, AMS-AAAS Media SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION: Subscription prices Fellow Named, Fan China Exchange Program Names Awardees. for Volume 51 (2004) are $401 list; $321 institutional member; $241 individual member. (The subscription price for members is included in the arinual dues.) A Reference and Book List 809 late charge of 10% of the subscription price will be imposed upon orders received from nonmembers Visiting Mathematicians 816 after January 1 of the subscription year. Add for postage: Surface delivery outside the United States and India-$20; in India-$40; expedited delivery to Mathematics Calendar 829 destinations in North America-$35; elsewhere-$87. Subscriptions and orders for AMS publications should New Publications Offered by the AMS 834 be addressed to the American Mathematical Society, P.O. Box 845904, Boston, MA 02284-5904 USA. All Classifieds 842 orders must be prepaid. ADVERTISING: Notices publishes situations wanted Meetings and Conferences Table of Contents 864 and classified advertising, and display advertising for publishers and academic or scientific organizations. Advertising material or questions may be faxed to 401-331-3842 (indicate "Notices advertising" on fax cover sheet). SUBMISSIONS: Articles and letters may be sent to the editor by email at not; ces@math . au . edu, by fax at 405-325-5765, or by postal mail at Department of Mathematics, 601 Elm, PHSC 423, University of Okla­ homa, Norman, OK 73019-0001. Email is preferred. Correspondence with the managing editor may be sent to not; ces@ams . org. For more information, see the section "Reference and Book List". NOTICES ON THE AMS WEBSITE: Most of this publi­ cation is available electronically through the AMS web­ site, the Society's resource for delivering electronic products and services. Use the URL http://www . ams. From the org/not; ces/ to access the Notices on the website. AMS Secretary [Notices ofthe American Mathematical Society is published monthly except bimonthly in June/July by the American Mathematical Society at 201 Charles Street, Providence, RI Report of the Executive Director, State of the AMS, 2004 ....818 02904-2294 USA, GST No. 121892046 RT1ddd:. Periodicals postagepaidatProvidence, RI, andadditionalmailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address change notices to Notices ofthe Report of the Treasurer (2003) 824 American Mathematical Society, P.O. Box 6248, Providence, RI 02940-6248 USA.] Publication here of the Society's street address andthe otherinformationinbrackets above is a tech­ nical requirement ofthe U.S. Postal Service. Tel: 401-455-4000 J email: not; ces@ams .0rg. © CopYright 2004 by the American Mathematical Society. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America.The paper used in this journal is acid-free and falls within the guidelines established to ensure permanence and durability. Opinions expressed in signed Notices articles are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect opinions of the editors or policies of the American Mathematical Society. Opinion

with much enthusiasm within the scientific community, Investing in the Future since NSF supports science research across all disciplines (e.g. over 65 percent of all mathematical research carried Each February the U.S. government budget season begins out in academic institutions is supported through the when the Administration presents its budget request for NSF). the fiscal year beginning October 1. This presentation ini­ So far PL107-338 has had little effect, as the FY 2004 tiates activity in the thirteen corresponding House and NSF budget is $5.58 billion, while the authorized amount Senate appropriations subcommittees. Several of these is $6.39 billion, and the FY 2005 budget request sets it at subcommittees oversee the budgets of agencies that sup­ $5.75 million, much less than the authorized amount of port science research and education. $7.38 billion. It is unlikely that the NSF budget will reach Over the course of the summer these subcommittees try $9.84 billion in FY 2007. to come up with agreements on the budgets of all programs Of course, the NSF budget should grow to $9.84 million and agencies falling under the discretionary part of the U.S. sooner rather than later. But what happens after the goal federal budget. Once the Congress finishes its work on is reached? What's the plan for future funding? Nothing the bills that contain these program and agency budgets, in the law indicates how funding levels are established or the bills are sent to the president for his signature. Once how they should be maintained over time other than this signed, these bills become law and these budgets are five-year span. As we see with the NIH after "the dou­ operational. Rarely are these budgets ready by October 1. bling", Congress, the Administration, and the biomedical Observing this budget process year after year, I have community are haggling over how to proceed with future come to the conclusion that the U. S. lacks a consistent, funding-never mind all the young scientists entering the stable, transparent, year-to-year funding mechanism for biomedical pipeline who will need to gain research sup­ supporting basic research across all disciplines of science port. and engineering. Not having such a mechanism inhibits A consistent method of funding basic research across scientific progress, quashes the morale of scientists, and all fields of science on a year-to-year basis is needed. Dou­ deters young people from becoming scientists. bling one agency at a time is not such a plan. Establishing For example, basic research is increased by only 0.6% a stable growth model that will enable all fields of science over fiscal year (FY) 2004 in the Administration's recent to prosper is critical. Such a model will support the needed budget request. The year-to-year rate ofincrease of the total scientific infrastructure that facilitates advances in many federal basic research budget has been decreasing since fields. Furthermore, this infrastructure will contribute to 2001, going up by 11.7% fromFY 2001 to FY 2002, by 6.3% our national security. from FY 2002 to FY 2003, by 5.5% from FY 2003 to 2004, The federal government needs to take note here. In­ and now by 0.6%. vesting in basic research is much like individuals putting Looking more closely at the Administration's FY 2005 money into their retirement accounts. Even though we federal basic research budget is eye-opening. Basic re­ may have debts or other pressures on our incomes, pru­ search funded by agencies other than the Department of dent individuals continue to invest, knowing in time their Health and Human Services (including the National Insti­ foresight will payoff. Society will also benefit from our fore­ tutes of Health (NIH)) decreases by 2.46% over FY 2004. If sight ifwe make steady, systematic, adequate investments the Department of Homeland Security funds are also sub­ now and over time. tracted, basic research drops by 3.36%. History has shown that basic research is the basis of The country's most recent model for funding science is technological invention and economic growth as well as the doubling model-more precisely, doubling infive years. being critical to security. Congress and the Administration This model was used successfully to double the budget of need to address the issue of science funding with the idea NIH. More recently this model was put forth in the guise of of developing a model that works fiscally as well as mak­ the National Science Foundation (NSF) AuthorizationAct of ing sure that our basic research enterprise runs robustly. 2002, now Public Law 107-338. This established a schedule The scientific community should advocate for such a for doubling the NSF budget over the next five fiscal years. process and help to develop a feasible method for taking Beginning with the FY 2003 budget, the NSF budget was to it forward. increase by 15% a year over the preceding year, until it dou­ bled the FY 2002 NSF level of approximately $4.8 billion to -Samuel M. Rankin III $9.84 billion in FY 2007. Passage of PL107-338 was greeted AMS Associate Executive Director, Director, AMS Washington Office This is a modified version ofan editorial that first appeared in the [email protected] April 2004 issue (volume 2, number 3) ofFrontiers in Ecology and the Environment. Reprinted with permission of the Ecological Society ofAmerica.

AUGUST 2004 NOTICES OF THE AMS 733 Letters to the Editor blindly in this intriguing unknown obtained. And mastery of a standard world of numbers. algorithm is portable when a child Paper-and-Pencil Math Recently a student ofmine came to moves from one school district to an­ While ostensibly a critique of mathe­ my office for help in baby calculus. other. Each of these is an important maticians who express interest in One of the problems had the expres­ consideration. mathematics education (particularly sion 3(2/3). Naturally, I cancelled the .I am surprised to learn that Tony those disagreeing with his views), two factors of 3 and said that the an­ made no reference to one of his ear­ Tony Ralston's article in the April No­ swer was 2. The student did not see lier and more provocative papers tices has a second but hardly subor­ ["The really new college mathe­ dinate theme: an updating of his ideas matics and its impact on the high expressed in other writings on school school curriculum," The Sec- mathematics. I think Tony is ondary School Mathematics wrong in many of his pro­ Curriculum (C. Hirsch and nouncements on school mathe­ M. Zweng, eds.), Reston matics, starting with arithmetic. VA: National Council of On page 407 of his Notices ar­ Teachers of Mathemat- ticle, Ralston tells us: "It may be ics (1985), pp. 200-210], that the teaching of pencil-and­ where he writes: "No paper arithmetic, which has sound argument can be been the gateway to the study adduced to support a of school mathematics for thesis that claims that more than a century, is as im­ high school students portant as it has ever been." must be very skillful at This cautionis not observed in polynomial algebra, his paper "Let's abolish pencil­ trigonometric identities, and-paper arithmetic" Uournal the solution of linear of Computers in Mathematics and quadratic equa­ and Science Teaching, volume tions or systems of 18, number 2 (1999),173-194]. equations, or any of Although there we learn that the myriad manipu­ Ralston wants youngsters to lative tasks that are have some knowledge of mental part of the current arithmetic, when the going gets high school cur­ tough-when, for example, stu­ riculum." Where dents might need a technique to are the statistical add two 4-digit numbers or three studies support- 2-digit numbers that they cannot ing Ralston's more do mentally-then Tony would why. So I wrote the equivalent im­ radical conclusions? demur. Calculators to the rescue! At proper fraction 6/3, and then it was Do most mathematicians really the very moment when addition is clear to the student that the answer share this view? I believe that they do about to blossom into an algorithm­ was indeed 2. This otherwise intelli­ not. Rather, I believe that the prepon­ and perhaps the first algorithm that gent student had used calculators ex­ derance of mathematicians want stu­ a child will see-Ralston declares it ed­ tensively since fifth grade at a very dents to internalize the procedures ucationally unnecessary, writing in good school. This is an example of and processes of the traditional basics this 1999 article that "children should what I mean by "calculator-assisted of algebra, geometry, trigonometry, not be expected to learn these algo­ mathematical incompetence". and, yes, arithmetic before coming to rithms." However unhappy Ralston is I support the intelligent use of com­ college. with the Klein-Milgram paper on the puter or calculator technology. Yet, Although Tony Ralston will and long-division algorithm, his real op­ while not every use of a calculator should be castigated by some readers position appears to be mastery by constitutes an abuse, students need of the Notices, at least he has taken the children of any pencil-and-paper al­ to be held accountable for mastering time to express his views on school gorithm of arithmetic. the mathematics that they study. And mathematics. His views have made their part of that accountability should in­ way into mathematics education cir­ Mastery of addition and the other clude homework and in-class exami­ cles because many mathematicians algorithms of basic arithmetic act as nations-the latter with at least have left it to others to address the a flashlight, allowing the young stu­ restricted calculator use. content crisis in school mathematics. I dent to move freely about in the world The standard arithmetic algorithms appreciate very much the work of re­ of numbers and basic numeric oper­ allow a teacher to communicate with searchmathematicians, butI pleadwith ations. Without such mastery a young students, and students with each other, them to allocate some of their time to student is condemned to move about to show hoyY a given answer was school mathematics. In addition to

734 NOTICES OF THE AMS VOLUME 51, NUMBER 7 Letters to the Editor some of the mathematicians cited in "Rational selfish prisoners always let U be a unipotent subgroup of G, Ralston's article, we need more math­ choose the one strategy pair [Le., the and let N be the normalizer of U in ematicians with good judgment to Nash equilibrium (D,D)] that both can G. If U coincides with the unipotent speak out on this matter of national agree is undesirable-in the sense radical of N, then N is a parabolic urgency. that they would both prefer (C,C)." subgroup of G. This theorem was Where are they? (Strategy D is to defect and C is to co­ provedbyBoris Weisfeiler inthe paper operate.) "On a class ofunipotent subgroups of -Richard H. Escobales Jr. Rational selfish prisoners should semisimple algebraic groups", Uspekhi Canisius College not choose the Nash equilibrium. Be­ Mat. Nauk 21:2 (1966), 222-3 (in Russ­ [email protected] cause the game is symmetrical for the ian). For an English translation ofWe­ two players andbecause bothplayers isfeiler's paper and related comments, (Received April 9, 2004) are rational, then whichever strategy see the arXiv: http://www.arxi v . Player 1 decides is best, Player 2 will org/math.AG/0005149. also decide is best. Thus, the only Geometry Texts for Teachers possibilities are (D,D) and (C,C). Since -Victor Kac Hung-Hsi Wu, in his review of Audun (C,C) is better for each player than MIT Holme's Geometry: Our Cultural Her­ (D,D), rational selfish prisoners should itage, laments the lack of the foster­ choose (C,C). The reason the Nash (Received April 29, 2004) ing of geometric intuition in geome­ equilibrium is not relevant is that its try texts and offers his own work with definition considers pairs of strategies B. Braxton (available on the Web) as which are impossible if both players one way to achieve that goal. There are are rational, Le., (C,D) and (D,C). at least two other published geome­ This is discussed in detail in Chap­ try texts I know of that pay careful at­ ter 30 of Metamagical Themas: Quest­ tention to that goal. One, meant for ing for the Essence of Mind and Pat­ high school students but easily adapt­ tern, by Douglas R. Hofstadter (Basic able for future teachers, is EDC's (Ed­ Books, March 1996, ISBN 0-465-04566­ ucation Development Center's) Con­ 9). Hofstadter notes that most people nected Geometry, one of the NSF when presented with the above argu­ curriculum projects of the 1990s. The ment still say they would choose D. other is David Henderson's Experi­ encing Geometry, which has gone -David Marcus, Ph.D. through various iterations (distin­ Northrop Grumman Information guishable by their subtitles), gradually Technology becoming more and more compre­ Reading, MA hensive. Both books have high stan­ [email protected] dards of mathematical correctness, mathematical depth, and careful at­ (Received April 19, 2004) tention to how students actually learn, and both are writtenwith remarkable clarity. In fact, years ago while I was Work of Morozov, Weisfeiler, reviewing a draft ofpart of Connected and Borel Geometry, my seatmate on the air­ Regarding the article onArmand Borel plane, who identified herself as some­ inthe May 2004 issue ofNotices, Iwould one ordinarily not interested inmath­ like to comment on the related impor­ ematics, got so intriguedwhile reading tant earlier contributions of Vladimir over my shoulder that she asked if it v. Morozov and Boris Weisfeiler, two was available as a Christmas gift. eminent Russian mathematicians who The Notices invites readers to are not with us anymore. submit letters and opinion pieces - Judy Roitman Comment 1 (cf. p. 510 ofMay 2004 on topics related to mathematics. University ofKansas issue): The conjugacy ofmaximal solv­ Electronic submissions are pre­ [email protected] able subalgebras of a complex finite­ ferred (noti ces-l etters@ dimensional Lie algebra was provedby ams . 0 rg); see the masthead for (Received April 15, 2004) Vladimir V. Morozov in the paper "On postal mail addresses. Opinion a nilpotent element in a semisimple pieces are usually one printed page Lie algebra", Doklady USSR 36:3 inlength (about 800 words). Letters Prisoner's Dilemma (1942), 83-86 (in English). are normally less than one page Regarding the Prisoner's Dilemma, Comment 2 (cf. pp. 517-8 of May long, and shorter letters are pre­ Steven E. Landsburg ("Quantum game 2004 issue): Let G be a semisimple al­ ferred. theory", April 2004,. page 395) says, gebraic group over an arbitrary field,

AUGUST 2004 NOTICES OF THE AMS 735 The Status ofthe Classificationofthe FllllteSllnpleGroups A1ichaelAschbacher

ommon wisdom has it that the theorem Assume G is finite, and write H :s;j G to indi­ classifying the finite simple groups was cate that H is a normal subgroup of G. A normal proved around 1980. However, the proof series for G is a sequence

of the Classification is not an ordinary 1 = Go