January 2005 Newsletter
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
GE Free New Zealand In Food and Environment Newsletter Summer 2005 * Please note that some articles have been abbreviated in order to meet size constraints * agriculture that formed the basis of believe Marian Hobbs is deliberately Terminator …call to action human civilization, but also threatens misleading the public about New the livelihoods of hundreds of millions Zealand's backing for Terminator NZ Govt Backs Terminator!!! of people around the world as well as genes, and may be covering up the 11/02/05 After being swamped by the environment and human health. fact that similar technology is already protest emails and letters, the Canadian being trialled in the field in this The biotech industry appears incapable government was forced to soften its country. of controlling its products, and by public position on Terminator at a failing to stop GE contamination United Nations meeting in Bangkok. The Minister has been asked to threaten world food security. "This is a Canada’s aim to reinstate trials and use support an international moratorium wake-up call for New Zealand farmers of Terminator genes by overturning a on development of Terminator seeds and the public at large: companies are worldwide ban on GE Terminator until the fundamental societal issues setting their sites on our food supply in Technologies (GURTS) was backed have been scrutinised by the world ways that will be detrimental to the only by the Governments of New community and has refused. She has Public Good." says Jon Carapiet. The Zealand & Australia. not been honest about the fact that NZ government has repeatedly backed GURTs caused international alarm ERMA appear to have approved GE the US at the WTO forcing GE foods because of the dire implications it has pine tree trials of a different "GURT" on other countries and limiting for food security and sustainable (Genetic Use Restriction Technique) regulatory control. Government must farming. Some GURTS even require a at Rotorua understood to include some back NZ farmers and the public proprietary chemical to be applied with the "barnase" gene construct - against the threat to legitimise before seeds start growing at all, another approach to genetic control. Terminator. fuelling fears of the impact of GURT’s Firstly the Minister misled the media on the environment due to increased Marian Hobbs is wrong to promote by implying she is being unreasonably chemical use. Terminator as a bio-containment asked to support a "ban" rather than a Terminator technology inserts a gene technique, as the technique creates moratorium on Terminator seeds. Her sequence that renders seeds sterile, sterile seeds but viable pollen, which press statement says "Marian Hobbs (the pollen remains viable and can can contaminate other crops, making rejected a call to (support a) ban on infect other crops) thus forcing farmers their seed sterile. It was developed to field tests for terminator genes raised to buy seeds each year and ending the ensure farmers buy new seeds each in the report" and in a personal right of farmers to save their seeds. year. response to messages, states: "It is Recently Iraqi farmers were banned important to note that countries are not from saving seeds under directive 81 Write to the following MPs at presently being asked to vote on from US administration there. Freepost, Parliament. Wellington or banning or otherwise of the use of GE Free NZ asked our government to Email: GURTs". support the international community and block moves by the Canadian Helen Clark [email protected] The Minster's main advisors failed to government to authorise Terminator correct a misleading impression of seeds, but they supported Canada in a Jim Sutton [email protected] avoiding the question about a betrayal of New Zealand national MarianHobbs worldwide moratorium on Terminator. interest and the NZ public will. [email protected] Talking generalisations about GURTS, not specifically about International consensus states Pete Hodgson Terminator seeds, Hobbs dodges the terminator technology is a threat to [email protected] ethical question facing the basic human rights and the food Jim Anderton international community. “Our supply. Biotech companies agreed not [email protected] government must keep faith with the to commercialise it, so recent moves to Minister Misleading Public Over public and the world by promising GE Terminator Trials. 16/02/05 Terminator in food is not next on the authorise Terminator are not only a GE Free NZ in food and Environment direct attack on thousands of years of agenda." GE Free New Zealand In Food & Environment Summer Newsletter February 2005 Page Page 1 "Buyer Beware" Action needed Take Action over people: its deceptive and demands over Misleading GE Labels action misleading GE Labels · This is a consumer rights and human Some years ago government reassured rights issue as well as one of cultural the public that we would be allowed Stagg Chilli Bean- Vegetable Mix- values, ethics, and safety to health and the choice to avoid GE/GM foods targeted at vegetarians- is one of the the environment. through a clear labelling system. So I first GE products to be 'labelled' as the · There is a higher incidence of people was shocked to find the first GE law requires, but in small print on the wanting to be clearly told if a product products appearing on supermarket ingredients list rather than the clearer is GE or not than needing to be shelves, under the new rules, and labels previously promised. warned about peanut allergens or on- angered that I was nearly conned into Please check out the label yourself, if pack messages such as "see the taste" buying it. you agree it is unsatisfactory complain · Supermarkets may be exposed to to the Commerce Commission, the liability for emotional or physical What appeared to be tasty, low-fat manufacturer, supermarket companies, Chilli Beans perfect for vegetarians damage if someone eats this product Food Authorities & Judith Tizzard unknowingly and unwillingly. The was not at all my taste in food. It was MP. See label already in my shopping basket when Australian Insurance Council has Hormel says it has now received warned manufacturers using GE may by chance I spotted "corn: genetically over 1000 emails, and is thinking modified" in tiny print in the be held liable through "asbestos-style" about withdrawing the product. lawsuits in decades ahead. ingredient panel. But 'chance' it seems Convince them to remove it.Contact: is good enough for New Zealand · Supermarkets need to keep faith with Hormel (Manufacturer) 09 379 5350 their customers. Even if the label is consumers as far as the Grocery [email protected] industry and the authorities are "legal" retailers should not stock this Foodtown/Woolworths product or should properly inform its concerned. [email protected] customers using a shelf sticker or The manufacturer and the owners of 0800 40 40 40 09 275 2788 visible sign. my local supermarket- Progressive Pak n Save / New World Giant experiment aims to compile a Enterprises, say the labelling meets the Auckland: 09 621 0600 photo file of products with labels letter of the law, believe if people are Wellington: 04 527 2510 identifying that they contain GE misled into buying a product because South Island: 03 353 8700 ingredients. If you have seen others, they miss the GE label then it's their [email protected] snap a photo of the label and email it own fault. Unfortunately the Commerce Commission to: [email protected] Commerce Commission agrees. It says 0800 943 600 (Fair Trading that even if people are misled it is complaints) PO Box 2351 Wellington GE cotton for use in NZ foods powerless to prosecute or require [email protected] 10/02/05 The trans-Tasman food clearer labelling because the rules are standards authority says it is safe to set under "Food Standards" and can Food Safety Authority eat foods containing ingredients made only be changed by our politicians. 0800 693 721 or 04 473 9942 from some GE cotton. Food Standards Once again industry and the authorities [email protected] Australia New Zealand FSANZ seeks are busy passing the buck leaving the public submissions, by March 23, on consumer playing piggy in the middle. Judith Tizzard, Minister of Consumer Affairs, Parliament Buildings the use in foods of GE cotton from The choice to avoid GE foods is not Wellington ( Free post) Monsanto cotton engineered to just an issue of food safety but of [email protected] tolerate glyphosate herbicides, such as cultural, ethical and environmental the company's Roundup. Food Standards Australia New values. People deceived into eating Last year, FSANZ approved a 20th Zealand 04 473 9942 such products may be justified in GE food ingredient, oil and "linters" [email protected] feeling a stomach-churning sense of from cotton, COT102-Bollgard II, betrayal at this sham labelling system. Things to mention engineered with gene codes to produce This may be the first of many foods a bacterial toxin, Bt, to kill insects. that will appear unless supermarkets · Scientists and doctors warn that Foods containing oil and linters from keep faith with their customers and current testing methods for GE food the GE cotton are exempt from GE take it off the shelves. Until the safety are inadequate to protect the labelling requirements. Linters, the Minister of Consumer Affairs takes public. They warn that GE foods fine, silky fibres are used in food action for new laws requiring clear and shouldn't be on the shop shelves as casings, and ice cream. honest labelling- 'buyer beware. some people are more vulnerable to Another GE cotton, MXB-13, has negative effects including the elderly, been reviewed which has been With plenty of exemptions under the pregnant women and those with law - including no labelling at engineered to be both herbicide suppressed immunity tolerant and insect-resistant.