High Temperature Corrosion and Corrosion Protection Part 3: High Temperature Corrosion and Corrosion Protection of the Boilers in Waste to Energy Plants
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
[Seminar] Lecture on Fundamental Aspects of High Temperature Corrosion and Corrosion Protection Part 3: High Temperature Corrosion and Corrosion Protection of the Boilers in Waste to Energy Plants Manabu NOGUCHI*, and Hiroshi YAKUWA** Abstract One of the characteristics of incinerators is that the waste used as fuel contains chlorine in high concentration. The chlorine reacts with alkaline metal, etc., to form a chloride, which is deposited as ash adhesion on boiler heat transfer tubes and the like. When this adhered ash melts, the corrosion environment is significantly deteriorated. In addition, the soot blow used to remove the adhered ash promotes the destruction of the corrosion scale and accelerates the metal loss of the heat transfer tubes. The ash adhesion behavior depends on temperature, and chloride is concentrated where the exhaust gas temperature is high, deteriorating the corrosion environment. Accordingly, a good understanding of the adhesion behavior and an appropriate design for the corrosion environment are required in order to prevent the corrosion of heat transfer tubes. This paper explains the metal loss behavior mainly due to the influence of ash adhesion, and also describes examples of corrosion behavior and corrosion protection in the actual plants. Keywords: High temperature corrosion, Chlorination, Molten salt, Waste to Energy Plant, Superheater, Boiler, Ash adhesion, Predication of corrosion rate 1. Introduction 2. Boilers for waste-to-energy plants Parts 3 and 4 of this lecture discuss high-temperature 2.1 Characteristics of waste-to-energy plants corrosion associated with incinerators. This part Figure 3-11) shows an example of a waste-to-energy focuses on boilers used in waste-to-energy plants, and plant. The plant shown in the figure uses a grate-type the next part, on other equipment. incinerator, a typically used incinerator at present. While thermal power plants practically use steam at Other than this type of incinerator, there are fluidized 600 °C or higher, in waste-to-energy plants, the steam bed furnaces, gasification melting furnaces, etc. The temperature is around 400 °C, which is significantly combustion method varies depending on the incinerator lower than the former. Waste-based power is a type. However, any type of incineration system is significant social need as renewable energy, and almost the same in configuration basically. Waste fed efficient power generation is also required. However, into the pit is burned in the incinerator. The heat is high-temperature corrosion of the heat transfer tubes recovered by the boiler, economizer, etc. Then the is a technical problem, which makes it difficult to use exhaust gas is purified using environmental measures higher-temperature, higher-pressure steam. This part such as exhaust gas treatment and dust removal, and of the lecture explains corrosion of boilers in waste-to- is discharged from the smokestack. energy plants and corrosion protection. In addition to a large amount of ash, waste contains chlorine and sulfur, which act as oxidizers; the amount of chlorine is much larger than that of sulfur, which is the prominent characteristic of waste2). Chlorine reacts * Ebara Enviromantal Plant Co., Ltd. with alkali metals or heavy metals to form chlorides. ** Technologies, R&D Division Ebara Engineering Review No. 253(2017-4) ─ ─1 Lecture on Fundamental Aspects of High Temperature Corrosion and Corrosion Protection Part 3: High Temperature Corrosion and Corrosion Protection of the Boilers in Waste to Energy Plants Flow of waste High-pressure steam header Flow of flue gas Flow of air Steam condenser Flow of ash and dust Steam turbine Flow of steam generator Chemical silo Condensate Flow of water tank Boiler Recycled Economizer water To atmosphere Waste crane Bag filter Superheater Deodorization Desuperheater unit Waste hopper Incinerator Stack Secondary blower Induced draft fan Drying stoker From other Platform Post-combustion stoker incinerators Combustion Forced draft Refuse stoker fan feeder Collected dust conveyor Weighing scale From other incinerators Collected dust and ash handling system Fallen ash conveyor Ash conveyor To the final landfill site Air preheater Input bunker Storage bunker Ash Solidified bunker material pit Fig. 3-1 Flowchart of a waste-to-energy plant1) Then, ash containing such chlorides flies from the other hand, in the superheater, ash adhesion greatly incinerator to the following equipment, adhering to the varies depending on the area, in general. Ash adhesion heating surface of the boiler. In general, to minimize is maximized at the superheater entrance (d). In some such ash adhesion, the exhaust gas is turned 180° at cases, adhering ash grows in a comb-like shape toward the bottom of the boiler to detach adhering ash, with a the upstream of the gas flow. Toward the downstream superheater installed in the third path of the boiler. of the gas flow, however, the amount of adhering ash Figure 3-2 shows an example of ash adhering to the gradually decreases with almost no adhering ash boiler of an actual incineration system for industrial observed at the superheater exit (f) in many cases. Ash waste. Adhering ash is partially removed from the adhesion may not only decrease the heat transfer upper area (a) of the water tube of the boiler. However, efficiency of boilers but also cause gas blockage in a no significant difference in appearance is observed superheater. Therefore, it is usual that adhering ash is among the upper, middle, and lower areas. On the periodically removed during operation using soot blowing which blows steam or the like. Tube side 2.2 Characteristics of adhering ash Gas side Water tube Adhering of ash affects corrosion of incinerators in particular. The composition of adhering ash is not constant and is often different between the gas side Flue gas and the water tube side. The photo of ash adhering to (a) Upper area (f) SH the water tube (shown in Figure 3-2 (a) to (c)) indicates that a hard cream-colored substance like a crispy rice SH bar is observed on the gas side. However, inside the (b) Middle area SH (e) above substance, there is a light green dense substance, inside which there is a reddish brown corrosion SH product covering the surface of the water tube. The ash adhering to the superheater (shown in Figure 3-2 (c) Lower area (d) Boiler diagram (d) to (f)) is not as clear as the ash that adheres to the :Sampling locations SH:Superheater water tube, but the properties of gas side and the tube Fig. 3-2 Example of ash adhering to the boiler of an actual waste-to-energy plant side are different. Except the ash in Area (f), where the Ebara Engineering Review No. 253(2017-4) ─ ─2 Lecture on Fundamental Aspects of High Temperature Corrosion and Corrosion Protection Part 3: High Temperature Corrosion and Corrosion Protection of the Boilers in Waste to Energy Plants Table 3-1 Analysis results of adhering ash3) Water tube Superheater Location Collected (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) ash Side Tube Gas Tube Gas Tube Gas Tube Gas Tube Gas Whole N=11 Na 5.79 2.75 5.36 2.38 6.00 3.46 15.18 1.42 1.83 1.60 3.51 0.96 Al 1.61 2.56 2.32 2.99 4.01 4.80 2.49 2.59 2.69 2.96 2.60 4.12 Si 2.03 2.40 1.97 2.11 2.02 1.90 5.37 6.22 5.52 6.88 5.85 20.62 S 8.43 12.18 8.74 12.68 11.90 12.60 2.53 3.31 5.55 3.43 5.62 2.17 Cl 12.81 5.16 13.35 4.52 4.40 3.71 23.06 14.32 14.29 11.48 10.25 2.69 K 6.41 0.82 8.66 1.13 6.64 3.37 5.73 2.33 2.67 1.90 3.01 1.16 Ca 6.59 28.46 7.46 26.60 12.37 20.24 21.06 30.44 27.72 29.01 19.96 15.43 Cu 7.69 1.31 8.56 1.60 5.79 3.81 3.98 3.26 7.24 2.37 7.16 0.61 Zn 2.39 1.23 2.38 1.24 2.25 1.81 2.00 1.71 1.78 1.79 2.46 0.70 Pb 22.18 0.09 14.86 0.09 6.85 0.73 0.73 0.31 0.21 0.18 2.86 0.14 Endothermic 344 ℃ 678 ℃ 361 ℃ 658 ℃ 466 ℃ 518 ℃ 527 ℃ 562 ℃ 534 ℃ 536 ℃ N.D. peak pH 6.2 10.13 5.81 9.82 6.78 8.56 amount of adhering ash is small, we identified the ash area. The higher the exhaust gas temperature becomes, collected at each location as the gas side one or the the higher concentration heavy metal chlorides, tube side one, and analyzed them. Table 3-13) shows the especially Pb, tend to have. On the other hand, as well analytical results. The ash on the gas side contained as Ca, S tends to be more concentrated mainly in the almost no component of heat transfer tubes, such as Fe. ash adhering to the water tube on the gas side. It is On the other hand, the ash on the tube side contained considered that S is concentrated as Ca sulfate in the a large amount of corrosion products and up to nearly areas where the exhaust gas and surface temperatures 50 % of the heat transfer tube components. For this are high. reason, these values removed Fe, Cr, and Ni and As described above, the temperature range of converted to 100 %. The table also shows the results of concentration varies depending on the compound, and analysis on the (collective) ash taken from the chlorides, which have a significant effect on corrosion, equipment following the boiler, which is considered to are likely to be more concentrated in the areas where have passed through the boiler.