Guidelines on Wilderness in Natura 2000
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Technical Report - 2013 - 069 Guidelines on Wilderness in Natura 2000 Management of terrestrial wilderness and wild areas within the Natura 2000 Network Environment Europe Direct is a service to help you find answers to your questions about the European Union New freephone number: 00 800 6 7 8 9 10 11 This document reflects the view of the Commission services and is not of a binding nature. ISBN 978-92-79-31157-4 doi: 10.2779/33572 © European Union, 2013 Reproduction is authorised provided the source is acknowledged This document has been prepared with the assistance of Alterra in a consortium with PAN Parks Foundation and Eurosite under contract to the European Commission (contract N°07.0307/2010/576314/SER/B3). It has also greatly benefitted from discussions with, and information supplied by, experts from Member States, key stakeholder groups and the Expert Group on management of Natura 2000. Parts concerning national legislation and mapping have built on work done in the Wildland Research Institute, University of Leeds. Photograph cover page: Central Balkan, Natura 2000 site number BG 0000494 ©Svetoslav Spasov, who has kindly made this photo available to the European Commission for use in this guidance document EU Guidance on the management of wilderness and wild areas in Natura 2000 Contents Purpose of this Guidance 5 Background 5 Purpose of this guidance document 7 Structure and contents 7 Limitations of the document 8 1 What is wilderness in the context of Natura 2000? 10 1.1 Introduction 10 1.2 Definition of wilderness 10 1.2.1 Ecological aspects of the definition 11 1.2.2 Wilderness continuum 12 1.2.3 Use of the definition in the guidance document 12 1.3 Other existing definitions 13 1.4 Legislative and statutory measures in EU Member States to protect wilderness 15 1.4.1 Strict nature reserve and wilderness (IUCN categories Ia and Ib) 15 1.4.2 Other IUCN categories 16 1.5 Spatial link between wilderness and the Natura 2000 network 17 2 EU policy framework on biodiversity preservation 19 2.1 EU Biodiversity strategy 19 2.2 EU Nature Directives 20 2.3 Managing and protecting Natura 2000 sites 22 2.4 Favourable conservation status 23 2.4.1 Requirements under Article 6 of the Habitats Directive 24 2.4.2 Requirements under Article 4(1) and 4(2) of the Birds Directive 28 2.5 Relevant guidance documents 30 3 Ecosystem resilience, ecosystem services and benefits of wilderness areas 32 3.1 Wilderness areas as resilient ecosystems 32 3.2 Pressures due to anthropogenic disturbances 34 3.2.1 Habitat fragmentation 35 3.2.2 Climate change 36 3.2.3 Invasive alien species 37 3.3 Ecosystem services and benefits of Natura 2000 and wilderness 38 3.3.1 Key ecosystem services 39 3.3.2 Social, cultural and economic benefits 41 4 Management approaches for wilderness in Natura 2000 43 4.1 Introduction 43 4.1.1 Best practice 43 4.2 Planning non-intervention management 43 4.2.1 Conservation objectives for wilderness areas 44 4.2.2 When is non-intervention management not appropriate? 45 4.2.3 Management measures in wilderness areas 47 3 EU Guidance on the management of wilderness and wild areas in Natura 2000 4.2.4 Management plans 47 4.2.5 Compensatory measures to overcome limitations posed by wilderness 48 4.2.6 Measures taken to ensure and improve wilderness qualities 49 4.3 Management challenges 58 4.3.1 Bark beetles as key species in areas with non-intervention management 59 4.3.2 Forest fires in Boreal and Mediterranean forests 62 4.3.3 Reindeer herding and wilderness management: seeking the balance 64 4.4 Concluding remarks 66 5 Communication strategies 68 5.1 Involvement of stakeholders 68 5.2 Importance of effective communication 68 5.3 Communication strategies and actions 69 ANNEXES 71 A1 Glossary 71 A2 Definitions of technical terms 72 A3 Legislation and protection provisions in EU Member States 78 A4 Responses to the Questionnaire 83 A5 Habitat types representing wilderness value 85 A6 Species of the Habitat and Birds Directives with wilderness values 88 References 92 4 EU Guidance on the management of wilderness and wild areas in Natura 2000 Purpose of this Guidance Background Natura 2000 protects areas of high biodiversity value across the European Union. It is the largest co-ordinated multi-national network of protected areas in the world, covering more than 18% of the European terrestrial territory of the Member States as well as significant marine areas. As establishment of Natura 2000 nears completion the focus is increasingly shifting to the effective management and restoration of sites in the network. Ensuring a fully functional Natura 2000 network is central to achieving the EU target of halting and reversing the loss of biodiversity and ecosystem services in the EU by 20201. Europe is one of the most densely populated areas in the world and European nature is to a large extent shaped by long-term human intervention. The sites in Natura 2000 reflect both historical and current human influences but the network also includes places that are in a relatively undisturbed natural state and where species and habitats of EU conservation concern are not dependent on human intervention. The management of the network will need to reflect the fact that human intervention has a key role to play in achieving conservation objectives for many of the sites whereas in specific cases non-intervention can be applied for the same purpose. There are also many degraded habitats which will require important investments and restoration measures in order to achieve the objective of favourable conservation status. Natura 2000 is not a system aimed at providing a barrier to activities. Instead, human activities need to comply with the provisions outlined in Article 6 of the Habitats Directive, to ensure that these activities are in line with the conservation objectives of Natura 2000 sites. Whereas Natura 2000 fully embraces the principles of conservation and sustainable use a variety of protection approaches can be applied to the sites by Member States at national or regional level. Several Member States apply strict protection in parts of their Natura 2000 network to protect sites' natural conditions. As a management measure this means ensuring minimal human intervention in order to allow natural processes to predominate. There are examples of such setting aside of areas for nature or non-intervention management in the Natura 2000 network. Natural processes require sufficiently large areas to allow for dynamic changes over time and space. Natural areas, where natural processes predominate, which are sufficiently large and lack infrastructure, or are managed to achieve those qualities, are for the purposes of this guidance document being called wilderness areas. Many Member States designate areas with the purpose of preserving those qualities of wilderness, or a set of them, and may have a special class of protected areas for this purpose. However, it is important to note that occurrence of wilderness qualities is not limited to areas formally designated for their protection. Protection and restoration of wilderness and wild areas has gained increasing attention in recent years (see text box: EP Resolution on wilderness in Europe). Wilderness and wild areas are not 1 http://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/biodiversity/comm2006/2020.htm 5 EU Guidance on the management of wilderness and wild areas in Natura 2000 explicitly mentioned in the EU Birds and Habitats Directives but applying a wilderness approach to the management of Natura 2000 sites is seen compatible with the provisions of the Directives. Furthermore, scientific evidence shows that wilderness areas are resilient against pressures affecting biodiversity and should be considered important tool in helping achieve biodiversity targets. Wilderness areas inside and outside protected areas could e.g. deliver an important element of Green Infrastructure2, by the amount of various ecosystem services these core areas could potentially deliver, and their function as reservoir of biodiversity that can be drawn upon to re-populate and revitalise degraded ecosystems. EP Resolution on wilderness in Europe In 2007, a broad coalition of NGOs in Europe addressed a resolution to the European Commission and the EU Member States on the preservation of wilderness areas. This was followed in December 2008 by a report drawn up by Gyula Hegyi3, Member of the European Parliament, stressing the importance of wilderness in Europe to stop further loss of biodiversity. This report contained a motion on a European Parliament resolution on wilderness in Europe and was adopted by the Committee on the Environment, Public Health and Food Safety. The vote on the special report on Wilderness in Europe provided the popular mandate for improving wilderness conservation in Europe as the report was adopted by the European Parliament on 3 February 2009. It was a non-legislative resolution bringing forward a range of recommendations, and stating the need for further action in several key areas - defining wilderness, mapping it, studying wilderness benefits, developing an EU strategy for wilderness, developing new wilderness areas, promoting them, bringing in effective protection of wilderness areas, accepting the Wild Europe Initiative, ensuring that wilderness zones are given special status and stricter protection for wilderness zones in the Natura 2000 network, getting Member States to set wilderness conservation as a priority in their strategy to address climate change and forward the resolution to the governments and parliaments of the Member States. The ‘Wilderness Report’ adopted by the European Parliament states that the European Commission should develop appropriate recommendations that provide guidance to the EU Member States on the best way of ensuring protection of present and potential wilderness or wild lands and their natural processes, which are likely to be covered by the Natura 2000 network.