Seniors/Disabled Ride Free
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Analysis of the RTA Seniors and People with Disabilities Ride Free Programs A Report Prepared for the Regional Transportation Authority -FINAL REPORT- Joseph DiJohn, Paul Metaxatos, Ashish Sen, Mike Pagano Lise Dirks and Valbona Kokoshi Phone: 312-996-1458 Email: [email protected] November 2010 Urban Transportation Center (MC 357) College of Urban Planning and Public Affairs University of Illinois at Chicago 412 South Peoria Street, Suite 340, Chicago, Illinois 60607-7036 Phone: (312) 996-4820; Fax: (312) 413-0006; URL: www.utc.uic.edu Analysis of the RTA Seniors and People with Disabilities Ride Free Programs – FINAL REPORT 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Seniors Ride Free (SRF) program began on March 17, 2008, and the People with Disabilities Ride Free (PDRF) program, also known as the Circuit Breaker (CB) program, began on October 24, 2008. The Regional Transportation Authority (RTA) commissioned this study to examine the short- and long-term ridership and financial implications of the Senior Ride Free Program and the short-term financial implications for the PDRF program. Based on our analysis this study has found the SRF program to be financially unsustainable. Registrations SRF registrations increased from under 2,000 in March 2008 to more than 396,000 in December 2009. At the same time reduced fare registrations decreased during the SRF program from 252,260 in March 2008 to 175,632 in December 2009. The registrations of persons with disabilities (Circuit Breakers) have increased from 22,000 in November 2008, the first full month of the program in place, to more than 37,000 in December 2009. At the same time the registrations of people with disabilities on reduced fare have remained relatively stable between 45,000 in March 2008 and 47,000 in December 2009. Ridership From March 2008 to December 2009, 77.6 million free rides were provided to seniors and people with disabilities on the RTA system. This represents 6.6% of total ridership. Since the inception of the SRF and PDRF programs, many seniors and people with disabilities that were previously eligible for a reduced fare but were not registered have signed up for the additional benefit, and therefore there has been a rapid increase in ridership for these two programs compared to the previous reduced fare program. Through March 2009, according to our estimates, the programs have attracted on average 1.3 million new free rides per month compared to an average 1.7 million seniors rides per month that had previously paid a reduced fare. This represents a 75% increase in ridership for those two groups, which is not to be confused with a potential overall ridership increase among these populations which is more difficult to calculate since people not registered for the reduced fare program‟s travel habits were unable to be analyzed. Through December 2009, free senior rides represent, on average, 5.2% of CTA‟s total ridership and 6.5% of Pace‟s ridership. Through December 2009, Metra estimates about 3.8% of total ridership, on average, are free senior trips. By December 2009, 19.2 million free rides had been provided to people with disabilities. During that period, CTA experienced rapid growth from 566,000 rides in November 2008, the first full month of the program, to 1,519,000 rides in December 2009. Similarly, Pace went from 26,000 rides in November to 90,500 rides in December 2009. Metra increased from less than 500 rides Analysis of the RTA Seniors and People with Disabilities Ride Free Programs – FINAL REPORT 2 in November 2008 to 27,800 rides in December 2009. It is estimated that from November 2008 to December 2009, people with disabilities ride free represent on average about 2.6% of RTA‟s average (for the same period) total monthly ridership. In summary, during the study period, free rides to seniors and people with disabilities represented 6.9% of CTA, 3.8% of Metra‟s and 8.2% of Pace‟s total ridership. In addition, ADA paratransit ridership appears to be rather insensitive to the fluctuations in SRF and PDRF ridership. During the study period gasoline prices have fluctuated significantly and unemployment in the Chicago region has increased. Moreover, Metra ridership during the study period was also impacted by various road construction projects (Edens and Dan Ryan) and the CTA Brown Line construction. These and other factors also influence both general ridership and usage by seniors and people with disabilities. In addition, future ridership projections are based, in part, on past performance. The recent years of 2008 and 2009 were not typical years due to the poor economy, changes in fares, unseasonable weather and fluctuating gasoline prices. For these reasons, future predictions may vary. Survey of SRF Program Users A survey of seniors registered for the SRF program revealed the following information about the travel behavior and attitudes toward the program Transit Use 44% of the respondents did not have a reduced fare card prior to the program. 34% of the respondents currently use transit one or more times per week. 28% responded they ride transit more frequently as a result of the program; an approximately equal percentage (31%) reported they use cars and taxis less. Why and How They Ride 13% reported taking rides that are work related while 16% were currently employed. 47% reported having ridden CTA bus in the previous week, 25% CTA rail, 31% Metra and 17% Pace. 50% of respondents reported taking more transit trips during rush hour, and 52% rode more during weekends since the program started. Socioeconomic Profile Over 90% reported living in households of 1 or 2 people. 79% respondents had a driver's license and 81% had an auto available. 16% are currently employed, 5% less than at the start of the program. 33% had incomes less than $22,000 annually. 28% had income more than $55,000 annually. Analysis of the RTA Seniors and People with Disabilities Ride Free Programs – FINAL REPORT 3 About 44% (59% of the rides) of the respondents would qualify for the CB program based on income eligibility. Attitudes about the Seniors Ride Free Program Continuation 71% of respondents think the program should be continued, 24% think it should be limited to low income seniors, and 4% think it should be discontinued. These results regarding attitudes about the SRF Program should be interpreted with caution as the majority of the survey respondents were mostly from Cook County. In addition, it is possible that riders who use their cards regularly were more likely to respond to the survey. Finally, the survey was only sent to seniors who have a SRF card and who, according to census data, are only about half of the seniors in the region. Recent Surveys in the Chicago Region Recent surveys in the Chicago region undertaken by Pace in 2007 and IDOT in 2009 have concluded that the majority of trips by seniors are non-work related trips and the cost of transit fares is not an important factor in choosing transit. Demographic Forecasts and Ridership Impact of the SRF Program The forecasted senior population data indicates that the senior population for the Chicago region will double between 2000 and 2030, growing from 870,000 or 10.8% of total population to over 1,780,000 or 17.6% of total population. This includes an 83% growth in senior population from 2010 to 2030. In terms of sheer numbers, Cook County will continue to dominate, with 60% or more of the region‟s senior population throughout the growth period. As the baby boomers age, the largest impact will be growth in the 65 to 74 age cohort over the next ten to fifteen years. The 65-74 age group forecast for 2010 is over 513,000, growing to 972,000 by 2030. Between 2020 and 2030 growth in this cohort will slow, and the 74 to 85 year old age cohort will increase accordingly. By the year 2030 the regional population for persons 75 and older is forecasted to be nearly 811,000. The growth rate in disabled population is influenced by growth in total population, since the disabled population is distributed throughout all age groups. However, seniors have a higher rate of disability than the rest of the population and as an age cohort, a higher growth rate. The percentage of disabled who are seniors is expected to increase from about 25% to around 35% over the forecast period. The fact that most of the growth in the disabled population will occur within the senior cohort has planning implications for transit and paratransit services. We might expect this pattern to follow the same trend as senior growth, with declining growth rates following 2030. Disabled population in Cook County and the Chicago region is projected to increase, respectively, from 1.03 and 1.53 million in 2000 to 1.24 million and 2.08 million in 2030, respectively. Analysis of the RTA Seniors and People with Disabilities Ride Free Programs – FINAL REPORT 4 If the Seniors Ride Free were to continue we expect total annual ridership to be approximately 64.5 million trips by 2030 with CTA, Metra, and Pace carrying, respectively, approximately 54.4 million, 6.2 million, and 3.9 million rides. Locations in the United States with Free Senior Fares Only one other state in the United States, Pennsylvania, provides free rides to seniors (commuter rail rides are $1) by using lottery funds to reimburse the operators. Philadelphia and Pittsburgh have experienced similar ridership trends as the RTA region resulting from the free ride program. Financial Implications of the SRF and PDRF Programs Short Term Financial Impacts The 2009 annual revenue loss for the SRF program is estimated to be between $26.1 million and $76.8 million with a median value of $38.5 million.