Power, Capital, and the Social Structure of Accumulation in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan [Book in Draft]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
! "#$%&'()*!'#(+(+,+&#-(-()*!'#(+(+.!"$/0#1!'2"(3241!2)%!350!+$'(24!+3#&'3�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ii ! ! 4%2!5+-*&6!3$!7&2+/(.6!&/8!9%11$! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! iii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`'(+H!X%;'1&!;%(0,%&!2(/+,!."/2&&15UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUULL77LC\VG^JZ! $5170+,!F+(H!!)+,'75+,1&'0#A!/+7+(/+(;#!1(/!05+!+Q0+,(1&!1,0';2&10'%(!%<!4%,/1('1(!;17'01&'-3UUUUUUU77L^J\G^[D! $5170+,!_&+:+(H!a+>'0'310'(>!(+%&'"+,1&'-3H!'(*1,/P%20*1,/!<1;'(>!'/+%&%>#!1(/!05+!4%,/1('1(!XX.UUUL77L^[JG^\Z! $5170+,!F*+&:+H!$%(;&2-'%(-UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUL77L^\\GVJ[! ! M(/+Q!JUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUL77LVJZGVJ\! b%,8-!$'0+/UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUULL77LVCDGV^C! ! ! iv 4C;<!@E!3>:FB;! ! c,%--!]'Q+/!$17'01&!]%,310'%(!"#!d'(/!%<!_;%(%3';!.;0':'0#!ICDDZGCDJYKH!V! 4%"!$,+10'%(!IX+;0%,!1(/!.;0':'0#KH!JV! e+>'-0+,+/!_Q710,'10+!b%,8+,-!"#!_;%(%3';!.;0':'0#H!J[! B+/'1(!1(/!B+1(!e+1&!b1>+-!'(!4%,/1(!ICDJD!1(/!CDJYKH!^D! $+(0,1&!c%:+,(3+(0!@2/>+0-!IJ\CVGJ\VVKH!ZY! X%2,;+-!%<!?%3+-0';!e+:+(2+-!IJ\W^GJ\YYKH!JJ^! .&&%;10'%(!%<!X010+!_Q7+(/'02,+-!IJ\W^GJ\YYKH!JJ^! X0,2;02,+!%<!4%,/1('1(!M37%,0-!1(/!_Q7%,0-!IJ\Y[GJ\[^KH!JCW! X%2,;+-!%<!c%:+,(3+(0!e+:+(2+-!IJ\W^GJ\YYKH!JCY! 4%,/1(O-!]%,+'>(!)10,%(-!IJ\YVGJ\[^KH!JC[! X%2,;+-!%<!?%3+-0';!e+:+(2+-!IJ\[VGJ\Z\KH!JVC! X0,2;02,+!%<!4%,/1('1(!M37%,0-!1(/!_Q7%,0-!IJ\[VGJ\Z\KH!JWYGJW[! X+;0%,1&!X51,+!%<!`10'%(1&!c?)!IJ\[VGJ\Z\KH!JYC! .77&';1(0-!1(/!.77%'(0++-!0%!05+!4%,/1('1(!$':'&!X+,:';+!IJ\\DGCDJ[KH!CJC! d.??@!4%'(0!f+(02,+-!ICDDZKH!CV\! ]%,+'>(!)%72&10'%(!e+-'/'(>!'(!4%,/1(!"#!$%2(0,#!%<!`10'%(1&'0#!ICDDVA!CDJWKH!^JV! X%2,;+-!%<!4%,/1('1(!T?.!ICDJWGCDJYKH!^^V! 4%,/1(O-!.,,1(>+3+(0-!*'05!05+!MB]!IJ\Z\GCDJYKH!^^Z! .&&%;10'%(-!%<!@'&10+,1&!T<<';'1&!?+:+&%73+(0!.--'-01(;+!ICDJWGCDJYKH!^^\! _Q0+,(1&!F,1/+!"#!$%33%/'0#!c,%27-!ICDJZKH!^WCG^WV! F%7!JD!]%,+'>(!$%371('+-!M(:+-0'(>!'(!4%,/1(!ICDD^GCDJWKH!^WW! ]%,+'>(!?',+;0!M(:+-03+(0!]&%*-!"#!$%2(0,#!ICDDWGCDJ[KH!^WY! ]%,+'>(!T*(+,-5'7!%<!.331(!X0%;8!_Q;51(>+!ICDJ[GCDJ\KH!^WZ! M(:+-0%,-!T*('(>!B%,+!051(!Jg!_=2'0#!'(!4%,/1(O-!)2"&';&#!a'-0+/!]',3-!ICDJ\KH!^YDG^YV! v 4C;<!@E!6CGH=B;! Gross Fixed Capital Formation (% of GDP): 5 National Savings (% of GDP): 5 Total Factor Productivity (Constant National Prices): 6 Output per Workers (2011 USD): 6 Growth of Labor Productivity per Person Employed: 7 Jordan Trade Performance (1985-2017): 8 Jordan’s Current Account and Trade Balance under King Abdullah: 8 Terms of Trade (1997-2017): 9 Ranking of Jordanian Export Complexity (1964-2017): 9 Manufacturing Value Added Per Capita (1990-2016): 10 Share of Medium and High-Tech Products in Manufactured Exports (1990-2016): 10 Jordan v. Comparator Countries, Share of Medium and High-Tech Products in Manufactured Exports (1990-2016): 11 Resident Patent Applications: 11 Distribution of Work Permits by Sector, Sex, and Nationality: 16 National Unemployment Rate: 19 Education Levels of New Market Entrants (1960-2010): 21 The Unemployment by Education Levels (2000-2010): 21 The Jordanian Employed (2013-2017): 22 Labor Force Participation Rates (1990-2018): 26 Employment to Population Ratio (2000-2018): 26 Employment Structure in Private-Wage Employment by Firm Size (2010): 32 British Subsidy to Mandate Transjordan (1921-1944): 89 Jordan Trade Performance (1954-1966): 125 Domestic and International Borrowing (1974-1989): 143 State Expenditures (1974-1989): 144 Foreign Trade (1974-1989): 158 Sources of Government Receipts (1974-1989): 158 Asset of Licensed Commercial Banks (1976-1990): 161 GDP Per Capita Growth (1982-1991): 165 Share of Public Sector in Total Employment under King Abdullah (2000-2016): 209 Public Sector Jobs Created (2007-2017): 209 Average Annual Household Expenditures on Health Services (2008-2017): 218 Tax Revenues (2005-2017): 219 Treasury Bills and Bond Issues to GDP Ratio (2001-2016): 223 Overall FDI Restrictiveness Index: 235 QIZ Exports (2000-2011): 239 QIZ vs. FTA, Exports (2010-2011): 239 QIZ Job Creation and Export Sophistication: 244 Total Assets of Licensed Commercial Banks (2000-2018): 272 Aggregate Sectoral Income (2017): 273 Share of Aggregate Sector Market Capitalization and Sector Annual Income (2017, 2019): 277-290 Work Permit Holders by Nationalities (2004-2014): 314 Jordan’s Official Development Assistance (1990-2009): 333 Jordan’s Annual Official Development Assistance (2010-2017): 336 US Aid Budget Allocations (2019): 340 Jordanian Trade Performance (1985-2017): 340 Jordan’s Current Account and Trade Balance under King Abdullah (2000-2017): 341 Terms of Trade (1997-2017): 345 Jordan’s Economic Complexity (1964-2017): 346 Jordan’s Export Basket (2017): 346 vi Jordan’s Export Basket, Product Composition (2017): 347 Value-Add of Domestic Manufactures (1990-2016): 348 ICT Exports as Percentage of Total Exports (Jordan v. Comparator Countries, 2000-2017): 349 Jordan’s Export Complexity Index Score and Rank (1964-2014): 352 Foreign Ownership of Amman Stock Exchange (2017-2019): 359 Education Levels of the Jordanian Workforce: Home v. the Diaspora (2010): 368 Workers’ Remittances under King Abdullah (2000-2017): 370 ! ! vii '52"30#!$)0! 2A!CA<=@IH?<C@A!<@!J9@=I>AC>AK!?>LC<>FC;M!CA!<NB!OP;<!?BA<H=Q! ! ! ! ! ! ! If not sui generis, Jordanian capitalism is undoubtedly peculiar, as is most obviously and saliently evinced through its relationship with crisis. On the one hand, it can be shown that crisis, broadly defined, constitutes both a necessary input and an inevitable output of capital accumulation in Jordan, an odd phenomenon in and of itself. Despite this being so and despite the economy’s loitering in a state of terminal distress, moreover, it can also be shown that this formation somehow demonstrates both resilience and immutability as well. An impossibility of sorts, then, Jordanian capitalism seems to endogenously generate then stubbornly persist within the very conditions meant to trigger either its demise or its evolution.J!! ! T(+!;%2&/!"+!<%,>':+(!<%,!<'(/'(>!05'-!1&&!1!"'0!/'-%,'+(0'(>L!F5'-!'-!05+!;%2(0,#!%<!1!7&2;8#A! 2+;%23-.(!d'(>A!1<0+,!1&&A!%<!1!3%(1,;5!*5%!;%(<'/+(0&#!0,1:+,-+-!*+-0+,(!;17'01&-!'(;1(0'(>!01&+-! %<!1!,'-'(>!<-*-'%/!=&8->!.(/!#+0A!05+!-&'>50+-0!-;,20'(#!*%2&/!"+!-2<<';'+(0!0%!,+:+1&!d'(> J! M0!'-!'(/'-7201"&+A!%<!;%2,-+A!0510!05+!:1>1,'+-!%<!4%,/1(O-!+Q0+,(1&!+(:',%(3+(0!'(0+(-'<#!05'-!;17'01&'-3O-!31(#! <1'&2,+-A!1-!05+!+<<+;0-!%<!05+!X#,'1(!,+<2>++!'(<&2Q!*+&&!100+-0-L!`+:+,05+&+--A!1-!'0!;1(!1(/!*'&&!"+!/+3%(-0,10+/! 0510!+Q%>+(%2-!-5%;8-!%(&#!+Q0+(210+!1(/!;%37%2(/!0+(/+(;'+-!-/(+2/&*!0%!05+!+;%(%3';!<%,310'%(R1-!<1'&2,+! 1(/!2(/+,/+:+&%73+(0!1,+!05+,+<%,+!-0,2;02,1&A!+(/%>+(%2-A!1(/!+:+(!%(0%&%>';1&!7,%7+,0'+-!%<!05+!4%,/1('1(!