JONATHAN EDWARDS in the TWENTIETH CENTURY Kenneth P

Home , George Marsden, Joseph Bellamy, New England Theology, Sarah Edwards (mystic), Yale Divinity School

JETS 47/4 (December 2004) 659–87

JONATHAN EDWARDS IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY

kenneth p. minkema*

It is hard to imagine that anyone interested in Jonathan Edwards, the great eighteenth-century American theologian, revivalist, and missionary, did not know that 2003 was the 300th anniversary of his birth. This milestone was marked by numerous commemorative conferences, symposia, lecture series, and other events across the country, accompanied by a wealth of publications, including scholarly and popular monographs, special editions of Edwards’s writings, collected essays, reference works, commemorative cat- alogues, and a magisterial biography.1 However, scholars of Edwards are not unaccustomed to large and diverse amounts of publications on him; indeed, they are spoiled, or glutted, depending on your point of view. The surge in Edwards studies over the past generation has been referred to as a “renaissance” that shows no signs of abating. But the road to that renaissance has been long and circuitous, and is itself a source of some fascination. This article examines interpretation and appraisal of Edwards primarily within the “academy” over the twentieth century. The “academy” is identiﬁed with the rise of professional scholarship as a cultural and class phenomenon and with the modern research university as it emerged in the very late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. I also include under this rubric

* Kenneth Minkema is executive editor of The Works of Jonathan Edwards, Yale Divinity School, 409 Prospect Street, New Haven, CT 06511. 1 Monographs include Robert E. Brown, Jonathan Edwards and the Bible (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2002); Stephen Nichols, An Absolute Sort of Certainty: The Holy Spirit and the Apologetics of Jonathan Edwards (Phillipsburg, NJ: Presbyterian & Reformed, 2003); Mark Noll, America’s God: From Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002); Amy Plantinga Pauw, The Supreme Harmony of All: The Trinitarian Theology of Jonathan Edwards (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003); Douglas A. Sweeney, Nathaniel William Taylor, New Haven Theology, and the Legacy of Jonathan Edwards (New York: Oxford University Press, 2003); Avihu Zakai, Jonathan Edwards’s Philosophy of History: The Reenchantment of the World in the Age of Enlightenment (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2003). For selected writings by Ed- wards, see Richard Bailey and Gregory Wills, eds., The Salvation of Souls: Nine Previously Un- published Sermons on the Call of Ministry and the Gospel by Jonathan Edwards (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2003); and Michael McMullen, ed., The Blessing of God: Previously Unpublished Ser- mons by Jonathan Edwards (Nashville: Broadman & Holman, 2003). Collected essays can be found in Paul Helm and Oliver Crisp, eds., Jonathan Edwards: Philosophical Theologian (London: Ash- gate, 2003); and Sang Hyun Lee, ed., A Companion to the Theology of Jonathan Edwards (Prince- ton: Princeton University Press, forthcoming). For a reference work, see M. X. Lesser, comp., The Printed Writings of Jonathan Edwards (Princeton: Princeton Theological Seminary, forthcoming). A commemorative catalogue is Jonathan Edwards Tercentennial Exhibition: Selected Objects from the Yale Collection (New Haven: Yale University, 2003). The latest biography is George M. Marsden, Jonathan Edwards: A Life (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003). 660 journal of the evangelical theological society theological schools and seminaries, many of which predated the advent of the modern “academy” but which, to a greater or lesser degree, have adopted its standards. As such, pastors and other religious writers, products and asso- ciates of these theological institutions, also figure here. We can locate the beginning of the appraisal of Edwards within this professional academic culture, thus broadly defined, with the first dissertation done on Edwards in 1899 at the University of Halle, followed closely by the first American dissertation on Edwards written in 1904 at Boston University.2 Table 1 tracks commentary and secondary works on Edwards over the twentieth century. I have registered items devoted wholly or in part to Ed- wards: books, articles, book chapters or respectable portions thereof, introductions to edited materials, pamphlets, and dissertations; I have excluded book reviews, entries in reference works, newspaper articles, passing references, and reprinted works (though I do digress to take notice of reprints at a couple of points in the discussion below). Some items are category-busters because of their range; in cases like this, I have had to look at factors such as the writer’s discipline, or department, or the place of publication, along with other criteria, before assigning a designation. Table 2 breaks out dissertations on Edwards, and utilizes the same categories in order to allow for comparison with Table 1.3 First, I shall unpack some of the information in these tables, then briefly discuss some current topics in Edwards studies, and finish with a reflection on the relationship of the academy and the church in this endeavor.

i. general observations

From the beginning of the century through the 1930s, the rate of scholarship on Edwards was, frankly, pitiful. These were the decades of the Pro- gressive Era, the Jazz Age, and the Scopes trial, when the stock of things Puritan and Edwardsean was about as low as it has ever been. One writer in 1918 stated that Edwards “believed in the worst God, preached the worst sermons, and had the worst religion of any human being who ever lived on this continent.”4 What is more, no one emerged to gainsay this estimation. Edwards was set up as the straw man of repression and snobbery, a medieval relic that had no place in modern America. Culturally, ﬁgures such as H. L.

2 John Henry McCracken, “Jonathan Edwards Idealismus” (Ph.D. diss., University of Halle, 1899); Clement Elton Holmes, “The Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards and Its Relation to His The- ology” (Ph.D. diss., Boston University, 1904). 3 Sources include M. X. Lesser, Jonathan Edwards: A Reference Guide (Boston: G. K. Hall, 1981); idem., Jonathan Edwards: An Annotated Bibliography, 1979–1993 (Westport, CT: Greenwood, 1994); Sean Michael Lucas, “Jonathan Edwards Between Church and Academy: A Bibliographical Essay,” in D. G. Hart et al., eds., The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards: American Religion and the Evangelical Tradition (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003) 228–48; America: History and Life Online; ATLA Religion Database; UMI Digital Dissertations; WorldCat; and the The Works of Jonathan Edwards archive, Yale Divinity School. 4 Marilla M. Ricker, Jonathan Edwards: The Divine Who Filled the Air with Damnation and Proved the Total Depravity of God (New York: American Freethought Tract Society, 1918). jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 661

Table 1. Secondary Literature on Jonathan Edwards, 1901–2000a Homiletics Revivalism/ Great Awakening Missiology Ethics/ Aesthetics Literature/ Cultural Criticism Philosophy/ Psychology History/ Biography Theology 1901–10 5 7 --214 4 9 (n=41) (12.2%) (17.0) (4.9) (34.1) (9.8) (22.0) 1911–20 1 1 --44 5 7 (n=22) (4.5%) (4.5) (18.2) (18.2) (22.8) (31.8) 1921–30 4 4 --14 10 5 (n=28) (14.3%) (14.3) (3.6) (14.3) (35.7) (17.8) 1931–40 4 4 --914 10 13 (n=54) (7.4%) (7.4) (16.7) (25.9) (18.5) (24.1) 1941–50 2 4 5 3 3 11 9 11 (n=48) (4.2%) (8.3) (10.4) (6.3) (6.3) (22.9) (18.7) (22.9) 1951–60 9 10 1 3 5 20 14 16 (n=78) (11.5%) (12.8) (1.3) (3.8) (6.4) (25.7) (18.0) (20.5) 1961–70 1 11 4 6 31 36 29 34 (n=152) (0.7%) (7.2) (2.6) (3.9) (20.4) (23.7) (19.1) (22.4) 1971–80 6 23 2 9 42 40 64 55 (n=241) (2.5%) (9.6) (0.8) (3.7) (17.4) (16.6) (26.6) (22.8) 1981–90 9 10 9 26 46 41 81 69 (n=291) (3.1%) (3.5) (3.1) (8.9) (15.8) (14.1) (27.8) (23.7) 1991–2000b 16 20 12 15 37 36 101 116 (n=353) (4.5%) (5.7) (3.4) (4.2) (10.5) (10.2) (28.6) (32.9)

a Includes books, articles, book chapters (or portions of at least 5 pp.), introductions to primary materials, pamphlets, and dissertations (see Table 2). Excludes book reviews, reprints, dictionary/ encyclopedia entries, newspaper articles, and passing references. b Incomplete data for this decade.

Mencken and Clarence Darrow vied against superstition and ignorance as personiﬁed in the pious hypocrisy of Puritanism. Academically, it was the Calvinist-denigrating work of Vernon Parrington that prevailed, in which Edwards was an “anachronism.”5 However, a change was in the wind even in the 1920s as Harvard historians Kenneth Murdock and Samuel Eliot

5 Clarence Darrow, “The Edwardses and the Jukeses,” American Mercury 6 (Oct. 1925) 147–57; Vernon Parrington, Main Currents in American Thought, vol. 1, The Colonial Mind, 1620–1800 (New York: Harcourt, Brace, & Co., 1927) 148–63. 662 journal of the evangelical theological society

Table 2. Dissertations on Jonathan Edwards, 1890–2000 Homiletics Revivalism/ Great Awakening Missiology Ethics/ Aesthetics Literature/ Cultural Criticism Philosophy/ Psychology History/ Biography Theology 1890–1900 -----1-- (n=1) 1901–10 ---1-2-- (n=3) 1911–20 ------12 (n=3) 1921–30 ------12 (n=3) 1931–40 1- - - 1225 (n=11) 1941–50 ---1-335 (n=12) 1951–60 32- 12544 (n=20) 1961–70 121651059 (n=39) 1971–80 - 1 - - 13151515 (n=59) 1981–90 54161072012 (n=65) 1991–2000* 24365121325 (n=70)

Sources: M. X. Lesser, Jonathan Edwards: A Reference Guide (Boston: G. K. Hall, 1981); idem., Jonathan Edwards: An Annotated Bibliography, 1979–1993 (Westport, CT: Greenwood, 1994); Sean Michael Lucas, “Jonathan Edwards Between Church and Academy: A Bibliographical Es- say,” in D. G. Hart et al., eds., The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards: American Religion and the Evan- gelical Tradition (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003) 228–48; America: History and Life Online; ATLA Religion Database; UMI Digital Dissertations; WorldCat.

Morison began rehabilitating the Puritans, followed, of course, by Perry Miller with his New England Mind and 1949 biography of Edwards.6 An-

6 Kenneth Murdock, Increase Mather, the Foremost American Puritan (Cambridge: Harvard Uni- versity Press, 1925), and Handkerchiefs from Paul, being pious and consolatory verses of Puritan jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 663

other valley of inactivity was the early 1940s, not because of a lack of interest in Edwards but because of the interruption presented by World War II and its aftermath. Here, the microcosm of Edwards studies reﬂected scholarship in the humanities as a whole.

ii. homiletics

Now we can turn to discussing each of the categories, beginning with Ho- miletics, by which I intend studies on Edwards’s preaching style, on specific sermons, or on his sermons as a whole. The late eighteenth and the nineteenth century saw a small though consistent number of pieces on the nature of pulpit oratory, the American clergy, and American sermonic literature that either focused on Edwards or in which he figured significantly. As the twentieth century moved on, there was some overlap between this category and others, particularly Literature. More recently, we have seen an upswing caused, we can surmise, by the increasing availability of sermons in the Ed- wards Works and elsewhere. Literary scholars— especially Wilson Kimnach and Helen Westra7—have shown the way in mining Edwards’s sermons, whether dealing with Edwards’s theory of preaching or using sermons as a source for plumbing his thoughts on a particular practice or topic. I cannot consider preaching without bringing in Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God. Studies of “the most famous sermon in American history” form a sub-industry. If we look for new editions of the text itself as well as commentary on it in the first half of the century, we find only occasional reprints, from places like Paducah, Kentucky, or Fort Worth, Texas.8 Then,

Massachusetts . . . (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1927); Samuel Eliot Morison, Builders of the Bay Colony (Boston: Houghton Mifﬂin, 1930), and The Puritan Pronaos: Studies in the In- tellectual Life of New England in the Seventeenth Century (New York: New York University Press, 1936); Perry Miller, The New England Mind: The Seventeenth Century (Cambridge: Harvard Uni- versity Press, 1939), The New England Mind: From Colony to Province (Cambridge: Harvard Uni- versity Press, 1953), and Jonathan Edwards (New York: Sloane, 1949). 7 Wilson H. Kimnach, “Jonathan Edwards’s Sermon Mill,” Early American Literature 10 (Fall 1975) 167–77; “Jonathan Edwards’s Early Sermons: New York, 1722–1723,” Journal of Presbyterian History 55 (1977) 255–56; “The Brazen Trumpet: Jonathan Edwards’s Conception of the Sermon,” in Jonathan Edwards: His Life and Inﬂuence, ed. Charles Angoff (Rutherford, NJ: Fairleigh Dick- inson University Press, 1975) 29–44; The Works of Jonathan Edwards, 10, Sermons and Discourses, 1720–1723 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1992). For some of the scholarship of Helen P. Westra, see “Jonathan Edwards’s Sermons: Search for ‘Acceptable Words,’ ” American Theological Library Association, Proceedings 38 (1984) 102–16; The Minister’s Task and Calling in the Sermons of Jonathan Edwards (Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen, 1986); “Jonathan Edwards and the Scope of Gospel Ministry,” Calvin Theological Journal 22 (April 1987) 68–90; “Jonathan Edwards on ‘Faith- ful and Successful Ministers,’ ” Early American Literature 23 (Winter 1988) 281–90; “ ‘Above All Others’: Jonathan Edwards and the Gospel Ministry,” American Presbyterians 67 (Fall 1989) 209– 19; “Cornerstones, Cannons, and Covenants,” Pro Rege 19 (Sept. 1990) 24–31; “Jonathan Ed- wards and ‘What Reason Teaches,’ ” JETS 34 (1991) 495–503. 8 The sermon was reprinted under its title by the Baptist Tabernacle of Paducah, KY, c. 1930– 39 and by the Presbyterian Board of Publication of Philadelphia, c. 1920–29; Short Sketches of the Life and Service of Jonathan Edwards, Including His Great Sermon Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God . . . (Fort Worth, TX: A. J. Edwards, 1922). 664 journal of the evangelical theological society

Edwin Cady published his “Artistry of Jonathan Edwards” in the New En- gland Quarterly in 1949,9 the same year as Miller’s biography. While Miller downplayed Sinners because he wanted to suppress the popular fire-and- brimstone image of Edwards, Cady centered on the sermon to show how Edwards masterfully combined images of suspension and suppression. The article was the standard statement for more than two decades. By the 1960s, Sinners was the proxy for Edwards in high school and college textbooks and anthologies. In more recent textbooks, Sinners is printed alongside “sweeter” texts, such as Personal Narrative or A Divine and Super- natural Light. In fact, the newest version of the Norton Anthology of Ameri- can Literature contains precisely these three texts. Carla Mulford’s Early American Writings has Sinners, Personal Narrative, and an excerpt from Dis- tinguishing Marks, while Andrew Delbanco, in Writing New England, keeps Personal Narrative but replaces Sinners with The Spider Letter—apparently we cannot wholly do without Edwards’s spiders.10 In the wider field of publishing, it was not until the beginning of the 1970s that we find a notable increase in the reproduction of Sinners, with ten re- printings and commentaries. The number rose to nineteen in the 1980s, and in the last decade rose still further to at least two dozen,11 as small religious presses issued reprints and recommendations, though with some concessions to new generations, as in the “made easier to read” version printed in 1996. But that’s a practice that goes back to at least 1826.12

iii. revivalism

Recommendations and studies of Edwards on Revivalism, on his involve- ment in the Great Awakening, and on his inﬂuence on revivals in subsequent history populate the next category, which, like Homiletics, stretches back to the late eighteenth century. While there was an interesting rise in the number of pieces on this topic in the 1950s and ’60s, the ’70s saw a doubling of occurrences. We can speculate that the Bicentennial of 1976 was a spur for work in this area, as studies appeared linking the revolution and religion.13 Also, we should note the publication of the fourth volume, The Great Awak- ening, in the Edwards Edition in 1972, which both spurred and reﬂected

9 Edwin H. Cady, “The Artistry of Jonathan Edwards,” New England Quarterly 22 (Mar. 1949) 61–72. 10 Carla Mulford et al., eds., Early American Writings (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002); Andrew Delbanco, Writing New England: An Anthology from the Puritans to the Present (Cam- bridge: Belknap, 2001). 11 Reprints and commentary on Sinners by decade: 1890s: 1, 1900s: 0, 1910s: 0, 1920s: 4, 1930s: 1, 1940s: 1, 1950s: 4, 1960s: 2, 1970s: 10, 1980s: 19, 1990s: 24. 12 John Jeffrey Fanella, Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God: Made Easier to Read (Phillips- burg, NJ: Presbyterian & Reformed, 1996; Daniel A. Clark, Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God. A Sermon, By the Venerated President Edwards, Rewritten, So as to Retain His Thoughts in a Modern Style (Amherst, 1826). 13 For example, Nathan O. Hatch, The Sacred Cause of Liberty: Republican Thought and the Millennium in Revolutionary New England (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1977); Religion and the American Revolution (ed. Jerald C. Brauer; Philadelphia: Fortress, 1976). jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 665 work in this category. (Incidentally, volumes relating to revival, both The Great Awakening and volume 2, Religious Affections, together remain the best-selling in the Edition.) Books by historians such as Edwin Gaustad, Cedric Cowing, J. M. Bumsted and John De Wetering, David Lovejoy, and David Harlan, among others, created something of a heyday for studies of the Great Awakening.14 These more historical approaches to the role of religion in the formation of America were juxtaposed by a smaller, avowedly religious literature recommending Edwards’s thought and example as the basis for a new revival, as in magazines such as Christianity Today and Moody Monthly, and in books and articles by Iain Murray, Martin Lloyd-Jones, and Richard Lovelace.15

iv. missiology

Studies of Edwards and Missiology—most often relating to his acquain- tance with David Brainerd and the publication of his journals—lay dormant for a number of decades. But while The Life of David Brainerd has never gone out of print, commentary certainly did. This inactivity stretched back to the 1830s, when hundreds of male and female seminarians ﬂocked to domestic and foreign mission ﬁelds, with Edwards and Brainerd as inspirations. Start- ing in the 1940s, though, there were signs of life, apparently caused by renewed interest in the connection between revivalism and the missionary movement; by the bicentenary in 1948 and 1949, respectively, of the publications of the Humble Attempt and The Life of David Brainerd; and by a new biography of Brainerd with the titillating title, Flagellant on Horseback.16 Such pieces formed a more traditional counterpoint to the “modern” Edwards of Miller’s biography or Cady’s essay. Over the past two decades Missiology has attracted increasing attention, due to a number of factors, including Joseph Conforti and Norman Pettit’s work on Brainerd and on Edwards’s

14 Edwin Gaustad, The Great Awakening in New England (New York: Harper, 1957; repr. New York, 1972); Cedric B. Cowing, The Great Awakening and the American Revolution: Colonial Thought in the 18th Century (Chicago: Rand McNally, 1971); J. M. Bumsted and John E. Van de Wetering, What must I do to be saved? The Great Awakening in Colonial America (Hinsdale, IL: Dryden, 1976); David S. Lovejoy, Samuel Hopkins: Religion, Slavery, and the Revolution (Phila- delphia: United Church Press, 1976); David C. Harlan, The Clergy and the Great Awakening in New England (Ann Arbor: UMI Research Press, 1980). 15 Lynn Ray Wessell, “Great Awakening: The First American Revolution,” CT 17 (Aug. 31, 1973) 11–21; Mark R. Shaw, “The Spirit of 1740,” CT 20 (Jan. 2, 1976) 7–8; Howard Whaley, “The First Great Awakening,” Moody Monthly 75 (June 1976) 47–49; Iain H. Murray, The Puritan Hope: A Study in Revival and the Interpretation of Prophecy (London: Banner of Truth, 1971); Martyn D. Lloyd-Jones, “Jonathan Edwards and the Crucial Importance of Revival,” in The Puritan Exper- iment in the New World (Huntington, England: Westminster Conference, 1976) 103–21; Richard F. Lovelace, Dynamics of Spiritual Life: An Evangelical Theology of Renewal (Downers Grove, IL: Intervarsity, 1979). 16 John Foster, “The Bicentenary of Jonathan Edwards’s ‘Humble Attempt,’ ” International Re- view of Missions 37 (Oct. 1948) 375–81; Philip E. Howard, Jr., “A Biographical Sketch of the Life and Work of Jonathan Edwards,” in The Life and Diary of David Brainerd (Chicago: Moody, 1949); Richard Ellsworth Day, Flagellant on Horseback: The Life Story of David Brainerd (Philadelphia: Judson, 1950). 666 journal of the evangelical theological society

publication of his journals; Iain Murray’s biography of Edwards, ﬁrst seri- alized in The Banner of Truth; and Ronald Davies’s dissertation on Edwards’s missiological thought, the ﬁrst of its kind.17

v. ethics

When considering studies of Edwards’s Ethics and Aesthetics, we initially have the same story as Missiology: goose eggs up through 1940, then a slow rise afterwards with, notably, Clyde Holbrook’s dissertation in the 1940s, and Roland Delattre’s dissertation and pivotal book, Beauty and Sensibility in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards, in the 1960s.18 In the 1980s came a threefold increase that represented the highest occurrence since the 1850s, which had featured the Yale-Princeton debate over The Nature of True Virtue and commentary on the newly published Charity and Its Fruits.19 The 1980s, for its part, featured essays exploring Edwards’s aesthetics that picked up on Delattre, such as Terence Erdt’s book on Edwards, Art and the Sense of the Heart; comparisons of Edwards’s ethics with that of Augustine and Nie- buhr; and dissertations by Stephen Crocco on Joseph Haroutunian’s Piety vs. Moralism, a Neo-orthodox study of the rise and decline of the New Divin-

17 Joseph Conforti, “David Brainerd and the Nineteenth-Century Missionary Movement,” Journal of the Early Republic 5 (Fall 1985) 309–29; Conforti, “Jonathan Edwards’s Most Popular Work: ‘The Life of David Brainerd’ and Nineteenth-Century Evangelical Culture,” Church History 54 (June 1985) 188–201; Norman Pettit, ed., Works of Jonathan Edwards, vol. 7, The Life of David Brainerd (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1985; Pettit, “Prelude to Mission: Brainerd’s Expul- sion from Yale,” New England Quarterly 59 (Mar. 1986) 28–50; Iain H. Murray, Jonathan Edwards: A New Biography (Edinburgh: Banner of Truth, 1987); Ronald E. Davies, “ ‘Prepare Ye the Way of the Lord’: The Missiological Thought and Practice of Jonathan Edwards” (Ph.D. diss., Fuller The- ological Seminary, 1988). 18 Clyde Amos Holbrook, “The Ethics of Jonathan Edwards: A Critical Exposition and Analysis of the Relation of Morality and Religious Conviction in Edwardean Thought” (Ph.D. diss., Yale University, 1945); see also Holbrook, The Ethics of Jonathan Edwards (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1973). Roland André Delattre, “Beauty and Sensibility in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards: An Essay in Aesthetics and Ethics” (Ph.D. diss., Yale University, 1966), published as Beauty and Sensibility in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards: An Essay in Aesthetics and Theo- logical Ethics (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1968). 19 Titles from the 1850s relating to Edwards’s ethics include Edward Beecher, “Man the Image of God,” BSac 7 (July 1850) 409–25; William C. Wisner, “The End of God in Creation,” in Lives of Eminent Literary and Scientiﬁc Men of America (New York, 1850) 134–67; Tryon Edwards, Charity and Its Fruits; or, Christian Love as Manifested in the Heart and Life (London, 1852); Anonymous, “President Edwards on Charity and Its Fruits,” New Englander 10 (May 1852) 222–36; Archibald Alexander, Outlines of Moral Science (New York, 1852); Anonymous, “Dr. Alexander’s Moral Science,” BSac 10 (April 1853) 390–414; Anonymous, “President Edwards’s Dissertation on the Nature of True Virtue,” ibid. 10 (Oct. 1853) 705–38; Lyman H. Atwater, “Review of Outlines of Moral Science, by Archibald Alexander,” Biblical Repertory and Princeton Review 35 (Jan. 1853) 1–43; Albert T. Bledsoe, A Theodicy; or, Vindication of the Divine Glory, as Manifested in the Con- stitution and Government of the Moral World (New York, 1853); Atwater, “Jonathan Edwards and the Successive Forms of the New Divinity,” Biblical Repertory and Princeton Review 30 (Oct. 1857) 585–620.

Two Lines Short jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 667

ity, and by Virginia Peacock on problems in interpreting Edwards on true virtue.20 Despite this level of productivity, the 1990s saw a signiﬁcant drop in this category, for reasons not altogether clear at this close range. Nearly half of the studies on Edwards’s ethics and aesthetics completed in this decade were dissertations, the number of which has held constant for three decades. This is usually an indicator of a good showing in the coming decade. Another good indicator has been the interest in Edwards’s ethics in connection with the tercentenary: for example, several conference sessions on the theme; the recent issue of the Journal of Religious Ethics, devoted entirely to Edwards; and the impending completion of Stephen Wilson’s book, Virtue Reformed: Re-reading Edwards’s Ethics.21 Also, as instanced in Louis Mitchell’s 1995 Harvard dissertation and in selections in Paul Helm and Oliver Crisp’s newly edited collection, Jonathan Edwards, Philosophical Theologian,22 the concept of beauty, with implications for aesthetics and ecology, seems to be a topic continuing to attract attention.

vi. literary and cultural criticism

In Literature, Edwards studies suffered the same degradation as other areas through the 1930s, while in Cultural Criticism Edwards ﬁgured as a bogeyman, blamed, among other things, for the violent gangsterism of the

20 Terrence Erdt, Jonathan Edwards, Art and the Sense of the Heart (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1980); James M. Gustafson, Ethics from a Theocentric Perspective: Theology and Ethics (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1981); John M. Guret, “Introduction to the His- tory of Paul’s Aesthetic,” in The New Testament Student and His Field (ed. John H. Skilton and Curtiss A. Ladley; Phillipsburg, NJ: Presbyterian & Reformed, 1982); William C. Spohn, “The Rea- soning Heart: An American Approach to Christian Discernment,” Theological Studies 44 (Mar. 1983) 30–52; Thomas A. Byrnes, “H. Richard Niebuhr’s Reconstruction of Jonathan Edwards’s Moral Theology,” in Annual of the Society of Christian Ethics (ed. Alan B. Anderson; Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 1986) 33–55; Stephen D. Crocco, “American Theocentric Ethics: A Study in the Legacy of Jonathan Edwards” (Ph.D. diss., Princeton University, 1986); Virginia A. Peacock, “Problems in the Interpretations of Jonathan Edwards’s Nature of True Virtue” (Ph.D. diss., St. Michael’s College, 1987), published in Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen, 1990. 21 See Stephen A. Wilson, “The Virtue of the Saints: Jonathan Edwards on the Nature of Chris- tian Ethics” (Ph.D. diss., Stanford University, 1998). 22 See the Summer 2003 issue of The Journal of Religious Ethics with articles by Stephen A. Wilson, Gerald R. McDermott, William C. Spohn, Roland A. Delattre, and Philip L. Quinn. Louis J. Mitchell, “The Experience of Beauty in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards” (Th.D. diss., Harvard University, 1995; recently published in Studies in Reformed Theology and History 9 [2003]); Sam Storms, “Joy’s Eternal Increase: Edwards on the Beauty of Heaven,” unpublished paper, Oct. 2003 conference, “A God-Entranced Vision of All Things: The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards,” Minne- apolis, MN; Philip L. Quinn, “The Master Argument of The Nature of True Virtue,” in Helm and Crisp, eds., Jonathan Edwards, Philosophical Theologian 79–97. On eco-theology, Belden Lane of St. Louis University is working on a project tentatively entitled Nature as a School of Desire: Spir- ituality and Ecology in the Reformed Tradition that includes Edwards on beauty, desire, and the sensory world. For an earlier work on environmental theology also incorporating Edwards, see Richard C. Austin, Beauty of the Lord: Awakening the Senses (Atlanta: John Knox, 1988). 668 journal of the evangelical theological society

Prohibition Era.23 Nonetheless, Edwards remained a constant in overviews of American literature, and comparison with Benjamin Franklin was a sub- theme stretching back to Carl Van Doren and Van Wyck Brooks.24 But there were important literary scholars renovating Edwards’s reputation, including Thomas H. Johnson, who completed his dissertation during the ’30s and, with Clarence Faust, published Representative Selections of the Writings of Jonathan Edwards, the anthology that was the standard for six decades. Through the 1940s and ’50s, the Harvard group dominated Puritan and Ed- wards studies, through Miller, with Images and Shadows of Divine Things, and then his students, such as Edmund S. Morgan and Alan Heimert, the latter completing his dissertation in 1960.25 For literary scholars, the 1960s were a boom time. The number of studies in this category increased sixfold over the previous decade, and the relative percentage was never higher. The poetry of Edward Taylor was published; a new journal, Early American Literature, was begun; and it was the golden age of the study of typology. Heimert published his monumental, and mon- umentally misunderstood book, Religion and the American Mind, while dis- sertators such as Daniel Shea, Mason Lowance, and Thomas Davis focused on Edwards in their considerations of American self-disclosure, millennialism, and typology.26 In the 1970s, the number of dissertations on Edwards in this area peaked as students followed their mentors into the Edwards vineyard. However, new literary theorists, structuralists, post-structuralists, and de- constructionists have found less appeal in Edwards; signiﬁcantly, it took a philosopher, Stephen Daniel, to bring Foucault and Derrida to Edwards.27 By the 1980s, literary scholars were treating Edwards as a cultural icon. Donald Weber and David Laurence published essays on his literary reputation over the previous two centuries, while Max Lesser compiled the ﬁrst of

23 Struthers Burt, “Jonathan Edwards and the Gunman,” North American Review 227 (June 1929) 712–28. 24 Carl Van Doren, Benjamin Franklin and Jonathan Edwards: Selections from Their Writings (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1920); Van Wyck Brooks, America’s Coming-of-Age (New York: B. W. Huebsch, 1915). 25 Thomas H. Johnson, “Jonathan Edwards as a Man of Letters” (Ph.D. diss., Harvard University, 1934); Clarence H. Faust and Thomas H. Johnson, eds., Jonathan Edwards: Representative Se- lections (New York: American Book Co., 1935); Perry Miller, Images or Shadows of Divine Things (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1948); Miller, “Jonathan Edwards on the Sense of the Heart,” HTR 41 (Apr. 1948) 123–45; Miller, “Jonathan Edwards’s Sociology of the Great Awakening,” New England Quarterly 21 (Mar. 1948) 50–77; Alan E. Heimert, “American Oratory: From the Great Awakening to the Election of Jefferson” (Ph.D. diss., Harvard University, 1960). 26 Heimert, Religion and the American Mind: From the Great Awakening to the Revolution (Cam- bridge: Harvard University Press, 1966); Daniel B. Shea, Jr., “Spiritual Autobiography in Early America” (Ph.D. diss., Stanford University, 1966); Mason I. Lowance, Jr., “Images and Shadows of Divine Things: Puritan Typology in New England from 1600 to 1750” (Ph.D. diss., Emory Univer- sity, 1967); Thomas M. Davis, “The Traditions of Puritan Typology” (Ph.D. diss., University of Mis- souri, 1968). 27 Stephen H. Daniel, The Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards: A Study in Divine Semiotics (Bloom- ington: Indiana University Press, 1994).

Two Lines Short jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 669 his two bibliographies.28 Many recent literary studies on Edwards examine him as a spiritual biographer and autobiographer (particularly as reﬂected in the Personal Narrative). We also see some crossover between Literature and Homiletics, especially, again, with Sinners; for instance, the June 2000 issue of the New England Quarterly contained two articles on the one sermon.29 Over the past three decades, Literary and Cultural Criticism of Ed- wards had been slowly languishing, and there is little indication this trend will reverse anytime soon.

vii. philosophy

After the customary doldrums of the 1910s and ’20s, philosophical consid- eration of Edwards rose and remained dominant in Edwards studies (though not by much) from the 1930s to the 1960s. The effort to treat Edwards philo- sophically stemmed very much from the attitude of leading lights in Edwards studies, such as Miller, to win respect for Edwards by downplaying his Chris- tianity, to detach his philosophy from his theology, and make him appear more modern. Miller, as the founding general editor of the Works of Jonathan Ed- wards, was against publishing Edwards’s sermons and scriptural commentary in favor of the philosophical treatises. Besides Miller, with his paradigm- setting essays such as “From Edwards to Emerson,” key ﬁgures in this area were Rufus Suter treating Edwards on morality and on the “problem of evil”; Harvey Townsend and his Philosophy of Edwards, the ﬁrst work to make wide use of the “Miscellanies,” Edwards’s private notebooks; Clarence Faust on Edwards and human nature; John E. Smith, linking Edwards to pragma- tism; and Douglas Elwood, who published The Philosophical Theology of Jona- than Edwards in 1960, at the turning of the tide.30 Numerically, studies in

28 Donald L. Weber, “The Image of Jonathan Edwards in American Culture” (Ph.D. diss., Colum- bia University, 1978); Weber, “The Figure of Jonathan Edwards,” American Quarterly 35 (Winter 1983) 556–64; David Laurence, “Jonathan Edwards as a Figure in Literary History,” in Nathan O. Hatch and Harry S. Stout, eds., Jonathan Edwards and the American Experience (New York: Ox- ford University Press, 1988) 226–45; Lesser, Jonathan Edwards: A Reference Guide. 29 Edward J. Gallagher, “ ‘Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God’: Some Unfinished Business,” and Christopher Lukasik, “Felling the Force of Certainty: The Divine Science, Newtonianism, and Jonathan Edwards’s ‘Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God,’ ” New England Quarterly 73 (June 2000) 202–21, 222–45. 30 Miller, “From Edwards to Emerson,” New England Quarterly 13 (Dec. 1940) 589–617; Rufus O. Suter, Jr., “The Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards” (Ph.D. diss., Harvard University, 1932); Suter, “The Concept of Morality in the Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards,” Journal of Religion 14 (July 1934) 265–72; Suter, “The Problem of Evil in the Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards,” Monist 44 (July 1934) 280–95; Suter, “An American Pascal: Jonathan Edwards,” Scientific Monthly 68 (May 1949) 338–42; Harvey G. Townsend, ed., The Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards from His Private Note- books (Eugene: Oregon University Press, 1955); Clarence H. Faust, “Jonathan Edwards’s View of Human Nature” (Ph.D. diss., University of Chicago, 1935); John E. Smith, ed., Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 2, Religious Affections (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1959); Douglas J. Elwood, The Philosophical Theology of Jonathan Edwards (New York: Columbia University Press, 1960). 670 journal of the evangelical theological society philosophy have been going up slightly since then, with a bit of a tailing off in 1990s. However, the relative percentage of this category has fallen from one quarter of the field in the 1950s to only one-tenth in the last decade.

viii. history

The precipitous drop in Philosophy leads us to our final categories. It is clear that the two disciplinary groups that are dominating Edwards in the academy today are History and Theology. I characterize historical commentary by a secular or undisclosed religious approach to Edwards that considers him strictly in context, with an intended audience of other professional historians and scholars in related fields, usually applying a historical method or typology, most often traditional intellectual history or some form of social history, but also extending to studies of Edwards from post-modern perspectives such as feminist studies or body theory. Theology takes in the constructive, polemical, pastoral, and ecclesiological, usually with an obvious presentist or commendatory approach or disclosed religious intent, aimed primarily though not exclusively at religious or churchly audiences. Some works in this category are based on criteria such as the writer’s educational background, institutional and denominational affiliation, or the issuing journal or press. There is obviously some overlap, some cross-fertilization, between these two categories, which is encouraging because it is the relationship between these two groups, I gather, that will set the course of Edwards Studies for the near future. For historical interpretation of Edwards, the 1960s was a period of doubled numerical growth over the previous decade. But the most significant increase was from the ’60s to the ’70s, when historiography for the first time outpaced Theology and Philosophy, climbing from one-fifth in relative percentage to over one quarter. The historiographical juggernaut was fueled by revolutionary, revisionist methods: the New Social history, family studies, ethnography, cliometrics, and the long train of hyphenated histories. The 1980s continued this trend, with the publication of landmark books such as Patricia Tracy’s Jonathan Edwards, Pastor and Norman Fiering’s Edwards’s Moral Thought and Its British Context.31 This period also saw a spate of dissertations and monographs on a range of Edwardsean and neo-Edwardsean topics by Ava Chamberlain, Allen Guelzo, Jack Fitzmier, Mark Valeri,32 and a generation

31 Patricia J. Tracy, Jonathan Edwards, Pastor: Religion and Society in Eighteenth-Century Northampton (New York: Hill & Wang, 1980); Norman Fiering, Jonathan Edwards’s Moral Thought and Its British Context (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1981). 32 Mary Ava Chamberlain, “Jonathan Edwards Against the Antinomians and Arminians” (Ph.D. diss., Columbia University, 1990); Allen C. Guelzo, “The Unanswered Question: The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards’s Freedom of the Will in Early American Religious Philosophy” (Ph.D. diss., University of Pennsylvania, 1986), published as Edwards on the Will: A Century of American Theological Debate (Middletown: Wesleyan University Press, 1989); John R. Fitzmier, “The Godly Federalism of Timothy Dwight, 1752–1817: Society, Doctrine, and Religion in the Life of New En- gland’s ‘Moral Legislator’ ” (Ph.D. diss., Princeton University, 1986), published as New England’s Moral Legislator: Timothy Dwight, 1752–1817 (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1998); Mark jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 671

of younger scholars who have been pumping out books and articles on an ever- increasing range of topics and disciplines, from ethnicity and race to gender and sexual mores to the life cycle and speech patterns. Inﬂuences on Edwards are an important topic among historians, but not as important as Edwards’s legacies. Since the 1980s and the work of Mark Noll, William Breitenbach, and Joseph Conforti,33 an interest in reassessing the nature and evolution of the New Divinity through the nineteenth century has led to a burgeoning literature that includes Conforti’s more recent work; Bruce Kuklick’s New-Divinity centered canon of American philosophy from Edwards to Dewey; Genevieve McCoy on the Oregon Mission; David Kling on Edwardsean and Hopkinsian revivals in northwestern Connecticut; Amanda Porterﬁeld on Mary Lyon and Mt. Holyoke Seminary; and Douglas Sweeney on Nathaniel William Taylor.34

ix. theology

Even during the height of Philosophy in the 1930s, there were signiﬁ- cant Neo-orthodox theological works that used Edwards, such as H. Richard Niebuhr’s Kingdom of God in America, or Haroutunian’s on the “ossiﬁcation”

R. Valeri, “Joseph Bellamy: Conversion, Social Ethics, and Politics in the Thought of an Eighteenth- Century Calvinist” (Ph.D. diss., Princeton University, 1985), published as Law and Providence in Joseph Bellamy’s New England: The Origins of the New Divinity in Revolutionary America (New York: Oxford University Press, 1994). 33 Mark A. Noll, “Moses Mather (Old Calvinist) and the Evolution of Edwardseanism,” Church History 49 (Sept. 1979) 273–85; Noll, “Jonathan Edwards and Nineteenth-Century Philosophy,” in Hatch and Stout, eds., Jonathan Edwards and the American Experience 260–87; Noll, “The Con- tested Legacy of Jonathan Edwards in Antebellum Calvinism: Theological Conflict and the Evo- lution of Thought in America,” Canadian Review of American Studies 19 (Summer 1988) 149–64; William Breitenbach, “Unregenerate Doings: Selflessness and Selfishness in New Divinity Theol- ogy,” American Quarterly 34 (Winter 1982) 479–502; Breitenbach, “The Consistent Calvinism of the New Divinity Movement,” William and Mary Quarterly 41 (Apr. 1984) 241–64; Breitenbach, “Piety and Moralism: Edwards and the New Divinity,” in Hatch and Stout, eds., Jonathan Ed- wards and the American Experience 177–204; Joseph A. Conforti, “Samuel Hopkins and the New Divinity: Theology, Ethics, and Social Reform in Eighteenth-Century New England,” William and Mary Quarterly 34 (Oct. 1977) 572–89; Conforti, Samuel Hopkins and the New Divinity Movement: Calvinism, the Congregational Ministry, and Reform in New England between the Great Awaken- ings (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1981). 34 Conforti, “Mary Lyon, the Founding of Mount Holyoke College, and the Cultural Revival of Jonathan Edwards,” Religion and American Culture 3 (Winter 1993) 69–89; Conforti, “The Inven- tion of the Great Awakening,” Early American Literature 26 (Fall 1991) 99–118; Conforti, Jonathan Edwards, Religious Tradition, and American Culture (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1995); Bruce Kuklick, Churchmen and Philosophers: From Jonathan Edwards to John Dewey (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1985); Genevieve E. McCoy, “Sanctifying the Self and Saving the Savage: The Failure of the ABCFM Oregon Mission and the Conflicted Language of Calvinism” (Ph.D. diss., University of Washington, 1991); David W. Kling, A Field of Divine Wonders: The New Divinity and Village Revivals in Northwestern Connecticut, 1792–1822 (Uni- versity Park: Penn State Press, 1993); Amanda Porterfield, Mary Lyon and the Mount Holyoke Missionaries (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997); Douglas A. Sweeney, Nathaniel William Taylor, New Haven Theology, and the Legacy of Jonathan Edwards.

672 journal of the evangelical theological society

of the New Divinity.35 Yet theological considerations of Edwards languished over the next two decades as the philosophers continued to dominate. In the 1970s, Theology finally overtook Philosophy and continued to increase, second only to History. But behold the 1990s when there was nearly double the output over the previous decade, surpassing even History for the first time in thirty years. One major influential study to come out in the late 1980s, which helped to spur this movement, was Sang Hyun Lee’s Philosophical Theology of Ed- wards, with its identification of Edwards’s dispositional ontology.36 Another important figure in the study of Edwards’s theology produced on a grand scale during this period: John Gerstner published his three-volume Rational Bib- lical Theology of Jonathan Edwards, culminating a string of articles and small books.37 Scholars and religious leaders who benefited from works like these, and from the increasing availability of Edwards’s own writings, included Michael McClymond, Gerry McDermott, Anri Morimoto, Amy Plan- tinga Pauw, John Piper, and Richard Sproul.38 Meanwhile, comparative studies returned: familiar couplings like Edwards and Wesley or Berkeley, but also Edwards and Loyola, Bonaventura, van Balthazar, and Schleierma- cher that ranged over time, topic, and theological tradition.39 Semi-systematic studies and considerations of single doctrines, such as the Trinity, justification, atonement, and hell, figured significantly—continued today, for example, in Steve Nichols’s dissertation-cum-monograph on Edwards on the Holy

35 H. Richard Niebuhr, The Kingdom of God in America (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1937); Joseph G. Haroutunian, Piety Versus Moralism: The Passing of the New England Theology (New York: Henry Holt & Co., 1932). 36 Sang Hyun Lee, The Philosophical Theology of Jonathan Edwards (Princeton: Princeton Uni- versity Press, 1988; repr. 2000). 37 John H. Gerstner, The Rational Biblical Theology of Jonathan Edwards (3 vols.; Orlando, FL: Ligonier Ministries, 1991–93). See also Steps to Salvation: The Evangelistic Message of Jonathan Edwards (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1960), reprinted as Jonathan Edwards: Evangelist (Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 1995); Jonathan Edwards on Heaven and Hell (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1980), reprinted Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 1998); Jonathan Edwards: A Mini-Theology (Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House, 1987). 38 Michael J. McClymond, Encounters With God: An Approach to the Theology of Jonathan Ed- wards (New York: Oxford University Press, 1998); Gerald R. McDermott, One Holy and Happy Society: The Public Theology of Jonathan Edwards (University Park: Pennsylvania State Univer- sity Press, 1992); McDermott, Jonathan Edwards Confronts the Gods: Christian Theology, En- lightenment Religion, and Non-Christian Faiths (New York: Oxford University Press, 2000); Anri Morimoto, Jonathan Edwards and the Catholic Vision of Salvation (University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1995); Amy Plantinga Pauw, “ ‘The Supreme Harmony of All’: Jonathan Edwards and the Trinity” (Ph.D. diss., Yale University, 1990); John Piper, God’s Passion for His Glory: With the Complete Text from “The End for Which God Created the World” by Jonathan Ed- wards (Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 1998); Richard C. Sproul and Archie Parrish, The Spirit of Revival: Discovering the Wisdom of Jonathan Edwards (Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2000). 39 William C. Spohn, “Jonathan Edwards and Ignatius Loyola,” in Finding God in All Things: Essays in Honor of Michael J. Buckley (ed. Michael J. Himes and Stephen J. Pope; New York: Cross- road, 1996); Nicola Anne Hoggard-Creegan, “The Grammar of Freedom: Edwards and Schleier- macher” (Ph.D. diss., Drew University, 1992); Matthew T. Mathews, “Toward a Holistic Theological Anthropology: Jonathan Edwards and Friedrich Schleiermacher on Religious Affections” (Ph.D. diss., Emory University, 2000). jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 673

Spirit.40 And studies of Edwards on the nature of the church—ecclesiology, sacraments, and psalmody—were also evident as never before.41 In the late 1980s and through the 1990s, Edwards was “appropriated” for constructive theology and church growth on an unprecedented scale. Robert Jenson’s America’s Theologian of 1988 was suggestively subtitled A Recom- mendation of Jonathan Edwards—a recommendation from a Lutheran, no less. A sampling of more recent titles will further illustrate the point: one dissertation claimed him “as a resource for current evangelical discussion,” the author of an article looked to him for lessons for “the future of Reformed theology,” while a 1996 conference in Philadelphia and the ensuing book of essays was entitled Edwards in Our Time.42 Th.Ds, Ph.Ds, articles, and handbooks, oriented to pastor and church leaders, treat Edwards as a model for preaching, as an expert on the signs of grace and revival, on delineating gender roles in the church, on family issues, and on Christian education.43

40 Stephen R. Holmes, “The Justice of Hell and the Display of God’s Glory in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards,” Pro Ecclesia 9 (Fall 2000) 389–403; John E. Colwell, “The Glory of God’s Jus- tice and the Glory of God’s Grace: Contemporary Reflections on the Doctrine of Hell in the Teach- ing of Jonathan Edwards,” EQ 67 (Oct. 1995); Bruce W. Davidson, “Reasonable Damnation: How Jonathan Edwards Argued for the Rationality of Hell,” JETS 38 (Mar. 1995) 47–56; Bruce M. Stephens, “An Appeal to the Universe: The Doctrine of the Atonement in American Protestant Thought from Jonathan Edwards to Edwards Amasa Park,” Encounter 60 (Winter 1999) 55–72; Kevin W. Kang, “Justified by Faith in Christ: Jonathan Edwards’s Doctrine of Justification in Light of Union with Christ” (Ph.D. diss., Westminster Theological Seminary, 2003); Stephen Nichols, An Absolute Sort of Certainty. See also Robert W. Caldwell, “The Holy Spirit as the Bond of Union in the Theology of Jonathan Edwards” (Ph.D. diss., Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, 2003). 41 David Rightmire, “The Sacramental Theology of Jonathan Edwards in the Context of Con- troversy,” Fides et Historia 21 (Jan. 1989) 50–60; Richard A. S. Hall, The Neglected Northampton Text of Jonathan Edwards: Edwards on Society and Politics (Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen, 1990); Rowena R. Jones, “Edwards, Dickinson, and the Sacramentality of Nature,” Studies in Puritan American Spirituality 1 (Dec. 1990) 225–53; “Editor’s Introduction,” in Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 12, Ecclesiastical Writings (ed. David D. Hall; New Haven: Yale University Press, 1994); William J. Danaher, Jr., “By Sensible Signs Represented: Jonathan Edwards’s Sermons on the Lord’s Supper,” Pro Ecclesia 7 (Summer 1998) 261–87; Mark F. Williams, “The Lord’s Supper and New Divinity: Post-Edwardsean Theology and Practice in the Context of the Colonial Puritan Tra- dition of New England” (Ph.D. diss., 1999). 42 Robert Jenson, America’s Theologian: A Recommendation of Jonathan Edwards (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988); Brandon G. Withrow, “Jonathan Edwards as a Resource for Cur- rent Evangelical Discussion Over the Language of the Doctrine of Justification” (Ph.D. diss., Trin- ity Evangelical Divinity School, 1999); Amy Plantinga Pauw, “The Future of Reformed Theology: Some Lessons From Jonathan Edwards,” in David Willis-Watkins and Michael Welker, Toward the Future of Reformed Theology: Tasks, Topics, Traditions (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans 1999) 456–69; Sang H. Lee and Allen C. Guelzo, eds., Edwards in Our Time: Jonathan Edwards and the Shap- ing of American Religion (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1999). 43 F. Allan Story, “Promoting Revival: Jonathan Edwards and Preparation for Revival” (Ph.D. diss., 1994); Gary Benfold et al., God at Work? Signs of True Revival (London: Grace Pub. Trust, 1995); Young H. Lee, “The Matter of Past Great Awakenings in American and Future Awakening: Renewed Preacher and Renewed Preaching” (Ph.D. diss., Columbia Theological Seminary, 1995); Robert W. Caldwell, “Pastoral Care for the Converting: Jonathan Edwards’s Pastoral Cure of Soul in Light of the Puritan Doctrine of Preparation” (Ph.D. diss., Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, 1997); Mark A. Shady, “Testing Revival Experience: The Nature of Sign of the Work of God’s Spirit as Expressed in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards” (Ph.D. diss., Denver Seminary, 1997); 674 journal of the evangelical theological society

Relatedly, polemical use of Edwards returned in a way not seen since the nineteenth century, as leaders of charismatic movements such as the Toronto Blessing used Edwards to legitimate their claims, while critics used Edwards to discredit them.44

x. recent areas of interest and areas to be encouraged

Next, I would like to touch on just a few topics that seem to be attracting attention today. I have already attempted a prognosis for ethics. A salient topic is Edwards’s trinitarianism, epitomized by Amy Plantinga Pauw’s 2002 monograph, The Supreme Harmony of One, really the ﬁrst full-length con- sideration of Edwards on the Trinity since the days of George Park Fisher. Virtually coincident with the appearance of this book, however, were no less than three new dissertations on the same theme, as well as an article in the Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society.45 This concentration of studies, along with related research, seems to presage interest in Edwards’s doctrine of God. Another area is Edwards’s view of “history,” or teleology, as enunciated especially in A History of the Work of Redemption. Robert E. Brown’s Jona- than Edwards and the Bible, despite the title, is very much about Edwards’s engagement with historical criticism. Avi Zakai, of the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, has written a monograph on Edwards’s Philosophy of History that treats Edwards’s views of time and space. In the introduction to volume 22 of the Edwards Works, and in a collection of essays on The Legacy of Ed- wards, Harry Stout has pointed to the History of the Work of Redemption as

E. M. Hartman, “Seeking in the Evangelism of Jonathan Edwards” (Th.M. diss., Dallas Theologi- cal Seminary, 1998); Doreen Moore, “Jonathan Edwards: Ministry and the Life of the Family,” Ref- ormation & Revival 4 (Summer 1995) 99–120; Beth A. McDermott, “Jonathan Edwards and the Redeﬁnition of American Masculinity: From the Power of Fathers to the Power of Men” (M.A. thesis, University of New Hampshire, 1998); B. Edwards, Men, Women, and Authority: Serving Together in the Church (Bromley, Kent: Day One, 1996); T. M. Moore, “A Brief Introduction to an Edwardsean View of Christian Instruction,” Presbyterion 25 (Spring 1999) 21–31. 44 Bruce Hindmarsh, “The ‘Toronto Blessing’ and the Protestant Evangelical Awakening of the Eighteenth Century Compared,” Crux (Dec. 1995) 3–13; James A. Beverly, Revival Wars: A Cri- tique of Counterfeit Revival (Pickering, Canada: Evangelical Research Ministries, 1997); John D. Hannah, “Jonathan Edwards, the Toronto Blessing, and the Spiritual Gifts: Are the Extraordinary Ones Actually the Ordinary Ones?” TJ 17 (Fall 1996) 167–89. 45 Pauw, “The Supreme Harmony of All”: The Trinitarian Theology of Jonathan Edwards; Rachel S. Stahle, “The Trinitarian Spirit of Jonathan Edwards’s Theology” (Ph.D. diss., Gordon- Conwell Seminary, 1999); Richard M. Webber, “The Trinitarian Theology of Jonathan Edwards: An Investigation of Charges Against Its Orthodoxy,” JETS 44 (June 2001) 297–318; William J. Danaher, Jr., “The Trinitarian Ethics of Jonathan Edwards” (Ph.D. diss., Yale University, 2002); Steven M. Studebaker, “Jonathan Edwards’s Social Augustinian Trinitarianism: A Criticism of and an Alternative to Recent Interpretations” (Ph.D. diss., Marquette University, 2003); Allen R. Baird, “The ‘Psychological Analogy’ of the Doctrine of the Trinity: A Comparative Study” (Ph.D. diss., Queen’s University of Belfast, 2001). jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 675

Edwards’s intended magnum opus in which he would have thrown systematic theology into the form of a “tri-world” narrative. And at conferences this year Michael McClymond and Sang Hyun Lee addressed related themes.46 Still another area is exegesis or scriptural commentary. In 2001 alone, at least two seminary students completed their dissertations on some aspect of Edwards’s exegetical method.47 Here we need to mention Bob Brown’s ex- cellent book again, as well as Douglas Sweeney’s new work-in-progress on “Edwards the Exegete.” The spring 2003 conference at Princeton included a session on exegesis featuring Brown, Sweeney, and of course Stephen J. Stein, who has done the most to make Edwards’s body of commentary available. Not only has he edited “Notes on the Apocalypse” and “Notes on Scrip- ture,” but he has just completed the draft of the “Interleaved Bible” that amounts to almost 2,500 pages in typescript—a huge repository of largely untapped scriptural exposition.48 There are also a couple of areas that beg further exploration. The ﬁrst is Edwards’s sojourn at Stockbridge, his efforts to make the mission succeed, and his interaction with the Mahicans, Mohawks, and Iroquois.49 With the publication of Edwards’s collected letters in the Edwards Works,50 the increasing availability of sermons, and the growing number of studies in the larger ﬁeld, this period of Edwards’s career can be approached in different ways. Most recently, the surge of interest in Euro-Indian contact, negotiated iden- tity, and geographical and cultural “middle grounds” has helped to draw scholars to Edwards, for example, in studies of the missiology of the “Interleaved Bible” and on Edwardsean spirituality in the nineteenth-century mission to

46 Brown, Jonathan Edwards and the Bible; Avihu Zakai, Jonathan Edwards’s Philosophy of History; Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 22, Sermons and Discourses, 1738–1743 (ed. Harry S. Stout and Nathan O. Hatch; New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003) 3–47; Stout, “Jonathan Edwards’s Tri-World Vision,” in D. G. Hart et al., eds., The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards: American Religion and the Evangelical Tradition 27–46; Michael McClymond, “A Different Legacy? The Cultural Turn in Edwards’s Later Notebooks and the Unwritten History of the Work of Redemp- tion,” unpublished paper, “Edwards the Theologian” conference, Princeton, April 2003; Sang Hyun Lee, “Does History Matter to God? Edwards’s Dynamic Reconception of God’s Relation to the World,” unpublished paper, “Edwards at 300” conference, Washington, DC, Oct. 2003. See also David E. Clark, “ ‘Leveling Mountains, Drying Up Rivers’: Jonathan Edwards’s Historiography Applied” (Ph.D. diss., Westminster Theological Seminary, 2001); Michael D. Peters, “Jonathan Edwards’s Politicization of Millennialism” (Ph.D. diss., St. Louis University, 2000). 47 John Ayabe, “A Search for Meaning: Principles of Literal and Spiritual Exegesis in Jonathan Edwards’s ‘Notes on Scriptures’ ” (Ph.D. diss., Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, 2001); Glenn Kreider, “Jonathan Edwards’s Interpretation of Rev. 4:1–8:1” (Ph.D. diss., Dallas Theological Seminary, 2001). 48 The Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 5, Apocalyptic Writings, ed. Stephen J. Stein (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1977); ibid., volume 5, Notes on Scripture (1998); ibid., volume 24, The Blank Bible (forthcoming). 49 See Lyon Miles, “The Red Man Dispossessed: The Williams Family and the Alienation of In- dian Land in Stockbridge, Massachusetts, 1736–1818,” New England Quarterly 67 (Mar. 1994) 46–76. 50 Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 16, Letters and Personal Writings (ed. George S. Clag- horn; New Haven: Yale University Press, 1998). 676 journal of the evangelical theological society

the Nez Perce.51 Rachel Wheeler, in her Yale dissertation comparing the En- glish and Moravian missions, for the ﬁrst time systematically utilized Ed- wards’s Indian sermons; she has since set Edwards’s treatise on Original Sin in relation to his labors with native peoples.52 Finally, in his new biography George Marsden has utilized Edwards’s extant letters—some two- thirds of which date from the Stockbridge period—to give us a fuller picture. But there is still much to be done with the Stockbridge period, as with other periods. In this vein, let us consider sermons a little further. The sixth and last sermon volume in the Edwards Works, soon to be completed, will include Indian sermons as well as, for example, military sermons and a number of ordination sermons that, as editor Wilson Kimnach describes them, show Edwards forming a “heroic” view of the ministry.53 Other sermons on the ministry can be found in Salvation of Souls, edited by Richard Bailey and Gregory Wills. This collection is but one among several new collections of Edwards sermons, many previously unpublished, that have come out over the past couple of years, such as the ones edited by Bill Nichols, Michael McMullen, and Don Kistler.54 Together, these promise a continuing interest in Edwards the preacher. But there’s more. Even as dozens of sermons have become available in print, the Edwards Works is moving into a new phase to produce an online, comprehensive edition of Edwards’s writings, including the texts of the letterpress series and all of our unpublished transcripts, the bulk of which are the rest of Edwards’s 1,250 extant sermons.

xi. history vs. theology, history and theology

In closing, I would like to return to the two current leaders of the pack, Theology and History, or, to use my somewhat clumsy working terms, the

51 Keely E. McCarthy, “ ‘Reducing Them to Civilitie’: Religious Conversions and Cultural Trans- formations in Protestant Missionary Narratives, 1690–1790” (Ph.D. diss., University of Mary- land, College Park, 2000); Francis D. White, “The Reformation Roots and Edwardsean Fruits of the Missiology of Jonathan Edwards’s Interleaved Bible” (M.A. thesis, Westminster Theological Seminary, 1991); Genevieve McCoy, “The Women of the ABCFM Oregon Mission and the Con- ﬂicted Language of Calvinism,” Church History 64 (Mar. 1995) 62–82; Ronald E. Davies, Jona- than Edwards and His Inﬂuence on the Development of the Missionary Movement from Britain (Cambridge: Currents in World Christianity Project, 1996). 52 Rachel Wheeler, “Living Upon Hope: Mahicans and Missionaries, 1730–1760” (Ph.D. diss., Yale University, 1998); Wheeler, “Lessons From Stockbridge: Jonathan Edwards’s Indian Sermons,” unpublished paper, “Edwards at 300” conference, Washington, DC, Oct. 2003; Wheeler, “ ‘Friends to Your Souls’: Jonathan Edwards’s Indian Pastorate and the Doctrine of Original Sin,” Church History 72 (Dec. 2003) 736–65. 53 Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 26, Sermons and Discourses, 1743–1758 (ed. Wilson H. Kimnach; New Haven: Yale University Press, forthcoming). 54 Bailey and Wills, eds., The Salvation of Souls: Nine Previously Unpublished Sermons on the Call of Ministry and the Gospel by Jonathan Edwards; William C. Nichols, ed., Seeking God: Jona- than Edwards’s Evangelism Contrasted with Modern Methodologies (Ames, IA: International Out- reach, 2001); Nichols, ed., Knowing the Heart: Jonathan Edwards on True and False Conversion (Ames, IA: International Outreach, 2003); McMullen, ed., The Blessing of God: Previously Unpub- lished Sermons of Jonathan Edwards; Don Kistler, ed., Our Great and Glorious God: Jonathan Edwards, 1703–1758 (Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 2003); Kistler, ed., To All the Saints of God: Addresses to the Church, Jonathan Edwards, 1703–1758 (Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 2003). jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 677

“theologizers” and the “historicists.” There are many constituents of the two groups who have a foot in both camps, but between others at the extremes there is a divide. Some historicists look down on theologizers as partisan apol- ogists, hagiographers, even whitewashers; some theologizers resent historicists for secularizing Edwards, for reducing him to a tool in their “humanist agendas.” Both of these views are caricatures, but caricatures that endure. Evangelical scholars, seminarians, pastors, and religious leaders have taken up Edwards as a theologian, preacher, and revivalist in a way not seen since before the Civil War. During the ’90s, fully one-third of all printed commentary on Edwards was theological in nature, the highest in more than a century. Even more, over half of these theological considerations of Edwards appeared in evangelical publications. Until recently, major theological pieces on Edwards had been conﬁned largely to mainline journals like the Harvard Theological Review, Bibliotheca Sacra, or the Journal of Religion. Now, however, interpretive essays are regularly found in the Southern Baptist Theo- logical Journal, Evangelical Quarterly, Fides et Historia, Reformation and Revival, Trinity Journal, Westminster Theological Journal, or the Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society.55 Likewise, religious presses of all sizes have been churning out new editions of Edwards’s writings as well as monographs: from large houses such as InterVarsity and the Dutch trinity of Eerd- mans, Baker, and Zondervan, to smaller ones like Banner of Truth, Bethany House, Crossway, Presbyterian and Reformed, and Soli Deo Gloria. Reformed, evangelicals, and charismatics—the “new evangelicals” from across a broad (white) spectrum—have embraced Edwards like never before. Historicists, meanwhile, continue the search for the “historical Edwards,” primarily seeking to situate and understand him as a product and reﬂection of his time. For historians, Edwards’s “modernity” is now not as much a con- cern as are his Puritan heritage and his New England and Enlightenment contexts. But something interesting has emerged from this turn away from Edwards’s supposed “modernity,” the notion that thrived at mid-century that Edwards was actually a proto-naturalist, or a Lockean empiricist, or a prom- ising scientist forced to settle on a clerical career. Edwards undeniably had time-bound beliefs and practices that make him alien to today in many re- spects. But as Doug Sweeney writes in the latest issue of Books and Cul- ture, the Edwards of history, the Edwards that the historicists have been painstakingly uncovering for some time now, is proving to be a supernatu- ralist, a thoroughgoing theist, a tireless student of Scripture, a parish pastor with an evangelical passion. Yet, Sweeney continues, Edwards’s genius for

55 For example, a survey of journal articles on Edwards published during the 1990s shows, of 105 articles tallied, the following breakdown among types of journals: Evangelical: 64 (61.0%); Main- line: 7 (6.7%); Non-religious: 34 (32.3%). An indication that this trend will continue is that, of 32 dissertations on Edwards from 2001–2003, 14 were completed at state or secular private univer- sities, while 18 were completed at seminaries, schools of theology, or religiously affiliated institutions. Within this latter group, it is interesting to note that the two institutions supporting the most graduate work on Edwards (3 dissertations each) within these three years were Westminster Theological Seminary (Presbyterian) and Marquette University (Jesuit). 678 journal of the evangelical theological society yesterday and today “is best understood in relation to that very context” in which he lived and worked.56 It seems that, ironically and unawares, many historicists and theologizers, while eyeing each other suspiciously and perhaps condescendingly, have been working towards similar ends for some time. The motives and audiences may be different, but the pictures that are emerging from each side are re- markably similar. I might also add that the very porousness of the bound- aries between historical and theological considerations of Edwards is another indication of the similarity of perspectives and approaches among a core group of writers in these two groups. Another thing they share in common is that, whereas scholars in categories in decline, such as Literature and Philosophy, tend to rely on traditional texts, writers in History and Theology are making best use of the wealth of new texts that have become available. No one sub- group may ever be able to “claim” Edwards. But, given what we know about the ebb and flow of interest in Edwards within different circles over the past 100 years, that may be a good thing. Last year a conference held in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, was entitled “Ed- wards and the Future of Evangelicalism: A Conference Bringing Together the Church and the Academy.” Not Church vs. Academy, but Church and Academy. That’s the kind of conjunction we need to see more often, because it recognizes that scholars and practitioners in the two spheres can and should learn from each other. The number of secondary publications on Ed- wards fast approaches 4,000, making him one of the most studied figures in Christian thought and the most studied American intellectual figure before 1800. Those who would do serious, responsible interpretation on him face the increasingly daunting but necessary task of navigating that literature. The recent tomes by Noll on America’s God: From Edwards to Lincoln, or Brooks Holifield’s Theology in America57—in which Edwards is the only figure who warrants his own chapter—not to mention Marsden’s synthetic new biography of Edwards, provide different, commendable models for approaching Edwards. Commentators need to combine a rigor in and sensitivity to the disciplines and nuances of both history and theology, and to strive to present a judicious, rounded view of the positive and negative aspects of Edwards’s life, thought, and legacy—an Edwards for the twenty-first century.

xii. bibliography

The titles provided below are by no means an exhaustive bibliography of primary and secondary publications on Edwards, but are meant as an entrée into the literature. Titles are grouped under headings, though readers should be aware that many works partake of different disciplines.

56 Douglas A. Sweeney, “A Plentiful Harvest,” Books and Culture: A Christian Review (Nov./Dec. 2003) 42. 57 Mark A. Noll, America’s God: From Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln; E. Brooks Holi- ﬁeld, Theology in America: Christian Thought in America from the Age of the Puritans to the Civil War (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003). jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 679

Biographies Lesser, M. X. Jonathan Edwards. Boston: Twayne, 1988. Marsden, George M. Jonathan Edwards: A Life. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003. Miller, Perry. Jonathan Edwards. New York: Sloane, 1949. Murray, Iain. Jonathan Edwards: A New Biography. Carlisle, PA: Banner of Truth, 1988. Winslow, Ola. Jonathan Edwards. New York: MacMillan, 1941.

Collected Essays Angoff, Charles, ed. Jonathan Edwards: His Life and Inﬂuence. Rutherford, NJ: Fair- leigh Dickinson University Press, 1975. Hart, D. G., Sean Michael Lucas, and Stephen J. Nichols, eds. The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards: American Religion and the Evangelical Tradition. Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003. Hatch, Nathan O., and Harry S. Stout, eds. Jonathan Edwards and the American Ex- perience. New York: Oxford University Press, 1988. Helm, Paul and Oliver Crisp, eds. Jonathan Edwards: Philosophical Theologian. Lon- don: Ashgate, 2003. Kling, David W. and Douglas A. Sweeney, eds. Jonathan Edwards at Home and Abroad: Historical Memories, Cultural Movements, Global Horizons. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 2003. Lee, Sang Hyun ed. A Companion to the Theology of Jonathan Edwards. Princeton: Princeton University Press, forthcoming. Lee, Sang Hyun and Alan Guelzo, eds. Edwards in Our Time: Jonathan Edwards and the Shaping of American Religion. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000. Oberg, Barbara O. and Harry S. Stout, eds. Benjamin Franklin, Jonathan Edwards, and the Representation of American Culture. New York: Oxford University Press, 1993. Schieck, William J. Critical Essays on Jonathan Edwards. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1980. Stein, Stephen J., ed. Jonathan Edwards’s Writings: Text, Context, Interpretation. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1996.

Editions and Anthologies Bailey, Richard A. and Gregory Wills, eds. The Salvation of Souls: Nine Previously Unpublished Sermons on the Call of Ministry and the Gospel by Jonathan Ed- wards. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2003. Faust, Clarence H. and Thomas H. Johnson, eds. Jonathan Edwards: Representative Selections. New York: American Book Co., 1935. Kimnach, Wilson H., Kenneth P. Minkema, and Douglas A. Sweeney. The Sermons of Jonathan Edwards: A Reader. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1999. Kistler, Don, ed. Our Great and Glorious God: Jonathan Edwards, 1703–1758. Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 2003. Kistler, Don, ed. To All the Saints of God: Addresses to the Church, Jonathan Ed- wards, 1703–1758. Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 2003. Levin, David. Jonathan Edwards: A Proﬁle. New York: Hill & Wang, 1969. McMullen, Michael, ed. The Blessing of God: Previously Unpublished Sermons by Jonathan Edwards. Nashville: Broadman & Holman, 2003. Nichols, William C., ed. Seeking God: Jonathan Edwards’s Evangelism Contrasted with Modern Methodologies. Ames, IA: International Outreach, 2001. 680 journal of the evangelical theological society

Nichols, William C., ed. Knowing the Heart: Jonathan Edwards on True and False Conversion. Ames, IA: International Outreach, 2003. Simonson, Harold P. The Selected Writings of Jonathan Edwards. New York: Ungar, 1970. Smith, John E., Harry S. Stout, and Kenneth P. Minkema. A Jonathan Edwards Reader. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1995; repr. 2003. Trigsted, Mark. Jonathan Edwards: His Greatest Sermons. Gainesville, FL: Bridge- Logos, 2003.

Reference Works Lesser, M. X. Jonathan Edwards: An Annotated Bibliography, 1979–1993. Westport, CT: Greenwood, 1994. Lesser, M. X. Jonathan Edwards: A Reference Guide. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1981. Lesser, M. X. The Printed Writings of Jonathan Edwards. Princeton: Princeton Theo- logical Seminary, forthcoming.

Sermons and the Ministry Cady, Edwin H. “The Artistry of Jonathan Edwards.” New England Quarterly 22 (March 1949): 61–72. Gallagher, Edward J. “ ‘Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God’: Some Unﬁnished Business.” New England Quarterly 73 (June 2000): 202–21. Kimnach, Wilson H. “General Introduction to the Sermons: Jonathan Edwards’ Art of Prophesying.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 10, Sermon and Discourses, 1720–1723. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1992. Pp. 3–258. Kimnach, Wilson H. “Jonathan Edwards’s Early Sermons: New York, 1722–1723.” Journal of Presbyterian History 55 (1977): 255–56. Kimnach, Wilson H. “Jonathan Edwards’s Sermon Mill.” Early American Literature 10 (Fall 1975): 167–77. Lukasik, Christopher. “Felling the Force of Certainty: The Divine Science, Newtoni- anism, and Jonathan Edwards’s ‘Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.’ ” New England Quarterly 73 (June 2000): 222–45. Westra, Helen P. “ ‘Above All Others’: Jonathan Edwards and the Gospel Ministry.” American Presbyterians 67 (Fall 1989): 209–19. Westra, Helen P. “Jonathan Edwards’s Sermons: Search for ‘Acceptable Words.’ ” Ameri- can Theological Library Association, Proceedings 38 (1984) 102–16. Westra, Helen P. “Jonathan Edwards on ‘Faithful and Successful Ministers.’ ” Early American Literature 23 (Winter 1988) 281–90. Westra, Helen P. The Minister’s Task and Calling in the Sermons of Jonathan Ed- wards. Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen, 1986. Westra, Helen P. “Jonathan Edwards and ‘What Reason Teaches.’ ” Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 34 (Dec. 1991) 495–503.

Revivalism Benfold, Gary et al. God at Work? Signs of True Revival. London: Grace Pub. Trust, 1995. Beverly, James A. Revival Wars: A Critique of Counterfeit Revival. Pickering, Canada: Evangelical Research Ministries, 1997. Bumsted, J. M. and John E. Van de Wetering. What must I do to be saved? The Great Awakening in Colonial America. Hinsdale, IL: Dryden, 1976. Cowing, Cedric B. The Great Awakening and the American Revolution: Colonial Thought in the 18th Century. Chicago: Rand McNally, 1971.

On Line Long jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 681

Gaustad, Edwin. The Great Awakening in New England. New York: Harper, 1957; repr. New York, 1972. Hannah, John D. “Jonathan Edwards, the Toronto Blessing, and the Spiritual Gifts: Are the Extraordinary Ones Actually the Ordinary Ones?” Trinity Journal 17 (Fall 1996): 167–89. Harlan, David C. The Clergy and the Great Awakening in New England. Ann Arbor: UMI Research Press, 1980. Hindmarsh, Bruce. “The ‘Toronto Blessing’ and the Protestant Evangelical Awakening of the Eighteenth Century Compared.” Crux (Dec. 1995): 3–13. Lambert, Frank. Inventing the Great Awakening. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1999. Lloyd-Jones, Martyn D. “Jonathan Edwards and the Crucial Importance of Revival.” In The Puritan Experiment in the New World. Huntington, England: Westminster Conference, 1976. Pp. 103–21. Lovejoy, David S. Samuel Hopkins: Religion, Slavery, and the Revolution. Philadelphia: United Church Press, 1976. Lovelace, Richard F. Dynamics of Spiritual Life: An Evangelical Theology of Renewal. Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 1979. Murray, Iain H. The Puritan Hope: A Study in Revival and the Interpretation of Proph- ecy. London: Banner of Truth, 1971. Wessell, Lynn Ray. “Great Awakening: The First American Revolution.” Christianity Today 17 (Aug. 31, 1973): 11–21.

Missiology Conforti, Joseph A. “David Brainerd and the Nineteenth-Century Missionary Move- ment.” Journal of the Early Republic 5 (Fall 1985): 309–29. Conforti, Joseph A. “Jonathan Edwards’s Most Popular Work: ‘The Life of David Brainerd’ and Nineteenth-Century Evangelical Culture.” Church History 54 (June 1985): 188–201. Davies, Ronald E. Jonathan Edwards and His Inﬂuence on the Development of the Missionary Movement from Britain. Cambridge: Currents in World Christianity Project, 1996. Day, Richard Ellsworth. Flagellant on Horseback: The Life Story of David Brainerd. Philadelphia: Judson, 1949. Howard, Philip E., Jr. “A Biographical Sketch of the Life and Work of Jonathan Ed- wards.” In The Life and Diary of David Brainerd. Chicago: Moody, 1949. McCoy, Genevieve. “The Women of the ABCFM Oregon Mission and the Conﬂicted Language of Calvinism.” Church History 64 (March 1995): 62–82. Miles, Lyon. “The Red Man Dispossessed: The Williams Family and the Alienation of Indian Land in Stockbridge, Massachusetts, 1736–1818.” New England Quarterly 67 (March 1994): 46–76. Pettit, Norman, ed. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 7, The Life of David Brainerd. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1985. Pp. 1–85. Pettit, Norman. “Prelude to Mission: Brainerd’s Expulsion from Yale.” New England Quarterly 59 (March 1986): 28–50. Wheeler, Rachel. “ ‘Friends to Your Souls’: Jonathan Edwards’s Indian Pastorate and the Doctrine of Original Sin.” Church History 72 (Dec. 2003): 736–65.

Ethics and Aesthetics Byrnes, Thomas A. “H. Richard Niebuhr’s Reconstruction of Jonathan Edwards’s Moral Theology.” Annual of the Society of Christian Ethics. Edited by Alan B. Anderson. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 1986. Pp. 33–55. 682 journal of the evangelical theological society

Delattre, Roland André. Beauty and Sensibility in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards: An Essay in Aesthetics and Theological Ethics. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1968. Erdt, Terrence. Jonathan Edwards, Art and the Sense of the Heart. Amherst: Univer- sity of Massachusetts Press, 1980. Gustafson, James M. Ethics from a Theocentric Perspective: Theology and Ethics. Chi- cago: University of Chicago Press, 1981. Holbrook, Clyde Amos. The Ethics of Jonathan Edwards. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1973. Mitchell, Louis J. “Jonathan Edwards on the Experience of Beauty.” Studies in Re- formed Theology and History, no. 9 (2003): 1–115. Peacock, Virginia A. Problems in the Interpretations of Jonathan Edwards’s “Nature of True Virtue.” Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen, 1990. Post, Stephen. “Disinterested Benevolence: An American Debate over the Nature of Christian Love.” Journal of Religious Ethics 14 (Fall 1986): 356–68. Ramsey, Paul. “Editor’s Introduction.” In The Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 9, Ethical Writings. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1989. Pp. 1–121. Spohn, William C. “The Reasoning Heart: An American Approach to Christian Discern- ment.” Theological Studies 44 (March 1983): 30–52. Wilson, Stephen A. and Jean Porter, eds. “Focus: Jonathan Edwards.” Journal of Re- ligious Ethics 31 (Summer 2003): 183–324.

Literary and Cultural Criticism Brumm, Ursula. American Thought and Religious Typology. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1970. Grifﬁn, Edward M. Jonathan Edwards. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1971. Heimert, Alan. Religion and the American Mind: From the Great Awakening to the Revolution. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1966. Levin, David, ed. The Puritan in the Enlightenment: Franklin and Edwards. Chicago: Rand McNally, 1963. Lowance, Mason I., Jr. Language of Canaan: Metaphor and Symbol in New England from the Puritans to the Transcendentalists. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1980. Lowance, Mason I., Jr. and David H. Watters. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 11, Typological Writings. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993. Miller, Perry. Images or Shadows of Divine Things. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1948. Miller, Perry. “Jonathan Edwards on the Sense of the Heart.” Harvard Theological Review 41 (April 1948): 123–45. Miller, Perry. “Jonathan Edwards’s Sociology of the Great Awakening.” New England Quarterly 21 (March 1948): 50–77. Scheick, William J. The Writings of Jonathan Edwards: Theme, Motif, and Style. Col- lege Station: Texas A & M University Press, 1975. Scheick, William J. “Family, Conversion, and the Self in Jonathan Edwards’ ‘A Faith- ful Narrative of the Surprising Work of God.’ ” Tennessee Studies in Literature 18. Knoxville: University of Tennessee Press, 1973. Pp. 79–89. Shea, Daniel B. Spiritual Autobiography in Early America. Princeton: Princeton Uni- versity Press, 1968; repr. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1988. jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 683

Weber, Donald L. “The Figure of Jonathan Edwards.” American Quarterly 35 (Winter 1983): 556–64. Yarbrough, Stephen R. and John C. Adams. Delightful Conviction: Jonathan Edwards and the Rhetoric of Conversion. Westport, CT: Greenwood, 1993.

Philosophy Anderson, Wallace E. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 6, Scientiﬁc and Philosophical Writings. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1970. Pp. 1–143. Anderson, Wallace E. “Immaterialism in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards.” Journal of the History of Ideas 25 (April–June 1964): 181–200. Chai, Leon. Jonathan Edwards and the Limits of Enlightenment Philosophy. New York: Oxford University Press, 1998. Daniel, Stephen H. The Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards: A Study in Divine Semi- otics. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1994. Elwood, Douglas J. The Philosophical Theology of Jonathan Edwards. New York: Co- lumbia University Press, 1960. Miller, Perry. “From Edwards to Emerson.” New England Quarterly 13 (Dec. 1940): 589–617. Smith, John E. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 3, Re- ligious Affections. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1959. Pp. 1–83. Suter, Rufus O. “The Concept of Morality in the Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards.” Journal of Religion 14 (July 1934): 265–72. Suter, Rufus O. “The Problem of Evil in the Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards.” Monist 44 (July 1934): 280–95. Suter, Rufus O. “An American Pascal: Jonathan Edwards.” Scientiﬁc Monthly 68 (May 1949): 338–42. Townsend, Harvey G., ed. The Philosophy of Jonathan Edwards from His Private Notebooks. Eugene: Oregon University Press, 1955.

Historical Breitenbach, William. “Unregenerate Doings: Selflessness and Selfishness in New Di- vinity Theology.” American Quarterly 34 (Winter 1982): 479–502. Breitenbach, William. “The Consistent Calvinism of the New Divinity Movement.” William and Mary Quarterly 41 (Apr. 1984): 241–64. Brekus, Catherine A. “Children of Wrath, Children of Grace: Jonathan Edwards and the Puritan Culture of Child Rearing.” In The Child in Christian Thought. Edited by Marcia J. Bunge. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2001. Pp. 300–328. Brown, Robert E. Jonathan Edwards and the Bible. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2002. Bushman, Richard L. “Jonathan Edwards and Puritan Consciousness.” Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 5 (Fall 1966): 383–96. Bushman, Richard L. “Jonathan Edwards as Great Man.” Soundings 52 (Spring 1969): 15–46. Chamberlain, Mary Ava. “The Grand Sower of the Seed: Jonathan Edwards’s Critique of George Whitefield.” New England Quarterly 70 (Sept. 1997): 368–85. Chamberlain, Mary Ava. “The Immaculate Ovum: Jonathan Edwards and the Con- struction of the Female Body.” William and Mary Quarterly 62 (April 2000): 289–322. 684 journal of the evangelical theological society

Chamberlain, Mary Ava. “Bad Books and Bad Boys: The Transformation of Gender in Eighteenth-Century Northampton, Massachusetts.” New England Quarterly 75 (June 2002): 179–203. Conforti, Joseph A. “Samuel Hopkins and the New Divinity: Theology, Ethics, and So- cial Reform in Eighteenth-Century New England.” William and Mary Quarterly 34 (Oct. 1977): 572–89. Conforti, Joseph A. Samuel Hopkins and the New Divinity Movement: Calvinism, the Congregational Ministry, and Reform in New England between the Great Awaken- ings. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1981. Conforti, Joseph A. “Mary Lyon, the Founding of Mount Holyoke College, and the Cul- tural Revival of Jonathan Edwards.” Religion and American Culture 3 (Winter 1993): 69–89. Conforti, Joseph A. “The Invention of the Great Awakening.” Early American Litera- ture 26 (Fall 1991): 99–118. Conforti, Joseph A. Jonathan Edwards, Religious Tradition, and American Culture. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1995. Danaher, William J., Jr. “By Sensible Signs Represented: Jonathan Edwards’s Ser- mons on the Lord’s Supper.” Pro Ecclesia 7 (Summer 1998): 261–87. Ellison, Julie. “The Sociology of ‘Holy Indifference’: Sarah Edwards’ Narrative.” Ameri- can Literature 56 (Dec. 1984): 479–95. Fiering, Norman. Jonathan Edwards’s Moral Thought and Its British Context. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1981. Grasso, Christopher. A Speaking Aristocracy: Transforming Public Discorse in Eighteenth-Century Connecticut. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1999. Guelzo, Allen C. Edwards on the Will: A Century of American Theological Debate. Middletown: Wesleyan University Press, 1989. Hall, David D. “Editor’s Introduction.” Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 12, Eccle- siastical Writings. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1994. Pp. 1–90. Hall, Richard A. S. The Neglected Northampton Text of Jonathan Edwards: Edwards on Society and Politics. Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen, 1990. Haroutunian, Joseph G. Piety Versus Moralism: The Passing of the New England The- ology. New York: Henry Holt & Co., 1932. Holiﬁeld, E. Brooks. Theology in America: Christian Thought in America from the Age of the Puritans to the Civil War. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003. Hoopes, James. “Jonathan Edwards’s Religious Psychology.” Journal of American History 69 (March 1983): 849–65. Howe, Daniel Walker. Making the American Self: Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lin- coln. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1997. Jamieson, John F. “Jonathan Edwards’s Change of Position on Stoddardeanism.” Harvard Theological Review 74 (Jan. 1981): 79–99. Jones, Charles E. “The Impolitic Mr. Edwards: The Personal Dimension of the Robert Breck Affair.” New England Quarterly 51 (March 1978): 64–79. Jones, Rowena R. “Edwards, Dickinson, and the Sacramentality of Nature.” Studies in Puritan American Spirituality 1 (Dec. 1990): 225–53. Kling, David W. A Field of Divine Wonders: The New Divinity and Village Revivals in Northwestern Connecticut, 1792–1822. University Park: Penn State Press, 1993. Kuklick, Bruce. Churchmen and Philosophers: From Jonathan Edwards to John Dewey. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1985. Minkema, Kenneth P. “Jonathan Edwards’s Defense of Slavery.” Massachusetts His- torical Review 4 (2002): 23–59. jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 685

Noll, Mark A. America’s God: From Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln. New York: Oxford University Press, 2002. Noll, Mark A. “The Contested Legacy of Jonathan Edwards in Antebellum Calvinism: Theological Conﬂict and the Evolution of Thought in America.” Canadian Review of American Studies 19 (Summer 1988): 149–64. Noll, Mark A. “Moses Mather (Old Calvinist) and the Evolution of Edwardseanism.” Church History 49 (Sept. 1979): 273–85. Porterﬁeld, Amanda. Mary Lyon and the Mount Holyoke Missionaries. New York: Ox- ford University Press, 1997. Rightmire, David. “The Sacramental Theology of Jonathan Edwards in the Context of Controversy.” Fides et Historia 21 (Jan. 1989): 50–60. Sklar, Kathryn Kish. “Culture vs. Economics: A Case of Fornication in Northampton in the 1740s.” University of Michigan Papers in Women’s Studies (May 1978): 35–56. Stein, Stephen J. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 5, Apocalyptic Writings. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1977. Pp. 1–93. Stein, Stephen J. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 15, Notes on Scripture. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1998. Pp. 1–46. Stein, Stephen J. “The Quest for the Spiritual Sense: The Biblical Hermeutics of Jona- than Edwards.” Harvard Theological Review 70 (1977): 99–113. Sweeney, Douglas A. Nathaniel William Taylor, New Haven Theology, and the Legacy of Jonathan Edwards. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003. Tracy, Patricia J. Jonathan Edwards, Pastor: Religion and Society in Eighteenth- Century Northampton. New York: Hill & Wang, 1980. Valeri, Mark R. “The Economic Thought of Jonathan Edwards.” Church History 60 (March 1991): 37–54. Valeri, Mark R. Law and Providence in Joseph Bellamy’s New England: The Origins of the New Divinity in Revolutionary America. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994. Wilson, John F. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 9, History of the Work of Redemption. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1989. Pp. 1–109. Zakai, Avihu. Jonathan Edwards’s Philosophy of History: The Reenchantment of the World in the Age of Enlightenment. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2003.

Theological and Exegetical Carse, James. Jonathan Edwards and the Visibility of God. New York: Scribner’s Sons, 1967. Cherry, Conrad. The Theology of Jonathan Edwards: A Reappraisal. Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1966; repr. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1990. Davidson, Bruce W. “Reasonable Damnation: How Jonathan Edwards Argued for the Rationality of Hell.” Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 38 (March 1995): 47–56. De Prospo, R. C. Theism in the Discourse of Jonathan Edwards. Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1985. Gerstner, John H. The Rational Biblical Theology of Jonathan Edwards. 3 vols. Or- lando, FL: Ligonier Ministries, 1991–93. Gerstner, John H. Steps to Salvation: The Evangelistic Message of Jonathan Edwards. Philadelphia: Westminster, 1960. Reprinted as Jonathan Edwards: Evangelist. Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 1995. Gerstner, John H. Jonathan Edwards on Heaven and Hell. Grand Rapids: Baker, 1980; repr. Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 1998. 686 journal of the evangelical theological society

Gerstner, John H. Jonathan Edwards: A Mini-Theology. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House, 1987. Hart, D. G., Sean Michael Lucas, and Stephen J. Nichols, eds. The Legacy of Jonathan Edwards: American Religion and the Evangelical Tradition. Grand Rapids: Baker, 2003. Holmes, Stephen R. God of Grace & God of Glory: An Account of the Theology of Jonathan Edwards. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000. Holmes, Stephen R. “The Justice of Hell and the Display of God’s Glory in the Thought of Jonathan Edwards.” Pro Ecclesia 9 (Fall 2000): 389–403. Jenson, Robert. America’s Theologian: A Recommendation of Jonathan Edwards. New York: Oxford University Press, 1988. Lee, Sang Hyun. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 21, Writings on the Trinity, Grace, and Faith. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003. Pp. 1–106. Lee, Sang Hyun. The Philosophical Theology of Jonathan Edwards. Princeton: Prince- ton University Press, 1988; repr. 2000. Logan, Samuel T., Jr. “The Doctrine of Justiﬁcation in the Theology of Jonathan Ed- wards.” Westminster Theological Journal 46 (Spring 1984): 26–52. McClymond, Michael J. Encounters With God: An Approach to the Theology of Jona- than Edwards. New York: Oxford University Press, 1998. McDermott, Gerald R. One Holy and Happy Society: The Public Theology of Jonathan Edwards. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1992. McDermott, Gerald R. Jonathan Edwards Confronts the Gods: Christian Theology, Enlightenment Religion, and Non-Christian Faith. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000. Moore, Doreen. “Jonathan Edwards: Ministry and the Life of the Family.” Reformation & Revival 4 (Summer 1995): 99–120. Moore, T. M. “A Brief Introduction to an Edwardsean View of Christian Instruction.” Prebyterion 25 (Spring 1999): 21–31. Morimoto, Anri. Jonathan Edwards and the Catholic Vision of Salvation. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1995. Morris, William S. The Young Jonathan Edwards: A Reconstruction. Brooklyn: Carl- son, 1991. Nichols, Stephen A. An Absolute Sort of Certainty: The Holy Spirit and the Apologetics of Jonathan Edwards. Phillipsburg, NJ: Presbyterian & Reformed, 2003. Pauw, Amy Plantinga. The Supreme Harmony of All: The Trinitarian Theology of Jonathan Edwards. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003. Pauw, Amy Plantinga. “The Future of Reformed Theology: Some Lessons From Jonathan Edwards.” In Toward the Future of Reformed Theology: Tasks, Topics, Traditions. Edited by David Willis-Watkins and Michael Welker. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1999. Pp. 456–69. Piper, John. God’s Passion for His Glory: With the Complete Text from “The End for Which God Created the World” by Jonathan Edwards. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 1998. Ramsey, Paul. “Editor’s Introduction.” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 1, Free- dom of the Will. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1957. Pp. 1–128. Rudisill, Dorus P. The Doctrine of the Atonement in Jonathan Edwards and His Suc- cessors. New York: Poseidon, 1971. Schafer, Thomas A. “Editor’s Introduction to the ‘Miscellanies.’ ” In Works of Jonathan Edwards, volume 13, ‘Miscellanies’ nos. a-500. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1994. Pp. 1–90. jonathan edwards in the twentieth century 687

Schafer, Thomas A. “Jonathan Edwards and Justiﬁcation by Faith.” Church History 20 (Dec. 1951): 55–67. Schafer, Thomas A. “Solomon Stoddard and the Theology and Revival.” In A Miscel- lany of American Christianity: Essays in Honor of H. Shelton Smith. Edited by Stuart C. Henry. Durham: Duke University Press, 1963. Pp. 328–61. Simonson, Harold P. Jonathan Edwards: Theologian of the Heart. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1975; repr. Macon, Ga.: Mercer University Press, 1982. Spohn, William C. “Jonathan Edwards and Ignatius Loyola.” In Finding God in All Things: Essays in Honor of Michael J. Buckley. Edited by Michael J. Himes and Stephen J. Pope. New York: Crossroad, 1996. Sproul, Richard C. and Archie Parrish. The Spirit of Revival: Discovering the Wisdom of Jonathan Edwards. Wheaton, IL: Crossway, 2000. Steele, Richard B. “Gracious Affection” and “True Virtue” According to Jonathan Ed- wards and John Wesley. Metuchen, NJ: Scarecrow, 1994. Stephens, Bruce M. “An Appeal to the Universe: The Doctrine of the Atonement in American Protestant Thought from Jonathan Edwards to Edwards Amasa Park.” Encounter 60 (Winter 1999): 55–72. Stephens, Bruce M. God’s Last Metaphor: The Doctrine of the Trinity in New England Theology. Chico, CA: Scholars Press, 1981. Stephens, Bruce M. The Prism of Time and Eternity: Images of Christ in American Protestant Thought from Jonathan Edwards to Horace Bushnell. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow, 1996. Storms, C. Samuel. Tragedy in Eden: Original Sin in the Theology of Jonathan Ed- wards. Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1985. Vetö, Miklós. La pensée de Jonathan Edwards. Paris: Éditions due Cerf, 1987. Webber, Richard M. “The Trinitarian Theology of Jonathan Edwards: An Investiga- tion of Charges Against Its Orthodoxy.” Journal of the Evangelical Theological So- ciety 44 (June 2001): 297–318.