Drivers of Woody Plant Form and Function in Relation to Water Acquisition and Use in Seasonal Forests
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Drivers of woody plant form and function in relation to water acquisition and use in seasonal forests A Dissertation SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA BY Christina Marie Smith IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Jennifer S. Powers, Advisor June 2019 © Christina Marie Smith, June 2019 All rights reserved. Acknowledgements First and foremost, I thank my advisor, Dr. Jennifer Powers, for her outstanding guidance, patience, and support throughout this whole process. Jennifer’s passion for understanding how tropical dry forests function is inspiring and motivated me to conduct the research in this dissertation. I will always be incredibly grateful for the countless steps Jennifer has taken to aid my development as a scientist and I could not have wished for a better advisor. I also thank, Dr. Tim Brodribb and Dr. Stefan Schnitzer, who at times served as my honorary advisors, for their advice and help. My present committee members Dr. Rebecca Montgomery, Dr. Jeannine Cavender-Bares, and Dr. Walid Sadok, and past members, Dr. David Moeller, and Dr. Peter Kennedy have provided support and helpful feedback over the years. I am thankful for many past and present members of the Powers’ lab. In particular, I think Dr. Leland Werden for all his support and advice throughout these years and for all the fun times we had while doing fieldwork. I am also very grateful to Laura Toro for all her help and friendship. It has also been a pleasure to get to know and collaborate with German Vargas, Dr. Naomi Schwartz, Dr. Bonnie Waring, Dr. Maga Gei, Dr. Kristen Becklund, Dan Du, Erick Calderon, Ariadna Mondragon, and Julián Tijerin. This work could not have been possible without the help of Daniel Perez and Damaris Pereira. I also appreciate the advice and interesting discussions provided by Dr. Géraldine Derroire, Dr. Catherine Hulshof, and Dr. Cristina Chinchilla. I have spent many months in the field in Costa Rica and in Panama and I have many wonderful people to thank. A large portion of this research was conducted at Área de Conservación Guanacaste and I am thankful for the help and support provided by the staff at Estación Experimental Forestal Horizontes, in particular, Milena Gutiérrez for supporting my research and Pedro Alvarado for logistical support. During my time in Panama, Jeremy La Che spent many hours helping me in the field also Dr. Omar Lopez, Dr. Joe Wright, and Dr. Helene Muller-Landau provided me with advice and support. I am also very thankful for the wonderful friends I made in Panama: Carolina Bastos, Lourdes Hernández, Anita Weißflog, and in particular María García. María, thank you for being such an amazing friend and housemate. I have received support from the University of Minnesota with a Doctoral Dissertation Fellowship, thesis research travel grant, Carolyn Crosby grant, Dayton natural history grants, and Plant and Microbial Biology travel grants. My research was also supported by a National Science Foundation Doctoral Dissertation Improvement Grant and I received a Smithsonian Institution Big Ten Academic Alliance Fellowship. In the Department of Plant and Microbial Biology, I have been surrounded by many wonderful people including Dr. Mohamed Yakub, Derek Nedveck, and in particular, Dr. Beth Fallon, Dr. Allison Haaning, and Dr. Diana Trujillo have made this process so much more fun. I would also like to thank Elisabeth Anderson, and in particular, Thierry Degehet for the love and support. Finally, I thank my mother, Patricia Martin, and my father, Timothy Smith, for all the love and support throughout the years. i Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to my parents, Patricia and Timothy, for their unconditional love and support. ii Abstract Understanding plant-water relations is of central interest to ecology, as patterns in water availability drive distribution, composition, structure, and function of plant communities worldwide. Plant-water relations are particularly important in forests that experience water limitation and periods of seasonal drought. However, little is known about the initial post-germination response of multiple species from seasonal forests to water availability, or how species with different growth forms respond over time to distinct water availability patterns. Moreover, few studies have examined woody plant drought resistance across entire communities or key traits that are difficult to measure, such as biomass allocation and rooting depth, but which may mediate responses to seasonal water shortage. In Chapter 1, I determined if legumes have a different regeneration niche than non-legumes. I found that legumes may indeed have a different regeneration niche, in that they germinate rapidly and grow taller than other species immediately after germination, maximizing their performance when light and belowground resources are readily available, and potentially permitting them to take advantage of high light, nutrient, and water availability at the beginning of the wet season. For Chapter 2, I measured drought resistance in all dominant woody species within a dry sclerophyll woodland community to determine community level drought resistance. I found that the leaf and stem xylem of all species was highly drought resistant, with two species being slightly more vulnerable to drought than the others. The overall high resistance to drought and similar levels of resistance between leaves and stems suggest that canopy and understory species in this evergreen forest have evolved similar strategies of drought resistance. However, because two species were more vulnerable to drought than the others, this could lead to shifts in iii community-level species composition caused by future increases in drought frequency and severity. For Chapter 3, to shed light on rooting depth and biomass allocation, I harvested above- and belowground biomass and measured maximum rooting depth for juvenile and adult lianas, deciduous trees, and evergreen trees. This was the first study to show that lianas had the shallowest roots, followed by deciduous trees, then evergreen trees, which had the deepest roots. In addition, my study was the first to find that contrary to predictions lianas and trees have similar allocation patterns to stems. To test the hypothesis that lianas perform better than trees during seasonal drought, for Chapter 4, I used a common garden experiment with lianas and trees. My results are the first experimentally support the hypothesis that lianas perform better and experience less physiological stress than trees during seasonal drought. Moreover, only trees responded to dry season irrigation with increased growth, whereas lianas did not, suggesting clear differences between growth forms in response to altered rainfall regimes. Ultimately, better dry-season performance may explain why liana abundance peaks in seasonal forests compared to trees. Collectively, these studies show that dry forest tree species differ in their strategies used to cope with seasonal drought, and how they respond to water availability. iv Table of Contents Acknowledgements........................................................................................................................... i Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... iii Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................. v List of Tables ................................................................................................................................. viii List of Figures .................................................................................................................................. ix Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1: Effects of soil type and light on height growth, biomass partitioning, and nitrogen dynamics of 22 species of tropical dry forest tree seedlings: comparisons between legumes and non-legumes .................................................................................................................................... 6 Synopsis ....................................................................................................................................... 6 Premise of the study ................................................................................................................ 6 Methods ................................................................................................................................... 6 Key Results ............................................................................................................................... 7 Conclusions .............................................................................................................................. 7 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 7 Materials and Methods .............................................................................................................. 10 Site description ...................................................................................................................... 10 Soils .......................................................................................................................................