Aspects of Complexity at Arslantepe

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Aspects of Complexity at Arslantepe Aspects of Complexity at Arslantepe Paolo Guarino Institute of Archaeology University College London March 2014 Thesis submitted to University College London for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy 1 Disclaimer I, Paolo Guarino, confirm that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Where information has been derived from other sources, I confirm that this has been indicated in the thesis. All translations of quoted material from foreign language sources are my own. 2 Abstract This doctoral research examines the multi-period site of Arslantepe (Malatya – South- eastern Turkey). It identifies archaeological evidence for social complexity within the site’s Late Chalcolithic (period VII in Arslantepe chronology) community and seeks to define the character and nature of this complexity. Craft specialisation and differential consumption is assessed through an analysis of the production and distribution of artefacts with a comparative analysis of the functional characteristics of monumental architecture and other buildings. A specific focus is placed on an analysis of the Arslantepe VII ceramic assemblage to investigate what this can tell us about the organisation of its production. The overarching aim is to assess the degree of economic centralisation and redistribution activities within Arslantepe’s developing socio-political organization. The evidence from Arslantepe is then reconsidered within the larger picture of 4th millennium Greater Mesopotamia, and wider debates on the formation of social complexity. A comparison of Arslantepe VII with contemporaneous sites in the region facilitates a revaluation of the interpretative models used to explain the emergence and development of complex forms of socio-political organization during the 4th millennium BC in Greater Mesopotamia. 3 Table of Contents List of Illustrations 8 List of Tables 12 Acknowledgements 13 1. Aspects of complexity at Arslantepe 14 1.1 Research statement 14 1.2 Research aims and objectives 15 1.3 Arslantepe VII as a case study for the emergence of complexity 16 1.4 Research context: emergence of social complexity in 4th millennium BC Mesopotamia 19 1.5 Original contribution: a fresh look at social dynamics 21 1.6 Thesis outline 23 2. Arslantepe: a background 26 2.1 Introduction 26 2.2 Arslantepe and Greater Mesopotamia: an overview 26 2.3 Anatolian geology 28 2.4 Malatya Plain, environment and resources 28 2.4.1 Water Supplies 30 2.4.2 The animal exploitation and the environment 31 2.5 Arslantepe VII: the site and the history of the research 33 2.5.1 The archaeological sequence 34 2.5.2 The chronology of Period VII 36 2.5.3 History of archaeological intervention at Arslantepe 38 2.6 Periods VIII, VII and VI A: basis for a diachronic comparison 41 2.6.1 Period VIII 42 2.6.2 Period VIA 43 2.6.3 Period VII – a case study for the analysis of social complexity 45 3. Theoretical Framework: approaches and themes for the interpretation of early complex societies 48 3.1 Introduction 48 3.2 The difficulties of defining early complex societies: a debate stretching from evolutionism to agency 48 3.2.1 Arslantepe VII in between types 56 3.3 Social and Political complexity in 4th millennium BC Mesopotamia 58 3.3.1 Late Chalcolithic Mesopotamia: Uruk expansion or local origins – the academic debate 59 3.3.2 The “southern perspective”: theories in support of Uruk’s predominance 62 3.3.3 The “northern perspective”: arguing for local origins of complexity 65 4 3.3.4 Unresolved questions concerning the relationships between North and South of Mesopotamia 67 3.3.5 General traits observed in Chalcolithic pottery in Mesopotamia 69 3.4 Reading social practices and dynamics inside “complexity”: further approaches for investigating social dynamics 73 3.4.1 Earle’s chiefs and the organisational dynamics of complex political entities 73 3.4.2 Materialisation of ideologies and feasts 74 3.4.3 Ways of consumption: differential distribution of the remains from human activities 78 3.5 Craft specialisation, standardisation and organisation of production 79 4. Methodology 83 4.1 Introduction 83 4.1.1 Fieldwork 83 4.2 Aim 1: The dynamics of social and political organisation 83 4.2.1 Objective 1: Contexts analysis and elements of monumentality 84 4.2.2 Objective 2: Pottery characterisation, organisation of ceramic production, patterns of use and distribution 87 Characterisation of the assemblage 87 Organisation of ceramic production 90 Function and consumption of ceramic artefacts 93 4.3 Aim 2: The regional framework 95 4.3.1 Objective 1: Regional analysis 95 4.3.2 Objective 2: Interregional analysis 96 4.4 Aim 3: Formative processes of social complexity 97 4.4.1 Objective 1: Arslantepe in the wider debate on the emergence of social complexity 97 5. Analysis of the ceramic assemblage from Arslantepe VII 98 5.1 Introduction 98 5.2 Arslantepe VII ceramic assemblage: an overview 99 5.2.1 Earlier studies 99 5.2.2 The present work 100 5.3 Functional categories 101 5.4 Distinguishing production processes through the analysis of ware classes: the identification of two clear groups 115 5.4.1 Handmade ware 116 5.4.2 Wheel-thrown of wheel-finished wares 117 5.4.3 Matching ware classes to functional categories 121 5.5 Mass produced bowls: a key indicator of public social practices 124 5.5.1 Types, chronology or manufacture? 126 5.5.2 Distribution of the bowls and their function at Arslantepe VII 128 5.6 Potters’ marks: insight into potters’ workshops 131 5.6.1 The ethnographic evidence 131 5 5.6.2 Potters’ marks at Arslantepe VII 132 5.7 Morphological variability and craft specialisation 140 5.7.1 The standardisation hypothesis: the theoretical and methodological background 140 5.7.2 ‘Time’ and ‘work units’: uncontrollable variables 143 5.7.3 Morphological variability at Arslantepe VII 143 Serving/storage jars 145 Cooking pots 149 Mass-produced bowls 155 5.7.4 The difficulty in interpreting the results from morphological variability analysis: final remarks 158 5.8 Arslantepe VII ceramics in the context of Northern Mesopotamia: redefining networks to understand regional power structures 160 5.8.1 Arslantepe VII in its regional context 161 5.8.2 Survey projects along the Turkish Euphrates: further evidence for networks of contacts 165 5.9 Specialists at Arslantepe 175 6. Arslantepe VII. Daily practices, ‘special occasions’ and their locations 176 6.1 Introduction 176 6.2 The archaeological contexts of Arslantepe VII 177 6.2.1 Describing the contexts 177 6.2.2 Evidence of artefacts consumption: methods for sampling the contexts 178 6.3 The North-eastern sector: excavations from the 1960-70s 181 6.3.1 The contexts: a domestic quarter 181 6.3.2 Analysis of the portable artefacts: utilitarian assemblage 187 6.4 The Western Slope, phases 1 and 2: first signs of social differentiation 197 6.4.1 Phase 1: early monumentality, the ‘elite residences’ 197 Analysis of the portable artefacts: storage facilities 200 6.4.2 Phase 2: domestic structures 208 Analysis of the portable artefacts: utilitarian assemblage 211 6.5 The Western Slope, phase 3: the latest phase 215 6.5.1 Building XXIX: the ceremonial monumental structure 216 Internal stratigraphy and analysis of the portable artefacts: evidence for redistribution practices 219 6.5.2 The long rooms complex 224 Internal stratigraphy and analysis of the portable artefacts 227 6.5.3 Contexts north of Building XXIX: possible meal preparation area 236 6.5.4 Structure A564: the bean-shaped building 242 6.6 Domestic and non-domestic buildings at Arslantepe VII as evidence for a complex social organisation 246 7. Results and Discussion 250 7.1 Introduction 250 6 7.2 The organisation of pottery production: evidence combined 250 7.2.1 Manufacture, marks and bowls. The focus on the organisation of the pottery production 251 7.2.2 Analysis of morphological variability. How much can we gain calculating the past? 253 7.2.3 Mass-produced bowls. Powerful evidence of complex organisation 254 7.3 Archaeological contexts, domestic and non-domestic buildings. The evidence for monumentality 256 7.3.1 ‘Domestic’ buildings, an over simplified category 257 7.3.2 Monumental architecture 257 7.4 Feasts and monuments, a look at Arslantepe VII social dynamics through the processes of materialisation of ideologies 259 7.4.1 Feasts and their ‘archaeological signatures’ at Arslantepe VII 260 7.4.2 Arslantepe: evidence for feasts in building XXIX 261 7.4.3 Monumental buildings and mass produced bowls as social landmarks 265 7.5 Arslantepe complexity across time. A diachronic look at the evidence 266 7.5.1 Period VIII: more egalitarian or simply less known? 267 7.5.2 Period VII: complexity across 400 years 267 7.5.3 Period VII and VIA: continuity and change at the end of the 4th millennium BC 269 7.6 The power of social practice 271 7.7 Arslantepe VII and other key sites in northern Mesopotamia: differences and similarities 273 7.7.1 Tell Brak and Arslantepe, similar complexity at the two ends of the size range? 273 7.7.2 Hamukar, another regional centre in the Khabur basin 275 7.7.3 Tepe Gawra a small site with strong evidence of hierarchical social structure 277 7.8 The role of Arslantepe VII in the ‘making’ of Mesopotamia 278 7.8.1 Urban and Non urban communities, a matter of scale? 278 7.8.2 Arslantepe and its neighbours, was it a hierarchically organised network? 281 7.8.3 Arslantepe VII, Northern Mesopotamia and the theoretical debate 283 8. Conclusions 285 8.1 Introductions 285 8.2 Original contributions 285 8.3 Shortcomings and suggestions for future research 288 References 281 7 List of Illustrations Figure 1.1 – Greater Mesopotamia and Arslantepe (Adapted from Google Earth) 17 Figure 2.1 – Greater Mesopotamia and Arslantepe (Adapted from Google Earth) 26 Figure 2.2 – The plain of Malatya from the mound of Arslantepe.
Recommended publications
  • A Research Program on Innovations in Prehistory and Antiquity?
    Special Volume 6 (2016): Space and Knowledge. Topoi Research Group Articles, ed. by Gerd Graßhoff and Michael Meyer, pp. 777–818. Svend Hansen – Jürgen Renn – Florian Klimscha – Jochen Büttner – Barbara Helwing – Sebastian Kruse The Digital Atlas of Innovations: A Research Program on Innovations in Prehistory and Antiquity Edited by Gerd Graßhoff and Michael Meyer, Excellence Cluster Topoi, Berlin eTopoi ISSN 2192-2608 http://journal.topoi.org Except where otherwise noted, content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0 Svend Hansen – Jürgen Renn – Florian Klimscha – Jochen Büttner – Barbara Helwing – Sebastian Kruse The Digital Atlas of Innovations: A Research Program on Innovations in Prehistory and Antiquity The authors discuss the simultaneous appearance of technological innovations in three key technologies (metallurgy, wheeled vehicles, weighing systems) in the second half of the 4th millennium. This is done from a source-critical perspective because the innova- tions are discussed with the help of dynamic maps from the Topoi project Digital Atlas of Innovations. Besides indications of diffusion gradients influenced by special research conditions, exceptional waves of innovation can be detected for all three technologies in the discussed period. These waves of innovation cannot, however, be generalized but have to be understood on the basis of the respective technology traditions and lines of devel- opment specific to local areas. Monocentric diffusion theories can be clearly disproven, local technology developments and their converging in certain centrally situated regions have to be assumed instead. Similarly, the transfer of objects and their châine opératoire can only be detected rather infrequently, while the adaptation to local socio-economic and environmental factors can be demonstrated.
    [Show full text]
  • Friday, the 19Th of June 09:00 Garcia Sanjuan, Leonardo the Hole in the Doughnut
    monumental landscapes neolithic subsistence and megaliths 09:25 schiesberg, sara; zimmermann, andreas 10:40 coffee break siemens lecture hall bosch conference room Stages and Cycles: The Demography of Populations Practicing 11:00 schiesberg, sara Collective Burials Theories, Methods and Results The Bone Puzzle. Reconstructing Burial Rites in Collective Tombs 09:00 schmitt, felicitas; bartelheim, martin; bueno ramírez, primitiva 09:00 o’connell, michael 09:50 rinne, christoph; fuchs, katharina; kopp, juliane; 11:25 cummings, vicki Just passing by? Investigating in the Territory of the Megalith Builders The pollen evidence for early prehistoric farming impact: towards a better schade-lindig, sabine; susat, julian; krause-kyora, ben The social implications of construction: a consideration of the earliest of the Southern European Plains. The Case of Azután, Toledo. understanding of the archaeological fi eld evidence for Neolithic activity in Niedertiefenbach reloaded: The builders of the Wartberg gallery grave Neolithic monuments of Britain and Ireland 09:25 carrero pazos, miguel; rodríguez casal, antón a. western Ireland 10:15 klingner, susan; schultz, michael 11:50 pollard, joshua Neolithic Territory and Funeral Megalithic Space in Galicia (Nw. Of 09:25 diers, sarah; fritsch, barbara The physical strain on megalithic tomb builders from northern How routine life was made sacred: settlement and monumentality in Iberian Peninsula): A Synthetic Approach Changing environments in a Megalithic Landscape: the Altmark case Germany –results of an
    [Show full text]
  • ASCS Newsletter 2018.2
    The Australasian Society for Classical Studies Newsletter No. 43 December 2018 President Hon. Treasurer Hon. Secretary A/Prof. Tom Stevenson Prof. Bronwen Neil A/Prof. Gina Salapata School of Historical and Philosophical Inquiry Department of Ancient History School of Humanities Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences Faculty of Arts Faculty of Arts University of Queensland Macquarie University Massey University [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] www.ascs.org.au From the Editor This is a bumper holiday edition of the Newsletter, because it also includes the full publication list for 2017. The Executive decided that this remains a useful exercise, especially for advocacy for our disciplines. The wealth of scholarship the publications list and the University Reports below reveal is certainly impressive, and to all but confirmed troglodytes, like those recently revealed by the disgraceful government interference in the Australian Research Council grant process (see ASCS response below), should be clear evidence for the vitality of our fields. I know that collating this list puts considerable pressure on the Campus Representatives, and I thank them for their time and diligence. President’s Report Dear Everyone, It’s worth remembering sometimes that there are only 24 hours in a day. Yet somehow our members manage to contribute mightily to ASCS in addition to their day jobs. Well done to the organisers of AMPHORAE 2018 in Auckland and thanks too for all the work that is being done in preparation for ASCS 40 in Armidale next year. On that score the convenors, Bronwyn, Graeme, and Clemens, have already laid impressive groundwork.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Monumentality and Social Differentiation in Neolithic Europe
    MEGALITHS SOCIETIES LANDSCAPES EARLY MONUMENTALITY AND SOCIAL DIFFERENTIATION IN NEOLITHIC EUROPE VOLUME 3 Eds.: Johannes Müller Martin Hinz Frühe Monumentalität und soziale Differenzierung 18 Maria Wunderlich Institut für Ur- und Frühgeschichte der CAU Kiel Megaliths – Societies – Landscapes Early Monumentality and Social Differentiation in Neolithic Europe Volume 3 Proceedings of the international conference »Megaliths – Societies – Landscapes. Early Monumentality and Social Differentiation in Neolithic Europe« (16th–20th June 2015) in Kiel Eds.: Johannes Müller, Martin Hinz, Maria Wunderlich in Kommission Verlag Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, Bonn 2019 Gedruckt mit Unterstützung der Deutschen Forschungsgemeinschaft, Bonn und des Institutes für Ur- und Frühgeschichte der CAU zu Kiel Verlag Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH, Bonn Redaktion Martin Hinz, Maria Wunderlich & Julia Menne (CAU Kiel) Bildbearbeitung Nicole Schwerdtfeger & UFG-Graphic Department (CAU Kiel) Satz & Grafik Nicole Schwerdtfeger & UFG-Graphic Department (CAU Kiel) Design-Konzept Janine Cordts (CAU Kiel) Umschlaggestaltung Janine Cordts (CAU Kiel) Umschlagfoto Vol. 3: Sara Jagiolla (CAU Kiel) Kapitelfotos Ch. 5, Ch. 6 & Ch. 7: Sara Jagiolla (CAU Kiel) Konferenzfotos Sara Jagiolla (CAU Kiel) ISBN 978-3-7749-4213-4 Titel auch als E-Book (PDF) erhältlich unter www.habelt.de Druck BELTZ Grafische Betriebe GmbH, Bad Langensalza Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deutschen Nationalbibliografie. Detailliertere Informationen sind im Internet über <http://dnb.d-nb.de> abrufbar. © 2019 by UFG CAU Kiel and authors 777 Preface of the Series Editor The DFG Priority Program1400 »Early Monumen- this early workshop continued throughout the years tality and Social Differentiation: On the origin and de- after. In consequence the international conference velopment of Neolithic large-scale buildings and the »Megaliths, Societies, Landscapes« was organized emergence of early complex societies in Northern five years after on a broader scale.
    [Show full text]
  • 2Nd Half of the 5Th Millennium BC) and Their Aftermath
    Syria Archéologie, art et histoire 90 | 2013 Dossier : Recherches actuelles sur l’occupation des périphéries désertiques de la Jordanie aux périodes protohistoriques Disappeared by Climate Change. The Shepherd nd Cultures of Qulban Ceni Murra (2 Half of the th 5 Millennium BC) and their Aftermath Hans Georg K. Gebel et Hamzeh M. Mahasneh Édition électronique URL : https://journals.openedition.org/syria/1739 DOI : 10.4000/syria.1739 ISSN : 2076-8435 Éditeur IFPO - Institut français du Proche-Orient Édition imprimée Date de publication : 1 janvier 2013 Pagination : 127-158 ISBN : 9782351593905 ISSN : 0039-7946 Référence électronique Hans Georg K. Gebel et Hamzeh M. Mahasneh, « Disappeared by Climate Change. The Shepherd Cultures of Qulban Ceni Murra (2nd Half of the 5th Millennium BC) and their Aftermath », Syria [En ligne], 90 | 2013, mis en ligne le 01 juillet 2016, consulté le 25 août 2021. URL : http:// journals.openedition.org/syria/1739 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/syria.1739 © Presses IFPO DISAPPEARED BY CLIMATE CHANGE THE SHEPHERD CULTURES OF QULBAN BENI MURRA (2nd HALF OF THE 5th MILLENNIUM BC) AND THEIR AFTERMATH 1 Hans Georg K. GEBEL 2 & Hamzeh M. MAHASNEH 3 Résumé – Le phénomène funéraire attesté dans le sud-est de la Jordanie témoigne d’une phase d’occupation méconnue de la région au cours du milieu de l’Holocène, en lien avec un mode de vie pastoral basé sur l’exploitation des ressources en eau des puits (« Early Mid-Holocene pastoral well cultures », 4500-4000 BC). À titre d’hypothèse, cette phase précoce d’occupation a pu aboutir au développement des premières « cultures des oasis » de la péninsule Arabique (« Oasis cultures », 4000-35000/3000 BC).
    [Show full text]
  • Durham Research Online
    Durham Research Online Deposited in DRO: 10 December 2018 Version of attached le: Published Version Peer-review status of attached le: Peer-reviewed Citation for published item: Chapman, John (2018) 'Climatic and human impact on the environment? : A question of scale.', Quaternary international., 496 . pp. 3-13. Further information on publisher's website: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2017.08.010 Publisher's copyright statement: c 2017 The Author. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Additional information: Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in DRO • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full DRO policy for further details. Durham University Library, Stockton Road, Durham DH1 3LY, United Kingdom Tel : +44 (0)191 334 3042 | Fax : +44 (0)191 334 2971 https://dro.dur.ac.uk Quaternary International 496 (2018) 3e13 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Quaternary International journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/quaint Climatic and human impact on the environment?: A question of scale John Chapman Durham University,
    [Show full text]
  • English / French
    World Heritage 44 COM WHC/21/44.COM/INF.2 Paris, July/ juillet 2021 Original: English / French UNITED NATIONS EDUCATIONAL, SCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL ORGANIZATION ORGANISATION DES NATIONS UNIES POUR L'EDUCATION, LA SCIENCE ET LA CULTURE CONVENTION CONCERNING THE PROTECTION OF THE WORLD CULTURAL AND NATURAL HERITAGE CONVENTION CONCERNANT LA PROTECTION DU PATRIMOINE MONDIAL, CULTUREL ET NATUREL WORLD HERITAGE COMMITTEE/ COMITE DU PATRIMOINE MONDIAL Extended forty-fourth session / Quarante-quatrième session élargie Fuzhou (China) / Online meeting / Fuzhou (Chine) / Réunion en ligne 16 - 31 July 2021 / 16 – 31 juillet 2021 LIST OF PARTICIPANTS LISTE DES PARTICIPANTS This list is based on the information provided by participants themselves, however if you have any corrections, please send an email to: [email protected] Cette liste est établie avec des informations envoyées par les participants, si toutefois vous souhaitez proposer des corrections merci d’envoyer un email à : [email protected] States Members of the Committee / États membres du Comité ....................................... 7 Australia / Australie ............................................................................................................ 7 Bahrain / Bahreïn ............................................................................................................... 7 Bosnia and Herzegovina / Bosnie-Herzégovine ................................................................. 8 Brazil / Brésil ....................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Textile Revolution. Research Into the Origin and Spread of Wool Production Between the Near East and Central Europe
    Special Volume 6 (2016): Space and Knowledge. Topoi Research Group Articles, ed. by Gerd Graßhoff and Michael Meyer, pp. 102–151. Cornelia Becker – Norbert Benecke – Ana Grabundˇzija – Hans- Christian Küchelmann – Susan Pollock – Wolfram Schier – Chiara Schoch – Ingo Schrakamp – Britta Schütt – Martin Schumacher The Textile Revolution. Research into the Origin and Spread of Wool Production between the Near East and Central Europe Edited by Gerd Graßhoff and Michael Meyer, Excellence Cluster Topoi, Berlin eTopoi ISSN 2192-2608 http://journal.topoi.org Except where otherwise noted, content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0 Cornelia Becker – Norbert Benecke – Ana Grabundˇzija – Hans-Christian Küchel- mann – Susan Pollock – Wolfram Schier – Chiara Schoch – Ingo Schrakamp – Britta Schütt – Martin Schumacher The Textile Revolution. Research into the Origin and Spread of Wool Production between the Near East and Central Europe The objective of the research group Textile Revolution is to contribute to research on the still largely unclear introduction of wool production in later Neolithic and Chalcolithic societies from Western Asia to Central Europe. Since direct evidence of wool depends on rare conditions of preservation,a multi-proxy approach based on different kinds of indirect evidence was chosen. The previous history of research on early wool production as well as the domestication history of sheep are reviewed briefly. Anthropogenic impacts on the landscape, possibly related to intensified grazing, are one kind of indirect evidence that we take into account. For the later part of the presumably long-lasting development of wool production, written sources are available, the earliest of which date to the Late Uruk and Jemdet Nasr periods (end of the 4th to beginning of the 3rd millennium BCE) in Mesopotamia.
    [Show full text]
  • Table of Contents
    Introductory Remarks 5 Preface by the Series Editor................................................... 7 Introductory Remarks ....................................................... 9 Western Anatolia Barbara Horejs Proto-Urbanisation without Urban Centres? A Model of Transformation for the Izmir Region in the 4th Millennium BC ...................................... 15 Ourania Kouka Past Stories – Modern Narratives: Cultural Dialogues between East Aegean Islands and the West Anatolian Mainland in the 4th Millennium BC ...................... 43 Z1/M^&_ New Insights into the Late Chalcolithic of Coastal Western Anatolia: A View from Bakla Tepe, Izmir ....................................................... 65 Sevinç Günel New Contributions Regarding Prehistoric Cultures in the Meander Region: Çine-Tepecik........................................................... 83 Christoph Gerber Iasos, the Carian Chalcolithic and its Relations with Northern Central Anatolia ...... 105 Stephan Blum The Middle Chalcolithic Cultural Sequence of the Troad (Northwest Anatolia): Chronological and Interregional Assessment .................................. 125 Bernhard Weninger – Donald Easton _}<!&9<Z_<~''''+<* Radiocarbon Dating and the Gap ........................................... 157 The Balkans, the Marmara Region and Greece &/ 'Z}}_%%Zth Millennium ....... 203 Agathe Reingruber The Wealth of the Tells: Complex Settlement Patterns and Specialisations in the West Pontic Area between 4600 and 4250 calBC .............................. 217 Svend Hansen
    [Show full text]
  • The Emergence of Cultural Identities and Territorial Policies in the Longue Durée: a View from the Zagros Piedmont
    The emergence of cultural identities and territorial policies in the LONGUE DURÉE: A view from the Zagros Piedmont R. Vallet, J.S. Baldi, M. Zingarello, M. Sauvage, H. Naccaro, C. Paladre, F. Bridey, C. Padovani, K. Rasheed, K. Raeuf and Q. Halkawt Abstract. Since 2015, fieldwork in the Western Qara Dagh (Sulaymānīyah governorate, Iraqi Kurdistan) is opening up new perspectives on the dynamics of interaction between late prehistoric Southern and Northern Mesopotamia. Two sites, Girdi Qala and Logardan, are being investigated with a special focus on three main historical phenomena between 6th and 3rd millennia BC. A first major event is represented by the diffusion of the Ubaid horizon, which appears to occur as a very early process of acculturation between Halaf and Ubaid cultural entities. Then, the so-called Uruk “oikumene” is attested in the Qara Dagh, three centuries earlier than previously documented in Northern Mesopotamia, at the very beginning of the 4th millennium BC. Later, around the middle of the 3rd millennium BC, the emergence of the so-called “Early Dynastic states” is documented at Logardan by the rebuilding of a monumental citadel. Architectural and ceramic data allow us to reassess these three major cultural dynamics, each of which implies specific modalities of interaction between the North and the South. This variable range of relationships shows that simplistic dichotomies between Northern and Southern people or “cultures” are misleading and ineffective. Indeed, as of the Late Prehistory, northern and southern communities have never evolved separately. Résumé. Depuis 2015, la mission pluridisciplinaire du Qara Dagh occidental (gouvernorat de Sulaymānīyah, Kurdistan iraquien) ouvre de nouvelles perspectives sur les dynamiques d’interaction entre la Mésopotamie du Nord et du Sud.
    [Show full text]
  • Biblical World
    MAPS of the PAUL’SBIBLICAL MISSIONARY JOURNEYS WORLD MILAN VENICE ZAGREB ROMANIA BOSNA & BELGRADE BUCHAREST HERZEGOVINA CROATIA SAARAJEVO PISA SERBIA ANCONA ITALY Adriatic SeaMONTENEGRO PRISTINA Black Sea PODGORICA BULGARIA PESCARA KOSOVA SOFIA ROME SINOP SKOPJE Sinope EDIRNE Amastris Three Taverns FOGGIA MACEDONIA PONTUS SAMSUN Forum of Appius TIRANA Philippi ISTANBUL Amisos Neapolis TEKIRDAG AMASYA NAPLES Amphipolis Byzantium Hattusa Tyrrhenian Sea Thessalonica Amaseia ORDU Puteoli TARANTO Nicomedia SORRENTO Pella Apollonia Marmara Sea ALBANIA Nicaea Tavium BRINDISI Beroea Kyzikos SAPRI CANAKKALE BITHYNIA ANKARA Troy BURSA Troas MYSIA Dorylaion Gordion Larissa Aegean Sea Hadrianuthera Assos Pessinous T U R K E Y Adramytteum Cotiaeum GALATIA GREECE Mytilene Pergamon Aizanoi CATANZARO Thyatira CAPPADOCIA IZMIR ASIA PHRYGIA Prymnessus Delphi Chios Smyrna Philadelphia Mazaka Sardis PALERMO Ionian Sea Athens Antioch Pisidia MESSINA Nysa Hierapolis Rhegium Corinth Ephesus Apamea KONYA COMMOGENE Laodicea TRAPANI Olympia Mycenae Samos Tralles Iconium Aphrodisias Arsameia Epidaurus Sounion Colossae CATANIA Miletus Lystra Patmos CARIA SICILY Derbe ADANA GAZIANTEP Siracuse Sparta Halicarnassus ANTALYA Perge Tarsus Cnidus Cos LYCIA Attalia Side CILICIA Soli Korakesion Korykos Antioch Patara Mira Seleucia Rhodes Seleucia Malta Anemurion Pieria CRETE MALTA Knosos CYPRUS Salamis TUNISIA Fair Haven Paphos Kition Amathous SYRIA Kourion BEIRUT LEBANON PAUL’S MISSIONARY JOURNEYS DAMASCUS Prepared by Mediterranean Sea Sidon FIRST JOURNEY : Nazareth SECOND
    [Show full text]
  • Some Important Aspects of Technology and Craft Production in the Indus Civilization with Specific Reference to Gujarat
    Some Important Aspects of Technology and Craft Production in the Indus Civilization with Specific Reference to Gujarat Kuldeep K. Bhan This paper will briefly review the archaeological record of some of the aspects of the craft production in the Indus Tradition from the point of technology, as reflected in manufacturing cycles, possible workshops / activity areas, stock piling and dumping areas so far identified in the available archaeological record of Gujarat. The data presented here is mostly derived from three recently excavated Indus sites by the Department of Archeology and Ancient History, Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda in combination with the data obtained through ethnoarchaeological studies carried on the stone bead making at Khambhat, Gujarat by Jonathan Mark Kenoyer, Massimo Vidale and myself. With the adaption of rigorous excavations with emphasis on the recovery methods along with ethnoarchaeological studies a lot of fresh useful information regarding the various Indus crafts is beginning to get revealed. The study of the crafts and especially Indus Civilization crafts is growing field of investigation, though some South Asian archeologists still prefer to them as ‘miscellaneous small finds’. This fresh data thus obtained is the highlights of this paper. Keywords: Indus Civilization, Technology, Craft Production, Gujarat, Shell working, Beads, Faience. In this paper, I will be discussing some important aspects various industries, but I will confine myself to certain of the current research on craft production in the selected crafts like stone bead making, shell working Harappan phase of the Indus Tradition that corresponds and faience making, with specific reference to the (c. 2600 to 1900 BC) to the Integration Era (as defined in recent data recovered from the Harappan sites of Kenoyer 1991a).
    [Show full text]