DOCSLIB.ORG

House of Assembly Thursday 29 November 2018

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
House of Assembly Thursday 29 November 2018 Thursday 29 November 2018 The Speaker, Ms Hickey, took the Chair at 10 a.m., acknowledged the Traditional People and read Prayers. RECOGNITION OF VISITORS Madam SPEAKER - Honourable members, I am very pleased to introduce everyone in the parliament to the grade 5 and 6 students from Sacred Heart College Catholic School from Ulverstone. It is important to note that this is Mrs Broad's class. Mrs Broad is the wife of our dear Dr Broad. Welcome to parliament, I hope you enjoy it. Members - Hear, hear. QUESTIONS Mr Adam Brooks MP - Integrity Commission Report - Legal Costs Ms WHITE question to PREMIER, Mr HODGMAN [10.04 a.m.] Despite what you say is a golden age, thousands of Tasmanians are struggling to pay the rent, to put food on the table and are facing a bleak Christmas. Yet, taxpayers handed over almost $60 000 to allow millionaire Adam Brooks to lie and to cheat and to bury evidence. Despite Mr Brooks moments ago saying he will pay it back, that $60 000 is more than the average wage of a worker in Braddon who trusted Adam Brooks to represent them. How did you possibly allow this to happen in the first place? ANSWER Madam Speaker, I thank the Leader for the question. I advised the House last evening that the Government had taken advice on this matter. We have received advice from the Solicitor-General about the indemnity that is provided to ministers, when, in the exercise of their duties, they are acting in good faith and entitled, by convention in parliaments across the world, to be indemnified for circumstance in which legal costs are incurred. In this matter, a payment was made two months ago, prior to the Integrity Commission making its final report, a copy of which was received this week and tabled in this parliament this week. Ms O'Byrne - A draft of which you had a month ago. When did you receive the draft of it? Madam SPEAKER - Order, please. Mr HODGMAN - As I advised the House yesterday, in addition to the advice we had received about such matters it was further my intention to review all of Mr Brooks' costs submitted to Government. That was my intention. As has been foreshadowed by the Leader of the Opposition in her question, Mr Brooks will pay all his legal costs incurred in relation to this matter. There will be no cost to the Tasmanian public. I would not have the Tasmanian public have anything other 1 29 November 2018 than the best outcome for it. In this instance the best outcome is for Mr Brooks to pay his legal fees with respect to this matter. Mr Adam Brooks MP - Integrity Commission Report - Legal Costs Ms WHITE question to PREMIER, Mr HODGMAN [10.06 a.m.] You originally forced taxpayers to pay millionaire, Adam Brooks' bills. Yesterday, when you were asked about money paid to this deeply deceitful and dishonest man, you claimed you did not know and delayed giving an answer until a time when you hoped the media would not be watching. Do you expect us to believe that $60 000 worth of taxpayer money was gifted to Mr Brooks two months ago and you did not know about it? ANSWER Madam Speaker, yesterday in response to the question from the Leader of the Opposition I said I would take advice on that matter, including how much had been paid. As is often the case, we want to put facts on the table and that is precisely what we did. The Tasmanian taxpayer will not pay one single cent for Mr Brooks' fees. Mr Adam Brooks MP - Integrity Commission Report - Legal Costs Ms O'CONNOR question to PREMIER, Mr HODGMAN [10.07 a.m.] Can you explain who made the decision to pay the legal costs of a member who is a serial liar and who has brought disrepute on the institution of parliament? Who made the decision and on what basis was it decided that one of this place's wealthiest members, one of whose eight properties is currently on the market for $2.7 million, should have his legal fees for being a serial liar covered by the taxpayer? Mr HIDDING - Point of order, Madam Speaker. Can I ask you, Madam Speaker, to consider the unparliamentary use of the word 'liar'? Speakers have always ruled that it is unparliamentary unless it is in a substantive debate. Yesterday we had a substantive debate and the word was used a thousand times. The whole question has now been sent to a body of the House, the Privileges Committee, and we are now not on the substantive matter. I propose we go back to the standard position which is the use of the word 'liar' is unparliamentary in this circumstance. Madam SPEAKER - I will uphold your point of order on the basis that the use of the word 'liar' is very unparliamentary. Whilst it has been bandied around a lot this week, I request a bit of temperance in the language and respect for the health of Mr Brooks. I will uphold it in this instance and we all need to be little more cautious about the language we use. Ms O'CONNOR - Madam Speaker, on the point of order, I will restate in safer terms for the parliament: who made the decision, Premier, and on what basis, to pay Mr Brooks' legal fees? 2 29 November 2018 ANSWER Madam Speaker, I thank the member for the question. As I have advised the House, the decision made by Government was on the basis of a convention that where a minister acts in good faith, he or she may be entitled to seek indemnity for legal costs incurred. That decision was made prior to the release and tabling of the Integrity Commission report which occurred only this week. Mr Brooks will pay for all legal costs he incurred as a consequence of this investigation. Mr Adam Brooks MP - Integrity Commission Report - Legal Costs Ms WHITE question to PREMIER, Mr HODGMAN [10.10 a.m.] Tasmanians deserve answers as to how it is possible that a millionaire lied to parliament, lied to the people of Tasmania and lied to your face, and then received a $60 000 payment from taxpayers. This goes to the warped priorities of your Government and your entitled 'born to rule' attitude. On what date was the decision made to indemnify Mr Brooks? Did it go to Cabinet and did you authorise the payment? ANSWER Madam Speaker, I repeat the answer I have previously given, which answers that question. The decision was made by Government. There will be no payment to Mr Brooks. He will pay for all his legal fees. Plans for Tasmania Mr HIDDING question to PREMIER, Mr HODGMAN [10.12 a.m.] Can the Premier update the House on how the Hodgman majority Liberal Government has delivered on our plans since the election earlier this year? Ms O'Byrne - How could he possibly know? He doesn't know what happened in Cabinet. He doesn't know if he paid $60 000. How could he possibly know anything? How can we believe a single word you say? Madam SPEAKER - Order, Ms O'Byrne - warning number one. ANSWER Madam Speaker, what I do know is that Tasmania's economy has never been stronger. There are more Tasmanians employed than ever before. Business confidence in our state is at its highest level ever and the highest in the nation. There are many more opportunities for Tasmanians as a result not only of the enterprise and endeavour of Tasmania's business sector and our industry base but also the strong policies that have been implemented by this Government that we delivered in the last four years of a first-term majority Liberal government and are now delivering in the second term. 3 29 November 2018 As we conclude this year, I reflect on the fact that we have been a productive government in getting legislation through this place. We have been working constructively with all those who want to see our state continue to head in the right direction. That does not include opposition parties who try to obstruct this progress. We have been delivering on the commitments we made and took to the election. We have detailed those and updated our progress with reports that are publicly released. We often release updates on our agenda and we are adding to our agenda. In addition to the election commitments we are delivering, we are also doing more to invest in essential services such as in our hospital system that is under increased strain. Where we can, we will do more, and we have. We have an opposition party who, when they demand more of us and we do it, they complain about it. We are also investing more into our education system. It is a fact there are more Tasmanian students now going through their schooling and being able to do so in regional communities to give them the best shot in life. That is a result of the policy we took into the last election and started implementing in our first-term agenda and it is delivering results. Mr O'Byrne - Come on, Peter, help him out. That's right, help him out. Madam SPEAKER - Order, Mr O'Byrne - warning number one. Mr HODGMAN - It is a policy that has been opposed by the Labor Party every step of the way, but it means more Tasmanian students getting the education they need. Opposition and Greens members interjecting.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Dwdtas AGM TUESDAY 22 AUGUST at 1.30 PM NELL PASCOE
    AUGUST 2017 IN THIS ISSUE: DwDTas AGM TUESDAY 22 AUGUST AT 1.30 PM NELL PASCOE ROOM, CRITERION CENTRE, HOBART Meeting will be followed by a discussion to help planning for the State election and the next Bill. Then the usual cuppa and cake. At the AGM, all positions will become vacant – please consider nominating. We need new people to become involved to keep DwDTas active and vital. ‘FADE TO BLACK’ DOCUMENTARY SCREENINGS, FOLLOWED BY Q&A FRIDAY 18 AUGUST, VILLAGE CINEMAS, COLLINS ST, HOBART 2 SESSIONS – ONE AT 4.00 PM AND ONE AT 6.30 PM VOLUNTARY ASSISTED DYING BILL – 24 MAY Thank you to everyone who contributed to the campaign for the Bill - contacting MPs, making the rally a great success, voicing your views in the media, sending us supportive messages and for donations. A very special thanks goes to some very generous donors, including some Committee members and others among our members and supporters, and to Darren and Jody at Resilience Marketing for their great efforts and support. The support deserved a better result but there were positives. The community support for voluntary assisted dying and of the 8 MPs who spoke and voted for the Bill came through stronger than ever. The debate also showed the support in-principle among MPs was much greater than the vote showed. Yes, we are angry, disgusted and disappointed about much of the debate, but will continue with even greater determination for the next Bill - whenever that is. ALSO: News from within Australia - Victoria, NSW, WA and Qld - and from NZ.
    [Show full text]
  • Delivering Our Long-Term Plan for a Brighter Future
    Delivering our long-term Plan for a Brighter Future First year report and second year Plan March 2015 1 Delivering our long-term Plan for a Brighter Future Headed in the right direction Returning to Government after 16 years has been a privilege and an honour, but also a The Hodgman Liberal Government is getting on with the job great responsibility. We inherited a State with significant challenges - an economy that had flat-lined, investment and confidence at record lows and unemployment at a decade-high. of delivering our long-term Plan for a Brighter Future Our immediate priority was to stimulate the economy, restore confidence and create jobs by delivering on our long-term Plan for a Brighter Future. Since the election, nearly 7,000 jobs have been created, and the gap between the Our vision is a Tasmania: Our goals national and State unemployment rate has reduced by more than two thirds. Gross State • That is more self-reliant and open for business, where everyone has the opportunity to Product is increasing again, construction and building activity is soaring, retail trade had enjoy our enviable lifestyle, get a job and raise a family; its strongest year and business confidence is the highest in the nation. The new Government has set itself a range of Our Plan is working, and while it’s early days and there is a lot to be done, there are very • Where we grow the economy and generate wealth so that we can create jobs and ambitious targets and goals, including: encouraging signs for the future.
    [Show full text]
  • Candidates for Tasmanian Election March 2014 (* Sitting Members in Bold )
    Candidates for Tasmanian Election March 2014 (* sitting members in bold ) Electorate of BASS Labor candidates Postal Address Phone Email address Andrew Connor Meander Valley Councillor 0435277745 [email protected] Adam Gore 2ndFl 63 Salamanca place Hobart 7000 0447062436 [email protected] Senka Mujik 2nd Fl 63 Salamanca Place Hobart 7000 62247255 [email protected] Michelle O'Byrne 53 St John St L'ton 7250 63362685 [email protected] Brian Wightman 53 St John St L'ton 7250 63362637 [email protected] Liberal candidates Leonie Mc Nair PO Box 373 Newstead 7250 0418353660 [email protected] Sarah Courtney PO Box 5140 Launceston 7250 0474128838 [email protected] Michael Ferguson PO Box 537 L'ton 7250 63362427 [email protected] Peter Gutwein 4th Fl.Henty HouseL'ton 7250 63362671 [email protected] Barry Jarvis Dorset Councillor [email protected] Green candidates Kim Booth 1st Fl Henty House Civic Sq L'ton 7250 6362294 [email protected] Amy Tyler GPO Box 1132 Hobart 7001 62369334 [email protected] Palmer candidates Chris Dobson Mark Hines Tim Parish George Town Councillor Independent candidates Brett Lucas only listed contact is Facebook Electorate of BRADDON Labor Candidates Darryl Bessell lives in Smithton Brenton Best 68 Rooke St Devonport 7310 64217889 [email protected] Shane Broad C/- Gawler PO Gawler 7315 0418276239 [email protected] Bryan Green 80B Wilson St. Burnie7320 64346252 [email protected] Justine Keay Devonport City Council Alderman [email protected] Liberal Candidates Adam Brooks 64 Wilson St Burnie 7320 64346391 [email protected] Kyron Howell c/- 2/24 Murray St Hobart 7000 62241015 kyron.
    [Show full text]
  • SPECIAL NEWSLETTER - March 2014
    SPECIAL NEWSLETTER - March 2014 VIEWS OF CANDIDATES - TASMANIAN STATE ELECTION 2014 It was very pleasing that we had a much greater response rate than for any other survey of candidates and the increased number of them across Parties who not only support voluntary assisted dying (VAD) legislation, but made comments showing strong support and understanding of the issues. Information on candidates’ views about VAD law reform has come from a variety of sources. This includes votes and speeches in the debate on the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill 2013 (VAD Bill) and survey of many new candidates. Because of our limited resources, we did not contact everyone, particularly those from minor Parties and independents. We did not contact all Greens candidates because we assumed support (please check this directly with any candidates). Kevin Morgan was contacted for the position of the Palmer United Party (PUP) and his own position but did not reply. The only other PUP candidate contacted was Barbara Etter. Craig Davey was contacted for the National Party and his own position but did not reply. We also obtained information from other sources, eg election material and surveys by other groups including religious lobby groups against the legislation, particularly Family Values Australia (FVA) (the re-named Festival of Light).i In the table below, those in support are highlighted. We recommend that you also consider the additional information because in some cases the support was “in principle” and there were provisos which are concerning. In most cases, the quotes are a limited part of their responses. If as a member you would like to see any responses in full, please contact us.
    [Show full text]
  • Building Yourfuture
    Building your future buildingyourfuture.com.au Building your future Elective Surgery Today, after three and a half years of majority Liberal Government, Tasmania is Where we • Waiting lists reduced by 36% since June 2014 Tasmania is heading in the right direction. More Tasmanians than ever are in • Now 5,453 Tasmanians waiting for elective surgery work, with over 10,000 new jobs created since the election. are today • Down from 8,528 in June 2014. heading in the Our hospital elective surgery waiting lists are at record lows and we’ve right direction Unemployment rate Education employed more than 250 nurses and are opening over 100 additional • Unemployment down to 5.8% • Students achieving their Tasmanian Certificate of hospital beds. • Down from 7.5% at the March 2014 State election Education up 8.6% since 2013 Our agriculture, aquaculture and tourism sectors are booming, creating vital and our long term • Tasmania now has the 3rd lowest unemployment • 30 schools now extended to Year 12 and rate of any State enrolments since 2014 up 58% jobs in regional Tasmania. More young Tasmanians are completing Year 12, Plan, including giving them the best possible start in life. Jobs – number of employed Police numbers And our budget is back in balance, meaning we can afford to invest more key targets, • Now 245,600 Tasmanians employed • Police numbers now up to 1204 FTE • Up from 235,100 employed at March 2014 • 84 FTE more than at March 2014 into essential services such as health. State election • Previous Government axed 108 police officers in is on track.
    [Show full text]
  • House of Assembly Thursday 24 May 2018
    Thursday 24 May 2018 The Speaker, Ms Hickey, took the Chair at 10 a.m. and read Prayers. STATEMENT BY SPEAKER Official Photograph Madam SPEAKER - Honourable members, we have a photographer present in the public gallery for the purposes of taking the official Chamber photo. QUESTIONS Child Protection - Total Support Services Ms WHITE question to MINISTER for HUMAN SERVICES, Mr JAENSCH [10.03 a.m.] When were you briefed about very serious allegations made about the for-profit provider, Total Support Services, which has been contracted by your department to care for Tasmanian children in out-of-home care? What did you do about these allegations after you were briefed to ensure the safety of these children? ANSWER Madam Speaker, as I have mentioned in here before, I will not comment on the individual circumstances of children or young people or their families in cases of this kind in this place. We know unfortunately that there will always be a need to bring some children into out-of-home care and when we do bring children into care we seek the most appropriate placement for that child's individual needs and circumstances. Many of the children we are referring to have experienced significant trauma in their lives and have a range of complex behavioural health and disability needs that cannot be met in family-based care arrangements. For these individuals specialist providers are used to respond to their individual therapeutic needs. Total Support Services is one of a number of providers used to provide a range of services to children in need.
    [Show full text]
  • Tasmania's New Cabinet Gives Housing Job to Newcomer Roger Jaensch by Rhiana Whitson Updated Yesterday at 4:24Pm
    Tasmania's new Cabinet gives housing job to newcomer Roger Jaensch By Rhiana Whitson Updated yesterday at 4:24pm PHOTO: Will Hodgman has promoted Roger Jaensch and Sarah Courtney to Cabinet. (ABC News: Scott Ross) Premier Will Hodgman has unveiled his new Cabinet, in which he has given the job of fixing Hobart's housing crisis to the northern MP Roger Jaensch. Despite being down two seats to 13 Lower House MPs, the size of the Cabinet has been returned to nine after it was reduced in the last reshuffle. Mr Hodgman said he made the decisions about who would do which jobs. "This is an opportunity for us to refresh, to put new blood, new experiences, new perspectives into important roles," he said. "This is an opportunity for us to refresh, to put new blood, new experiences, new perspectives into important roles," he said. Mr Jaensch would take on Planning and the difficult portfolio of Human Services. PHOTO: Roger Jaensch has three tough jobs in Housing, Human Services and Planning (ABC News: Scott Ross) Mr Jaensch said as Housing Minister he would need to understand the circumstances that led to people living at the Hobart showgrounds. "I'm open to input and evidence and ideas from all quarters," he said. That leaves Jacquie Petrusma, who during the campaign expressed her desire to stay on as human services minister, to take on Disability Services and Community Development, Aboriginal Affairs, Women, Sport and Recreation. Long-serving MP Rene Hidding will replace Mark Shelton as Speaker. Mr Hodgman will relinquish the role of attorney-general to Elise Archer, who was overlooked by the position, in the last reshuffle.
    [Show full text]
  • House of Assembly Wednesday 23 May 2018
    Wednesday 23 May 2018 The Speaker, Ms Hickey, took the Chair and read Prayers. QUESTIONS Housing - High Rental Prices Ms WHITE question to MINISTER for HOUSING, Mr JAENSCH [10.01 a.m.] The May rental affordability index released today by National Shelter, the Brotherhood of St Laurence and SGS Economics and Planning shows Hobart has now become Australia's least affordable capital city in which to rent, taking that unenviable title from Sydney. It shows average rents in Hobart are now unaffordable even to median rental households on an income of $61 300. The report provides a damning commentary on this Government - There has been a single minded focus on population growth, but a complete lack of vision of where this growth needs to go and how all households are going to be accommodated … for and rising rents for even modest accommodation, is proving unbearable. The consequence is that people are being pushed into homelessness. Do you concede your comment that your Government was 'caught napping' on housing has been proven to be horrifyingly accurate? ANSWER Madam Speaker, Tasmania is experiencing a period of unprecedented economic growth and Tasmanians are more confident about a job than ever before with recent data highlighting that Tasmania's positive economic direction and business confidence now leads the nation. Many Tasmanians are experiencing - Ms O'Connor - What are you the minister for? Madam SPEAKER - Order, Ms O'Connor. Mr JAENSCH - this success and enjoying it. Our Government wants to make sure nobody is left behind. We acknowledge there are real challenges for many Tasmanians on low incomes seeking to buy or rent a house, which is why we convened the housing summit in March and brought together 34 key stakeholders to identify solutions.
    [Show full text]
  • Refreshed Cabinet to Deliver Government's Plan
    20 March 2018 Will Hodgman, Premier Refreshed Cabinet to deliver Government’s Plan The refreshed cabinet I am announcing today provides a blend of experience, passion and new ideas to deliver our Plan to take Tasmania to the next Level. A hallmark of my Government over the past four years has been stability and certainty and this continues in the new cabinet, with myself, Jeremy Rockliff, Peter Gutwein and Michael Ferguson retaining our key portfolios to continue work that is only part way through. At the same time, new members will enter the cabinet, with new experiences, new passion and energy. I will retain the portfolios of Tourism, Events and Hospitality. This sector is truly a driving force of our economy and there is much work ahead to manage the boom in the sector for the benefit of all Tasmanians. I will also add the portfolio of Parks to maximise the synergies between our magnificent natural assets and our tourism sector. In addition, I will take on responsibility for the new portfolio of Trade, to continue to drive economic growth and job creation in our state which is now a prouder, stronger and more confident place. Deputy Premier Jeremy Rockliff will continue with his portfolio of Education. Jeremy is passionate about the sector and wants to continue to work to improve our State’s education outcomes. Jeremy will also take on the critical portfolio of Infrastructure – during the election campaign we promised around $660 million of infrastructure investment over the coming term of Government, and I can think of no one better qualified to roll out this program and literally build Tasmania’s future.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Election Edition - February 2018
    SPECIAL ELECTION EDITION - FEBRUARY 2018 Authorised by the President of Dying with Dignity Tasmania Inc, Margaret Sing, 7 Faraday St, West Hobart Tas 7000 IN THIS ISSUE: • SUMMARY • ADDITIONAL INFORMATION BY ELECTORATE – BASS, BRADDON, DENISON, FRANKLIN AND LYONS • ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON SOURCES OF INFORMATION, SURVEY AND OVERVIEW SUMMARY • The Tasmanian State election will be held on Saturday 3 March 2018. The Hare-Clark electoral system of multi-member electorates gives Tasmanian voters an excellent opportunity to vote for candidates who support voluntary assisted dying legislation. • Candidates most supportive: Based on the 24 May debate and the DwDTas survey of candidates, the following candidates have clearly indicated that they support voluntary assisted dying legislation in-principle AND are likely to vote for or have voted for a Bill similar to the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill 2016: ➢ Bass: (Greens) – all, including sitting member Andrea Dawkins; (Lab) Michelle O’Byrne; Jennifer Houston: (Lib) Bridget Archer ➢ Braddon: (Greens) – all; (Lab) Danielle Kidd, Wayne Roberts ➢ Denison: (Greens) – all, including sitting member Cassy O’Connor; (Lab) Scott Bacon, Tim Cox, Ella Haddad and Zelinda Sherlock; (Lib) Sue Hickey ➢ Franklin: (Greens) – all, including sitting member Rosalie Woodruff; (Lab) Kathryn Barnsley, Alison Standen and David O’Byrne; (Lib) Nic Street ➢ Lyons: (Greens) – all; (Lab) Rebecca White, Kylie Wright, Gerrard Gaffney (may be supportive of VAD Bill; mentioned Victorian law) • Candidates who have said they are supportive in principle but have not (yet) made a commitment to vote for Bill similar to the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill 2016: ➢ Bass – (Lab) Brian Roe (not likely at this time but mentioned Victorian law); Adam Gore; (Lib) Sarah Courtney (voted for the VAD Bill to go to an inquiry, and then against it and did not discuss in detail with DwDTas or proponents beforehand) ➢ Braddon - (Lib) Roger Jaensch (same as for Sarah Courtney) • See additional information to make up your own mind about some other candidates.
    [Show full text]
  • FEBRUARY 2014 in THIS ISSUE, in Brief
    FEBRUARY 2014 We wish all our members and supporters all the best for 2014 - and yet another chance for voluntary assisted dying legislation to be passed! Our first issue for 2014 is the State election, to be held on 15 March, and we would greatly appreciate your help. After the results are known we’ll be in a better position to plan our activities for the year, including the campaign for another voluntary assisted dying Bill which we expect to be introduced into Parliament during the year. Our activities in relation to end-of-life planning will continue through the year. IN THIS ISSUE, in brief: COMING EVENTS: Sunday 2 March, from 12.00 noon, BBQ at Waterworks Reserve. Members and friends are welcome. See details below. RSVP essential by Wed 26 February. First Committee meeting - 12 February, 2.00 pm at the Glenorchy Library. Members are very welcome. STATE ELECTION: Please use your vote to support candidates in favour of voluntary assisted dying law reform. One of the features of the Tasmanian Hare-Clark voting system is that people can vote for their preferred Party but have a choice between candidates within that Party. Please help to gather information on candidates’ views so that we can let voters know to take them into account before they vote. See more information below. THE VOLUNTARY ASSISTED DYING BILL 2013: As you know, despite our considerable work and best efforts, the Voluntary Assisted Dying Bill 2013 was defeated by only one vote before there was a full and open debate on the detailed sections of the Bill.
    [Show full text]