Text, Context, and Identities in Pointe Coupee, Louisiana

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Text, Context, and Identities in Pointe Coupee, Louisiana Louisiana State University LSU Digital Commons LSU Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 2004 Text, context, and identities in Pointe Coupee, Louisiana: six young women positioned as writers Patricia Meeks Smith Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations Part of the Education Commons Recommended Citation Smith, Patricia Meeks, "Text, context, and identities in Pointe Coupee, Louisiana: six young women positioned as writers" (2004). LSU Doctoral Dissertations. 2160. https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations/2160 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at LSU Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in LSU Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized graduate school editor of LSU Digital Commons. For more information, please [email protected]. TEXT, CONTEXT, AND IDENTITIES IN POINTE COUPEE, LOUISIANA : SIX YOUNG WOMEN POSITIONED AS WRITERS A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in The Department of Curriculum and Instruction by Patricia Meeks Smith B.A., University of Tennessee, 1992 M.Ed., Converse College, 1994 Ed.S., Louisiana State University, 1999 May, 2004 © Copyright, 2003 Patricia Meeks Smith All Rights Reserved. ii DEDICATION For David iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I want to thank my committee and the faculty of Louisiana State University for your patience and tolerance while guiding me through the doctoral program in curriculum and instruction. Each of you has added a vital component to my dissertation and my understanding of pedagogy. Thank you, doctoral committee: Professors Claudia Eppert, John May, Petra Munro, William Pinar, and Miles Richardson. Thank you, faculty: Professors Jill Allor, Earl Cheek, and Flo Durway. I especially want to acknowledge the undying faith and support that has been given to me by my advisor and committee chair, Professor Nancy Nelson. I am very proud of the quality of work that she has held me to and extremely proud to say I studied under her at Louisiana State University. I hope to continue in the future both a professional and personal relationship with her and each of the other faculty members. Thank you, Nancy. Thank you to my colleagues, friends, and family for the love and support helped me through this project. Thank you for your support and the discourse we shared: Lane Goutheir, Keitha Pharis, Donna Porche-Frilot, Emma Schorzman, and Sally Tyler. To my husband, David, and children, McKinsey and Killian, thank you for your understanding, support, devotion, and inspiration. In the same breath, I want to also thank my parents, Linda and Dene, for rearing me to one day enjoy the experience and freedom of a professional woman. I also want to also thank my iv college and now adult friends, Karen and Linda: May we grow old together. Thank you to my family for their interest and support: Rusty and Michelle; Tutu and Granddaddy Mooneyhan, and Barbara and Everett; Tutu and Granddaddy Meeks, Patti, and Sandy; Jan and Lynn, Lee, Scott, Jason, Jenn, Sue, Jeff, and Beth. I want to thank my professional colleagues—Mike Dennis, Charmaine Fritchey, Cathy Hicks, Teresa Kerley, Candy McCown, Christy McWilliams, Tina Schwettman, and Bob Warner—who assisted and supported me in editing and my student “assistants”:—Kona, Mandy, Matt C., Matt H., Ryan, Taylor, and Valerie, and the countless other seniors at Cy-Fair High School in Houston, Texas. Most importantly, I want to thank Catholic High School and the community of New Roads for allowing me the opportunity to come into their “place.” I want to thank the principal of the school and the English teacher who allowed me to observe. I am especially grateful to the young women who shared their lives and writings with me, Aaliyah, Aimee Lynn, Bailey, Elle, Hannah, Kayla, and Kendall. I hope to continue to remain friends. v TABLE OF CONTENTS DEDICATION . iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS . .. iv LIST OF TABLES . ix ABSTRACT . x CHAPTER 1 POSITIONS AND PLACE . 1 The Place: Catholic High of Pointe Coupee . 2 The People: Students of Pointe Coupee . 4 My Approach . 7 My "Place" . 9 The Study. .. 10 Purposes of the Study . 12 2 IDENTITY TO IDENTITIES . 13 Identity: From Enlightenment to Modern View . 13 Current Challenges to the Modern Conception . 22 Identity in Writing: From Stable Categories to Multiplicities . 29 Development of Social Identities in Composition . 50 Conclusion . 59 3 CONTEXTUALIZED IN POINTE COUPEE . 62 Early History of the Area………. 65 The Emergence of the "Place" of New Roads . 78 Civil War and Post Reconstruction . 84 The Growth of Pointe Coupee Schools . .. 89 Current Pointe Coupee . .. 96 Conclusion . 97 4 METHODOLOGY OF THE STUDY . 99 Context of the Study . 99 vi Participants . 101 Data Collection Process . 106 Organization Processes for Data Collection . 132 Data Analysis Process . 135 Trustworthiness . .. 149 Conclusion . 154 5 GENDERED POSITIONING: THE MULTIFACETED CHARACTER OF KAYLA'S, AIMEE LYNN'S, AND BAILEY'S WRITINGS . 155 Kayla: Striving for Excellence .. 157 Aimee Lynn: Seeking Distinction from Others . 176 Bailey: Taking Care of "School, Hannah, and Other Things" . 194 Summary and Conclusion . 221 6 POSITIONS ON SELF AND SOCIETY: ISSUES IN THE WRITING OF AALIYAH, ELLE, AND KENDALL . 224 Aaliyah: Seeking Inner Beauty and Peace . 224 Elle: Reconciling Conflicting Selves . 246 Kendall: Pondering Social Justice and Family . 268 Summary and Conclusion . 286 7 TEXT, IDENTITY, AND GENRE OF WRITING . 289 Genre and Writing Instruction . 290 The Genres and Identity Positions . 294 "Positioned" Within the Research . .. 312 Contributions of the Study . .. 314 Conclusion . 317 REFERENCES . 318 APPENDIX A INTERVIEW GUIDE: SAMPLE QUESTIONS . 338 B TEXT-BASED INTERVIEW GUIDE . 340 vii C FACULTY INTERVIEW GUIDE . 341 D KAYLA'S POSITIONS . 342 E AIMEE LYNN'S POSITIONS . 343 F BAILEY'S POSITIONS . 344 G AALIYAH'S POSITIONS . .. 345 H ELLE'S POSITIONS . 346 I KENDALL'S POSITIONS . 347 VITA . 348 viii LIST OF TABLES TABLE 1 School Observation Log: Overview . 109 2 Classroom Observation Log . 112 3 Interview Log . 115 4 Aaliyah's Written Documents . 127 5 Aimee Lynn's Written Documents . 128 6 Bailey's Written Documents . 129 7 Elle's Written Documents . 130 8 Kayla's Written Documents . 131 9 Kendall's Written Documents . 132 ix ABSTRACT Texts are contextualized—tied to times, tied to places, and tied to the people who live in those times and places. This dissertation is based on a study of writing and identity set at Catholic High School in Pointe Coupee, Louisiana. For their senior English class, the six young women participating in the study produced a number of pieces of writing of various types, contrasting in genre, length, content, and register. These kinds of writing represent varying discourse practices, and it was within these practices that the young women positioned themselves or were positioned by influences in their social context. The genres produced by the young women in my study were, for the most part, associated with the familiar school genre, the essay, which is common in English classes and in academic discourse. Essay types were the analytical literary essay, the problem-solution essay (or argument), the process essay, the descriptive essay, and the informative report. The genres also included creative writing, comprising stories and fables for all as well as poetry for some individuals. There were two kinds of writing explicitly addressing experiences and events in individuals' lives: personal narratives, which are a common form in school, and autobiographies, which are less common. One student wrote meditations. In addition, students kept journals, but these had few similarities to journals that people keep in the world outside of school. The inquiry revealed convergence as well as tension among various positions associated with gender, race, class, place, and religion and also showed x evidence of recurring themes and conflicts in writers’ bodies of work. Also apparent, through the analyses, was an influence from genre, writers assuming a particular position when writing in a particular genre and not in others. In addition, there was some evidence of intertextual historydirect connections of texts with prior texts a writer had written. Most interestingly, the various writings showed the students to be dealing with future “possibilities” as well as present and past “realities” in their own lives, not only in writing that is considered to be focused on the self, such as personal narrative, autobiography, and poetry, but also in writing that is not considered to be self-focused, such as literary essays. To summarize, the study shows the multiplicity and flexibility of writing identity even in bodies of work produced for school. xi CHAPTER 1 POSITIONS AND PLACE False River, which is actually a lake, . materializes as an image which one can delve into for introspective purposes. It provides a quiet place to think. It is a place to lose one’s self and to contemplate the world at large. Most importantly, it offers a haven in a hyperactive world. —Elle, “Crystal Clear” Texts arise in and because of contexts, and identities of individuals develop in and because of contexts. Texts and the people who write them are contextualized—tied to times, tied to places, and tied to the people who live in those times and places. Such is the case for Elle, a high school senior who wrote the words that I use as an epigraph for this chapter. To her, False River is a geographical place, but it is more. It is a facet of her own identity. This dissertation is based on a study I conducted in southern Louisiana at Catholic High School in the town of New Roads, Pointe Coupee Parish, as I investigated, during four months in the fall and early winter of 1999, how the writing of Elle and five other young women reflected the various kinds of social affiliations they were negotiating at that time and in that place.
Recommended publications
  • Text, Context, and Identities in Pointe Coupee, Louisiana
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Louisiana State University Louisiana State University LSU Digital Commons LSU Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 2004 Text, context, and identities in Pointe Coupee, Louisiana: six young women positioned as writers Patricia Meeks Smith Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations Part of the Education Commons Recommended Citation Smith, Patricia Meeks, "Text, context, and identities in Pointe Coupee, Louisiana: six young women positioned as writers" (2004). LSU Doctoral Dissertations. 2160. https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_dissertations/2160 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at LSU Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in LSU Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized graduate school editor of LSU Digital Commons. For more information, please [email protected]. TEXT, CONTEXT, AND IDENTITIES IN POINTE COUPEE, LOUISIANA : SIX YOUNG WOMEN POSITIONED AS WRITERS A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in The Department of Curriculum and Instruction by Patricia Meeks Smith B.A., University of Tennessee, 1992 M.Ed., Converse College, 1994 Ed.S., Louisiana State University, 1999 May, 2004 © Copyright, 2003 Patricia Meeks Smith All Rights Reserved. ii DEDICATION For David iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I want to thank my committee and the faculty of Louisiana State University for your patience and tolerance while guiding me through the doctoral program in curriculum and instruction.
    [Show full text]
  • Statewide Student Profile System System Specifications
    Statewide Student Profile System System Specifications August 25, 2003 BoR Statewide Student Profile System Specifications Page 2 LOUISIANA BOARD OF REGENTS Statewide Student Profile System July 15, 2003 Memorandum to Users Due to the development and implementation timeline of the Student Transcript System (Louisiana high school transcript data), the following data elements for academic year 2003-04 (Fall, Winter, or Spring): 1) High School Grade Point Average, 2) High School Percentile Rank, and 3) Board of Regents' Core Flag will: a) NOT be required for in-state students and b) be OPTIONAL for out-of-state students. These elements will become active and required in Fall 2004. Regents' Staff BoR Statewide Student Profile System Specifications Page 3 LOUISIANA BOARD OF REGENTS Statewide Student Profile System Systems Specifications Due Date: Fall Semester/Quarter January 15 Winter Quarter March 15 Spring Semester/Quarter June 15 Summer Semester/Quarter September 15 Report Scope: 14th class day (or equivalent) census of current term enrollment, but collected at the end of term to facilitate the compilation of student level term outcomes. Reporting Medium: (1) The preferred reporting medium is via electronic File Transfer Protocol (FTP). An FTP site has been set up for this purpose. You will need the following information to access the site: Logon ID: anonymous Password: call (225) 342-4253 to obtain current password Format: ASCII with CR+LF following each record IP Address: as400.regents.state.la.us or 198.176.252.98 Filename: SPSINPUT.SPXXYZZ Where; XX = BoR Institution Code Y = Semester/Term ZZ = Academic Year Begin (exclude century) NOTE: After the file has been transmitted, send e-mail to [email protected] indicating the successful upload of the file.
    [Show full text]
  • Salute T O Louisiana Veterans
    A S A LUTE TO L OUI S I A N A V ETER A N S N O V EMBER 9-10, 2007 L OUI S I A N A ST A TE UNI V ER S ITY ✩ H A LL OF H ONOR I NDUCTEE S ✩ Alden L. Andre Captain, U.S. Army Alden L. Andre, a native and resident of Point Coupee Parish, graduated from LSU in 1961 with a bachelor’s degree in basic sciences. Commissioned that same year in the U.S. Army, he served two years on active duty and four years in the Army Reserve, achieving the rank of captain. Following military duty, Mr. Andre joined Baton Rouge Allied Chemical Plant and rose through management ranks until 1978, when the plant was sold to Imperial Chemicals (ICI), and he was immediately promoted to operations manager. ICI was sold to Formosa Plastics in 1981, and he held a number of positions, including plant manager, vice president of operations for Formosa Plastics Corporation USA, vice president of environmental/safety affairs, vice president for new business development, and vice president/general manager of the Baton Rouge plant. He is currently vice president for new business development. Active in community affairs and professional associations, Mr. Andre served in several capacities in the Louisiana Chemical Association and was also a member of the Chlorine Institute Board of Directors. He was a board member of the Greater Baton Rouge Chamber of Commerce and the Louisiana Economic Development Corporation and served as chairman of the Louisiana Process Technology Committee of Governor Mike Foster’s Workforce Development Commission.
    [Show full text]
  • Comprehensive Master Plan 2016
    MOUGEOT ARCHITECTURE 10343 Siegen Lane, Building 7, Suite A Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70810-4981 NEW ROADS, Louisiana COMPREHENSIVE MASTER PLAN 2016 Mougeot Architecture, LLC LJC Planning and Design, LLC Villavaso & Associates, LLC i COMPREHENSIVE MASTER PLAN 2016 NEW ROADS, LOUISIANA Robert Myer, Mayor City Council Anthony Daisy, Mayor Pro-Tem Vernell Davis, District 1 Bernadine St. Cyr, District 1 Kurt Kellerman, District 2 Kirk White, District 2 February 2016 prepared by Mougeot Architecture, LLC in collaboration with LJC Planning and Design, LLC and Villavaso and Associates, LLC i ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Special thanks to the following: Citizens of New Roads Lynette Nelson and the City of New Roads Staff New Roads Planning and Zoning Commission Joyce Benton Stafford Chenevert Arthur Ewing Ben Farrar Melissa Smith New Roads Comprehensive Plan Steering Committee Joyce Benton Les Cantrell Stafford Chenevert Anthony Daisy Arthur Ewing John Ewing Casey Guidry Donna Hammond Gail Hurst Stephen Jewell Joe Langlois Felix Lee Pedro Leonard Tommy Leonard Richard Maciasz Joe Major Brian Pangburn Salvador Rinaudo Paula Rush Theron Smith and Jimmy Laurent, Pointe Coupee Parish Tax Assessor and Staff ii TABLE of CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..............................................................................................................viii I. INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................................I – 1 A. Background and Goals..........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Pointe Coupee Parish Community Resource Guide
    Pointe Coupee Parish Community Resource 2013 Guide QUICK REFERENCE United Way Information and Referral Service…………………………………………………211 Emergency Services…………………………………………………………………………….911 Pointe Coupee General Hospital Emergency Room……………………………….(225) 638-6331 Coroner’s Office……………………………………………………………...……(225) 638-5736 Office of Community Services…………………………………………………….(225) 638-4846 Sheriff Department………………………………………………………………...( 225) 638-5400 Child Protection Office…………………………………………………………….(225) 638-4846 Adult Protective Services (ages 18-59)……………......…………………………..1-800-898-4910 Adult Protective Services (ages 60+)………..…………………………………….1-800-256-4277 Poison Control Center Hotline…………………………………………………….1-800-222-1222 Clerk of Court’s Office…………………………………………………………….(225) 638-9596 COPE Team…………………………………………………...(225) 765-8900 or 1-800-864-9003 Crisis Intervention Center……………………………………..(225) 924-3900 or 1-800-437-0303 Battered Women’s Program…………………………………..(225) 389-3001 or 1-800-541-9706 Louisiana Domestic Violence Hotline…………………………………………….1-888-411-1333 Capital Area Human Service District’s Adult Crisis Team………………………. (225) 922-0631 Transportation Services (Medicaid)……………………………………………….1-800-259-1944 Transportation Services (Public)…………………………………………………..(225) 638-4402 1 | Page TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................................... 1 HISTORY OF POINTE COUPEE PARISH .............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Changes in the Pointe Coupee Parish School System During the Years of School Desegregation 1965-1972
    Louisiana State University LSU Digital Commons LSU Historical Dissertations and Theses Graduate School 1975 Changes in the Pointe Coupee Parish School System During the Years of School Desegregation 1965-1972. Alvin Joseph Fabre Jr Louisiana State University and Agricultural & Mechanical College Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_disstheses Recommended Citation Fabre, Alvin Joseph Jr, "Changes in the Pointe Coupee Parish School System During the Years of School Desegregation 1965-1972." (1975). LSU Historical Dissertations and Theses. 2785. https://digitalcommons.lsu.edu/gradschool_disstheses/2785 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at LSU Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in LSU Historical Dissertations and Theses by an authorized administrator of LSU Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. INFORMATION TO USERS This material was produced from a microfilm copy of the original document. While the most advanced technological means to photograph and reproduce this document have been used, the quality is heavily dependent upon the quality of the original submitted. The following explanation of techniques is provided to help you understand markings or patterns which may appear on this reproduction. 1.The sign or "target" for pages apparently lacking from the document photographed is "Missing Page(s)". If it was possible to obtain the missing page(s) or section, they are spliced into the film along with adjacent pages. This may have necessitated cutting thru an image and duplicating adjacent pages to insure you complete continuity. 2. When an image on the film is obliterated with a large round black mark, it is an indication that the photographer suspected that the copy may have moved during exposure and thus cause a blurred image.
    [Show full text]
  • Statewide Student Profile System System Specifications
    Statewide Student Profile System System Specifications May 02, 2008 LOUISIANA BOARD OF REGENTS Statewide Student Profile System March 01, 2008 Memorandum to Users Beginning Winter/Spring 2007-2008, institutions can report an institutional common id (12 bytes) which can be used to assist in editing the student unit data. The SSN is still a required field, but will not be used to identify students in the Edit/Error reports. The institutional common id will be printed on the reports instead. See Definitions for specific instructions in using the institutional common id. ++++++++++++ October 05, 2004 Memorandum to Users The Student Transcript System (Louisiana high school transcript data) has now been implemented. Therefore, the following data elements are required for Academic Year 2004-2005 (Fall, Winter, and Spring): 1) High School Grade Point Average, 2) High School Percentile Rank, and 3) Board of Regents’ Core Flag These elements are now ACTIVE and REQUIRED in Fall 2004. Please see Appendix I for helpful notes and information. Regents’ Staff ++++++++++++ BoR Statewide Student Profile System Specifications Page 2 July 15, 2003 Memorandum to Users Due to the development and implementation timeline of the Student Transcript System (Louisiana high school transcript data), the following data elements for academic year 2003-04 (Fall, Winter, or Spring): 1) High School Grade Point Average, 2) High School Percentile Rank, and 3) Board of Regents' Core Flag will: a) NOT be required for in-state students and b) be OPTIONAL for out-of-state students. These elements will become active and required in Fall 2004. Regents' Staff +++++++++++++++ BoR Statewide Student Profile System Specifications Page 3 LOUISIANA BOARD OF REGENTS Statewide Student Profile System Systems Specifications Due Date: Fall Semester/Quarter January 15 Winter Quarter March 15 Spring Semester/Quarter June 15 NOTE: As this data will be presented at the first Board of Regents monthly meeting following the above due dates, it is expected that the completed file is received on the above due dates.
    [Show full text]
  • TOPS Program Continues to Deliver on Promises
    Pat A. Strong Robert J. Bruno Chair Richard E. D’Aquin Maurice C. Durbin Scott O. Brame Donna G. Klein Vice Chair Ingrid T. Labat Robert W. Levy Artis L. Terrell, Jr. W. Clinton Rasberry, Jr. Secretary Mary Ellen Roy William Clifford Smith E. Joseph Savoie Victor T. Stelly Commissioner of Harold M. Stokes Higher Education BOARD OF REGENTS Roland M. Toups P. O. Box 3677 James Klock Baton Rouge, LA 70821-3677 Student Member Phone (225) 342-4253, FAX (225) 342-9318 www.regents.state.la.us November 30, 2007 Contact: Kevin Hardy TOPS Program Continues to Deliver on Promises Students who earn a TOPS scholarship are significantly more likely to stay in college and graduate sooner than their fellow students enrolled without TOPS. Moreover, data show that since the advent of TOPS, Louisiana high school students are increasingly more likely to take the more rigorous TOPS Core curriculum, which helps prepare them for career success even if they do not choose to attend college. These facts were part of a report on TOPS, Louisiana’s Tuition Opportunity Program for Students, presented this week by the Board of Regents to the House Education Committee in Baton Rouge. According to the report, 59% of TOPS students at four-year institutions graduate within six years, while their non-TOPS counterparts graduate at a 25% rate. Student retention, the rate at which students persist in college from year to year, is also positively impacted by TOPS. Report data showed that students who enrolled with TOPS in 2003 remained in school for the second year at a rate of 88%, while those without TOPS persisted at rate of 66%.
    [Show full text]