DOCSLIB.ORG

How the Sangre De Cristo Land Grant Became Part Of

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
How the Sangre De Cristo Land Grant Became Part Of THESIS FROM BORDERED LAND, TO BORDERLAND, AND BACK AGAIN: HOW THE SANGRE DE CRISTO LAND GRANT BECAME PART OF THE UNITED STATES, 1844-1878 Submitted by Jacob Swisher Department of History In partial fulfillment of the requirements For the Degree of Master of Arts Colorado State University Fort Collins, Colorado Summer 2020 Master’s Committee: Advisor: Jared Orsi Ann Little Andrea Duffy Sarah Payne Copyright by Jacob Swisher 2020 All Rights Reserved ABSTRACT FROM BORDERED LAND, TO BORDERLAND, AND BACK AGAIN: HOW THE SANGRE DE CRISTO LAND GRANT BECAME PART OF THE UNITED STATES, 1844-1878 From 1844 to 1878, the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant, a one-million-acre parcel in Colorado and New Mexico’s San Luis Valley, experienced a transition from a Ute landscape, to a Ute, Nuevomexicano, and American borderland, and, finally, to an American region. This rapid, thirty-year transformation centered on conflicts between Utes, Nuevomexicanos, and American and European migrants and land speculators over the grant’s borders, including legal, racial, political, economic, and scientific ones. By 1878, the outcome of these border contests was a relatively stable, bordered landscape on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant. Examining this transition as a shift from a Ute bordered land, to a Ute, Nuevomexicano, and American borderland, and, finally, into a bordered, American region not only demonstrates that border contests were central to the expansion of the United States and its settler populations across the American West but also shows how contests over borders have offered important avenues of resistance for local communities in the San Luis Valley in both the past and present. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS For a project like this one, there are certainly too many people to thank—many more than can adequately be listed here. I am grateful to the department of history at Colorado State University, the Rosser Family, and the Charles Redd Center for Western Studies for their financial support of this project. I have also been fortunate enough to embark on a journey into the historical profession at two institutions where I have met faculty and peers who helped me along the way as I became increasingly interested in historical scholarship. To Mary Murphy, Michael Reidy, Mark Fiege, and Janet Ore, thank you for encouraging me to attend graduate school. To Janet Ore, I owe a special thanks for sending me to Colorado State University; my time here has been beyond fruitful. I am particularly grateful for the time and energy that the faculty here at CSU have invested in my education. To Ann Little, Sarah Payne, and Andrea Duffy, thank you not only for being excellent members on a master’s committee but for reading paper drafts and always challenging me to be a stronger thinker. To Michael Childers and Leisl Carr Childers, thank you for offering me valuable scholarly and professional advice and for always keeping your office doors open. I owe a special thank you to Jared Orsi, who has read countless drafts of my work in the past two years and has made me a better thinker and writer. Jared is both a model historian and a model of a good human being; words here cannot fully express my gratitude for the role he has played as my advisor for the past two years. And last, although certainly not least, my biggest thank you is to Tori, who, throughout this project, has remained my most valuable sounding board and source of support as she has also been working to complete her own master’s degree. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................... ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................................... iii LIST OF TABLES ...........................................................................................................................v LIST OF FIGURES ....................................................................................................................... vi Introduction ......................................................................................................................................1 “On Borderlands”.................................................................................................................4 Mapping Beyond the Archive: Environmental and Spatial History on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant ..............................................................................................................13 Scope of Study ...................................................................................................................17 A Note on Terminology .....................................................................................................21 Chapter 1 – From Bordered Land to Borderland: The Unmaking of Ute Space in the San Luis Valley, 1200 to 1868 ......................................................................................................................23 The Indigenous Southwest .................................................................................................27 Nuevomexicano Borders in the Ute Bordered Land ..........................................................36 The Demise of the Ute Bordered Land ..............................................................................48 Conclusion .........................................................................................................................63 Chapter 2 – Bordering the Ute-Nuevomexicano Borderland, 1864-1878 .....................................65 Scientific Borders...............................................................................................................69 Racial Borders ....................................................................................................................77 Legal Borders .....................................................................................................................85 Conclusion .........................................................................................................................92 Chapter 3 – Migration, Labor, and Environment on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant .................95 Ecology and Human Geography ........................................................................................98 The Geography of Production ..........................................................................................113 Race and American Economic Borders on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant .................122 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................131 Conclusion – From Bordered Land, to Borderland, and Back Again ..........................................133 From Bordered Land to Borderland .................................................................................138 The Internal Borderlands of U.S. History ........................................................................141 Bibliography ................................................................................................................................145 iv LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Precipitation (inches) in the San Luis Valley, 1848 to 1855 ...........................................50 Table 2. High-frequency terms in Blackmore’s Colorado ............................................................74 v LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Map of Colorado Embracing the Central Gold Region, 1869 ........................................22 Figure 2. Network of Property Transfers in Costilla County, 1862-1864 .....................................44 Figure 3. Reconstructed Drought Severity, North America, 1851 ................................................51 Figure 4. Fort Massachusetts Viewshed Analysis .........................................................................55 Figure 5. Fort Garland Viewshed Analysis....................................................................................55 Figure 6. “Map of the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant Situate in the San Luis Valle, Colorado Territory,” No Date ........................................................................................................................76 Figure 7. “Map of the Trenchara and Costilla Estates Forming the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant Situate in the San Luis Valley, Colorado Territory,” No Date ............................................87 Figure 8. Map Showing the Blue Grama Grass Habitat Range on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant ............................................................................................................................................101 Figure 9. Map Showing the Hydrology of the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant ..............................103 Figure 10. Map Showing Travel Time from Costilla ..................................................................105 Figure 11. Map Showing Travel Time from Fort Garland ..........................................................107 Figure 12. Map Showing Grazing Area for Sheep on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant .............109 Figure 13. Map Showing Grazing Area for Cattle on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant .............112 Figure 14. Map Showing Water Claims on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant.............................117 Figure 15. Map Showing Nuevomexicano Population Density on the Sangre de Cristo Land Grant ............................................................................................................................................128
Load more

Recommended publications
  • An Environmental History of the Middle Rio Grande Basin
    United States Department of From the Rio to the Sierra: Agriculture Forest Service An Environmental History of Rocky Mountain Research Station the Middle Rio Grande Basin Fort Collins, Colorado 80526 General Technical Report RMRS-GTR-5 Dan Scurlock i Scurlock, Dan. 1998. From the rio to the sierra: An environmental history of the Middle Rio Grande Basin. General Technical Report RMRS-GTR-5. Fort Collins, CO: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station. 440 p. Abstract Various human groups have greatly affected the processes and evolution of Middle Rio Grande Basin ecosystems, especially riparian zones, from A.D. 1540 to the present. Overgrazing, clear-cutting, irrigation farming, fire suppression, intensive hunting, and introduction of exotic plants have combined with droughts and floods to bring about environmental and associated cultural changes in the Basin. As a result of these changes, public laws were passed and agencies created to rectify or mitigate various environmental problems in the region. Although restoration and remedial programs have improved the overall “health” of Basin ecosystems, most old and new environmental problems persist. Keywords: environmental impact, environmental history, historic climate, historic fauna, historic flora, Rio Grande Publisher’s Note The opinions and recommendations expressed in this report are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the USDA Forest Service. Mention of trade names does not constitute endorsement or recommendation for use by the Federal Government. The author withheld diacritical marks from the Spanish words in text for consistency with English punctuation. Publisher Rocky Mountain Research Station Fort Collins, Colorado May 1998 You may order additional copies of this publication by sending your mailing information in label form through one of the following media.
    [Show full text]
  • Colorado History Chronology
    Colorado History Chronology 13,000 B.C. Big game hunters may have occupied area later known as Colorado. Evidence shows that they were here by at least 9200 B.C. A.D. 1 to 1299 A.D. Advent of great Prehistoric Cliff Dwelling Civilization in the Mesa Verde region. 1276 to 1299 A.D. A great drought and/or pressure from nomadic tribes forced the Cliff Dwellers to abandon their Mesa Verde homes. 1500 A.D. Ute Indians inhabit mountain areas of southern Rocky Mountains making these Native Americans the oldest continuous residents of Colorado. 1541 A.D. Coronado, famed Spanish explorer, may have crossed the southeastern corner of present Colorado on his return march to Mexico after vain hunt for the golden Seven Cities of Cibola. 1682 A.D. Explorer La Salle appropriates for France all of the area now known as Colorado east of the Rocky Mountains. 1765 A.D. Juan Maria Rivera leads Spanish expedition into San Juan and Sangre de Cristo Mountains in search of gold and silver. 1776 A.D. Friars Escalante and Dominguez seeking route from Santa Fe to California missions, traverse what is now western Colorado as far north as the White River in Rio Blanco County. 1803 A.D. Through the Louisiana Purchase, signed by President Thomas Jefferson, the United States acquires a vast area which included what is now most of eastern Colorado. While the United States lays claim to this vast territory, Native Americans have resided here for hundreds of years. 1806 A.D. Lieutenant Zebulon M. Pike and small party of U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • 7 Aug-Sep 2018.Pages
    Pike National Historic Trail Association Newsletter Aug/Sep — 2018 Vol. 12 No. 7 The New Pike Website is about to be checked and will soon be launched we trust in October. Our website designer currently is caring for the technical end of her design. The website (www.zebulonpike.org) was created by the Santa Fe Trail Association and given to us 10 years ago. We have altered it somewhat but it focuses basically on Pike’s 2nd Expedition (1806-7) since the Santa Fe Trail Association owned the website for the Pike Bicentennial. The new website has been updated with current information about the Pike National Historic Trail Association. Persons on the Board and State Coordinators, for example, has changed over these 10 years. We have altered our MISSION to include Pike’s a. Early Life, b. 1st (Mississippi River 1805-6) Expedition, and Later Life as well as the 2nd Expedition. A great deal has been added together with Pike Field Maps and modern maps to reflect our Mission. Because smartphones (iPhones and Android) as well as iPads have evolved over the 10 years, our new look website had to be altered to allow for the use of these devices. You will be able to see our website on your smartphone and it will fit on the phone screen. The ability to donate and pay for membership by credit card or PayPal has been also been added. Once the new design and content is checked and approved by us the old website will be taken down and replaced by the new one.
    [Show full text]
  • ETHNOGRAPHIC OVERVIEW DRAFT #2 Colorado National Monument Sally Mcbeth February 26, 2010
    ETHNOGRAPHIC OVERVIEW DRAFT #2 Colorado National Monument Sally McBeth February 26, 2010 written in consultation with the Northern Ute ETHNOGRAPHIC OVERVIEW DRAFT #2 Colorado National Monument Sally McBeth February 26, 2010 written in consultation with the Northern Ute Submitted to the National Park Service Cooperative Agreement # H1200040001 (phases I and II) and H1200090004 (phase III) ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The generosity of many Ute friends, whose willingness to share their stories, remembrances, and recollections with me cannot go unacknowledged. I treasure their rich and profound understandings of ancestral landscape shared with me over the past three years. These friends include, but are not limited to Northern Ute tribal members (alphabetically): Loya Arrum, Betsy Chapoose, Clifford Duncan, Kessley LaRose, Roland McCook, Venita Taveapont, and Helen Wash. Their advice and suggestions on the writing of this final report were invaluable. Special thanks are due to Hank Schoch—without whose help I really would not have been able to complete (or even start) this project. His unflagging generosity in introducing me to the refulgent beauty and cultural complexity of Colorado National Monument cannot ever be adequately acknowledged. I treasure the memories of our hikes and ensuing discussions on politics, religion, and life. The critical readings by my friends and colleagues, Sally Crum (USFS), Dave Fishell (Museum of the West), Dave Price (NPS), Hank Schoch (NPS-COLM), Alan McBeth, and Mark Stevens were very valuable. Likewise the advice and comments of federal-level NPS staff Cyd Martin, Dave Ruppert, and especially Tara Travis were invaluable. Thanks, all of you. Former Colorado National Monument Superintendant Bruce Noble and Superintendant Joan Anzelmo provided tremendous support throughout the duration of the project.
    [Show full text]
  • A TIMELINE for GOLDEN, COLORADO (Revised October 2003)
    A TIMELINE FOR GOLDEN, COLORADO (Revised October 2003) "When a society or a civilization perishes, one condition can always be found. They forgot where they came from." Carl Sandburg This time-line was originally created by the Golden Historic Preservation Board for the 1995 Golden community meetings concerning growth. It is intended to illustrate some of the events and thoughts that helped shape Golden. Major historical events and common day-to-day happenings that influenced the lives of the people of Golden are included. Corrections, additions, and suggestions are welcome and may be relayed to either the Historic Preservation Board or the Planning Department at 384-8097. The information concerning events in Golden was gathered from a variety of sources. Among those used were: • The Colorado Transcript • The Golden Transcript • The Rocky Mountain News • The Denver Post State of Colorado Web pages, in particular the Colorado State Archives The League of Women Voters annual reports Golden, The 19th Century: A Colorado Chronicle. Lorraine Wagenbach and Jo Ann Thistlewood. Harbinger House, Littleton, 1987 The Shining Mountains. Georgina Brown. B & B Printers, Gunnison. 1976 The 1989 Survey of Historic Buildings in Downtown Golden. R. Laurie Simmons and Christine Whitacre, Front Range Research Associates, Inc. Report on file at the City of Golden Planning and Development Department. Survey of Golden Historic Buildings. by R. Laurie Simmons and Christine Whitacre, Front Range Research Associates, Inc. Report on file at the City of Golden Planning and Development Department. Golden Survey of Historic Buildings, 1991. R. Laurie Simmons and Thomas H. Simmons. Front Range Research Associates, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Colorado Southern Frontier Historic Context
    607 COLORADO SOUTHERN FRONTIER HISTORIC CONTEXT PLAINS PLATEAU COUNTRY MOUNTAINS SOUTHERN FRONTIER OFFICE OF ARCHAEOLOGY AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION COLORADO HISTORICAL SOCIETY COLORADO SOUTHERN FRONTIER HISTORIC CONTEXT CARROL JOE CARTER STEVEN F. MEHLS © 1984 COLORADO HISTORICAL SOCIETY FACSIMILE EDITION 2006 OFFICE OF ARCHAEOLOGY AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION COLORADO HISTORICAL SOCIETY 1300 BROADWAY DENVER, CO 80203 The activity which is the subject of this material has been financed in part with Federal funds from the National Historic Preservation Act, administered by the National Park Service, U.S. Department of the Interior and for the Colorado Historical Society. However, the contents and opinions do not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the U.S. Department of the Interior or the Society, nor does the mention of trade names or commercial products constitute an endorsement or recommendation by the Department of the Interior or the Society. This program receives Federal funds from the National Park Service. Regulations of the U.S. Department of the Interior strictly prohibit unlawful discrimination in departmental Federally assisted programs on the basis of race, color, national origin, age or handicap. Any person who believes he or she has been discriminated against in any program, activity, or facility operated by a recipient of Federal assistance should write to: Director, Equal Opportunity Program, U.S. Department of the Interior, 1849 C Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20240. This is a facsimile edition of the original 1984 publication. Text and graphics are those of the original edition. CONTENTS SOUTHERN FRONTIER Page no. 1. Spanish Dominance (1664-1822) .• II-1 2. Trading �nd Trapping (1803-1880) .
    [Show full text]
  • Bent's Fort Primary Resource
    1 Bent’s Fort: Trade in Transition How did family relationships influence trade relationships on the southern Colorado plains? What role did Bent’s Fort play in the westward expansion of the United States? What does the story of Bent’s Fort suggest about the relationship between trade and war among American Indians and Colorado settlers? By Jennifer Goodland* Standards and Teaching Strategies by: Corey Carlson, Zach Crandall, and Marcus Lee** Paid for by a grant from the Institute of Museum and Library Sciences * Jennifer Goodland has a master’s in history from University of Colorado Denver, where she concentrated on history tourism and the American West. She taught history at Metro State in Denver. Goodland runs a history research business called Big Year Colorado. ** Corey Carlson teaches 4th grade at Flatirons Elementary in Boulder, Zach Crandall teaches 8th grade U.S. Society at Southern Hills Middle in Boulder, Marcus Lee teaches and is the chair of the social studies department at George Washington High School in Denver. 2 Contents Standards Addressed Overview Essay Resources Growing the Border 1. The Louisiana Purchase and Missouri Territory 2. Bent and St. Vrain Families 3. Colorado’s Changing Borders 4. Bent’s Fort and the Border 5. Cheyenne Territory Travel and Trade 6. Bent’s Fort Floor Plan 7. Fur Trappers and the Bent, St. Vrain and Company Network 8. Jean-Baptiste Charbonneau 9. Fugitive at Bent’s Fort 10. Mexico Retaliates 11. Battleground: Bent’s Fort 12. Kearny’s March 13. Rebellion in Taos 14. Cut Off 15. Destruction of the Fort 16.
    [Show full text]
  • The Culebra River Villages of Costilla County, Colorado
    NPS Form 10-900-b ,$$.»,- term/en «*, » ITO No. 1024-0018 (Revised March 1992) United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Multiple Property Documentation Form This form is used for documenting multiple property groups relating to one or several historic contexts. See instructions in How to Complete the Multiple Property Documentation Form (National Register Bulletin 16B). Complete each item by entering the requested information. For additional space, use continuation sheets (Form 10-900-a). Use a typewriter, word processor, or computer, to complete all items. X New Submission Amended Submission A. Name of Multiple Property Listing The Culebra River Villages of Costilla County, Colorado B. Associated Historic Contexts (Name each associated historic context, identifying theme, geographical area, and chronological period for each.) The Culebra River Villages of Costilla County: Village Architecture and Its Historical Context, 1851-1964. C. Form Prepared by name/title Maria Mondragon-Valdez______________________________ organization Valdez & Associates date June 1. 2000 street & number Rt. 1 Box 3-A telephone 719-672-3678 city or town San Luis state Colorado zip code 81152_____ D. Certification As the designated authority under the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966,1 hereby certify that this documentation form meets the National Register documentation standards and sets forth requirements for listing of related properties consistent with the National Register criteria. This submission meets the procedural and professional requirements set forth in 36 CFR Part 60 and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards and Guidelines for Archaeology and Historic Preservation. (See continuation sheet for additional comments [ ].) t^^jL*^J^LJ/W4^G<^ <^V^l^'L£^ ZC^.
    [Show full text]
  • Contents from the Editor
    Volume 15 Spring 2009 No.2 OSTA 2009 Annual Conference Contents From the Editor . 1 The conference will be held at the Sky Ute Resort in Ignacio, CO, June President’s Corner . 3 6-7, 2009. The schedule includes a meeting of the OSTA board on June Articles 5, symposium speakers, the annual OSTA membership business meeting, Sheep Trade in New Mexico and a banquet with entertainment on June 6, and field trips to local historic (Baxter) . .5 sites on June 7. OSTA’s Colorado Director Pat Fluck is coordinating the Sabanilla Weaving and Colcha event, with assistance from James Jefferson of the Southern Ute Nation. For Stitching conference schedule, see pages 34-35. (Henderson) . 16 Spanish Trail Treasure (S. A. Matheson) . 20 From the Editor Establishment of the Old Spanish Trail Park in Las Vegas First, some good news. The Old Spanish Trail Park in Las Vegas was (Saines) . .36 officially dedicated this past November. Nevada Director Nick Saines’ News from the Trail article on page 36 gives the details. Congratulations, Nick! OSTA has Favorite OST Photos . 18 also received a request for Trail photos from National Geographic Books Chapter Reports . .26 for their upcoming book, Complete National Parks, which will include Traces Survey . 31 many National Historic Trails. Finally, I have contacted the producer of OSTA Contributions & Taxes . 33 a long-running California Public Broadcasting program, “Huell Howser’s Rituals & Societies, Taos Library 33 Road Trip,” about highlighting the OST. He said Mr. Howser was very Conference Schedule . 34 interested in doing a program on the OST and asked if we could suggest Reviews five to six stops on the Trail in California for him to visit.
    [Show full text]
  • Bent's Fort Chapter Santa Fe Trail Association
    Bent’s Fort Chapter Santa Fe Trail Association April 2013 Newsletter January Annual Meeting Draws a Full House DON’T Our Bent's Fort Chapter began its 19th Taos. Details of the tours can be found FORGET year with a great meeting at the John in our January newsletter. (You can These W. Rawlings Heritage Center in Las read this newsletter online by going to Future Animas on January 19th. Over 75 www.santafetrail.org, click on Chap- Events ters, the Colorado chapter, and then click on our newspaper link.) One of the highlands of the day came with the presentation of the 2012 Mem- April 13: BFC annual ber of the Year Award which went to clean-up day at Boggsville Pat Palmer, our President. During Pat's May 18: Tour of his- leadership our chapter has grown and toric sites on PCMS prospered and is now the largest chap- (Note: this tour is full) ter along the Santa Fe Trail. Probably it June 8: Tour of his- is also the most active one. toric sites on private ranches between La members and guests shared a catered Junta and Trinidad lunch and then heard Santa Fe Trail July 20: presentation Association President Roger Slusher on the Cherokee Trail give a presentation on James Aull, a prominent mer- chant and trader on Inside this issue… the Santa Fe Trail Annual Meeting during the 1830's. Trail Marking Roger lives in Lex- BFC Vests ington, Missouri, 79th Annual Santa Fe the home of the Trail Day in Las Animas Aull brothers, and Our chapter ended 2012 with 136 paid has done extensive The Civil War in the Ar- memberships.
    [Show full text]
  • Railroad Conflicts in Colorado in the 'Eighties*
    Railroad Conflicts in Colorado in the 'Eighties* .WILLIAM S. JACKSON This year of 1945 marks the 75th anniversary of the coming of the first railroads to Denver and Colorado-the Denver Pacific and the Kansas Pacific-now both part of the Union Pacific system. It also marks the 75th anniversary of the founding of the Denver & Rio Grande Railway Company, which has been so interestingly celebrated this fall. References were made to the beginnings of the three railroad systems that located their lines in Colorado in the 'seventies and that have surYived to this day: the Union Pacific, the Denver & Rio Grande, and the Atchison, Topeka & Santa F'e, in the order named. The railroads in Colorado seem almost consciously to have written their two opening chapters by even decades. Their first conveniently began with a new calendar decade in 1870. And to celebrate the close of that first ten year period, the Denyer & Rio Grande and the Santa Fe, after their lines had met at Pueblo, staged the famous battle for possession of the Royal Gorge which involved armed warfare as well as two years of bitter litigation in both federal and state courts. The story of this contest is a chapter in itself.1 Its historical importance is in the fact that it deflected the Denver & Rio Grande from its southward course to Mexico City westward into the mountain country, and the Santa Fe in turn gave up its attempt to follow the Arkansas River above Canon City aud turned its line southwestward. Those two rail­ roads thereupon entered into their first tri-partite agreement with the Union Pacific, and the reader may be left with the impression *This is the address that was given by Justice Jackson of the Colorado Supreme Court at the Annual Meeting of the State Historical Society, December 11, 1945.-Ed.
    [Show full text]
  • PASSAIC COUNTY TECHNICAL INSTITUTE US HISTORY II HONORS 2019-2020 Summer Project Assignment
    PASSAIC COUNTY TECHNICAL INSTITUTE US HISTORY II HONORS 2019-2020 Summer Project Assignment Welcome to US History II Honors! Your Summer Assignment is due Monday, September 23, 2019. Please read the following sets of documents this summer: Chapter 17: Document Set 1: The Native American Presence: The Massacre at Sand Creek. Answer all the “Questions for Analysis”. Please write each question first then the answer. Please type of all your work and use your own words to answer each question. Have a great summer!!! See you in September. CHAPTER 17 DOCUMENT SET 1 The Native American Presence: The Massacre at Sand Creek Questions for Analysis 1. What do the documents reveal about the Native Americans involved in the conflict at Sand Creek? How would you assess the military's understanding and perception of the Indians' intentions? To what extent were Chivington's and Evans's actions justified? 2. What do the events at Sand Creek tell us about the nature of Indian warfare on the Great Plains and the status of white relations with the Native American population in the nineteenth century? Do the documents speak to the matter of human weaknesses or strengths? 3. Why do you think Sand Creek became a political issue in 1864-1865? What do the documents suggest concerning the search for causes and the assignment of ultimate responsibility? Were the criticisms in the congressional report justified? 4. Why were Black Kettle, White Antelope, and their followers encamped at Sand Creek? What does their presence suggest about the Native American situation in 1864 and the white advance? Did the Cheyenne and Arapahos have a right to I hold any land? What land? Why or why not? What realistic alternatives were there to Indian dependency on the white government? 1 5.
    [Show full text]