CATHOLIC WORKER

Sub1cription1 Yol. XXXI No. 5 DECEMBER, 1964 25o P1r Vear Price le Protest Vietnam War Dec. 19th Throughout the nation on Satur­ day, December 19th there will be a concerted action by the peace groups to end the war in Vietnam. Cooperating groups are: THE CATHOLIC WORKER; COMMIT· TEE FOR NON-VIOLENT AC· .TJON; FELLOWSIDP OF RECON­ CILIATION; SOCIALIST PARTY; STUDENT PEACE UNION; STU· DENTS FOR A DEMOCRATIC SOCIETY; WAR RESISTERS LEAGUE and WOMEN'S STRIKE FOR PEACE. These groups are appealing to President Johnson to declare an immediate cease fire on the' part ol American forces in South Vietnam, followed by their earliest po sible withdrawal. Fur­ ther, the cooperating groups urge the immediate convening of a con­ ference ol those nations concerned, including both mainland China and the United States, and that the Conference seek: (1) To secure co­ operative action in a program of relief and rehabilitation, carried on through neutral auspices, and di­ rected toward bringing swift and compassionate economic and medi­ cal aid to the terribly ,.avaged peo­ ple of outh Vietnam; (2) To se~ cure an independent and neutral government in South Vietnam through free elections in which democratic, trade union, and reli­ gious forces can all have an effec­ tive voice; (3) To insure that the associated states of what was for­ merly French Indochina

"The main difticulty in eliminat­ ing armaments is found in the measure of our ability to substitute some other equally strong or stronger and more efficient means of defense than that of being Christinas EpiStle armed • . • Jt is urgent and indis­ pensable that the people should understand the danger and take Beloved: The grace of God, our Savior, has dawned on all men alike, part in protests in the most active possible way against the lunatic schooling us to forgo irreverent thoughts and worldly appetites, and to possibilities which threaten the ex­ live, in the present world, a life of order, of justice, and of holiness. istence of all of us." Danilo Doiel We were to look forward, blessed in our hope, to a day when there will be a new dawn of glory, the glory of our Savior Jesus Christ; who "If you do not specify and con­ front real Issues, what you say gave himself for us, to ransom us from our guilt, a people set apart will merely obscure them. If you do not alarm anyone morally, you for himself, ambitious of noble deeds. Be this thy message, this thy will yourself remain morally asleep. If you do not embody con­ encouragement in Christ Jesus our Lord. troversy, what you say will be an Titus 2. 11-15 acceptance of the drUt to the com­ ing human heJJ." C. Wright Mills Page Two THE CATHOLIC WORKER December, 1964 YoL XXI ,,o. J December, 1964 The Morality Of ciniouc ~WORKER Published Monthly September to .June, Bl-monthly .July-A111u& Thermonuclear Deterrence ORGAN OF THE CATHOLIC WORKER MOVEMENT PETER !WAURJN, l<'ounder By JAMES W. DOUGLASS DOROTHY DAY, Editor •nd Publisher During last year's Military Pro­ between combatant and non-com­ land's best-known Catholic the­ MARTIN J. CORBIN, Managing Editor curement Authorization Hearings, batant and the obligation to pre­ ologians, Dr. L. L. McReavy, made Associate Editors: a Senator requested that a speech serve the rights of the innocent, the statement in 1958 that " In no CLARE BEE, CHARLES BUTTERWORTH, THOMAS CORNELL, relating current defense policy to rights obviously transgressed by circumstances, not even save EDGAR FORAND, JUDITH GREGORY, WILLIAM HORVATH, to WALTER. KERELL, KARL MEYER, DEANE MOWRER, HELEN C. the Christian just war doctrine be "the pure and simple annihilation the Westea-n world from being RILEY, ARTHUR SHEEHAN, ROBERT STEED, ANNE TAILLEFER, inserted into the record. He was of all human life within the radius swamped by atheistic communism, EDWARD TURNER, STANLEY VISHNEWSKI. quick to note, however, that he of action." Since few Protestant will it e'7er be lawful to explode New subscriptions and change of address: agreed only with some obliteration bomb­ ever justify the use of megaton a negation a creation. A stark, Is never broken except to shoat ing oroperty of nity seems therefore to be ap­ job is to make the fact ol Christ In both books we find the ab­ gard to nuclear war. Almost 1111 proaching unanimity on at least real to people who have se.ntimen- surdity of a world preoccupied the innocent) cannot be C01I11Pen­ moralists are agreed on the gen­ one limitation of means by which tallzed Christ in order to destroy with God balanced against a world sated for by a problematical, spec­ eral . principle that the< dockine tihe justice of a prospective nu­ HIM, who wish to imitate the sen- -emptied Qf all save materialiistic ulative, future good (the winning does establish certain limits of 'de­ or shortening ot the war). clear war can be measured: ther­ timentalized Christ liut not to be- preoccupation; they deny one an­ fense, and that nuclear war to be lieve in any Christ. They are at other, the confrontation is gro­ This limitation of means estab­ monuclear weapons must never be just must conform w them. The used against population centers palns to establish a relirion with- tesque. And the author, with her lished by Ford in terms of World case foe a "just nuclear war" cis War II - the moral immunity of no matter what the provocation. out teeth, a Church without Christ. inimitable combination of fero­ argued by scaling down the pros­ Falib is really our cross in the cious irony and of sense of the civilian areas from massive bomb­ Such an act involves necessarily, pective conflict to the moral the­ modern world ana I am concerned sacred, 1 pits the semi-literate ing-has been brought up to date through its very nature, a direct ory's limits, not by opening u11 with how people try to get-rid of it. atheist or the sensualist against -by his more recent analysis of intention o saint left within the radius --of action. This least, the immorality Of total war.'' weapon, is enough to suggest that 1tbeh' pitiful distdriions but at ·the and the whole small world has la not 1 permitted Jor any reason -This finding · !seems· consistent our greatest •moral problem lies !same ·time r the' .trot! •core · of 'faith been delivered to evil, it .Js the whatsoever." t wifu the teaching df Pius' X:U ahd not •SO much in deciding whether •iebiiad them. b makes him a syfn. writer who becomes1the , saint. By 'Phe Pope• was -here realfirfning has been confirmed by the' 'W'Qrk we can justify such carna~e · as. it patbetic ~ Judgo. , I have been de- I • ( Contlhued 1froml page T) • the classic just war • distinction.. of other JIJPr&lists.· One ot Eng- (Continued !on page 8) · ------r -

December,' 1964 TH-E CATHOLIC WORKER Page Three

Friday Night Meetings· Farm With A View In accordance with P e t e r By DEANE MARY MOWRER Maurin's desire for clarification By On the second Sunday of Ad- home-making type, will decide to of thought, THE CATHOLIC vent, when Bob Stewart was driv- try community living, here on this ~WORKER holds meetings every 1131 S. 1st W. A rich ~8:" ~;:ends nearly half of Ing us in the high-seated Travel-all farm with a view. Friday night at 8:30 p.m. at St. Salt Lake City, utah 1 (which one of our retreatants last We were Also grateful this Joseph's House, 175 Chrystie St., On Thanksgiving Day we had Chasing a little w~ite ball. summer said ·resembles an old- Thanksgiving for several food between Houston and Delancey thirty men sleeping on the floor. But the rich man says that Pig fashioned stage coach) to the 11:30 donations-a large donation of Streets. Three of these are young men who "It's a HP~~!:w ;:.~~~ g~~e crooks Mass at St. Sylvia's in Tivoli, Rita groceries from Herman Bookjans, After the discussions, we con- have been here for a week or Corbin and Mary O'Neil looked a neighbor in Tivoli; and some tinue the talk over hot sassafras more working at the Mormon Re- . rendezvous." . about them and exclaimed at the sizable donations Of canned goods tea. Everyone is welcome. lief for clothing and bringing home But don't you suppose if you burned Mormon br ead and other extra- down the bank beauty of the Decemlier morning from Our Lady of Angels Semin- food. Bob and Slim have been here You'd flush out a scoundrel or two? scene-the sun-glinting lakelike ary in Albany and Our Lady of for sev·eral months and help out h · beauty of the Hudson River, the Lourdes High School in Pough- 1-f ~~~TIJ E with the housework. One young A Man W o Never Died sun-bright majesty of t he moun- keepsie. It was a cause of thanks- man from New England noticed On the F!riday night nearest tains beyond, the snow-carpeted giving, too, that Andy Spillane, CJ Novem'ber 19th, which was the that Cajun, Paul, Patricia and I lawn and fields, even the trees in who lived with us at Peter Maurin ~ .forty-ninth anniversary of the ex- the woodland hung with snowy Farm but went back t o Ireland fast whenever we have colds, so he ecution of Joe Hill, two young folk draperies, and the hemlocks, pines, last summer to visit relatives, S REET began a fast to get rid of a ringing singers came from the University B TOM RITT in his ears and is now on his four- and cedars looking under their came up with Beth and Frances Y with a tape recorder to tape some hangings of gleaming, iridescent and has decided to stay with us People come to the Catholic teenth day. Jie has a quiet little of the Joe Hill songs we sing every cubby-hole off the kitchen, over the snow, all Christmasy and beautiful. again. Worker for a variety of reasons: cellar door, and plenty of blankets, week. One of them sang a song Lit urgically speaking, Advent We were also very grateful that most come out of hunger tinged which is important when you are against the draft, and the other one this year has come with a differ- Fr. Leo Neudecker, whose parish with the loneliness of the dispos- fasting in cold weather. We still about Hiroshima. For CW readers ence. I am referring, of course, to is in Rochester, Minnesota, and sessed and the disinherited and by need blankets. Almost all the who may not be familiar with Joe the new Mass in the vernacular, who is an old friend of Dorothy their presence they give the lie to other men are transients whom I Hill, here is- a resume of his story: which was approved by the Day and the catholic Worker, was the myth of affluence and accentu- have not seen before. That is what Hill came from Sweden in 1901, Ecumenical Council and inaugu- able to spend a few days with us ate the grinding poverty which still we want: folks who need a rest for at the age of nineteeni worked on rated at the parish level on the in November and say Mass for us. exists in this land of plenty. a time. We also have an old boats and on shore around San first Sunday of Advent. Fr. Kane Once more I should like to em- Others, however short of fulfill- sheep-herder who will probably Pedro, California, and up and down at st. Sylvia's prepared his phasize that we have a chapel with ment, make an effort to imitate His stay until lambing time in the the coast as a transient, and was parishioners for the change-over the Blessed Sacrament and a room concern for these poor by trying to spr.ing and an old man waiting for jailed in free-speech fights. From with several rehearsals during the reserved for -priest.~ if any pries·t live the principles of His social a pension, who gets the warmest early years he wrote songs and fall. The result was really good would care to come and visit us. gospel. A few, perhaps, come be- blanket. Three men off the freights picked out the melodies on the pi­ participation on the part of the It seems the greatest blessing of cause of an acute need for purga- from California stopped me last ano; he is said to have been an congregation. all to have Mass said in our own tive action in their live6, the cleans- night on my way back from the indilferent guitar player. At out- It ls true that a few parishioners chapel. ing but difficult way of service. post office and asked me where the door meetings, the Salvation Army remarked, as they left the Church, Work, too, is something for They combine devotion with a mission was. I told them to follow used to try to drown out !.W.W. that they thought the new liturgy which most of us feel grateful. genuine concern which demands me. Right now four chickens the (Industrial Workers of the World) more like a Protestant service than The mainstays are, as a1 ways: the1·r active participation in pro- men worked for at Mormon Relief speeches · (I rem-ember- · attend1"ng the Catholic Mass, but this kind John Filliger, Hans Tunnesen, J oe mulgating the principles which are being prepared, and they are such meet1"ngs m· Oh1"0 1·n 1912 ·) of reaction should probably be ex- Cotter, Larry Doyle, Alice Law- have stirred so many others across talking about where they spent pre- So Hill would compose parodies of pected during the transitional rence and George, but they have the years, one of which is the joy- vious Thanksgiving Days. (Many religious songs, the best known of Period. For all those somewhat many helpers. Joe Ferry, Arthur ful and quiet acceptance of the of them spent them in jail.) One which is "Long Haired Preachers," bewildered by the new liturgical Sullivan and Fred Lindsay do rigors of voluntary poverty. Fi- of my Mormon friends has just WI.th i"ts well -known ref~~1- · n • "You nally, I think, there are those who get p1·e 1·n the si.... h d" " changes, and for everyone who much to lighten Alice's household walked in with a lot of candy and ?-J w -en you le. enjoys the catharsis of laughter, I chores. Grant Bowers is becoming come because they are called (and cocoa. His young son is looking "Casey Jones-the Union Scab" is recommend a reading of Stanley a better bread baker with every curiously at our men, some of another of his songs that is sung - Vishnewski's - short satire- baking he attempts. Peter Lums- whom are lying on the carpet in all over the world. Three years "Spare Us, O Lord"-whi~h ap- den, Paul Rothermil, Joe Durnen- the front room while others sing ago, a girl from ~ngland who peared in the December 5th issue ski, Steve Kaune, George Burke, songs about unrequited love as stopped in to see us said that when of America, the we.ekly periodical and prob~bly others have been they prepare the dinner. ;;he worked with the Quakers in published by the Jesuits. After the very busy with the saw and axe, Love, Courage and Wisdom• Poland one summer they had sung ·eep of laughter, we can getting wood ready for the wood- Joe Hill's songs. Clean Sw Paul reminded me tbat it was I D ,__ 1913 all. I thm. k, take a better view ol burning stoves in Joe's hermitage, on Thanksgiving Day fifteen years n · ~Mlfiuer t , live thousand -real good of the new liturgy- John's little house, Peter's room ore mmers Wl!n on strike at Park the. ago that I wrote an epigram that I c·t h. h · the' fact that the true meaning of in the old mansion, and, most im- still think "came from the blue." I Y, w ic is not far from here. the Mass is at last lifted out of portantly, for the chapel in Peter It was while I was digging a dozen Joe had worked there, and every- linguistic obi;curity and made Maurin House. holes fot planting of roses in the o~e knew his songs. On the night clear and accessible to al so that Stanley Vishnewsk1, john Sul- driveway of my friend and · em- 0 January lO, l914, two men held all can participate with the priest livan, and Arthur Lacey give ployer, James Hussey, who lived up a grocer at 8th and South West Who celebrates the Mass. Marty Corbin some much needed Ph · D" · · th d Temple, five blocks from here, and near oemx. iggmg m e ry- killed an ex-col> named Morrison Since the first Sunday of Ad- help with the CW correspondence. packed stony earth was very diffi- and his son. The only witness to ~ent fell so soon after Thanks- Lorraine Freeman helps in the cult. Thinking that I might be the killing was a thirteen-year-old giving Day, it seemed almost the -dining room and works at her invited in for Thanksgiving dinner, son of Morrison, who said that the culmination of a season of thanks- writing; Lorraine recently had an I had taken only a peanut-butter two killers were shorter than Hill. giving, particularly since some of article in the Bard College paper. sandwich, but James went to his That same night Hill was shot in our guests-Beth Rogers and Rita Corbin keeps busy with in-laws' and I was left alone. --What Murray "in a fight over a woman," Frances Bittner, and Mary O'Neil family, art work, and community < with my energetic breathing in the as he told the law. It is believed and her three charming daughters duties. Agnes Sydney, as always, crisp air and the only noise being that Hill had beaten the time of -were able to stay over. To coon- finds something t<> mend. Herbert the mooing of a cow in the barn another man and that this man, or ple.te the tlianksgiving note, Roger Sund keeps busy in his carpenter may their number increase): they· for her absent calf, by four-thirty perhaps the girl, had shot him in O'Neil, who will be remembered shop in the basement; beside my h d . t 0 i th . li I had digested the sandwich and a stru.agle for the gun. A man by many of our. f rien· d s an d rea d - b e d now Is· a b eautiful rad" 10 t a bl e aveGod a besire kin. g vet their ~es th was thinking of higher things. shot in"' the lung could not have h h . h H b"1 d to Y wor g oge er Wl (Th1"s was three years be"fore I be- ers as a former· editor of t e w ic er e ma e. mind d h ts t 0 i I t walked the several mUe11 from Mor- Catholic Worker and as one of th e 1Mik e Sullivan,. J.im c anavan, like s. anal d earto-d mpb e. menth came a Catholic.) rison's store to Murray. When the b d "' B k h b b on a practic • ay- ay asis, e Love without Cour,..,.e and Wis- most active of our: staff mem ers an ueorge ur e ave een usy bl 1. 0f th h 0 - officers came to see Hill, he was in at the· old Chrystie Street house, putt mg. up Pas1 t" Ic s t orm wm· d ows no ed d moth Ivesc th li w ose..... w · dom is sentimentality, as with the bed nursing the wound. He lilted ·f d d h t k t · try bl t Mi h I fou. n e e a 0 c 0 • .er over ordin...... chnrch member·, Courage came to join his Wl e an aug. - o eep ou wm as s. c ae -J one hand to scratch himself and the ters-Tyrrel, five, Siobahn, three, Co h en h e IPS out m· th e e l ec tromcs · thirty years ago. without Love and Wisdom is fool- stupid law, thinking that he was and Branwen, eight een mon th s of d epartme n t . P au 1 L yga ma d e a Friday Night Meetings hardiness, as with the ordinary reaching for a gun, shot him red hair and Celtic. femininity. beautiful Advent wreath, and put As if to give impetus to many 10ldier; Wisdom without Love and through the hand. A street-car Roger and Mary have been living a bright new coat of paint on of the sentiments expressed above, Courage ls, cowardice, as with the conductor ·said that a man who was at the community in Glen Gardner Dorothy Day's room, so that her over a hundred people heard Wil- ordinary intellectual. Therefore bleeding had boarded his car near where Marty and Rita Corbin also room will be welcomely clean and Ham Stringfellow, eminent Episco- on·e with Love, Courage and Wis- the Morrison store and that this lived until they moved up here so colorful if and when she arrives. palian lay theologian, address one dom is one in a million, -who man was definitely not Joe Hill. that Marty could take charge of We miss Dorothy. very much, and of our weekly meetings. Asser_ting changes the world, as· with Jesus, Hill's court-appointed lawyers were the- new Catholic Worker Farm at :qeed her as much II.! we miss her, that the racial crisis is careening Buddha, and Gandhi. inept and he fired them. However, . Tivoli, New York. I \hink, th<>ugh we realize that to.ward a violent "day of wrath" in .Pig Hollow he was found guilty. Around the Needless to say, the reunion other needs mus.t take priority the United States. Stringfellow This is the name of the "jungles" same time, an army officer who between the Corbin and O'Neil over ours. counseled his audience: the onty in the city of Ogden thirty miles had killed an I.W.W. was quickly children has been -0n· the ecstatic AUhough I have called this way out for the white man Is to north of here where for many acquitted. A man who told the side. Although Beth and Frances column A Farm With a View aild take his "share ofr suffering ·as a: .y;ears tramps have. put, up shacks Seattle _police that he had been had to return to New York, Mary I have spoken. often of. the beauti- good soldier of Christ Jesus." · and lived in them. Birchers Jiving with Hill on the night of the killing and her children, with Roger com- ful view which so many have Stringfellow, a New Yo-rk attor- in the wealthy &uburbs have· been and could prove his innocence was ing up for weekends, have been descFibed for me, I hav.e ~ever ney and author of five books, is a complaining because there is in kept in prison and not allowed to able to stay for a longer visit. The intended that the word view frequent contributor to theological terest in folk music at a certain testify until after the sentencing. O'Neils are good communitarians should refer only to the pie- and legal journals and author of an high school. The idea is that On a motion from To:n Mooney, and do much to bring warmth and turesque and scenic, but most im- excellent boolf.. My People Is The since Joan Baez and Pete Seeger the American Federation of Labor joy to those about them. Mary and portantly should connote that Enemy, published recently by Holt, are pacifists or radicals, all folk convention asked for Hill's release, her little daughters also ad<;I a ideologic view which is implicit Rinehar.t and Winston. He sees singers must be Communists. So as did the Swedish Ambassador. much needed note of femininity. in ail the teachings of Peter little hope . for achieving racial planned a special President Wilson twice obtained a True, we have a few women here, ,Maurin and Dorothy Day. 1 re- justice. . "God knows," he said, group of songs based on Utah his- reprieve for him. The school prin­ but few indeed compared to the · fer, of course, to that program "how Negroes must feel, but I, as a tory, some of which he sings at cipals of Salt Lake ,City . publicly number of men. Moreover, three· of cult, . cultvre, ~d cultivation, white man, am ahµost overwhelmed our Friday night meetings. Tl)ey applauded Governor Spry for re­ of our small feminine contingent and the program of theory and with the feeling that I do not want include: "I Dreamed I Saw Joe Hill lusing to commute the sentence. -Lynn Rousseau, Beatrice Russo, action in such areas as pacifism, to hear- anything more of it, or see Last Night," one about the closing The only 'pr,otest meeting was and Marietta-recently ·left us, personalism, farming communes, anything more of it, or do anything of ·our first Joe Hill House, and scheduled for Unitarian _Uall, . Jrut while men, more men; .arrive every cooperatives,.· and always, e\'.ery- more in lt. another about the burning of the the · authorjties cancelled .it., ; iA . week. For the sake· of. a better> wlJ~e1 the works of mercy. In his "I \,Vish it would en4 wlthout my. shacks at Pig Hollow. Here is ,the promiµ~nt , local -r.e~ident who .. P,ro­ ,. balance. in our community, I hope work ~ manning. edit.or . of the being. anf .longer or a_ny mor~ ' deep- third :Verse from this last: ~scilI>e A' poor mah• is fighting- .f.or oall that #)now · Ste.Phen1 1 daughtJ!r ; of 1 the .• Jncluding .one. . .or . r mor.e -of· the spQkesmaq , for ttte. c9m.mu,ntt~ . irom what now h~ppens to· this na- ;. · he bu. », . . · i>resident o~- , tl\!t.MorQJ.e>n ~tum®. fH ' ill , cheerfully , cledic;ated. , . pi;ac~_ical, :· (ContiJiued.- oil page 6) · , (Continile4 :on. page,1i~ : Be •HD~ .-1Ua:llil 11a:ck~ · Uae wall. I (Continued· on page 4>1 ; ·•· Page Four THE CATHOLIC WORKE'a December, 1964

reorganized.' Headquarters are Non-Citizens now in New York City, the center 35 Arkwright Road of $PU's largest region. Hempstead, Closed down in Chicago in June + + FROM~ THE London, N.W. 3 because of a temporary financial England strain and lack of adequate per­ too. For example, the neighbor­ article, Leonardo Pinzanti, re­ moochers, carpenters, thieves, fin­ sonnel, the SPU national office hood leaders of Harl~~m and the ceived six months suspended. ishers, cooks, and old ones formed Dear Martin: was re-established at a convell!tion Eas~ When the Asturian miners a family. At one of O\ll" weekly I am pleased to tell you that the Lower Side should be given meetings CI don't think any of Simon Community in England is held in New York over the Colum­ scholarships to study the went on strike in Spain, repressive ua bus Day weekend. The SPU main­ system here .. Ninety-five per cent measures were taken against them, will ever forget or quite figure growing. Anton Wallich-Clifford tains its traditional broad-b.ased of business in Sweden is either including humiliation, imprison­ out these meetings), the boys de­ has opened three more . peace position and continues to re­ private or co-operative'. . ment and torture. No trade unions, cided that they should be allowed With the help of Christian Action, quire of members only that they William Horvath other than those operated by the to drink their cherished Italian a Church of England group, he has agree with the Statement of Pur­ state, are allowed in Spain. Strikes Swiss Colony in their own home, also been able to buy a farm in pose that "neither war nor the are illegal. Free speech does not if it was really to be t heir own the country. Anton tells me that threat of war can any longer be 25 ·years of Exile exist. Protestant denominations home. '7~11. I naively agreed, on he has to depend on Divine Provi­ successfully used to settle · inter­ have only partial freedom; no open condition that they not fight or dis­ dence. He says that he receives national disputes" and that while · Spanish Refuge Aid propagation of their creeds is al­ turb the sleep of others and that a lot of criticism from organized acting "indep'endently of both East Room 406 lowed. A limited number of chap­ they continue to perform the vari­ social workers because of the and West ... the SPU works to­ 80 East 11th St. els and schools have been re­ ous functions that I had assigned chaos in running his houses of ward a society which will ensure New York, · N.Y. 10003 opened recently. Protes·tants are them or that they had undertaken hospitality, yet ·when one talks both peace and freedom and suffer Dear Frie"nds: -now allowed to worship in private on their own initiative. As they with some of the lads I meet on no individual or group to be ex­ Again winter is ·starting and the and are no longer forced to attend wobbled wine-soaked through the my visits to St. Joseph's House ploited by another." ~ holidays al:e coming. For us this Oatholic services when in the day and thr-0ugh the night, I be­ (129 Malden Road, London), they We urge all students who wish is a joyful tim... For the Spanish armed forces or in prison. gan to realize the folly of my ex­ seem so grateful to have ,reached t-0 jo:in or remain affiliated with Civil War rdugees it means lack Neil Snelders periment, but by then it was too there and to have a r oof over their the Student Peace Union to get in of heat and comfort, insufficient Ed. note: Amnesty Interna­ late, and anyhow I couldn't go heads. touch with the new na.tional office clothing, not enough food for nour­ tional (1 Mitre Court Building, back on my word. Many of these men had walked at 5 Beekman Street, New York 3"8. ishment. After 25 years of exile, London, E. C. 4, England) will I was also discovering that the the streets of London for weeks l\.oget Lockaril in 'France, 10,000 still live in provide more detailed infor­ West Side remained pale and before they found a Simon meJil­ National Chairman misery. Can you help us make mation about these and other stricken behind the economic ber who directed them to St. this a better season for .them? instances of coercion of con­ wall, which is more formidable Joseph's House. · No one is ever As you know, one of our main science by governments. than anything the Berliners have turned away without being glven Building Co-op concerns is for the 1,261 old peo­ to face. They needed lots more a meal or a bed. Many of these ple on our rolls, who are living_on time, and I needed more wisdom. c/ o Allan Egenwall men sleep in our great station's ·starvation pensior.s in one of -the Spanish Tragedy That is not to say that many waiting rooms, in lavatories, or on . Nordhemasgatan 31 most expensive countries in Eu­ West Siders didn't come. Most fun GotebQrg, Swed~n Callejoin de la Iglesia benches in Hyde Park. ' ' rope. They ·could all ask as one were Friday night fish fries, with October 30, 1964 Puerto de la Torre . \ of them, Sra. Josefa M., did re­ the fish mooched by "Cos" Cos­ Some told me stories of sleep­ Dear Miss Day: Malag·a, Spain ing in doorways in the West End cently: "How can twQ people live tello, the Mayor of Franklyn This is my third month in Swe­ on a dollar a day?" She and her Dear Editor: Avenue, and delicately prepared and of being removed by the den. i have earned my union card I have just read "Cooperative or police. The Simon ·Community is husband are among the three hun­ by "Bum" Fry, our former seasonal as a brick mason. T.he mont!).ly dred families ·waiting for tempo­ " by William Hor­ hotel chef. Later, seventy-year-old bringing hope to men who had lost dues are six dollars, but we don't vath (September 1964), which rary help, which will cost nine "Overcoat" Spalding would splash all confidence in themselves; they pay if we are out of work. Unem­ makes me think the co-operative thousand dollars to give. To these out a stompin' good 11umber while are the rejects of society. Help ployment benefits are about eight scheme should exist here in Mala­ for the Simon Community is com­ we must add three hundred and jamming the air with his accom­ dollars a day for over four months. sixty old men and women in hos­ ga, where the housing situation ing from many other religious They a·re provided from a special for thousands of families is de­ panying guitar, to the delight of bodies. Opmar House is part of pitals, to wtiom we want to send our curious guests. fund to which both governmell!t a Christmas or New Ye'ar's gift. plorable. The government, the un­ the com~unity and is run by and employers contribute. There ions and the parishes are all doing But as time proceeded, the need Father William Kahle. This house, There is finally the Foyer Pablo for perspective and -spiritual rest is a shortage of skilled construc­ Cas·als, where over two hundred something, principally condomin­ for homeless mothers' and their· tion workers. The work week is ium, but the need for minimum became predominant. Rolling out babies, is full at the moment. fo:rty-five hours. adequate housing is enormous. the scroll in the evolution of hu­ man relationships or Christian Last month, Anton presented a The trade unions here have a The tourist boom in the C-0sta . packed, illustrated report on del Sol has made a bad situation. Anarchism is no easy artistic feat, seventy-year history of joining but it is the 1supreme md crucial homeless men to the new Labor with community societies at the infinitely worse by attracting job­ Prime Minister Harold Wilson, at seekers from other parts of Spain. value, the "Omega point," and· as lollal level to educate working peo­ exhilarating a . joy as a man or 10 Downing Street. The report, ple in socio-economic matters. Housing prices are soaring, and called "The Non-Citizen 1964" was the poor have no chance of com­ woman can hop'e to know. The Sv.enska Riksbyggen co-oper;i­ Philip Leahy the result of a one-year pilot tive house building company was peting but must wait years on survey he and other Simon work­ formed in 1941. Today this union­ somebody's list for even a new ers conducted. It contains many owned general contracting co-op room. I would be very grateful facts and figures documenting the has constructed ten thousand if you could send me details of Bombay Apostolate tragic lives of the homeless men apartmell!ts and planned whole the co-op housing scheme or an Sodality House and women who live on the neighborhoods. It has its own address where I might get more J . J . Road, Byculla shadowy side of our "affluent" architects and engineers and works information. Bombay 8, India society. . to improve the quality of housing. My wife and I, after six y,ea,rs Dear Editor: I have been asked to speak on It is financed by fees from the lo­ of trying to get something going I should like to thank my friends the Catholic Worker to the West­ cal housing it helps construot. here, Oatholic Worker style, at last and benefactors for all the help minster Cathedral Legion of Mary There are twelve special local people gather together and are have a clothing room for poor they have given me in running the next month. I will talk about development construction oo-ops, aided in their everyd·ay needs. The people. The stock comes from a Catholic Information Bureau, in Dorothy's work and what she does which build all kinds of houses in expenses for the . Foyer for the Swiss group, the European Friend­ the way of Catholic books, dona­ in t11e States. Last month I gave order to reduce the cost to the next six months will amount to ship Circle. We hope, with their tions, and cards. I beg to be a talk to the Legion of Mary group consumer and at the same time forty-five hundred dollars. help, to have a reclliperation ·camp excused if each and every one of in Hempstead on "The Catholic provide work for their union mem­ You may remember that recent­ for the poor in Malaga eventually; my benefactors has not received a Case Against the Nuclear Deter­ bers. These twelve co-ops are fi-· ly we turned our attention also to the E.F.C. is building one at Ste. personal lett~r of thanks. I also rent." The young priest who nanced up to 50 per cent by the the very young. We are specially Jalle, ·in the south of Franc~. request that the assistance to my chaired my meeting turned out to cent11al trade unions; the local un­ interested in gifted children To work in Spain today is rather apostolate be continued. be a member of my Catholic ions must put up the balance. The among the Spanish refugees. We a difficult task with CW ideals, Thank you !iO much for · your · Nuclear Disarmament group. masons, carpenters, laborers and now have thirty children with ex­ but we would gladly welcome any kindness. I will remember you in There were over sixty people cement workers all belong to one cellent school records, each need­ of your co-workers who would like my prayers. present. ' union and contribute from their ing .fifty dollars this semester to to try or who may be visiting Yours sincerely in God bless you in your work. monthly dues to raise the invest­ help with clothing, books, carfare Spain. The needs of the poor here Jesus ·Christ, You will all be in my prayers. ment capital. In Eskilstuna, where and extra food. are quite overwhelming, but read­ Father J. 0. Pujol, S.J. Eddie Sean Linden I worked when I first came to Cordially, ing the CW each month helps us, Sweden, over eight hundred people Hannah Arendt. perhaps more than· anything else, ( to keep following where we believe are emplbyed in conStruction, in J Threat to Family Life Education For Peace the office, and in th ir own fac­ God is leailing us. ' tories. Cases . of Conscience 'God bless you and your work. Cathedral of Christ the King New York. N.Y. Yours in Christ, P . 0. Box 32 In 19-H, forty per cen't of the 5, Bynon Avenue Johannesburg Dear Editor: building-trade men. were out of Kevin and Jean Ryan One of the country's largest Bexley Heath ' South Africa work. So they set up the first pro­ Kent, England. My Dear People: progressive student organizations, ducer c -op to build ho1Jslng; amt the Student Peace Union, has been 0 Dear Friends: "Whom God hath joined togeth­ sell it on the market. In New York Now is the ti.me to declare open­ Post-Mortem , er let not man put asunder." These City, we are faced ' with a similar ly the need for a radical change in S~. Louis, Missouri familiar words at the head of the problem: . too many luxury apart­ the attitude of Oatholics in nom­ Dear Friends: invitation made it plain to me that THE KINGS CAME ments an\i not enough low-income· i'nally Catholic countries, and else­ · This is a brief account of a I should accept. It came from the hou ~ ing _ Until we set u;p labor­ where, towards freedom of con.­ short-lived St. Louis house of hos- Black Sash. One usually associates BEARING GIFTS and consumer-controlled housing science. By this, I mean that there pitality. . that · movement with public pro- utility companies, we will not be should be freedom fQr all those Were there humans fit for it, I made many serious mistakes, tests against injustice. This, how­ able to hire people with sufficient who do 'not advocate violence, but chiefly taking too many men in too ever, was an invitation to attend poetry would descend management ability to stick it out merely differ in ideology from a swan upon the flesh; fast instead of growing organically a two-day forum on migratory la­ and make the enterprise work for Catholics, especi~lly conscientious as a family should, and n-0t allow- bour. It had been organised by first gift. us. objectors to military service. This ing myself enough privacy and . women who feel that the migratory The second, One Sunday an American friend is a matter of basic human rights spiritual "sanctuary." The ·' mis..i labour system of our country un­ a perfect world borne otl and I visited Father Selman to· express one's views privat-ely takes impeded fulfilment of, but dermines family life. by a supernal bull, Threadgill, O.M.I., in Nasby Park and publicly, in speech, association did not invalidate . a Christian · The ladies had gathered togeth­ the Pt appropriate works Dear Dorothy Day: take steps to make the Southern fortunate of the world with some threat of force usually results in of mercy that can be perfonned 'The June issue of the Catholic Hemisphere free of nuclear wea­ financial donations. a more violent, more disturbed, as we prepare to celebrate the and more irrational patient. Worker included a letter that was pons or testing. However, the God will surely bless you. I shall birthday of the Prince of Peace is unsigned and written to you fron;i government of New Zealand ap­ keep those kind souls in daily Recently the writer took charge to send a greeting card to these Cairo. Living here in Durban, and pears to accent the· American prayers and Masses. of a maximum-security-ward in a witnesses to the primacy of knowing Archbishop Hurley per- policy statement bhat it would be · Yours gratefully, mental hospital. This ward con­ conscience. Just sign your name; sonally, I though that the enelosed "unwise" to ban all nuclear wea­ Father Paul Cruz tains alcoholics, runaways, and written messages .are not permit­ letters from the readers' corre- pans from the half of the world some apparently violent psychotic ted. Here is a list of those cur­ spondence columns might interest lying below the Equator. Judging patients. One day a co-worker rently imprisoned in the United you. from the willingness on the part The New P r oletariat asked that one of the patients, States. f how the English- tainly influences governments. letariat has lost what culture it miles an hour." The writer said: a..t ~ ry , Chillicothe, Ohio. 1 a n g µ a g e pa~rs, although at- There have also been protests once had, and' gained no true sub­ "Just a ·minute, I'll get you a Russ Goddard-Medical Center tacked by the Nationalists and against the tests from Tahiti, stit4te. A 1 'stream of half-baked paddle and we'll play some ping­ fol," Pdsoners, Springfield, Mo . s1,1pporters of apartheid, are in re- 'western Samoa, and Pitoairn Is­ amu'sements hinders thou~ht and pong.'' Whenever, the patient tried John Ross-Federal Correction­ ality standing behind the govern- land. Recently, a nonviolent, di­ thP. enjoyment of art and even of to stop playing, the writer would al Institution, Terminal Island, ment. A very few white people rection-action group was formed. <'OrlVP.rsation. Equality of opportu­ ask: "Are the axes still flying?" San Pedro, Calif. her e stand at t&e side of t he Af- It is called CRAFT (Committl!e nJtv produces, not a society of If the patient said yes, the writer Paul Salstrom-Federal Correc­ ricans. Seeing the rage for an easy f or Resolute Action Ag>ainst eauals, but a society in which the would insist on playing on. When tional Institution, Danbury, Conn. life and possessions, one can hard- French Tests). The tentative plan <'lass division is made more sinister the patient finally reported that Robert Switzer-Cook County ly expect anything <'lse. This urge is to place an international team by the removal of intelligent per­ the "axes stopped flying," the Jail, Chicago, Ill. • for self-aggrandizement has be- of volunteers in the area before sons into the bureaucracy and the writer put the ping-pong equip­ deviled our society ever sinc,e the testing begins. (Some reports say destruction of their roots and ment away. Subsequently, the pa­ first white settler, van Rebeeck, that the Frenoh plan to begin characteristics as members of the tient exhibited no violent behavior "The simple love of country and oame here in 1652. )ate in 1965; others say in 1966). mass. In short, a proletariat in the and no form of restraint was home and soil, a love that needs There have. bee,n a few cou- One or more ships would be based fundamental sense intended by needed. The writer has experi­ neither reason nor justifications, rageous men, ordained and lay, of at Pitcairn IsfanQ. or perhaps the Marx still exists: a deracinate, dis­ enced similar situations in which is turned by the official apologists whom one can hardly learn the uninhabited atoll, Oeno, which is inherited and excluded mass of a nonviolent creative approach has of ·the state into the demented names. One is Bishop Colenso, an sixty-five miles north of Pitcairn, people. Only this mass is now seemed to help the patient manage cult of 'patriotism': coercive group Anglican prelate who died in 1884. a typical South Sea island, with quiescent, its manner of life his own behavior. unanimity; _b lind support of t he~ This man was hounded and slan- a coral !~!lf1 .sheltered lagoon full largely suburban and its outlook The institution where the writer r ulers of the state; maudlin na­ dered during his. lifetime and is of fish, some cocoanut trees, and, 'petty . bourgeois', and it increas­ works encourages a nonviolent tional •egotism; an imbecile will­ J!OW practically forgQtten, apart mosl import,apt, a supply of fresh ingly' lacks any concept of itself as and rtnblamin~ approach toward ingness to• conµnit , collective 1 from a small town that is named .wiiter from a . well. It is hop~d deprived." ' • the patient. In some ibstances, atrocities ffle 1~e ,sake ,o_f 'national · after him. < r 1 that 11uch p. project, with a two- -Iris ¥ur4och, , , in · ~o,n vi ctJ ~n where 'this attitude has not been glory'." , ·· 1 • ·That there is division among way radio c onn ec ti~n , with the (Monthly Review Press) maintairied, there i's · a 1 histocy of -LEWIS ~UMFORD Ir ' ' t ' I I I • ·I I• l ' I I THE CATHOLIC WORKER December, 1964

Tamar. Her visit made the holiday complete. I first met Dorothy Chrystie Street through the pages of the Catholic -Joe Hill House Worker many years ago. However, (Continued from page 3) it was not until 1963, while visiting (Continued from page 3) New York from California, that I Eicarch of the Russian Orthodox who taught art at the university. tion. Yet I am certain both in my had the pleasure of meeting her manacled to the floor with their mind and in my guts that this ex­ Church in North and South Amer­ She was fired for her humane arms through two sets of ba.rs and personally. One nevel' really stand. As the five men poised haustion will not hasten the resolu­ ica, talked to us about his church knows what the Holy Spirit has in tear-gassed. The warden and the tion-much less reconciliation of in the Soviet Union. The Arch­ their rifles through the window of head of the prison board admitted bishop, accompanied by Miss store, but when I first met and the blacksmith's shop at the old the racial crisis: it can only frus­ talked with Dorothy an idea of all this, but said they could not af­ trate and compound it." Helene Iswolsky, proved to be a Sugar House prison, Joe shouted: ford to have any revolts in the provocative guest, satisfactorily an­ mine began to crystallize. Just ''Fire!" Before he died, Hill asked Speaking softly, but using words twelve short months later the idea prison. Even the judge wondered swering some rather pointed ques­ to be buried in Wyoming, e~lain­ how men who couldn't even scratch , pregnant with meaning, Stringfel­ came to fru~tion: I joined the low made the following points: (1) tions, although Miss Iswolsky made ing: "I don't want to be found their eyebrows could revolt. How­ it clear that the Archbishop did not Catholic Worker family and am dead in Utah." So our Joe Hill The racial crisis is now a matter of now convinced that a life of volun­ ever, nothing came of this investi­ survival, at least for a free society, wish to answer questions with House is a lasting memorial in this gation. tary poverty, lived so eloquently state to Joe Hill, rebel singer and and everyone in the country is in­ political connotations. by Catholic Workers, will be good I have received word that my old 1 tramp. 1 volved; (2) Non-violence has not Visitors for my spiritual development. friend Jack Baker, who picketed yielded results and the adherents Dr. Felix Zengouta, a self­ In a recent issue of Our Sunday Speaking Engagements with Mary Lathrop and me for of non-violence will not be able to sacrificing physician w o r kin g Visitor, a stalwart Jesuit defender A new rule permits the students months in 1960, has finally been maintain leadership among Ameri­ among the po~r of the Bronx, in­ of the Right wrote a sur:1=£ising at Westminster College to choose released from prison and has a job , can Negroes; (3) A "day of wrath" vited Ed Forand and me to din­ column which can only be charac­ a speaker once a month for in the East. is coming and the Negro will turn ner. When he arrived he had two terized as an outright attack on the their compulsory chapel service Concluding Words to overt violence which will be met of the Little Brothers of Charles de integrity of Dorothy Day-and in­ For Veterans Day they chose me, I should like to quote a para­ by violence on the part of the white Foucauld with him. With Walter ferentially upon the members of and my talk was taped and broad­ graph from my Christmas Message l population and which will result in Kerell acting as interpreter, we the Catholic Worker family, both cast over a downtown radio station. Of 1962: the establishment of a police state; spent a most enchanting evening in present and past. We were pleased These youngsters, all Protestants "Right forever on the scaffold; (4) There is but one hope-the wit­ animated conversation. The Broth­ to see thait a recent issue of the except for one Catholic boy, asked wrong forever on the throne.'' ness of the Cross: the white man ers, Yvon Baillet and Jean-Baptiste Georgia Bulletin (Atlanta) carried questions for hours, and some of (But you don't have to be a part of must meet the coming Negro vio­ Prat, witness the presence of Christ an editorial, signed by the editor, them now attend our meetings. it.) People are naturally rood, if lence with love. by working as ordinary seamen on Gerard Sherry, defending Dorothy Naturally, I told of this being the U doesn't cost them anytbinc • • • Stringfellow was almost prophetic a Norwegian ship. The brothers, Day and the work of the Catholic anniversary of St. Martin of Tours, Now at Christmas time they have in calling for Christian love as a who were on their way to New Worker. We are grateful to Mr. who around 380 A.D. refused a a faint glimmer that comes through solution to the racial crisis. Say­ Zealand, were impressed by our Sherry and feel that the many fol­ bonus from the Emperor and of­ and for the moment they reallJ" ing that after ten years of unparal­ work and told us they would be lowers of the CW across the coun­ fered to go to battle without a mean what they say when they call leled dignity and humanity and re­ back to visit us. We hope they do. try will echo our sentimeillts. sword or shield on the following for brotherhood, peace, kindness; straint the Negro could only look J>n November 12th, at the invita­ The Catholic Peace Fellowship day, because God would protect yet 'theJ" are surrounded. and they back and see the decomposed re­ tion of Pax Romana, Ed Forand and Jim Forest, a one-time Catholic him. But before breakfast, the conaciously keep themselves sur­ mains of three youths, dead in an I attended a reception for Mon­ Worker, is executive secretary of enemy surrendered. It is also the rounded by yes-men and lick.spit­ effort to register Negroes in Mis­ signar Albert Giovannetti, per­ che newly emerging Catholic Peace anniversary of the execution of tles, so that nothlnr is ever reallJ" sissippi; the body of Medgar Evers manent observer of the Holy See Fellowship, an affiliate of the Fel­ the four Haymarket anarchists, done that mlrht cripple their power rotting in its grave in Arlington to the United Nations. Msgr. lowship of Reconclliation. Like all which took place in 1887. So No­ or decrease their revenue. National Cemetery; the graves of Giovarmetti graciously consented social apostles, Jim is feellng the vember 11th belongs not to the the children of Birmingham; the to come and visit the Saint Jo­ sting of the Radical Right. The military but to Catholic pacifists scars of those branded by cattle seph's House on Chrystie Street Catholic Peace Fellowship's pro­ and anarchists. and address one of our Friday prods and maimed by police dogs; gram for peace is being misinter­ A student Methodist minister night meetings some time in more than forty churches and preted and, perhaps, deliberately heard me at the college and asked TIVOLI homes bombed and burned; the February. distorted by the devotees of the me to speak at a luncheon of the Hoover Versus Kin&" children of Harlem livitig in rat­ Right. It is revealing, I think, to Methodist ministers of Utah and A Farm With infested tenements; token integra­ The CW prides itself on its rele­ compare the letter attacking the vance to the social issues of the their wives. I did so, but much tion and widespread despair, CPF and Jim's temperate and bal­ prefer speaking to young folks, A View Stringfellow pointed out that the moment. When the director of the anced reply, both of which ap­ whose lives are not so enmeshed in (Continued from page 3) first step must be the total eradica­ Federal Bureau of Investigation peared in the Brooklyn Tablet. used the prestige of his position to protocol. Father Roger Wood, of tion of ghettoes. The- address of the CPF: Post Of­ Provo, the Episc<>palian priest who here, Marty Corbin is certainly It was a sobering night at the impugn the honesty of Martin fice Box 455, Staten Island 2, New baptized death-house inmate Dar- the most scholarly and articulate Catholic Worker. Fortunately, Luther King, Jr., the CW family York. rell Poulsen, and who had me speak exponent of this ideologic view. at Chrystie Street was astonished hundreds of thousands will hear Reform And Renewal three years ago against tbe execu- The other night at the Marist this magnHicent address. Through and even angry. The Sermon on Ed Forand, charged with the re­ the Mount speaks of those "who tlon of Garcia and Rivenburgh, in- College in Poughkeepsie, before the courtesy of the Pacifica Foun­ sponsibility of keeping Chrystie suffer persecution for justice' vited me to address a meeting at the assembled Newman Clubs of dation (WBAI, New York; KPFK, Street running smoothly, is also sake" and there is no doubt here, the Community Congregationa,1 Vassar, New Paltz and Dutchess Los Angeles; and KPFK, Berkeley, active in the activities of Holy Church. It was an excellent meet- Community College, Marty gave a Calif.), the talk was taped. It will that Martin Luther King, Jr., has been maligned by J. Edgar Hoover. Crucifix Chul'Ch, on Broome Street. Ing, with lively questioning. No talk on the subject of A Catholic be broadcast over all three of On the First Sunday of Advent, We were happy to note that some Mormons, Quakers or Catholics View of Disarm.anent. From those Paciflca's FM stations in the near Ed acted as a commentator at the were present. Provo is the home who heard him, I understand that future and tapes are available for Catholics condemned Mr. Hoover's 9:00 A.M. Mass when portions of intemperate and unjustified re­ of Brigham Young University, he spoke with the assurance of one clubs ~nd organizations by writing the directives in the newly which is larger than the University who has thorough knowledge -of to: Pacifica Radio, 30 East 39th marks, but pleased that Mr. Hoover_ adopted Constitution on the Sacred and Dr. King sat down and dis­ of Utah. Room and board charges his subject and with the moving Street, New York, New York. Liturgy went into effect in the Grier Dee came back after a cussed their differences as two men are so low that poor students conviction of one who is sure of New York Archdiocese. Other come from all over the country. his view. year to engage in a dialogue with should. The arrests promised by members of the Ohrystie Street a white woman, titled "The Black Mr. Hoover have taken place and at Whether Moromon or not, they are As always we have had our ill­ household will be following Ed's required to sign a statement that nesses. Shorty Daniels finally be­ and White of It." Sprinkled with least twenty-one men of the State lead in the near future. Reform levity, their words brought laughter of Mississippi are involved. One they will follow the Word of Wis- came so helpless and ill that he and renewal, alter all, must be im­ dom, which means no smoking, had to be put in a hospital. Jean at some points, although I felt that hopes that the paths of justice will plemented at the parish level. the subject of the dialogue called not be obscured by local Mississippi drinking or g~mbling. Walsh, our nurse, who has been for a bit more depth and articula­ authorities. , Faceliftiq Prison Etiquette so faithful in visiting Albert Check tion: sex· is not the only aspect of Thanksgivinc Through the efforts of Dennis The Poulsen case continues to since he entered the hospital, will The Thanksgiving weekend at Kuhn, a seminarian and an artist drag on; a decision is awaited from undoubtedly be as faithful in the racial crisis. with a paint-brush, the outside of Arnold Johnson spoke on the Chrystle Street was delighUul. the state Supreme Court. Two visiting Shorty. our building is undergoing a face-. McCarran Act. The questions ran There was ham and turkey and all other murder trials are going on, We have our usual problems and lifting. Putty and paint and per­ 1 the gamut, but Mr. Johnson was the fixin's, of course; but we were severance is paying otf. Cooperat­ so it seems that the subject of frictions, too. Sometimes, some of • true to his job of being public rela­ particularly pleased to have Dor­ capital punishment will always be those who suffer from the afflic- ing with "Whiskers" and other tions director for the Communist othy Day among us. Dorothy came a factor in my life here. I am on tlon of alcoholism succumb to volunteers, the men have washed Party. In that role, he was great. down from Vermont, where she is speaking terms with Governor- their weakness and drink more Archbishop Ioann Wendland, baby-sitting for her daughter, down the walls of the first floor, windows have been cleaned, paint elect Rampton and will give him than they should. Sometimes a copy of my book. As I told him others suffering fram the tens.ion has been used where needed. during the campaign, I'll picket of other problems become irritable Mike ·Herniak, another volunteer, him for Poulsen if necessary. and impatient. Yet with it all, we performs miracles with a hammer, POET AT GEORGETOWN Two young men at the state "have joy and th-e hope that if we

Flannery O'Connor Thursday Nights· Oakland Farm Report (Continued from page 2 l.. There's a homemade sign in By BILL ESHER bis despair, fierceness and soli­ her dilemma at being asked by the the window ... "AA Tonight at In December, California's cen- captive-labor scheme (P.L. 414) tude, he redeems both book and Dominican Nuns of the Rose 8 p.m. Everyone Welcome." tral valley is damp and cold. From I will be held in San Francisco on reader, for he forces upon them Hawthorne Cancer Foundation in Inside a man is standing at Chico to Bakersfield, the wet fog Monday, December 7th. We of the the · -only possible solution, the Atlanta to write the story of a the front of the room talking. ·u h lik hr d West Oakland Farm Workers As- missing love to fill the yawning saintly little girl, Mary Ann, who There are a few people sitting wi ang e a s ou over end- sociation will be on band-on the gap. spent nine years in their care up in straight-backed chairs listen­ less spaces of flat fertile land. sidewalk-to make our position From the title-story of the vol­ to her death. With wry and point­ ing. But here and there some­ Half a million seasonal farm work- known to the public. Most of us, ume A Good Man Is Hard to Find, blank sincerity she spells out her one has fallen asleep. ers will start the long wait which feeling that the hearing itself is in which an infantile grandmother distaste for hagiography and her The speaker says: "Just ends with the early pea harvest an insult since the decisions have suddenly jumps to ' adult>hood and incapacity to write a pious, edify­ twenty months ago, I came in March. In a hundred shack- already been made, wiJI be out­ external charity in the few min­ ing tale. So she turns the tables on through that door and attended towns the scene will be the same, side. Some of our friends, how­ utes that precede her execution by the nuns and advises them to my first AA meeting, And be­ as gaunt women try to stretch two ever, will be inside, in order to an escaped convict who exclaims write the story themselves, promis­ lieve me, I was in worse shape days' food over a full week. This condemn this sham ceremony. regretfully: "She would have been ing to write a preface for it. A than any of you." is a quiet, u~e ctacular kind of We have seen growers refuse to a good woman if there bad been year later, she is faced with the The man -is clean-shaven. suffering, invisible to travelers on pay their workers after the day's somebody there to shoot her every story which is everything she had Suit pressed. His shoes shined. the giant cord of concrete binding work; we have seen labor con­ -minute of her life" to "The Dis­ feared, edifying, monotonous, de­ He talks about his life when the valley together: Highway 99, tractors cheat and lie to their placed Person," an exposition of void of selective taste or drama. he was drinking, and what bis where shiny loads of '65 model workers; we have heard at least the situations caused by racism in But musing upon it, she realizes life bas become ... what be pickup trucks speeu past gaudy two farmers say: "The trouble with its deepest sense, which is poverty, that it nonetheless comes to life; hopes to become. billboards proclaiming as a public that crew of farm workers · is the protagonists are brought to the secret of the child's soul be­ And people listen. The man service: "World Goal: 1''reedom _they're not hungry enough.'' face the Last Judgent and we, the says: "If l can do it, so can comes apparent. Lives of the saints from Hunger." The imported-labor scheme readers, have to render the sen­ are usually imagined by sweet" old you." tence with our own consciences. A few beads nod. Others still In September, a top-level meet- could not operate in California priests or maiden ladies whose ing was.held in Washington whose without t he support o·f Govern:>r In "The Displaced Person," a hard, experience is fictive; this accounts s~eep . mean little proprietress ho~ds sway "Keep cor_:Ung back," the effect was to insure the continu- Edmund G. Brown. He has assured for their sentimentality. But the ance of' the shacktowns, the long us, personally and in the press, over poor whites and Negroes child who brought joy to everyone man says. The meeting closes. It's a winter watting, and the hunger. that be is against introduction of whose livelihood is in her hands. had one downy, giowing cheek typical AA meeting that goes Top officials of the Departments such labor. Nevertheless, he has Among themselves there exists a and one hideous one, inflamed and on every Thursday night at The · of Agricu1ture and Labor met witlb yielded to p ressure from the gentleman's agreement of a kind: distorted by a cancerous tumour. Catholic Worker, 175 Chrystie representatives of the growers state's growers, and now the en­ to do the least work possible. What The nuns who, loving her, tended the proprietress loses financially St. Speakers come from AA and organized labor in a closed- tire bureaucratic machinery is in­ her, suffered this with her; when groups all over the city to share door session to decide what :would valved. Farm Placement Service she recoups in her sense of superi­ they taught her the story of the ority: What can one expect of such their faith, hope and experience happen now that Congress had officials and grower-group ad­ Passion, they witnessed hers. The people? They are all the same. with the Chrystie Street Group. voted down the bracero program. ministrators are often inter­ effort on both sides for nine years But bhe ~cene is doisrupted by the They come to help them­ , It was decided that ; ~assive changeable. must have been overwhelming. arrival of the Dis.placed Person selves. They hope that they imported contrac;t-labor program Foreign contrac.t laborers en­ From what she and the nuns made and his family, Poles ju&t out of help someone else ' in 'the in .California would be carried out tering the United States under the of her death, a living force, concentration camps. The new­ process. Flannery's musings led her back to under the provisions of the Mc- 1965 ru:rangements will be housed comer becomes overseer. A man Carran-Walter Immigration Act. in sanitary barracks, moved from Nathaniel Hawthorne, the found- superior to his position, an ardent It was also decided that public field to field in late-model pas­ ress' father, who, we know from and sltilled worker, he sets a pace hearings would be held as a senger buses, and fed en1Jugb · so his wife's diary, one day had to that completely disrupts the lacka­ smokescreen and that a "prevail- that they can work at top ef­ clasp in his arms, where it had daisical rhythm of his co-workers. ing wage" of $1.25 per hour for ficiency. Although their contracts thrown itself, a small child dis­ Dirty War Hatred, caused by insecurity, be­ 1965 would be paid to the Mexican will specify $1.25 an hour wages, figured by a hideous sore: "If it gins to mount and the Pole tops In the past few weeks JJhotog- contract laborers by California's doctoring pay records is easy to -Rverythlng by arranging a marriage had been my child," said raphs have appeared in the British corporation farmers. do and the contract workers are Nathaniel, "if it had chosen me ---- bv correspondence between a niece Press 1thowing the tortures inflicted Eoreign contract laborers are t oo poor to b uy wristwatches.· still in a refugee camp and a young for a father." And the Puritan on Viet-Cong prisoners by troopS - of &he Vietnam army. preferred by growers because they Government inspections under IOoa:i Negro. The force of the pre­ father, guilt-ridden, produced the Catholic ·nun who could not bear can be mobilized and regimented the bracero law rarely uncovered dicament is attained by the very In the long, frnstraiinr war- more efficiently than American payroll frauds, and the new im­ · understatement with whic·h it is to see cancer victims treated as lepers. And musing on these things now nearly 20 years old-in lndo- workers. More impo11antly, their port arrangement will probably expressed, the Southerners hardly China there has, ol course, always mere presence tends to depress the not even provide for inspections. troubling to explain why it is im­ Flannery O'Connor comes to terms with truth, with its double been • practice of torture by the existing wage structure to the There will be no complaints amt possible for the marriage to take French-but d least in the old point where American farm work- no labor trouble, because six place, the Pole incapable of under­ aspect, glowing and hideous like the cheeks of Mary Ann. No doubt days of the lone, long war hypo- ers can be made to work for bare centuries of oppression have standing why anyone would with­ crisy pajd • tribute to virtue- by subsistence wages. This bas been taught the peon a forceful lesson. hold kindness, food and liberty the Atlanta nuns may have gone hushing up the torture inflicted by th · from his unharuiy niece. In dazed to Miss O'Connor for her clear and e function of the bracero and -And in the farm worker shack- i ts own soldiers and condemning th e wetb ac k and the F-ilipino and towns of rural Oalifornia, the and semi-conscious horror both the swooping mind, her devastating the torture inflicted by the other proprietress (who had grudgingly outlook, but more perhaps for her side. the Chinese Held laborer for a awesome emptiness of poverty come to admire her overseer) and body, wasted by a -deadly disease The st.range new feature about hundred years. According to the will descend for another year on the poor, black and white, watch carrying all this strength on the JJhotogra]lbs of torture now State Department of Employment, a half-million unwanted people. the average farm worker earns For 'them, California is a mouth­ a tractor orush the Pole to death crutches, her body who knew. appearhlg In the British and Amer- $1,085 a year. Spokesmen for the ful of dust in the endless, season- under their eyes without lifting a Her last printed work, to my i can Press, is that they have been finger to help him. They are all knowledge, was an interracial taken with the approval of the tor- three-hundred-million-dollar agri- less despair of a useless life. This cultural industry say they can't is the staggering price we pay for afterwards to be overcome by ter­ story whose title is borrowed from turers and ue published over cap.. ror or disaster. And the proprie­ Teilbard de Chardin: "Everything tions that contain no hint of con- afford to pay higher wages. In- winter lettuce, lemons and avoca­ tress most of all. dividual tanners with whom we does. That Rises Must Converge." demnation. They mirht have come have conversed are convinced Ed. note.· To learn more '.rbe author's style is a fantastic She was one of those very few out of a book on insect life. "The melange of fierceness and humor; fully achieved beings who gave white ant takes certain measures that anyway "farm workers are , about this problem, -read Claude! has said that there is no their all swiftly 11nd burningly, acainst the red ant after a success- bums; aren't worth any more than Farm Labor, Box 1173, Berke- ful foray." they're getting." ley, California <$3.00 a year; tragedy without its element of and we must now accept our loss comedy, and she is most keenly and admit with her that: But these, after all, are not ants · The rigged bearing on the new thirty cents a copy). aware of this. But great writing One of the tendencies of our but men. The long, slow slide into does not separate the one from age Is to use' the suffering of chil­ barbarism of the western world Other in compartments, they the dren to discredit the goodnese of seems to have quickened. For fuse. Perhaps all this boils down A unique and inexpen•ive gift that will be remembered God, and once you have dis· these pbotocraphs are of torturen to our infinite importance , to our­ credited his goodness you ue belonging to an army which could every J.ay of the yeari _ selves and our infinite unimpor­ done with Him. [The PurHa1;1s] not exist without American aid tance in the face of the univeise. whom Hawthorne saw as a menace and counsel. There lies both

. ' I ~ J t ' • ~ Memoir of Mary Ann that the the, iunount of- tb~ery 1, decre1JS­ '' 5 B~kman St., New' York,' }-,00,33, 1 ~ter reveals h~rseif in 1he most ip~ wJJµ~ the: s~ial nee,t for it ,, . I,' N.Y. • r l • t t st,artling manner, and ' it is done increases." · ,. ! COrtland 7-4592 ' .1 • , 1 • 0 • l ' . ' . \ tJtrQugh a _chil~I, ~e ln:l11arts Jo -qs, JRJS . ~t>QCS .. ·+ l · . • '• • l I I Page Eighe THE CATHOLIC WORKER Deeemher, 1964 The Morality Of Thermonuclear Deterrence (Continued from page 2) does in realizing personally the is constituted from the intrinsic might restrain itself, and that its a citizen who supports such a pub­ oowe.ver, there is some prudence proportions of the evil involved. character of the act and from the command might be preP"ared to do licly stated and reiterated policy in the view that neibher Christi­ But welcome as it is nineteen natiwal, permanently inviolable so in perfect secrec.y withowt Olf "destroying an enemy society anity nor democracy is well served years after Hiroslhima, agreement rights of the innocent. No circum­ alarming Senators like bhe two if driven to it" is cooperating in by means which on any close 1n­ on an absolute limitation of means stances exist or could exist in quoted earlier. It is also possible oond.iitional genocide, with no spectiop bear the sign of man­ is only the first step in a theologi- whidh "it might be all right" or that a particu•lar thermonuclear awareness of the presumably right kind's destruction. Such a pru­ cal response to the nuclear crisis. "necessary" to commit a few Hiro­ war might not be so awful as we intentions which lie secretly at its dence would ~uggest as well that Leaving aside for the moment the shimas. The moral barrier against imagine. And after it all we might heart. 'Jibe oooperaition and re­ it is the Christian who is uniquely question what further principles city-destroying and against its even call ourselves Ohristians sultant re51Ponsibility would, of equipped to maintain the rights of c must supplement this well-estab- cumulative effect, society-destroy­ when confronted by tlhe results of course, be g·reatiy heightened for life and of conscience against the lisbed limit, the irrelevance of any ing or genocide, is a stone wall our work. All these are possibili­ certain classes of citizens, like a murderous "necessity" of world principle is clear without its ap- made of a millicm Mosaic slabs ties. A secret resolution never to missile manufacturer or a "but­ events and in spite of the conse­ plication to the quaestio facti. The- having the individual and collec­ destroy cities is no less likely tlhan ton-pusher." Yet in each case, ac­ quences his stand may bring upon ological principle must meet stra- tive strength of bhe divine impera­ the others, all of which possibili­ cording to the · argument from him. Genuine Ohristiian prudence tegic fact. Still it is at !'his point tive, "'I1hou shalt not kill." ties, however unlikely in fact, we bluff, any moral responsibility for is no apologia for skirting thermo­ that theologians understandably The only conceivable way out are inclined to look upon hope­ what is potentially the most mur­ nuclear occasions of genocide. For become hesitant, approaching as of this conflict between absolute fully as narrow ways out of a derous act in man's history can be the p:riact;ical wisdom of the Ohris­ they must the specialized realms moral principle and strategic ne­ moral impasse. avoided by a leap of faith, beyond Uan is founded not on an ethics of nuclear strategy and politics. cessity, short of rejecting all nu­ Blind Faith publicly stated t'areats, to the right of fear but on the scandalous ex­ Despite the crucial importance of clear war, is to introduce a moral More relevant in evaluating the moral intentions secretly animat­ treme of a cross. application, the natural inclina- split between deterrence, or the argument from bluff than the pos­ ing the Pentagon's "War Boom." Ed. note: James F. Douglass has tion of the theologian is instead threat of city destruction, and the sibility of its premise being ob­ The argument f!rom bluff rests ul­ studied theology at Notre Dame to stop short at the door of offi- act itself in execution. Since the jectively true ubt that faith in the good will \Vorldview (170 E. 64th St., New have a convenient, frequently the argument thait the West would tively good c<>nscience for a few of those we live and work witJh is York, N.Y.; $4.00 a year), pub­ emptied file for suoh principles. never in fact carry out in actual responsible officials, there remain an essential element in human lished by the Council on Religion The point here is not simply a war its threaits of city or society several hundred million uninitiat­ life. This is equally true of the and International Affairs and ed­ matter of good or bad will but destruction. If suoh final restraint ed particiiPants in the West's nu­ faith we place in elected officials. ited by Mr. James Finn, formerlj more one of vision and awareness. could be legitimately assumed de­ clear policies, namely its citizens. We must often rely on ther judg­ of Commonweal.) It is the seeming irrelevance of spite appearances to the contrary, The argument from blu.lf to be ef­ ment for' the sake of order. moral principle to a vast military thermonuclear deterrence would fective must maintain a purity of At the same time there are cer­ machine grown accustomed to the -not involve a conditional commit­ tain crucially important political permissive silence of Christianity ment to the murderous methods issues, concerning the destiny of and to the autonomous demands of total war. Tille upper reaches wlhole peoples, on which eve.ry Tadpoles of military necessity. Funda- of the deterrent could be consid­ citizen must pass judgment per­ "It is possible that intelligent mentalcy then the question is, how ered instead as a "bluff" wihose sonally and with his entire moral tadpoles reconcile themselves to can the ChUTch make its princi- only purpose is to restrain the en­ being. The racial crisis is one of the inconveniences of their posi­ ples felt on so profoundly im- emy witlhin the same nuclear lim­ !Jhese. Thermonuclear war is an­ tion, by reflecting that, though portant a question when the pub- its which we ourselves would in other. For a citizen deliberately most of them will live and die as lie authorities (and most Ohris- no case exceed. to make a blind act of faith in his tadpoles and nothing more, the tans for that matter) inteiipret its Before considering the merits superiors' judgment on suoh mat­ more fortunate of the species will present stand as a sign of unqual- of the argument from bluff from -ters, against all objective evi­ one day shed their tails, distend- - - ified support? the standpoint of the no-city im- dence, and then go dutifully about their mouths and stomachs, hop The most obvious way to begin perative, one particularly loose his affairs with eyes averted, is a nimbly on to dry land, and croak to make principle .relevant is for assumption in it which is not for­ sin and crime that we should by addresses to their former friends the moralist to acquaint himself mally at issue here should "at least now, after an abundance of Third on the virtues by means of which with the strange discourse of 1.her- be noted. That assumption is that Reich accounts, be able to recog­ tadpoles of character and capacity monuclear war strategists now in- a perfectly targeted counterforce, nize instinctively, Our failure to can rise to be frogs. ereasingly audible to civilian ears. no-cities nuclear war could in lt­ do so, and the readiness of mora­ This conception of society may Tlte writings of strategists have self, apart from any higher threat, lists to provide a rationale for our be described, perhaps, as the tad­ reached such abundance that from fu!Iill the requirements of a just own evasions of conscience, are pole philosophy, since the consola­ this point on the kind of theologi- war. Given, however, the increasing suggestions enough of the moral tion which it offers for social evils cal innocence which issues and possibility CJlf a large num·ber of passivity in our own society. consists in the statement that ex­ ends in unapplied, and sometimes hardened enemy missile bases vul­ .Aipart then from the moral ceptional individuals can succeed inapplicable, principles should no nerable only to the larger wea­ sopihistkation required for a pres­ in evading them. longer be taken seriously. A sec- pons, even an attack directed intention in all those committed ervation Olf innocence through Who has not heard it suggested ond step therefore in a theologi- exclusively at suclh military tar­ to an o_utwardly evM policy, citi­ "bluff," and which could there­ that the presence of opportunities, cal response to- the nuclear crisis gets would raise a grave question zens as weH as statesmen. No fore be a legitimate escape only by means of which individuals can is the task of making establiSihed with regard to the "incidental" eif­ Western leader could employ a for theologians, it can be ques­ ascend and get on , relieves principle meet strategic fact. fects of several hundred thermo- nuclear deterrent without the sup­ tioned if it is this kind of faith economic contrasts of their social With regard to the basic limit- nuclear ex1>losions across a coun­ port and coopeiiation CJlf the body which we need most in our pres­ danger and their personal sting; ing principle of no-city destruc- try. A huge loss of civilian life politic. A presumed right inten­ ent crisis. Christian citizens are that there is, as some suppose, an tion, there is a central strategic through fallout or ecological ef­ tion, held secretly by the staites­ right to place a proper faith in element in nuclear 'war which fects, however, "indirect" or "un­ man and conflicting with all out­ the holders of legitimat ely con­ educational ladder up which talent seems to render the "just nuclear intended," would still be unjusti­ ward signs, must f the thermonuclear de­ were to scramble to shore, un­ ness to break it and "destroy an it · is most unlikely tlhat we can tarily effective. But on the other terrent rests is a faith against pub­ deterred by the thought of drown- enemy society if driven to it," as keep the philosophy behind them hand, the American citizen must lic policy, against poised weapons ing companions!" r Secretary McNamara put it in his secret," thus calling into question disbelieve the threat in order to systems, and aiganst a congress -R. H. Tawney, EQUALITY Ann Arbor address (June 16, the perfectly kept secrecy of a make his support of it morally and electorate which would ruin