Populism in Latin America
Dr. Richard Gioioso Saint Joseph’s University July 10, 2019
Outline
I. What/where/who is Latin America? II. Overview of history of the region A. Colony and characteristics B. Independence and beyond III. Populism, Politics and Policy IV. Latin American dichotomies A. Democracy vs. authoritarianism B. Right vs. left C. Urban vs. rural D. Race and ethnicity V. Contemporary Latin American political landscape VI. Trends of change VII. Comments on ‘doing’ politics for future leaders
CENTRAL AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN 90 80 70 60
Tampa Saint Petersburg UNITED STATES Grand Bahama Great North Freeport Abaco Miami Atlantic Gulf of Mexico BIMINI THE BAHAMAS ISLANDS New a G Eleuthera
Providence
d r
i e Ocean r Nassau o a Key West l F t
Cat Island f o Andros
s t i a Island San Salvador r B ancer Trop t ropic of C ic of Cance S T r Cay Sal a h Rum Cay Bank a Great (THE BAHAMAS) m Exuma Hava na a Long Island Samana Cay k Guinchos Cay a n Matanzas B (THE BAHAMAS) B RAGGED Crooked Island Pinar del a e n k ISLAND c h Rio Santa Clara Mayaguana e Cay Lobos RANGE p Yucatan Cienfuegos (THE BAHAMAS) Acklins Turks and m Island Caicos Islands a Channel C CUBA (U.K.) Mérida Cancún Camagüey Isla de la Grand Playa del Juventud Great Inagua Las Tunas Turk Carmen Cozumel Bahía de Holguín 20 Isla 20 Cozumel Manzanillo Ba yamo Campeche Campeche Guantánamo Windward Cap Haïtien PUE Santiago Milwaukee Deep RTO RICO Passage (deepest point of the Ciudad del MEXICO de Cuba Gonaïves Santiago TREN George Town U.S. Naval Base Atlantic Ocean, -8605 m) Anegada CH Carmen Caym an Islands Guantanam o Ba y British (U.K.) DOMINICAN Virgin Is. Passage Chetumal HAITI (U.K.) N C H Navassa REPUBLIC Cha rlotte T R E Mona San Juan Roa d Town Villahermosa M A N Montego Bay Island Port-au-Prince Ama lie The Va lley Anguilla (U.K.) C A Y (U.S.) Passage Ma rigot Philipsb urg Sint Maar ten (NETH.) Les Cayes Virgin Is. Saint-Mar tin Spanish Santo (U.S.) Gustavia Saint Barthelem y(FRANCE) Belize City To wn Domingo Isla (FRANCE) Tuxtla SWAN ISLANDS Kingston Mona Puerto Rico St. Croix Saba and ANTIGUA AND BARBUDA (HONDURAS) Sint Eustatius (NETH.) Saint John's Gutiérrez Flores Belmopan JAMAICA (U.S.) Basseterre BELIZE SAINT KITTS AND NEVIS Comitán ISLAS DE Plymouth Guadeloupe LA BAHÍA Montse rrat (U.K.) S (FRANCE) IE Puerto R Isla de Aves Basse-Terre Marie-Galante RA Barrios La Cebia M (VENEZUELA) A GUATEMALA El Progreso DOMINICA Tapachula D San R Guatemala Pedro Roseau
E Martinique Quetzaltenango City Sula
(FRANCE)
HONDURAS e
Fort-de Comayagua g
Cayos France
Escuintla d
Miskitos i Castries Santa Tegucigalpa Caribbean Sea t s R SAINT Ana a
San Danlí o Sonsonate LUCIA Bilwi C s BARBADOS Sa n Miguel (Puerto Isla de la o e t Salvador i Providencia Kingstown u Cabezas) v
Choluteca Estelí q (COLOMBIA) s A Bridgetown
EL SALVADOR o Matagalpa M
M Ar ub a SAINT VINCENT AND I D Chinandega
D Isla de San Andrés (NETH.) L NICARAGUA THE GREN ADINES E Curacao (COLOMBIA) Oranjestad Bonaire León Ma nagua ISLAS (NETH.) GRENADA AM (NETH.) E Juigalpa DEL MAIZ Saint R Granada George's IC Lago de Bluefields W illemstad A Punto Tobago Nicaragua Isla de T Golfo de Fijo R Isla Margarita Port of Santa Marta Venezuela La Tortuga TRINIDAD AND EN Spain C Liberia Barranquilla TOBAGO H La Guaira Gulf of 10 Trinidad 10 Sa n Cartagena Maracaibo Cumaná Paria Puerto Valledupar Caracas José Limón Barquisimeto Valencia Maracay Barcelona Puntarenas San Panama Lago de Maturín Isidro Bocas Canal Maracaibo COSTA del Toro Colón Panama City Golfito Balboa Montería RICA La Mérida Ciudad North David P ANAMA Palma Barinas Bolívar Ciudad Gua yana Santiago Ori San Fernando o noco Gulf of Cúcuta S Rí Panama Pacific San Cristóbal Embalse Georgetown de Guri Bucaramanga E Ocean a VENEZUEL A n Linden le
a L d g A
a T H Medellín Isla del Coco M N
C Puerto GUYANA (COSTA RICA) o D E
í I N Scale 1: 12,500,000 R R Ayacucho
E O R G U I A N A H I G T H Lambert Conformal Conic Projection, L A N Manizales C OLOMBIA standard parallels 7°N and 24° N D E Pereira A S L I R Armenia N E 0 100 200 300 Kilometers H L Isla de Malpelo C L Bogotá I (COLOMBIA) Ibagué - 0 100 200 300 Miles D R Villaviencio U Buenaventura O Boundary representation is not necessarily authorit ative. R E C BRAZIL P A 90 80 Cali 70 Boa Vista 60 803613AI (G00800) 8-13
Outline
I. What/where/who is Latin America? II. Overview of history of the region A. Colony and characteristics B. Independence and beyond III. Populism, Politics and Policy IV. Latin American dichotomies A. Democracy vs. authoritarianism B. Right vs. left C. Urban vs. rural D. Race and ethnicity V. Contemporary Latin American political landscape VI. Trends of change VII. Comments on ‘doing’ politics for future leaders Globalization • Globalization • Process of increasing interconnectedness btn societies such that events in one part of the world more & more have effects on peoples & societies far away.
• Globalization is NOT new. • Think about connectedness through history due to EMPIRE • Roman Empire – Europe, Central Asia, N. Africa (25 BC-500 AD) • Mongol Empire throughout Eurasia (1200-1400) • Spanish Empire in the Americas (1500-1850) • British Empire, where the sun never sets… • Ottoman Empire from Mediterranean through Middle East (1300-1922)
Outline
I. What/where/who is Latin America? II. Overview of history of the region A. Colony and characteristics B. Independence and beyond III. Populism, Politics and Policy IV. Latin American dichotomies A. Democracy vs. authoritarianism B. Right vs. left C. Urban vs. rural D. Race and ethnicity V. Contemporary Latin American political landscape VI. Trends of change VII. Comments on ‘doing’ politics for future leaders Politics
Process through which actors use means to interact with each other to gain favorable outcomes for their values and interests. Public Policy
• The result of political process • Decision or action by government that results in the allocation of a value • Normative values and rights (liberty, freedom) • Services (health care, education) • Material (roads, housing) • Symbolic (status of country around world) • Military • Economic (trade, finance) Liberalism
Also has centuries-old roots from at least three different intellectual strands
(not same as being a “liberal” in American politics)
1. Philosophical liberalism – John Locke (17th century) 2. Economic liberalism – Adam Smith (18th century) 3. Constitutionalism – Vattel, Wilson (18th century) 4. Idealism – natural harmony among states; humans can learn from mistakes & therefore world politics can change Structures • What kind of states? – democracies, authoritarian or?
• What is a democracy (liberal-democracy)? • Meaningful and regular ways of holding officials accountable (watch out for elections – “democracy”) • Restriction of state power over individuals; protections for civil rights & liberties (“liberal”) • Typically these states have (some form of) market economy
• What is authoritarianism? • Population has no direct say over who governs them. Leaders try to minimize or control citizen participation. • Rights/liberties stated, but not protected; occur at the discretion of the leadership • Authoritarians may repress, but use other mechanisms to gain support/acquiescence to their rule. Outline
I. What/where/who is Latin America? II. Overview of history of the region A. Colony and characteristics B. Independence and beyond III. Populism, Politics and Policy IV. Latin American dichotomies A. Democracy vs. authoritarianism B. Right vs. left C. Urban vs. rural D. Race and ethnicity V. Contemporary Latin American political landscape VI. Trends of change VII. Comments on ‘doing’ politics for future leaders Latin American dichotomies
Democracy vs. authoritarianism
Right vs. left
Urban vs. rural
Race and ethnicity Outline
I. What/where/who is Latin America? II. Overview of history of the region A. Colony and characteristics B. Independence and beyond III. Populism, Politics and Policy IV. Latin American dichotomies A. Democracy vs. authoritarianism B. Right vs. left C. Urban vs. rural D. Race and ethnicity V. Contemporary Latin American political landscape VI. Trends of change VII. Comments on ‘doing’ politics for future leaders
Outline
I. What/where/who is Latin America? II. Overview of history of the region A. Colony and characteristics B. Independence and beyond III. Populism, Politics and Policy IV. Latin American dichotomies A. Democracy vs. authoritarianism B. Right vs. left C. Urban vs. rural D. Race and ethnicity V. Contemporary Latin American political landscape VI. Comments on ‘doing’ politics for future leaders