Which Way Is Jerusalem? Which Way Is Mecca? the Direction-Facing Problem in Religion and Geography
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Which Way Is Jerusalem? Which Way Is Mecca? The Direction-Facing Problem in Religion and Geography Daniel Z. Levin ABSTRACT Why would a mosque in New York City face toward the northeast when Determining the direction in "everyone knows" that Mecca is south and east of New York? This question is which to face another location on the globe an example of the direction-facing problem in geography: When standing at a is a problem with significant social and reli particular point on the globe, in what direction is another point elsewhere on gious meaning, and one with a rich and the globe? As in the above example of the New York mosque oriented more or interesting history in the Western world. less toward Greenland, the answers can be surprising. Perhaps even more sur Yet a fully satisfying geographic solution to prising, though, is that, from the perspective of mathematics and cartography, this problem is hindered by our intuitive there is not just one scientific answer to the direction-facing problem, but two perception of the world as a flat surface where a 0 straight0 path (1) is the shortest potentially valid mathematical answers. As we shall see, the reality of compass distance, and (2) maintains a constant direction on a round earth does not always fit with what our intuitive notions of angle. On a curved surface, however, only distance and direction would have us believe. one of these two properties can be satis For religious Jews and Muslims, for example, this issue is not merely fied: the first, by a great circle; the second, academic. In both faiths, worshippers have been conducting their prayers for by a rhumb line. These two solutions are centuries while facing a holy city: for Jews, Jerusalem; for Muslims, Mecca. analyzed, compared, and applied to the Thus, beyond its usual importance to social science, public policy, and industry, direction-facing problem. the tools and techniques of geographic analysis in this case have significant social (even theological) meaning to religious institutions as well. Although reli Key Words: direction facing, religion, great gions have relied upon various folk traditions and rules of thumb, modern wor circle, rhumb line shippers might also wonder if mathematics, geography, and cartography can provide a scientific answer to the direction-facing problem. Yet, deciding what exactly is the direction in which to face another point on the globe turns out, for theoretical reasons, to be far from straightforward, even scientifically. In fact there are two potential mathematical solutions to the direction-facing problem: either the initial compass direction of a great circle (i.e., the shortest path) con necting the two locations; or the constant direction of a rhumb line (i.e., the path of constant compass direction) connecting the two locations. In this arti cle-designed to spark the interest of students of geography and requiring no more than high-school trigonometry-I review the diverse history of prayer ori entations and then describe how and why we might use the great circle versus the rhumb line to solve the direction-facing problem. DIRECTION FAONG IN WESTERN REUGIONS Several major religions-Judaism, Christianity, Islam, and Baha'i-have historically observed the practice of orienting prayer in a particular geographic direction. Moreover, over time, these groups have approached the direction-fac Daniel Z. Levin (Ph.D., Northwestern ing problem in a number of different ways. University, 1999) is an assistant professor of organization management at Rutgers University. Ordinarily, his research interests Judaism include organizational learning, change, and The tradition among Jews to face in the direction of Jerusalem while innovation, but they also extend to intellectu praying is an ancient, biblical one. According to the Bible, King Solomon (10th ally interesting problems in social science, century B.C.E.) built the first Temple in Jerusalem and then stated when dedi geography, and the overlap between the two. cating that structure that the Israelites would "pray to the Lord in the direction of the city which You have chosen [Jerusalem], and in the direction of the House [Temple] which I built to Your name" (I Kings 8:44). After the destruction of this Journal of Geography 101:27-37 ©2002 National Council for Geographic Education 28 Levin Temple, the Bible notes that Daniel (6th century B.C.E.), should lean a little towards the southeast. while in exile in Babylonia, faced in the direction of (L'vush, as quoted in Mishna B'rurah, O.H. 94:2) Jerusalem while praying (Daniel 6:11). After the final However, a rabbi writing in 17th-century Prague destruction of the secorid Jewish Temple (70 C.E.), located noted that he had only witnessed Jews facing directly east on the same site as the first, this tradition remained and ward. He therefore concluded-even though his own opin was soon codified into Jewish law. For the most part, how ion was to face southeast-that most Jews must be taking ever, it appears that in actual practice Jews have had a the view that simply choosing one of the four compass rather flexible attitude toward the direction of Jerusalem directions mentioned 1,400 years earlier in the Talmud was and moreover, even in theory, have never been extraordi sufficient (Divrei Hamudot, B'rachot 30a). In fact, most syna narily precise about determining its direction. gogues from the middle ages to the 18th century placed the The earliest rabbis, whose views were first record ark along a wall that was due east; one notable exception, ed around the year 200 C.E., believed that Jews should though, was the 16th/17th-century 0 Spanish synagogue" in physically face Jerusalem when praying, but added that Venice, which was oriented to face south by southeast someone on a boat could simply direct his 0 heart" to the (Kashtan 1971). At the turn of the 20th century, yet anoth site of the destroyed Temple in Jerusalem (Babylonian er Jewish legal authority-one who lived in Lithuania and Talmud, B'rachot 28b). Another source from the same time Poland-again reiterated that Jews in Europe should face period elaborated, "Those in the north face the south, southeast; that is, toward where the sun is 30-60 minutes those in the south face the north, those in the east face the after sunrise in the spring or fall (Mishna B'rurah, O.H. west and those in the west face the east so that all Israel 94:2). Despite these admonitions, however, today all, or [i.e., the Jewish people] prays toward one place" (Tosefta nearly all, synagogues in Europe and North America (if B'rachot 3:16). By the late 5th century, subsequent rabbis they have any intentional geographic orientation at all) are had reiterated this viewpoint but added the opinion that a oriented to face due east. blind man or someone who does not know the direction Besides praying in the direction of Jerusalem, 3rd should simply direct his 0 heart" towards his Father in heav to 5th-century rabbis also applied the direction-facing prin en (Babylonian Talmud, B'rachot 30a). Archaeological evi ciple to a Jewish law that one should avoid showing disre dence confirms that 2nd- to 5th-century synagogues were spect by relieving oneself while facing the Temple in roughly oriented to face Jerusal~m (Avi-Yonah 1971). Jerusalem when it is in view. These early rabbis debated As Jews migrated to North Africa and Europe, and differed over whether this prohibition applies when later commentaries on this Jewish law-e.g., rabbis writing the Temple is not in existence (i.e., after 70 C.E.), or when in 13th-century Germany (Mord'khai, B'rachot 30a) and in Jerusalem is not in sight, or when one is not due north or 14th-century Spain (Tur, O.H. 94)-noted simply that Jews due east of Jerusalem, or when one is outside the Land of to the west of the Land of Israel should face eastward. Israel entirely. Interestingly, those who followed this prohi Interestingly, in Arab lands-where Muslim astronomers bition would avoid facing Jerusalem and avoid turning their and Qthers focused intensely on the direction-facing prob backs to it; thus, many rabbis argued that someone to the lem-medieval Jewish scholars showed no interest in treat east of Jerusalem should face north or south when reliev ing more scientifically the direction of prayer (Goldstein ing himself (Babylonian Talmud, B'rachot 61b). Many cen 1996). Perhaps the only scientific treatment of this issue turies later, Jewish burial also became associated with the was by a 15th-century Jewish astronomer in Lisbon who direction of Jerusalem. One early-19th-century European wrote in Hebrew of finding the direction of Jerusalem rabbi wrote that, although it is not mentioned in ancient or using geographic coordinates, although he did not indicate early Jewish texts, it had become an established Jewish cus what method he used or what dire,::tion he found tom in Europe to bury a person with the legs to the east (or (Langermann 1999). By the 16th century in Poland, one sometimes south) "as symbolic of the faith in resurrection . legal codifier (a rabbi) wrote of facing eastward, but then of the dead, indicating that he will stand up from his grave added that Jews should build a synagogue such that the and leave ... to travel to the Holy Land [when the Messiah direction of prayer is actually southeast, since facing direct comes anq ends the Jewish exile]" (Responsum Hatam ly east (toward where the sun rises) is the way Christians Sofer Y.D.