I 36104 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1971, Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, I item of business I ask unanimous con­ stand in adjournment until 12 o'clock suggest the absence of a quorum. sent that the Senate stand in recess sub­ noon, on Monday, November 18, 19'74. The PRESIDING OFFICER. The clerk ject to the call of the Chair or until that The motion was agreed to; and, at 5:41 will call the roll. item of business arrives. p.m. the Senate adjourned until Mon­ The legislative clerk proceeded to call There being no objection, the Senate day, November 18, 1974:, at 12 o'clock the roll. at 5:37 p.m. recessed subject to the call noon. Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, I ask of the Chair; whereupon, at 5:40 p.m. unanimous consent that the order for the Senate reassembled when called to the quorum call be rescinded. order by the Presiding Officer (Mr. APPOINTMENTS BY THE PRESIDENT The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. GRIFFIN). PRO TEMPORE HARRY F. BYRD, JR.). Without objection, it is so ordered. Pursuant to the provisions of Public Law 93-443, section 310, the following ADJOURNMENT UNTIL MONDAY, were appointed to the Federal Election RECESS SUBJECT TO THE CALL NOVEMBER 18, 1974 Commission: OF THE CHAm Joseph F. Meglen, of Montana, for a term Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, I of 3 years. Mr. MANSFIELD. Mr. President, as move, in accordance with Senate Con­ Joan D. Aikens, of Pennsylvania, for a term long as we are waiting for only one other current Resolution 120, that the Senate of 1 year.

EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS THE FARMER'S SIDE OF THE STORY accept the higher prices and get the Govern­ agencies. Congress has an obligation to ment out of the .farming business through root out these abuses and to see that its controls and subsidies.; or support the they never happen again. HON. CHARLES S. GUBSER controls and subsidies in return for lower Mr. Presi~ent, I ask unanimous .con­ OF CALIFORNIA wheat prices. You can't have both. I hold no brlef for Mr. Butz, but it does sent that the articles I referred to and IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES appear he is the first Secretary of Agriculture an editorial from the September 29, 1974 Wednesday, October 16, 1974 that has done what you, the taxpayer, have edition of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch been demanding the past 40 years and now be printed at this point in my remarks. Mr. GUBSER. Mr. Speaker, in these you don't like the alternative. You have en­ There being no objection, the articles days of escalating prices at the super­ joyed a food bill as low as 15 cents of the and editorial were ordered to be printed market, many people find it all too easy consumer dollar for decades. At the present in the RECORD, as follows: to blame the farmer for the prices they 19 or 20 cents, it is still the lowest of any must pay. nation 1n the world-the next lowest being [From the st. Louis Post-Dispa-tch, in excess of 26 cents. September 25, 1974] Recently Mr. Stephen D'Arrigo, Jr. It 1s strange indeed that we do not hear Civn. SERVICE HEAD HELPED GET GSA Jon wrote a letter to the Public Forum of the same complaints about paying $1,000 FOR POLITICIAN'S COUSIN the San Jose Mercury which gives an­ more for a 1975 auto or more every year for (By Robert Adams) other side to this story. I commend Mr. cigarettes, t.v .. clothes, boats, sports, etc. But, WASHINGTON, September 25.-The cousin D'Arrigo's letter to both farmers and apparently, the farmer 1s expected to subsi­ of a. Texas Representative wa.s given a federal consumers. His letter follows: dize the U.S. citizen's dinner table. career job after Robert E. Hampton, chair­ SALINAS, CALIF., October 10, 1974. Sincerely, STEPHEN D'ARRIGO, Jr. man of the Civil Service Commission, person­ PulJLIC FORUM, ally told the No. 2 man in a Government San Jose Mercury, San Jose, Calif. agency of a. desire r.to help" the Representa­ GENTLEMEN: This is a reply to "Oust Butz" tive, the Post-Dispatch learned today. Public Forum of October 10, 1974. There are According to documents in the hands of a few considerations overlooked by Mr. Wal­ CALLS FOR CONGRESSIONAL IN­ Government investigators, Hampton made ton and I present them here. QUIRY INTO POLITICAL HEAR­ his desire known in a Dec. 8, 1970, letter to Basically, Mr. Walton, the taxpayer has a INGS Rod Kreger, then deputy administrator of the choice, namely government subsidies or General Services Admlnlstration. higher food cost. He can't have simultane­ The letter concerned job possibilities for ously low cost food and no subsidy. There HON. THOMAS F. EAGLETON Dwight W. Jones, a first cousin of Representa­ is no law, moral or legal, that requires a OF MISSOURI tive Robert Price (Rep.), Texas. It noted that farmer to produce wheat or any other crop Jones had passed the Civil Service examina­ IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES and sen at a loss 1n order to provide the tion and added: "If at all possible, I would citizens of this country with the lowest food Thursday, October 17, 1974 like to help Congressman Price." budget as a percent of the consumer dollar The documents indica.te that Jones was 1n the world. Mr. EAGLETON. Mr. President, are­ quickly considered a "must case" by GSA For forty years the Government has main­ cent series of articles by Robert Adams, staff' and later received a mid-level career tained artificially high surpluses for a mixed Washlngton correspondent of the St. job in the Kansas City regional office of the bag of reasons--mostly bureaucratic and po­ Louis Post-Dispatch, alleges numerous GSA. litical. Naturally, this lowers prices below instances of political influence being The documents include a Jan. 26, 19'71, production costs and requires a bureaucratic letter over the name of Robert L. Kunzig, agency administer the "program". They, used to secure positions with the Fed­ to who was then administrator of GSA, to Ha.mp~ therefore, have a stake in the program"­ eral Government, positions which the law says should be awarded strictly on ton saying that a position had been "estab­ their jobs. The polltician can go home and lished" for Jones-although Jones heatedly brag about the lowest food cost in the world. a merit basis. denied today that any job had been set up Everyone is happy except the taxpayer who These are disturbing reports and I just for him. Jones said his post as Customer foots the bill and the farmer who no longer believe the relevant committees of the Service Director for the Kansas City regional enjoys the fruits of the free enterprise sys­ Congress should begin an immediate in­ tem, which happens to include the benefits office o:t GSA's Federal Supply Service had quiry into the situation and, if the facts existed long before he was hired. of a supply and demand economy. are as charged, conduct full public The Civll Service Commission has been ln­ Because the surpluses are the lowest since vestlga"tiing alleged patronage rings in GSA 1948 does not mean that this artificial sur­ hearings. plus was the "magic" level or the wise eco­ Mr. President, I know of no one who and other agencies since at least last year. But today's disclosure was the first public nomic surplus level. We presently have a is not anxious to put Watergate and all indication that the commission's chairman surplus and it 1s a healthy surplus. Until the it represented behind us. But we would breaking of the export contracts, the farm­ have sadly missed the lessons of that had ever passed along a. desire to help a po­ ers were holding back in excess of 70% of litical figure 1n connection with a .federal the 19'14 crop, and we are still in an adequate national trauma if we fail to correct the job. grain situation. The "shortage" is polltical corruption that was revealed before we It was also the first time that the name hokum. The 1975 acreage is committed to close the book. of Kunzig, who is now a judge ln the United planting or in the process of belng planted. No offense of the Watergate period States Court of Claims, had been connected While the public may complain about the was more shocking or more threatening with attempts to find a job for a person in­ "high" price of wheat, they also complain to our system of Government than the directly referred by a political patron. about the subsidies. You will either have to political manipulation of Government In an interview, Hampton said he did not '

October 17, 197!,. EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36105 consider his action improper, but, "I probably "I told Bob Hampton that I knew you agency to hire someone for a speciflc Civil wouldn't do it again." would want Ito do everything possible to Service job, even though the Whlte House Kunzig, through a law clerk, refused to help." The GSA's a.dm.lnistrator at the time used a four-level rating system with "must comment. was Kunzig. place" at the top. AccordiD.i to federal regulations, Civil Serv­ The memorandum went on to ea.y ihat ID :response, Hampton told the Post-Dis­ ice jobs such a.s ~ones's are supposed to be Kreger had given the papers to • st&Jf mem­ patch that he consulted with Malek only on filed on merit under .a competitive system. ber "and asked that he g!l.v-e tb.is matter legitimate toplcs, such as what positions No special favoritism is to be shown to any urgent priority... could be properly exempted from Ctvll Serv­ candidate. A "note to tile.'' which bears no stgna.ture. ice~ Sources familiar with Civil Service rules told of two phone calls made 1n regard to a Hampton said he had no idea untu earlier told the Post-Dispatch that although Hamp­ job of Jones. It ,said that J'Ones "is a must this year that a Nixon Adm1n4stration per­ ton's action did not appear to be illegal, it case." sonnel aid named Alan May had written a raised serious questions about; propriety. A Jan. 26, 1971, letter bearing Kunzlg's document called a "Federal Political Person­ One congressional source said it might ap­ signature. and addressed to Hampton, said: nel ManuaL" In the manual, May discusses pear inconsistent for Hampton to be the chief "Just a note to let you know that we have ways of "getting around" the Civtl Service guardian of the nation's merit system, while established a GS-13 Special Assistant to the laws and removing career government em­ at the same time making a referral of his Regional Director of the Federal Supply ployes who were .not loyal to the Nbron Ad­ own based on a desire to do a favor for a position in Kansas City for Dwight Jones. ministration. poll tical figure. "We will be requesting 11m name certifica­ Hampton said he was •r agency," the souroe said. to you in this matter." House three times in the NiXon Adm.inistra­ "A guy would have to be very naive to In an interview, Hampton acknowledged tion to ask for a directive stmnar to the believe that this would be treated as just that he wouldn't make such a .referral today, one President Fbrd .issued this tn'Onth. The another character reference." although he denied .any Impropriety. Nixon White House never issued such a di­ The source noted also that Hampton was He said he had personally sent letters about rective, he noted. among those who might ultimately sit in individuals to agencies on other occasions Hampton served as a personnel specialist judgment on the question 'Of df.scipllning since being named chairman by then Presi­ in the Air Perce and in the White House un­ the eight or more GSA staff members who dent Richard M. Nixon in 1969. He put the der Presidents Dwight D. Eisenhowe-r and have been charged with violating the Civil total number at "not more than '30," and John F. Kennedy before being named a mem­ Service rules. "He'U be sitting on a case In said that most were referred to him from ber of the Civil Service Commission 1n 1961. which he himself seems to have been in­ nonpolitical sources. He was named chairman ln 1969 and was re­ volved in one matter," the source said. Except for Jones, he said, ••to the best of appointed ln 1973. "It would seem that the man in charge my knowledge not one of them ever got a Neither Prtoe nor Kreger could be reached of upholding the Civil Service rules should job." He said he referred Jones to GSA be­ for comment about the Jones case. have no part in referring people f'Or Civil cause Pri~e was a personal friend of his. Jones. however, defended h1s appointment Service Jobs." "I didn't look upon my letter to them a.s to the job he now holds in the Kansas City In another development, the chairman of a request to do anything improper," Hamp­ regional GSA office. He gave the name of his the House Post Office .and Civil Service Com­ ton said, "and I don't think I can be held predecessor, who confirmed Jones's conten­ mittee said a subcommittee of his panel responsible for what they (the GSA) might tion that the post had existed before Jones would hold hearings on the alleged violations have done." came. of the Civil Service laws. In looking at the doouments, he said, "It's Jones noted that the GSA was the agen­ The announcement was made ln a joint quite obvious that they were trying to please cy responsible for managing the Federal Gov­ statement by Representatives Thaddeus J. me." ernment's buildings and procuring its sup­ Dulski (Dem.), New York, the chairman, and Hampton said he felt that the tone of h1s plies. David W. Henderson (Dem.), North Carolina, letter "anticipated the possibillty of a nega­ "I'm not some used-car salesman who was vice chairlnan. tive reply. It was not something where I unqualified for the job but was brought in In the statement, the two praised Presi­ said: Go out and do this because I want lt!' as a favor to somebody," Jones said... I took dent Gerald R. Ford's recent directive that Hampton noted that he w.as currently in the Civil Serv.ioe exam and passed lt. I've had agencies and departments must keep the a bureaucratic dispute with GSA over wheth­ 20 years in the furniture business. They merit system free from politics. They said, er the Civil Service Commission has the needed somebody with that experience." however, that they were upset about what power to order that GSA staff members be Jones said he had no idea that his name they considered ..inordinate delays.. by GSA disciplined. He voiced a suspicion that some had been discussed 1n high places at GSA in taking disciplinary action agalnst elght in GSA might be atbempttng to smear him and the Civil Service Commission before he staff members accused in a still-secret Civil because he had attacked the ••patronage ring" got the Job ...I guess I'm flattered." he said. Service Commission report. considered friendly to the Nixon Admlnls­ Jones said his mother and Representative Dulski and Henderson said their commit­ tratlon. Price's mother were sisters, making him and tee had been conducting its own investiga­ Hampton noted that the commission was Price first cousins. He refused to go into de­ tion 1n.to allegation'S that CivU Service also investigating a number of other .agen­ tail ltbout his d1scussions with Price about violations had become widespread under the cies, including the Department of Housing a federal job, but said: Ni.xon Atraight from the White Ice of the Department of Health, Education cial consideration because of high connec­ and We1fare. tions or political pull are forbidden. House," a -source familiar with the case told the Post-Dispatch. In another development today. it was In the Shultz case the confidential Civil learned that the comm.ission's attempt to Service Commission report told of how Peter In evaluating the matter, the eommission sa.'id that • wh.a.t was necessary to Normally, such low-paying jobs are filled bring him on board . ., Nesbit received a high degree of preferential through routine Civil Service channels. A handwritten note between two other treatment in GSA's apparent attempt to be Another document, an internal staff GSA staff members, with no da.tes, quotes 'responsive' to the Congressman. memorandum dated Nov. 19, 1971, referred another staff member as saying he under­ "The fact that Mr. Nesbit was not ap­ to a conversation in which Casselman was stood "that there has been discussion per­ pointed does not detract from the fact that said to have told Saylor that GSA would take haps between PHS and Mr. Casselman of set­ in this case the special referral system per­ action to recruit Nesbit for the protective ting up another position for Nesbit in Wheel­ mitted partisan political influence to seri­ officer's job. ing." "Casselman's interest was known by every­ ously disntpt personnel operations in Region The commission's report says that efforts to 3, 1n an apparent attempt to secure a job body there," one source familiar with the employ Nesbit were resumed in the fall of case told the Post-Dispatch. "If there had for Mr. Nesbit in violation of merit princi­ 19'71, but Nesbit could not place high enough ples." been a one-plus priority, this would have on the list of eligible candidates. It quoted been it." Palman as suggesting tha.t Nesbit might The report quotes Palman as saying that According to a confidential Civil Service come to Washington to see if he might be the Nesbit case cost him a.nd his staff at least report on the "special referral unit" in GSA, qualified for some other type of job. But Pal­ one man-month in time, as well as travel Nesbit was offered two jobs as a protective man is quoted as saying that Le May refused, money. Hayas was quoted as saying that he officer but apparently declined both. saying that GSA should see Nesbit instead. alone spent seveml weeks on the case. October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36111 Reached at his home, Nesbit acknowledged patch disclosed last week that the Senator and Norris Ootton of New Hampshire, and writing to Saylor and said: "He's the one, I had been cited as the man who referred former Republican Representative Fred think, who set me up for that job." But he Paul J. Caggiano for a job that the Civil Schwengel of Iowa. noted that he had gone through the civil Service Commission also said involved merit The report says tha-t in 24 of the 25 addi­ service system and had been qualified, and violations. tional cases studied, preferential t~ment "I didn't think they treated me any different "I want to get an explanation of why a was given through GSA's "special referral from anybody else." government official felt he should bend the system." Nesbit said that Hayas, on his visit to rules in a case when he certainly had not It indicates also tha-t Robert Kunzig, Reynoldsville, had indicated that he might been urged to do so by me,'' Mathias's state­ former head of GSA and now a judge in the be able to get a GSA job if he came to Wash­ ment said. u.s. Court of Claims, apparently acquiesced ington. But Nesbit sal~ he preferred to live The aid said Mathias planned also to send in the alleged improper use of 700-hour in a smaller city, so he kept his assembly­ a letter to President Gerald R. Ford urging line job at a factory in Reynoldsville. "temporary appointments" in two cases. him to go beyond his recent reaffirmation It quotes Kunzig as telling one member of Casselman, 33 years old, was a legislative of merit principles and take "affirmative ac­ assistant to Representative Robert McClory Congress that a woman he recommended was tion to deal with those involved" in im­ being given a temporary appointment, and (Rep.), Illinois, from 1965 to 1969. proper activities. In 1969 he was named deputy special as­ adding: "During her 700-hour temporary ap­ Mathias's correspondence file on Mulhall pointment, we plan to initiate proceedings ~o sistant to then President Richard M. Nixon begins with a June 20, 1972, letter from the for congressional relations. He served as obtain her permanent appointment to th1s Senator's office to Ken Duberstein, who was posLtion." GSA's general counsel from 1971 to 1973, and congressional liaison officer for GSA. Worded became counsel to Mr. Ford as vice president But the commission said that such use of a routinely, it asked the GSA to give "every "temporary" appoi.nltment as a wedge for a on Dec. 12, 1973. proper consideration" to Mulhall. Casselman was named to his present job permanent job "was improper under com­ On June 30, Sampson, who was then act­ mission requirements." after Mr. Ford became President. He is one ing administrator, wrote back. He told Ma­ of three attorneys with the title of counsel One case cited by the commission involved thias that Mulhall's application had been a man na.med Richard Lee Finnerty, who to the President. Ph111p Buchen is President referred "to key officials in several of our Ford's counsel with Cabinet rank. was given a GSA job after being referred by services" and that the departments were a member of Congress. The Commission said asked "to review all available and antici­ th.a;t a special job of administrative aid was £From the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, pated vacancies in an attempt to match his Oct. 10, 1974] set up for Finnerty in the Kansas City re­ qualifications with a position." gional office of GSA in viol:a.tion of merit GSA HEAD, JOB SEEKER LINKED on Aug. 15, Mathias wrote a letter re­ rules. (By Robert Adams) peating his hope that Mulhall would be It quoted letters from the unnamed Con-. WASHINGTON, October 10.-Arthur F. "properly considered for a position" and gress member to GSA officials saying it was Sampson, head of the General Service Ad­ thanking Sampson for the GSA's efforts. important to him that "aibsolutely every­ ministration, told a Republican Senator in on Sept. 1, Sampson wrote to Mathias that thing be done on Mr. Finnerty's behalf," and 1972 that the GSA was continuing to try to Mulhall had had interviews with various thalt getting a job for Finnerty would be find a career job for a constituent "because GSA officials on Aug. 11. Because of "per­ hel:pful to public oftlcials, "especially those of your deep interest," it was learned today. sonnel ceiling limitations and lack of vacan­ who think along our lines." The comment was made by Sampson in cies in his field," Sampson said, no job had Investig.altive sources told the Post-Dis­ a Sept. 1, 1972 letter to Senator Charles M. been found so far. patch that the member of Congress in this Mathias Jr. of Maryland. "Because of your deep interest, however, 1971 case was Schwengel, who is now presi­ The letter concerned efforts to place Wal­ we are still pursuing other avenues and dent of the U.S. Capital Historical Commis­ ter P. Mulhall of suburban Washington, who will advise you further within the next two sion. eventually was given a job under conditions weeks," Sampson said. Reached by the Post-Dispatch, Schwengel that the Civil Service Commission said in­ On Dec. 13, Mathias wrote Mulhall that said he knew Finnerty, whose daughter had volved violations of the merit system. "I was very pleased to have been telephoned worked in his Congressional omce. He said Today's disclosure marked the first inci­ by Arthur Sampson, Administrator, General he had referred Finnerty, who then was a dent in which the name of Sampson, whose Services Administration and advised that you constituent living in Keokuk, Ie.., for govern­ title is Administrator of GSA, had been have been accepted at a GS-14 rating with ment jobs. But he said he could not imagine linked in a case in which the Civil Service GSA." having written letters with such language Commission found improper activity. Asked some time ago about Mulhall, in them. After the placement, Sampson apparently Sampson told the Post-Dispatch that he did "I never demanded a job for anybody," made a personal phone call to Mathias's of­ not recall the case. But he said it would not Schwengel said. "There was no pre·ssure. fice to tell him about Mulhall's new job. A necessarily be unusual for the head of an That's so uncharacteristic of anything I've letter from Mathias to Mulhall wishing him agency such as GSA to be in personal con­ ever done, that I just can't imagine it." ..the best of luck in your new position" re­ tact with a senator's office about the filling The collUllission, in its supplemental re­ ferred to the call from Sampson. of a civil service job. port recommended that the GSA review t:t..:> When told by the Post-Dispatch about the One source familiar with the case, how­ necessity of the a.dm.in.1strative aid post to Civil Service Commission's findings. Ma.thlas' ever, told the Post-Dispatch: "Sampson cer­ which Finnerty was named. o:m.ce immediately made the correspondence tainly had to know what was going on." The report noted that 1t had found no file on Mulhall available. Mathias is seeking The Civil Service Commission, without naming either Sampson or Mathias, con­ evidence of fraud or misrepresentation on re-election. An aid said that no special fa­ the part of those who had been given the vors had been asked for, or known about, cluded that the hiring had been done im­ jobs. Sources familiar with the Investigation by the Senator's office. properly. "Based on the special interest said that such job seekers often were the Mulhall was apparently brought to shown in his appointment by the Senator, unwitting beneficiaries of favors for which Mathias's attention by Herbert J. (Jack) Mr. Mulhall was appointed to a position for they had not asked. which open competition had been improper­ Miller Jr.. a prominent Washington lawyer The sources noted also that there was who now represents former President Rich­ ly restricted and for which preferential con­ nothing improper in a referral, as such, from ard M. Nixon. Notations on some of the let­ sideration was given to Mr. Mulhall to the a Senator or a Representative. They indicated ters from Mathias's o:m.ce indicate that a systematic exclusion of all other potential candidates," the commission said. that the political :figures who referred the copy was to be sent to Miller. job seekers may well have been unaware of Mulhall, who said he did not believe he The commission's conclusions were con­ the 81lleged preferential treatment. was granted any special favors, told the tained in a "supplemental report" on its earlier 54-page study of an alleged patron­ In its supplemental report, the Oivil Serv­ Post-Dispatch he knows Miller and may have ice Commission cited some of the techniques mentioned his interest in a government job age ring in GSA. The new report, which cites 24 additional cases of aJ.leged merit­ allegedly used to "get around" the merit sys­ to him in 1972. Mulhall said he went to tem. It said one job seeker was described by a Mathias's office seeking assistance, but did system violations, was made public today by the manpower and Civil Service subcom­ GSA staffer as "a very hot case." Others were not meet the senator. referred to as "must cases" or "must place­ "You surprise me so much I can't get mittee of the House Oommittee on Post ments." over it,'' he said when the letters were read Office and Civil Service. Although the rep<»"t does not name the . In one instance, a GSA staffer was quoted to him. as saying he was told by two GSA officials to · But Mulhall maintained his belief that he political and othe:r sources of the referrals to GSA, the Post-Dispatch learned that "move fast" in finding a job. had received his GB-14 (mid-level) job in Mathias had been the Senator involved in In another, an applicant was purportedly GSA's Automated Data and Telecommuni­ the Mulhall case. told to rewrite her resume to conform to a cations Service on merit, pointing to his 26 Reliable sources said that other political job description. When even that failed, she years experience in marketing and his cer­ figures who made referrals in cases men­ was L!ven a "confidential assistant job"-but t.ifi.cation by the Civil Service Commission. tioned in the report included Republican is exempt from the career service. The aid to Mathias repeated a statement Senators Hugh Scott of Pennsylvania, John One grateful applicant told a GSA staffer made by the Senator a,fter the Post-Dis- c. Tower of Texas, Hiram L. Fong of Hawaii, allegedly involved in the agency's special re-

. 36112 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 ferral un~t the.t her efforts were "essential to Privacy Act of 1974 (H. Rept. 93-1416). privacy and individual rights "transcends my securing employment," according to the The bipartisan measure was unani­ political partisanship ... report. ' DIFFERENCES Representative David N. Henderson (Dem.) mously reported by the Government Op­ North Carolina, f.s chairman of the manpower erations Committee by a 39 to 0 rollcall While forces lining up behind Senate and and CivU Service subcommittee, which re­ vote on September 24 and an open rule House btlls agree that individuals have little leased the supplemental report today along was granted by the House Ru1es Com­ or no control over the information that 1s with the commission's earlier 54 page study. collected about them, strong differences of mittee on October 8 calling for 1 hour opinion exist on the best way to check-as [From the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Sept. 28, of general debate. The crowded legisla­ Ervin puts it--"the government's voracious 1974] tive schedule of the past several days appetite for personal information about each of us." UNCURBED PATRONAGE RINGS unfortunately has prevented action on Ervin, along with Goldwater, Koch and Robert E. Hampton, chairman of the Civil this importr.nt legislation before the Oc­ others, is convinced that nothing less than Service Commf.ssion, says he was "utterly tober recess. a new personal privacy board is required to shocked.. to learn that the White House H.R. 16373 will provide an individual dictate to federal agencies procedures for under President Nixon had prepared a docu­ access to records e,bout him being held by collecting and circulating information about ment detalling ways to circumvent the civil Federal agencies and give him the right individual citizens. service system. His shock has not been trans­ to correct misstatements of fact in those Ervin's insistence on this point was lated into much reform. in prompted by a survey of federal data banks The document was prepared as part of a records, · most cases. The bill has the conducted by the Senate's Constitutional deliberate program to place Nixon loyalists "enthusiastic support" of President Ford, Rights Subcommittee which he chairs. "Find­ in key positions throughout the Government as I indicated in my remarks in the REc­ ing about these [data] systems has been so that federal programs could be manipu­ ORD of October 9, 1974, at page 34838 difficult, time-consuming and a frustrating lated in order to help re-elect the President inserting the fu11 text of his statement experience," Ervin wrote. "The subcommH­ in 1972. This so-called "Responsiveness Pro­ on H.R. 16373. tee met evasion, delay, inadequate and cava­ gram" and mounting evidence of wide-spread Mr. Speaker, to better acquaint Mem­ lier responses {from certain agencies], and political influence peddling in several federal bers with the background on this legis­ all too often a laziness born of a resentment agencies which are supposedly to be staffed that anyone should be inquiring about theh· on a nonpolitical basis constitute, in Mr. lation, I insert at this point the text of activities. Some agencies displayed their ar­ Hampton's view, perhaps the greatest threat an article from the September 28, 1974, rogance by not replying at all. With others, to the federal merit system in its 90-year issue of Congressional Quarterly entitled extracting information was like pulling history. "Privacy: Congress Expected to Vote teeth." Yet a measure of how pervasive threats Controls." A House source, who has worked closely to the merit system have become is that Mr. The article follows: on the privacy issue, put it bluntly: "We Hampton himself has admittedly used his PRIVACY: CONGRESS EXPECTED To VoTE don't trust bureaucrats as far as we can personal in:fluence to help about 30 persons CONTROLS spit." The board concept is incorporated in find jobs, including one candidate placed s 3418 introduced by Ervin and pending in as a favor to a Texas congressman. Privacy: The claim of individuals, groups the Senate Judiciary Committeee. As disclosed by Washington correspondent or institutions to determine for themselves, The Domestic Council Committee on the Robert Adams, government investigators are when, how and to what extent information Right of Privacy, as well as government de­ looking into so-called "patronage rings" in about themselves is communioated to partments, would place personal information several agencies and have already uncovered others."-Dr. Alan Westin, Privacy and Free­ disclosure regulation within the federal ''clear and conclusive" evidence that "a spe­ dom. agencies. "We're not thrUled with the cial referral system" in the General Services With a. coalition of liberals and conserva­ thought of a privacy board or commission tives ln and out of government leading the at this point," a spokesman for the pa11el Administration "gave improper and preferen­ way, Congress is expected before adjourn­ tLal treatment to candidates referred from ment to complete work on privacy legisla­ said. nominally political sources." The committee has been working closely tion that for the first time would clamp with the House Subcommittee on Govern­ Among those who received such treatment controls on the federal government's collec­ foo: job candidates were , when tion and dissemination of personal informa­ ment Information, which reported HR 16373 he was Republican minority leader in the tion about individual citizens. to the full Government Operations Commit­ House, and Hugh Scott, the Republican mi­ But federal agencies and the White House, tee Sept. 12. That measure leaves enforce­ nority leader in the Senate. The GSA, the while supporting the privacy concepts in the ment to the agencies rather than a separate agency charged with buying and maintaining legislation, are lobbying against one proposal board. federal property, allegedly gave candidates that would set up a watchdog panel to see The committee took this approach, Phillips from Mr. Scott's home state of Pennsylvania that the agencies follow strict procedures said, because "if you interpose a layer of bu­ preferential treatment and kept referrals and are seeking amendments that would pre­ reaucracy between citizens and the agencies, from the Senator's office in a special file. vent federal employees and applicants from you are courting an administrative monstros­ The irregularities in the GSA have been obtaining their examination and employ­ ity." Once a board Is created, Phillips added, Iulown to CivU Service investigators for al­ ment investigation results. "it would be almost impossible to eliminate most a year now, and the question is what The outcome could determine whether it." has been done to put the GSA house in order. President Ford signs a final blll, according to The ACLU, meanwhile, is avoiding these A still-secret report called for "immediate William Phllllps, staff director of the House squabbles altogether, taking the position and strong action," yet there have been in­ Government Operations Subcommittee on that any movement on the privacy issue by ordinate delays in disciplining the employes Government Information, which has worked Congress is a progressive step. "We're awed singled out as participants in the GSA pat­ with executive branch officials on the privacy by any action," said Douglass Lea, director of the organization's Privacy Project, a non­ ronage ring. legislation. L Perhaps CivU Service Chairman Hampton, Another Government Operations Commit­ profit tax-exempt effort set up to monitor who defends his efforts to do a favor for a tee staff source, however, said the panel could data collection by government and private congressman-but concedes he ••probably report "the most outrageous privacy blll, and institutions. in the moment of truth, everyone would go Despite assertions by privacy bill sup­ wouldn't do it again"-is not the best man porters that their proposals are compre­ to carry out a vigorous effort to defend the along with it so they wouldn't be on the record in opposition to privacy." hensive, both Senate and House measures merit system from persistent political attack. provide broad exemptions for files containing TRANSCENDING PARTISANSHIP national defense, foreign policy and crim­ House and Senate privacy legislation, which inal investigation data. would give Americans acce&.; to many of their "This is one area where I feel that most H.R. 16373-PRIVACY ACT OF 1974 records maintained by federal agencies, has proposed privacy legislation has been grossly drawn such diverse proponents as the Domes­ deficient," Rep. BellaS. Abzug (D N.Y.) told tic Council Committee on the Right of Pri­ the House April 2 during a colloquy on pri­ HON. WILUAM S. MOORHEAD vacy, headed by President Ford; the American vacy organized by Goldwater and Koch. OF PENNSYLVANIA Civil Liberties Union (ACLU); the House Legislation introduced by Abzug "spe­ Republican Research Committee; Represent­ cifically includes records in this area, be­ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES atives Barry M. Goldwater Jr. (R Calif) cause I believe we cannot make an exception Thursday~ October 17, 1974 and Edward I. Koch (D N.Y.) and Senators of one of the most abused areas and then Sam J. Ervin (D N.C.) and Charles H. Percy expect people of this country to feel tllat Mr. MOORHEAD of Pennsylvania. Mr. (Rni.). we have. produced a serious piece of legisla­ Speaker, soon after the House recon­ Koch, who along with Goldwater, has been tion." Under Abzug's proposal, however, rec­ venes next month, Members wm have the in the forefront of the privacy issue in the ords that are being used in active criminal opportunity to vote on H.R. 16373, the House, asserts that the matter of personal prosecution would not be disclosed. October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36113

LOBBY REPORT-2 FEDERAL DATA BANKS

Number not Number not reporting reporting Number of Number number Number Number of Number number Number Agency data banks computerized of records of ret:ords Agency data banks computerized of records of records

ACTION ______:-_-:-_-:. _-:-_:. .; 6 351,700 Federal Mediation and Concili8- Administrative Office of the U.S. tion Service ______~__ :;:; ••••:.: :;;;;; I I 0 1, 000 Courts _._-----__ :. ______:. ••• 9 9 4 757,000 Federal Power Commission •• :..;.-= 1 0 0 1, 100 App~la_chian Regional Com· Federal Reserve Board ••:. -.;;..;;;;.·. 1 0 0 1,369 miSSIOn ___ :. -----=------.: 3 2 3 0 Federal Trade Commission ____-= ;,-;.; 1 1 1 0 Civil Aeronautics Board ______1 1 0 0 General Services Administration •• 2 1 0 119, 000, 160 Civil Service Commission ______13 8 4 18,972,800 Interstate Commerce Commission. 1 0 0 1, 750 Department of Agriculture ______6 5 0 5, 539,200 National Aeronautics and Space Department of Commerce ••••••• 8 8 3 204, 165, 500 Administration ______--=· 1 0 1 26,931 Department of Defense: National Credit Union Adminis· Department of the Air Force_ 73 36 13 18,001, 109 tration ______----- __ ----- __ I 0 1 512 Department of the Army ____ 385 382 12 34,467,849 National Science Foundation _____ 4 4 1 375,505 Department of the Navy _____ 20 12 6 6,154,368 Office of Economic Opportunity ___ 13 13 3 108,360 Miscellaneous Department of Office of Emergency Ppeparedness. 2 2 0 1, 905,000 Defense offices and Office of Management and Budget. 3 2 0 2,083 agencies _____ :::::. .::-•• _____ 19 13 3 2,626, 090 Railroad Retirement Board ______9 4 5 15,468,000 Department of Health, Educa- Securities and Exchange Com· tion, and Welfare ______61 60 0 402, 428, 158 mission ______=--- ______6 6 0 679, 50(} Department of Housing and Selective Service System ______1 1 0 14,860,811 Urban DevelogmenL ______27 25 6 9,862, 305 Small Business Administration ___ 4 2 0 884,000 Department oft e Interior ______1 0 0 79,800 Special Action Officer for Drug Department of Justice ______19 12. 4 139, 031, 722 Abuse Prevention ______.: 1 0 0 23,000 Department of Labor______4 3 1 24,000,000 Tennessee Valley Authority ______8 7 3 146, 150 Department of State ______.______2 1 1 243,135 U.S. Atomic Energy Commission •• 6 6 0 1, 088, GOO Department of Transportation ____ 18 17 2 6, 194,430 U.S. Commission on Civil Rights •• 3 1 1 379 Department of the Treasury __ • __ 46 38 7 155, 571, 458 U.S. Information Agency ______2 2 0 17,698 Environmental Protection Agency. 4 4 0 41,200 U.S. Postal Service ______2 2 0 23,000 Equal Employment Opportunity U.S. Tariff Commission ______2 2 2 0 5 Veterans Administration ______Commission _____ ------131,000 White House ______29 21 1 72,604,326 Farm Credit Administration ______3 2,900 7 4 0 151,940 Federal Communications Com- mission ___ :. _·______----- __ 12 12 2, 253,481 TotaL ______------858 741 93 1, 245, 699, 494 Federal Deposit Insurance Cor- poration ______30,000

Source: Senate Constitutional Rights Subcommittee. Privacy push Nixon White House order that had given the "There are organizations we thought would While observers say Watergate is responsi­ Department of Agriculture permission to ex· have lined up with us-oommon Cause and ble in part for the likely passage of a privacy amine farmers' tax records, killing a. General Ralph Nader," Lea said. "But they are wary b111 this session, Douglass Lea of the ACLU Services Administration plan for a new gov­ of the issue. They want more disclosure (by belleves the activities of the White House ernment data bank and winning House ac~ government and business), and they seem. committee on privacy, the Department of ceptance of the 1974 education records' pri­ to think there would be a confiict" by taking Health, Education and Welfare, the ACLU vacy amendments. an active role on privacy. itself and Goldwater and Ervin, among others The committee also has worked closely with The Privacy Project closely obse·rves con­ in Congress, created a "billiard ball effect" the House Government Operations Subcom­ gressional action on privacy legislation, al· on privacy, keeping the issue rolling in the mittee on Foreign Operations and Govern­ though the group has refused to take public Senate and House. ment Information in developing the privacy positions on pending bills because of its Liberals have been drawn to the issue, Lea bill (HR 16373) sponsored by the panel's tax status. The project, nevertheless, issued said, because of their "disillusionment that chairman, WilliamS. Moorhead (D Pa.). Staff a memorandum March 1 outlining s·ix cate­ massive record keeping just hasn't worked Director Phillips told gories of needed priva;cy legislation, includ­ out," while conservatives "with breathing the White House committee has "probably ing some 40 separate proposals. time after the social unrest of the last few done as much as onyone to call attention to The ACLU suggested that Congress take years, have become aware of the potential the dimensions of this Issue." steps to protect cittzens against invasion of of a pollee state." The House Republican Research Committee their political rights, to protect individuals Although the privacy issue faces few out­ Task Force on Privacy. Chaired by Rep. Gold­ ·against abuse of the oriminal process, to con­ spoken critics, "pockets of resistance do sur­ water, the task force Aug. 21 issued a set of trol wiretapping and computerized data face when you get down to specifics,'' Lea legislative recommendations for combating banks and to increase citizens' ability to en­ said, referring to amendments regulating the threats to privacy in the folloWing areas: force privacy rights against government and privacy of school records that were included government surveillance, federal information private organizations. in the 1974 education bill (HR 69-PL 93- collection, social security numbers, census in· Senator Ervin's forthcoming retirement has 380). The provisions barring federal funds to formation, bank secrecy, consumer reporting, distressed the organization, which feels that any educational institution or agency that school records, juvenile records, arrest rec­ he "alone has the seniority and influence permitted the release of a student's records ords, medical records and computer data among his colleagues, the subcommittee without parental consent were an anathema banks. chairmanship (Constitutional Rights), the to "education data massagers," Lea said. ACLU Priv·acy Project. Launched two years stab111ty of an established political figure ago, the project serves as a clearing house FORCES INVOLVED and the wlllingness to take on tough pri­ and monitoring point on priva.cy matters, vacy and survelllance issues." Major centers of activity on the privacy is­ supplying reports and information to others sue are: But some civil libertarians, the ACLU working on the issue, including the White noted in its Privacy Re-port, "have sensed in The Domestic Council Committee on Pri­ House committee, members of the House and vacy. Established by former President Nixon Congress on any pl"ivacy issue a lazy 'leave Senate and congressional committees. A it to Sam' attitude that may be dissipated on Feb. 23, the committee was given responsi­ monthly Privacy Report is published by the bility for developing plans to protect an indi­ project, detailing privacy abuses and actions when Ervin returns to North Carolina." The vidual's right of privacy. taken by others to gain public attention on ACLU believes Ervin's departure may mean Under Ford's direction, the committee ap­ data collection. that privacy issues wm be splinteTed among proved 14 specific proposals July 10 for "im­ 'I'he tax-exempt project 1s supported by seve·ral senators with particular interests: mediate action" by federal agencies. Included foundation and business funds, including Edward M. Kennedy (D. Mass.) on military were in.itiatives to prohibit miUtary surveil­ grants from the Marshall Field Foundation, surveillance, Gale W. McGee (D Wyo.) on lance of civilian political activities, to protect federal employee rights, Charles McC. Mathi·as personal bank account records against dis­ IBM and Polaroid. The reason IBM is sup­ porting the ACLU effort, according to Lea., Jr. (R Md.) on criminal justice, Alan Cran­ closure to government agents, to safeguard ston (D. Calif.) on bank secrecy and Barry unauthorized disclosure of federal tax re­ is the corporation's "long range interest to turns and build privacy safeguards into fed­ see that confidence in the computer is not M. Goldwater (R Ariz.) on data banks. eral computers and communications systems. eroded." Congress' concern According to a spokesman for the commit­ While other private organizations, includ­ In its Aug. 21 report on privacy, the House tee, the panel will review the progress the ing the American Trial Lawyers Association Republican Research Committee concluded agencies have made on the proposals at its have taken some initiative on privacy issues, that the "individual has been physically by­ next meeting this fall. the ACLU is the most active non-govern­ passed in the modern information process" The committee takes credit for reversing a mental group pursuing the privacy cause. because he is "assumed to waive any .and all 36114 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 interest and control over the information priv-acy had been introduced with 207 spon­ The major area of contention on the House collected about him.'' sors; in the Senate, various privacy b111s were bill is the effort by John N. Erlenborn (RIll.) Under most information systems, an indi· sponsored by 62 members). to prevent federal employees from gaining vidual does not really know who has col­ Most of the pending bills are directed to access to their examination and employment lected data about him or how many agencies one aspect of the privacy question: they investigation results. An amendment by or corporations are using it for what pur­ range from banning the disclosure of Soci-al Erlenborn to provide these exemptions was pose, Rep. Goldwater maintad.ns. Security numbers to prohibiting financial defeated Sept. 19 by the Government Oper­ AREA OF CONCERN institutions from disseminating inform-ation ations on a 22-11 vote and is not expected on their customers to government agencies. to win approval on the House floor. "I just Republicans cite Bureau of Census data Other bills would restrict existing practices don't know what Ford will do with a pri· collection and dissemination practices as one of criminal information systems, ban polit­ vacy bill that doesn't contain the exemp· major a-rea of concern. ical surveillance by the Army and control tions,'' said Phillips. Under penalty of law, each citizen is forced ilUcit uses of wiretapping. Another potential trouble spot on the pri­ to divulge intimate personal facts about his With the introduction of the Ervin and vacy legislation is the inclusion of private public and private life, nQited the Republican Moorhead bills, privacy forces feel they have as well as federal data banks in the Ervin Privacy Tll!sk Force. The Census Bureau then found a satisfactory approach to dealing bill. But there is a certain reluctance by pri­ sells parts of its collected data to anyone with the central issue raised by the seem­ vacy forces to become involved in the regula­ who wishes to purchase the information. ingly disparate pieces of leg"islation. tion of private data banks. "As the [census] quest ions become more . The common thread, said p,ercy, is the in­ - According to the White House privacy com­ detailed and extensive, broad-scale dissemi­ dividual's right to cont rol how, when and mittee, "Federal example and experience in nation becomes more threatening and fright­ to what extent information about himself is this complex field should precede federal di­ ening,'' according to the task force. "When communicated to others. rectives to the non-federal governmental and used in combination with phone directories, private sectors." drivers' licenses and street directories, cen­ ERVIN AND MOORHEAD BILLS Under the Ervin bill, an individual could Douglas Lea of the ACLU agrees. "There is sus data may enable anyone interested to a lack of knowledge in this area. It would be identify an individual." not be forced to disclose any information easy to leap into regulating private activity if While the task force points to census prac­ not required by law, and he would have to you're not careful." tices as a potential area for privacy abuse, be informed of his right not to dis.close. He And according to Joe Overton, "You don't Ervin's Constitutional Rights Subcommittee also would be notified of the existence of any want to legislate in the private sector until in a 1974 report on "Federal Data Banks and information maintained on him and how the you know what you're dealing with. Infor­ Constitutional Rights" reported the exist­ information was used. m ation practices widely vary in the private ence of three "peculiar data banks" : Secret In addition, a person would h ave the right sector. There's less sharing of data. The fed­ Service files on persons who make antl-gov· to inspect information pertaining to him and eral level is different. With these agencies, ernment remarks or embarrassing statements have the right to challenge any information it's easier to exchange information." about government officials; a Department of on the basis of its accuracy, completeness or Health, Education and Welfare blacklist of necessity. scientists, and an Army computer system in· The bill also places strict restrictions on volving political surveillance. the dissemination of information contained BASIC LESSON in data systems, requiring an agency to re· CLIFFORD MciNTIRE quest permission from the individual before According to the committee's report, distributing data about him to those not "There are immense numbers of government having regular, authorized access to the in­ HON. JOHN J. RHODES data banks, littered with diverse information formation. OF ARIZONA on just about every citizen in the country." But the most controversial part of the IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES (Chart, preceding page) measure is the provision establishing a fed­ But it was the committee's difficulty in eral privacy board that would have the au­ Tuesday, October 8, 1974 determining the a.ctual number and extent thority to intercede in the event an agency . Mr. RHODES. Mr. Speaker, it was with of data. banks in existence that led Ervin to abuses data information procedures. conclude: "The most basic lesson the sub­ The Moorhead bill, on the other hand, a deep sense of loss that I learned of the committee survey teaches is the absolute ne­ which also grants an individual access to his untimely death of our former colleague cessity of replacing this voluntary survey ap­ federal records, would depend on self-en­ and dear friend, Clifford G. Mcintire. proach with a statutory requirement that all forcement by government agencies and, if Cliff came from the heartland of federal data banlts be fully and accurately re• that failed, by the federal courts. -Aroostook County-potato coun-· ported to the Congress and the American Federal agencies feel that the federal pri­ try. He was drawn to the land, studied. people." vacy board plan "would insert a new layer agronomy at the ­ The informa•tion-gathering impulse of the of bureaucracy in their transactions,'' said federal government is mirrored by similar Joe Overton, a legislative assistant to Rep. and engaged in farming throughout his­ developments in the private sector, according Goldwater. "They are dragging their heels life. to Sen. Percy, a co-sponsor of Ervin's pri­ and resisting an invasion on what they see After a 4-year stint with the Farm vacy bill (S. 3418). as their traditional prerogatives." Credit Administration, he became assist-· Credit agencies with their consumer files . Moorhead's subcommittee staff, Overton ant general manager of the Maine Potato have proliferated in recent years; educa­ added, "believes in privacy, but they are also Growers at Presque Isle. tional institutions are beginning the process looking to efficiency in government" which He came to the 82d Congress after a of computerizing student records; hospital might be affected by privacy board activities. and medical centers are finding computers special election to fill the vacancy caused· Staff member Phillips points out that a by the death of Frank Fellows. For 14 the answer to much of then· record keeping privacy board would be expensive to set up difficulties. years in the House of Representatives he "When such information is stored on tape and "would be open to attack" because of served Maine and the Nation with dedi­ it is easily transferred from one user to that on the House floor. "If Congress finds that self-enforcement cation and distinction. another,'' Percy said. "The individual has After leaving the Hill and until his re­ no knowledge of the transfer, and no ability (by the agencies) is not working, then it can to correct information about himself that always come back later and say, 'We're going tirement in December 1963, Cliff worked could ruin his chances for a new job ... or to shove a c01nmission down your throat'," with the American Farm Bureau. His: be taken as cause for investigation by a law he added. But the agencies "will take the bill knowledge of Congress-of farming­ enforcement agency. seriously,'' because there are strong civil and and of the legislative problems connected Which approach? criminal penalties for violations in the meas­ with the law and land, led to his appoint­ ure. The legislative controversy over the im­ ment to the President's Task Force on pact of federal data banks on individual OUTLOOK Rural Development, 1969-70; to the Ad­ privacy began in the mid-1960s when pro­ The subcommittee rejected the privacy visory Council of the Public Land Law posals to set up a national data bank sta­ board plan by a 7-2 vote, but the proposal Review Commission, 1968-70; and to the tistical center were discussed in the execu­ was expected to be offered again during con­ board of directors of the U.S. Railway tive branch. sideration of HR 16373 by the full Govern­ Association, for which confirmation was Although the idea was abandoned after ment Operations Committee. assured, and voted posthumously by the outcries from the public, press and Congress Phillips said, however, that he does not Senate. that the data center would lead the United expect the amendment to pass and that 1t Cliff Mcintire epitomized the spirit of States directly into "1984," hundreds of bills probably faces defeat if offered on the House Maine. H~ was direct-he spoke sparing­ have been introduced in Congress relating floor. Should the Senate adopt the idea, the to other personal privacy issues. (In the 93rd issue then would have to be resolved in con­ ly-but tellingly. He truly represented Congress through Mat·ch, 102 House bills on ference. the craggy indepe~dence that always has October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36115 characterized the Pine Tree State. You be given to the public that these meet­ ing to inter-agency and intra-agency mem­ knew where Cliff Mcintire stood-and ings will be held. orandums and letters, is inapplicable and why. Generally, agencies are complying with cannot be invoked by defendants or their Our Nation has suffered a loss in being agents or employees as to documents which the provisions of the act. In addition, the have been voluntarily disclosed by the agency deprived of his presence and his talents. very small staff within the Office of Man­ to members of an advisory committee who are I join my fellow Members of the House in agement and Budget assigned to oversee not full-time officers or employees of the expressing our appreciation for having these advisory committees are valiantly Federal government; Cliff as our colleague-and I extend my attempting to comply with the act. (3) Exemption Five of the Freedom of In­ condolences to his wife, Wilda, and to formation Act, 5 U.S.C. § 552(b) (5), is inap­ his children. Fortunately, where the agencies have plicable and cannot be invoked by the de­ failed to interpret the act correctly, the fendants or their agents or employees as a courts have not. I have previously sub­ basis for closing any meeting of the Travel mitted statements for the RECORD con­ Advisory Board or any other advisory com­ mittee from the public, or for excluding the CLIFFORD G. MciNTIRE cerning court decisions relating to the plaintiffs or any other interested persons interpretation of the Freedom of Infor­ from any such meeting; HON. ROBERT L. F. SIKES mation Act, an integral part of the Fed­ (4) The defendants and their agents and eral Advisory Committee Act. "any special aspects of reflects his personal perspective on the ma­ dation may never achieve the dignity of an the facUlties and equipment and the extent terial being summarized. agency's final decision; it may do so when of departmental and interdepartmental co­ An example may be taken from the Sum­ the agency adopts it as its own, and at that operation" at the appllcant's institution. The mary Statement before us without com­ point its disclosure can be required. Ameri­ proposed project budget is then analyzed promising any information for which exemp­ can Mail Ltne, Ltd,. v. Gulick, 411 F.2d 696 with reference to its adequacy, justification, tion !s claimed. In the course of describing a (D.C. Cir. 1969) is a case in point. The1·e the and projected duration (6). Supplemental proposal for evaluating the relative efficacy of question was "whether an administrative requests are related to previously approved a number of drugs in the treatment of agency {the Maritime Subsidy Board] may amounts.lB To all of this may be appended hyperkinetic children, the following state· take affirmative action against a private (7) the Executive Secretary's Note, de· ment appears: "The assessment battery con­ party by means of a decision in which it scribed supra at p. 5, {8) the minority report sists of a number of rating scales, and various states that the only basis for such action is of two or more dissenting members, and (9) cognitive and performance measures." Signif­ a certain specified [staff] memorandum and a summary of any site visit report. icantly, however, while the various per­ t hen refuse to disclose the memorandum to The site visit report itself contains, in ad­ formance and cognitive tests are then the party affected by the action." Whlle the dition to purely identifying material, such enumerated, the rating scales are neither question was answered in the negative, the as application number, date, and persons identified nor described, but are said only reason was that the agency had made the seen, (10) evaluations of the proposal, the to have provided sensitive in prior, unspeci­ memorandum the express and only basis for investigator, and his staff, (11) sections on fied studies. This difference of treatment inay its decision and not thS~t it had made the the facilities and other support available at well reflect no more than the greater ease staff into the "agency." In the present case, the institution and (12) the budget, and with which named tests can be referenced however, leaving aside the problem of {13) "other comments." Because of the sub· than rating scales described. It may, on the whether even the denial of a grant award is stantial overlap necessary between the site other hand, reflect the view that certain well­ "affirmative action" against an applicant, the visit report and Summary Statements, site known tests have a definite reputation for reasoning of the ma is not the "only basis" visitors are advised to follow the format for reliability, and that rating scales are only so for the Secretary's decision. The Executive the latter document "since the site vtsit re .. much surplusage. A different group of re­ Secretary's Note and the NAMHC's policy port, it accepted by the [ IRG] can serve as viewers with a different set of views might choices, and in some instances the latter's a basis for the Summary Statement." NIMH well have elaborated on the rating scales' 46. particularized scrutiny, intervene.1• Cf. Sterl­ Handbook, at utility and never specified the cognitive and ing Drug, Inc. v. FTC, 450 F.2d 698, 706 (D.C. From this mere recitation it is clear that performances tests proposed. What the effect Cir. 1971). We hold, therefore, that the IRG most of the matters called for in the site of such a choice might be on the proposal's is not itself an agency under the APA nor, report and Summary Statement for each ap­ prospects we need not guess. The point is plication are evaluative, and call into play simply that choices are and must be made by con~~equently, subject to the strictures of the someone or some group with a unique per­ FOIA.1G the policy of protecting the deliberate proc­ 2. Application of Exemption 5. ess, at which Exemption 5 is directed. See spective, and decisions may be based on Having decided that the IRG is not an EPA v. Mink, supra; Soucie v. Davia, supra. them. Accordingly, the two items under dis­ Indeed, the only matters that are even argu­ cussion must also be held exempt from dis­ agency, nor its Sununary Statements and site closure.00 visit reports the final decisions of an agency, ably subject to compelled disclosure are the Summary Statements' (2) description of the The NIMH Handbook alone does not in­ it becomes necessary to determine just how dicate whether the two items in the site much of the disputed information in these proposal, its aims and methodology, and any factual matter contained in {9) the summary visit report-{11) the facilities and (12) intra-agency documents is exemp·t from dis­ of the site visit report. In the site visit re• budget references--are meant to be narra­ closure. Exemption 5 applies only to matters. port itself, only (11) the statement of fac111- tive or analytic. The representative site visit "which would not be available by law to a ties, and (12) the budget, merit comment. report submitted to the District Court, which party other than an agency in litigation with Of these four items, the two (2 and 9) in is of controlling significance,21 suggests the the cgency." While there are often problems the Summary Statement are abstracts of latter, however, at least with respect to in determining the precise scope of the ex­ other information--either the site visit re­ budgetary considerations. The short section emption without the benefit of actual litiga­ port or portions of the underlying applica­ on the budget relates the amount requested tion the nature of which informs the breadth tion. As such we think them covered by the to the site visitors' analysis of the amount of discovery, see Environmental Protection reasoning of Montrose Chemical, supra. That needed, and suggests for IRG consideration Agency v. Mink, 410 U.S. 73, 86 (1973), its case involved application of Exemption 5 to a possible economizing step. As such, it is application in this case is relatively uncom• summaries, made by agency staff attorneys, clearly a part of the deliberative process and plicated. As a general proposition Exemption of evidence developed at a public hearing. exempt from compelled disclosure. But this 5 does not shield from disclosure "purely fac­ The summaries were prepared for and sub­ particular report makes no reference to the tual, investigative matters," as opposed to mitted to the Administrator of the Environ­ matter of facilities, neither describing nor ••materials reflecting deliberative or policy­ mental Protection Agency "to assist [him] rendering an opinion on the adequacy of the making processes." Ia. at 89. Even purely in his study of the record" on the basis of facilities available to the grant applicant. 2~ factual matter may be exempt, however, it which he was obliged to make a decision. The entire document, however, other than it is inextricable without compromise of the This court held the summaries exempt as an the opening paragraphs which describe the deliberative process, id. at 91, and so too integral part of the deliberative process. proposal and for which no claim of exemp­ may be "a summary of factual material Sensitive to the necessity of attaching vary­ tion is made, is an expression of the visitors' [that] is part of the deliberative process," ing degrees of significance to different facts opinions and not a recitation of facts. This even though the facts themselves are else­ in the course of epitomizing the record, we suggests that facilities references, if any, in where on the public record. Montrose Chem­ said: the site visit repo1·ts for other of the applica­ "Even if they cited portions of the evidence tions sought by appellee would be of the ical Corp. v. Train, 491 F.2d 63 (D.C. Clr. same nature. In llght of the parties' agree­ 1974). verbatim, the assistants were making an evaluation of the relative significance of the ment, supra note 21, however, we need not In order to apply these propositions to the choose between reliance on this speculation, facts at bar, the contents of the Summary facts recited in the record; separating the pertinent from the impertinent is a judg­ with its potential effect of relieving the Statements and site visit reports need fur­ mental process, sometimes of the highest agency of its statutory burden of proof, and ther elaboration at this point. We take as order; no one can make a selection of evi­ in camera inspection of all the site visit re­ our texts appellee's Exhibit 1, the NIMH dence without exercising some kind of ports in suit. Finding no matter of the type Handbook, S'Upra note 2, at 33-36, documents judgment, unless he is simply making a sought in the controlling document, there is as illustrated by the sample submitted to random selection." 491 F.2d at 68. no relief respecting item {12) to which ap­ the court. The Summary Statements begin No significant difference distinguishes the pellee can lay claim. 2~ with ( 1) a concise resume, "no more than present case from Montrose Chemical. The IU six or seven sentences," of the proposed proj­ research design and description of methodol­ Appellant challenges the District Court's ect, its review by the IRG, and the reasons ogy in the application submitted for in jurisdiction to order the agency to amend for the ma•s recommendation, including the camera inspection covers fifteen, single­ its regulations to conform with the court's contrary reasons offered by a minority.1s spaced typewritten pages; their description opinion. The FOIA, it is contended, "grants There follows (2) a "brief description of the in the Summary Statement is one page in jurisdiction to the district courts only to proposal," lts "alms, methodology, and, for length.19 In the Montrose Chemical paradigm. review agency denials of requests for specific renewal, supplemental and revised proposals, the judgmental element arises through the documents and to enjoin withholding of the background or history." The next and necessity to select and emphasize certain those documents" from the person who n1ade "most critlca.l." section is the ma•s critique the request. That is of course true insofar facts at the expense of others. In the instant as it goes, but is not respmslve to whether (3) which discusses "the strengths and weak­ case, where the whole proposal must be de­ nesses of various aspects of the proposal in the court may not draw on powers apart from, scribed at least in general, various aspects and unabridged by, the FOIA in order to detail." 11 The "background and competence" of it are described in greater detall than give complete relief whe:re it is due. "With of the appllcant and his associates (4) are others. In virtually every sentence the author the express vesting of equitable jurisdiction must operate at a level of specificity that in t he District Court by § 552 {a), there is Footnotes at end of article. October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36119 little to suggest, despite the Act's primary tarily disclosed the purely factual matter research, could conceivably be shown to have purpose, that Congress sought to limit the contained the·rein, in an apparent recogni­ a commercial or trade interest in his research inherent powers of an equity court." Rene­ tion that such matters do not come within design. For the eleven grantees whose proto­ gotiation Board v. Bannercraft Clothing Co, the purposes of the exemption. Lastly, we cols are sought in this case, however, their 415 U.S. 1 (1974) (dictum). have found, in the circumstances of this institutional affiliations with colleges and One can imagine circumstances, such as record, an inappropriate exercise of equity universities (7), research institutes (2), hos­ its actions to the known requirements of jurisdiction in the District Court's injunctive pitals and state agencies (1 each), make this the Act in order to deter requests for infor­ command that HEW conform its regulations possibility extremely remote. In addition it where an agency simply refuses to conform to the court's mandate. is established by an undenied allegation in mation by repetitive litigation, that would The judgment of the District Court is, ac­ the complaint that "[n]one of the grants is tempt a court to use any or all of "the usual cordingly, affirmed in part and reversed in concerned with the production or marketing weapons in the arsenal of equity," Banner­ part; and the case is remanded for the entry of the drugs being tested." ll 9, JA 5. This craft Clothing Co. v. Renegotiation Board, of a decree consistent herewith. does not absolutely preclude the possibility 466 F.2d 345, 354 (1972), rev'd on other It ~ so ordered. of commercial activity, but in any event, grounds, 415 U.S. 1 ( 1974). In the case at FOOTNOTES the burden of showing the trade or commer­ cial character of the research design infor­ bar, however, it is unnecessary to decide 1 We consider that continuation, renewal, whether the District Court would be so em­ and supplemental applications are all inci­ mation was on the agency, and since it did powered. dent to the initial application; and we see not introduce a single fact relating to the Appellee initiated the process, culminat­ commercial character of any specific research no reason to distinguislh. between them for project, it can hardly have carried its bur­ ing in this action by a letter requesting purposes of their availability to disclosure access to documents relating to eleven spe­ under FOIA. den on this point. 7 See note 6, supra. cifically identified research grants. When 2 The District Court stated that "the the request had been denied in part and Council members do not receive individual s See Restatement of Torts § 757, Com­ administrtive 81ppeal exhausted, appellee grant applications. Their decision is based ment b (1939): "Definition of trade secret. filed a complaint the prayer of which re­ solely on the review group Summary State­ A trade secret may consist of any formula, quested that the coul"t declare the plain­ ments," 366 F.Supp. at 934. The NIMH pattern, device or compilation of information tiff's right to disclosure of the disputed Handbook for Initial Review Staff states, which is used in one's business, and which records and order their disclosure, and however, that the NAMHC "reviews each ap­ gives him an opportunity to obtain an ad­ "[t]hat this Court declare invalid under plication and its accompanying Summary vantage over competitors who do not know the F1reedom of Information Act the regula­ Statement." P. 38. This publication was in or use it." (Emphasis added.) o See FINAL REPORT OF THE ATTORNEY GEN­ tions issued by [HEW] which exempt from the record before the District Court as public disclosure all research protocols and ERAL'S COMM. ON ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE, Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 1. The only contra­ Doc. No. 8, 77th Cong., 1st Sess. 7 (1941) all proposed grant applications." J.A. 6. In its dictory indication seems to be a statement s. opinion the District Court merely suggested ("the power to determine, either by rule or in the deposition of Dr. R. S. Lipman, Chief by decision, private rights and obligations"); that " [a] t a minimum, the defendants should of the Clinical Studies Section. Psycho­ promptly modify existing regulations and 1 K. DAVIS, ADMINISTRATIVE LAW TREATISE pharmacology Research Bmnch, NIMH. Dr. § 1.01, at 1 (1958) ("a governmental au­ grant application instructions to bring them Lipman was Acting Executive secretary at into conformity with the decision of this thority, other than a court and other than the time of his deposition, and was familiar a legislative body, which affects the rights Court," but its order elevated this sugges­ with the operation of the IRGs but not with tion into an injunctive obligation presum­ of private parties through either adjudica­ that of the NAMHC. When asked whether tion or rulemaking"); Freedman, Adminis­ a~bly enforceable in the same manner as any the latter group acted solely·with the Sum­ injunction, namely, by contempt. trative Procedure and the Control of Foreign mary Statements before it, he replied (p. Direct Investment, 119 U. PA. L. REv. 1, 9-10 The FOIA requires each agency to make in­ 102): formation, not exempt by the terms of the (1970): "Where a center of gravity lies, where A. I believe, and I am really talking off the substantial 'powers to act' with respect to Act, available "in accordance with published top of my head, I believe they have all of - individurus are vested, there is an administra­ rules." From this may readily be inferred an the pink sheets and then they can have tive agency for purposes of the APA .... oblig81tion to publish rules that accurately made available to them any particular grant reflect the agency's substantive obligations [But] a definition stated thus broadly is not [appllcation] that they have a particular self-applying. It is an abstract proposition under the Act, and rules that fail to do so question about. that does not neatly decide concrete cases." are of no force when "any person" seeks ac­ The best evidence of what the practice is 10 This system originated with the National cess to information not exempt from dis­ would appear to be the official publication Cancer Institute Act, which created, in addi­ closure under the Act. Pretermitting the on which both parties have relied extensive­ tion to the Institute, the National Cancer very real question of whether a single ly and the accuracy of which neither has Advisory Council. Ch. 565, § 3, 50 Stat. 560 request for documents creates a continuing questioned in any p·articular. (1937). case or controversy :u sufficient to support an a Instances are related in HousE CoMM, 11 As added, Pub. L. No. 87-838, 76 Stat. order to amend regulations of only specula­ ON GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS, THE ADMIN• 1073; see Public Health Service Act§ 301, ch., tive future effect on an FOIA plaintiff, there ISTRATION OF RESEARCH GRANTS IN THE PUB~ 373, § 301, 58 Stat. 691 (1944). is no warrant in the record of this case for LIC HEALTH SERVICE, H. REP. No. 800, 90th 1.2 "If the OST's sole function were to ad­ anticipating that HEW would not proceed Cong., 1st Sess. 62 (1967). vise and assist the President, that might be in good faith to incorporate the substance • The District Court stated that " [ g] eneral taken as an indication that the OST is part of a final court decision into its rules and priorities for funding are determined by the of the President's staff and not a separate practices. Director of NIMH, with the advice of the agency. In addition to that function, how­ The District Court was sensitive to the [NAMHC]," and no further elaboration is ever, OST inherited from the National Sci­ public interest that the FOIA, "to the ex­ possible on the basis of this record. See Def. ence Foundation the function of evaluating tent practical, be self-operative to assure Exh. No. 2, U.S. Government Information federal programs. . . . By virtue of its inde­ prompt disclosure." It was equally aware of Policies and Practices-Public Access to In­ pendent function of evaluating federal pro­ the necessity "that grant applicants be placed formation from Executive Branch Advisory grams, the OST must be regarded as an on notice that information submitted pur­ Groups, Hearings Before a Subcomm. of the agency subject to the APA and the Freedom suant to an appllc81tion for NIMH grant House Comm. on Government Operations, of Information Act." 448 F. 2d at 1075. funds" is subject to public disclosure. We, 92d Cong, 2d Sess., pt. 9, at 3619 (1972) u The executive branch represented the of course, share the court's concern, but are (Statement of Dr. John F. Sherman, Deputy proposed OST as being organizationally without sufficient reason to doubt that ap­ Dir., NIH). The finding that "[w]ithin these analogous to the Bureau of the Budget, the pellant does also. Considerations of inter­ general priorities [approval] is in the order Council of Economic Advisors, the National branch comity impel us to withhold coercive of numerical priority set by the [IRG]" is Security Council and the Office of Emergency orders that are not demonstrably necessary. very likely correct, however, since often no­ Planning. 448 F. 2d at 1075 & n. 22. Congress' body other than the IRG will examine the contemplated that OST would be sufficiently Cf. Nixon v. Sirica, 487 F.2d 700, 712 (D.C. scientific merit of a particular application. disitinct from the President's staff to be Cir. 1973). & The purely factual information in these beyond the reach of executive privilege and What we have held hereinabove is that the documents has been released by NIMH vol­ thus responsible to Congress. eleven initial grant applications involved untarily. H The result may be that there is no "final in this case (all of which had been approved a Public Health Service regulations provide opinion" of the agency-NIMH-accompany­ by HEW), together with any continuation, that "[a]ny corporation, institution, agency ing its decision on whether to make a grant renewal, or supplemental applications inci­ or other such person, other than an individ­ award. Whether this comports with existing dent thereto (either approved or pending), ual, that is organized or operated for profit" notions of administrative fairness is not an are not exempt ·from disclosure under the is ineligible to receive a grn.nt award. 42 issue in this case, nor do we see how it could Freedom of Information Act. Contrarily, we C.F.R. § 52.11 (a) (2). Only an individual be an issue for the courts in the absence of have held that site visit reports and summary grantee engaged in profit-oriented research, a legislative provision for judicial.revlew of Statements are exempt under Exemption 5. or a non-profit organization that engages in the decision. The impact of this latter holding is limited profitmaking ventures based on biomedical 16 The rather sparse legislative history of in this case by the fact that HEW has volun- 36120 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974. Section 2 of the APA is collected in Freed­ request and presently withheld." 366 F. Supp. THE SERIOUSNESS OF FOREIGN Ol.L man, supra note 9, at 6-12, and analyzed at 932. PRICING wlth reference to the meaning of "agency." 22 The proposal in question did not require That history tends to confirm our view that the use of technical medical equipment, IRGS a.re not agencies. STAFF OF SENATE which undoubtedly made the question of fa­ HON. LOUIS C. WYMAN COMM. ON THE JUDICIARY, REPORT ON THE cilities irrelevant to the IRG's evaluation of OF NEW HAMPSHmE the application. ADMIN. Paoc. ACT, 79th Cong., 1st Sess. 13. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES (Comm. Print 1945): '''Authority means !!3 The District Court rejected appellant's any officer or board, whether within another argument that Exemption 6, which applies Thursday, October 11, 1974 agency or not, which by law has authority to certain files the disclosure of which would to take ftnal and binding action with or constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of Mr. WYMAN. Mr. Speaker, the enor­ wlthout appeal to some superior administra­ personal privacy, is an alternative ground for mous impact on the economies of major tive authority." See H. REP. No. 1980, 79tll non-disclosure of any references, in the Sum­ world powers of the unreasonably high Cong., 2d Sess. 19 (1946). See also ATTORNEY mary Statements and site visit reports, to the OPEC nation oil pricing policy can be­ GENERAL'S MANUAL ON THE ADMINISTRATIVE professional qualifications or competence of a come a world disaster in a matter of PROCEDURE ACT 9 (1947). particular researcher. Our holding that the months. It can destroy nations as com­ Whether the IRG is subject to the dis­ non-factual information in these documents pletely as aggression. Eventually it can closure requirements of the Federal Advi­ falls within Exemption 5 extends to these sory Committee Act, 5 U.S.C. App. I, § 10, is expressions of opinion, and we therefore need destroy its authors because its ultimate not a question before this court. We note, not reach the merits of this argument. effect is to precipitate worldwide infla­ however, that that Act makes the FOIA Neither do we need to dellil with the District tion, starvation, unrest and eventual standards applicable to advisory committees' Court's intimation that under certain cir­ revolution. reports and other papers only insofar as the cumstances HEW may delete from the site The OPEC nations must cut their oil head of the agency to which the committee visit report or the Summary Statement an price at least in half and do it now. Even reports fails to determine in writing that the expression of opinion adverse to the qualifi­ with a 50 percent reduction they will reports or documents contain information cations or competence of particular indi­ have more money than they know what within an exemption to the FOIA. Id. § lO(d). viduals involved in the research project under Whether such a determination has been consideration. The District Court, of course, to do with. made respecting IRG reports is not disclosed found that these documents constituted the In this connection the attached articles by the record in this case. But see Summary opinions of an agency and were disclosable by James Reston in Statement, Dept. of HEW (Notice of deter­ as such; and it then referred to a provision and Roberta Hornig in the Washington mination to close certain meetings under of FOIA which says that an agency may make Star-News are significant: authority of Executive Order 11671 of June such deletions in an opinion. 5 U.S.C. 552(a) [Frorr. the New York Times, Sept. 29, 1974] 5, 1972), in U. S. Government Information (3). We, of course, have reached a different Policies and Practices, supra note 4, at 3633, conclusion on this latter score, and under STATE DEPARTMENT SUMMIT which made the same determination under our approach the deletion authority con­ (By Jamoo Reston) the pre-Committee Act regime established tained in the statute is not applicable. WASHINGTON, September 28.-Qver the by executive order. Similarly, the court is not ~ The District Court itself prefaced its con­ weekend, the foreign and finance ministe1·s now called upon to decide whether failure sideration of this prospective relief with the of the United States, Britain, West Germany, to make such a determination subjects the words, "Apart from resolution of the instant France and Japan have been meeting pri­ affected information to disclosure at the in­ controversy ...." vately at State Department to discuss the stance of "any person" as under the FOIA. world economic crisis. This ~ the ftrst indica­ 10 From the Summary Statement submitted tion that the major industrial nations have for in camera inspection it appears that finally recognized that they must try to exemption is claimed for the resume of the TRIBUTE TO CLIFFORD MciNTIRE agree on common policies to deal with the IRG's review and reasons, but not for the common threat of worldwide inftation, soar­ resume of the project itself, which gives only ing prices of on and other raw materials and the most general indication of its subject HON. GARNER E. SHRIVER the consequent danger of economic deprefl­ matter and cannot be regarded as anything OF KANSAS sion and financial, social and political but purely factual and nonexempt. anarchy. 1t The critique is specifically dh·ected to IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES This was a limited meeting with limited the following issues: Tuesday, October 8, 1974 purposes, and with some awkward handi­ Are the aims logical? Is the approach valid caps. Canada, Italy, the Scandinavian coun­ and adequate? Are the procedures feasible? Mr. SHRIVER. Mr. Speaker, I want tries and many others were left out, but it Is the research likely to produce new data to take this opportunity to pay tribute was at least a beginning by the big boys and concepts ~r confirm existing hypotheses? to a former colleague, Clifford Mcintire toward cooperation. What is the significance and pertinence of of Maine. His untimely death has sad­ Earlier this year, they were dealing with the proposed work with regard to the state dened all of us who knew him, and who this critical problem separately, and fussing of the field and importance of the aims? For with one another about how to analyze what continuation and supplemental requests,· served with him in this body. everybody agreed was a worldwide crisis. comment on past progress. Cliff was a dedicated and conscien­ President Ford and Secretary of State Kis­ tB When the IRG is an ad hoc committee, tious member of the House Agriculture singer have been criticized in the last few the names and institutional affiliations of Committee, and, throughout his serv­ days for overdramatizing the problem and each reviewer are listed. Five additional cri­ ice on that committee, played an im­ seeriling to threaten the oil-producing states teria are to be addressed in the case of for­ portant role in shaping . our national with military action, if the latter did not eign applications. roll baclt the prices that were disrupting the agricultural policy. economies of the industrial and underde­ 1D The site visit report, which is two and After leaving the House of Represen­ one-half pages in length, is not summarized veloped states alike. but rather incorporated by reference. Were tatives he continued his work in agri­ "Sovereign nations," Mr. Ford said in it summarized the principle discussed in the culture with the American Farm Bureau Michigan the other day, "cannot allow their text would apply equally to that summary. Federation, as director of the Natural policies to be dictated or their fate decided by artificial rigging and distortion of world 2G As in Montrose Chemical, the court does Resources Department, and director of commodity prices." not confront a situation 1n which the under­ legislation. He served on the President's "Throughout history," he added, "nations lying information, a summary of which is Task Force on Rural Development, the have gone to war over natural advantages determined to be exempt is itself secreted such as water, food or convenient passages from public inspection, and in which we Advisory Council of the Public Land Laws Review Commission, and had just on land or sea." And now, he insisted, "ex­ said "a different result might be reached." orbitant" on prices set by the oil-producing The proposals summarized in item (2) are been appointed by President Ford as a nations and their cartel were threatening available by virtue of our holding in Part director of the U.S. Railway Association. "the breakdown of world order and safety.'' II.A, supra. The site visit reports summarized Clifford Mcintire was a dedicated Mr. Kissinger was more subtle, but Mr. in item (9), insofar as purely factual, were legislator during his seven terms in the Ford's remarks were taken in the Arab world not even claimed to be exempt, although, as as a mllitary threat, and this troubled the appellant points out, they have very little House, but in addition to his fine work Japanese and the Europeans, for the threat factual content. here, he will be remembered as a man did not seem to be credible. It violated the :n The parties "agreed that the deter­ of dignity and integrity, and a fine first rule of diplomacy, namely, that nations minations made by the court based on this friend and colleague.· I extend my deep­ should never threaten to do what they are example would control the disposition as to est sympathy to his widow, Wilda, and not prepared to do, or suggest policies their other smilar material covered by plaintiff's his entire family. allies could not afford to support. October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36121 Nevertheless,- the Ford-Kissinger speeches remedies for what is obviously a worldwide might affect the exchange value of the dol.. did dramatize the dangers, and, what was danger. lar. The monthly reports, he sald, wlll gtv.e "a largely forgotten, tnsisted that cooperation · more comprehensive view of the banks' posi­ by the industrial nations with one another [From the Washington Star-News, tions ln major foreign currency." and with the oil-producing nations was im­ Oct. 16, 1974] Simon also listed 29 countries cited by the perative if the world was not to drift into U.S. TIGHTENING SCRUTINY OF OIL United Nations as being confronted with the political, social and financial chaos. NATIONS' INVESTING -potential of near-term bankruptcy or finan­ What the President and the Secretary of (By Roberta Hornig) cial collapse because of high energy costs. State were saying, not too subtly, was that a The countries include Cameroon, eentral continuation of soaring oil prices would shat­ The U.S. government is moving to deter­ African Republic, Chad, Kenya, Lesotho, Ma­ mine if the oil-producing nations could up­ ter the world as we know it, that it would l&.g~asy Republic, Mall, Mauritania, Niger, Si­ ·1ead· to unemployment and human misecy set the American economy through their -erra Leone, Somalia, Sudan, Tanzania, Upper all over the world, that democracy might not foreign investments and bank transactions. Volta, Bangladesh, India, Pakistan, &1 La.nka, be able to survive fn1Iation at the present The tightening of monitoring procedures Haiti, Senegal, El Salvador, Guyana, Hondu­ rate and that it might even lead to Com­ to better determine how members of the Or­ ras, Dahomey, Ghana, Ivory Coast, Guinea, muniSt or other authoritarian governments ganization of Petroleum Exporting Countries the Yemen Arab Republic and the Democratic in ·many parts of what now t•emains of the (OPEC) are investing their oil revenues was ·Republic of Yemen. · - · .free world. .. revealed today by Treasury Secretary William The facts before the ministers at the State -E. Simon in testimony submitted to the Sen- Department·were not in dispute. These facts ate Permanent Investigations subcommittee. demonstrated the strain on the industrial Specifically, Simon said, his department "is nations by the rise in on prices and also the about to put into effect" a new weekly and THE FACES OF HUNGER dramatic swing of monetary reserves to the monthly reporting requirement for banks do­ producers of oil. Here are the basic facts and ing business in the United States, and With projections of the money flowing out of the branches elsewhere. HON. RALPH H. METCALFE industrial nations and to the oil producers Further, he said, the government intends OF n.LINOIS as the result of the rising price of fuel. to study the adequacy of the present data­ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES acquiring programs now conducted by var­ PAYMENTS MADE ious U.S. government agencies to get a better Wednesday, October 16, 1974 analysis of foreign investments. . (1n billions of dollars) The testimony by Simon, who is in Rus­ 1\Ir. METCALFE .. Mr. Speaker, one of sia, is in answer to questions from Sen. Henry the most serious problems facing the United Other major M. Jackson, D-Wash., whose Senate subcom­ world today is the specter of increas­ Year States importers mittee is holding hearings today on the 1m- ing world hunger. Drought, famine, . pact of high oil prices on the world economy. natural disasters, and, unfortunately, 1972.------4.9 14.0 Also scheduled to testify are Alan Green­ governmental mismanagement and in­ 1973.------8.5 21.1 span, chairman of the President's Council of sensitivity have caused the deaths of 1974.------25.2 74.8 Economic Advisers; Interior Secretary Rogers 1975.------27.0 81.0 many people throughout the world. 1976.---__ : ______------30.3 90.7 C. B. Morton, who is also the Ford adminis­ What is even worse, it has been es­ 1980.------43.3 129.7 tration's new chief energy spokesman; and 1985.------_: ______64.0 192.0 John Sawhill, chief of the Federal Energy timated that an additional 500 million Administration. people are in great danger of starving The movement of revenues into the oil One of Simon's major points is that none to death if steps are not taken quickly producing (OPEC) countries over this same of the oil-consuming nations knows exactly ·to alleviate their plight. _ periad is estimated by the United States what the oil producers are doing with their Presently, the areas where the prob­ Government and the World Bank as follows: growing revenues accruing from higher oil lems of hunger are most severe are the prices. Sahel region of West Africa, parts of "We must recognize that OPEC countries are not prepared to inform fully the United East Africa, and the countries of South States government, -other countries, or inter­ . Asia. These areas, which contain some Oil revenues Reserves of natlonal agencies as to the nature and loca­ of the poorest nations in the world, have of OPEC OPEC tion of their investments throughout the been struggling under the burden of _a countries countries world or their future plans for imports of severe drought for the last 6 years. Ih goods and services," Simon said. order to bring the magnitude of hunger 1972 •••• ------18.9 ------~ Simon estimated that OPEC invested $7 and death in these areas to the atten­ 1973 ___ ------29.6 2ii · billion in the United States between Jan. 1 tion of the American people, the Chicago 1974.------100.0 ------1975.------108.0 170 and Aug. 81 this year. "of which over $4 bil­ Tribune has been printing a series of ar­ 1976 •• ------______:._ 121.0 ------lion, perhaps $5 billion, in U.S. treasury bills 1980. __ _. ______------173..0 653 -and other marketable govE-rnment securities." ticles on these drought-stricken areas. 1985.-----:_------256.0 1, 206 He estimated .that the OPEC countries, These articles have been excellently re­ during the same period, had invested about searched, written, and photographed by On the basis of these staggering figures, $3 billion in the United Kingdom and $2 bil­ Tribune rep01·ter William Mullen and the primary questions before the ministers lion in other European countries and Japan; Tribune photog1·apher Ovie Carter, who in Washington were how the oil-consuming a half-billion in 1nternational institution spent nearly 3 months traveling through nations were going to meet these bllls, and bonds; $2.5 billion in less developed countries these areas. They are to be highly com­ what the oil-producing countries were going and $13 billion in European currency mru-- to do with this vast and growing accumula­ · kets. mended for their fine work, and the Chi­ tion of petro-dollars. Legislation requiring the Treasury and cago Tribune is also to be highly com­ The trend in the industrial world is toward Commerce Departments to undertake a com­ mended for helping to bring the prob­ more unemployment and social and political prehensive study of existing investments in lems of world hunger to our attention. disruption. In the underdeveloped world, the United States is now pending in both Mr. Speaker, the articles on world particularly in Africa and the Indian sub­ the Senate and House and is supported by continent, the trend is toward hunger, mal­ the Ford administration. hunger which are being printed in the nutrition and death. In the oil-producing OPEC surpluses are being estimated now are informative and countries, the trend is toward riches almost at a rate of roughly $5 bUlion a month. very moving. I include the first of these beyond absorption and control. In the world Simon, in his testimony, said that "we can­ articles in the RECORD at this point. I at large, the trend is obviously toward re­ not project with sufficient validity to be use­ am sure that my colleagues will find volutionary change~ ful the volume of oil-producer funds which No wonder, then, that the State Depart­ may be placed in any particular money mar­ them informative, and I hope that they ment was surrounded this weekend with l\:et in the future." will help stimulate congressional action secrecy and security mea-sures. The major na­ He said that even in countries with more on this vital issue. tions have just begun to think together comprehensive systems to monitor capital The article follows: about the alarming consequences of the in­ imports, "it is often impossible to identify THE FACES OF HUNGER-FAMINE: SLOW DEATH flation. They are all diverted by domestic, with certainly the ultimate beneficial owner OF 500 MILLION PEOPLE economic and political crises, with weak gov­ of invested funds. In virtually all countries, banks are allowed to preserve confidentially (By William Mullen) ernments, most of them facing elections, but . . . the identity of their depositors . . ." It is the same sun that rises each day over at least they are now recognizing that they to Singima.rie Pachuniper, a tiny village in east­ are faced with problems beyond their na­ Simon said the weekly reports be re­ quired f1'om banks will enable a better moni­ ern India, and Kao. a tiny village tn central tional control and have to find international t oring of "current developments" a-s they Niger in the middle of Africa. CXX--2277-Part 27 36122 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 Dawn comes first to a refugee camp for failures and poor food distribution have left service stations, farmers in India could npt farmers in Singimarie where 6-year-old S.aku 400 million people "permanently hungry." get gasoline to operate their irrigation pumps Barman rises unsteadily to his feet and tot­ "Over the past two years it [the food short­ nor could they get petroleum based fertilizers ters out of an open lean-to into a listless day age] has become so serious that it quite for their crops. of numbing hunger. literally threatens the survival of hundreds Indian farmers, who were growing surplus Six hours later, dawn comes to the Sahara of millions of human beings around the crops three years ago, will harvest an esti­ nomad camp in Kao where a spindly 4-year­ world," Marei said. ma-ted 10 million tons less food this year old girl named Hameda weakly gets to her "Such a threat carries with it the gravest than the nation needs. That food the coun­ feet to face the same sort of day. implications for the peace and security of try can ill afford to replace thru world pur­ Once in the sun, Saku and Hameda, though the world." chases. 5,500 miles apart, cast the same shadow. In three months of travel thru the African While American mothers complained in They are the shadows of ghastly appari­ Sahel-the semi-desert area just south of the the supermarkets this year about the mount­ tions, of walking child-skeletons, doomed .by Sahara-and the flood-stricken northeast ing prices of bread and milk, the rising prices the same natural and man-made forces to a section of India, we saw why the experts are were causing more serious problems in Af­ short, unhappy existence on Earth. worried. rica and India. "I don't think Hameda will survive much We saw in West Africa thousands upon World grain prices shot up so steeply that longer," a village official told Tribune photog­ thousands of acres of once productive pas­ the government of Niger couldn't buy and rapher Ovie Carter and me when we visited tureland destroyed by the growing Sahara deliver enough food to Hameda's village, and on a ch11ly desert morning early in August. Desert. No amount of aid or work could re­ she began to die. "It will only take a cold now, or a case of cla-im it--and so the entire lifestyle of no­ Milk became so short in supply in the U.S. diarrhea, and she will be gone." madic cattlemen, who for centuries were able that we could no longer ship it to n81tions Already too weak to stand on her own for to live off the land, has been destroyed. dependent on our powdered milk-like In­ long, Hameda's emaciated body clung spider­ In Ethiopia we saw the aftermath of the dia-and Saku Barman began to die. like to her mother's back most of the day. drought destroy Emperor Haile Selassie's gov­ President Ford expressed his concern when Mother and child stayed close to each ernment and throw the nation into turmoil he told the United Nations on Sept. 18: other and close to their skin tent. A row of that threatens to disrupt any concentrated "Developing and developed countries . . • tents stretched like a finger from the village development effort for years. we are all a part of one interdependenrt eco­ into the rolling, brown desert dunes. In India we saw the intense resistance by nomic system. "There just isn't enough food coming in," mothers and fathers to any form of birth "The food and oil crises demonstrate the the village official said. "We are losing two or control. Their reasoning was simple. They extent of our interdependence. Many devel­ three people every day now." must have at least six or seven children so oping nations need the food surplus of a few When we visited Singimarie several weeks that one or two would survive to adulthood developed nations, and many industrialized later, the village teacher gave Saku Barman and take care of them in their old age. nations need the oil production of a few de­ about the same chances for survival. The story was the same in each of the veloping nations. "Unless he gets some milk within a few countries we visited-senegal, Mauritania, "Let us not delude ourselves. Failure to days," the teacher said, "he will be dead. Malle, Upper Volta, Niger, Chad, Ethiopia, cooperate on oil and food infl.a.tion could ,Twenty people have died already this week." and India. Each country has more people spell disaster for every nation represented in Saku and a younger sister spent their days than it has land and resources to feed this room." walking like stick figures through the swel­ them. Ford pledged that the U.S. would substan­ tering little town, wandering among a gaunt, Tho the catastrophic drouth in West tially increase its development aid to projects ragged populace that was just as hungry as Africa and Ethiopia seemed to have been geared to increasing food production. they. broken this year with a near-normal rainy When he announced the U.S. would spend Hameda is black, the child of desert no­ season, people continue to die in the remote $475 million on such projects compared to mads whose cattle and lfvelihood has been bush because it is impossible to get food to the $253 million spent this year, however, the · destroyed by a six-year African drouth. · them. nation which will be receiving the aid were Saku is brown, the child of rice farmers India, which even in good years loses thou­ disappointed. killed in a devastating August flood in India. sands of people to malnutrition, is quietly They were expecting far more, and in fact Until this summer, they were children of bracing for its worst famine since 1943. will ask for far more from all wealthy na­ different worlds, separated by race, religion, The problem is that in recent years nearly tions at the Rome conference. cUlture, and way of life. everything that coUld go wrong with food They insist the main cause of the problem Weakened in the aftermath of flood and ·production has gone wrong-and all at the is unfair distribution of the world's wealth, drought, starved by the world's inab111ty to same time: noting that the U.S. has 6 percent of the get food to them when they needed it most, The global energy crisis has dried up the world's goods and services. they faced the same fate. flow of fuel and fertmzer to poor developing The poor nations argue that birth rates of By the end of the summer, Saku and nations which, when they began using them Europe and America have been steadily de­ Bamed.a looked like brother and sister-dirty, in the last decade, thought they were going clining in proportion to the rising standard naked, and dying. Their faces were no longer · to be self-sufficient food producers. of living and education of their populations. the faces of children, but immobile m·lisks, World inflation and recession has forced The same thing would happen, they say, if deeply lined with unfilled form of skin. · the cutback in millions of dollars of devel­ the wealthy nations transfused more of their The only emotion left was the terror that opment assistance from wealthy nations to wealth into the development of poor nations. sometimes silently filled their eyes while they the poor. Dr. M. s. Swa.m.inathan, director general sat quietly thru the day, haunted perhaps by Emergency food reserves held by the of the India Council for Agricultural Re· their own priva.te child dreams. world's wealthy nations have been depleted search, said he hopes the U.S. will be won By now it is likely Saku and Hameda are to their lowest level since World War II by over to that point of view by the time the several years of massive crop failures and · dead. Rome conference starts. The thin lifeline of trucks that brought natural cala-mities. "The crucial role the U.S. must play in irregUlar food shipments to Hameda's village Erratic global weather patterns have Rome this November is to put the political was stopped in the middle of August. wreaked havoc in the form of floods, storms, will of the developed nations to work to alter When we visited Saku's village, India ha.d and drouth on millions of acres of crops in the world's food problems," he said. no food a.t all to deliver there. The govern­ Africa, India, Russia, and North and South "Today's food problems are too important ment was just starting to ask around the America. This year experts are predicting at for more words. They need commitment and world for emergency food donations. least 2 per cent less food will be harvested action." The story of Hameda and Saku is, of course, than last year. At the conference, the poor nations will be not a new one. Famine has been a killer every The impact of food production in one na­ asking the U.S. and Europe to buy them dam year since history began. tion on the wellbeing of people in another projects, irrigation systems, fertilizer, roads, But there is growing concern among WQII'ld nation on the other side of the world is very and expertise. food, agricultural, and weather experts that real and immediate. "President Kennedy said we could wipe the world has fallen into a situation much Failures of the corn crop in Illinois this out hunger within our lifetime given the more serious than ever before. summer most certainly mean prices will go political will to do so," Swaminathan said. They fear that the many thousands of up and somebody, somewhere in the world "I think he was right, and I think he children like Saku and Hameda who died this for lack of money to buy the corn will go proved his point when you put a man on the year have been carried away in the first wave hungry. moon. He wanted America to put a man of what may become the greatest disaster in Crop failures in Russia that two years ago there within 10 years. There was political history. forced the secret sale of 30 million tons of will to do so, and it was done." Many experts are predicting 500 million wheat from the U.S. had a dramatic effect There is considerable doubt that the U.S. people will perish in fa.mine by the year 2000. on the rising price of bread for American and Europe, reeling from infl.ation and re­ Sayed A. Marei, secretary-general of the housewives. cession, would be willing to foot the bill for World Food Conference which will convene When Chicagoans last winter impatiently the sort of assistance the poor nations wlll in Rome next month, believes current crop cursed their way thru lines at gas rationing seek in Rome. Octobe'r 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36123 Rather than lncreastng its fol'eign aid, 1n water under the street. A local investi­ The report submitted by Chairman Eugene recent years the U.S. has been putttng back gating committee detenntned. that the Black Jr.. Ron Dorminey and Sal Glovtngo, both In money commJ.tments and tn the girl would drowned said that although .loe'a action .. whlle brlef, young certainly have was detlnltely at the risk of his own Ute." The scope of Ita ald. 1f had been •'Btg showcase projects-bullcllng damS it not for Joe's quick action. report said that "both children were 1n grave and highways--just isn't our bag anymore," He, too, could have drowned in the deep danger ot being swept Into the culverts and one U B. oftlclal tn Bthtopla told me. water or been sucked into the culvert to carried beneath the street through the cui.. No matter how large or small foreign ald. certain death. vert." becomes tn scope, lt may not be able to alter Mr. Speaker, I was especially honored QUICK ACTION the vast problems confronting us ln the end. to present Joe this award because he is The three men on the Scout Advancement Five years ago there was great hope that not only my neighbor and a close friend Committee said they felt that .. Holly Me~ the so-called ..green revolution" must wipe of my son, he also brings such high credit Gaughey 1s alive and well today solely be.. out hunger and malnutrition. cause of the quick and appropriate reaction Scientists came up with new plant va.. to his family. friends, and church. I am of Joe Jones." rieties and Irrigation and fertilization enclosing a copy of an article that ap­ In addition to the award, Joe has been schemes that transformed. several chronic peared in the Albany Sunday Herald re­ notified by Woodrow sasser of American food-short nations in Asia and South Amer­ garding Joe's meritorious act prior to the Family Life Insurance Co. of Columbus that ica Into food exporting nations. receipt of his medal: he will receive a $500 scholarship. But the scientists have yet to come up JUST A MA'tTER OF REFLEXES Joe's parents, Mr. and Mrs. R. Bruce Jones, with a maglc formula to curb the greed and (By Yvonne Williams) and his older brother Rickey say they are very self-Interest of oil and fertilizer producing proud of Joe's efforts to save the little girl nations. They have put the green revolution "It all happened so fast, it was just.refiexes, from drowning. out of reach for most of the world's farmers I guess," said 12-year-old Joe Jones. "We really believe in Scouting," said Bruce by quadrupling the price of oil and fertilizer The efforts of Jones to save the life of Jones, "nowadays it's the best training you in the last two years. 4~-year-old Holly McGaughey from drown­ can give a boy." Medicine has tried to help by sending ing last February belies the myth that Boy cheap vaccines to the far corners of the Scouts are concerned primarily with merit Earth, eradicating dozens of fatal diseases, badges and camping. doubling the life expectancy of the people The 12-year-old Jones lives at 415 Forest MAOIST REGIME SUCCEEDS IN of India and Africa. Glen Road and is a member of Boy, Scout But medicine has yet to develop a vaccine Troop 106 sp<_>ns~red by Porterfield Methodist HAVING CONFUCIUS PLAQUE that could have filled the empty stomachs Church. ' REMOVED FROM U.N. HEAD­ of the children of Singimarie when the vil­ on that day in late February Joe stayed QUARTERS lage ran out of food. home t'r~m school with a slight fever. It had Nor has medicine found a pill that cures been raining heavily all day and he went the colds or the dehydrating attacks of outside to look a~ the flooded street in front HON. 0. C. FISHER diarrhea that were killing the malnourtshed of his house. children of Kao. The McGaughey girl who lived several OF TEXAS Massive dosages of foreign aid could build houses down from Joe was also outside and IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES she talked for a whlle with Joe before going d,ams and harness rivers to help the im· Thursday, October 17, 1974 pover1shed nations of the world become self­ off to play in the flooded streets. sufficient. SWIFT CURRENT Mr. FISHER. Mr. Speaker, a strange But no amount of money can buy a mon­ Holly stopped to play on a curb where two and significant event occurred in the soon season when the rain fails and the flooded culverts drained beneath the street. A United Nations on September 16 which rivers go dry and the Irrigation ponds evap­ swift current had formed due to the large has received little notice in the news orate. amounts of water being forced through the media. I am referring to the removal, at In the villages and camps where people small four-foot wide drainage culverts. The the behest of Red Chinese, of the green have already started to die, the arguments, water traveled through drainage pipes under speculation, and expectations for manmade the street for about 50 feet until it reached marble plaque which was presented by solutions seem far away. an opening on the other side of the street. the Republic of China in 1968 to com­ In those dark, faraway places where peo­ "Scum and debris had gathered on top of memorate the 25th anniversary of the ple day by day watch hunger erode the the water in the ditch and Holly must have founding of the world organization. bodies of their families and neighbors, there thought you could walk on lt," said Jones. We are informed the plaque was in­ is a quiet almost ethereal acceptance of "She stepped off the edge and sunk like a scribed with Confucius "Ta Tung Essay," things. rock," he said. The boy said he recalls the the great commonwealth of peace and A mother's comforting hand placed on little girl "bobbing up" once and then going her starving child's head replaces words. back under the fast moving water. Realizing prosperity in which mutual confidence A father's prayer gives them hope, that he could not reach her from the curb, is promoted and good neighborliness cul­ "It ts up to Allah," a nomadic tibesman Joe jumped into the swirling water. tivated. This, we are told, is the main told me in Niger. "If He wants us to live, we Investigators have estimated that the water thought of Confucius and this is also the will get rain. If He wants us to die, then Holly fell into was some nine feet deep. lofty ideals and principles with which we shall surely die." "I don't know how deep the water was Dr. Sun Yat-sen, the Chinese national but I know that it came up to my neck and father, founded the Republic of China. I never did touch the bottom." sald Joe. It would appear, therefore, that the "I grabbed Holly and set her up on the HONOR MEDAL FOR LOCAL SCOUT bank and then pulled myself out of the wa­ conception of Confucian "Ta Tung ter. She was crying and coughing at the same Essay" is completely in line with the time and I told her not to cry because she principles embodied in the Charter of might swallow water. I just kept telling her the United Nations. And it would appear HON. DAWSON MATHIS that everything was all right." the Communist action in having the OF GEORGIA Joe then rinsed all the mud and debris off plaque removed was highly reprehensible IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES of Holly with the garden hose and sent her and in effect a challenge against the home to put on dry cl~thes. Thursday, October 17, 1974 On Sept. 29, at Porterfield Methodist U.N. Charter. Mr. MATHIS of Georgia. Mr. Speaker, Church, Jones will be presented with the Under leave to extend my remarks, on September 29, I had the privilege of Honor Medal by Congressman Dawson Mathis I include an article which appeared in presenting to a constituent of mine, Scout for the National Scout Council's Court of the October 6, 1974, issue of Free China Joe Jones of Troop 106 in Albany, Ga., Honor for his efforts in saving the life of his Weekly. This article relates to the reac­ the Honor Medal for Heroism. 4Y2 -year-old neighbor. tion of President Chiang Kai-shek in The Honor Medal, awarded by the According to the Boy Scout manual, the regard to the removal of the plaque. The National Court of Honor of the Boy Honor Medal is awarded to Scouts who saved article follows: Scouts of America, is given in rare cir­ life or attempted to save life at the risk of PRESIDENT SAYS COMMUNISTS SHOW FEAR OF their own. They must have shown heroism, CONFUCIUS IDEALS IN INCIDENT AT U.N. cumstances when an individual saves a resourcefulness, and skill. life or lives at the risk of his own. President Chiang Kai-shek declared Sept. The three-member Advancement Commit­ 29 that the removal of the Confucius marble Joe was credited with rescuing a 4- tee for the Cheha.w Boy Scout Councll was plaque from the U.N. headquarters in New year-old neighbor from the swirling appointed to make a full investigation of the York was another indication of the Chinese waters of a fiood drainage ditch, right in near tragic event and to submit a report to Oomm.untsts' fear of the pervasive inftuence f1·ont of a large culvert which carries the National Scout Council. of the Sage's teachings. 36124 EXTENSiONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 In a message to the Confucius-Mencius percent of welfare cases have been re­ a.nce administration and on . procedural Society, holding its annual convention at ceiving an incorrect grant. The District changes required by federal regulations. the City Auditorium, President Chiang said of Columbia has been paying an average Last January, Yeldell announced :that all the U.N. Secretariat knuckled under to the of $2,818 per year to 3,781 ineligible new public assistance appliQa.tions would be persistent demands of the C~inese Com­ thoroughly checked out to reduce the num­ munists and removed the marble plaque from AFDC cases, an estimated $758 per year ber of errors. the U.N. building last Sept. 16. in overpaymentS to 7,623 cases, and an Yesterday, he said that beginning Nov. 1 The marble plaque was presented to the average of $758 per year less to 1,260 the payments a.ssistanance administration U.N. by the Republic of China six and a half cases. would be reorganized, staff will be increased years ago. The plaque was inscribed with Through projection, the AFDC pay­ and every case on the roles will be reviewed an excerpt from "The Great Learning", one ments to ineligibles and overpayments­ before June 30. of the Four Books of Confucius classics. The less underpayments-result in an annual Yeldell said the agency workers will visit quotation is from a Confucius ideal of a uto­ each home within five days of application pian commonwealth. cost of over $15.5 m1llion in Federal and and also will rectify all cases every 90 or 80 President Chiang, the honorary president D.C. funds. days. of the Confucius-Mencius Society, said the Since welfare recipients automatically Additional personnel will be hired immedi­ Chinese Communists have revealed their qualify for the food stamp program, most ately, using federal funds under the Compre­ fear of the deep and pervasive influence of AFDC families can get them as "assis­ hensive Employment Training Act. The new the traditional Chinese culture by insisting tance" households. The monthly average employes will be clerks, aides and computer that the plaque be removed. They fear, he number of food stamp recipients, in the operators. They must be District residents said, that the Confucius ideals will permeate who have been unemployed for 30 days or the whole world . . They had to have the District of Columbia during fiscal year more and "to the maximum extent possible, plaque removed because it was a constant 1974 was in excess of 113,500 of whom current public assistance recipients will be reminder of the contrast of Mao Tse-tung's 85,800 were on public assistance. It is hired," Yeldell said. atrocities and crimes. estimated that the bonus value of food He said his department expects to receive President Chiang also told the convention stamps issued to the latter group in fiscal about half of the $2 million given to the that the anti-Confucius drive, which has year 1974 amounted to $17,049,328. Since District under the CETA program adminis­ been going on for some time on the China 12.6 percent of recipients on welfare rolls tered by the U.S. Department of Labor. mainland, 1s an indication of Chinese Com­ were found to be ineligible in fiscal year The federal money expires after 13 months. munist fear for the San Min Chu I (Three At that time, Yeldell said, he hopes to keep People's Principles), which embodies the 1974, a conclusion can be made that this the additional employes on with District Confucian teachings. The ideals are deeply­ group received $2,148,215 in bonus value funds. He said that even with the increased ingrained in the Chinese culture. Any anti­ of food stamps. The amount of overpay­ staff, there will be about 100 vacancies in his Confucian drive, said the President, 1s ments that went to the 25.4 percent group department. against the very essence of traditional Chi­ is difficult to estimate. It is conservatively nese culture and is doomed to fail. estimated to be about $550,000. The teachings of Confucius, President Abuses of these two welfare programs THE BICENTENNIAL CHALLENGE­ Chiang continued, are everlasting and irre­ cost the taxpayer $18.2 ·million, a size­ STRENGTHENING INTERNATION­ pressible. They are always new and fresh. AL MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING Light and justice wm in the long run pre­ able sum which exceeds by a factor of 5 vail over darkness and dictatorship. Now the amount the D.C. taxpaying families that Mao has amassed all the evils in the with incomes above $15,000 would pay HON. WILLIAM A. STEIGER world in himself, President Chiang declared, in surtax should that proposed revenue­ OF WISCONSIN the .anti-Confucius drive will only hasten raising measure become a reality. his downfall. President Ford in his comments on the IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES The President said Confucius has preached proposed surtax stated that an average Thursday, October 17, 1974 "benevolence" throughout Chinese history. $15,000/year income family will pay only Confucian students who have practised the Mr. STEIGER of Wisconsin. Mr. Sage's teachings have come to the fore to $72/year more in taxes. Should 1970 sta­ Speaker, original sound ideas are rare, defend the nation in its dark hours. He told tistics on the income of D.C. families hold and when they are presented they merit members of the Confucius-Mencius Society true today, this means an added revenue special attention. One such idea, world that Confucian teachings again would help of about $3 million, a far cry from the peace through mutual understanding in­ the nation in its task of national recovery. welfare boondoggle of $18.2 million. This ternationally of people to people, was is the reason why I and some 100 of my propounded recently by Deputy Assistant colleagues in the House of Representa­ Secretary of State Alan A. Reich to the FAKE CLAIMS RISE FOR D.C. tives believe that our first priority is to Rotary Club of New York. WELFARE eliminate this wasteful spending before Secretary Reich presented a 12-point we legislate additionar taxes on the al­ program through which American vol­ ready overburdened productive sector of untary associations could effectively HON. STANFORD E. PARRIS our society. play a role toward furthering world OF VIRGINIA The Washington Star-News article of peace through mutual understanding. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES October 11, 1974, follows: Through his broad experience, Secre­ Thursday, October 17, 1974 FAKE CLAIMS RISE FOR D.C. WELFARE tary Reich is well qualified to present The number of people illegally receiving such a practical program to the Ameri­ Mr. PARRIS. Mr. Speaker, public as­ welfare payments in the District rose 3.3 per­ can people. His recommendations merit sistance statistics for April 1974 pub­ cent this year, according to a survey by the the thoughtful consideration of all who lished by HEW this past August indicate D.C. Department of Human Resources. read the CONGRESSIONAL RECORD. that in April of this year, 30,010 District Between 1973 and 1974, the study indicates, The speech follows: an·a.verage of 12.6 percent of the welfare re­ of Columbia families with 74,117 chil­ BICENTENNIAL CHALLENGE-8TRENGTHENING dren, a total of 101,585 recipients, re­ cipients were ineligible for aid. In addition, INTERNATIONAL MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING ceived $7,046,927 under the aid to fami­ 25.4 percent of the recipients were overpaid lies with dependent children-AFDC­ and 4.2 percent were underpaid.· INTRODUCTION program, a significant rise over the Feb­ Both this year and last year 800 of the It is a. pleasure and privilege to address ruary 1972 figures which showed 88,550 more than 29,000 public assistance cases again the New York Rotary Club and par­ were sampled to indicate the rates of errors ticularly on the subject of the "Bicenten­ recipients and $4,957,436 in AFDC ex­ nial Challenge and Strengthening Inter­ penditures. A shocking corollary may be made in public assistance. Joseph L. Yeldell, director of the human national MUtl,lal Understanding." This Club drawn from the above figures in light of has had over the years an international pro­ the revelation by the October 11 issue of resources department, said the city has until gram with considerable radiating impact. June 30 to meet federal guidelines that set New York City, since its founding, has lead in the Washington Star-News that in 1973 maximum levels of 3-percent ineligibility and 1974, according to a survey by the the development of the nation and of the and 5 percent overpayment. American ideals to be commemorated in D.C. Department of Human Resources, Failure to meet these standards could 1976. New York symbolizes for the United an average of 12.6 percent of the welfare mean the loss of $1.6 million in federal funds States and the world the internationalism recipients were ineligible for aid, 25.4 during a six-month period, Yeldell said yes­ and global concern required of Americans percent were overpaid, and 4.2 percent terday. as we enter our third century. were underpaid. In summary, these sta­ Yeldell blamed the increase in errors on a The American Revolution Bicentennial tistics mean that approximately 42.2 lack of adequate staff in the payments assist- commemoration is international. October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36125 . The American Revolution Bicentennial F.ormal diplomatic channels, of course, are munity festivals throughout the United Administration has designated three crucial for the conduct of official business States. _ . . themes-heritage, festival, and horizons­ and the resolution of differences between na- · Endowment of library collection of Amer.. for the Commemoration. Each has impor­ tions. To an unprecedented degree, however, icana. tant international implications. '.1..'he herit­ the problems nations confront, the means Commissioning of a number of historical age theme recalls the ethnic origins and they choose to solve them, and even the pe-­ books, studies, and films about the Ameri­ diversity of America and the fact that ou1• ceptions people of one country have of an­ can experience. way of life owes much to other peoples other, evolve outside official channels. Diplo­ Historical and philosophical conferences of the world. Their contributions find rich macy has gone public. Foreign affairs is no abroad on American civ111zation. expression throughout the United States. longer the exclusive domain of the profes­ Theatre and opera tours and traveling Reflecting together upon this heritage and sional diplomat. The tone and content of our museum exhibits to the United States. its meaning will result in significant and international relations are set increasingly As other nations are developing their Bi­ constructive international dialogue. by the vastly expanding contacts which oc­ centennial programs, Americans too are in­ Recently I somewhat mistakenly referred cur between Americans and other peoples of corporating an international dimension in to "our Bicentennial" in a conversation with the world. their planning. Many of the local programs a cabinet minister of a nation making plans The geometric increase in citizen involve­ being organized and carried out by state and for the Commemoration. He interrupted and ment in world affairs has special significance community Bicentennial groups involve noted politely, "The Spirit of '76 belongs to for the diplomat. When people-to-people peoples of other nations. Here in New York, us, too, you know!" His remark brought home bonds and networks for two-way communi­ you have a number of exciting international to me the fact that others around the world cation are fully developed, there will be a projects. The International Salute will fea­ share with us and hold dear the ideals and greater readiness to seek accommodation, and ture exhibits from other nations. values associated with our Revolutionary to negotiate. When people know and under­ The South Street Seaport Restoration period. Other nations have been guided by stand each other and appreciate their dif· Project in Lower Manhattan will recall New the American model in establishing their ferences, the likelihood of confrontation di­ York's early maritime connections with the systems of governments. George Washing­ minishes, and prospects for peaceful solu­ rest of the world. The Bicentennial Visitors ton's words, "the basis of our political sys­ tions are enhanced. This rationale governs Center and Council is organizing for recep­ tem is the right of people to make and to the interest of the State Department in the tion of New York's visitors. Statue of Liberty alter their constitutions of governments" furtherance of meaningful people-to-people events will feature the importance of immi­ have had world-wide meaning. interchange. gration to the development of the United The festival theme suggests the oppor­ In the past few years, scholars increas­ States. tunities international visitors will have to ingly have studied the relevance of informal, Across the nation there are many programs discover and get to know America and our non-governmental communications activities aimed at providing international focus for people. Over a year ago, the President, to matters of war and peace. Social scientists the Bicentennial horizons program and at through the Department of State and our are developing a more scientific base for such improving understanding over the long term. embassies, officially invited other nations to activities. Their research suggests that the A few examples are: participate in the Commemoration. It will existence of informal communications tends Operation Sail '76 is a visit of tall-masted be much more than a celebration, more than to reduce t he level of tensions when conflicts sailing vessels from around the world to parades, and more than fireworks. There will of interest occur and contributes to a climate come to New York City on July 4, 1976 and be cultural, sports, arts, and other attrac­ of opinion in which conflicts may be nego­ visit other world ports. tions both in the United States and abroad tiated more effectively. Second, informal re­ The World Theatre Festival, a non-profit which will enhance the understanding of our lationships create a greater openness in in­ foundation based in New York, will sponsor respective achievements and societies. dividual attitudes toward other nations, peo­ appearances of distinguished theatre com­ Last month, appreciation of the American ples, and cultures. These predispositions also panies from around the world. democratic system in surviving the Water­ lead to greater readiness to communicate and The American Host Program, through its gate problem was expressed by leaders and to resolve differences peaceably. Third, social "Meet the Americans" project, is organizing writers around the world. One Asian news­ scientists tell us that international coopera· home hospitality for foreign visitors. paper, traditionally anti-American, com­ tion and two-way exchange contribute to Numerous international conferences are mented, "Never before have the ideals of world-mindedness and to an international­ being planned such as the World Food Con­ freedom and democracy emerged more tri­ ist perspective on what otherwise might be ference to be held at Iowa State University. umphant than from the trial and torment viewed as purely national problems. The California Bicentennial Commission is· of Watergate. The whole world," the editorial Finally, international people-to-people re­ sponsoring a publications program on ethnic added, "owes this land and people a solemn lationships help develop enduring networks contributions to California history. homage.... "Thomas Jefferson set the tone of communication which cut across polit­ Binational, international exchange, and when he said, "Here we are not afraid to ical boundaries and reduce the likelihood of ethnic organizations are developing new ex­ follow truth wherever it may lead, nor to polarization along nationalist lines. The Bi­ change-of-persons programs. tolerate any error as long as reason is left centennial Commemoration provides both The American Council of Polish Cultural free to combat it." The United States is seen the occasion and the opportunity for ex­ Clubs is conducting a poster contest on by peoples around the world as custodian of panding and strengthening these people-to Polish immigration to the United States. the ideals of democracy, and they wish to people relationships. The American Medical Association is in­ help ensure its continuation for the benefit Many bicentennial international activities viting counterpart associations of other of mankind. are underway. countries to attend their 1976 annual con­ The horizons theme of the Bicent ennial is As you know, the Bicentennial Commem­ vention to review medical contributions to perhaps the most important to all of us be­ oration has no single national focus. It is man's well-being over the past 200 years. cause it looks to the future. John Adams put nationwide, involving all our states, com­ The American Association of Museums is munities and people. In addition to the organizing a program for American museums it succinctly when he said, "I like the dreams to exhibit foreign contributions to America's of the future better than the history of the American Revolution Bicentennial Admin­ istration in Washintgon and the ten re· development. past." The notion of the continuing revolu­ Sister Cities International plans to increase tion and all it stands for is captured in the gional offices, every state has its own com­ mission. Many cities, including, of course, from 1; 100 at present to 1,976 by July 4, 1976 growing awareness that we are interdepend­ the number of U.S. and foreign cities affili­ ent; if mankind 1s indeed to survive, we must New York, have commissions and active pro­ grams. ated in sister city relationships. cooperate. Problems which a few years ago The American Historical Association is were national, now are global. Our neighbo1•s' Many other governments of the world, as well as private individuals and organiza­ offering a prize to the author of the best problems are ours, and vice versa. Improv­ historical work on the American Revolution ing the quality of life is a world-wide chal­ tions of other nations have asked the De­ partment of State and the American Revo­ written in a language other than English. lenge. These few projects I have singled out are Concerns with population, inflat ion, food, lution Bicentennial Administration for sug­ gestion.s as to what they might do to com­ essentially international in character. There and resources require cooperative action. are, however; international dimensions in Strengthened informal relationships and peo­ memorate the Bicentennial and in the proc­ ess strengthen ties with the American peo­ many programs which are primarily domestic ple-to-people bonds help improve the climate in nature. for cooperation in solving these problems ple. Many exciting Bicentennial activities which know no national boundaries. The are being planned by governments and peo­ The organizers have found ways to make Commemoration will focus not only on the ples of other nations. A sampling includes: them international as well. One of the most U.S. future, but also on goals and aspirations Chairs in American studies to be estab­ promising is the recently-announced Amer­ for mankind. lished in foreign universities. ican Jssues Forum conceived by Walter Cron­ . People-to-people relations further inter­ Estabilshment of chairs for stud-ies o:t kite. The Forum is intended to effect a year­ national mutual understanding and are rele­ foreign nations in American universities. long nationwide dialogue by people in all vant to world peace. Symphony orchestra tours to the United walks of life and all levels of education con­ Why, you might ask, are people-to-people States. cerning the values which have characterized relations and infonna.l communications ac­ National folk group participation in the our national development and their relevance tivities of concern to the State Department? Smithsonian Folklife Festival and in com- to the future. One of the nine major issues 36126 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 to be discussed is "America's Role in the 9. Expand programs of international inter­ as just that-an old warehouse. There was World, Past, Present and Future." change involving America's ethnic and ra­ no insurance to speak of ($10,000) when fire Community service organizations are a cial minority groups, drawing upon their struclt, so for all practical purposes, the com­ potent 1orce for international mutual under­ special sensitivity and competence in cross­ pany was wiped out. Up until that time, standing. cultural communication. though, the company was a big builder of In government and in the private sector, 10. Form international institutional link­ hunting buggies for wealthy plantation own­ there is much to be done. Service organiza­ ages affiliating universities, hospitals, schools, ers, truck bodies, cultivators, and some pea­ tions, such as Rotary International through institutes, libraries, and museums for ex­ nut wagons and a few cotton wagons. Sales its people-to-people programs, are contrib­ change relationships. were less than $100,000 dollars. After the fire uting a great deal to international mutual 11. Establish university chairs of interna­ in 1966, the company was cranked up again understanding. Rotary's international youth tional studies. with help from the Small Business Adm.n­ exchange, involving 700 youths throughout 12. Maximize the goodwill generated by istration. A building 200 x 50 w ::; initially the world annually, is a model program with ensuring public visibility for these activities constructed at the site of VADA Builders, Inc. considerable impact. both here and abroad. today. Since then, the company has grown The Rotary Club matching program, which The challenge, the Bicentennial challenge, and prospered. Additional square footage was links Rotary Clubs in 151 countries with is to develop durable mechanisms which will added and today that figure stands at 65,JOO counterpart clubs for direct Rotarian-to­ continue beyond 1976 to contribute to inter­ square feet. Of course from 1966 until the Rotarian relationships and shared service national mutual understanding. While the present time, the company has been growing projects ls equally impressive. Rotary's world Government can help, meeting this Bicenten­ in other ways as well. Sales have gone from commun1ty service program has helped people nial challenge will depend far more upon less than a mlllion per year in 1970 to a throughout the world. Through Rotary's America's private sector strengths of initia­ projection this year of 5 million. The product small business clinic progTam, many indi­ tive, diversity, and dynamism. line has grown from truck bodies and hunt·· viduals in less-developed countries have been Such a Bicentennial commitment and pro­ ing buggies which are no longer manufac­ helped to self-sufficiency and community gram will be in our national interest as well tured, ·to peanut and grain drying wagons, contribution. as in mankind's interest of improving the cotton wagons, tobacco curing systems, stock The mere existence of some 15,000 Rotary climate for working together on our global trailers, implement trailers and cultivators. Clubs JoJning 750,000 Rotarians in 151 coun­ problems. I thank the Rotary Club of New In 1973, VADA of Oklahoma, Inc. was founded tries 1s a potent force for world peace. Rotary York and Rotary Clubs throughout the by VADA Builders, Inc. of Georgia. That is made up of leaders from all segments of United States for your very real contribution plant is located in the Southern Oklahoma society; these fraternal relationships-pro­ in helping to build the "human foundat ions city of Springer. Primary units of manufac­ fessional to professional, businessman to of the structure of peace." ture there are peanut drying wagons and businessman and so on-generate two-way cotton wagons. During the first year of op­ communication and further mutual under­ eration of the Oklahoma plant, sales ther9 standing. passed the one million dollar mark. Another service which Rotary Clubs per­ THE 20TH ANNIVERSARY OF VADA Today, VADA Builders, Inc. markets proa­ form is the advancement of international BUILDERS, INC. ucts in Georgia, Florida, Alabama, North and person-to-person programs of other orga­ South Carolina, Virginia and will move later nizations in their communities. In my own this year into Mississippi and the "export" travels throughout the United States, I have HON. DAWSON MATHIS market. U.S.S. Agri-Chemicals is marketing been impressed with the extent to which our new tobacco curing system in the Caro­ Rotary and other service clubs have initiated OF GEORGIA linas as well as various other merchandise in and developed, for example, sister city affilia­ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES our product line. Goldkist, Inc., based in At­ tions, professional and people-to-people ex­ Thursday, October 17, 1974 lanta, is also marketing a number of drying changes, international hospitality programs, trailers, stock trailers, implement trailers, and international activities of local perform­ Mr. MATHIS of Georgia. Mr. Speaker, and other products all built by VADA, but ing arts and sports groups. These activities on Saturday past I had the honor of carrying the Goldkist label, thru their net­ contribute to strengthened bonds between delivering the main address at the 20th work of FMX stores throughout Georgia, participating local groups and their counter­ anniversary celebration of Vada Build­ Florida, and Alabama. The number of em­ parts in other nations. ployees in the Vada, Georgia plant 1s about Can community service organizations do ers, Inc., a farm equipment manufactur­ 160 with a total weekly payroll of approxi­ more? ing firm located in the southern part of mately 15,000 dollars. Production capacity Leaders of private organizations frequently the Second District of Georgia. Vada varies according to the various units being ask us in the Bureau of Educational and Builders, Mr. Speaker, is living proof of manufactured. About 20 peanut drying trail­ Cultural Affairs what they might do to in­ the success of our free enterprise system ers can be built daily and about 15 cotton crease international understanding. I would and of what dedication and hard work wagons per day. On the average Vada puts only hope Rotary and other community serv­ can accomplish. The founders and man­ into manufacture near 1.5 million pounds of ice organizations in the United States would agers of Vada Builders, and others like steel per month. do more of the same--demonstrating so well The man behind the VADA operation today the capacity for commitment of the American them all across America, are truly the as he has always been is Levy L. Harrell, Sr. people to furthering world peace. The Bi­ backbone of the American economy. He is 58 and a staunch Christian. He has centennial Commemoration provides the These are the individuals who produce, earned everything he has the hard way. To­ focus. Specifically, I urge community service who employ, and who keep the system day, he plays a semi-retired role but appears organizations to undertake in whole or in running for the good of us all. Yes, they at the plant almost every day. He tends to big part the following 12-point program: themselves prosper in the process, and financial matters but always has a word for 1. Expand home hospitality and community rightly so, yet their enrichment is only a the employees of VADA. He drives a Cadillac orientation programs for international visi­ trifle compared to the prosperity ac­ and likes to fish. He spends some time at his tors (including doctors and other profes­ trailer located on Lake Seminole. He is very sionals, businessmen, diplomats and military corded the hundreds they employ and easy-going and real down to earth. He is very and government leaders). - the thousands who appreciate the goods proud of his sons that run the plant. He is 2. Develop programs for continuing ties and services they provide. As Americans married to Christine Sellers Harrell and they with the international alumni of area uni­ become increasingly cynical of our free live in a fashionable brick home in Vada. versities and colleges. enterprise system, I think there is a les­ Four of his sons run the Georgia plant with 3. Enlist the cooperation and support of son to be learned from the story of Vada the fifth son, Levy Harrell, Jr. serving as U.S. corporations operating internationally Builders, and I hope that the following plant manager of the Oklahoma plant. His for meaningful public service activities. story will demonstrate the continued middle son Bobby Jack Harrell, serves as Gen­ 4. Expand and strengthen programs of art, eral Manager and Executive Vice-President. sports, and cultural interchange. vitality of the free enterprise system and His oldest son, Ronnie Harrell, serves as Pro­ 5. Develop and improve community pro­ how it contributes to our own well-being: duction Manager and runs the day-to-day grams for foreign students to enhance their VADA BUILDERS, INC. activities in the production area. His second experience while in the United States. Vada Builders, Inc. was founded in 1954 to youngest son, Gary Harrell, serves as Sec­ 6. Internationalize your community in­ as a small welding and repair shop. It was retary-Treasurer and attends to the book­ volvement by affiliating with an appropriate housed at the time 1n an old tin-roofed keeping and finance functions. His youngest international organization in cooperation wooden shed at the Vada crossroads. The son, Hugh Harrell, serves as Plant Manager. with the U.S. National Commission for company then was primarily a "blacksmith" He attends to the production schedul!ng and UNESCO. shop. It continued to operate like that works hand-in-hand with engineering. Cal­ 7. Support established people-to-people, through the fifties and into the sixties. Busi­ vin Culverson is the Sales Manager, Larry youth, and binational exchange programs. ness was pretty fair until a fire completely Harrell, no relation to the other Harrells. is 8. Strengthen relationships with profes­ destroyed the operation during the winter the Chief Engineer; Dwight Godwin serves as sional counterpart organizations in other of 1966. The only thing that was saved was Cost Accountant and Management Consult­ countries. an old warehouse which still functions today ant, and Jim Turknett is Personnel Director. October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36127 THE GREAT PAYCHECK RAID (By Bill Duncliffe) "A healthy Boston is vital to the sm·vival A blue-collar worker whose $201 paycheck and prosperity of the entire area, and I be­ is being butchered by the raid which a whole lieve the entire area should contribute to HON. MICHAEL HARRINGTON horde of open and hidden taxes is making on making it healt.hy." it each week is angrily certain that in many As a land mass of business activity and OF ~ASSACEnjSETTS ways he is being robbed-principally because commerce Boston is well-fed economically, IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES he happens to be a resident of Boston. Wall declared, but as a city government it is He's convinced that both the suburbs and starving-and he insisted that the state iS Thursday, October 17, 1974 the state are playing Boston for a patsy, that largely to blame for that. Mr. HARRINGTON. Mr. Speaker, the they are refusing them the right to win a For one thing, he said, Beacon Hill has American people are quite understand­ measure of relief from that oppressive load. made a mockery of real home rule by blind­ ably outraged at the declining value of One articulate though understandably bi­ ing Boston with all sorts of restrictive the dollar. Inflation is, without a doubt, ased authority on the subject maintained policies and mandates, has forced it to ac­ that not only is the blue collar worker cor­ cept obligations it did not want, and has the single greatest problem facing us to­ rect all the way down the line, but predicted prevented it from using devices that would day. Even as the purchasing power of that if the situation is allowed to remain enable it to march long way toward solving the dollar declines and inflation claims a unchanged it will not be Boston-but the the problems that now beset it. larger part of the working person's pay­ state and the suburbs-who will lose the And one of those devices, he declared, is check each week, the Federal budget con­ most. a payroll tax-withheld from the wages of tinues to grow larger, making greater and At the moment, though, the taxpayer, a everyone holding a job in the city. greater demands on the already over­ factory hand and family man, isn't all that As a "Boston bill" that is a hardy and burdened lower and middle income level worried about future damages to someone regularly rejected perennially in the legis­ else. He's more concerned about what his lature, and Wall does not delude himself taxpayers. present problem is doing to him, and he said: into believing that it will become law in the These same taxpayers have recently "When you come right down to it the whole foreseeable future. been deprived of an opportunity to con­ setup is screwy. I live in Boston and I love Yet he insisted that it is a fairer and less trol the rise of prices directly by means the city, but a guy who lives in Wellesley, regressive tax than the one which owners of of price controls, which President Ford Newton or one of those places and works here Boston's homes and business properties, and has ruled out, and since the price of basic doesn't pay through the nose the way I do. those who rent space for them, are whacked foodstuffs and commodities continues to "The state is killing us, particularly in the with now. rise at an ever-increasing rate, despite way it makes us pay assessments for the T "Both Philadelphia and Cincinnati have a the availability of WIN buttons, our con­ and the MDC, and the way it hits us for all payroll tax of three percent," he said, "and the costs of Suffolk County, even though they get more from that than they do from stituents plead for and demand relief. As Chelsea, Revere, and Winthrop are as much a the property tax. elected Representatives, we are obligated part of it as we are. "Neither one had to ask their state Legis­ to provide this relief, by whatever means "Take the T: it's a pretty good transporta­ lature for approval. The city government we can. We cannot control prices in the tion system, I guess," he continued. "I really just voted it in, and that was that. But supermarkets or on the farms of the Na­ don't know, though, because I don't use it. Boston has to go hat-in-hand to the State tion, but we do control the Federal purse Yet I've got to pay more on its deficit each House for everything." and the less money we appropriate from year than a guy who lives in one of the Wall's reference to- the real estate tax was that purse, the better off the majority of suburbs and uses it ·every day. made in this conte-xt: Well back in the past taxpayers will be financially. "And what about my car? Okay, compul­ city was a hive of factories and other manu­ sory auto insurance isn't a tax in the strict­ facturing activities-all of which were Members of Congress will benefit, too, est sense of the word but I've got a 1971 dunned for large hunks of money annually with the renewed support and confidence Maverick and I had to pay $350 to register it on their property. of the people, who certainly view us now this year. But, he said, over the years the emphasis. as shirking our responsibility to the "But the guy next door registered his in­ shifted from manufacturing to service in­ American taxpayers by not taking grasp Newton-and he's paying only half as much dustries, which generally yield a smaller as I do. amount in taxes, and he declared: of the situation to cut Federal spending "So sure. I'm disgusted living in Boston­ "If we were able to levy a payroll tax we'd. and alleviate the tax load. Instead, we but it's not the city·s fault. It's the state's, continue to pass legislation which aggra­ get more money from it than we get from and it's the fault of those suburbs who have manufacturing plants. If we had real home vates the problem and frustrates the tax­ enough members in the legislature to defeat rule we'd have been able to shift to a pay­ payers. any idea that would shift part of the burden roll tax as the economic activity shifted. from us and put it on their shoulders. This past summer, I inserted in the "But it's tough getting "Qsed to the fact REcORD a series of articles from the "Outsiders coming into Boston every day to work are getting off lighter than I am­ that Massachusetts local government is so Boston Herald American highlighting the and I think that kind of a setup is lousy." closely regulated by state law. For example, increasing burden of Federal taxes on Though he doesn't put it quite that blunt­ you can't change a municipal charter with­ working persons. ly. Richard Wall, Mayor White's budget direc- _ out getting the state's approval for it. The author of this series, Bill Dun.. tor, couldn't agree more. "Yet year after year at least one bill goes cliffe, has brought his exceptional talent Wall, who was born in Massachusetts but through the Legislature which lays more to bear on this issue and has produced went out of state-to Philadelphia and Cin- . costs on municipal government. You hear· cinnati-to get his experience in municipal a_lot about mandates now, about how cities. an unusually perceptive look into atti­ and towns are protesting against the state's tudes which prevail among disgruntled finance, said nothing lie learned in those cities prepared him for the shock of how policy of forcing programs or policies of one taxpayers. Boston is hamstrung by the heavy hand of kind or another on local communities with­ I would like, at this time, to share with the state government. out providing the money to pay for them. · my colleagues the articles which I did "The city's name is a dirty word in the "I believe those protests are valid-and not insert in the RECORD before the legislature," he declared. "The quickest way yet, for more than 100 years now Boston has August recess. ' to get a bill is to label it a 'Boston bill.' Year been saddled with a mandate to pay all the The texts follow: in and year out mayors of Boston have gone costs of running Suffolk County. It's the up to Beacon Hill with pleas and ideas for only county in the state where that kind of THE GREAT PAYCHECK RAm: HUB EARNERS re11ef-and every year they've come back arrangement is in effect, and in the new city SHORT-CHANGED down again, emptyhanded. budget the county costs amount to Each week your livelihood-and that of "It's a matter of emotional attitude, I $23,000,000. every other person in Massachusetts-is being think. There's a general antipathy toward "That's a mandate we've been trying to g~t picked apart by a multitude of national, the central city in the minds of a great many changed for a number of years. Every year state, and local taxes. people, and there is little sympathy among Boston asks for it-and every year the Legis­ But while everyone is aware of how much them for the city's problems-even among lature refuses." is taken in withholding and Social Security those who are in many ways dependent on A new mandate which could cause wide­ spread conflict in the city and town halls taxes, few realize how large a slice of their the city." Wall said that about half of all those who throughout Massach•.1setts in time to come income is being consumed by the many other went into effect July 1. It requires that in lev ies to which they are subjected. come into Boston each day to their jobs live in the suburbs; each day they receive-for cases where local officials cannot come to Two typical wage earners opened up their free-the services that residents must pay terms with their police or firemen on a new financial records and family budgets to the for, and he believes that is eminently unfair. contract their dispute must, as a last step, Herald American in order to explore just how "You ask yourself what would happen to be submitted to binding arbitration. Each these indirect and hidden taxes hurt them. the suburbs if Boston suddenly vanished party would choose a representative and What was found-and what it all means, to from the face of the earth," he said. "The would agree on a third, impartial, arbiter. you as well as to them, is told in this se1·ies, economics of the situation are that those The three arbiters to whom a given dispute "The Great Paycheck Raid., suburbs would immediately go bankrupt. would be handed for settlement would have 36128 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 to choose between "the final and best offer" may perl}aps best be Iru!asured in terms like. factors. In the past few years the rise has made by either side. these: · slowed because of revenue sharing. Now; Boston does not yet have any problem with In 1973, for the first time in Beven years, however, they're on the way up again-"per­ that particular mandate since its contract the annual rate of rise in real estate taxes haps faster than before"-because oi: a wors­ with the Police Patrolmens' Union does not was less than 10 percent-primarily because ening inflation and a . tougher collective bar­ run out until June 30, 1975. The city is now many cities and towns used the money they gaining law which mandates compulsory ar­ negotiating with firemen, whose pact ex­ got from revenue sharing for tax reduction. bitration of wage disputes with police and pired this past June 30, but Wall said he Despite that, the total take, statewide, firemen when all other means of reaching believes agreement wlll be reached with them from that one operous levy was $2,168,000,- agreement on a new contract prove futile. soon. What concerned him about the man­ 000-a boost of 5.8 percent more than in Gov. Sargent's new budget contains $786 date, however, was this: 1972, according to the Taxpayers' Foundation. million in local aid for cities and towns, and "There is not mu<:h history of binding ar­ If Ziegler's estimate of the expected in­ Ziegler is hopeful that a new and complex bitration to Judge by, so we don't really know crease is correct, then an additional $173,- formula for deciding who gets how much of how great an effect this new law wlll have," 440,000 will be taken from property owners it wlll enable many communities to keep he declared. "But we are concerned about it this year. their tax rates under reasonable control. It's because it places a vital declsionmaking If Shaw's prediction on the low side proves fairly certain, too, that revenue sharing­ function in the hands of an outsider who true, they'll have to find an extra $216,800,- which still has two years to run-will help will, to a significant degree, establish how 000 to keep their community tax collector in those localities which apply it to their large a community's tax rate is going to be.'' happy. rates. In any event, the state is apparently far If his high-side guess turns out to be the But though Sargent and the Legislature more ready and willing to intrude upon home rule rather than the exception, they wlll have appeared to be more concerned this rule than it is able to meet its responsibili­ have to come up with $325,200,000 more. year than in the past over the plight of ties to the cities and towns that are so Thus, while most of the comment and home owners, "local aid" they offer is like greatly affected by its decisions. quarreling in the public forums of Mas­ an 80-cent dollar. And Boston is no different than any other sachusetts at the moment revolves around As a rule, cities and towns get about 80 community in that respect. whether the state wlll need another $200,- percent of what they're entitled to under the Wall said that in the upcoming year Bos­ 000,000 or so in boosted taxes to help pay law, and any time there's a shortfall in ton will get approximately $90,000,000 in its b1lls, the unlovely fact is that the pro­ local aid, the difference has to be made up state aid-and while that might sound like jected and little-publicized rise in prop­ by the property tax. a lot, it's only about 80 percent of what the erty levies could approach and even outstrip In addition, the Commonwealth persists in city is entitled to receive. that monstrous figure. its practice of mandating programs such as In substance, what that breaks down to is The remarkable thing about all this is kindergartens, police incentive pay, school that Boston-and people like the blue col­ that, somehow, in spite of the insatiable lunches, etc., on cities and towns-without lar worker--are being short-changed of what inroads which real estate taxes make on providing the means to pay for them. is rightfully theirs to the tune of f18,000,000 everyday earnings, people like the white­ "This whole thing has become a question in this year alone. collar worker are managing to pay them. of faith," Hathaway said. "The state man­ It is for that, as well as all the other rea­ They may be living on short rations, but dates programs because it doesn't have any sons listed above, that he is certain he's be­ they're finding the money for their taxes. faith that the local communities wlll caiTy ing Jobbed, and he said that no one has "Cities and towns are collecting 97 per­ them out on their own-and the communi­ shown him-yet-where he's wrong. cent of their bllls, so no one's losing their ties don't have any faith in promises by the home," Ziegler declared. "And if that's the state to reimburse them." THE GREAT PAYCHECK RAm: ANOTHER HIKE standard by which to judge you would have Ziegler, Hathaway and Shaw all agreed IN REAL ESTATE TAXES COMING to conclude that while the property tax that the campaign to restrict the fiscal au­ (By Bill Duncliffe) may be unfair and regressive, the money 1s tonomy of School Committees is by no means Any time now, a new raid will be made on still there. the central issue, although education does the paychecks of every home owner and "People are somehow making the pay­ claim an enormous share of municipal costs. rent payer in Massachusetts-and in the case ments." According to Ziegler, the experience of of the white-collar worker whose personal Ziegler and everyone else with any knowl­ other states indicates that there really budget has been examined in this series it edge of the problem are agreed that too wouldn't be any great change in school wlll take between $2 and $5 more a week from heavy a chunk of public money is raised spending if a City Council or Town Meeting his earnings. by putting one arm on home owners and were given a veto over School Committee The raid wlll take the form of stlll another rent payers, and on those who hold busi­ budgets. What he urged was that committees increase in constantly rising real estate tax ness properties. Last year, according to be given professional help in their negotia­ rates in the state's 351 cities and towns and, charts made by the Taxpayers' Foundation, tions With teachers. He declared: depending on which expert is right, the rise property levies claimed 56 cents out of every "We've got to strengthen the school board wm range from eight to 20 percent. tax dollar raised by local and state govern­ and give them the facts and the attitude they Last year the white-collar worker paid $25 ment In Massachusetts. need, the attitude that they and they alone a week in property taxes on a $35,000 Cape This year's bite will be at least as large, can speak for the public interest and have which he and his working wife are trying and on that point Shaw said: as much a duty to demand things of the to buy in one of Boston's bedroom commu­ "What strikes me is the psychological ease teachers that Will strengthen education and nities. with which we extract income taxes from help children, than the teachers have to If Lyman Ziegler, vice president of the people. They never see the money that's make demands on them." Mass. Taxpayers• Foundation, is close to cor-' withheld from their paychecks, they don't Hathaway said fiscal autonomy is a "paper rect with his educated guess of an eight per­ realize how much is being taken out and tiger issue," and Shaw added: cent jump, that particular home owner wm they don't complain. "Tax reform is a far more significant issue be cUpped for another $2 a week. What wm "Yet they go up the wall when they get than fiscal autonomy because both the keep the rate from going higher in many their property tax bill because the money schools and local governments are living on areas, he said, is a new formula for distribut­ for that comes right out of their household the same limited tax base, and instead of ing state aid which wlll give 200 commu­ budget. fighting each other we ought to be trying nities more money from that source, but will "They can see the services their prop­ to change that. leave the other 151 with less than they re­ erty tax buys; they can see pollee and fire "I believe we are at one of those times ceived in the past. protection, schools, and the like. But in many in history where a really significant economic cases their income tax money is going over­ If Kennedy Shaw, executive director of change is being dictated by the conditions seas, or to subsidies that benefit some other under which we live. The load on the prop­ the Mass. League of Cities and Towns, hits part of the country or society, and they the target With his estimate of "more than erty tax 1s unfair and it just can't carry actually see only a small part of what they're the burden that's being placed on it. 10 percent,'' the tab wlll be at least $2.50. He paying for. wants a closer look at that new formula be­ "So now there is talk of transfeiTing the "The taxpayer tends to get more upset at costs of education to the state, as other fore dec.i.ding that it's as marvelous as its the property tax because of the way it is adherents claim. raised and because it comes in one big blll states have done. What we are advocating But both Shaw and Robert Hathaway, the that changes his mortgage payments. The in­ 1s moving welfare to the federal level, and league's legislative director, said a spot check come tax is automatically adjustable to the education to the state. This wlll take the indicates that an increase of 20 percent inflationary factors in our society. A worker curse from property taxes--and it's an idea in some communities won't be all that un­ gets a cost-of-living raise and his income whose time wlll come, sooner or later. usual-and if the white-collar worker is tax automatically goes up. But the property "Everyone says that education is a function unfortunate enough to live in a town with a tax isn't adjustable that way, and so the of the state, and if the state took it over problem of that size he'll be dunned for a taxpayer gets hit in one Shot.'' legislators would be more responsive and full $5 a week more than he's paying now. During the late sixties, Shaw said, tax more responsible because they'd have to find The impact of figures like that on the live­ rates jumped like Mexican beans because of the money for every program they mandate. lihood and future of anyone owning a home infiation, the beginning of collective bar­ "I'm confident that this kind of a change or commercial property in Massachusetts gaining or municipal employes, and other is coming," Shaw maintained. "All these October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36129 pressures-inflation, etc.-will dictate it, as The question is, who's to blame for that Releasing $40,000,000 in state highway will national trends, court cases and a basic depressing condition-and the answer is, it money for road building over the next three sense of fair play. depends on who you ask. years, and "Educators and local government must In the view of House Majority Leader Rep. Asking the Legislature to okay $13,000,000 work together to put this program across, Thomas P. O'Ne111, Jr., the current doldrums in additional housing subsidies which would because if it ever becomes law property taxes are not particular to Massachusetts, but are be used to create jobs in the construction will have to decrease." general to New England. industry. Whatever drop occurs, however, will be "When a new industry thinks about com­ The announcement of his program, coming less pronounced in the cities than in sub· ing here they take several things into ac­ at the tall end of the legislative session and urban areas because of the "trrban markup count," he said, "and among them are taxes, the beginning of his summer-long drive for factor." power costs, transportation, nearness of the re-election, left Sargent open to charges that That's a gobbledegook term which means product to the market, and the stability of he was playing politics with unemployment. that it costs more per person to operate the workers. He denied that too-but apart from that an older city than a newer suburb because "The truth is that on an over-all basis we he insisted that the picture of him as anti~ the city has more senior citizens, more poor haven't had many new industries come into business is a false one, and he declared: and more minority-group fam111es. this o..rea," O'Neill continued, "and I'm told "I think it's time for the business com­ Because of that-and because a city such that there are a lot of companies talking munity to recognize the many advantages as Boston usually has a smaller ratio of tax­ about moving out--although I don't know we've got here, and to use the many incen­ able property from which to draw its funds­ of anyone who's gone yet. tives we've made available for them, rather police and fire protection cost more, welfare · "But we are close to the major markets than be forever talking gloom." and public education cost more, and every­ here, and our transportation system is more Sargent said that when he took over as thing involved in the operation of a munici· than adequate as long as we keep the rail• Governor in early 1969 he could see that the pality costs more. roads running. As far as stability is concern· state's economy was headed for trouble, and But any decrease at all, however large or ed, the average worker in Massachusetts is so he asked a task force of businessmen and small it turns out to be, wm help make absent from his job no more than five per­ labor leaders to come up with a program to the owning of a. home more of a pleasure cent of the time-but in many areas of the expand industry here. "I told them that if· and less of a problem for the white-collar country the absentee rate runs as high as 15 that meant tax incentives and legislative worker and people like him. percent. proposals, okay, let me see them," the Gov­ "I've met textile people who left here years ernor declared, and added: ago to locate in the south, and all they talked "What they recommended became 12 bills [From the Boston Herald American, July 16, about was how reliable the employes they that were passed by the Legislature and 19741 had here were compared to what they've got signed by me-but what amazes me is that THE GREAT PAYCHECK RAID: TAX SQUEEZE now. when I held a seminar in Springfield recently FELT BY ALL "So the difficulty is, I think, in taxes and I found out that a lot of business leaders (By B111 Duncliffe) the cost of energy-and that last is a real didn't even know about these things." Massachusetts is a Commonwealth caught crunch because of the added fuel charges. Among the measures Sargent said he made between two "htghs"-and those being hurt "We've had progressive government for available were a $500 tax credit to any com­ most by that state of affairs are people whose years in this state, and that always costs pany for each new employe taken from the paychecks are being raided every week by more. We had Workmen's Compensation a welfare or unemployment rolls, as well as the insatiable assaults of a legion of hidden long, long time ago--and some states don't tax breaks on purchases of machinery and and openly-imposed taxes. have it yet. And we've got pension systems anti-pollution equipment, on industrial de­ They include the blue collar worker who is here-and other areas stul don't have them." velopment financing, and on excises and left with slightly more than $100 to feed, O'Neill's thesis that high taxes are a by­ tangible property taxes assessed against clothe, and house his family of five after product of social progress is not accepted corporations. all three levels of government bite into his ln toto by other authorities on the subject. "Several months ago I met with Wall salary of $201 a week. They include couples One business-oriented tax expert maintained Street investors," the Governor said. ••They like the white collar worker and his wife that Massachusetts is in such desperate knew about the tax incentives and the other who between them earn $19,000 a. year and straits now because no Governor for the things we'd done-and they liked them. They surrender 88 percent of it to tax collectors past 20 years-Democrat or Republican-has told me they were innovative proposals and on the Federal, state, and local levels. They made the state's economic health his Num­ beca~ of them they were looking favorably include people subsisting on pensions or ber One concern, and he said: at Massachusetts for investment purposes. savings, whose standard of living is lowered "There is absolutely no realization in the "I see evidence that the economy is on the by tnfiatlon and by the multitude of levies legislative and executive branches of govern­ upswing here. I see indications that the they are required to pay. ment that we're in trouble. Spending beyond companies along Rte. 128 are winning major In short. they include just about everyone income is a bi-partisan thing, and the poll­ new contracts. I maintain that there are old enough to know the difference between ticlans give no thought whatever to where 50,000 more jobs here than there were a year a dime and a dollar. the money Is coming from. ago. and we are seventh among the states in The "highs" that will largely affect their "I think we•re at the point where taxes terms of foreign money being invested here. future livelihood are contained in these con­ and the cost of government in Massachusetts So whUe there are st111 problems to be solved, trasting sets of statements: are a detriment to the growth of the econ­ I think there are a lot of encouraging signs Massachusetts looks especially good to any omy. If we don't control both we're going in the economy.N industries desirous of setting up shop here to have an increasingly unhealthy load on Gordon D. MacKay, a Boston insurance because of the high degree of reliab111ty and the economy that will drive more busi­ executive who is also one of the guiding sklll which its labor force possesses. nesses-and jobs-out of the Common­ spirits of cttizens for Economy in Govern­ But it also looks especially bad to many wealth. ment, described Sargent's 12-point program of those same industt1es because of the high "We've got to have people at the State as "bandaid treatment for a basic problem," and steadily-escalating level of government House who will face reality and stop passing and said what's needed more than anything spending, and because there seems to be no new programs. without providing the money else in Massachusetts is to create the justified disposition on the part of anyone at the to pay for them. We've got to have depart­ impression that this state is being run well. State House to do anything about it. ment heads who will be able to justify every That can best be done, he said, by budget Those statements are not necessarily dollar they ask for, and we've got to force reform. beyond dispute; they are, rather, expressions them to look at their programs with a "We've got to develop a system of measure· of informed opinion on the part of omce critical eye. ment that will enable us to look at various holders and experts whose concern about the "Until we do we'll never be able to put programs and make cuts or changes in them state's economy is a continuing thing. a dent in state spending and we'll never be where indicated. When money is short the But what is beyond dispute is that new able to give the taxpayers of Massachusetts, average family takes steps to live within business means new jobs-and new jobs large and small alike, the assurance that their budget. They tighten their belts, do usually result in a spreading of the tax bur· their government has an honest concern for without some things, and develop alterna­ den among a larger number of people and their wellbeing." tives. We don't think the state government companies. However, the state has been des­ The expert maintained that Gov. Sargent, has explored alternatives. They've just added perately short of both business and jobs in while not necessarily hostile to industry's taxes and more taxes. recent years, and the deepening gravity of interests, is certainly indifferent to them­ "Many other states have been able to the situation is shown by the latest govern­ and many businessmen agree with him. cut taxes-but we haven't. They've measured ment figures which show 203,800 unemployed That is an allegation which Sargent denies output, what they're getting for their tax here. heatedly and repeatedly. His most recent dollars-and we've never done that. That adds up to a jobless rate of 8.1 per­ attempt to put the lie to it centered around "The businessman is a person oriented to cent loca.lly compared to a national average a $101,000,000 program that would, he said, the bottom line, and we need to create a of 5.2 percent--and that compels those who create 33,000 new jobs by: positive attitude that this state is being run are working to contribute more, via taxes, to Floating $48,000,000 in loans to help indus­ well,'' MacKay maintained. "When that's the support of those who are not. tries that either want to expand or locate done the word wlll spread, and new business here; will be attracted here. 36130 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974

"In order to correct the bad Impressions "Extreme austerity, cutting back on state "Neither th~ Legislature 9r the Governor about Massachusetts-like its being known as activities and not filling jobs simply because has seriously trie<;l to cut spending," he Tax·achusetts, for example-we've got to get they became vacant; maintained. ~'They talk austerity but they're state government squared away and create "By being very conservative in estimating stlll spending. We're not going to cut costs by the reality that it is being run well and how much we'd realize from various taxes. eliminating services but by making them efficiently. For example, we expect to get $30,000,000 more efficient, by getting people out of ad­ "After all, how do you think the marginal more from the corporation tax than anyone ministrative jobs and moving them out Into businessman-not the big corporations but outside this administration predicted; the field where they can provide services to the marginal businessman-feels when he "We anticipated we'd get revenue-sharing the public." reads about a new tax increase here? We're money from the Federal government, and I Kelly stressed, however, that the vast ma­ trying to create the attitude that this state was one of three governors who worked hard jority of state employes give a good day's is interested in business-and to transfer in Washington and elsewhere to win approval work for a good day's pay-but he conceded that attitude into action is what we've got to of that prograJn, and; that there are some people paid for no-show do." "There Is $100,000,000 which Is owed the jobs and others who not only don't do their state by the Dept. of Health, Education, and own work but prevent others with more en­ [From the Boston Herald American, July 17, Welfare. We have documented bllls for every thusiasm from doing theirs. 1974] dollar of that. We're under-estimating what "We're trying to squeeze loafers out by THE GREAT PAYCHECK RAID: SARGENT A MINOR­ we'll get from that source, but even if we get forcing department heads to justify what ITY OF ONE ON BALKING TAX BOOST $35,000,000 we'll be in good sha-pe. they've got, to choose between those who are (By Bill Duncliffe) "With that money, the additional $30,- doing their jobs, and those who are not," he 000,000 from the col'poratlon tax, and $35,- said. "If we could cut the cost of govern­ How much more will the paychecks of 000,000 in reversions from departmental the blue collar worker, the white collar work­ ment by one-twentieth, In this year's budget budgets we'll be all right. that would wipe out the need for a new tax er-and you and I-be raided for In addi­ "So there shouldn't be any new tax pro­ program." tional state taxes next year? gram In '75. There are a lot of problems re­ One of the few people outside of Sargent's If Gov. Sargent is right, not a dime-as maining, but if the economy picks up and long as the Legislature refuses to open the executive suite who thought-for a while­ we ge•t the money we expect we'll be all that there was some slight chance of avoid­ public purse for any program or proposal re­ right." qu1,r1ng a large outlay of dollars. Ing a tax hike was Rep. Joseph D. Early (D.) Sargent s·aid, however, that the legislature's of Worcester, vice chairman of the House But Sargent, up to now, has been a minor­ failure to pass more of his reorganization pro­ ity of one on that issue. Ways and Means Committee. gram-which on~e was figured to save about But Early's hope was hedged by two big The overwhelming majority of private ex­ $100,000,000-dlsappolnted him greatly and perts and public officials to whom this re­ "ifs"-lf Sargent's budget could be cut to he declared: $2,715,000,000, and if no deficiency budget to porter talked were convinced that Sargent "The urgency of reorganizing state govern­ Will have no choice but to seek anywhere keep state agencies running until next June ment Is greaJter now than it ever was, and if 30 became necessary. from $100,000,000 to $400,000,000 more in I'm s·till here In January we've got to give taxes in 1975. . The first hope was dimmed when the low­ pl'iori ty to ramrodding the rest of that pro­ est the budget could be cut to was $2,732,- If they are right, the money will probably gram through the Leglsl,ature." have to come from the sales, income, and 000,000, and the second didn't do any better Sargent's claim of austerity appears to when Early became reasonably sure Sargent coq><>ration levies-and that wlll il.ssa.ult clash with figures put together by the Mass. everyone's paycheck with blows like the fol .. would have to look for more money via a Taxpayers Foundation which, in an analysis deficiency budget. lowing: of his new budget, noted that since 1969 the Anyone who pays $75 in sales taxes th!l.s At least one such budget has been sub­ :P:umber of permanent state employes had in­ mitted in each of the last ten fiscal years, year w"-11 pay $100 next year, if the rate is creased from 50,219 to 62,578-a jumtJ of 24.6 lincreased one peroent. However, at least one and Early saw no reason why this one should percent. And that does not in.clude temp~­ be any different. Ieglsla.tor believes it could g~ up two percent, rary or '03 help. The Foundation also count­ or could be made a general rather than a "He Is just trying to get by the November ed, in Sargent's budget requests, 56 programs election," Early said. "He's trying to be all limited tax. If either happens, the impact will or items that were being included for the be even rougher. things to all people and promising them first time. things he can't possibly deliver on fully. But Anyone who has $5 taken from his pay­ The Governor's reply to those statistics is check for state income taxes will probably be the deficiencies won't show up until after that, first, higher educatio~ has been hugely November, and so he'll have to come in some dunned for another dollar a week In 1975. expanded during his tenure, that a number And if the rule-of-thumb cited earl!ier In time later with a request for more money." of community colleges have been opened, as Early maintained th81t the state budget is this series 1s accurate, half of wh~tever tax well as a state medical school at Worcester increase is charged to corporations will be lo,aded with fixed costs for such t.hings as and the new multi-million dollar campus of food, personnel, and fuel, and he said that a passed on to their customers. UMass-Boston. Nor Is tharli necessarily all. "We had to ask for a. lot of jobs for those way must be found to "un-fix" them to some degree. And he declared tha~ in some areas One of ·the more powerful lawmakers at schools because there is no sense 1n putting the State House, who out of a sense of self­ up buildings like that if there's no one to what Massachusetts" needs is' management preservation asked that his identity be with­ staff them," he said. and clear thinking. . held, &aid that two rather hair-raising inno­ In addition, he decided, many of the jobs ..For example," he declared, "when we vations mlghrt be explored. added to state rolls were the responsibillty of started the state pension system 20 years ago · The first would be to place a tax, similar the cost was $2,000,000 a year. to the &ales levy, on such "services" as a the Legislature which passed laws and man­ dated programs that made more hiring un­ "The employes' contribution was five per­ haircut and 001r on TV repairs, and he cent. But over the years we've increased the guessed: avoidable. · "Another thing," th~ Governor continued, benefits without increasing the contribu­ ~'About $80,000,000 could be realized from tion--and this ye.ar pensions will cost at rthat source alone." '.'I want an additional 200 state troopers to The second would be to make any income fight crime in this tiine of violence because I a;bout $170,000,000. tax increase that might be approved nexrt year feel they're absolutely necessary. But at the "I wanted to raise the contribution to a.ppllcable to incomes earned this year. To same time we're letting jobs in other agen­ seven percent, but we couldn't get It do that, he declared, would be to provi.de cies go uilfilled-so what we're dong Is shift­ through. I told teachers and state employees .,instant money," which he claimed, may very ing priorities." that they were killing the pension system well be needed if the state's financial situa­ One of those who are certain that Sargent without an Increase of that nature. tion Is as serious as Sargent's critics say it Is. wlll have to put the arm on the public for "And then, there are our judges. They're in But the Governor told this reporter they more taxes is Sen. James A. Kelly, Jr., (D.) of a non-contributory pension system and it have been wrong before-and· he happens to Oxford, chairman of the Senate Ways and never cost us anything because they never be r-ight about that. Means Committee. retired. But then we made it mandatory for And he Insisted they'll be proven wrong For one thing, Kelly said, the new budget them to retire when they reached the age of again-and that remains to be seen. 70, and in one year we knocked out 40 of "For the past three years a lot of people is many million dollars short of breaking even, and for another, Sargent has made them. have been saying we needed a tax Increase of "Their pensions came to 75 percent of their $100,000,000, or $200,000,000, or whatever," he commitments to the future that will entail maintained, "but for the past three years large sums of money. The Governor will need salary, so that meant they get $25,000 a year. we've been able to hold the line on taxes between $60,000,000 and $80,000,000 more for Now maybe $25,000 doesn't seem like much­ while tripling the aid we give to the cities state employes, and he'll need at least $60,- but multiply that by 40 and it comes to and towns. 000,000 to meet the state's obligations to its $1,000,000 a year. "Th-at's been particularly tough to do in elderly, disabled, and blind under the Sup­ "It's in places like this, ,and in state aid a time of inflation but we were able to do plementary Security income program, Kelly for school construction, ff}r example, we need lt by: said. management and direction." October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS .36131: [From the Boston Herald-American, will come at the expense of those other cities The survey, based on 798- personal inter­ July 18. 1974) and towns whose share 1s reduced. views with people reflecting the state's popu­ THE GREAT PAYCHECK RAm: TAX PICTURE BAD, In either case, whatever sum any commu­ lation characteristics, showed that more GOOD nity gets will almost certainly be less than than twice as many cltlzens-39-.6 percent it is entitled to under the law-because the to 16.5 percent-would rather cut back serv­ (By Bill Duncliffe) historical fact ls that Massachusetts usually ices than raise taxes. The immediate future contains a mixture makes good on about 82 percent of the aid U Yet, given a list of 16 specific services, of both bad news and good for everyone has pledged to its cities and towns. thoee interviewed recommended reductions whose quality of life is being wounded by In spite of all the depressing evidence how­ 1n only three-and wanted more money spent the slashes in their income being inflicted ever, there are some encouraging-if less on ten others. each week by The Great Paycheck Raid. substantial-signs that officials on all three "The contradiction of people at the same Firat, the bad news: levels of government are beginning to tumble time demanding less spending but more serv­ Despite all the bright and "it's high time" to how the Great Paycheck Raid is causing ices clearly shows the political dilemma fac­ talk coming out of the Capitol, there is no hardship for those they are supposed to ing the Governor, legislators, and local offi­ chance whatever of a cut in the Federal serve. In Washington, there is increasing cials in dealing with fiscal chaos in Massa­ income tax being passed before the end of pressure not only for tax reform but welfare chusetts," said Henry S. Lodge, executive the year. reform-changing the system so that the director of CEG. The only answer is a gov­ Plus which, despite the long labors of the needy can live in dignity and hope and the ernment which works seriously to maximize House Ways and Means Committee, there is taxpayer can be sure his money is being the effectiveness of every tax dollar." no chance either that Congress will get dispensed wisely and fairly. There is sup­ But no public official can really do that un­ around at this session to correcting some of port, too, for the thesis that welfare should less he or she knows what the public thinks the more obvious inequities that now exist be solely a Federal function-and if that about any given problem or program. Speak­ in the nation's tax laws. The impeachment ever becomes law a huge load will be lifted ing strictly about the situation at the State proceedings and the pressures of an election from the state's tax structure. House-although his words would apply year will act to shove that issue aside until Despite the bungling and filibustering equally well on the national or municipal 1975 at the earliest. which bushwhacked the tax-cut efforts of level, Peter Keyes, legislative director of Com­ Those same factors wlll give the kiss of Sen. Kennedy and several of his colleagues mon Cause, said: death to any hope that the same Committee it wm come up again in 1975, and it is "Leglslators don't hea.r from their constitu­ will allow the House to vote on the bill pro­ quite likely that Burke-if he is reelected­ ents on many issues. Sure, they hear on such posed by Rep. James A. Burke of Milton and will be able to shake his Social Security blll things as gun control, abortion, and the like, cosponsored by 132 of his colleagues to give loose from Ways and Means and bring it be­ but virtually no one knows that court clerks, low and middle-income wage earners a break fore the House for a decision. for example, have an organization and they're on their Social Security tax. At the moment, he is about four votes up at the State House every year looking for As for Sen. Kennedy's proposal to increase short on the Committee, an Burke's ex• a raise. Other groups of workers and officials the personal income tax exemption to $825, pectation is that if he gets those few he have organizations doing the same thing, and forget it for now. Next year, maybe-but it wm win by a large margin in the House. the public isn't aware of them. will stlll be a tough one to win. Both Burke and House Majority Leader Legisl81tors are pressured by these groups, On the state front the common feeling is Thomas P. O'Nelll, Jr., insist that there is but there is no counterva111ng pressure from that whoever wins the governorship in No­ every prospect that, as far as tax reform is the people back home-and lawmakers have vember will have to perform the political concerned, Ways and Means will retain the to know how their constituents feel if they equivalent of walking on water if he is to "little man loopholes" used by many people are to do a truly effective job." avoid. asking for a massive tax hike next in filling out their income tax returns. These So that's it. Apathy, a widespread hopeless year. include deductions for union dues, medical feeling of "what's the use of saying .anything" There is, however, no discernible hope of a insurance premiums, state gas taxes, and the has allowed The Great Paycheck Raid to go miracle where the auto excise tax is con­ like. as far as it has. What's needed now to change cerned. Bills to reduce it and to require local But while allowing those to remain, the things for the better ls constant, construc­ authorities to make automatic refunds of Committee will very probably urge that other, tive action by people like the $200-a-week overpayments to motorists were scuttled by larger loopholes which work to the advan­ blue collar worker, the white collar worker the Legislature this year, and it wm take a tage of major on companies and other mem­ with an income nearly twice as large-and complete change of mind for them to become bers of "Big Business" be closed. Almost people like you and me. law in the foreseeable future. certainly that wm prove to be one of the "The rate ($66 per $1000 of valuation) is toughest fights of all in the next session of too high, and enforcement of the tax is Congress. replete with red tape and mistakes," said In Massachusetts a new reform bill wm­ Eivhard W. Hoover of the AAA. "Take the if signed into law by Gov. Sargent-make the MASS TRANSrr LEGISLATION refund procedure, for example. If a depart­ next state budget a truly "open" one from BEFORE ADJOURNMENT ment store over-charges you the refund wW beginning to end. It is the combined prod­ ord1nar1ly be handled quickly and with little uct of the thinking of Rep. Joseph D. Early trouble. (D) of Worcester, House Speaker David M. HON. RAY J. MADDEN "But neither the state or the local com­ Bartley (D) of Holyoke, and a coalition of OF INDIANA groups that included the Citizens for Econ­ munities will do that. If you don't know you IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES over-paid they won't tell you-and that's omy in Government, League of Women wrong." Voters, Mass. Taxpayers Foundation, Com­ Thursday, October 17, 1974 Even more unjust and oppressive, in the mon Cause, Massachusetts, and Citizens for Mr. MADDEN. Mr. Speaker. the House view of tax and financial experts and of­ Participation in Political Action. of Representatives is vitally concerned ficials, is the steadily-escalating cost of gov­ • • • but proponents claim that this would that this Congress pass a mass trans­ ernment in Massachusetts -but there is me.an that school costs would be spread portation bill this year. I was most virtually no chance of any significant reduc­ more justly over all segments of the popu­ tion either In state spending or the number lation rather than on the property owner pleased when some weeks ago, after 3 of state employes. alone. days of debate, this body by a large ma­ The more realistic goal is to control the But will it-and any or all of the other jority passed the mass transportation growth of both. remedies suggested above-be approved? And bill that was reported from the Commit­ On the municipal scene the prospect is that if approved, will they work? tee on Public Works. This is a long range property tax rates will continue to rise­ Those are the key questions, and the an­ swer to them is while they may be approved 6-year bill which would establish a per­ primarly because of inflation, school costs, manent program in the mass transpor­ and the new collective bargaining law that they cannot possibly work without the active requires compulsory arbitration as an ulti­ and articulate-and persistent-help of blue tation field. collar workers and white collar workers alike, This bill has been languishing in the mate step in settling contract disputes with without the pro or con contribution of every­ police and firemen. For a time, the new one whose taxes help pay the freight of gov­ other body for several weeks and no Special Education law appeared to be a major ernment. action has yet been taken. factor in this regard-but the decision of the There are always cries that too much During the last 10 to 15 years, traffic Legislature to provide $26,000,000 1n "up money is being spent, and that government congestion has multlpled several times front" money to help cities and towns put it must stop frittering funds away on every until today our economy is being threat­ into effect this coming September eased its program that's proposed by this special-in­ impact considerably. terest group or that. But a survey made by ened by millions of workers, shoppers, The expected rise in real estate rates would Joseph Napolitan Associaltes of Springfield business, and industry being tied up in be slowed somewhat in 200 of the Common• for Citizens for Economy in Government in­ urban traffic tangles by bumper-to wealth's 351 communities by a new formula dicated that many taxpayers are talking out bumper truck, automobile, bus, and rail­ increasing their cut of state aid-but that of both sides of their mouth. road congestion. 36132 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 Not all Members of this Congress, espe­ But, not only is this good legislation, (3) Cut export of U.S. food.-A larger feted cially those from rural communities, are it is one of the best examples I have seen supply at home would mean lower prices. directly contending with this unspeak­ in my short time in Congress of the im­ Rep. Long has sharply criticized the past sales of U.S. grain to Russia, and has sup­ able traffic burden now being endured pact of one man with a good idea. ported programs to help small farmers by the citizens in metropolitan areas. In ·All of us in this chamber have been around the world grow more food themselves, some cities, workers are now being de­ looking for ways to cut consumer spend­ rather than rely on U.S. food assistance. layed from 30 minutes to an hour and a ing to relieve inflationary pressures. And (4) Increase world's food supply.-Rep. half in getting to and from their work here the gentleman has offered an idea Long has sponsored the Food Research and in factories, industries, offices, and shops. for a program which involves an expend­ Development Act, a bill to increase Amer­ Members of Congress from urban iture by the Government of only $6 mil­ ica's and the warrld's food supply (and there­ areas during past years have, with few lion which can reduce consumer spend­ by cut long-term food prices) by developing better means of food production, processing, exceptions, supported farm subsidies and ing by $380 million-in effect, a 6,000- irrigation, and livestock breeding. other forms of aid to rural areas percent return on our investment. (5) cut taxes for savers to increase mort­ throughout the country. We are now But all of us know that putting a good gaae money, boost homebuilding.-Rep. asking our colleagues to reciprocate bY idea in the form of a bill does not auto­ L~g has introduced legislation ( co-spon­ supporting mass transit. matically make it law. This bill has sored by 31 other Congressmen) to exempt I recently sent a telegram to the reached the point it has because of the the first $500, or $1,000 on a joint ret~rn, of American Transit Association which re­ tireless efforts of the gentleman from savings account interest from Federal tncome affirmed our position that the Public Massachusetts. He has walked the cor­ tax. Rep. Long's bill helps those lower- and Works Committee bill on mass transpor­ middle-income savers who have been hit hard ridors of Capitol Hill, seeds in hand, by inflation. In addition, Rep. Long's ~ill tation should be moved by the other buttonholing Members. On our first en­ would boost the housing market by provtd­ body. This is still my position, and I be­ counter, I left with a package of cucum­ ing more construction and mortgage funds lieve that, if the other body would hold ber seeds and the gentleman left with a through savings banks. immediate hearings on a mass trans­ firm commitment. (6) Plug tax loopholes.-Rep. Long has portation bill and report it out right I would like to take this opportunity to sponsored several bills to plug the tax loop­ after the recess, there could be a quick urge my colleagues to support this meas­ holes for the wealthy which drain the Treas­ conference and legislation would be ury and add to the tax burden of the aver­ ure when it comes up for a vote next age taxpayer. Such reforms would be aimed forthcoming before we adjourn for the month and to commend our distin­ at capital gains taxes, farm 'loss' deductions year. guished colleague for his tireless efforts claimed by wealthy investor-farmers, special It is my firm feeling that such action on behalf of the American consumer. tax treatment of foreign subsidiaries of U.S. should be taken by the other body, and corporations (including foreign tax credits I urge Senator HARRISON WILLIAMS of the claimed by oil companies), and the oil deple­ Senate Committee, and other Senators LONG PRESENTS PROGRAM TO tion allowance. who have done such a great job in the (7) Reduce energy costs, break up monop­ COMBAT INFLATION olistic energy companies.-Rep. Long has past in the field of mass transportation, sponsored the Energy Industry Competition to move now to meet with the Commit­ Act to halt the anti-competitive practices of tee on Public Works and give us the bill HON. CLARENCE D. LONG oil, gas, coal, and oil shale companies. Large, we need. OF MARYLAND integrated energy companies would be com­ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES pelled to divest themselves of a segment of 'their operations, leading to increased com- BURKE SEED LEGISLATION Thursday, October 17, 1974 petition and lower prices. Mr. LONG of Maryland, Mr. Speaker, I (8) Increase U.S. oil yields.-Rep. Long shall oppose the President's proposals for pushed for and got an increase of appropri­ -HON. JOE MOAKLEY ations for research on increasing the yields an income surtax and increased invest­ OF MASSACHUSETTS from existing oil wells. Such advanced oil re­ ment tax credit. covery techniques could produce more oil IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES The 5-percent tax surcharge is offered from existing wells-prices should drop witll Thursday, October 17, 1974 to finance a proposed investment tax the increased supply. credit for industry which will cost the (9) Stop automatic rate hil~es.-Rep. L.o?tg Mr. MOAKLEY. Mr. Speaker, I am the U.S. Treasury about as much as the has sponsored a ·bill to requtre ·that uttltty pleased to learn that we will have an surtax will increase revenues. companies justify any rate increases in a opportunity, after the recess, to vote on public hearing-forbidding use of such mech­ legislation to provide free seeds to the The investment tax credit is a waste­ anisms as the "automatic fuel adjustment American public. ful gimmick which only subsidizes invest­ clause." This bill was introduced by my distin­ ments that companies would have made (10) Ease materials shortages _by boo~ting guished colleague from Massachusetts anyway; thus, it adds to inflation with­ recycling.-With industry jaczng htgher out adding new supplies of goods and prices for scarce raw materials (often con­

Allende was overthrown by Chileans. He Ham Colby said: "In light of current Ameri~ such that he lives on through those of never at any time had the support of the can policy, it would not have a major impact­ us who knew and loved him. majority of the people. He was overthrown on our current activities or the current se­ Governor Hodges was an alumnus of because he and his more radical adherents curity of the United States." alienated, frightened, and ultimately radi­ While the triple use of the word "current" the University of North Carolina at calized in the opposite sense the uncon­ is ominous, this statement is mildly reas­ Chapel Hill, a member of the class of verted majority, particularly its most power­ suring. It is to be hoped that the President 1919. He was a student there along with ful element, the military. and secretary of State will be persuaded that, the late author Thomas Wolfe, the re­ It is necessary to make this point in order in the broader perspective, these "dirty tired newspaperman Jonathan Daniels, to clarify the broad issue-whether admitted tricks" do more harm than good to the na­ and our distinguished senior Senator, the CIA activities in Chile, even if they played tional security and should be phased out. Honorable SAM J. ERVIN, JR. no substantial part in the overthrow of It is a fitting tribute to Luther Hart· Allende, were in the national interest of the U.S. I would argue that they were not. well Hodges that his beloved alma mater American and other Western spokesmen AN UNUSUAL FELLOW-THE HON- is establishing in his memory-not a have for the past half century been pointing ORABLE LUTHER HARTWELL dorm or classroom building-but a pro­ out that, whlle the Marxist revolutions in fessorship in business ethics. the Soviet Union and elsewhere were no HODGES The editorial tributes to Gove1nor doubt directed to noble ends, the atrocious Hodges follow: means so often employed grossly distorted HON. IKE F. ANDREWS [From the Asheboro Courier-Tribune, Oct. 9, and even vitiated those ends. Yet since the 1974] onset of the cold war the U.S. has taken a OF NORTH CAROLINA leaf out of the Communist book and too IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES AN UNUSUAL FELLOW often resorted to means so shabby we dare Luther Hodges was an unusual fellow. He not avow them. In the long run this does Thursday, October 17, 1974 never really retired nor showed any signs of not pay. Mr. ANDREWS of North Carolina. Mr. preferring inactivity to public service of one Ignoble means debase and demoralize the Speaker, earlier this month, on Sunday, nature or another. actors, corrupt and brutalize those acted October 6, my State, our Nation, and the Every North Carolinian knows the Horatio upon and, in so doing, transform and disin­ Alger story of Mr. Hodges' climb from the tegmte the end itself. This is as true for world su:trered a great loss with the death tenant farm to the corporate boo.rdroom. democrats 818 for Communists. of Luther Hartwell Hodges. "Retiring" from an executive position with The consequence of a quarter century of He served long and well-as a top Marshall Field textile mill chain, he ran for "dirty tricks" by the CIA, that is, the U.S. executive with Marshall Field & Co., as lieutenant governor and succeeded to the Government, has been to make the agency Lieutenant Governor and then Governor governor's office upon the death of Gov. Wil­ throughout the world a symbol for unscrupu­ of North Carolina, as Secretary of Com­ liam B. Umstead in 1954. He won a term in lous intervention in other people's internal merce under Presidents John F. Kennedy his own right two years later and served the aft'alrs and hence often to undermine, rather longest of any North Carolina chief execu­ than to serve, the obje<:tives of U.S. foreign and Lyndon Baines Johnson, as president tive, six years. policy. of Rotary International, as chairman of It was a distinguished governorship. No We see how lt is almost universally be­ the board of the Research Triangle schools were clooed during these turbulent lieved in Greece that the CIA inspired the Foundation. years nor was there rac!a.l violence in the July 15 coup in Cyprus which set in train Earlier, in the 1930's, he was appointed wake of the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling the subsequent disasters. I believe this is a to the State highway conunission by Gov. which knocked down metal barriers In mistaken judgment, because upsetting the J. C. B. Ehringhaus, and, during World American schools. A consumma.te salesman, status quo was so obviously counter to U.S. War II, he served as head of the textile the governor's sales pitch for North Caro­ interest. But the fact it is plausible to sup­ lina-made products skirted the ridiculous, pose that the CIA might have inspired the division in the Office of Price Adminis­ especially when he posed in a shower wearing coup 1:f it had been in the U.S. interest lends tration. a wrlnkle-free suit. color to the accusation. It wa.s my privilege to serve in the But it was the kick in the seat of the pants I A New York Times story last week quotes North Carolina State Senate in 1959 the starte needed. After all, business means a telegram from the U.S. Ambassador in Delhi when Governor Hodges was rounding out jobs-and that's something the governor­ to the effect that the recent revelations about the longest tenure of any North Carolina who rose from the poverty-stricken ranks­ CIA activities in Chile have confirmed the chief executive. We became friends at understood. worst suspicions of the Indians about tbat that time, and our friendship continued "Operation Bootstrap" we remember as a agency and caused Indira Gandhi to wonder sort oif huckster promotion to attract indus­ whether the Indian Government may not be until the day he died at his .home in try into the state, but it wasn't a fa.ilure con­ the next target for elimination. This is ha.rdlr Chapel Hill. sidering the state's relatively hea.lthy state the image of its foreign policy and practice For the benefit of my colleagues I am With a stable industrial mix. The governor the U.S. Government should Wish to see wide­ including in the RECORD some of the edi­ will share a bit in our success of late in de­ ly held around the world. torial tributes to Governor Hodges that pleting the state of North Carolina as a good Supporters of CIA activities of this kind appeared in some of the North Carolina place to work and live. think of themselves as "hard-nosed" realists. He represented a.l1 that was good in the The Bay of Pigs is one instructive example newspapers. state. The mixture of salesmanship blarney, and Gordon Liddy's little operation at Water­ They sum up the man-his life, his common sense a.nd public decency which gate is another. careers, his long service-quite well, and were all part of the Hodges image were good The fact is that "dirty tricks" conducted to them I would like to add a recollection for the state. by agents of the U.S. Government very rarrely that was somehow overlooked and largely And Horatio Alger lives! Other sons of ten­ serve the national Interest of the United forgotten, I imagine, by those who have ant farmers should look to the example Lu­ States, even 1! one Interprets these interests joined in paying editorial tribute to this ther Hodges set during the productive rags­ in strictly "cold-war" terms. Experience has to-riches lifetime. shown that they cannot be adequately "con­ exceptional man. trolled" Within the executive branch, because My recollection, which has been veri­ [From the Durham Morning Herald, Oct. 8, lt is so often the controllers, as in the case fied by Mr. Ed Rankin, who was adminis­ 1974) of the Bay of Pigs and perhaps of Chile, trative assistant to Governor Hodges, was Gov. LUTHER HODGES whose perceptions and judgments are at that during the fifties he advised Mr. fault. We need not repeat in these lines the long Vietnam has tragically demonstrated the Rankin and others that it was his per­ and impressive list of contributions that for­ limitation on the capacity of the U.S. to de­ sonal preference that no bridge, building, mer Gov. Luther Hodges, who died Sunday, termine the structure of an alien society park, highway, or other permanent struc­ made to life in North Carolina. even by a massive injection of armed force. ture be named for him during his life­ Few would deny that he was one of the How much less likely that America could time. state's most distinguished and successful hope to do so by clandestine operations. The governors, businessmen and citizens. In his U.S. can, no doubt, occasionally contribute Governor Hodges was one who put long career, he seemed almost to personify to the rise or fall of a particular government greater stock in intangibles-truth, love, that which is best about North Carollna. or politician, but over the longer run indig­ and human spirit-than in brick and When he ran for lieutenant governor in enous forces, which it cannot control, will mortar. 1952, he campaigned as a. businessman, not determine whether this superficial change as a politician, who wanted to bring good has any lasting effect. He was one who appealed to others business principles to state government. Yet In referring at a public meeting in Wash­ to serve unselfishly, one who spurred he became an exceptionally adroit politician, ington last week to proposals that CIA aban­ others on to help their fellow human a. politician in the best sense, whose high don its covert action programs, director Wil- beings, one whose exemplary life was ethical sense, energetic devotion to progress October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36137 and insistence on the sane, sensible middle (One of the photos showed him in a wrinkle­ It was passed by the legislature and okayed way helped to bring North Carolina through free suit taking a shower, another showed by the voters but was never used. the turbulent 'fifties in good shape. him hitching his well-pressed pants over his Hodges -once told an interview "I consider He did not personally believe in the de­ North Carolina-made underwear.) The gim­ the calm manner in which North Carolina segregation of the schools, but North caro­ mickry was a sidelight to substantive ee~ handled its integration problems the num­ lina was lu<:ky to have him as governor when nomic leadership such as founding the Re­ ber one. achievement of my administration. the first token desegregation came to the search Triangle Park. It also was the thorniest problem." state. The Pearsall Plan adopted under his He learned to be a politician. He preferred He'll be remembered for the formation of governorship, was an astute exercise in com­ Lyndon Johnson at the 1960 National Demo­ the Research Triangle which he and banker promise during an uncompromising time. It cratic convention. He became an indefatig­ Robert Hanes of Winston-Salem pushed to saved the state from the futile resistance -of able campaigner for John F. Kennedy, and entice high quality industry into the state. the kind undertaken in Virginia, yet it was later launched yet another public service Hodges wished to create jobs for persons never invoked to close a school or to pay career as U.S. secretary o1 commerce. leaving the f-arms. the private tuition of a single North Caro­ In 1964, he came back for another retire­ Hodges was dignified and looked every bit lina student. It set the stage, as much as ment .and another decade of work for the the part of the governor. Yet he posed in his anything else, ~or North Carolina's entry Research Triangle and other North Carolina underwear for a Life photographer in a move into the even more drastic social revolution causes. Few men in this state's histo1·y lived to help the state's industry. of the 'Sixties. so fully as Luther Hartwell Hodges. He was a man of action, a m-an needed for Former Gov. Terry Sanford summed lt up the times. He continued to be active right best, perhaps, when he said. "His courage and {From the Raleigh Times, Oct. 7, 1974] up to the end. He will be missed by North sense <>f fairness and enlightenment calmed Gov. LUTHER HODGES SERVED Carolina and particularly the Research Tri­ the angry seas of racial strife and estab­ NoRTH CAXOLINA WELL angle area. lished North Carolina as a model for the na­ tion." Luther Hodges, who died yesterday after sutfering a heart attack at his home in [From the N{)rth Car.olina Leader, Gov. Hodges was also a model for the Oct. 15, 1974] genre from which he sprang, the nation's Chapel Hill, was the epitome of the Ameri­ industrialists and businessmen. But the can success story. PuRPOSE enormous energy he invested in bringing in· Starting his career as a mill hand he went Be!ore they were married a few years back, dustry to North Carolina, the Research Tri­ on to become governor of North oarolina. Mrs. Luther Hodges told "the Leade-r, "The angle Park and his own successful business He was born in Pittsylvania County, Va., Governor is, In so many ways, about the career marked only one aspect of the man. March 9, 1898, but his early llfe was tied to youngest person I've ever known:• As governor, as secretary of commerce, as an nearby Leaksvllle, N.C., where the family Anyone who came in contact with this re­ author and a speaker, he continued right up moved when he was two. His father worked markable man had to agree. until the cloBing days of his life to empha· in tbe textile m1lls there. Hodges himself He was a man of action with a probing size that businessmen not only have a duty worked as an office boy in the mills 1910- mlnd and vlslon about the future of North to make money-they have a responsibility 1911. He also worked as a mill hand during Caronna. to do it honestly and to contribute to the summer vacations. He obtained an AB degree Just a few weeks ago. we heard him explain social welfare of their community and na­ from the University of North Carolina at Research Triangle Park-its reason for tion. Chapel H111 in 1919 then went to work as being-to members of the Chapel Hill Rotary Luther Hodges was a conservative in a secretary of the general manager of the Club, which he founded. basically conservative southern state. But his Leaksville mms. "We wanted to raise the income level of was an enlightened, creative conservatism Hodges went on to become genel"al man­ North Carolina and keep the young men and which never ceases to grow and which builds ager of the Marshall Field and Co. mills in women educated in our schools at home in­ upon the best that we have. North Carolina. 1938 and was made vice president of the stead of having them seek higher paying jobs was fortunate to have his energy, his sure­ company in 1943. He retired in 1950. in the North or West." he said. rootedness and his inspiration in her serv• He was active in the Rotary Club and was Prof. Joel Carter of the University of North ice f-or such a long period of time. a member of the Highway Commission under Carolina faculty whispered, "Any meeting is Governor Ehringhaus ln the early 1930s. enhanced just by his being there. He hn.s [From the News and Observer, Oct. 8, 1974] Hodges took part in Democratic Party politics such integrity!" LUTHER HODGES LIVED A FULL LIFE at the precinct and congressional district Former Gov. Luther Hodges' integrity, ded­ levels. ication and purpose were a beacon light in When Luther Hodges ran for lieutenant But he was a political unknown when he governor in 1952, a lot of people thought him the development of Research Triangle Park. decided to run for lieutenant governor .in The Leader, as the Research Triangle's just another retired businessman looking for 1952. something purposeful to keep busy. The no­ newspaper, enjoyed .a unique, joyful relation He set out to change this. He told friends with him. We weren't around him a great tion sprang naturally from his arduous climb later that during the campaign he never from tenant farmer's son to $75,000-a-year deal, but interviews with him were fun; his bought more than one-gallon of gasoline at quick-witted mind supplying the answer to executive of the Marshall Field textile m111 a time. He'd pull into a service station, buy chain. the next question before it was spoken. a gallon of gas, shake hands all around and His wife, Louise, brightened the last years But unlike many young men who pursue say "I'm Luther Hodges. I'm no politician, success and attain it in maturity, Hodges was of his life. They were almost inseparable. but rm running for lieutenant governor. I'd We remember one autumn morning seeing neither tired nor overly impressed by achiev­ appreclate your vote." Then passing out ing it. :He retained a young man's sense of them stroll together with Louise Hodges · cards he'd move on to the next service sta­ reading aloud from a book. vigor, optimism and openmindedness. He re­ tion or restaurant where he'd go through garded retirement as merely a different set "What book are you reading?" we asked. of circumstances for more growth and the routine again. Governor Hodges chuckled and supplied achievement. Although he was a definite underdog, he the answer. Hodges won that lieutenant governor's race won. He became governor Nov. 7, 1954, when "It's a joke book," he confessed. And we as a novice politician because he worked Gov. William B. Umstead died. thought he knew all the jokes! hardest at learning public affairs and cam­ He finished the term, then was elected He lived to see his dream come true iu paigning for votes. And hindsight tells us governor on his own Nov. 7, 1956 and served Research Triangle Park. However, as he him­ that if Gov. William B. Umstead had no1i untn Jan. 5, 1961. He thus served longer self reminded people in a special article he died two years later, propelling H.adges to the thanlB.ny governor in this century. wrote for the Leader in 1969, the "unremit­ governorship, Hodges very likely would have By moving from an unknown to governor, ting dedication" o! North Carolina citizens earned it in his own right. Indeed. he did win Hodges showed that it was stm possible to is always needed to see that things keep a full term in the 1956 gubernatorial election. beat the bushes and get elected witho"Ut the happening in Research Triangle Pal'k. Those were the turbulent years of school backing of a political machine. integration in. the South. Though some of us Hodges was appointed secretary of com­ sharply questioned the "safety valve" plan merce by President Kennedy and continued MANPOWER POLICIES FOE. A NEW which Hodges promoted in North Carolina, the post under President Johnson. ADMINISTRATION it closed no schools. This state escaped the As governor, Hodges advocated the so­ racial violence he counselled against, too. Industrial promotion and economic devel­ called Pearsall Plan as a safety valve toward integration ir. the state's schools. At the HON. WILLIAM A. STEIGER opment most marked his years as governor. OF WISCONSIN Hodges was comfortable in the board rooms same time he said he hoped it would never and the waiting rooms as a salesman for his be used. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES state. Often he was successful. He pursued Before it was struck down by the federal Thursday, October 17, 1974 many avenues. He prevalled on the legtsla· courts it allowed closing of schools under ture to eut taxes for corporations. He coop• certain conditions and allowed the state to Mr. STEIGER of Wisconsin. Mr. erated for a series of pictures for Life maga­ grant tuition to students not wishing to Speaker, the National Manpower Policy zine, promoting North Carolina. products. attend racially mixed schools. Task Force recently completed a policy CXX--2278-Part 27 36138 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 statement of substance and importance. ence as deliverers of manpower and social unemployment rates increase. The Ford ad­ For the information of my colleagues I services. It contributed to spreading a nega­ ministration's plans for a Community Im­ want to share this statement with tive image of manpower efforts, far beyond provement Corps to hire unemployment in­ th~m what was justified by evaluation data. surance exhaustees for short-term public for their review and thought at this Budget retrenchment made the decentrali· works and beautiflcation projects emphasize point: zation of programs to state and local officials temporary, work-relief at low wages. An an­ MANPOWER POLICIES FOR A NEW more difficult as they faced the unwelcome nual average of over 1.8 million persons ex­ ADMINISTRATION task of breaking a smaller loaf among an hausted benefits in the past three years, and The beginning of a new administration is increasing multitude of potential clients. there may be many more in the coming year. an appropriate time for reviewing past poli­ THE CURRENT SCENE If a plan is adopted which provides jobs for a large proportion of these unemployed, it cies, assessing current conditions, and anal­ The Ford administration faces difficult yzing future needs. The National Manpower could be a very useful tool. But the Commu­ manpower challenges. The most immediate nity Improvement Corps is not a substitute Policy Task Force offered its assessments and issue is to cope with the problems of unem­ recommendations at the beginning of the for an expanded program along the lines of ployment and inflation. Joblessness is rising the Emergency Employment Act which Nixon administration, hopefully with same to socially and politically unacceptable levels positive impacts. In this policy statement, we served a broad range of the unemployed and yet "double digit" inflation persists, a pac~ funded needed "regular" jobs above as well briefly review the manpower policies of the never before known in peacetime. Traditional last six years, and offer unsolicited advice to as at the entry level, thus insuring transi­ methods of fighting inflation have always tional opportunities. Provision should be policymakers in the Ford administration and visited their major costs on those least able in Congress. made not only for those who exhaust com­ to bear them-those already at the lower pensation benefits, but for those who lose PAST PERFORMANCE margins of the labor market. Strong voices their jobs and want to continue working. The major manpower policy thrusts of the in the federal establishment and outside President Ford's proposal might complement Nixon years were the decentralization, de­ continue to advocate fighting inflation with an expanded public employment program categorization, and consolidation of man­ insufficient regard for rising unemployment. along the lines initiated in 1971 subject to power programs. These were ultimately com­ But the current inflation did not originate a 4.5 percent trigger funding formula. bined in the passage of the Comprehensive with labor shortages, excess labor market Public service employment is only a piece Employment and Training Act in December bargaining power, or excess demand. Labor of an antistagf:lation manpower policy. Are­ 1973. A solid achievement, it was the right market bargaining power is now obviously a cession is also an appropriate time to up­ approach for the right time. The initial im­ factor, but it must be recognized as an effort grade the skills of the labor force. The costs petus for manpower programs was necessarily to "catch up" after remarkable restraint. of training otherwise unemployed people are nattonal, but with a decade of experience to We believe that the use of weapons with reduced by the drop in their foregone earn­ build upon, the time had come to adopt the adverse labor market impacts to fight an ings. Trainees are not tempted by job avail­ results of that experience to the particular inflation which counts no labor market phe­ ability to drop out before completion of needs of local labor markets. The passage of nomena among its causes will be costly in­ training courses, and employers are not likely the Comprehensive Employment and Train­ effective, and above all, inequitable. Yet: the to raid the training facilities. Program ad­ ing Act was only a first step. A major effort pace of inflation must be slowed, and we ministrators are not so anxious to reduce will be required before the chief elected state have no pat answers how to deal with the training time to the minimum, and substan­ and local officials will acquire a full apprecia­ situation. tial skills can be provided. Training must re­ tion and understanding of manpower prob­ One thing is certain, however. Increased main a central component of manpower pol­ lems and before state and local manpower monetary and fiscal restraint wm further icy. staffs will develop the necessary planning boost the already high levels of unemploy­ The public employmei).t service is a neces­ and administrative skills. ment. Whatever policies are adopted, we be­ sary cornerstone of our manpower efforts. The Department of Labor, which retains lieve that society has a clear responsibi11ty Important improvements have been and are federal responsibility, has several difficult to protect and compensate those who bear being made to augment its ability to serve assignments. It must continue to confront the burden of national policies aimed to both employers and jobseekers. Experiments some manpower issues which are national in reduce inflation for the rest of us. have d~monstrated that, in addition to its scope, such as the problems of youth, older Unemployment compensation and public direct placement functions, it can do more to workers, and veterans, and accept respon­ assistance benefits are first line defenses. spread job market information and improve sibility for aiding migrant workers, Indians, President Ford's proposal to bolster unem­ the abilities of employees and employers to and others whom state and local government ployment compensation by extending regular exercise their own initiative in the job mar­ cannot, or would not, effectively serve. It benefits 13 weeks and implementing a spe• ket. Shortening the duration of frictional also must maintain a monitoring and evalua­ cial program of up to 26 weeks for workers unemployment is an obvious contribution tion role to assure that national objectives who qualify for compensation on the basis to reducing overall unemployment. Vigorous specified in the C'omprehensive Employment of employment and earnings but who are not steps are, therefore, needed to increase the and Training Act are pursued, and to provide in covered industries, are necessary and effectiveness of the public employment serv­ technical assistance without "hovering" over timely steps, but not enough. Except for ice and to fully utilize its resources under state and local decisionmakers. those for whom gainful employment is not CETA. The Nixon administration left omce with a reasonable alternative, income support is Despite notable progress in the last decade another important, but unfinished, accom­ not desirable. To idle willing hands is no way race, sex, and age discrimination still per~ to fight an inflation originating in shortages. plishment to its credit-the introduction of sis~. Differences in skill, experience, produc­ a plan to reform the welfare system. Earn­ Public service employment was sufficiently tivity, and labor market mob11ity account ings from employment is the preferred successful under the Emergency Employment for only a portion of the high average un­ source of income in the American, as in any Act of 1971 to win the approval of liberals employment (and lower earnings) among and conservatives alike. It makes sense be­ minority groups and women. The immediate other society, but a basic floor of economic cause it maintains productive activity and security should be a social right of all citi­ goa~ should be to eliminate market discrimi­ zens in an amuent society. A guaranteed output. It is less costly than often supposed na.tlOn to assure that persons with equal minimum income accompanied by work in­ because its expenditures are partly offset by sk1lls and abilities are treated equally. In the centives and income supplements for the savings in income maintenance programs. longer run, differences in training, education, working poor appears to be a desirable way Creation of public service jobs is less infla­ and work experience must, then, be attacked. to accomplish the goal. While the Nixon tionary than the customary "trickle down" A more vigorous antidiscrimination policy administration faltered in its commitment approach of creating employment by gener­ and enforcement is needed both in the short­ before Congress might have acted, important atmg aggregate demand for goods and serv­ and long-run to achieve these aims. groundwork was laid in formulation of the ices. It requires minimal capital investment Finally, continued research is needed into concepts and education of the public. and rations its jobs directly to the unem­ the functioning of labor markets. The cur­ In other manpower policy areas, the Nixon ployed. While public employment measures rent economic crisis has suggested how much could become a disguise for unproductive in• there is still to be learned. Research is a administration's record was mixed. It op­ come mai:htenance and could replace other posed the introduction of a public employ­ public budgetary commitments with no real long-range investment, not to be cut back ment program as a countercyclical device and increase in jobs, these abuses can be min­ in short-run emergencies. The limited funds as an initial small step toward guarantee­ invested in labor market research have been ing employment. However, once Congress imized by prudent public administration. The major issue is not whether to introduce carefully husbanded and for the most part insisted, the executive branch followed wisely spent. Advancing the frontiers of through with vigor and determination in public employment programs, but on what its administration of the program. scale. The Task Force has previously rec­ knowledge and experimenting with new ap­ On the negative side, the administration ommended a public service employment pro­ proaches are high risk activities where fail­ was responsible for cutting back badly gram providing work for one quarter of the ures are more likely than successes. Yet, needed budgetary support for manpower unemployed above 4.5 percent, with an auto­ there is no other road to progress. Continued services as well as community antipoverty matic "trigger" releasing funds for use in research into improving productivity and agencies which had gained valuable experi- depressed local labor markets as national labor market efficiency is an indirect but not October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36139 unimportant weapon against both unem­ portion of the population, however, the Phyllis Wallace, Massachusetts Institute ployment and inflation. choice is not work or welfare, but work and of Technology. THE LONG-TERM CHALLENGES welfare. The need is to provide income sup­ Robert Taggart, Executive Director. In addition to pressing immediate needs, plements to the working poor with a decent longer-range challenges also cannot be ig­ support for all at a level which is com­ nored. The American people, guided by (or patible with an afl.luent society. guiding) every administration since World A MANPOWER AGENDA HUMANITIES ENDOWMENT'S War II, have made Herculean efforts to up­ In summary, this is no time to slacken "COURSES BY NEWSPAPER" grade the quality of the nation's human re­ human resource development efforts nor to sources. That expenditures on education visit the costs of anti-lnfl.ation efforts upon have risen from $6 billion to over $100 billion those who have been less the villains and a year is only one gross indicator of those more the victims than others. Despite the HON. JOHN BRADEMAS efforts. With a ve..st deficit in human resource occasional stumblings of trial and error OF INDIANA development stemming from a severe depres­ and fl.uct"Uations in commitment, the man­ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES sion and a major war, followed by a rapidly power experience overall has been one of changing technology, the corrective action persistent progress. That progress should Thursday, October 17, 1974 was timely and positive. As a result, no per­ continue with: sistent skill shortages remained even during 1. Augmentation of decentralized planning Mr. BRADEMAS. Mr. Speaker, as the the tight labor markets in the past decade. and administrative capabilities under federal chairman of the Select Education Sub­ In the 1970s clrcumstances have changed, policy guidance. committee, which has jurisdiction over and imbalances in the supply of and demand 2. Compassionate efforts to promote self­ the National Foundation on the Arts and for skilled and highly-educated manpowe!l support methods of income maintenance, the Humanities Act, I want to bring to are becoming a more and more frequent combining, where necessary, work with wel­ the attention of my colleagues the occurrence. In a society where freedom of oc­ fare, rather than treating the two as sep­ Courses by Newspaper program sup­ cupational choice is an unchallenged right, arate systems. ported by the National Endowment for planning and information are needed to 3. Priority of improving the employability guide human resource investments in order and employment opportunities for those fac­ the Humanities. to maintain a balance between supply and ing disadvantages in their competition for The programs makes available, demand and to avoid wasteful surpluses or jobs. through 200 newspapers, weekly 1,500- shortages. 4. Vigorous antidiscrimination enforce­ word lectures by a faculty of nationally Accompanying that investment in human ment. and internationally known scholars. It resource development was the challenge of 5. Long-range investment in human re­ is estimated that the newspapers reach absorbing into the work force the swelllng source development including early and re­ 20 million Americans, and that 15 mil­ cohort of youths, the product of the high current career education for t~.dults as well as postwar birth rates. That group has now youths. lion of them have read one or more of passed through the years of formal educa­ 6. Expansion of public service employment the lectures. tion. Continual improvements in the qual­ as both a countercyclical tool to protect the In addition, Mr. Speaker, 180 colleges ity of preparation given youth for produc­ unemployed and as a transitional process for and universities last year ofi'ered credit tive lives will be needed, but the quantifiable the disadvantaged. for successfully passing a test based on challenge is a declining one. However, hu­ 7. Continued emphasis on training andre­ the full 18-week lectures, and almost man resource development needs do not end training during the recession to take advan­ tage of immediate lower costs and to spark 5,000 students enrolled for credit. with a high school or college diploma. M1·. Speaker, the Courses by News­ Whether because of changing technology productivity during recovery. and social priorities or due to the changing 8. Search for other opportunties to in­ paper program was conceived of last occupational preferences of maturing work­ crease productivity and reduce labor costs. year as a pilot program involving five ers, a need for institutional facilities to 9. Research into labor market behavi-or and newspapers and five colleges and uni­ provide recurrent education-upgrading and institutions. versities. mid-career changes-will be a continuing 10. Most of all, recognition that the cur­ But the response has been extraor­ challenge in which the efforts of individuals, rent inflation did not start in the labor dinary, leading to the involvement of public institutions, and employing organi­ market and cannot be cured there. 180 institutions of higher education and zations must join. Opening second or sub­ These general principles, 1mplemented pro­ sequent careers and other productive out­ gramatically based on a dozen years of ex­ 200 newspapers such as the Decatur lets for the persisting energies of the longer­ perience with manpower policy, can, we are Ala., Daily; the Honolulu Advertiser; th~ lived population and assuring that educa­ convinced, contribute both to short-run Elkhart, Ind., Truth, in my own con­ tionally disadvantaged people are not left problem solution and long-run national gressional district; the Boston Globe; out, are parts of that same challenge. progress. They can be the basis of wise man­ the McGuire, N.J., Airtides and others. In the long run., increased productivity is power policy for a new administration. Because this important program, sup­ the major route to raising living standards. The National Manpower Policy Task Force is a private nonprofit organization of aca­ ported by the National Endowment for Much has been learned by employers about the Humanities, will be of interest to motivating employees, but Ut~le oi lt has demic manpower experts. It is devoted to been applied in public policy. The new career the promotion of research in manpower pol~ every Member of Congress. I insert, at education emphasis relating schooling to ley. This statement represents the combined this point in the RECORD, a description work can be expanded for adults as well as judgment of the Task Force members. De­ of the Courses by Newspaper program children and youth. Areas of particularly spite divergence of opinion on details, the from the September 30 Chronicle of slow productivity growth can also be iden­ members agreed to a unanimous statement Higher Education: without indicating individual exceptions. tified and attacked. "COURSES BY NEWSPAPER" STARTS ITS SECOND TASK FORCE MEMBERSHIP As another ever-present long-range chal­ YEAR lenge, we always have the poor with tis. Sar A. Levitan, Chairman, The George Manpower programs have helped many in­ Washington University. (By Beverly T. Watkins) dividuals to surmount the handicaps they Curtis C. Aller, San Francisco State Uni­ Readers of some 200 newspapers will have have faced in job market competition, but versity. an· opportunity this week to brush up on someone is always at the end of the line. Rashi Fein, Harvard University. their American history-for college credit if The task of helping them is a never-ending, Frederick H. Harbison, Princeton Univer­ they wish-as "Courses by :r;ewspaper" begins but an essential one. Current efforts to im­ sity. its second year. prove the efficacy of the remedial manpower Myron L. Joseph, Carnegie-Mellon Univer­ Part of a projected trilogy keyed to the system which evolved over the last decade sity. forthcoming Ametican Bicentennial, the should not obscure its fundamental mis­ Charles C. Killingsworth, Michigan State 1974-75 course, "In Search of th.>· American sion-to provide a helping hand to those University. Dream," will offer 18 "lectures'' through both who are failing in or being failed by the Juanita M. Kreps, Duke University. dally and weekly newspapers nationwide. labor market. Garth L. Mangum, The University of Utah. The first course, the 20-week "America and ·Finally, there remains the challenge to Ray Marshall, University of Texas. the Future of Man," had appeared in 273 design a system that would provide ade­ S. M. Miller, Boston University. newspapers by the time the 1973-74 academic Charles A. Myers, Massachusetts Institute year ended. quately for those who cannot support them­ of Technology. Some 126 institutions, including two-year selves, but without destroying incentives for R. Thayne Robson, The University of Utah. and four-year colleges, universities, and col­ the able-bodied to contribute to their own Philip Rutledge, Howard University. lege extension programs. wlll offer academic maintenance. Work and welfare have typi­ Gerald G. Somers, :University of Wisconsin. credit for the second course. Almost 5,000 cally been portrayed as mutually exclusive Lloyd mman, University of California, students enrolled last year Bit the 180 Institu­ alternatives. For an increasingly large pro- Berkeley. tions that offered credit. 36140 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974

SUPPLEMENTARY LEARNING KIT ica. and the Future of Man," which was sec­ The same apparently cannot be said Courses by Newspaper, developed and co­ ond in popularity only to "Dear Abby." for the U.S. taxpayers since the Frank­ ordinated by the extension division of the Although no figures are available on the lin National fiasco has reportedly now University of California. at San Diego, ofi'ers number of students who actually received cost $100 million and is expected to even weekly 1,500-word lectures by a. "faculty" of credit for the first course, 1,769 took a. dUll­ cult 30-item multiple-choice final examina­ go higher. nationally known scholars to newspaper stu­ In May of this year the Federal Re­ dents numbering 1n the millions. If they wish, tion. Some traveled many miles to complete readers may purchase a supplementary it. serve Banking system, in a futile attempt learning kit that includes an extensive "We had one student who went from Jack­ to bail out Franklin National reportedly reader, a. study guide, and self-tests. son Hole (Wyo.) to Salt Lake City and an­ agreed to loan it up to $1.1 billion at its " 'In Search of the American Dream,' will other from Nova. Scotia to the University of "discount" window. focus on the persistence ... of the utopian Massachusetts," said Mr. Lewis. In the meantime as the national debt spirit that animated this country's begin­ The overwhelming response to Courses by grows-now estimated at public and pri­ ning,'' according to Robert C. Elliott, pro­ Newspaper has caused the project some trou­ ble. vate to be $2¥2 trillion-our inflation in­ fessor of literature at the university and creases and other American banking in­ academic coordinator of the program. Course "We definitely underestimated the prob­ content will span American history from lems involved in matching newspapers and terests are overextended, the American "Columbus Discovers Utopia," the first lec­ colleges," said JaneL. Scheiber, editorial di­ people are told that we must continue ture, through "Crisis and Continuity: the rector and assistant director for the project. our bankrupt foreign policies of sharing 20th century" and "Now and History," the Under the plan, the first newspaper in any our food, energy and credit with all the concluding le~ures. city to apply for the course receives the ex­ world. The authors, in addition, to Mr. Elliott, clusive right to it for that area. This ar­ Recently the East German Communist rangement has caused some friction within who wrote the introdu~lon and first lecture, party leaders in gaining diplomatic rec­ include Winthrop Jordan, University of Call­ the Copley News Service, which distributes ognition from our Government, advised forma., Berkeley; Michael Kammen, Cornell the lectures, according to Ms. Scheiber. University; William Goetzmann, University The large institutional response meant that they are looking forward to most of Texas; Jay Martin, University of Califor­ that "we faced four to five times as many favored nation trading status with our nia. at Irvine; and Robert Penn Warren, Yale colleges as we could accommodate," said Ms. country. This means not only the ad­ University. Scheiber. "We tried to go with the land grant vantage of a devalued U.S. dollar, but also The project to distribute college-level ma­ institutions where we could," she said, "but on subsidized credit terms cheaper than terial through the country's most widely we sometimes had trouble recruiting the any American can obtain. read medium almost overwhelmed its de­ right college for the newspaper." Today we are advised that Treasury velopers with its success last year, according "The biggest mistake,'' acording to Mr. Lewis, was limiting participation to four-year Secretary Simon in Moscow is proposing to Caleb A. Lewis, director of media. programs most favored nation trading status and at the University of California at San Diego's institutions. "We wanted to keep the course extension division and project director for at an upper-division-equivalent level to credits with the Soviets. the newspaper courses. make it consistent across the country. If Soon there must be a day of reckoning An evaluation of the 1973-74 program by someone wanted to transfer units from the with -~he share-the-wealth policies of the a researcher at California. State University, University of Tennessee to Oregon, they'd one-worlders and the domestic crisis of San Diego, revealed that more than 75 per be talking about the same thing," he said. the American people being understood by cent of the potential readers had read some But intense pressure from junior and com­ all. The Franklin National Bank incident of the lectures. munity colleges, plus the fact that four-year should remind us that the foreigners are For all its success, however, Courses by colleges offered the course for lower-division, not only rapidly getting control of our Newspaper has not been without problems. upper-division, and eve·1 graduate credit­ And, although it has benefited from its ex­ and some senior high schools picked it up food and money, but now they are even perience, the project faces a dilemma this for honors progr:..ms--prompted Mr. Lewis taking over our banking institutions. year that may not be easily resolved. to reverse that decision. This year "the jun­ I insert the related news clippings Courses by Newspaper, financed by the ior colleges are as welcome as anyone," he following my remarks: National Endowment for the Humanities said. [From the Washington Post, Oct. 17, 19741 Ironically, a new problem unique to the with additional support last year from the BANKRUPTCY PETITION FILED BY FRANKLIN Exxon Education Foundation, was developed medium now faces Courses by Newspaper. primarily for those who don't participate in "The newsprint shortage has caused a NEw YoRK, October 16.-Franklin New York higher education, according to Mr. Lewis. downswing in the number of papers partici­ Corp., the holding company that used to "We wanted to reach those who aren't in­ pating this year," said Mr. Lewis, who esti­ control Franklin National Bank, filed for volved because education is unavailable; mated a drop of about 75 and a proportional bankruptcy in Federal District Court here those who are afraid of education because of drop in readers. today. some past experience or because they feel it However, if Courses by Newspaper is The holding company's chief asset was the funded for its third year as originally stock of the bank which was declared in­ is all beyond them because [they feel] they solvent on Oct. 8 by federal banking author­ are so stupid,'' he said. planned, Mr. Lewis expects "participation to double in all areas." ities. At that time, most of the bank's assets PROJECT EXPANDS GREATLY "Newspapers are evaluating the course were sold to European-American Bank & What was conceived as a modest undertak­ now," he said. "Some are taking full-column Trust Co., which is owned by six large Euro­ ing to expose the unexposed to higher educa­ ads asking their readers if they want it again pean banking concerns. tion exploded into a project that also in­ They're surprised at the response-not th~ An attorney speaking for the holding com­ volved people with formal higher education size of it but the intensity. Those who want pany said the papers were filed this morning but no degree, degree-holders, senior-high­ it, want it badly," he said. at 10. He said it was "a voluntary petition in school students, and even some university bankruptcy." graduate students. Officials of Manufacturers Hanover Trust The pilot study planned for five selected Co., which is known to have loaned Franklin newspapers and five matching colleges ex­ New York Corp. $30 million earlier this year panded into a project that included such FOREIGNERS TAKE OVER U.S. BANK before Franklin National Bank's troubles diverse papers as the Decatur (Ala.) Daily, were made public, couldn't be reached for Denver Post, Honolulu Advertiser, Elkhart, comment on the latest Franklin development. (Ind.) Truth, Boston Globe, McGuh·e (N.J.) HON. JOHN R. RARICK (Another large creditor listed in the papers Airtides, Kansas City Star, Tullahoma OF LOUISIANA is Morgan Guaranty Trust Co., acting for (Tenn.) News, and the Seattle Post-Intelli­ some of its customers.) gence?', plus nearby colleges. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES At the end of the year, 4,974 people had Thursday, October 17, 1974 enrolled for credit at participating colleges (From the Wall Street Journal, May 23, 1974] and an additional 6,630 had purchased the Mr. RARICK. Mr. Speaker, the Frank­ FED'S LENDING TO FRANKLIN NATIONAL BANK learning kit at $10. lin National Bank of New York upon Is ABOUT $1.1 BILLION, A HIGII FOR SUCH Following a telephone survey of news­ being declared bankrupt on October 8, AID paper subscribers in five cities-San Diego, has been taken over by six European (By Edward P. Foldessy) Denver, Shreveport, La., and Huron and banking concerns and is operating as the NEw YoRK.-Franklin National Bank's bor­ Chamberlain, S.D.-Oscar J. Kaplan, director European-American Bank & Trust Co. rowings from the Federal Reserve System of the Center for Survey Research at San have reached about $1.1 billion. Diego State, estimated that of the potential Apparently, the transfer was so smoothly Neither thhe bank, a subsidiary of Frank­ 20 million readers nationwide, 15 million had engineered by the Federal Reserve and lin New York Corp., nor the Fed would con­ read one or more of the lectures. The poll banking interests that the bank was open firm the figure, a record in terms of Fed aid showed that 35 per cent of Chamberlain the next morning with the same employ­ to a troubled bank. In the middle of last Register readers and 27 per cent of Huron ees and the depositors did not lose a week, the level of Franklin's Fed borrowings Daily Plainsman subscribers had read "Amer· permy. was around $750 million. October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36141 The $1.1 billion figure, obtained from usu­ (From the New York Times, May 13, 1974] From 1934 until last year, the FDIC paid ally reliable sources, represents about a quar­ RESERVE COMMENTS ON BANK CASE out $903 million to 502 banks that failed (or . ter of the bank's. deposits and borrowings WASHINGTON .-The following iS the text Of were forced into shotgun mergers). But that from all sources. money was not lost. In retur~ for its It was learned yesterday that officials of a statement made today in response to in­ largesse, the FDIC acquires some or all of the Federal Reserve' Bank of New York have quiries about the Franklin National Bank by the assets of the failed bank. This year, for been asking other large New York banks to George W. Mitchell, vice chairman of the example, it has become the lucky owner not resume "normal banking relationships" with board of Governors of the Federal Reserve only of stocks and bonds but apartment Franklin National to the extent that they System: houses, cattle ranches, hotels and even a "Inquiries have been raised in recent days fishing fleet. ca~he reserve bank has been noting that about the position o! Franklin National over time, the FDIC sells these assets and Franklin is solvent according to the U.S. Bank. The bank has reported a poor earnings even may make a profit on them. Since 1934, Comptroller of the Currency and that the record recently, and the management of the it has recovered $779 million of the $903 Fed itself has been lending funds to the controlling holding company announced Fri­ million it dispensed. That's a total loss of •. troubled bank. day that it would recommend that the regu­ only $124 million over 40 years. Its average On May 10, Franklin New York announced lar dividend payment on both comomn and annual profit on investments (mostly U.S. plans to skip dividends on its common and preferred stock be passed. The board is fa­ government securities, once the ranches and preferred stocks because of poor earnings. miliar with this situation and looked care­ fishing :fleets are sold) comes to $400 million. Later it disclosed a large loss in its foreign fully at the bank's condition in connection The FDIC could save other Franklin Na­ exchange department that it said was caused with the proposed acquisition of Talcott Na­ tionals out of profits alone. by unauthorized dealings by one of its tional Corporation by the bank's holding Whenever a bank has failed, the FDIC has traders. company. Its decision earlier this month was paid off within days, on all accounts up to Franklin currently is adjusting its pre­ to turn down this proposal in part because the ins~red limit. Subsequently, the bank's viously reported first quarter earnings, partly it felt that management's energy should be assets have been liquidated in such a way to reflect the trading losses. But according to devoted to the remedial program for the that 93 per cent of the uninsured deposits some sources, the restatement may go well bank, which is now underway. also were paid back. beyond the foreign exchange losses and show "There is, of course, the possibility that­ The books of the FSLIC tell a similar a sharp net loss for the period. The restate­ with many rumors about the bank-Frank­ story. In 40 years, some 103 savings and ment is expected to be made public either lin National may experience some unusual loans have failed or needed financial aid, today or tomorrow. liquidity pressures in the period ahead. As for a total booked loss so far of $167 million. Franklin originally reported first quarter with all member banks, the Federal Reserve Reserves now stand at $6.6 billion. Its record operating net of 582,000, or two cents a share, System stands prepared to advance funds for helping depositors coulq.n•t be much bet­ down 83% from $3.6 million, or 68 cents a to this bank as needed, within the limits ter; the FSLIC says that no one has ever lost share, a year earlier. At the time, it said in­ of the collateral that can be supplied. Work­ a nickel in an insured S & L, even on ac­ come from foreign exchange trading in the ing with Franklin National, the Federal Re­ counts larger than $20,000. quarter rose $2.3 million from the year­ serve Bank of New York has determined that A bill that went to the President for earlier period. there is a large amount of acceptable col­ signature Oct. 10 would raise the amount Franklin has had to borrow from the Fed lateral available to support advances to the of insured savings from $20,000 to $40,000. because of its difficulties in obtaining funds bank from the Federal Reserve Discount That means that, if your thrift institution from normal channels. But the loans from window if they are needed. got into trouble, up to $40,000 in each ac­ the Fed have had a beneficial side effect: As a matter of general policy, the Federal count would be paid off in a matter of days. batgain basement prices for the borrowed Reserve makes credit extensions to member If you had an individual account, a joint money. banks, upon acceptable collateral, so long as account with a spouse, a trust account and In borrowing from the Fed, Franklin pays the borrowing member bank is solvent. We a joint account with a parent you'd be en­ an 8 % annual rate of interest (the Federal are assured by the Comptroller of the Cur­ titled to up to $40,000 on ~ach of them. Reserve's discount rate) on loans backed by rency that Franklin National Bank is a sol­ Eventually, you'd also get back most of your vent institution. el,igible and acceptable collateral, such ~s savings over $40,000. But a better idea is to Chairman Burns, who is in Europe, has U.S. governme~t se~urities. An 8% % rate 1s keep excess savings in a different institu­ paid on advances backed by other types of been kept informed of developments. Since tion. Then you're insured in both places. collateral, including long-term municipal this matter does not require his personal But check to see that your savings are securities, mortgages and long-term corporate attention, he has no intention of changing indeed insured by a state or federal agency. loans. · his travel plans which call for his return to A few states still permit banks and S & Ls By contrast, the cost of funds in the open Washingt on later this week. to operate without government backing. money market recently has hovered in the With financial conditions so uncertain 11% to ·12% range. Thus, on $1.1 billion, (From the Washington Post, Oct. 17, 1974] there's no sense taking that risk. Franklin stands to save from $500,000 to How U.S. INSURANCE SETUP SAFEGUARDS $750,000 a week in interest costs over wh~t YoUR SAVINGS (From the Washington Post, Oot. 17, 1974] it would bave to pay in the open market 1f (By J ane Bryant Quinn) SIMON BACK FROM: TALKS IN U.S.S.R. it were able to tap that source. NEw YoRK.-Surprising numbers of other­ President Ford will decide on whether to The Fed hasn't publicly specified the wise prudent people have taken to storing allow a suspended multimillion-dollar Soviet amount of funds it stands ready to inject cash in safe deposit boxes. They're willlng grain deal to go ahead after being briefed into Franklin or the amount of collateral to forgo the interest that cash might earn by Treasury Secretary William E. Simon, who Frankltn has available for such purposes. because they think that savings accounts has just returned from Moscow. On May 12 the Fed said the bank had a "large aren't safe. Simon spoke briefly to reporters on his amount of acceptable collateral available to Yet, in the largest U.S. banking failure ret urn from a four-day visit for economic support advances." At the time the Federal to date-the collapse of New York City's Reserve said that it could make loans to any talks with Soviet officials. Franklin National Bank-depositors didn't He said he had full and frank discussions solvent bank and that the U.S. Comptroller lose a penny. The government engineered an of the Currency had found Franklin to be wit h the Soviet leaders, including the agree­ overnight sale of the bank's assets to the ment reached by two grain companies to solvent. , According to sources, the Federal Reserve s European-American Bank, which opened for sell some 3.4 million tpns of corn and wheat request that bankers resume normal activi­ business the next morning with the same to the Soviet Union. ties where possible with Franklin hasn't re­ doorkeepers and the same tellers. President Ford blocked the $500 million ceived much response. At least two banks So far, the ~ranklin National disaster has transaction earlier this month, principally have turned down the request almost ou t of cost the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. because fears of domestic shortages follow­ hand, they said. $100 milllon. That sum will go much higher, ing a particularly bad summer had pushed Originally, reports circulated that t he Fed but the FDIC now has reserves of $5.8 bil­ up prices to a point where they threatened to was waging an arm-twistin g campaign to lion, plus another $3 billion line of Treasury worsen inflation. have banks resume so-called federal funds credit. Simon said he would discuss the matter trading with Franklin. Federal funds are un­ It's possible that, in the year ahead, other with Mr. Ford. But, he added, "The President committed reserves banks lend each other. poorly managed banks will buckle under the must make the decision." But sources within the Fed said the reserve's weight of bad loans. But the government suggestion to bankers was broader; involving can handle it. Here's the background on the [From the Washington Post, Oct. 17, 1974] all t ypes of interba nk relationships. insurance system that protects your savings: SIMON ENDS TALKS IN MOSCOW ON TRADE Fed sources stated that the reserve bank The FDIC a.nd its sister insurer, the Federal Moscow, October 16.-Secretary of the in each case reminded bankers of their Savings and Loan Insurance Corp., were Treasury· William E. Simon said today the legal responsibilities to their own share­ born in the Depression. Their task was to U.S. government shares Soviet Communist holders and depositors, and, in effect, cau­ rebu ild America 's confidence in the bank­ Party leader Leonid Brezhnev's desire to re­ tioned them to enter only those kinds of ing system by gua ranteeing every depositor solve trade problems between the two coun­ transactions that would be considered pru­ that the first $2,500 of his savings would be tries. dent for the benefit of their banks' depositors as safe as the U.S. Treasury. Since then, the Simon spoke with newsmen at the airport and shareholders. insured amount has risen to $20,000. before he left for Washington after two days 36142 ·EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 of talks wlth Soviet oftlclals, including tossing down slugs of vodka. They are play­ admitted. "We sit around in our apartment- Brezhnev. ing cards-loudly-and telllng war stories-­ . me, my husband, my parents, maybe an aunt At a banquet ending the talks last night, more loudly still. A man, the husband of one and uncle-and everybody is looking at Kolya the Soviet party chief made a hard-line of them, enters wearing an apron, carrying a (age 8]. 'What's new with you, Kolya?' 'How's speech in whlch he said the Soviet Union's tray full of hot cups of tea. life, Kolya?' 'What's happening in school, domestic policies were irrelevant to increas­ With nervous, jerky gestures he tries to Kolya?'-That's all you hear for hours at a ing U .a.-Soviet trade. clear empty vodka bottles off the table and time." Slmon told newsmen he did not find the serve the tea. The women start complaining At the opposite extreme is the story told speech surprising. "We share his desire to get to him about the food, the dirty table. He in a woman's letter to the radio program the resolution on MFN and trade," he said. shrugs his shoulders. Finally the guests de­ "Man and Society," perhaps the nearest So­ He was referring to congressional efforts to cide it is time to go home. The husband viet equivalent to a personal advice column. deny the Soviet Union "m08t favored nation" fetches their coats and boots. "My life has been a nightmare," the woman trading status and credits until the Kremlin When her pals are gone the man's wife wrote from Maga.dan, a remote corner of eases emigration restrictions which are ap­ throws her arms around hlm drunkenly. Eastern Siberia not far from Alaska. "I got plied mainly to SoViet Jews. "Don't touch mel" he shouts. She responds married in 1946, and hoped to raise a happy indignantly. "Whatsa matter, doncha think family.•.. " Her first son was born in 1947 [From the Washington Star-News, OCt. 14, I can drink? I drink on my own money, you and-"perhaps to celebrate this event," her 1974] know ..." husband took a drink of vodka that was his Speaking of money, the husband com­ downfall. A lifetime of drinking followed. U.S. DEBT OF $2.5 TRILLION HELD ECONOMY "Our family survived extreme material diffi­ THREAT plains, she doesn't give him enoug!h house­ keeping money to do the shopping. She culties, since more than half our income was NEW YoaK.-The total debt of every seg­ brushes him aside . . . spent on vodka." ment of American society has swelled to $2.5 Difficult to imagine? For a Soviet audience Finally, after 21 years of marriage, she and trUlion and poses a serious threa,t to the na­ her three children decided to throw him out tion's economy in this inflationary period, watching a group of comedians acting it out, of the house. To get away from him com· Business Week magazine says in its latest this scene 1s hysterically implausible. The pletely they went to Magadan. Papa stayed edition. theater rocks with laughter. The audience in the industrial city where they'd lived, still "'Never has the debt economy seemed more obviously loves the mirror image of Soviet drinking. He remarried, then divorced, then VUlnerable, with a distressing number of bor­ family life that the comedians crea,te. moved in with another woman. Several years Reality, as one of the comedians explains rowers and lenders in precarious shape," the ago he had a stroke, which lef·t hlm para­ magazine said. in an introduction to the skit, is different: lyzed. Learning of this, mother and children Since the close of World War II, the nation Papa comes home from work and reads the decided to invite hlm back. has borrowed an average net of $200 million paper. Mama comes home from work and goes "He getting better now," the woman wrote. a day, the magazine said. shopping, makes supper, does the laundry "He's back at work, and most important, he Now the debt ts so huge that it would take and ironing, and helps the chlldren with isn't drinking any spirits. But life has already more than one-third the gross nation&l prod· their homework. Sometimes, papa helps out passed us by. We can't repeat our youth .•."' uct of Japan, the world's second-largest capi· after dinner by turning on the television set. Alcoholism is a perpetual epidemic in this talist economy, just to pay this year's interest In Russia, "A good wife doesn't let her hus­ society. There are no published statistics on on the American debt, the magazine said. band help her keep house. She keeps it clean the consumption of vodka or the prevalence Of the total debt, $1 trillion Ls in corpo­ hersel·f, sews and weaves for her husband of alcoholt.sm, but evidence of it can be seen rate debt, $600 billion ln mortgage debt, $500 and children. A good wife is always merry­ on the str&elts of any v111age or town. Perhaps bllllon in u.s. government debt, $200 billlon she always smUes and makes her husband's 40 per cent of all divorcea are caused by in state and local government debt, and $200 life easy and pleasant. A g100d wife doesn't drunkenness, 8/CCOrding to sociologists' re­ billlon in consumer debt. interfere in her husband's business talks, and search. Business Week said the debt "is an omi­ in generalis mostly silent." Vodka and wme play an important role in nously heavy burden with the world as it is Well, those were the rules in the 16th cen­ Soviet family life. Wh·at does an ord·lnary today-ravaged by ln:flation, threatened with tury, when this prescription for a good wife worker's family do to celebmte a birthday economic depression, torn apart by the mas­ was written in the "domostroi" or "rules of or a big event? "Buy a bottle of vodka," is sive redistribution of wealth that has ac­ the household" that were then accepted by the most common reply, An enormous Rus­ companied the soaring price of oil." church and state. Though contemporary Rus­ sian woman who works as a janitor confided The magazine said the consensus among sian society has little in common with the that she would need 20 (half pint] bottles economists was that the economy stUl was 15th century, the ln:fluence of the domostrol for the four-day May Day weekend. not overborrowed but the breaking point was is still evident. Family celebrations are likely to happen at drawing near. Yet mama's role ha.s grown enormously, home. Mll11ons of Soviets--very likely the vast "'In the end, the world may very well escape although she continues to act a.s a servant majority-never go to a restaurant. (Restau­ disaster," Business Week wrote, "'but there of the rest of the family. In the 16th century, rants are neither good nor oommon. In Mos­ 18 no way it can escape change. The very as­ papa was the lord of the manor, but today he cow, the best-served clty in the country, there sumptions on which the United States built is much less imposing, and much less influ­ are 127 of them-or one for every 55,000 in· its debt economy, for instance, must be re­ ential. A woman who allows her husband to habitants.) The Russian "talble" for a big thought. Not in the foreseeable future will loaf around the apartment while she does all occasion 1s another of the things Russians any na.tion pile up debt a.s rapidly as this the housework is also-in many ifammes­ love most 8ibout their country. nation." the pUlar of family life and the chief decision Besides vodka, lt wUl be plied h1gh with The magazine said corporations had tripled maker. a dozen different "zakuski" (hors d'oeuvres)e their debt in the past 15 years, and consumer The Russian family is one of the Institu­ from canned sprats in oil to el8iborate Cau-­ debt ha.d soa.red 50 percent in the past three tions that Russians love most about their casian chicken in walnut sauce. The com.­ years. country. In its ideal form. the family is a pany can easily spend an hour or two ovet In a separate article, the magazine says fortress of love and mutual protection whose these washing them down with the toasts tha.t a survey of 550 major nonfinancial cor­ wa.lls shield all within from an uncertain that inevitably accompany the consumption porations found that 23 percent or 114 of outside world. Though reality may seldom of alcohol. the companies as of last June "had &massed live up to these grand intentions, sentimental A soup may follow the zakuskl, and a piece more total debt , , . than they carried in Russians (and that means virtually all of of meat, or perhaps a duck, wlll follow the equity." them) often overlook the family's failures soup. Mama and grandma serve and clear and romanticize its accomplishments. the dishes-none of which match each Modern Soviet society does not challenge other-and yell at the young people to eat traditional family relationships the way the more of everything. Three generations crowd FAMILY LIFE IN RUSSIA fast-paced societies of the industralized West around the table, many sitting on stools, be .. do. There is no sign of the hedonistic lifestyle cause there are never enough chairs, and here: No amusement industry to fill leisure all crowded, be·cause the table is always too HON. LEE H. HAMILTON time, no cult of youth and beauty, no con­ small. The men tell Jokes and give toasts, sumer industry for children or cemeteries for OF INDIANA the girls gossip and tease. pets. The Soviet population is relatively There is no cocktail hour, no coffee in the IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES stable and immobile. drawing room a.fterw.a,rd (there's no dra.wlng Thursday, October 17, 1974 Parents have time for children, and chil­ room), and somehow, it is usually more fun dren for parents. Soviet sociologists claim than any dinner party in Washington or Mr. HAMILTON. Mr. Speaker, under that comparative surveys of Russian and London. the leave to extend my remarks in the Weste1·n families show that a mother or If Soviet society lacks the distra.ctions from RECORD, I include the following: father here is likely to devote more of her or family life typical of Western countries, it SoVIET LIFE ORIENTED TOWARD FAMILY his week to the children than does a Western has substitute distractions of its own. The parent. There are fewer distractions, at least most important of these is the requirement (By Robert G. Kaiser) in the evening and on weekends, and per· that able-bodied women, particularly in the (Washington Post Foreign Service) haps-as many Russians would insist-a city, hold a full-time job. Moscow.-Imagdne a Soviet apartment: greater desire to share the child's life. For some traditionalists, this is an out­ Four women sit around a table, periodically "Sometimes it's silly," one mother recently rage. Alexander I. Solzhenitsyn, the author, October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36143 stated the conservative view of women at ciological studies, but with01At apparent can substitute for the official peri:nlssion to work in his recently publ,ished open letter effect. go abroad. to the Soviet leaders: (There aren't spaces in these resorts for "For many people," a Moscow film director "How can one fa.il to feel shame and com­ even half the population, so many Soviet recently argued, l•money doesn't give satis­ passion at the sight of our women carrying citizens do take their vacations with their faction-it creates difficulties. Spending heavy burrows of stones for paving the families-even if they'd rather not.) money is difficult. street . . . ? When we contempla-te such The question remains what is Russian He explained: A family without preten- scenes, what more is there to say, what doubt family life really like? Hopefully some of the sions can quite easily maintain a simple ca.n there possibly be? Who would hesitate to answers have been included in these articles, life--a basic diet, ordinary clothes worn un­ abandon the financing of South American but a lot of them haven't. For an outsider til threadbare, vodka and television for en­ revolutionaries to free our women from this who has had only a limited opportunity to tertainment. Such families are common. bondage?" see fam1lies at home, many of the answers If a sudden jump in income induces that Old women doing hard physical labor are remain out of reach. family to try to live better, life becomes an embarrassment to many Soviet officials, For an American, it is instructive to refiec't complicated. Any attempt to improve the but the general notion that women should on typical aspects of middle-class American family's diet, for instance, would require a work is not. "The state's interest presupposes life which have no obvious equivalent here. large increase in the amount of time devoted only one decision," Elena Ivanova, a senior The list is long. to shopping. GoOd foods are the hardest to editor of the government newspaper Izvestia There is no family car in the Soviet Union, get, and they attract the longest lines in said recently. "The country needs hands for save in about one in 14 families in Moscow, the shops. work, including women's hands . . ." one in 70 for the country as a whole. There A determined effort to acquire the best To a large extent, women agree. In surveys, is no house, but rather a small apartment for food available in Moscow absorbs hours a half or more of the working women ques­ the luckiest families (in urban areas, about week beyond the time it would take to pur­ tioned regularly sa.y that they work for the half the total), and a room for the others. chase a diet of cheese, salami, bread, cab­ satisfaction and enjoyment, not just for the It is an officially stated goal of Soviet hous- bage and dairy products. money. Mrs. Ivanova points out that 60 per ing policy that every citizen should have his It is no easier to buy clothes. "Some peo­ cent of the college graduates in the country own room in his own apartment, but the goal pie," the movie director sa.id, "can never buy are women. "Do they want to sit at home is· just a distant hope now. a new suit-when they've got the money, and waste their qualifications?" she asked. The consumer goods that set the tone of there are no suits, and when there are suits, ''Of course not." Polls show that the higher American family life don't exist here. There they haven't got the money." Women inter­ a woman's level of edooation, the more she are no cold Cokes in the refrigerator (which ested in acquiring the best Yugoslav or Hun­ wants to work, regardless of the number of is tiny, if it exists), no cartons of milk garian fashions that are sometimes sold here children she has. brought home by the milkman, no garbage must devote hours to scouring the stores and The compromises available to an American disposals or food freezers. collecting inside information: (A tip from a middle-class woman who wants to raise a There is nothing here to compare with the salesgirl about when Polish sweaters are. go­ family and pursue a career are not available organized activities that occupy American ing on sale is worth a week of window-shop­ here. The Soviet economy is rigid, and Soviet children and become the focal points of so ping.) institutions live by a stern rule book. They many families' lives. Schools don't have or- The movie director thinks many people do not believe in women taking 10 years off, ganized athletic teams or--except in special are so put off by these difficulties that they or starting a career at 35, or working part cases--bands or orchestras. Dancing classes, would rather live their simple, subsistence time. Either you work, or you don't. pottery classes, church choirs--none exist. lives. But many Soviet citizens are also will­ The infiexibUity of the system puts a psy­ Nor do part-time jobs for young people. ing to go to whatever lengths are required chological strain on women. As one sociologist Life In the Soviet Union Is quieter, duller · to get more and better consumer goods. The observed recently, Soviet women may start and harder than in the West. It is also more other day a full colonel in the Red Army life on an equal footing with males, study, secure. No one need fear unemployment, in- was seen in Moscow waiting patiently in a begin work and marry on the basis of equal­ fiation or a financially catastrophic 111ness. . long line to buy a pair of Hungarian shoes. ity, but suddenly lose their equality with On the other hand, no one outside a very Money does talk on the Soviet black mar­ the arrival of a child, if not earlier. special elite can realistically hope to visit the kets which seem to b& extensive. In Russian families a child is the mother's Champs Elysees or the canals of Venice. The The term is misleading, for' many "black business, whether or not her job, her house­ state provides, but it also withholds. market" sales are simply unofficial exchanges work and shopping already fill her time. A In the unique environment that Soviet between friends at free market prices. For working woman with a child in this society society has created, family life goes on in six to eight rubles, for instance, qne can has an enormous amount of work-30 hours recognizable patterns. Kids come home from buy a one-ruble coupon valuable in special a week, according to one survey, on top of · school, have something to eat, go out to play. hard-currency shops that sell imported goods. a work week that averages 45 hours including Mothers prepare supper, fathers read the eve- The coupons are sold by people who have­ transportation to and from the job. ning paper, everybody watches television. worked abroad and earned hard currency, or If she _finds a place for her baby in a "We're living well," Russians like to tell each had it sent to them by relatives. nursery or kindergarten, a Soviet woman is other, "Life is good." This winter a pair of foreign-made ladies' still on call in case of illness. Day care cen­ Moscow.-Money-a remnant of capitalism boots on platform soles cost 150 rubles on the ters won't keep a sick baby, for fear others that is supposed to disappear when true com- black market. The prices for foreign-made will catch the illness, so the mother must muntsm is ac~eved-st111 exerts a powerful double-breasted sheepskin coats began at take care of her child at home. (She is given infiuence on daily life in the Soviet Union. 750 rubles. some paid leave from work for. this purpose.) Rubles and kopecks do not have the tyran- The official press periodically reveals that Work discipline is lax in most Soviet fac­ nical power that dollars and cents achieve 1n bribery is a phenomenon of modern Soviet tories and offices. Many women manage to American life, because Soviet society is not life. A man with a wife and daughter, theo­ do errands on office time. "A woman scientist as oriented toward consumption. It couldn't retically entitled to a two-room apartment in our institute is about one-third as produc­ be, since It doesn't prodnce a fraction as could offer the right local official 1,000 rubles tive as a man," a research chemist claimed. many consumer goods. and find himself with three rooms. A man Babysitters are virtually unheard of here. Here the issue is still subsistence, or some- . builqing a cottage in the country might get Either the baby goes out with the adults, thing a little better. The average soviet fam- the lumber he needs with a well-placed "tip" or mama stays home-unless there's a grand­ ily spends its entire income on necessities, in a state construction organization. mother who can be persuaded to look after with little left for frills. A five-ruble bottle Millions of Soviet citizens are prepared to the child. Soviet teenagers don't seem to have of champagne is a grand splurge for many. risk a little money in the hope of malting a the entrepreneurial spirit or the confidence On the other hand, extreme poverty is un- . lot. State sponsored lotteries are popular. So of their elders that would be necessary if usual. is the race track in Moscow, where betting is they were to copy the American babysitting To a foreigner who developed monetary allowed, though the payoffs are miserly. In system. refiexes in the capitalist world, the role of . many offices, t_he female employees, maintain Like most Soviet workers, a working money in Soviet society seems unique-not · a "blaclc cash box" to which each contributes woman is entitled to a month of paid holi­ for what it can do, but for what it cannot. five or ten rubles a month, then takes her day each year. In theory, this vacation could The acquisition of a lot of money does not chance in a winner-take-all drawing. be devoted entirely to the family, and often assure a Soviet family a radical improve- '· The average family lives on a modest it is. But it is common for Soviet parents to ment in its standard of living. Sudden wealth budget. According to published statistics, take separate holidays. This is officially­ would allow a better diet and more clothes, that family (composed of 3.5 people and 1.6 though coincidentally-encouraged. but mere money won't buy a big new apart- wage earners) has a monthly income of Places in trade union sanitoria, rest homes ment, a new car or a summer vacation in about 220 rubles. This is $285 at the ofilcial and resorts-the most sought-after holiday Yugoslavia. exchange rate, but the comparison 1s mis- spots in the Soviet Union-are allocated at . Those things are allocated, not sold. The leading. A small Soviet-made Fiat costs 5,500 work. Unless husband and wife work in the best apartments are assigned to Communist rubles. A pound of tomatoes in the farmers' same place, they cannot expect to get spaces Party officials and other influential citizens. market may cost four rubles in early spring. in the same resort at the same time. So they The opportunity to buy a new car is sim- According to the book "Family Needs and often go off alone at different times of the ilarly distributed as a privilege. Foreign travel Income," published here in 1967, a well-bal­ year. The effect of this on family life has been ls .the rarest--and thus the most coveted- anced, nutritional diet costs ·about 50 rubles repeatedly criticized in the press and in so- pnvilege of all, and no amount of money per person per month. Thus the typical fam- 36144 . EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 1ly woUld have to spend 175 rubles a month with a .:Solemn Mass of Thanksgiving in the as your •retarded' bishop. I a.m able to look on food, were it to eat that well. In fact. modified Gothic-style church at 3815 Russell back and say these have been good years." he most famutes seem to spend 40 to 60 per cent Road. said. "All through the years St. Rita's has . of their cash income on f~. and settle for Memories were ·evoked for the parishioners been a wonderful parish. I hope that it wm something less than the ideal diet. from the first moment of the entrance pro- continue to be even though. we are 'sepa­ Another 10 to 20 per cent goes for rent, gas cession, for along with their new Blsb.op of rated' brethren." he said, referring to the divi­ and electricity. (Rents are heavily subsidized Arlington, Bishop Thomas J. Welsh, who was sion of the diocese of Richmond. "Down in by the state.) making his first visit to their church, were 'the holy city,' we miss you," he concluded, That leaves the average family with, say, familiar faces which had come and gone over "but we pray that God will bless your new . 50 to 100 rubles a month for clothing, trans- · the years, their former bishop, two former bishop and wlll bless you." portation, entertainment, medicines (which pastors, former associates and two former Continuing the jocular tone of Bishop · are only part1a1ly paid for by the state med- deacons, now ordained; Sisters of St. Joseph Russell's remarks, Bishop Welsh told him, ical system) and incidentals. Thus a basic who had long taught in the parish school, "We're glad to have you back and hope you item like a 200-ruble television set will ab- and lectors. Later some lay members of the have no trouble at the border." To the peo­ sorb all the family's spending money for two community who had a long history in the ple of St. Rita's he said, "No amount of or three months. church, some as charter members of the little searching had found any substitute for a Wealthier people-members of the Soviet community who first met in a cobbler's shop parish. This celebration, this jubilee," he middle class-have family incomes of 350 to in 1913, and then the little church in Mt. said, "represents a great continuity of priests 600 rubles a month, which leave them a little Id.a, a mission of St. Mary's built in 1914, and people, and a spiritual continuity. more flexibility. A chemist and his wife who were to form the offertory procession. "The Church," he sa.ld, "has been caught make 500 rubles a month say they spend at Bishop Welsh was the principal celebrant up in the acceleration of change, as wen. least 220 on food for themselves and two at the Mass which combined tolk music and But there is one thing that does not·die, and sons. The rest goes on ordinary expenditures, Latin hymns, and he was fla.n.ked by retired that is the devotion to the saints of the "and we never have anything left at the end Bishop John J. Russell of Richmond and places where we worship." He spoke of the of the month." their pastor, Father Fra.nois L. Bradican. "downgrading of devotion to the Blessed Other middle-class families invest in the seated in a place of honor in the sanctuary Mother. I don't know quite what was behind status symbols of contemporary Moscow- was Msgr. Leonard J. Koster, first pastor of it," he said, "but we stand in need of the antique furniture (which was scorned just a St. Rita's when it was elevated to parish kind of continuity that you have had in your few years ago), old jewelry, china, crystal and status in 1924, now pastor-emeritus of St. parish of St. Rita. There hasn't been any real carpets. Charles, Arlington. change," he said. ''Thoughts have been up~ Some people save money, too. Soviet sav- Father Edward P. Browne, pastor trom dated, but real theologians are a.s true today lngs banks (which pay 2 per cent interest) 1967-72, in his homily traced the history of to patron saints and especially to the Blessed have deposits of about 70 b1llion rubles, an St. Rita's, but said, "If you talk only ab0u1i Mother as they ever were. Pope John, who average of 280 rubles per man, woman and the buildings, you're not ta.lk1ng abOut a gave us the Vatican Council, said 15 decades chlld in the country. This appears to be parish. A parish 1s most of all the people,.. of the Rosary a day," he said, "and the Coun· ra.tny day money. When asked, most people he said, "and the priests who spree.d. the gas­ ell wrote at great length about the Blessed express surprise at the size of personal sav- pels and help to build community. We have Mother, more than any other Council. When ings, and claim they themselves spend all been blessed with a good, dedicated, zealous Pope Paul closed the Council, he gave Mary they earn. One explanation for these sav• priesthood, varied in talent, varied in virtue, one more name-'Mother of the Church.' lngs is that many people cannot find the but one in dedication to the people. My life This is not ancient history," the Bishop said, products they would happily buy, U they were with the people of St. Rita's," he said, "were "this 1s ln recent days. It 1s a crucial fact," available. The waiting time to buy a car among the happiest years of my life because he said, "that from the earliest moments of stretches to several years in many towns. of the people. They are unique," he said, the Church, Mary has been included in es~ Some of these savings undoubtedly belong "because there are chUdren in the echool, sential dogma of the church." to the very rich-a tiny slice of Soviet so- whose parents and grandparents built the ciety, whose lives have little in common with church before them and they are stlll carry­ ordinary citizens'. A couple like Roman ing on. We are indebted to those of the past," Shedrin, the composer, and his wife, Maya he asserted, "and we must continue to build ENVIRONMENTAL PERSPECTIVE Pllsetska.ya, the prima ballerina of the Bot- ourselves, so that we wm have 110methlng to shoi, probably earn several thousand rubles pass on to those in the future. As we cele­ a month-more than a worker can make In brate this Golden Jubilee, ma.y it awaken 1n HON. ROBERT E. JONES a year. They have a large Moscow apartment. us a renewed sense of community and may 071 ALABAMA a foreign car, a big country dacha, hired help, we especially remember Msgr. Emmett P. foreign clothes and much more that ordinary Gallagher." (Msgr. Gallagher, who died 1n IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Russians never even dream of. 1968, had become pastor in 1947 and had Thursday, October 17, 1974 overseen the buUding of the presen-t church and school complex.) "l.st us pray for the Mr. JONES of Alabama.. Mr. Speaker, future," Father Browne concluded, ..that the quality of the environment is of prop­ ST. RITA'S GOLDEN JUBll.JEE God w111 bless St. Rita's with many young er concern to each citizen. The concern CELEBRATED men and women who will dedicate them• is reflected 1n the great volwne of IegtsM selves as priests and Sisters." Bearing the gifts at the Offertory were lation introduced in the Congress each HON. STANFORD E. PARRIS five parishioners, whose family roots go deep session with the objective of improving in the church's history, Mrs. Catherine Cou­ the quality of life available to the peo­ OF VIRGINIA sins, Anthony Glammlttarlo, Miss Frances ple of the Nation. I N THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES Conlon, Miss Mary Conlon, and Miss Camille The intensity of concern can some­ Thursday, October 17, 1974 DeLane, first organist of the original church. times cause loss of perspective on the It was a happy, ebullient crowd of 250 distance the Nation already has traveled Mr. PARRIS. Mr. Speaker, this year which gathered later for a reception and toward the common goal of a better en­ St. Rita's Church in Alexandria.. Va., is dinner at the round, red-covered tables at vironment. celebrating its 50th anniversary as a the Ramada Inn on North Fairfax Street. A A refreshing examination of the eco­ parish. Sunday, October 20, the cor­ string trio circulated throughout the room on playing "requests'' and Bishop Russell dis­ logical situ~tion has been published 1n nerstone from the original church bulld­ played a fine tenor as he joined in "Santa the Huntsville, Ala., Times by the asso­ ing will be relaid next to the cornerstone Lucia.," and Father Bradican in "Galway ciate editor, Mr. Bob Ward, from a.n inM in the present church. Bay." For Bishop Welsh there was the "Penn­ tervlew with a farmer in north Ala;bama, For the interest of my colleagues, I sylvania Polka.." Mr. Holland Baker. would like to insert at this point 1n the Father Bradican spoke of his pride 1n St. Mr. Baker's thoughtful comments and RECORD a recent news article describing Rita's, and thanked all the laity who had helped "to make it what it 1s" as well as Mr. Ward's skillful presentation of the the golden jubilee celebration. It fs my the Sisters of St. Joseph for their work in views are most worthwhile and I include understanding that it is the Intent of the the parLsh school. He paid tribute to the them as a. part of my remarks so that parish to place a copy of today's CoN­ former pastors and "especially Msgr. Gallag­ others may appreciate this fresh per­ GRESSIONAL RECORD with other memora­ her, who set us up and got us started. We spective: bilia of church history under the corner­ shall work unitedly for the good of the par­ ENVIRONMENTAL PERSPECTIVE: ONE MAN'S ish to help each other and make it one of the VIEW OF How BAD IT IsN'T stone. finest in the diocese," he told his people. A LEXANDRIA PARISHIONERS CELEBRATE ST. Msgr. Koster, first pastor, called "those days (By Bob Ward) RITA'S GOLDEN JUBILEE the happiest of my life. It has always been a At 60 years of age, Holland Baker seems It was a grand night for singing and cele~ family," he said. His final words were drowned a tad too young to be termed an oldtimer. brating as St. Rita's Church of Alexandria out by a standing ovation. Stlll, he likes to talk about how things m-arked "Fifty Golden Years" as a parish Bishop Russell who served as bishop from used to be, back 1n the good old days. last Saturda.y night, the evening beginning 1958-73, said, "I come 1n great, good humor Except, as he remembers them, they were October 17, 1974 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS 36145 the bad old days. But, that is, with respect dries were belching forth thick black smoke coasts during World War II. A lot of that oil to what 1s today lumped under the twin all the time." washed up on our beaches then, but I don't headings of Ecology a.nd 'Ib.e Environment. And then there were the forest and woods know of any lasting ecological damage from What disturbs Baker is the popular view fires. it.'' that the natural environment has reached its "A lot of people out in the country," Baker Baker doesn't have unkind words even for sorriest state ever, that pollution of the ele· recalls, "would set the woods on fire, and just strip-mining. He thinks reclamation of strip­ ments and despoliation of the land have nev· let them burn, and there would be a smoky mined areas would be nice, but he questions er before been so bad. He regards such think· haze all through the air around the moun· its necessity. He lately ·has seen some strip ing a.s alarmist and he blames it on "mass tains here. The farmers did it to improve the ~nes of 30 and 40 years ago and he says: hypnotlsm"-a.nd on ignorance, of past con· browse for their cattle. Well, we don't see .. You can hardly tell what they were, they ditions a.s well a.s present. much of that today. People today think all look almost natural now, mostly grown "It seems like so often some of the best· forest fires are so bad, but the Indians used over-and with no reclamation." educated people are so ignorant on this ecol· to do the same thing and so do foresters It's not that Holland Baker is in favor of ogy thing," says Baker. "I claim the ecology today. environmental damage or pollution. It's is in better shape than it's ever been." "And people now yell about others who that he feels the American public has gained Holland Baker, it should be quickly noted, might burn a pile of leaves in their yard, a "warped view" of our ecological ills from is no ecologist, no certified scientist of any and then these same people turn around "the mass media, especially television.'' kind. He has a small farm on Highway 72 and go inside to build a fire in their fire­ "Things get blown out of proportion and West at Monrovia, to which he ha.s recently places that burns for hours and puts out 10 they get the people 1n a trauma,'' he says. retired after 25 years as a Huntsvllle postal times as much smoke." "It's some kind of mass psychological thing, worker. His own formal education wa.s brief, And consider water pollution. Huntsville mass hypnotism. But most people are better stopping short of high school. But this fath· Spring Branch, for example, decades ago was off today, environmentally as well as ma­ er of two grown children reads a great deal, so filthy it wa.s called-well, ~ Baker deli­ terially, than they ever were. They just don't he is widely traveled, and his first-hand ex· cately explains, it had "the appellation of know it. As old Will Rogers said, 'Everybody's perience with the environment does date a common four-letter word in front of the ignorant, just about different things.' back better than half a century. word 'Creek.' " "I'm for eoology, myself," Farmer Baker He ca.n cite dozens of examples of an en· "They dumped all the sewage of Huntsvllle insists. "If I hadn't been, I sure wouldn't vironment that is today better, not worse, into it," he recalls. "It went all the way to have spent the better part of my life trying than it used to be. the river, just open like that. But that was to make this place better. "'Ib.ink how it was in the 1920s and '30s" nothing unusual back then. Every city be- "I suppose my point is that there is really he says. "To tell you the truth, this whole • tween Asheville, N.C., clean on down and nothing man can do to Nature that, given country-and by that I mean the South• around to Paducah," Ky., at the other end, enough time, Nature can't repair." east-was washed away back then. We had dumped their sewage into the Tennessee No doubt the people living elsewhere to­ forest fires all the time. And about the time River-untreated. And most of them took day near some major rivers and lakes choked trees got big enough to make a stick ot their drinking water from just above where nearly to death with man-made pollutants stovewood, they were chopped down and they dumped their sewage. 'Ib.ey called them­ hope he's right. burned up. selves purifying it before using it, but I don't "Now, I don't go back to the last century, know how much purifying they really did in but my father did-he was born right after those days.'' the Civil War. About the time of the end of Fish and wildlife are other ecological con­ WAYS AND MEANS COMMITTEE that war, this country was used up and worn cerns which Baker mentions. CREATING NEW TAX LOOPHOLES out. It had been 'cottoned to death,' as they "We used to fish on the river a week with­ say." out catching a thing." he remembers. "Now, As one small indicator of how soil condi· after they've built the dams, you can't go HON. CHARLES A. VANIK tions have changed, Baker points to the 100· without catching fish. The ecologists today OF OHIO acre farm on rolllng land he bought in 1946. yell against building dams, but dams help IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES He had applied for a Farmers Home Admin· fish and wildlife. There weren't a.ny ducks istratlon loan to help him buy the place. It along the river here until the dams were Thursday, October 17, 1974 took the agency almost a year to decide to built, not to mention all the fish that were Mr. VANIK. Mr. Speaker, I was very let the loan go though, he recalls, "because killed and land ruined before flood control concerned when the President in his eco­ the land was so poor, they weren't at all came. sure the place was worth even the $330-a· "And take wild game, for instance. My nomic message of October 8, 1974, gave year payment on the loan." daddy never saw a tleer. Now they're all over a blanket endorsement to the tax bill "This land, like a lot of other land around the place. And beaver were only a fond mem­ which has been developed by the Ways here, was absolutely worn out. There wasn't ory around here. Now you see them; they've and Means Committee. This tentative one acre on the place that was considered worked their way up Limestone Creek from bill is more loophole than reform. Some Class A land-land that would make a bale the Tennessee and are beyond the Capshaw have tried to give the committee's bill the of cotton to the acre." area now. I've got squirrels returning to my odor of tax reform-but it reeks or spe­ Today, his land is restored to production, place after all these years, now that the nut cial interest loopholes. The American thanks to fertllizers a.nd years of caring for trees are getting big. And woodchucks are it. Because it is so heavily contoured, it re­ taking over the place. And I even get wUd people must not be fooled into accepting mains marginal land for row crops and fit duck in my pond." this tax bill as a reform bill. only for grazing, and so Baker has it in pas­ Baker is especially critical of environmen­ I would like to include at this point in ture for the beef cattle he raises. But the son talists' alarm over phosphates, particularly the RECORD a column of October 17, 1974, conditions have been so restored, he says, phosphates in detergents under attack be­ by the economics writer of the Washing­ that his land could produce up to two bales cause they cause excessive algae growth in ton Post, Mr. Hobart Rowen, entitled of cotton per acre for a year or two-until, rl vers and lakes. "Creating New Tax Loopholes": with the plant cover gone, all the topsoil had "The phosphates you find in detergents," washed away. he argues, "are approximately the same CREATING NEW TAX LOOPHOLES Baker's point is that he, along with vir­ chemical constituents in many fert111zers, (By Hobart Rowen) tually all farmers today, have learned not to such as the one I use. But the fish 1n my By endorsing the House Ways and Means mistreat this facet of the environment that pond are waxing fat on the same chemicals Committee tax "reform" bill, President Ford way. they're trying to ban in detergents. I think has focused attention-no doubt uninten­ But that's not by any means all that's the publie is being fed a lot of malarkey on tionally--on what could be one of the major changed. phosphates. It's largely because of phos­ tax giveaways in U.S. history. "Across the board, the ecology is in so phates and other chemical fertilizers that As it now stands, the bill is not a tax much better shape than it was 40 or 50 years we're now getting 50 to 60 bushels of corn "reform" bill at all, although it does reduce ago," argues Baker good-na.turedly, "it's just per acre. The average corn yield in this coun­ or eliminate a few special privileges, notably amazing to me that people are so perturbed try used to be 15 to 16 bushels. the oil depletion allowance. over it. Any area. you could name is im­ "Now, I don't have anything against or­ But the main thrust of the proposed legis­ proved. Back 35 years ago, for instance, when ganic faming-I keep a compost heap myself. lation is to create $3 billion to $4 bHlion Huntsville had 16,000 population and there But what a lot of people who are against worth of new loopholes for businessmen, and were probably 10,000 cars 1n the county, chemical fertilizers forget is that they pro­ those wealthy individuals whose income is . those cars were probably doing far more pol­ duce a lot more stalk and stem, which is largely derived from capital gains rather than iuting per car than cars today do. turned under and makes more humus to wages. "And take the coal fires we used to have. enrich the soil. And it's yet to be shown that Thus, although the bill contains $1.6 bil­ They were. the worst air polluters. I've had any of these fertiUizers cause cancer, as lion in tax relief for the working poor (not asthma all my life and I used to go into town some have been saying." enough to compensate for inflation) it is on in wintertime on a frosty morning. Every Oil spills, another environmental concern, balance a bad piece of legislation which ben­ store burned coal for heat, as did an awful do not trouble Baker unduly. "011 spills at efits upper income brackets in too many ways lot of houses, and the air would be so heavy sea are nothing new," he says. "There's no while leaving what Rep. Henry Reuss (D• with smoke. And back then all the smoke­ telling how many big tankers were sunk by Wis.) calls "the old established loopholes" stacks at the mllls and factories and laun- German subs along the Atlantic and Gulf very much alone. 36146 EXTENSIONS OF REMARKS October 17, 1974 Take the capital gains proposal, which has IN SUPPORT OF VETO OVERRIDE OF will bring the two sides in this conflict most true tax-reformers up in arms. At pres· HOUSE JOINT RESOLUTION 1163 to the negotiating table. We must dem­ ent, 50 per cent of a capital gain-say on se­ curities-is excluded from any tax if held six onstrate unequivocably to Turkey that months. The generous Ways and Means Com­ HON. MARIO BIAGGI continued violation of the Foreign As- mittee would exclude 1 per cent in addition oF NEW YORK sistance Act will no longer be tolerated. for each year the asset is held over five years, Above all, we have an opportunity to but not over 25 years. IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES assert ourselves in an important matter That neat trick would increase the exclu­ Thursday, October 17, 1974 of foreign policy. Our vote last week in- sion to a potential 70 per cent and presum.:. ably make stocks more attractive to buy­ Mr. BIAGGI. Mr. Speaker, I support dicated that we in Congress still are con­ as well as persuade those holding stocks over the motion to override the President's tent to play a subservient role. Our vote a long period of years and said to be "locked· most recent veto, of House Joint Resolu- today may be the last chance we have in" by potential tax liab111ties to take their tion 1163. I find this action to be an un- to maintain our strong positions with profits (with a minimum tax bite) and buy fortunate move by the President and one respect to aid to Turkey. Failure to over­ new stocks. which should not be tolerated by the ride this veto will only serve to prolong Economists Roger Brinner and Alicia Mun· Members of this body. the Cyprus and intensify the embittered nell point out: "While a declining inclusion ratio would not solve either the inflation nor It has been almost 3 months since feelings of the Greek community who lock-in problem, such a change would sig· Turkey invaded Cyprus yet still we find have viewed with a sense of betrayal the nificantly reduce the tax rate on capital ourselves debating the issues of both our U.S. Government's failure to act in the gains." For individuals in the 70 per cent top continued providing of aid to Turkey and wake of Turkey's action. Most impor­ bracket, their tax on capital assets held 26 our efforts , toward restoring peace to tantly a vote to override will tell those years would be cut from 35 per cent to 21 per Cyprus. Yesterday we in the House passed Greek Cypriots who have seen their cent. an effective compromise amendment to families and friends, killed, their homes The Committee's proposal, if it worked to solve the lock-in problem, might be a shot the resolution which gave the ad.minis- destroyed and their future imperiled, in the arm for the ailing brokerage business. tration until December 10 to work out an that we are still committed to assisting But it would cost the Treasury at least $1 agreement on Cyprus, with the condition tJ:em, and that we are still the cham­ b1llion a year, while the biggest capital gains that if any of the aid which we provide p1ons of freedom for all men. We can­ loophole of all-the nontaxation of capital to Turkey was shipped to Cyprus the • not forsake tJ:te people of Cyprus any gains at death-remains untouched. President would be authorized to t~rmi- longer, for the1r hour of need is upon us. The surest way of tackling the lock-in nate aid to Turkey immediately. This was I urge a. decisiye and overwhelming vote problem, as Brinner and Munnell point out, is to provide a tax on capital gains trans­ a responsible and vitally important to overnde th1s veto today. ferred at death. Tax expert Joseph A. Pech­ amendment, one which could prevent man of the Brookings Institution estimates any further military aggression by Tur- the current cost of that loophole, which al­ key in Cyprus. Yet once again, the ad­ lows wealth and power to be transferred from HUD SECRETARY JAMES T. LYNN ministration has chosen to reject our COMMENDED generation to generation, at $3 billion a year. efforts at bringing peace to Cyprus and Other bonanzas created by the bill: Industrial Development· Bonds-Presently, has once again demonstrated its lack of private industry has a nice little racket un· concern for the future security of Cyprus. -HON. MARGARET M. HECKLER der which it can finance up to $5 million of I reluctantly supported the compro­ OF MASSACHUSETTS an expansion in a six-year period at public mise reached yesterday, reluctantly to IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES expense. This is done through issuance of the extent that I would have preferred, tax-exempt bonds by a state or local govern­ and have supported legislation in the past Thursday, October 17. 1974 ment to finance a new facility. Not only does which would cut off aid to Turkey imme­ Mrs. HECKLER of Massachusetts. Mr. this system provide tax-exempt investment diately. Her blatant violations of the Speaker, iri the midst of what I consider possibilities for high income individuals, but unfair criticism of Secretary of Housing the companies lease the plants at low rents Foreign Assistance Act with respect to because the construction borrowing costs are· use of military aid dictated to me ·that and Urban Development James T. Lynn, less than normal due to the tax-exempt gim­ this aid should be cut off forthwith. How­ I would like to share with my colleagues mick. But now the committee proposed to ever, realizing that compromise was my own perspective on Secretary Lynn's take off the $5 mt}Uon ceiling. With the sky needed, I supported the Rosenthal performance, which I believe has been the limit, the potential tax loss is another $1 amendment. very creditable in the most difficult of billion. However, I cannot support the Presi­ circumstances. Savings Account Interest-The bill would dent's veto today. While we have been No Secretary of Housing has worked as exempt the first $500 of interest in savings closely with Congress as has Jim Lynn. I accounts ($1,000 per couple) in an effort to debating this issue, the crisis on Cyprus help thrift institutions keep deposits, and has continued virtually uninterrupted. can assure my colleagues that the reason thus aid the housing industry. Whether new The Turkish Army continues its illegal we have a new housing bill (the Hous­ savings would be encouraged is debatable. and ruthless control of more than one­ ing and Community Development Act of But what is clear is that high-income fami­ third of Cyprus using our military aid In 1974) and not a veto is due in large meas­ lies would benefit most (a family would need open defiance of the Foreign Assistance ure to Secretary Lynn's untiring efforts nearly $20,000 in a 5.25 per cent passbook Act, yet confident knowing that they to find common ground between a num­ account to accumulate $1,000 in interest), have a friend in the administration ber of powerful interests, which have and the Treasury would be out an estimated been at odds for over 3 years of housing $1.8 billion. which seems content to allow them to Tax Simplification-Many deductions pres· continue their actions without any inter­ legislation. During the committee's ently itemized would be replaced by a lump ruption. months-long drafting sessions on this sum deduction up to $650 whether or not I most vehemently disagree with the legislation, Jim Lynn visited with each a taxpayer had actually qualified for any. The contention of the President that any committee member individually to ex­ net result: taxpayers with many and varied change views. He spent several hours in expenses which are now deductible would be decision to cut o:f aid can only prolong the Cyprus crisis. Unless we asset our­ my office discussing my proposal to pro­ sho.!'t-~hanged, Whi.le others would get what anwunts to a tax cut from Uncle Sam. Net selves in preventing any further ship­ vide loans for elderly housing construc­ tion which he ultimately supported. The -~ timated cost: $400 million. ments of arms to Turkey, Turkey will be As mentioned earlier, there are some in an excellent position to solidify her bill which passed authorizes $11.2 billion wo~t11while things in the bill, including a position on the island, and it is this that for housing, and charts a new direction heftier minimum tax, a reduction in real will prolong the misery and suffering for for the Federal housing and development estate shelter possibilities, a limitation on effort. So let us not say that Jim Lynn . tax-free junkets for doctors, lawyers, and more than a quarter of a million Greek other professional groups, and tightening of Cypriots. has been ineffective. · taxes on salaries earned. abroad. We are again confronted with a his­ As in all compromises, no one is en- But such welcome steps are as nothing toric opportunity to override a Presiden­ tirely satisfied with the final version of alongside the new loopholes and old ones tial veto. A vote to override is critical the new housing law. I fought hard to such as tax-free bond interest, the existing if we are to maintain our commitment keep the Model Cities prog£am fully capital gains benefits, and the "DISC" give­ to the people of Cyprus. We must sup­ funded for an additional 3 years, and I away that allows corporations to avoid taxes was the author of a new elderly housing 011 export sales. Better no bill at all than this port the bill we passed yesterday if we one! are to get the machinery in motion which construction program, as well as a pro- November 18, 1974 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD-SENATE 36147 hibition of discrimination against women leader in community affairs, but a man Veteran organizations have chosen him as of honor and integrity. He is an out­ V.F.W. Commander and American Legion in mortgage credit. Nevertheless, I did Commander locally. He has served as State not get everything I wanted in the legis­ standing American, and we in Tennes­ Vice-Commander of the American Legion and lation. In the process, however, I did de­ see's Seventh Congressional Distl1ct are in 1973-74 he served as National Vice-Com­ velop a finn respect for Secretary Lynn, indeed proud of him. mander of the organization's Councll on who demonstrated that he cares about Mr. Speaker, at this point I would like Americanism. housing as much as I do. He is a dedi­ to insert in the RECORD an article from Postmaster Herndon and his wife, Peggy, cated, hard-working leader. the Camden, Tenn., Chronicle of Octo­ reside on Woodland Drive in Camden. Their ber 10, 1974, concerning Mr. Herndon's son, Joe, is a senior at the University of Ten­ I also fought last year to continue full nessee in Knoxville where the postmaster funding for existing housing and com­ award: graduated in 1949. munity development programs, after a Postmaster w. c. Herndon of Camden has As coincidence would have it, the same Dr. moratorium on these programs was an­ been named the U.S. Postmaster of the Year. Andy Holt who presented Herndon his Na­ nounced, but I do not hold Secretary The award was presented on September 27 tional Postmaster's award was the same Dr. Lynn responsible for that decision. The in Hollywood, Florida by Dr. Andrew Holt, Holt, who as president of U.T. presented him moratorium was imposed before he be­ president emeritus of the University of Ten­ the'tiiploma in 1949. nessee and a member of the Board of Gov­ Another Tennessean was honored at the came Secretary, and the decision was not ernors of the U.S. Postal Service during the recent meeting in Florida. Kenneth Jen­ made by HUD, it was made by President annual convention of the National League nings of Powell, Tennessee, was elected presi­ Nixon. It was a decision that no one in of Postmasters. dent of the National League of Postmasters. the administration could have over­ Earlier in the year Herndon was named turned. Postmaster of the Year in Tennessee at the Mr. Speaker, we now have on line an State Convention at Paris Landing in July. $11.2 billion housing program. It is the His selection as Postmaster of the Year came CLIFF MciNTIRE from a field in which competition was tough. first opportunity Jim Lynn has had to All other states had chosen their representa­ demonstrate what he can do for housing. tives with which he had to compete. I believe he deserves a fair chance to per­ The award was based on recognition and HON. W. R. POAGE form on his own, and to be judged objec­ appreciation of his outstanding service in the OF TEXAS tively on his own record. Camden Post Office and this community and IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES to the National League of Postmasters. The honor reflected credit upon himself, Tuesday, October 8, 1974 the entire postal service and honored the Na­ TENNESSEAN NAMED "POSTMASTER tional League. Those were the criteria on Mr. POAGE. Mr. Speaker, all who OF THE YEAR" which the selection was based. served with Cliff Mcintire in the Con­ During the two days that Herndon served gress knew him as an able and distin­ as president of the State Tennessee beat all guished legislator. Those of us who served HON. ED JONES other states in the membership drive. with him on the Agriculture Committee, OF TENNESSEE Postmaster Herndon has been an influen­ because of a close personal relationship, IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES tial and dedicated worker in many facets of knew him also as a gentleman in the community life. He 1s active in Boy Scouts, Thursday, October 17, 1974 having earned the Sliver Beaver Award by the highest meaning of that word. National Council. His efforts in the Cancer He was considerate and helpful, kind Mr. JONES of Tennessee. Mr. Speaker, Crusade have been untiring. As both a Sun­ and understanding. His counsel was at its recent annual convention in Holly­ day School teacher and a Deacon, he serves sought by his colleagues. He was unstint­ wood, Fla., the National League of Post­ well in Camden's First Baptist Church. ing in service to his country, and in the masters named as the U.S. Postmaster of Today, Herndon is a Lt. Colonel in the U.S. field of agriculture he was truly a na­ the Year, Mr. W. C. Herndon of Camden, Army Reserve. He teaches classes for the tional authority. Tenn., which is located in the congres­ military. He is proud of the Army and has a News of his untimely death saddens sional district I represent. l'eason to be. During World War II, he served in the all who knew Cliff Mcintire, and I join I have known Mr. Herndon person­ European Theatre of Operations where he with his countless other friends in e.­ ally for many years and know him to be was taken prisoner by the Germans and held tending sympathy to his wife and the not only a fine postmaster and noted for four months. other members of his family.

SENATE-Monday, November 18, 1974 The Senate met at 12 o'clock meridian he may walk in Thy light and possess leadership has been recognized tomor­ and was called to order by the President Thy peace. row, the distinguished Senator from Mis­ pro tempore (Mr. EASTLAND). And to Thee shall be all praise and souri