Goal-Directed Fantasy, Imaginative Involvement, and the Development of Suggestibility Martin W
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Rhode Island DigitalCommons@URI Open Access Master's Theses 1975 Goal-Directed Fantasy, Imaginative Involvement, and the Development of Suggestibility Martin W. Ham University of Rhode Island Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.uri.edu/theses Recommended Citation Ham, Martin W., "Goal-Directed Fantasy, Imaginative Involvement, and the Development of Suggestibility" (1975). Open Access Master's Theses. Paper 1598. https://digitalcommons.uri.edu/theses/1598 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@URI. It has been accepted for inclusion in Open Access Master's Theses by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@URI. For more information, please contact [email protected]. GOAL-DIRECTEDFANTASY , IMAGINATIVEINVOLVEJl1ENT , ANDTHE DEVELOPMENT OF SOOCESTIBILITY BY MARl'INW . HAM A THESIS SUBMITTEDIN PARl'liL FULFILLMENTOF THE ~lJIRB)IFl{TS FOR THE DmREE OF MASTEROF ARTS IN PSYCHOLOGY UNIVERSITYOF RHODEISLAND 1975 ABSTRACT studies have repeatedly demonstrated a developmental trend in suggestibility -- responsiveness to suggestions traditionally asso ciated with the tezm hypnotin is low for those under six years of age, r.lses to a peak near the ages of nine through eleven , and pro gressively declines the:reatter . It has also been consistently shown that with adult populations , involvement in task-relevant 1111agin ings , functions as a cognitive strategy enhancing response to sug gestion. On the basis of evidence such as this , at least one in vestigator, J. HUgam, has suggested that changes 1n responsiveness with age are due to variations 1n 1:mag1native 1nvolvaent . Speci fically , it has 'been proposed that the decline in suggestibility aay be the result of an increased developmental trend tolf&1'da :ra tional-logical mode of thinking , which is inconsistent with the in volvement in 1aag1.na.tive processes so important in responsiveness to suggestion . While the develOpllental literature relating to free fantasylike activity lends some support to this notion , no previous study has attempted to detemine either a) the relationship be tween the passing or falling of suggestions and involvement in task relevant 1mag1nings in subjects from the lower age levels , orb) changes occur.lag in these imaginative involvements with age. In the present investigation , one hundred subjects between the ages of eight and seventeen were individually tested 1n a single 111 session . Each subject was administered standardised task -motiva tional instructions followed by an 8.1'1l-lev1tation suggestion , an arm-catalepsy suggestion, and an amnesia suggestion for the number four . Each subject was interviewed immediately after his response to each suggestion to deteJ:mine whether or not he engaged in sug gestion-related 1mag1n1ngsand , if so, the elaborateness and dur ation of these 1.magininge. It was found that , regax-dless of age , subjects who passed the suggestions a) tended to report engaging in suggestion-related imaginings , whereas those who did not respond were less likely to engage in this pattern of imaginative responding , and b) reported engaging in imaginings that were more elaborate and of longer dur ation than those who failed the suggestions . In addition , partial support was obtained regarding the notion of age trends in 1.mgin ative involvoent . Elaborateness and duration of imaginings were characteristically low for the youngest subjects , rose to a peak around the ages of ten to twelve , and declined thereafter . How ever , analyses indicated that only for elaborateness of imaginings in response to the amnesia suggestion was there a significant cur vilinear relation with age, the remaining relationships , while in the 88Jlle direction , did not achieve conventional. levels of signi ficance . It is suggested that future research considering develop mental trends in imaginative involvement may prove to be more pro ductive if variations are examined across one-year age groups, and a larger battery of test suggestions is eaployed . iv ACKNOWLEJx:;fflmTS I would like to acknowledge the help of the many people who made this thesis project possible . First , although they wish t o rems.in anonymous, I want to thank the adll1n1strators , teachers , parents, and students of the school system 1n which this research was carried out :for their cooperation and patience . I also thank Dr. Albert Lott and the other members of my committee for their active interest and for patiently reading and 1.Jllprov1ngupon this manuscript . For stimulating and critical discussion of many as pects of this project , I would like to thank my friend and col league, Dr. John Chaves. A special debt. of gratitude goes to Drs. Theodore x. Barber and Nicholas Spanos. It was Dr. Barber who first introduced Jle to hypnosis as a res8&1'Charea and provided ae with the opportunity to develop my skills . Both he and Dr. Spanos have unselfishly given innmerable hours in discussing and encouraging •7 research interests , and have served as constant sources of inspiration tor new ideas . Last , but certainly not least, I would like to express my aost sincere appreciation to my wife, Marie, for her persistent encouragement, aoral. support , and understanding . V 1... ABSTRAC'l'••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 111 ACKHOWLEMffffiTS•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• LIST OF TABLSS..,•••••••• , ••••••••••••••••••••••••• LISTOF FIGURES•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• LlS'l'OF APPDMOES.,••••••••• , •••••••••••••••• , •••• I HISTORICALPmBSPECTIVE.,,, ••••••••••••••••••• , •• ,., II JltACIIIATIYEPJCXlmssm AID Tim ~"~ OF SlCCESTimtn ••••••••••••• 7 Ill Ml'flt:)rx>LOCt••••••••• , ••••••••••••• , ••••••••••••• ,,. 13 IV Rt"8ULTs.• • • • •• ••••• • • • • • • •• ••• •••• ••••• •••• •• • • •• •• 20 V lltSOUSSION,,,•••••••••••••••••••••••••••• ,, •• , ••••• 33 VI APPSlfDICES,•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 41 VII I<EF.lfflOC"s.S••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 63 LIST OF TABLES Table Page 1 Relationship Between Perf01'1D&Dceon the Anl- Levitation Suggestion and Engagementin Goal- Directed Fantasy for Each Age Group•••••• ••• •• ••• ••••• 21 2 Relationship Between Perfomanca on the Selective Amnesia Suggestion and Engageaent 1n Goal-Directed Fantasy for Each Age G1'0up•• •••••••••• •••••• •••• ••••• • 22 SUIDJl1U'7ot Mann-WhitneyU Tests Comparing the El.ab- o:rateness of Fantasy Reports Provided by Subjects WhoPassed the Am-Levitation and Selective Amnesia Suggestions With that of Subjects WhoFailed •~••• ••• •• 25 4 Summar:,of Mann-WhitneyU Testa Comparl.ng the Duration of Fantasy Reports P1'0v1dedby Subjects WhoPassed the Am-Levitation and SelectiTe Allnes1a Suggestions With that of Subjects WhoFailed ••••••••• ••• •• ••••••• • 28 5 Mean Elaborateness and Duration Sco:res• ••• •••••••• •••••• 29 vii LIST OF FIGtJR&q Figure Page 1 MeanElaborateness and Duration Scores Across AgeGroups ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 31 viii LIST OF APPENDIC!l5 Appendix Page A Form Letter Requesting Part1c1pat1on ••••••••••••••••• 41 B Manual for Scoring Goal D1Nctad Fanta.a7 ••••••••••••• 42 C Manual for Scoring Elaborateness and of Suggestion- Related Iaag1n1ngs••••••••••••••••••• 52 1x I HISTORICALPERSPECTIVE Four sets of phenomena have txaditionally been subsumed under the rubrlc of hypnotism. These 1ncludea a) heightened responsive ness to suggestions for am lowerlng , hand anesthesia , visual hal lucination , selective amnesia , and the likes b) obeerY&ble changes in posture and movements such as limpness-relaxation , lack of spon taneity , fixed gaze , and psychoaotor retaJ.'dation1 c) reports of un usual alterations in body feelings such as changes in the size of the body or body parts and feelings of unreal.1 t;n and d) post experlmental reports of having entered a unique state of conscious- ness . Historlcally , a variety of theories have been put forth in an attempt to explain the occurrence of phenomena such as these . Yet, one conceptualization has been dominant for the past 100 years . Basic to this conceptualization , which has commonly been labeled the trance-state app:roach, are two assumptionsa 1) Whena rltualistic cereaony collllllonlylabeled as hypnotic induction procedure is successful , a unique state of consciousness is induced which differs fundamentally from the waking state . This state has been varlously temed as the hYpnotic state , trance , or hy:pnosis. 2) The four sets of phenomena traditionally subsumed by the te1'11hypnotia result from the operation of this unique trance state . Moreover, the deeper this state , the more readily these phenomena are manifested. 2 Although the trance-state conceptualization has been dominant during the past century , critics have periodically asserted that the occurrence of hypnotic phenOJllenaneed not be assumed to result from the operation of an unusual state of consciousness . For instance , as early as 1823, Alexander Bertmnd concluded that, "••• The psychological phen0J1ena observed during the (hypnotic) state are not exceptional, but axe nomal , or at least phenomena which can be observed under various conditions . Artificial sonmanbulism• •• servea merely to render conspic uous and to aaplify phenomena dependent upon the wo1'k1.ngof th~ general laws of illagination, expec tant attention , and desire" (Bertrand , cited in Janet , 1925, vol . I , P• 157). Nearly a quarter of a centu:t')' later , James Braid , in his theory of monoideiBlll, wrote that , "hypnotin occurs