Comments Received from Brockwell Park Community Partners Stakeholder Groups
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Comments received from Brockwell Park Community Partners stakeholder groups Brockwell Lido Steering Committee Dear Brockwell Community Partners, I am writing in my capacity as Chair of the Brockwell Lido Steering Committee (BLSC) to formally express our objection to the Field Day and LoveBox events proposed for Brockwell Park. The BLSC believes the number of participants and the footprint far exceeds a scale appropriate for a closed event for Brockwell Park and would be highly detrimental to the enjoyment of the park by the general public and local residents. We also think it would be detrimental to users of the Lido who would be impacted by the noise, and would be likely to find access very difficult due to crowds and entrances being closed off. During the summer the whole of the park is well used by the general public who visit to picnic, relax and play games with friends and family. These events would either force people to stay away or cram into a small section of the park for the whole of July. Access to the playground, wet play area, and ponds would be made more difficult and unpleasant for families as they have to navigate moving vehicles and have a permanent view of 7 foot high fences to enjoy. Most of the grassed area of the park that will be free from the fencing is also unsuitable for playing or picnicking on because it is un-cut and therefore scratchy and unpleasant, especially for young children. The noise pollution from events is likely to be very bad, this might possibly be overlooked by residents if they finished early (Sunfall finished at 10pm) and be a single night, but the proposal states that events will take place on three consecutive nights and that the nights will finish at 11pm. Even after the music stops this will mean people spilling out and being a noise nuisance in local roads well after 11.30pm. Brockwell Park is 60% the size of Victoria Park. Brockwell Park is also surrounded houses, whereas Victoria Park is surrounded by trees and busy roads. The committee recognises the financial difficulties of funding parks but these events are inappropriate given the location and use of Brockwell Park. Sunfall was a reasonably successful event when it catered to 10,000 people in 2016. In 2017 they increased the numbers to 20,000 and had serious issues with queues and damage to the park infrastructure as well as litter in the surrounding areas. Field Day propose a capacity of up to 40,000 - it is inevitable that these events will cause more serious issues than Sunfall. We ask that the BPCPs and Lambeth reject both applications and only consider future applications that are much smaller in size, scale and potential disruption. Any future events should also require a much higher payment to Lambeth - 50p per person should be viewed as an insult. Yours sincerely Bianca Ioannides Chair - BLSC Brockwell Miniature Railway From: Jrobe87821 > (Brockwell Miniature Railway) Date: 22 November 2017 at 19:04:32 GMT Subject: RE: The Two proposed Festivals I am extremely concerned that again it looks very likely that the railway could fall victim to vandalism with these two major events taking place. Also not happy at all that we may lose the summer operating season in which the railway relies on the customers for the generation of funds to cover our public liability insurance. At the same with no movement on the container it looks as if next year we’ll be closed for most of the busy season. It's bad enough that the country show actively discourages us from operating. Yours John St Matthew’s Project From: Lee Dema > ) Date: 22 November 2017 at 18:48:12 GMT Subject: Re: The Two proposed Festivals The two bids are just cut and paste jobs. To have the Love Box event the weekend before the Country Show is not viable and just shows contempt for regular park users. The two events allude to being of a similar size to the Country Show, so imagine anyone suggesting a few years ago hosting 3 Country Shows. Regards Lee Brockwell Bowlers I am appalled to hear that 2 three day events are to be held in the Park. I write as a) A park lover... these events inevitably lead to churning up of the grass and damage and litter and the park out of use to for quiet recreational activities. b) A local resident, NOISE!! Congestion!! Removal of parking from Water Lane. c) Chair of the bowls group. That would be 2 more weekends when bowling is disrupted Heather Bouchier Hayes The comments below were received by Brockwell Park Community Partners following a mailing of the Pro-Formas for both Lovebox and Field Day. 1. On Fri, Nov 24, 2017 at 3:29 PM, louise fincham > wrote I write to object in the strongest terms to the proposal to hold these two festivals in Brockwell Park in the summer of 2018. As a daily user of the park I am fed up with the increasing amount of time that large sections of the park are fenced off for large events. Brockwell Park is a local amenity, it was founded as a space for the people of Herne Hill and their dogs, it is entirely unsuited to large events. I resent the loss of the park as an amenity. Many local residents do not have a garden and Brockwell Park is a place for them to go and enjoy some fresh air and peace and quiet. The park becomes virtually unusable in the lead up, during and after events with anti-social behaviour, litter and noise all affecting local residents. The local transport system is put under strain and even local businesses which might gain from the increased number of people coming to the area appear not to support the plan. The previous venue (Victoria Park) for the Field Day festival is a much larger park. Please leave Brockwell Park alone for us local residents to support and enjoy. Please keep me up to date with developments. Louise Fincham 2. On Fri, Nov 24, 2017 at 10:47 AM, Noelle Egan > wrote: We live in , very close to Brockwell Park which we use on a daily basis. We went to a meeting on Monday called by the promoter of the Field Day Festival ( as a residents' consultation) who confirmed that it has applied to hold the festival in Brockwell Park, over 3 days in June 2018, with 40,000 people attending per day, taking over a third of the park for 3 weeks (20th May to 10th June to include set up and de-commissioning) with walled fences. We understand that Lovebox/Citadel festivals have also submitted an application for an even bigger event July 2018, a week before the Lambeth Country Show. Both have sought to find a new location, having been pushed out of Victoria Park where they have been for many years. There was a strong level of concern voiced by all those present and indeed shock at the scale of proposals for this and other events. Field Day has a fine reputation as a festival (can’t say the same for Lovebox alas), and we are all aware of the financial pressures on Councils. We don’t object to events in principle, but have these four issues relating to Field Day/Lovebox. 1. The scale of these events as proposed is unsustainable. Victoria Park is 70% larger than Brockwell Park and it struggled to manage the pressure of numbers, noise, nuisance, congestion and other impacts on residents that 40,00 people a day brings. Half the proposed size and a much tighter set of requirements for building and de-commissioning timescales for the event might be manageable, but this scale will totally disable normal life in the area for excessive periods. 2. Allied with other proposed events including the locally focussed and very popular Country Show, these further events will virtually exclude locals enjoying the park for significant and unacceptable periods of the summer months - this is simply wrong. 3. The proposed footprints takes up far too much of the area of the park. The space permitted should be limited to a smaller area. 4. The financial recompense is entirely insufficient to allow the benefits to outweigh the adverse implications for the park and residents’ detriment, and an insufficient proportion of the parks levy is directly invested in the park. More income from fewer events should be the strategic model to be pursued on events, using Brockwell Hall more and so on, rather than all these massive events. I ask that you please use your influence to ensure that the Council challenges or rejects these proposals, and/or seeks to get much better outcomes, including a reduction in scale and greater mitigation of impacts than currently proposed. Noelle Egan 3. I have heard recent news that there is the possibility of field day & LoveBox moving to Brockwell park in 2018. I wanted to email to raise my concerns about this on a number of levels: 1.Community – you estimate 90,000 people will travel to the event over the weekend. Based on previous events that only ran for 1 night this will have a detrimental impact on the community and its inhabitants. How will you manage transport, litter, drug usage, drinking in the streets and the repercussions this might have on peoples neighbourhoods and homes? What about residents who wish/need to use local facilities and won’t be able to for three whole days? 2.