DOCSLIB.ORG

Technical Report the Role of Small Cities in Shaping Youth Employment

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Technical Report the Role of Small Cities in Shaping Youth Employment Technical Report The role of small cities in shaping youth employment outcomes in India and Indonesia February 2019 *Project Title: The role of small cities in shaping youth employment outcomes in India and Indonesia *IDRC Project Number-Component Number (if applicable): 108082-001/108283-001 *By: Mukta Naik, Gregory F Randolph *Report Type and #: Technical Report (Final) *Period covered by the report: March 1 2015– 31 December 2018 *Date: 1 February 2019 *Country/Region: India, Indonesia *Full Name of Research Institution: Centre for Policy Research JustJobs Network *Address of Research Institution: Centre for Policy Research, Dharma Marg, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi 1100021 JustJobs Network, 8300 Greensboro Drive, Suite L1-184, McLean, VA, USA 22102 *Name(s) of Researcher/Members of Research Team: Mukta Naik, Eesha Kunduri, Sama Khan, Shamindra Nath Roy, Pranav Kuttaiah, Deepaboli Chatterjee, Rimjhim Saxena, Gregory F Randolph, Sabina Dewan, Prachi Agarwal, Divya Kumar, Zaeem Hossain *Contact Information of Researcher/Research Team members: CPR: [email protected] JJN: [email protected] Table of Contents 1. SYNTHESIS ............................................................................................................................................................ 6 2. THE RESEARCH PROBLEM ............................................................................................................................ 10 2.1. The context: structural transformation and mobility .................................................................................. 10 2.2. Why small cities are important ............................................................................................................................ 11 2.3. Research questions ................................................................................................................................................... 16 3. METHODS ........................................................................................................................................................... 16 3.1. Secondary analysis using national level datasets .......................................................................................... 16 3.2. Case city analysis ....................................................................................................................................................... 17 3.2.1. Selection of case studies ..................................................................................................................................................... 18 3.2.2. Quantitative Survey .............................................................................................................................................................. 24 3.3. Qualitative fieldwork ............................................................................................................................................... 25 3.4. Comparative research: India and Indonesia ................................................................................................... 27 4. RESEARCH FINDINGS ...................................................................................................................................... 29 4.1 Secondary data analysis ........................................................................................................................................... 29 4.1.1. Migration junctions in India and Indonesia ............................................................................................................... 29 4.1.2. Comparing subnational urban and rural geographies on migration, work and urban governance ... 30 4.1.3. Limitations posed by data and the importance of field-based enquiry .......................................................... 33 4.2. Insights from Primary Data ................................................................................................................................... 34 4.2.1. Migration and mobility ....................................................................................................................................................... 34 4.2.2. Labor markets in small city economies ........................................................................................................................ 38 4.2.3. Small city employment landscapes ................................................................................................................................ 42 4.2.4. Getting stuck: Threats to economic mobility ............................................................................................................. 45 4.2.5. The small city as a site of negotiated opportunities for women ........................................................................ 49 4.2.6. Carving out space: women’s relationship with the small city ............................................................................. 55 4.2.7. Planning the small city ........................................................................................................................................................ 56 4.2.8. Envisioning economic futures .......................................................................................................................................... 62 5. PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION AND MANAGEMENT ............................................................................... 63 5.1. Research tasks ............................................................................................................................................................ 63 5.1.1. Secondary data analysis ..................................................................................................................................................... 63 5.1.2. Primary data collection ....................................................................................................................................................... 63 5.1.3. Ethics protocols ...................................................................................................................................................................... 64 5.1.4. Documentary film: Small City Dreaming ..................................................................................................................... 65 5.2. Advisory committee ................................................................................................................................................. 66 5.3. Team composition and management ................................................................................................................. 66 5.4. Capacity-building among partners and local civil society organizations ............................................. 68 6. PROJECT FINANCIALS ..................................................................................................................................... 70 7. PROJECT OUTPUTS AND DISSEMINATION .............................................................................................. 70 7.1. Journal articles ........................................................................................................................................................... 70 7.2. Policy Reports ............................................................................................................................................................. 71 7.3. Policy Briefs ................................................................................................................................................................. 71 7.4. Opinion pieces and blogs ........................................................................................................................................ 72 7.5. Media .............................................................................................................................................................................. 73 7.6. Website.......................................................................................................................................................................... 73 8. IMPACT ................................................................................................................................................................ 73 8.1. New directions in research and policy .............................................................................................................. 73 8.2. Impacting local government and civil society action ................................................................................... 74 8.3. Summary of policy recommendations ............................................................................................................... 75 8.3.1. Building future-oriented economies ............................................................................................................................. 76 8.3.2. Managing migration and mobilities ............................................................................................................................... 77 8.3.3. Increase women’s workforce participation and economic mobility ................................................................ 78 9. PROBLEMS & CHALLENGES .......................................................................................................................... 80 10. RECOMMENDATIONS ..................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Visit to the Barefoot College General Exposure Visit Agenda
    TILONIA 2019 Visit to the Barefoot College General Exposure Visit Agenda The Barefoot College, Tilonia 305816 Madaganj, Dirstrict Ajmer, Rajasthan India. Google maps link How and When to Reach Us Contact Person: Visit Coordinator: The Barefoot College is located in the Ajmer district, between vibrant villages and yellowy mustard fields, int the central part of the rocky Mr. Brijesh Gupta +91 and dry desert of Rajsthan. 8209869426 [email protected] There are multiple and at times adventurous ways to reach us. g. FLIGHT: Kishangarh where spice jet operates a flight from Delhi everyday at 3.20 pm, there we can arrange a pick up for you at the Stella Morielli +9179 cost of around 800 ₹ 76387514 TRAIN: the closest train station will be Kishangarh where Shatabdi from Delhi arrives daily as well as many other trains. GOVT. BUS: to Kishangarh or to Patan turn on the Ajmer Jaipur Highway. If you wish to fly or arrive through Jaipur instead, a pick up will cost around 3500 ₹ ***Please note that opening times for visitors 10am to 5 pm excluding Sundays and National Holidays. Awareness If you are staying overnight we would really appreciate your Empowerment consideration for our opening times. Environmental Stewardship 1 The Footprints of the Mahatma “The future of India lies in its villages”. This is the fundamental tenet of the Barefoot Approach to sustainable rural communities, thus we propose our guests and visitors to experience living “barefoot” with humility and detachment from our daily and sometimes superfluous material needs. Be the change you want to see in the world while staying with us.
    [Show full text]
  • The Tilonia Covid Fund
    THE TILONIA COVID FUND We are pleased that the first donation of $ 4,000 was received from the 137 staff of the Barefoot College (SWRC) Tilonia, who agreed to take a minimum wage as salary till the corona virus crisis is officially over. Others (individuals and organizations) may also voluntarily contribute. We plan to distribute the basics that every migrant worker, daily wage labourer, woman and child; with no source of income, living in remote villages and slums needs at the very minimum to tide over the crisis. The month’s supply will include: Food and Provisions Nutrition Supplement Powdered Milk . Rates approved by Govt SUPER 5 PRODUCED IN TILONIA For Protection against the virus: Hand sanitiser Soap Face Masks PRODUCED IN TILONIA PRODUCED IN TILONIA Every complete package consisting of these items will cost $ 32/each/survival kit. It weighs 30 kgs. Each one contains:- 1. Wheat Flour - 20 Kg 2. Chili - 250 Gram 3. Turmeric - 100 Gram 4. Salt - 1 Kg 5. Onion - 2 Kg 6. Potato – 2Kg 7. Oil – 1 Liter 8. Lentils – 2Kg 500g 9. Super 5 - 250 Gram 10. Soap – 1 Pack 11. Masks(5) 12. Hand Sanitizer – 150 ML THE BENEFICIARIES It is proposed to initially cover 20,000 men, women and children within a radius of 100 kms around the Barefoot College, Tilonia; including the poorest and hardest hit slums in Kishengarh and Beawar. Tilonia Centres will be located in strategic places where the $ 32/survival kit will be available for distribution to anyone who approaches the Centres. CONFIRMATION: They must show some documentation (voter card, Aadhar, pension papers, bank account) when receiving the survival kit.
    [Show full text]
  • OTHER CONTRIBUTIONS Barefoot College, Tilonia: Interview with Teja
    Other Education - The Journal of Educational Alternatives ISSN 2049-2162 Volume 3 (2014), Issue 1 · pp.89-95 OTHER CONTRIBUTIONS Barefoot College, Tilonia: Interview with Teja Ram By Gregor Lang-Wojtasik, September 2013 The Barefoot College, Tilonia, or One of the most prominent Social Work Research Centre, was aspects of The Barefoot College is its founded in 1972 by young academics holistic, democratic and participatory around Bunker Roy and continues approach concerning education and today. These academics in the 70s society. Night-schools and Bal Sansad were interested to learn from people (children’s parliament) are models for in dry and down-trodden villages of alternative approaches in learning rural Rajasthan (North-Western part processes and offer chances of of India) and exchange knowledge on education to children out of school sustainable challenges of society. due to various reasons. The work at the college starts at Gregor Lang-Wojtasik used the the grassroots of society. It focuses on example of SWRC night-schools and the belief of existing talents and the Bal Sansad in in his paper presented potential of people in the villages to last year at the European Union solve various problems for Democratic Education Conference themselves. (EUDEC). He has been acquainted The main activities encompass with this NGO since 1997, when he solar energy to support appropriate included it in his research sample for ways of self-reliance, community his PhD on non-formal education in health to reduce child and maternal India and Bangladesh
    [Show full text]
  • Unique Green Valley
    https://www.propertywala.com/unique-green-valley-jaipur Unique Green Valley - Kishangarh, Jaipur Villas, Club House, Apartments, and commercial and Retail Space Kishangarh Unique Green Valley is township project that offers Villas, Clubhouse, Apartments, Landscaped Gardens and commercial and Retail Space and plot on affordable rate in Kishangarh, Jaipur. Project ID : J290692311 Builder: Unique Builders Properties: Apartments / Flats, Independent Houses Location: Unique Green Valley, Kishangarh, Jaipur (Rajasthan) Completion Date: Jun, 2015 Status: Started Description The first ray of the sun, the gardens, the greens, clean fresh air and cheerful environment. The project is your window to nature’s beauty and wonder. Dedicated green spaces and beautifully manicured park integrate seamlessly with living places, fading the lines between nature and the secured confine of your comfort living space. It is one of the finest townships in Kishangarh, Unique Green Valley is a fabulous and beautiful mix of symmetry, grandeur and sophistication. It is a attractive expression of space and comfort, your own private paradise. A world in itself, Unique Green Valley aims to give its residents the excitement of life. It has each and every skill and amenity that make for a comfort living and you can stay healthy life. They promise you the space for all the happy of a modern lifestyle in the way you want it to be. Types Villas Club House Apartments Landscaped Gardens Commercial & Retail Spaces Plots Project Highlights: Street Lights Wide Internal Roads Designer Entrance Gate Beautiful Landscaped Parks 24 Hrs Security Commercial and Retail Spaces Club House Features: Multipurpose Hall Steam Swimming Pool Jacuzzi Carom Sauna Massage Cards Room Table Tennis Well Equipped Gymnasium Unique Builders is one of the pioneer real estate developers of Mumbai, the flagship venture of the Mannat Group, started its operations from Jaipur, which is capital of Rajasthan and better known as the pink city of India.
    [Show full text]
  • Industrial Potential Survey Ajmer (2019-2020)
    INDUSTRIAL POTENTIAL SURVEY AJMER (2019-2020) DISTRICT INDUSTRIES CENTRE, AJMER Email Id- [email protected] TEL. NO. : 0145-2970791 1 DIC Ajmer CONTENTS S.NO. CHAPTER PAGE 1. Chapter I District Profile 1-5 2. Chapter II Social Infrastructure 6-10 3. Chapter III Location Profiling 11-12 4. Chapter IV Agro Resources 13-15 5. Chapter V Live Stock & Related Resources 16-19 6. Chapter VI Water Resources 20-25 7. Chapter VII Minerals & Raw Material 26-30 8. Chapter VIII Tourism 31-37 9. Chapter IX Energy Resources 38-44 10. Chapter X Transportation 45-47 11. Chapter XI Pollution Control Measurement 48-50 12. Chapter XII Financial Facilities 51-53 13. Chapter XIII Export 54-55 14. Chapter XIV Salt 56 15. Chapter XV Cluster in District 57-60 2 DIC Ajmer 16. Chapter XVI Handloom & Handcraft 61-64 17. Chapter XVII Infrastructure 65-72 18. Chapter XVIII Potential industries/Services/Trade 73-88 19. Annexure-I Whom to Contact for What 89-91 20. Annexure-II Name and address of the institution 92-93 Assisting in promotion of SSI in the Country 3 DIC Ajmer DISTRICT PROFILE 01 CHAPTER 1.1 DISTRICT AT A GLANCE Ajmer is the 5th largest city in Rajasthan and is located 135 Kilometers south west of Jaipur, the state capital. Ajmer is surrounded by the Arawali Mountains. It is a pilgrimage centre for the shrine of the Sufi Saint Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti andBrahma Temple in Pushkar. Ajmer has been selected as one of the heritage cities for Hriday-Heritage City Development and Augmentation Yojana Scheme of GOI.
    [Show full text]
  • Beawar-Pali-Pindwara Section of Nh-14 in the State of Rajasthan
    Intended for L&T Infrastructure Development Projects Limited Document type Final Traffic Report Date September, 2017 TRAFFIC STUDY FOR BEAWAR-PALI-PINDWARA SECTION OF NH-14 IN THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN Traffic Study for Beawar-Pali-Pindwara section of NH-14 in the state of Rajasthan 1 Revision 01 Date 28/09/2017 Made by Ramya/Nitin/Harpreet Checked by Meenakshi Asija Approved by Srinivas Chekuri Description Final Traffic Report Traffic Study for Beawar-Pali-Pindwara section of NH-14 in the state of Rajasthan 2 DISCLAIMER In preparing this report, Ramboll India Private Limited relied, in whole or in part, on data and information provided by the L&T IDPL, which information has not been independently verified by Ramboll and which Ramboll has assumed to be accurate, complete, reliable, and current. Therefore, while Ramboll has utilized its best efforts in preparing this Report, Ramboll does not warrant or guarantee the conclusions set forth in this Report which are dependent or based upon data, information, or statements supplied by third parties or the client. This Report is intended for the Client’s sole and exclusive use and is not for the benefit of any third party and may not be distributed to, disclosed in any form to, used by, or relied upon by, any third party, except as agreed between the Parties, without prior written consent of Ramboll, which consent may be withheld in its sole discretion. Use of this Report or any information contained herein, if by any party other than the Client, shall be at the sole risk of such party and shall constitute a release and agreement by such party to defend and indemnify Ramboll and its officers, employees from and against any liability for direct, indirect, incidental, consequential or special loss or damage or other liability of any nature arising from its use of the Report or reliance upon any of its content.
    [Show full text]
  • Small Cities
    Case city report: Kishangarh, Rajasthan SMALL CITIES REPORT RESEARCH The Front Lines of India’s Employment, Migration and Urban Challenges January 2020 RESEARCH REPORT RESEARCH Case city report: Kishangarh, Rajasthan SMALL CITIES The Front Lines of India’s Employment, Migration and Urban Challenges January 2020 ThinkTank Initiative Published in January 2020 by Centre for Policy Research Acknowledgments: This report is part of a research program examining small cities in India and Indonesia from the perspective of employment, migration and youth, led by Mukta Naik, Fellow, Centre for Policy Research and Gregory F Randolph, Executive Vice President, JustJobs Network. This initiative is made possible through generous funding from the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) and the Think Tank Initiative (TTI). We thank those institutions, and particularly program officers Seema Bhatia-Panthaki and Navsharan Singh, for enabling us to explore critical development issues in creative and fulfilling ways. We would like to express our gratitude to our mentors Sabina Dewan of the JustJobs Network and Partha Mukhopadhyay of the Centre for Policy Research for their encouragement. For the invaluable assistance in collecting data, we thank Baladevan Rangaraju and his team from Indus Information Initiatives Pvt Ltd and our partners in Kishangarh, Manthan Sanstha Kotri and Mr. Teja Ram. This work would not have been possible without the contribution of CPR researchers Babu Lal, Deepaboli Chatterjee, Eesha Kunduri, Kanhu Charan Pradhan, Pranav Kuttaiah, Rimjhim Saxena, Sama Khan and Shamindra Nath Roy as well as Deepshi Arya, Harish Sai, Niti Deoliya, Sparsh Agarwal and Zainab Firdausi who spent their internship periods working on the project.
    [Show full text]
  • ISOC-DEF Visit to Tilonia
    WIRELESS IN A RURAL CAMPUS Revisiting campus-wide wireless broadband community network at Barefoot College in Tilonia, Rajasthan WIRELESS FOR COMMUNITIES ➤ In developing countries, wireless connectivity has emerged as an inexpensive technology to bridge the connectivity gap in remote areas. This wireless technology has created much interest in the international development community. In India, even with mobile penetration, tele-density in rural areas is still less than 40 per cent. The reason has mostly been issues around last-mile connectivity, which have the potential to resolve the issue of prohibitive cost of deploying conventional wired infrastructure in remotest areas of the country. ➤ Wireless for Communities or W4C is an initiative of Digital Empowerment Foundation (DEF) and the Internet Society (ISOC) that has been supported by various partners over the years. ➤ Launched in 2010, W4C aims to connect marginalised communities in rural, remote and geographically difficult locations of India, where mainstream Internet Service Providers are not willing to provide connectivity as they feel their operations would not be commercially viable. W4C involves line-of-sight and low-cost Wi-Fi equipment, which utilise the unlicensed spectrum bands — 2.4 GHz and 5.8 GHz — to create community-owned and community-operated wireless networks. BAREFOOT COLLEGE ➤ Barefoot College in Tilonia, Rajasthan, has demystified technologies and decentralised their use by transferring the access, control, management and ownership of sophisticated technologies to rural men and women, who can barely read and write. The College believes that even uneducated poor have the right to use technologies to improve their life and skills. Barefoot College believes that ‘literacy’ is what one acquires in school but ‘education’ is what one gains from family, traditions, culture, environment and personal experiences.
    [Show full text]
  • About the BC
    THE BAREFOOT COLLEGE, TILONIA THE BAREFOOT The Barefoot College Tilonia The Barefoot College SWRC, Tilonia, 305816 Madanganj, District Ajmer Rajasthan, INDIA tel. + 91 (0)1463 88205 / 88210 fax. + 91 (0)1463 88206 email. [email protected] www.barefootcollege.org The Barefoot College Equality Collective Decision-making Self-reliance Decentralisation THE BAREFOOT COLLEGE, TILONIA THE BAREFOOT Austerity Why Barefoot? • Because millions of poor people in India who carry the knowledge, skills and wisdom of their forefathers live and work barefoot. They sit and work on the floor. • It is symbolic of the recognition, respect and importance we give to the collective knowledge and skill that the poor have. • By calling it ‘barefoot’ we want to give its application a unique category of its own, that is superior, sophisticated and enduring. Far more valuable than any paper qualification. Why College? Because it is a centre with a difference •a centre of learning and unlearning. •where the teacher is the learner and the learner the teacher. •where everyone is expected to keep an open mind, try new and crazy ideas make mistakes and try again. •where only those are welcome who have no paper degree to hide behind. •where only those are considered who are NOT eligible for the lowest government job. •where tremendous value is placed on the dignity of labour, of sharing and on those who are willing to work with their hands. •where no certificates, degrees or diplomas are given. Gandhi & the Barefoot College THE BAREFOOT COLLEGE, TILONIA THE BAREFOOT The Barefoot College has internalized into its lifestyle and work ethics, Gandhian ideas that are still relevant and universal in the 21st Century.
    [Show full text]
  • JETIR Research Journal
    © 2018 JETIR July 2018, Volume 5, Issue 7 www.jetir.org (ISSN-2349-5162) A Study of water crisis problem in Kishangargh area in Ajmer, Rajasthan 1Vikash Choudhary, 2Dr. Ashit Dutta 1Research Scholar, 2Associate Professor 1Bhagwant University, Ajmer, Rajasthan, India Abstract : In this paper we are presenting a Study of water crisis problem in Kishangargh, Ajmer, Rajasthan. The desert of Kishangargh is in the grip of a water crisis with 19 out of the 33 districts being famine affected, with the government sending water trains to parched Kishangargh and tankers to other areas facing acute shortage.The water crisis in Kishangargh is one of the major issues tormenting developing nation, as still millions of people in the country do not have access to safe drinking water and clear water for sanitation purpose. The development and over-population has created a lot of stress on water resources in the Kishangargh, especially in the district Ajmer.No future action plan has been formulated to solve the crisis of water. The village people have to go a long distance (500 meters) daily to collect water for their domestic purpose. In public places well is the main source of drinking water. The village people demand government help through MJSA scheme. The literacy rate of village is approximately 30 % which is low. Due to scarcity of water the village is less developed. The contribution of village people to solve the crisis of water is nil. The village people are keenly interested to construct a pond to meet their demand. Due to low forest cover extreme heat and less precipitation, the ground water level is going down day by day.
    [Show full text]
  • Social Entrepreneurship
    Skoll World Forum 2009 A quarterly journal published by MIT Press innovations TECHNOLOGY | GOVERNANCE | GLOBALIZATION Special Edition for the Skoll World Forum 2009 Social Entrepreneurship: Shifting Power Dynamics Lead Essays President Jimmy Carter The Hope of Our Future World Paul Farmer Three Stories, Three Paradigms, and a Critique Cases Authored by Innovators Matt Flannery Kiva at Four Mark Plotkin Changing the Landscape of Power Karen Tse From Fear to Hope commentary by Kenneth Neil Cukier Bunker Roy Empowering the Rural Poor to Develop Themselves commentaries by John Elkington; Martha Stone Wiske Martin Fisher Income is Development commentaries by Paul Polak; Julia Novy-Hildesley; Eric Simanis & Stuart Hart Analytic and Policy Articles Brian Trelstad Simple Measures for Social Enterprise Alex Nicholls Learning to Walk J. Gregory Dees Philanthropy and Enterprise FEATURING SKOLL SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURS innovations TECHNOLOGY | GOVERNANCE | GLOBALIZATION Introduction 3 Social Entrepreneurship: Power to Change, Power to Inspire Jeff Skoll 5 Framing the Change and Changing the Frame: A New Role for Social Entreprenuers Sally Osberg Lead Essays 11 The Hope of Our Future World President Jimmy Carter 19 Three Stories, Three Paradigms, and a Critique of Social Entrepreneurship Paul Farmer Cases Authored by Innovators 29 Kiva at Four Matt Flannery 49 Changing the Landscape of Power Mark J. Plotkin 63 From Fear to Hope: Upholding the Rule of Law via Public Defenders Karen Tse 89 Case discussion: International Bridges to Justice Kenneth Neil Cukier
    [Show full text]
  • Empowering the Rural Poor to Develop Themselves: the Barefoot Approach
    Bunker Roy with Jesse Hartigan Empowering the Rural Poor to Develop Themselves: The Barefoot Approach Innovations Case Narrative: Barefoot College of Tilonia Two roads diverged in a wood, and I— I took the one less traveled by, And that has made all the difference. —Robert Frost, “The Road Not Taken,” 1920 Empowering the rural poor means developing their capacity. It means developing their skills so they become competent decision-makers with the confidence to act on their choices. Thus far, conventional approaches to such empowerment have failed. The approach that big donors and Western-conditioned experts have taken to reach the poor—forget about allowing the poor to develop themselves—has been patronizing, top-down, insensitive, and expensive. It excludes the marginal- ized, the exploited, and the very poor and keeps them from making decisions on their own. Thus it disempowers them, leaving them dependent and hopelessly ill prepared to improve their lives. Moreover, these “patrons,” however well inten- tioned, have refused to learn from their mistakes. They are stuck in a rut that wastes money on a process that simply has not worked. But there is another way to empower the poor. It starts with giving the poor the right to decide for themselves how they want to improve their quality of life. They must have the right to choose whether they want the urban experts to come into their villages with “modern” ideas. They must have access to information and knowledge and the right to decide whether they would like to be independent of advice and skills from outside when they already have such incredible technical, Bunker Roy is the founder of the Barefoot College of Tilonia.
    [Show full text]