Assessment of Ecological Quality of Hot Springs in the Eastern Amhara Region Sisay Derso1*, Abebe Beyene2, Melaku Getachew3 and Argaw Ambelu2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Derso et al. Environ Syst Res (2015) 4:19 DOI 10.1186/s40068-015-0044-z RESEARCH Open Access Assessment of ecological quality of hot springs in the Eastern Amhara Region Sisay Derso1*, Abebe Beyene2, Melaku Getachew3 and Argaw Ambelu2 Abstract Background: Currently in Ethiopia, Ecotourism is expanding around hot springs, and the increasing recognition of the value of this smokeless industry suggests that there will be a rekindling of interest in thermal springs in the near future. The objective of this study is to examine the relationship between bird diversity with physicochemical water quality and habitat quality of hot springs in Easter Amhara Region. Methods: A cross sectional study of physical, chemical and biological components of the hot springs was carried out to assess their ecological status. Samples were collected from March to May 2013. Biological samples were collected to provide a qualitative description of the community composition of bird species at each sampling site. Water sam- ples were collected for analysis of selected physicochemical parameters following water quality assessment protocols. Results: A total of 2484 birds belonging to 56 species were recorded at the 12 sampling sites. Black headed Oriole (Oriolus larvatus), Spur Winged Lapwing (Vanellus spinosus), Spectacled Weaver (Places ocularis) and Yellow Wagtail (Motacilla flava) where the most abundant bird species in the study area and accounts 35 % of the total species. Human disturbance and habitant conditions varied considerably between sites in the study area. Conclusion: Although human disturbance and water pollution are among the factors influencing ecological quality, there are no strong correlations between physicochemical properties of hot springs and species diversity and this suggests that birds are not the major ecological indicator in hot springs. Keywords: Hot spring, Bird, Ecological status, Diversity, Eastern Amhara Background to be the cleanest of all. The study conducted on seven Thermal springs are the most under researched and hot springs in Ethiopian revealed that, the high value of underutilized of all natural resources in Ethiopia. Cur- chemical species, including bicarbonate, sodium, and rently in Ethiopia, Ecotourism is expanding around conductivity was reported. As a result, if the practice is hot springs, and the increasing recognition of the value not hygienic, the water may cause acute infectious diar- of this smokeless industry suggests that there will be rhea, repeat or chronic diarrhea episodes, and other non a rekindling of interest in thermal springs in the near diarrheal disease, which can arise from the chemical spe- future. The development around this recourse should be cies (Haki and Gezmu 2012). Furthermore, several stud- ecofriendly and take into accounts, its human and ani- ies have found that geothermal water may contain toxic mal health impact. A number of hotels and lodges are elements such as arsenic and mercury (Oliver et al. 2011). constructed on main hot springs, for instance, Sodere, The ecological quality and safety of surface waters still Wondo Genet and Filwuha. today suffer strong degradation because of anthropogenic Many Ethiopians believe that water from hot springs activities that directly impact the water body. Activity can relieve from a number of diseases and is considered related to agriculture, livestock, industry, and urban com- plex could alter surface water and its surroundings too. *Correspondence: [email protected] In addition, rivers continue to be used as recipients for all 1 Environmental Health Research Team, Ethiopian Public Health Institute, kinds of waste materials, which leading to eutrophication, P.O. Box 1242, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia organic pollution, acidification, and hydrological and Full list of author information is available at the end of the article © 2015 Derso et al. This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. Derso et al. Environ Syst Res (2015) 4:19 Page 2 of 13 hydromorphological alterations (Torrisi et al. 2010). A Moreover, the concentration of threatened avian spe- study conducted on the Borkena River of Dessie Kombol- cies is greater in the tropics than elsewhere. Of the 1029 cha that encompass many Eastern Amhara hot springs, threatened species, 884 occur in developing countries. indicated that the concentration of both conservative and Thus, the burden of conserving threatened species lies non conservative chemicals increase downstream of the on the developing nations, where resources are scarce for river in both dry and wet seasons (Beyene et al. 2009). effective conservation measures (Aynalem et al. 2008). Although water physicochemical analyses can pro- The objective of this study is to examine the relationship vide a good indication of the pollution level in rivers and between biological parameters (bird diversity) with phys- streams, these analyses do not consider the state of bio- icochemical water quality, habitat quality and human dis- logical communities. Therefore, end pipe testing cannot turbance of Hot springs in Easter Amhara Region. properly reflect the condition of freshwater ecosystems. In consequence, over the last decades, the use of biologi- Methods cal methods has been promoted and recommended as a Study area useful and complementary technique for the assessment The study was conducted in three zones of the eastern of freshwater pollution (Camargo et al. 2011). Using the Amhara region (Fig. 1) . The study area includes Shewa biological approaches to determine the ecological effects Robit Aregawi hot springs in Kewet district, Shekla and of pollution have more advantages than determining Borkena hot springs in Chefie Dolana district, and Harbu the pollution with just using physicochemical methods, hot springs in Kalu district. These areas located in rift because physicochemical variables give information valley regions which are known for several hot springs. about only the situation of water at the time of measuring Cheffa Wetland is located 300 km northeast of Addis (Rosenberg and Resh 1993). Ababa, the capital of Ethiopia in Oromia zone. The wet- Assessment of river health using biological methods land is located within 10°32′–10°58′ and latitudes and is currently common place in most temperate countries. 39 46′–39 56′E longitudes in the Borkena and Jara River Several of these methods have been standardized and Basins. Its total area is estimated to be 82,000 ha (Lang- included in national and regional monitoring programs ford et al. 2009; Tamene et al. 2000). The altitude of the (De Pauw et al. 2006; Hering et al. 2003) serving as a basis wetlands ranges from 1402 to 1520 m above sea level. for policy decisions concerning surface water manage- This wetland contains many hot springs, which are used ment. However, this is not the case in most tropical coun- for local community as means of traditional healing and tries, where physical, chemical methods, some of which as a source of drinking water for domestic purpose and require expensive laboratory analysis, are predominantly their cattle. Two main sites were selected, Shekla and used to assess surface water quality. Since most tropi- Borkena, based on their importance in this wetland. cal regions consist of developing countries, their lim- Shekla wetland is located at the entry of the main ited technical and financial resources for environmental Cheffa wetland and Borkena site is located at the exit issues constrain the establishment of national monitoring of Cheffa wetland. The Shewarobit Aregawi wetland is programs. Therefore, for these countries, including Ethi- located 220 km away from Addis Ababa, the capital of opia, cost effective monitoring programs are required. Ethiopia to Northeast direction in Kewet district, north After a process of adaptation, testing, and standardiza- Shewa. tion, biotic indices for biological entities can be reliable The Harbu hot spring sampling sites are located 370 km systems for application in river management of tropical away from the capital city of Ethiopia in the northeast regions (Dominguez Granda et al. 2011). Biological enti- direction in the Kalu district of South Wollo. ties (e.g. bird) are species rich, responds to a broad range Totally 12 sampling points were selected from the 4 of environmental conditions, and are relatively immobile main hot spring sites, i.e., three from each sampling site. and live in close contact with water body, thereby having Namely Borkena hot spring (B1, B2 and B3), Shekla (S1, the potential for exposure to stresses via both anthropo- S2 and S3), Harbu (H1, H2 and H3) and Shewarobit Are- genic and natural pathways (Brazner et al. 2007). gawi (A1, A2 and A3) were selected based on distance To ensure environmental sustainability in Ethiopia and the temperature gradient. water resources, ecological indicator systems can support The Oromo ethnic group constitutes the major- surface water managers to analyze the status of water- ity of the people living in the Cheffa Riverine plain and courses and to select critical restoration actions. In order Amhara dominated the Shewarobit Aregawi and Harbu to use biological indicator, including bird species as water areas in the