CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL fl CALCUTTA BENCH uRfiy No. O.A. 350/01324/2016 Date of order: 10.2.2017

Present : Hon'ble Ms. Jasmine Ahmed, Judicial Member

Shri Saikat Ghosh, Son of Balaram Ghosh, Aged about 24 years, Residing at Viii & P.O. Purbanawapara, P.S. Dhantala, Dist- Nadia, Pin- 741501, State of , Written Examination Roil No. 4120360.

Shri Bidhan Roy, Son of Tanu Roy, Aged about 26 years, Residing at Vill & P.O. Taranipur Colony, P.S. Swarupnagar, Dist- North 24 Parganas, Pin- 743273, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roil No. 12235948.

3. Shri Sadananda Biswas, Son of Basudeb Biswas, Aged about 28 years, Residing at Viii. Sankarpur, P.O. & P.S. DhantaIa, Dist- Nadia, Pin- 741501, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roil No. 41105411.

Kahita Barman, Daughter of Narugopal Barmn, Aged about 27 years, Residing at Viii. Ramkrishna Paily, P.O. Akaipur, P.S. Gazole, Dist- Maida, Pin- 732124. State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No.32124267.

Shri ManOtosh Biswas, son of Tusta Charan Biswas, Aged about 27 years, Residing at Viii, Bhadrashila, P.O. & P.S. Itahar, Dist-Uttar Dinajpur, Pin- 733128, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roil No.32123687.

Shri Ashis Kumar Mondal, Son of Dwarik Nath Mondal, Aged about 39 years, Residing at Viii. Gaza, P.O. Poaii, 2

P.S. Nodakhali, Dist- South 24 Parganas, Pin- 743318, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No.121011291.

Shri Anirban Kundu, Son of Late Ashutosh Kundu, Aged about 32 years, Residing at 17, Bagmari Lane, C.l.T:,B.R.S.- 10 Block- 15, Flat No. 10, P.O. Kankurgachi, P.S. Maniktala, Kolkata- 700054, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 12208165.

Shri Premananda Mandal, Son of Ashananda Mandal, Aged about 33 years, Residing at Vill. Pathabinagar, P.O.- Dharmadanga, P.S. Bamangola, Pin- 782138, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 52239868.

Shri Mithun BISWaS, Son of Baburam Biswas, Aged about 25 years, Residing at Vill. Marnalpur, P.O. Purbanawapara, P.S. Ohantala, Dist- Nadia, Pin- 740501, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 31222053.

Sadhana Sarkar, Husband of Manoj Roy, Aged about 23 years, residing at Vill. Dakhin Belbari, P.O. Belbari, P.S. Gangarampur, Dist. Dakhin Dinajpur, Pin - 733 124, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 41102927.

Shri Mahesh Roy, Son of Banamali Roy, Aged about 32 years, Residing at Vill. Bahadi Pur, P.O. , P.S. Bamongola, Dist. Malda, Pin - 732138, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 31240527.

Dipa Roy, Daughter of Mukunda Roy, Aged about 25 years, Residing at Vill. Salalpur, P.O. Pakuahat, P.S. Bamangola, Dist. Malda, Pin —732138, 3

State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 52229103.

Shri Joyram Mondal, Son of Utsab Mandal, Aged about 38 years, Residing at VIII. Mirajpur, P.O. Pakuahat, P.S. Bamangola, Dist. Malda, Pin 732138, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 51240939.

Shri Hiren Mondal, Son of Pulin Mondal, Aged about 32 years, Residing at VIII. Tetulbari, P.O. Pakuahat, P.S. Bamangola,

Dist. Malda, Pin - 7321380 State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 21230994.

Shri Sumon Sarkar, Son of Jagannath Sarkar, Aged about 26 years, Residing at VIII.. Jangal Gram, P.O. Madanpur, P.S. Chakdaha, Dist. Nadia, Pin —741245, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 42210916.

Shri Malay Kanti Biswas, Son of Rebati Ranjan Biswas, Aged about 36 years, Residing at VIII. & P.O. Pakuahat, P.S. Bamangola, Dist. Malda, Pin - 732138, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 32112628.

Shri Krishna Das, Son of Nitai Das, Aged about 28 years, Residing at Vill. NaiayahUr, P.O. Narayanpur, P.S. Haringhata, Dist. Nadia, Pin - 741249, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 32230167.

Shri Nilkamal Biswas, Son of Gajen Biswas, Aged about 25 years, jc

4

Residing at VIII. Balidanga, P.O. Chanak, P.S. Mongalkote, Dist. Burdwan, Pin-71313l, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No, 22128102.

19., Shri Kartick Das, Son of Umapada Das, Aged about 28 years, Residing at VIII. & P.O. BIrudih P.S. Kanksa, Dist. Burdwan, Pin —713148, State of West Bengal, Written Examination Roll No. 31234486.

20. Sarjina Khatun, Daughter Naimuddin Mandal, Aged about 28 years, Residing at Viii. & P.O. Gobinda Pur, P.S. Hanskhali, Dist. Nadi, Pin-742505, Written Examination Roll NO. 41126192.

All the applicants are unemployed.

Applicants

- VERSUS-

Union of , service through the General Manager, Eastern Railway, Fairlie Place, Kolkata - 700 001.

The Chief Personnel Officer (Recruitment), Eastern Railway, Fairile Plaee, Kolkata 700 001

. The Chairman (Rectt.), Railway Recruitment Cell, Eastern Railway, 56, C.R. Avenue, RITES Builditig, 1st Floor, Kolkata —700,012.

4. The Senior Personnel Officer (Rectt.), Railway Recruitment Cell, Eastern Railway, 56, C.R. Avenue, RITES Building, 1st Floor, Kolkata - 700 012.

Respondents

For the Applicant Mr. J.R. Das, Counsel For the Respondents None

ORDER(Orall Per Ms. Jasmine Ahmed, Judicial Member:

Mr. J.R. Das, Ld. Counsel for the applicant prays and states that the fact and issue of this matter is completely identical and similar in nature with

O.A. No. 926 of 2015 which was decided by this Tribunal vide its order dated 1.9.2015 and also by a common order passed in O.A. No. 154/2015,

O.A. No. 252/2015, O.A. No. 242/2015, O.A. No. 583/2015, O.A. No.

353/2015 and Q.A. No. 350/00424/2015 vide its order dated 25.6.2015.

The Ld. Counsel for the applicant states that as the present matter in hand is completely covered by the judgments already passed by this

Tribunal, he would be happy and satisfied if a direction is given by this

Tribunal to consider and dispose of this case in the Ught of the JLdgftièht passed in O.A. No. 926 of 2015, O.A. No. 154/2015, O.A. No. 252/2015,

O.A. No. 242/2015, O.A. No. 583/2015, O.A. No. 35 3/20 15 and O.A. No.

350/00424/2015 respectively.

Accordingly, taking into consideration the statement given by the Ld.

Counsel for the applicant at Bar, I feel that the O.A. could be disposed of very well at the admission stage itself with a direction to the applicantsto prefer a fresh representation attaching a certified copy of this order within

15 days from the date of receipt of a copy of this order and the respondents are directed to consider and decide the case in hand within a period of three months in the light of the judgments passed in O.A. No. 926 of 2015, O.A. No. 154/2015, O.A. No. 252/2015, O.A. No. 242/2015, O.A.

No. 583/2015, O.A. No. 353/2015 and O.A. No. 350/00424/2015

4. Accordingly with the above said direction, the O.A. is disposed of in the admission stage itself. It is made clear that nothing has been commented on the merits of the case.

(Jasmine Ahmed) Judicial Member sP