Standing with Dr. Timnit Gebru — #Isupporttimnit #Believeblackwomen
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Google Walkout For Real Change 810 Followers · About Follow Sign in Get started Standing with Dr. Timnit Gebru — #ISupportTimnit #BelieveBlackWomen Google Walkout For Real Change 2 days ago · 83 min read We, the undersigned, stand in solidarity with Dr. Timnit Gebru, who was terminated from her position as Sta Research Scientist and Co-Lead of Ethical Articial Intelligence (AI) team at Google, following unprecedented research censorship. We call on Google Research to strengthen its commitment to research integrity and to unequivocally commit to supporting research that honors the commitments made in Google’s AI Principles. Until December 2, 2020, Dr. Gebru was one of very few Black women Research Scientists at the company, which boasts a dismal 1.6% Black women employees overall. Her research accomplishments are extensive, and have profoundly impacted academic scholarship and public policy. Dr. Gebru is a pathbreaking scientist doing some of the most important work to ensure just and accountable AI and to create a welcoming and diverse AI research Deld. Instead of being embraced by Google as an exceptionally talented and prolic contributor, Dr. Gebru has faced defensiveness, racism, gaslighting, research censorship, and now a retaliatory Dring. In an email to Dr. Gebru’s team on the evening of December 2, 2020, Google executives claimed that she had chosen to resign. This is false. In their direct correspondence with Dr. Gebru, these executives informed her that her termination was immediate, and pointed to an email she sent to a Google Brain diversity and inclusion mailing list as pretext. The contents of this email are important. In it, Dr. Gebru pushed back against Google’s censorship of her (and her colleagues’) research, which focused on examining the environmental and ethical implications of large- scale AI language models (LLMs), which are used in many Google products. Dr. Gebru and her colleagues worked for months on a paper that was under review at an academic conference. In late November, Dve weeks after the piece had been internally reviewed and approved for publication through standard processes, Google leadership made the decision to censor it, without warning or cause. Dr. Gebru asked them to explain this decision and to take accountability for it, and for their lackluster stand on discriminatory and harassing workplace conditions. The termination is an act of retaliation against Dr. Gebru, and it heralds danger for people working for ethical and just AI — especially Black people and People of Color — across Google. Research integrity can no longer be taken for granted in Google’s corporate research environment, and Dr. Gebru’s Dring has overthrown a working understanding of what kind of research Google will permit. This is also a moment of reckoning beyond Google. As we know, Dr. Gebru is one of the few people exerting pressure from the inside against the unethical and undemocratic incursion of powerful and biased technologies into our daily lives. This is a public service, and its importance cannot be overstated. Google’s retaliation against Dr. Gebru, and its move to silence this work, concerns us all. We have the following demands of Google Research leadership: 1. We demand that Je Dean (Google Senior Fellow and Senior Vice- President of Research), Megan Kacholia (Vice-President of Engineering for the Google Brain organization), and those who were involved with the decision to censor Dr. Gebru’s paper meet with the Ethical AI team to explain the process by which the paper was unilaterally rejected by leadership. 2. We demand transparency to the broader public, including Google users and our colleagues in the academic community, about Google leadership’s decision to order Dr. Gebru and her colleagues to withdraw their research on large-scale language models. This has become a matter of public concern, and there needs to be public accountability to ensure any trust in Google Research going forward. 3. We demand that Google Research make an unequivocal commitment to research integrity and academic freedom, drastically strengthening the commitments made in Google’s Research Philosophy, and commit to supporting research that furthers the goals of Google’s AI Principles by providing clear guidelines on how research will be reviewed and how research integrity will be respected. To add your name to the list of academic, civil society, and industry supporters (Googlers, see go/stand-with-timnit): 1. Email [email protected] from your institutional email address (preferred) with the subject line “support” 2. Include your name and abliation, as you’d like it to appear on the list of signatories. Signed, 1534 Googlers and 2196 academic, industry, and civil society supporters Googlers include: Aaron Homer, SWE Aaron Sy, Software Engineer Aaron Zakem, Software Engineer Abi LaBounty, Site Reliability Engineer Adam Klein, Sta< Software Engineer Adam Paszke, Research Scientist Adam Pearce Adesola Sanusi, Product Manager Aditi, Software Engineer Adji Bousso Dieng, Research Scientist Adriana R , Global Mobility Adrien Kunysz, Systems Engineer Aekta Shah, UXR JEDI (Justice, Equity, Diversity and Inclusion) Alan McAvinney, Software Engineer Alan Morales, Site Reliability Engineer Alberta Devor, Software Engineer Alec Glassford Alex Hanna, Senior Research Scientist Alex Liu, Software Engineer Alex Saiontz, Product Manager Alex Zani, Software Engineer Alexander D’Amour, Senior Research Scientist Alexander Gorban, Senior Research Scientist Alexandra Camargo, Software Engineer Alexios Mantzarlis Alice, Software Engineer Alice Crawford, Site Reliability Engineer Alice Lemieux, Software Engineer Alicia Chang, Technical Writer Alison C. Allie Miller, UX Researcher Alyssa McDevitt, Software Engineer Alyssa Vessey, Software Engineer Amber Zhang, Software Engineer Amy Unruh, SWE Ana Rocha, News Product Experience Strategist Anass Koudiss, UX Programme Manager Andan Lauber, Technical Program Manager Andrea Dunlap, Makani Archivist Andreas C. Schou, Sta Privacy Engineer, Machine Learning Andreas Haas, SWE Andreas S., Software Engineer Andrew Blatner, Firmware Engineer, Verily Life Sciences Andrew Fitz Gibbon, Developer Advocate Andrew Gainer-Dewar, Ph.D., Software Engineer Andrew Gorcester, Developer Programs Engineer Andrew Sherman, Software Engineer Andrew Smart Andrew Zaldivar, Ph.D., Senior Developer Relations Engineer, Ethical AI, Google Research Andy Blank, Software Engineer Andy Schneider, Software Engineer Andy Walner, Product Strategy Angela Chen, Software Engineer Angela Pablo, UX Designer, Equity Engineering Angelica Pando, Software Engineer Angjoo Kanazawa, Research Scientist; Assistant Professor, EECS UC Berkeley Aniran Chandravongsri, Software Engineer Ann Fernandez, Google Children’s Center Educator Anna Greenwood, Program Manager Anna Wysen Annamaria Andolino, Ads Policy Lead Annie Sullivan, Sta Software Engineer AnsonZ Anuraag K Ariel Koren, Product Marketing Manager, Google for Education Arkanath Pathak, Software Engineer Ashe Robinson, Software Engineer Ashley Alese Edwards, US Partnerships Manager, News Lab Atish Agarwala, AI Resident Austin Myers, Software Engineer Ayan Daniels, Design Lead Bart van Merriënboer, Research Scientist Baruch Tabanpour, Software Engineer Becca Milman, SWE Becca Roelofs, Research scientist Becky Norling-Ruggles, SWE Ben Calabrese, Senior Software Engineer Ben Kellogg, Software Engineer Ben Lickly, Software Engineer Ben Love, Sta SRE Ben Packer, Software Engineer Ben Poole, Research Scientist Benjamin H. Benjamin Wolf, Senior Software Engineer/Tech Lead Bharath S, Software Engineer Bobby Dygert, Senior Software Engineer Bonnie Zhou, Software Engineer Brandon Parrott, Program Manager Brian Ichter, Research Scientist Brian Nachbar, Software Engineer Brianna Groenhout Britny Herzog, Program Manager Bryan Seybold Caitlin Donhowe, Software Engineer Caitlyn Britt, Software Engineer Caroline Ho, Software Engineer Caroline Liu, Software Engineer Cassandra Cruz, SWE Catherina Xu, Product Manager Cathy Mao, Program Manager Cecilia Rabess, Data Scientist Cesar Francisco Ibarra, SWE-SRE Channing Kimble-Brown, Software Engineer Charles Tam, Software Engineer Chelsea Price-Gallinat, Inclusion Lead, Google Children’s Center Chewy Shaw, Site Reliability Engineer Chieu Nguyen, Computational Linguist Chris Barrick, Cloud AI Solutions SRE Chris Demeke, Product Manager Chris Koch, Software Engineer Chris Palmer, Software Security Engineer Chris Torres, Product Technology Manager Chris Wilson Christian Biesinger, Senior Software Engineer Christian Brunschen, Software Engineer Christine Htoon, Program Manager Christopher Anderson, Senior Software Engineer Christopher Chestnut, SWE Christopher Schmidt, Senior Software Engineer Christopher Suter, Senior Software Engineer Christy Cui, Software Engineer Claudia McKenzie Clay Murphy, Technical Writer Clayton Robbins, Diversity Equity Inclusiveness Program Manager Colden Cullen, Software Engineer Cole Murphy, Software engineer Colin Bottles, Analyst Coline Devin, Research Scientist Colm Buckley, Engineering Director Conan Dooley, Privacy Engineer Conner Kasten, Software Engineer Connor Regan, Senior Analyst, YouTube Policy Conrad Parker, Software Engineer Cortney Cassidy, Visual Designer and design ethics advocate Craig Chasseur, Senior Software Engineer Craig Citro, Damien Desfontaines, Senior Software Engineer Dan Ellis, Research Scientist Dan Nanas, Program Manager Dana Jansens, Sta Software Engineer Daniel Dressler, Software Engineer Daniel Lucio, Community