DOCSLIB.ORG

Rabbi Gil Student Search Engine

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Rabbi Gil Student Search Engine Search Engine Finding Meaning in Jewish Texts Volume 1: Jewish Life Rabbi Gil Student Search Engine © Gil Student, 2018 ISBN: 978-1-947857-04-9 Paperback Edition All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in printed reviews, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means (printed, written, photocopied, visual electronic, audio, or otherwise) without the prior permission of the publisher. The Publisher extends its gratitude to Rabbi Yeshayahu Ginsburg for his assistance with this project. Letter from Rav Menachem Genack, CEO of OU Kosher Letter from Rav Shlomo Aviner, Rosh Yeshiva of Yeshivat Ateret Kohanim Letter from Rav Yitzchak Breitowitz, Rav of Kehillat Ohr Somayach ק''ק אהבת תורה Woodside Synagogue Ahavas Torah 9001 Georgia Avenue Silver Spring, MD 20910 4 Kislev 5778 21 November 2017 Rabbi Emeritus Yitzchak Breitowitz For almost 15 years, first in Hirhurim and now in Torah Musings, Rabbi Rabbi Gil Student has educated, inspired and entertained thousands of people Moshe Walter with his perceptive and comprehensive essays on halacha, Jewish thought and Jewish history. He is one of the true pioneers in harnessing the power of President the internet to convey the timeless and eternal truths of the Torah and it is Richard Sassoon no accident that his blogs have been consistently recognized for their Vice President for Administration excellence. Chanoch Kanovsky For the second time, he has collected many of these pieces in book form. Vice President for Programming In almost 300 pages, R. Gil covers a wide variety of topics—marriage, Adina Gewirtz Shabbat and holidays, prayer, food, recreation, death. All of the essays, as Vice President for brief as many are (a concession to the diminished attention span of the Membership and Community Relations online generation!), are well-thought out, organized and cogent. He Alida Friedrich addresses his topics with clarity and roots his conclusions in authoritative Treasurer Jerry Saunders Torah sources. Moreover, his tone towards rabbonim and poskim, even Secretary those that he may disagree with, is consistently respectful. He debates Daniel Friedman ideas, not personalities. As such, both in style and substance, his work is a pleasure to read and is of real benefit not only to beginners but even to accomplished Torah scholars. May R. Gil continue to spread the Dvar Hashem in his “Yeshiva without walls.” Yitzchak A. Breitowitz Rav, Kehillat Ohr Somayach Jerusalem, Israel Letter from Rav Aharon Rakeffet, Rosh Yeshiva at RIETS Letter from Rav Arie Folger, Chief Rabbi of Vienna Table of Contents Preface . 14 Introduction . 17 Part 1: Marriage & Family The Super-Mitzvah to Have Children . 25 All-In-One Weddings . 30 Do Husbands Own Their Wives . 38 Equalizing and Nullifying Weddings . 42 Orphans and Affirmative Action . 46 Jewish Sexual Ethics . 51 When Did Jewish Childhood Begin? . 55 The Late Mohel . 57 Part 2: Jewish Education It’s All About Education . 60 Religious Zionism and Kollel . 64 Who Really Started Jewish Education? . 67 Are Kabbalah Classes Kosher? . 71 Part 3: Shabbos Shabbos Guides . 75 When is a Kiddush Not a Kiddush? . 82 Good Shabbos Afternoon . 85 Pass the Challah . 87 Medicine on Shabbos . 90 Working Out on Shabbos . 94 Disposable Diapers on Shabbos . 98 The Candy Wrapper Dilemma . 101 Is This Switch Kosher? . 106 Electric Sensors on Shabbos . 114 Combat Exoskeletons on Shabbos . 121 Pocketwatches on Shabbos . 126 Home Fires in Jewish Law . 131 Driving Under the Influence of Coffee . 137 Part 4: Jewish Holidays Seder on the Rooftops . 139 Buying Clothes During Sefirah . 142 Staying Up Most of the Night . 145 Learning Torah on Shabbos Erev Tisha B’Av . 148 Deodorant on Tisha B’Av . 151 Sheva Berakhos in a Sukkah . 153 Women Dancing with Torah Scrolls . 157 Is Every Day Thanksgiving? . 161 Is the Yom Ha-Atzma’ut Liturgy for Everyone? . 164 Dirty Laundry on Chol Ha-Moed . 170 When is Kiddush Levanah? . 173 Electric Menorahs Throughout the Year . 176 Part 5: Prayer Synagogue Dues: The Middle Path . 180 Why No Tefillin? . 187 Dew’s Disappearing Comma . 190 Mispronouncing Hebrew . 193 Bypassing Kohanim . 197 Ebola and Tefillin . 201 Three Steps Forward . 203 Pray with the Leader . 208 Rav Henkin on Carlebach Minyanim . 211 What to do about a Yarmulke #Fail . 216 The Short Minchah . 219 Pollard’s Blessing . 222 Prayer and the Longest Shiur . 227 Tzitzis at Ma’ariv . 230 Answering a Priest’s Blessing. 232 The Bencher App . 237 Turning a Lower East Side Church into a Synagogue . 240 Part 6: The Power of Speech Is Careful Language Possible? . 245 Preventing Damage . 250 Too Busy to Tell the Truth . 254 Hilkhos “Bli Neder” . 257 Swearing to G-d . 261 How to Undo a Minhag . 265 Lincoln’s Angry Letters in Jewish Law . 273 Denigrating the Dead . 277 There Is No Mitzvah to Be a Freier . 281 Part 7: Internet & Social Media Instagram and Jewish Law . 284 Skype and Jewish Law . 288 SoundCloud and Jewish Law . 295 Lashon Ha-Ra in the Internet Age . 302 Social Media for Shabbos . 306 Is the Fake Excuse App Kosher? . 310 Part 8: Food & Drink Wine in All Its Halakhic Glory . 315 Is Chinese Food on Xmos Kosher? . 318 Converts Immersing Utensils . 320 Demographics, Terumah, and Ingathering of the Exiles . 324 Rewashing After the Bathroom . 329 Part 9: Recreation & Hobby Chess in Jewish Law . 333 Video Game Idolatry . 337 Is Stand-Up Comedy Kosher? . 341 Is Powerball Kosher? . 343 Superheroes in Jewish Thought and Law . 348 Surviving Self-Endangerment . 359 Gun Ownership in Jewish Law . 362 Part 10: Death The 9/11 Memorial and Jewish Law . 368 Vehicular Homicide in Jewish Law . 372 Community Burial . 375 Abortion and Fathers’ Notification . 377 Part 11: Miscellaneous Nail-Biting in Jewish Law . 381 From Ethiopia to Shulchan Arukh . 387 Jews Attending Church . 389 Lift-and-Cut Shavers . 391 The Living Wage and the Working Poor . 394 Afterword . 396 Preface I thank God for allowing me to complete this book and pray that He allows me to continue learning and teaching. In 2004, I started the Hirhurim blog for publishing my Torah thoughts. To my surprise, the blog grew in popularity, starting an exhausting marathon of daily writing and publishing about Torah texts, laws, and thought. Along the way, co-bloggers added important content to the blog. Among them were Steve Brizel, Joel Rich, and R. Ari Enkin. I thank them for their years of contributions to the blog. The blog opened many opportunities for me, including speaking and writing for newspapers and magazines. In 2013, I dropped the blog format and transformed Hirhurim into an online periodical, titled Torah Musings, with an editorial board and more formal literary style. The editorial board includes R. Basil Herring and R. Moshe Schapiro. Efraim Vaynman does a lot of work on the website behind the scenes, often going above and beyond the call of duty. Regular contributors to the magazine include R. Gidon Rothstein, R. Daniel Mann, and Joel Rich. R. Micha Berger served as an invaluable early source of advice and editorial assistance during the transition to Torah Musings. I thank them all for their continued efforts to spread Torah. This book emerges from my contributions to Torah Musings over the past four years. 14 Search Engine Alec Goldstein of Kodesh Press served as the impetus for this volume. In addition to being a good friend, he is an excellent editor. His tireless work and precision has made this process a pleasure. I also thank Yesh Ginsburg for his editorial work on the book. It would be difficult for me to name every teacher who has influenced me or taught me, and I certainly do not want to imply that they agree with everything that I say or write. However, I would be negligent if I did not acknowledge their contributions to my education. What follows is a list of synagogue and school rabbis from whom I have learned: R. David M. Feldman, R. Ephraim Kanarfogel, R. Feivel Cohen, R. Mordechai Marcus, R. Yisroel Hirsch, R. Baruch Pesach Mendelson, R. Shalom Z. Berger, R. Yitzchak Goodman, R. Shlomo Stochel, R. Menachem Meier, R. Benzion Scheinfeld, R. Mordechai Willig, R. Hershel Schachter, and in particular R. Mayer Twersky. I also highlight the influence of R. Aharon Rakeffet and R. Menachem Genack. I thank them all for inspiring and educating me in the path of Torah. My lifelong friends, R. Daniel Z. Feldman and R. Benjamin G. Kelsen, have been constant sources of support and advice. I thank them for always being there for me. I would not be where I am, for better or for worse, without the dedication of two people who have set me on my current path: my mother and father. Their devotion to our family and Jewish education, and their encouragement for each of their children to grow in their own ways, serves as an inspiration to me and my children. And, of course, nothing in my life would have been possible without the loving patience and support of my wife, Miriam. She is a true partner in everything that I do. I thank her every day for bringing joy to my life. Our four children—Deena, Shea, Shmuly, and Tzaly—have always been blessings and sources of pride. Our 15 Search Engine family was recently joined by our son-in-law Dovid, and even more recently by our granddaughter, Ayala. We have so many blessings for which to be thankful. We pray for all their continued success in a Torah-infused life. Gil Student [email protected] 12 Kislev 5778 / November 30, 2017 16 Introduction I. Why Halakhah? Imagine if someone asked you to name the most important elements of Judaism or the most relevant parts, the things that really speak to you.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Rethinking Amalek in This 21St Century
    religions Article Rethinking Amalek in This 21st Century Steven Leonard Jacobs Department of Religious Studies, The University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL 35487-0264, USA; [email protected] Received: 16 May 2017; Accepted: 15 September 2017; Published: 18 September 2017 Abstract: Twice in the Hebrew Bible—Exodus 17:14–16 and Deuteronomy 25: 17–19—the ancient Israelites were commanded to “blot out” the memory of Amalek, their enemy for all time (as God intended to do as well). Yet, because these texts are a part of Jewish (and Christian) religious traditions, annually these passages are read in the synagogue on the appropriate Sabbath occasions in the annual reading cycle, and linked to the Festival of Purim that is based on the Book of Esther. Over the course of Jewish history, Amalek has served as the symbolic enemy of the Jewish people (e.g., Armenians, Nazis, Palestinians); indeed, all of the enemies of the Jews were and are understood to be descendants of the original Amalekites, and thus worthy not only of enmity but of destruction as well (e.g., Haman, Antiochus, Titus, Hadrian, Torquemada, Khmelnitsky, Hitler). Today, many of those in Israel allied with the so-called “settler movement” associated with right-of-center Orthodox Judaism and located among populations primarily of Palestinian Muslims, and Arabs view them as the descendants of Amalek as well, and thus sanction and legitimate their own at times violent actions and behaviors. At its most transparent level, responding to Amalek is a response to antisemitism, both historical and contemporary. This paper examines the history of Amalekut (“Amalek-ness”) within the Jewish (and Christian) religious tradition, the role of memory and forgetting of those survivors and their descendants traumatized by their enemies, the current manner of branding one’s enemies as descendants of Amalek, and whether, in truth, reconciliation is even possible among enemies of long standing.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 2: Who Is the Lubavitcher Rebbe?
    Can the Rebbe be Moshiach? Copyright © 2002 Gil Student – www.MoshiachTalk.com Chapter 2: Who is the Lubavitcher Rebbe? The first Lubavitcher Rebbe was R' Shneur Zalman of Liadi (1746-1812). He was a student of R' Dov Baer (The Maggid of) Mezeritch, who was in turn a student of the Baal Shem Tov. R' Shneur Zalman, the Alter Rebbe, led a group of Chasidim who called their movement Chabad. It was also called Lubavitch, after a town in Lithuania that was at one time the center of the movement. He had an illustrious lineage going back to Rashi and through him to King David. After the Alter Rebbe's death, his son R' Dovber (1773- 1827), the Mittler Rebbe, led the movement. Third in the line of Lubavitcher Rebbes was R' Dovber's nephew, R' Menachem Mendel (1789-1866). He is commonly known as the Tzemach Tzedek after the title of his highly regarded tshuvos (responsa). He led the movement through a very difficult time. The Czar in Russia was making life very difficult for Jews and R' Menachem Mendel tried to intervene with the government on behalf of his followers. After R' Menachem Mendel's death, his son R' Shmuel (1834-1882), the Rebbe Maharash, led Lubavitch. In turn, 20 Can the Rebbe be Moshiach? Copyright © 2002 Gil Student – www.MoshiachTalk.com his son R' Sholom Dovber (1860-1920), the Rebbe Rashab, took over after him. In 1920, R' Yosef Yitzchok Schneerson (1880-1950), the Rebbe Rayatz, took over the mantle of leadership of Lubavitch from his father.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 5: What Counter-Proofs Can Be Brought?
    Can the Rebbe be Moshiach? Copyright © 2002 Gil Student – www.MoshiachTalk.com Chapter 5: What Counter-proofs can be Brought? There are two types of proofs that are brought for the claim that a dead person can be Moshiach. The first type is passages from primary sources and the second is commentary on these sources. The former tries to demonstrate that Chazal considered it possible, or maybe even likely, that a resurrected figure can serve as Moshiach. The latter attempts to show that regardless of what we think the primary source actually says, there were commentators who may have thought differently. This distinction is important because it highlights that the value in a commentary’s statement rests totally on the weight of who the commentator is and not on what text the author is explaining. For example, if a relatively unknown twentieth century rabbi wrote a commentary on the Talmud Yerushalmi in which he says that Moshiach can come from the dead, we can only conclude from this that this obscure 67 Can the Rebbe be Moshiach? Copyright © 2002 Gil Student – www.MoshiachTalk.com modern commentator thought the idea was possible. We cannot deduce any more than that. This clarity in the relative value of proofs is crucial in making a final evaluation of the evidence. The texts that are generally brought revolve around statements that either Daniel, King David, or Moshe will be the future Moshiach. Since these righteous men are deceased we can infer that there is nothing in Judaism that contradicts the idea that Moshiach can come from the dead.
    [Show full text]
  • Challenging Messianism and Apocalyptism: a Study of the Three Surviving Messiahs, Their Related Commonalities, Problematic Issues and the Beliefs Surrounding Them
    CHALLENGING MESSIANISM AND APOCALYPTISM: A STUDY OF THE THREE SURVIVING MESSIAHS, THEIR RELATED COMMONALITIES, PROBLEMATIC ISSUES AND THE BELIEFS SURROUNDING THEM by Lilian Krawitz submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Literature and Philosophy in the subject BIBLICAL ARCHAEOLOGY at the UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AFRICA PROMOTER: PROF C L VAN WYK SCHEEPERS November 2010 I declare that: CHALLENGING MESSIANISM AND APOCALYPTISM: A STUDY OF THE THREE SURVIVING MESSIAHS, THEIR RELATED COMMONALITIES, PROBLEMATIC ISSUES AND THE BELIEFS SURROUNDING THEM is my own work and that all the sources that I have used or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged by means of complete references. SUMMARY: The thesis is concerned with two issues, modern messiahs and their appeal, namely the highly successful Rebbe M.M. Schneerson from Chabad; and hostile, modern day, militant messianists and their beliefs, namely the USA Christian evangelicals and their rapture belief. The study directs attention at the three successful (in the sense that their movements survived their deaths) Jewish Messiahs, the 1st century Jesus, the 17th century Sabbatai Sevi and the present day, but recently deceased (1994) Rebbe Schneerson. The focus in the study falls on the latter two Jewish Messiahs, especially Rebbe Schneerson and Chabad, from Crown Heights, New York, whose messianic beliefs and conduct the thesis has been able to follow in real time. The thesis argues that Rebbe Schneerson and Chabad‟s extreme messianic beliefs and praxis, and the marked similarities that exist between all three Jewish Messiahs and their followers indicate that Chabad will probably, over time, become another religion removed from Judaism.
    [Show full text]
  • The Next Generation of Modern Orthodoxy
    The Next Generation of Modern Orthodoxy Next Generation.indb 1 4/3/12 3:43 PM Chancellor of Yeshiva University, meets each year to consider major issues of concern to the Jewish community. Forum participants from throughout the world, including academicians in both Jewish and ah, Jewish educators, and Jewish communal professionals, gather in conference as a think tank to and disseminate a new and vibrant Torah literature addressing the critical issues facing Jewry today. gratefully acknowledges the support of the Joseph J. and Bertha K. Green Memorial Fund established by Morris L. Green, of blessed memory. OF 19 r10 draft 08 balanced.indd ii 9/23/2008 8:19:37 AM Next Generation.indb 2 4/3/12 3:43 PM The Next Generation of Modern Orthodoxy EditEd by Shmuel Hain Robert S. Hirt, Series Editor the michael scharf publication trust of the yeshiva university press new york Next Generation.indb 3 4/3/12 3:43 PM Copyright © 2012 Yeshiva University Press Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The next generation of modern orthodoxy / edited by Shmuel Hain. p. cm. -- (Orthodox Forum series) Includes index. ISBN 978-1-60280-206-3 1. Orthodox Judaism--Congresses. 2. Judaism--21st century--Congresses. I. Hain, Shmuel. BM30.N49 2012 296.8’32--dc23 2012013967 Distributed by KTAV Publishing House, Inc. 888 Newark Avenue Jersey City, NJ 07306 [email protected] www.ktav.com (201) 963-9524 Fax (201) 963-0102 v Next Generation front-chp 11 rev 2.indd 4 4/10/12 10:16 AM Contents Contributors xi Series Editor’s Preface xvii Robert S.
    [Show full text]
  • Can the Rebbe Be Moshiach?
    Can The Rebbe Be Moshiach? Proofs from Gemara, Midrash, and Rambam that the cannot זצל Rebbe be Moshiach by Gil Student Can the Rebbe be Moshiach? Copyright © 2002 Gil Student All rights reserved. This book may not be reproduced, copied, and/or distributed without prior permission in writing from the author. Contact at: [email protected] Portions of this book can be downloaded for free from http://www.moshiachtalk.com Universal Publishers/uPUBLISH.com USA • 2002 ISBN: 1-58112-611-5 www.uPUBLISH.com/books/student.htm Can the Rebbe be Moshiach? Preface 1 Introduction 3 Chapter 1: What is Moshiach? 9 Chapter 2: Who is the Rebbe? 20 Chapter 3: Is the Rebbe alive? 24 Chapter 4: Can a Dead Man be Moshiach? 46 Chapter 5: What Counter-proofs can be Brought? 67 Chapter 6: Is this Heresy? 92 Appendix A: Is Yaakov Avinu Alive? 101 Appendix B: Maharal on Moshiach’s Name 115 Index 124 Can the Rebbe be Moshiach? Preface: The light of the Torah is meant to dispel the darkness of ignorance. However, there are times when Torah is used to confuse rather than to enlighten. In these cases it is incumbent upon those who were blessed with knowledge to publicize the truth and dispel the darkness of falsehood. Eight years ago, there was a history professor who was widely acclaimed as one of the leading Modern Orthodox figures of the time. There are very few talmidei chachamim who are academics and this particular rabbi was a tremendous baal midos (refined individual) as well. Not being in his circle, I had never met him.
    [Show full text]
  • Table of Contents Elul5763.Qxd
    Elul 5763 Edah, Inc.©2003 The EdahJournal3:2 The Edah Journal ELUL 5763/CONTENTS Pesaq orPersuasion HalakhahandPesaq:Continued DiscussionOf" Values, COMMUNICATIONS Jonathan Sacks " Cultural DiversityWithoutMoralRelativism: REVIEW ESSAY Of BooksandBans A intheJewishDaySchool: Arts The CaseStudy An 1873ResponsumonEducation Amsterdam: LiepmannPhillipPrinsof To RaphaelHirsch Rabbi Sampson Bible Education andOverviewsInOrthodox Meta-Themes Avoiding Fear oftheForest: Reading: Torah andPublic Women Congregational DignityandHumanDignity: ARTICLES Editor's Introductiontothe CONTENTS Challenges ContemporaryDangersandProspective Mysticism: MedievalRoots And Escapism:ContinuedDiscussionof" Mysticism, Hasidism The Dignity of Difference: How to Avoid theClashOfCivilizations, Avoid The DignityofDifference:Howto Eugene Korn Yehuda Gellman,LippmanBodoff Yehuda David Shasha Marc B.Shapiro Ed Codish David Ellenson Esther OrensteinLapian Daniel Sperber Gil Student, Reuven Singer Gil Student, " " Elul 5763 Edition Halakhic Values: Jewish " by Editor's Introduction to Elul 5763 Edition Welcome to the Elul 5763 edition of The Edah Journal.No verses and commentary, at the expense of student inter- articles published in the Journal have generated greater est in and deeper comprehension of the text. The essay discussion than those in the Sivan 5761 edition authored offers a pedagogy of "extensive reading" to overcome by Rabbis Mendel Shapiro and Yehudah Herzl Henkin this tendency and enumerates an inventory of skills for analysing the halakhic issues surrounding
    [Show full text]
  • New Wine in Old Flasks: the Just Price and Price-Controls in Jewish Law
    Munich Personal RePEc Archive New Wine in Old Flasks: the Just Price and Price-Controls in Jewish Law Makovi, Michael 30 January 2016 Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/69549/ MPRA Paper No. 69549, posted 16 Feb 2016 12:01 UTC “New Wine in Old Flasks: the Just Price and Price-Controls in Jewish Law”1 Michael Makovi [email protected] Unaffiliated; recent BA graduate of Loyola University, New Orleans (2015, economics, BA, summa cum laude with university honors) Abstract: The halakhah (Jewish law) includes legislation aiming at might be called “social justice.” These halakhot (pl.) include the laws of ona'ah and hafka'at she'arim / hayyei nefesh – roughly analogous to the famous Medieval “just price” laws – as well as legal restrictions on middlemen and speculators. In the light of modern economics, these Jewish laws, like all attempts at price-fixing, are shown to be self-defeating; the means conflict with the ends sought. The conflict between religion and science is not limited to cosmology and biology, but may include economics as well. It is proposed that the halakhah be modified in such a way as to preserve – as much as possible – the integrity of both the halakhah and economic science alike; when an ethical system makes certain scientific presuppositions, it is sometimes possible to preserve the ethical system by disentangling it from its non-essential scientific presuppositions. Keywords: price controls; price fixing; just price; jewish business ethics; religious economics JEL Codes: A12, B11, D00, K20, P00, Z12 Louis Ginzberg once joked (1920: 97) that The devil, according to Shakespeare, quotes Scripture.
    [Show full text]
  • Rabbi Gil Student Search Engine
    Search Engine Finding Meaning in Jewish Texts Volume 2: Jewish Leadership Rabbi Gil Student Table of Contents Preface 13 Introduction 15 Chapter 1: Authority and Leadership 30 A Rabbi’s Role 32 Rabbinic Qualifications 36 What is Ordination? 42 Gradations of Authority 47 Who Can Be Called “Rabbi”? 51 Revoking Ordination 57 Revoking Ordination II 61 Undermining a Rabbi 66 The Repentant Rabbi 71 Chapter 2: Studies in Leadership 78 Learning from Moshe 79 Growth into A Rabbi 86 The President’s Rabbi 90 The Elected Official 95 How Should Jews Vote? 98 Religious Liberty 101 Religious Politicians 104 Is A Politician Allowed To Retire From Public Office? 111 Finding Inspiration In Politics 115 Chapter 3: Using Authority 119 A Rabbi’s Obligation 120 A Rabbi’s Method 127 A Rabbi’s Approach 133 Religious Law and Change 137 Religious Law and Historical Context 141 Contemporary Changes 144 Proposed Changes 148 Communal Impact of Strict Standards 153 Threatening Halakhah 161 Losing the Next Generation 164 The Israeli Chief Rabbinate: Why? 168 Determination of Jewish Status 175 The Decline and Fall of Local Rabbinic Authority 180 Chapter 4: Followership 207 The Need For A Rabbi 208 Communal Cynicism 214 Challenging Your Rabbi 217 Rating Your Rabbi 221 Retreating From Community: House Minyanim 226 Conversion Guidelines, Transparency, and Accountability 232 Conversion Control In Israel 237 Chapter 5: Community 242 Why Are There Jewish Denominations? 243 Secession 247 Crossing Denominational Lines 252 Will Charedi Ideology Change? 257 Why We Fight 260 The
    [Show full text]
  • The Decline and Fall of Local Rabbinic Authority
    6 The Decline and Fall of Local Rabbinic Authority Gil Student t he issue of rabbinic authority in the Modern Orthodox community is not a matter of how wide a rabbi’s authority spreads—whether his opinion is decisive on issues of aesthetics, politics, and so forth, or just on ritual.1 those were the subject of discussions held at previous Orthodox Forums and generally contrasted our (centrist) limited views with the more expansive conceptions on the religious right.2 today’s debate is whether rabbis have any authority at all. A rabbi who has shown himself to be wise will be consulted on issues ranging from the religious to the personal. His advice will be taken seriously because of his insight—but is it binding? When the issue is not halakhic, it is assumed in our community that his advice is nothing more than helpful suggestions. the question before us deals with halakhic issues. in the following three sections, i argue that there is a need for a personal halakhic decisor, that this guide should be your synagogue rabbi, and that today people often do not turn to their synagogue rabbi 86 Next Generation.indb 86 4/3/12 3:43 PM The Decline and Fall of Local Rabbinic Authority for halakhic guidance due to a variety of reasons. i then offer practical suggestions for changing the situation by establishing a partnership among rabbis, communal leaders, and roshei yeshivah.3 THE NEED FOR AUTHORITY Asking a Question the idea of asking a personal she’eilah on halakhic matters seems to be rooted in an explicit biblical passage: if there arise a matter too hard for you in judgment, between blood and blood, between plea and plea, and between stroke and stroke, even matters of controversy within your gates; then you shall arise, and go up to the place which the Lord your God shall choose.
    [Show full text]
  • Response to Prof. Marc B. Shapiro
    35 Response to Prof. Marc B. Shapiro By: ASHER BENZION BUCHMAN The most crucial issue that Dr. Shapiro raises in his response is his meaning in referring to the “Brisker” mode of study as “ahistorical,” and we look forward to his elaboration on the subject in a future Hakiraḥ article. But for the present he “strongly rejects” my charac- terization of the position he presents as “ridicule,” and says that “Readers should examine my words and determine if I have engaged in any such ridicule.” While Dr. Shapiro uses only respectful language in his book, the fact that he labels the “Brisker” method the “hagio- graphic approach” is sufficient reason for me to consider his opin- ions “ridicule.” In this very response he clarifies his position by not- ing (footnote 6): “One observer has remarked that the Chazon Ish judged R. Chaim’s interpretations of Maimonides ‘by the wrong crite- rion; he wanted to determine if they were true!’” I consider the “ob- server’s” statement ridicule and am surprised at Dr. Shapiro’s appar- ent approval. I also believe that a glance at the on-line reviews of “Mai- monides and His Interpreters” suggests that most of his readers un- derstood “ahistorical” along the lines that I did, and hence viewed it as a devaluation of “lomdus” as well as a claim that Mishneh Torah is not a work of great depth that demands the formulation of abstract principles in order to be properly understood. One scholar titles his review “Maimonides: The Unmasking of a Godol (Sage),” and begins his essay with “Marc Shapiro’s latest volume contributes
    [Show full text]
  • Advisor Guide
    ADVISOR GUIDE A BRIEF GUIDE TO HEL P ADDRESS THE ISSUES CONFRONTING MODERN R ELIGIOUS LIFE I NTRODUCTION: THE PURPOSE OF THE A DVISOR GUIDE This advisor guide is, as its name suggests, a guide. It does not provide the decisive answer to questions and it is not a script explaining what you must say, rather it provides a context in which to approach questions posed to you by NCSY teens. Since the tone, object, and context of people’s questions change, so will this guide. We hope to continue to add, edit and revise as necessary. If you have any questions, additions or comments you would like to share please contact: David Bashevkin 212. 613. 8247 [email protected] NCSY Advisor Guide Page 2 THE FORMAT OF THE AD VISOR GUIDE DEFINING THE MAIN CHALLENGE Each subject begins with a section entitled “Defining the Main Challenge”. This section will present what the main challenges are regarding a particular issue: What makes it controversial and why is it so grating to the modern teenager. FRAMING THE ISSUE The goal of the second section, entitled “Framing the Issue,” is not to present a certain approach but to foster a healthy and well informed discussion. New perspectives on approaching the issue at hand will be presented in this section. Special care will be taken so that the context in which to approach the issues are presented with a focus on brevity and clarity. FOR FURTHER THOUGHT The approaches and perspectives presented in the guide do not begin to even scratch the surface of the issues at hand.
    [Show full text]