Comparison of Intravenous Digital Subtraction Angiography with Radionuclide Ventilation-Perfusion Lung Scanning in Patients with Suspected Pulmonary Embolism
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Thorax: first published as 10.1136/thx.40.8.576 on 1 August 1985. Downloaded from Thorax 1985;40:576-580 Comparison of intravenous digital subtraction angiography with radionuclide ventilation-perfusion lung scanning in patients with suspected pulmonary embolism KC FLINT, N McI JOHNSON, A MANNHIRE, P DAWSON, S GEORGE, PJ ELL From the Medical Unit, the Department ofRadiology, and the Institute of Nuclear Medicine, Middlesex Hospital, London ABSTRACT Fifty one patients with suspected pulmonary embolus were studied by radionuclide ventilation-perfusion scanning and intravenous digital subtraction pulmonary angiography. In 31 patients the results of both investigations were reported as negative and in a further 11 both results were reported as positive, giving a concordance rate of 82.3%. In nine patients there was disagreement between the two investigations and an attempt to resolve this difference on the basis of clinical data was made. On this basis digital subtraction angiography would have falsely classified three patients as not having an embolus who were correctly identified by radioisotope scanning. Angiography would, however, have correctly classified four patients misclassified by ventilation-perfusion scanning. The relative merits of digital subtraction angiography and copyright. radionuclide lung scanning are discussed. Confirmation of the diagnosis of pulmonary embol- Digital subtraction angiography combines digital http://thorax.bmj.com/ ism remains a common but difficult clinical prob- imaging with computer subtraction techniques to lem.' 2 Accurate and early diagnosis is important provide arterial images after intravenous injection because of the considerable morbidity and mortality of contrast medium.'3 This technique will provide associated with both untreated embolisation34 and images of the pulmonary circulation after injection inappropriate anticoagulant treatment.56 of contrast medium via a central venous catheter.'4 Radionuclide pulmonary perfusion scans are sen- It therefore avoids the additional risk of cardiac sitive but lack specificity. Many chronic cardiac and catheterisation, which is responsible for most of the pulmonary disorders result in perfusion abnor- complications and the deaths that follow conven- malities indistinguishable from pulmonary embol- tional pulmonary angiography. In 31 patients who on September 30, 2021 by guest. Protected ism.7'8 With the addition of ventilation studies were subsequently investigated by pulmonary specificity can be improved, but in the absence of a angiography'5 digital subtraction angiography cor- characteristic pattern of mismatched defects diag- rectly identified 12 as having suffered pulmonary nostic accuracy may be low.9 II Pulmonary angiogra- embolism and excluded embolic disease in a further phy therefore continues to be the most specific test 18. The result was falsely positive on only one occa- for the detection of pulmonary emboli. The associ- sion. In another study'6 the sensitivity of digital sub- ated morbidity (1%) and mortality (0.5%) have, traction angiography after experimentally induced however, precluded its use in most patients and it is gelfoam embolisation in dogs was found to be 100% usually reserved for those with life threatening com- if defects in parenchymal staining during the capil- plications in whom aggressive treatment is being lary phase were taken into account. Even if the more considered." 12 specific criteria of demonstrating vessel cut off and intravascular filling defects are used, the method Address for correspondence: Dr N Johnson, Middlesex Hospital, compares favourably in sensitivity (75%) with London WlN 8AA. (Reprints will not be available.) radionuclide lung scanning. Accepted 22 February 1985 We have compared intravenous digital subtrac- 576 Comparison of intravenous digital subtraction angiography with radionuclide lung scanning 577 Thorax: first published as 10.1136/thx.40.8.576 on 1 August 1985. Downloaded from tion angiography with radionuclide ventilation- defects accompanied by a normal chest radiograph perfusion lung scanning, which is the most fre- and normal ventilation, and where perfusion defects quently used investigative technique in patients with were substantially larger than any corresponding suspected pulmonary embolism. radiographic abnormality with normal ventilation. Methods DIGITAL SUBTRACTION ANGIOGRAPHY Digital subtraction angiography was performed with Fifty one consecutive patients were studied. All a Technicare DR960 apparatus, which has a maxi- were referred to the Institute of Nuclear Medicine at mum field size of 22.5 cm. The framing rate used the Middlesex Hospital with the suspected diagnosis was 1.25 per second with a matrix of 512 x 512 of pulmonary embolism and gave informed consent pixels. to additional investigation. Sixteen were hospital An arm vein was selected in the antecubital fossa inpatients, 14 were outpatients and 21 were referred and a 5 Fr catheter with side and end holes was from outlying hospitals. The mean age of this popu- introduced by the Seldinger technique after local lation was 52 years, 26 were female, 21 were smok- anaesthesia. The catheter was advanced centrally ers and eight had spirometric evidence of airflow until the tip was situated in the superior vena cava. obstruction (FEV,/FVC ratio < 70%). On one occasion no suitable arm vein was available In all cases ventilation-perfusion lung scans and and the femoral vein was punctured and the catheter digital subtraction angiograms were performed tip placed in the inferior vena cava. Forty millilitres within 24 hours of each other. Each was reported of iohexol (Omnipaque 300) 300 mg iodine/ml were independently in the presence of a current chest injected at 25 ml per second. The patient was radiograph but without knowledge of specific clini- instructed to hold his breath in inspiration and cal details or the result of the alternative investiga- frames of the arterial, capillary, and venous phases tion. Digital subtraction angiograms were were recorded for later examination. reported in groups of 15-20 by two radiologists A posteroanterior view of the right lung was (AM and PD) in combination and ventilation- obtained followed by a 25° left anterior oblique view perfusion lung scans were reported in similar groups of the left lung, a 22.5 cm field being used. Further copyright. by two nuclear medicine physicians (SG and PE). oblique views of suspicious areas were obtained All patients were interviewed by an independent after a further injection of contrast material with a clinician (KF) and clinical features recorded. 15 cm field for elucidating specific problems. Our preliminary studies showed three characteris- VENTILATION-PERFUSION LUNG SCANS abnormalities in digital subtraction angiograms: tic http://thorax.bmj.com/ Ventilation study (1) Defects in the perfusion image during the capil- A Nuclear Associates xenon lung function unit was lary filling phase. During this phase of the digital used. Each patient inhaled 222 MBq (6 mCi) xenon subtraction angiogram, parenchymal staining is pro- 133 and images were obtained of the wash in, nounced and areas of oligaemia are easily seen. Such equilibrium, and wash out phases. Three wash out defects may correspond to areas of radiographic images were obtained: 0-1 min, 1-3 min, 3-6 min. abnormality (I) or they may not (II)-see figure 1. Increasing image acquisition time during wash out (2) Abrupt termination of pulmonary arteries with increases the sensitivity for gas trapping. All images diminished peripheral perfusion (III). (3) Filling were obtained in a posteroanterior projection. defects visible within the pulmonary arteries on September 30, 2021 by guest. Protected (IV)-figure 2. Perfusion study The last two abnormalities (III and IV), which are We gave albumin macroaggregrates labelled with commonly seen in experimental embolisation of the technetium 99m (140 MBq (4 mCi)) intravenously pulmonary arteries,'5 were taken to be specific for to each patient. Six planar projections were pulmonary embolism. The first type of abnormality acquired-posteroanterior, anteroposterior, right (perfusion defects) may or may not represent pul- and left laterals, and right and left posterior obli- monary emboli. To improve the specificity of such ques. All images were obtained with a gamma cam- defects they were interpreted in conjunction with a era having a large field of view-either a General chest radiograph. Multiple perfusion defects not Electric Maxicamera 400 AT or a Nuclear Enter- corresponding to areas of radiological abnormality prises Mk V LF. (Ilb) were reported as positive for pulmonary Ventilation-perfusion lung scans were reported embolism. Defects corresponding to areas of radio- according to conventional criteria. They were graphic abnormality (I) and single defects which did regarded as positive where there was one or more not correspond to such areas were reported as nega- segmental or two or more subsegmental perfusion tive (IIa). 578 Flint, Johnson, Mannhire, Dawson, George, Ell Thorax: first published as 10.1136/thx.40.8.576 on 1 August 1985. Downloaded from Results The results of the 51 digital subtraction angiograms and ventilation-perfusion lung scans are compared in table 1. In 31 patients the results of both investi- gations were reported negative and in 11 patients both results were reported as positive, giving a con- cordance rate of 82.3%. In nine patients there was disagreement between the two results. The clinical features, digital subtraction