Request for Proposals for Tuckpointing, Stone Replacement and Masonry Repair Rfp-Rh-14-007 Proposal Tabulation

REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR TUCKPOINTING, STONE REPLACEMENT AND MASONRY REPAIR RFP-RH-14-007 PROPOSAL TABULATION

NAME National Restoration, Inc. M One Limited, Inc. Poe Restoration & Waterproofing Co Meridian Group, LLC ADDRESS Keego Harbor, MI Detroit Oak Park, MI Washington, MI

Years in Business 10 years 20 years 18 years 67 years Years providing tuckpoint & masonry restore 10 years 20 years 18 years 50 years Full Time Employees 14 full time employees 45 full time employees 15 full time employees 5 full-time employees Part Time Employees 2 part time employees 0 part time employees 5 part time employees 8 part-time employees

Qualifications Current masonry repair contracts with Specializes in historical restoraction Skilled, trained & exp trades people; Oakland County and Oakland University. and completed many projects. Recently qualified, conscientious laborers, do job Long list of successfully completed completed historical restoration exterior correctly, efficiently, respectfully; historical resotration,masonry, caulking, of Old Federal building; Grand Rapids Safety in tool usage, quality of job, and waterproofing projects. Armory Bldg; Lansing WSU theater good supervision, satisfied customers

Experience Masonry maintenance contract with Concrete restoration, repairs, replmt, Family owned/operated/3rd generation Over 60 plus years experience in both Oakland County and Oakland University remove & replace joint sealants, restoration masons, knowledge gained commercial and residential renovations Housing, performing same kinds of work structural shoring, bldgs, parking decks, decades of restoration projects; employees we'd be performing for RH. Many decades dams, structural at least 20 years hands-on experience in experience performing historical, etc. trade; public projects schools to Fed govt

Experience working on historical structures Performed historical masonry restoration Numerous historical buildings; restored Numerous hist structures incl res, Have decades experience providing UofD Mercy, Edsel & Eleanor For House, first terra cotta high rises in Chicago, religious, education & govt bldgs; renovation to historic homes/bldgs Henry Ford Fair Lane Estate, MSU, GVSU, repairs to Detroit Windsor Tunnel, Old projects requiring adherence to Hist dating back over 150 years. Historic Ft. Gratior Lighthouse, Soo Locks, Federal Bldg; Grand Rapids, Armory Dists Comm or Nat Park Serv Preservation properties common place in cities such Schoolcraft College, Oakland County, Bldg; Lansing, etc Guidelines; understand hist significance as Detroit, Grosse Pointe, and others. Churches, Lighthouses, Municipalities, & sensitivity; employees skilled in mortar and private buildings. match by color & tooling & hardness; familiar w/ traditional materials & newer speciality products; maximum longevity

Supervision J Fletcher - General Mgr - 10 yrs Kelly Dallo-Pres Poe-VP, oversees field operations- Mike Parvor - lead masonry repair J. Cusin-Field Supervisor-20 yrs Dave Tycocki-VP 3rd general restoration mason Pete Divito - Owner/supervisor J. Fletcher - Field Supervisor - 15 yrs Steve Raymond-Superintendant Schumacher-mgmt degree, exp in Others as needed J. Fletcher - President - 30 yrs Scott Hunt- Masonry Foremen construction project mgmt

Products/Services Equipment List provided. Brick, block, and All equipmt & material utilized of highest Not one size fits all. Materails used Equipment as needed per task will be stone repairs and replacmeent, patching quality for masonry/historical restoration LaFarge, St Mary's, Glen-Gery, Belden, provided. Materials will vary depending tuck pointing, caulking, sealing, water- Only name brands which are industry Gen Shale, local reclaimed brick, ProSoCo, on application. proofing, clenaing, epoxy injections, standard will be utilized. Diedrich, Thoro, Sika, Mapei, Thoro, coating, leak repairs. Materials: mortar Conproco, GE Silicone, Dow Silicone, brick, block, stone, patching materials, Tremco; Fully qualified, exp & insured anchors, epoxy, waterprofing membranes to perform all work listed in RFP; Drainage board, adhesives, sealants, Equipment list provided to perform cleaners, concrete, structural steel, and work other materials as needed REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR TUCKPOINTING, STONE REPLACEMENT AND MASONRY REPAIR RFP-RH-14-007 PROPOSAL TABULATION

Work Plan Like to meet on-site with city rep to Inspect work to be performed, if anything Will respond within 24 hrs; review Provide timely quality service at a fair assess needs, discuss solutions, write out of ordinary city will be notified. scope of work, discuss methods, price to cities structures on an as up proposal w/scope of work. After Setup pedestrian containment. Perform reqs & costs. All work coordinated w/ needed basis receiving OK to proceed perform work work per masonry restoration industry City to accommodate time, noise, access in accordance with US Dept of Interior standards. Clean up job related debris. & other restrictions that impact City Preservation Briefs. employees, residents & guests. Make all reasonable effort to be flexible & efficient in conduct of work

Materials/Method of Basement Waterproofing Call Miss Dig, and discuss project with RH More than likely will require a cold Approach each job unique situation; Only effective way we have found to w/ cobblestone/fieldstone wall structures excavate and assess work area. applied waterproof membrane along Consider all factors incl current wall, excavate on exterior of wall. Clean wall Waterproofing solutions could vary w/ a protection board and drainage exist waterproofing, drainage, soil type thoroughly and apply a tar based water- depending on site and exact nature of layer. All areas will be cleaned per & solid grading. Frequently area can be proofer. Partial infill with stone to aid project, but could include using drainage manufacturers specifications and excavated, cleaned & repair, then in drainage. board, waterproofing memberance, installed per manufacturers specs. coated w/ fluid applied elastomeric drainage trenches, or any number of waterproofing membrane. Then assess other materials and methods. opts for repairing drainage mechanisms & repair appropriately; install protection board & backfill taking care to grade soil appropriately

Manufacturer's products Sika, Dow, Tremco, BASF, Jahn Restoration TREMCO, Dayton, Superior, BASF, LaFarge, St Mary's, Glen-Gery, Belden, All products will be at high quality and mortars, and many others depending on PROSOCO, Dow Coming, W R Meadows General Shale, locally reclaimed brick, meet State of MI standards. job and needs. ProSoCo, Diedrich, Thoro, Sika, Mapei, Conproco, GE Silicone, Dow Silicone, Tremco silicones & urethanes, Tremco waterproofing membranes & others

Rationale for use of specific manufacturer's Use only highest quality materials from All products used are the industry High quality materials that have proven Products will vary depending on products high quality manufacturers. Wherever standard for masonry restoration and themsleves to perform well w/ application possible, we use American made products. waterproofing. Material that we would consistent reliabiity & longevity; City's needs will often determine what use are the highest quality and would Higher quality materials that last longer product we use. Sometimes a more meet any Engineer/Architects specs. & perform better resulting in extended expensive products will carry longer maintenance intervals that ultimately warranty as an example. save money & headaches

Subcontractors N/A None Generally do not use subcontractors Delta Power Wash, Inc to pre-clean surfaces

References University of Detroit Mercy Riverside Park Place Condo - Ann Arbor Oakland County City of Warren REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR TUCKPOINTING, STONE REPLACEMENT AND MASONRY REPAIR RFP-RH-14-007 PROPOSAL TABULATION

Oakland County 41 Burroughs Lifts-Detroit Grosse Pointe Public Schools D&S Contractors St. Hugo of Hills Catholic Church MSU - East Lansing Hamtramck Public Schools Orion Construction Oakland University Housing Imlay City Façade Repairs Southwest Nonprofit Housing and College for Creative Studies - Detroit Muskegon Water Plant Development - Pontiac Michigan State University Cranbrook Institute The Community House - Birmingham City of Sturgis New Amsterdam Activation II-Detroit DIFCO Laboratories Enterior - Detroit Ypsilanti City Hall Façade

Availability Immediately As soon as weather permits Begin most jobs within 3 days/high Immediately priority or emergency jobs within 24 hrs

Warranty - Product/Work 2 year conditional labor and material 1 year for workmanship an material 3 yr warranty - covers replacements of Product warranties vary by manufacturer failure both labor and materials Work is warranted for a period of two years.

Insurance Requirements Yes Yes Yes Yes

Additional Comments

COST PROPOSAL: Brick Repair & Replacement $65.00 sq ft $85.00 sq ft $25.00 sq ft $55.00 sq ft Block Repair & Replacement $20.00 sq ft $75.00 sq ft $20.00 sq ft $40.00 sq ft Chimney Restoration $80.00 sq ft $115.00 sq ft * $100.00 sq ft $80.00 sq ft Terrazzo Wall Tile Repair & Replacement $36.00 sq ft $75.00 sq ft $35.00 sq ft $45.00 sq ft Tuckpoint - Stone Walls $19 sq ft $10.00 sq ft $8.00 sq ft $25.00 sq ft Tuckpointing - Historical Buildings $20.00 sq ft $12.00 sq ft $9.00 sq ft $30.00 sq ft Tuckpointing -General $3.90 lineal ft $10.00 lineal ft $2.20 lineal ft $20.00 lineal ft Basement Waterproofing-Cobblest/Fieldst $58.00 sq ft $25.00 sq ft does not include exc/backfill ** $8.00 sq ft + excavation $75.00 sq ft

Remove door/windows/repl w/ brick/block $40.00 sq ft $25.00 sq ft *** $5.00 sq ft+unit price of replacement $60.00 sq ft

Percentage of Increase - 2nd Year 2% 10% 0% 5% Percentage of Increase - 3rd Year 2% 10% 0% 5%

Additional Services Labor Rate - Bricklayer $74.50 Manlift Rental 45' $800.00/week Use of aerial lift $180.00/day Labor Rate - Laborer $58.00 65' $1,000.00/week Cartage of lift (each way) $200.00 ea way 85' $1,500.00/week Bob Cat $150.00/day SkyTrack $250.00/day Scissor Lift $225.00/day 185 air compressor $150.00/day Sand Blast Pot $100.00/day Power Washer $80.00/day REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR TUCKPOINTING, STONE REPLACEMENT AND MASONRY REPAIR RFP-RH-14-007 PROPOSAL TABULATION

Mortar Mixer $125.00/day

Exceptions/Alterations Any work requiring man lift over 8.5' will May recommend substitute product at Pricing does include motorized man require negotiation for pricing of eqpt no added cost; aerial lift cost if req'd; lift if needed to work at heights and work. Work not incl'd in proposal will be at T&M or mutually agreed job specific Any excavation and backfilling will price. require additional pricing/negotation. *Chimney restoration price inclds remove & repl brick & cap. If added tuckpting at applicable price **$8 inclds cleaning wall, appl of waterproofing & install protection board; one hrly rate (mutually agreed) for excavation; additional repairs may be extra ***Removing doors/windows price of $5.00 added to unit price to replace brick at $25/sf or block at $25/sf. REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR TUCKPOINTING, STONE REPLACEMENT AND MASONRY REPAIR - RFP-RH-11-013

Years in Business 5 years 11 years 27 years 7 years Years providing tuckpoint & masonry restore 5 years 11 years 27 years 7 years

Full Time Employees 10-20 full time 12 full time employees 18 seasonal full time employees 3 full time employees Part Time Employees 3 part-time 5 part time employees

Qualifications Specializes in historical restoration and Owners have over 20 yrs exp in masonry Member Bricklayer's Local 02 Michigan Been in masonry for 33 years. Trained in certified installer of many repair products restoration; certified w/ Jahn, Conproco, President D Cusack 39 yrs exp, VP C. brick, block, stone, tile, wet plaster. Conproco, Sika, etc. Tremco, Basf, Thoro, WR Grace and Cusack 33 yrs exp, All other employees Worked as union brick/block mason for WR Meadows. Pre-qualified w/ UM have extensive masonry restoration local contractors. Started own business experience subject to rigorous on job tr. done work for local contractors.

Experience Commercial/Municipal structures Tuckpointing, brick, block, limestone, terra Company works throughout MI & Been in masonry for 33 years. Trained in including high-rise buildings (swing cotta, fieldstone & cobblestone. Repair & surrounding states to provide quality brick, block, stone, tile, wet plaster. stage work) replmt all; repl sealant joints, repair & repl masonry restoration. Worked repeadetly Worked as union brick/block mason for structural steel; concrete repairs, rebld for St MI, MSU, UofM, numerous other local contractors. Started own business defective masonry colleges, churches, businesses, etc. done work for local contractors.

Experience working on historical structures Birmingham schools/school buildings Repair, repl & tuckpt brick, block, lime- References for historical restoration. Work on historical projects in Winkler from 1900-sealants, brick replacement stone, terra cotta, granite, fieldstone & Sessions Schoolhouse, Ionia, last year Mill, Masonic Block building in downtown tuckpointing, cleaning & sealers cobblestone. Lintel replmt. Structural restored Wright Opera Block in Alma. Rochester, Pine Grove (Wisner House). United Artists Building/downtown steel repairs. Masonry cleaning & sealing. Detroit, 18-story building - performed Masonry infill. Wall flashing & shelf angle Many historic jobs previously incl Fayette make safe repairs to structure from replmt. Sealant replmt. State Park, Ft Mackinaw, Voigt House swing stage Museum & Michigan Theatre

Supervision Todd - Office Contact S Hixson D Cusack - Project Manager Dietmar Hansen Tim - Field Operations R Hill C Cusack - Superintendent Nicholas Hansen (Mason) Erich Sievertsen (Mason)

Products/Services SIKA repair mortars/quikrete ready-mix All required services. Materials utilized in project will conform Use only high quality materials historical mortars/conproco mimic patch Products: mortar, stone patching mortar, to specifications. CMRI either owns or purchased from local vendors. Brick TBD/Prosoco sealer/Eacochem waterproofing & sealants. will rent any and all equipment needed cleaner Equipment: scaffolding, swing stages, to complete this project. water blasters, barricades, grinders, pick up trucks & various hand tools Brick replacement, limestone repairs limestone replacement, tuckpointing site mixed mortar, etc REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR TUCKPOINTING, STONE REPLACEMENT AND MASONRY REPAIR - RFP-RH-11-013

Work Plan All work to be performed around owner Evaluate work and provide a price. Job specific - to be determined Work will start with City approval and operations/work completed per MIOSHA Schedule with building manager. will be completed within allotted time guidelines & Arisco Company safety Provide safety barricades. Perform frame determined by City and Mr. Hansen. manual. Noisy Sawing operations, etc to work be accomodated as needed. Right of way & citizen access to be maintained during work program

Materials/Method of Basement Waterproofing Tuckpoint/patch all open voids; once Work from interior. Clean and prep wall, BASF products Waterproofing will consist of a parging w/ cobblestone/fieldstone wall structures full cure is achieved, power wash wall in apply thoroseal cement based coat of cementitious mortar and a preparation for fluid-applied water- waterproof coating coating of HLM 5000 or similar proofing. Use BASF HLM5000 liquid waterproofing membrane. waterproofing with drainage panel to divert water as needed.

Manufacturer's products SIKA/BASF/Quickrete/Prosoco/Eachochem ProSoCo, Jahn, BASF, Tremco and SIKA ProSoCo, Deidrich, Chemtrete, BASF St. Mary's Cement, Rockwell Lime

Rationale for use of specific manufacturer's Products we use specifically formulated These products are manufactured BASF has been field tested with HLM 5000 is a membrane that will products for historical structures, and provide for specific masonry applications successful results time after time. "rubberize" after being applied with a maximum vlaue when considering life trowel staying flexible allowing a little cycle costs movement for the foundation. We use a diamond clear to protect all masonry repairs against water penetration

Subcontractors None-self perform all work None None REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR TUCKPOINTING, STONE REPLACEMENT AND MASONRY REPAIR - RFP-RH-11-013

References Birmingham Public Schools Oakland County University of Michigan Butcher & Butcher Washtenaw County Botsford Hospital State of Michigan Bloomingdale Construction Glen Oaks Community College Jackson County Airport St. Joseph's Church Dillman & Upton Pinnacle Contracting Ann Arbor Housing Commission Wright Opera Block Oakland County Pioneer & Historical Soc. Redico Northeastern Illinois University Kathleen Bolio, Lisa Sage, Jay Fakhoury, Huron-Clinton Metroparks Mark McLocklin

Availability Anytime - weather permitting 1-Jun-14 As soon as weather allows Could begin within 2 weeks from date 40 degrees and rising of agreement.

Warranty - Product/Work Materials will include respective 1 year labor and materials 1 year warranty for both 2 year warranty on all brick, block work manufacturer's warranty. One year labor. 5 year manufacturer's warranty on on concrete and tuckppointing will select products give 6 month warranty.

Insurance Requriements Yes Yes Yes Yes

Additional Comments Please visit our website

COST PROPOSAL: Brick Repair & Replacement $49.00 sq ft $40.00 sq ft $175.00 sq ft $25.00 sq ft Block Repair & Replacement $19.00 sq ft $25.00 sq ft $85.00 sq ft $25.00 sq ft Chimney Restoration $64.00 sq ft $150.00 sq ft $150.00 sq ft $120.00 sq ft Terrazzo Wall Tile Repair & Replacement $9.00 sq ft $20.00 sq ft $175.00 sq ft $34.00 sq ft Tuckpoint - Stone Walls $29.50 sq ft $10.00 sq ft $28.00 sq ft $8.00 sq ft Tuckpointing - Historical Buildings $23.25 sq ft $12.00 sq ft $28.00 sq ft $8.75 sq ft Tuckpointing -General $3.89 lineal ft $3.50 lineal ft $8.50 lineal ft $2.20 lineal ft Basement Waterproofing-Cobblest/Fieldst $6.50 sq ft $15.00 sq ft $6.50 sq ft $8.00 sq ft plus excavating cost

Remove door/windows/repl w/ brick/block $50.00 sq ft $50.00 sq ft $75.00 sq ft $6.00 sq ft plus cost of CMU/Brick

Percentage of Increase - 2nd Year 3.50% 3% 5% 0% Percentage of Increase - 3rd Year 5% 3% 5% 0%

Additional Services See attached tool rates Clean masonry $1.35 sqft Paver repair and placement $16.00 sq ft Mason Sand $25.00 yd Seal masonry w/ clear, penetrating Landscape retaining wall $18.00 per block sealer $1.35 sqft Wet plastering interior/exterior $8.00 sq ft Cut out existing caulking, recaulk $6.00 lf staging wll be chg in addition to sq ft if job is smaller than 200 sq ft Sidewalks, curb, potholes and vertical REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR TUCKPOINTING, STONE REPLACEMENT AND MASONRY REPAIR - RFP-RH-11-013

PROPOSAL TABULATION NAME Arisco Contracting Group Boss Construction Cusack's Masonry Restoration, Inc. Rochester Masonry Design LLC ADDRESS Clinton Twp, MI Taylor, MI Hubbardstone, MI Rochester Hills, MI concrete resurfacing with MG Krete up to 1/2" thick $20.00 sq ft Aerial lift/mini excavator/bobcat $120.00 per day transport of equipment $200.00 to and $200.00 from destination. Foreman $55.00 hour Mason/Carpenter/Skilled Trade $50.00 hour Laborer $40.00 per hour Materials are at the cost (copy of receipt) plus 10% Exceptions/Alterations None No exceptions. Acknowledgement of Addendum #1 Prices given in proposal will cover items given in RFP. Might be a time where job requires product/process not shown above. AT that point recommendation will be made and will seek City approval. Prices for power equipment are given in case it should be needed and would be more cost efficient than scaffolding or excavating sub.