Writ Appeal Nos.1611/2019 & 2282-2365/2019
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 13 TH DAY OF APRIL, 2020 PRESENT THE HON’BLE MR.ABHAY S. OKA, CHIEF JUSTICE AND THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ WRIT APPEAL NOS. 1611/2019 & 2282-2365/2019 C/W WRIT APPEAL NOS. 1272/2019, 1481-1519/2019 & 2761-2769/2019, 1520/2019, 1540-1566/2019, 1567-1601/2019, 1602-1604/2019, 1612-1618/2019, 1619/2019 & 2744/2019, 1620/2019, 1621/2019, 1623-1628/2019, 1629-1653/2019, 1679-1680/2019, 1681-1682/2019, 1704/2019,1765-1792/2019, 1794-1825/2019, 1846/2019, 1872-2214/2019, 2266-2267/2019, 2272/2019 & 2918-2972/2019, 2280-2281/2019, 2465/2019 & 2928-2937/2019, 2466/2019, 2467/2019, 2468/2019, 2546/2019, 2547/2019, 2656-2659/2019, 2667/2019, 2683/2019, 2745/2019, 2778/2019 & 2913-2915/2019, 2779/2019 & 2898-2900/2019, 2814/2019, 2823-2831/2019, 2909/2019, 2910/2019 and 2911/2019 (L-MW) WRIT APPEAL NOS.1611/2019 & 2282-2365/2019 IN W.A. NOS. 1611/2019 & 2282-2354/2019 BETWEEN 1. PRIVATE HOSPITAL & NURSING HOMES ASSOCIATION PHANA, KMC 2, 1ST FLOOR, VIDYABHAVANA 16/6, MILLER TANKBUND ROAD, VASANTH NAGAR BANGALORE - 560052 REP. BY ITS: PRESIDENT/ NOW HONORARY SECRETARY, DR.RAVINDRA - 2 - 2. HEALTHCARE GLOBAL ENTERPRISES LIMITED KALINGA RAO ROAD SAMPANGI RAMA NAGAR BANGALORE - 560002 NOW REP. BY ITS: CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER MR. S. RAJARAJAN 3. MALNAD HOSPITAL AND INSTITUTE OF ONCOLOGY NO 600/601,OPP. TO PANCHMUKHI ANJANEYA TEMPLE IRWIN ROAD, MANDI MOHALL MYSURU - 570001 NOW REP. BY ITS: P & l HEAD MR. JAYARAM M. 4. BHARATH HOSPITAL AND INSTITUTE OF ONCOLOGY NO.438, OUTER RING ROAD, HEBBAL MYSORE-17 NOW REP. BY ITS MEDICAL SUPERINTENDENT MR. MS.S. VISHWESHWARA 5. GOKAVI MATERNITY AND GENERAL HOSPITAL GOKAVI MATERNITY AND GENERAL HOSPITAL BESIDES BASEL MISSION CHURCH NEAR CHANNAMMA CIRCLE KARWAR ROAD HUBLI - 580029 REP BY ITS PROPRIETOR DR.PUSHPA E GOKAVI 6. AMARJYOTHI HOSPITAL AMARJYOTHI HOSPITAL, 1 ST CROSS SHANTICOLONY KAMALAPUR, YADAW A ROAD DHARWAD – 580001 REPRESENTED BY ITS: PROPRIETOR DR. UMA.J.SULTANPURI 7. DR. N.B.PATIL HOSPITAL DR N.B.PATIL HOSPITAL, MULANDNAKA GADAG 582103 NOW REP. BY ITS: MANAGING PARTNER MR.PAVANKUMAR N. PATIL - 3 - 8. NAREGAL NURSING HOME NO 23, SRI SIDDHARUDH-SWAMIMATH OLD HUBLI-24 NOW REP. BY ITS: PROPRIETOR DR. SHARATCHANDRA GOVIND NAREGAL 9. DR. BIJAPUR HOSPITAL DR. BIJAPUR HOSPITAL, OPP ESI HOSPITAL ARVINDNAGAR, KARWAR ROAD OLD HUBLI - 580029 REP BY ITS: PROPRIETOR DR. BIJAPURA KHAWAJA MAINUDDIN 10. DR L.S. KULKARNI CENTRE FOR CHILD CARE DR. L.S.KULKARNI CENTRE FOR CHILD CARE VIKAS NAGAR, HUBLI - 580021 REP. BY ITS: PROPRIETOR DR. ABHIJITH L KULKARNI 11. SUSHRUTHA MULTI SPECIALITY HOSPITAL AND RESEARCH CENTRE (P)LTD SUSHRUTHA MULTI SPECIALLITY HOSPITAL AND RESEARCH CENTRE (P)LTD,P.B.ROAD, VIDYANAGAR, HUBLI - 580021 REP BY ITS: MANAGING DIRECTOR D.KADASIDDESHWAR GURUNATH BYAKODI 12. KASTURBA MATERNITY AND ORTHOPAEDIC HOSPITAL KASTURBA MATERNITY AND ORTHOPAEDIC HOSPITAL MULGUND ROAD, GADAG - 582103 REP BY ITS: PROPRIETOR DR. JAGADISH V BHOOMRADDI 13. NMR IMAGING PVT. LTD NMR CURIE CENTER DESHPANDE NAGAR, HUBLI – 580029 NOW REP BY ITS: CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER DR. RENATE SAMUEL 14. SHIVAKRUPA HOSPITAL AND INTENSIVE CARE UNIT SHIVAKRUPA HOSPITAL AND INTENSIVE CARE UNIT BEMBALGI COMPLEX, SRI SIDDAPPA KAMBLI ROAD - 4 - HUBLI - 580020 REP BY ITS: MANAGING DIRECTOR DR.ANIL KUMAR MAHANTAPPA BEMBALGI 15. TAVARGERI NURSING HOME PVT LTD TAVARGERI NURSING HOME PVT LTD, REGD OFFICE: NEAR K.C.PARK POST OFFICE DHARWAD NOW REP BY ITS: DIRECTOR DR.SRIDHAR PUJAR 16. HEBSUR HOSPITAL HEBSUR HOSPITAL DESHPANDE NAGAR HUBLI – 580029 REP BY ITS: PROPRIETOR DR.NAGAREKHA N HEBSUR 17. OUR LADY OF LOURDESCHARITABLE HOSPITAL OUR LADY OF LOURDESCHARITABLE HOSPITAL KELGERI ROAD, DHARWAD - 580008 NOW REP BY ITS: ADMINISTRATOR SISTER SAVITHA 18. DR S.R. RAMANAGOUDAR MULTISPECIALITY HOSPITAL DR S.R. RAMANAGOUDAR MULTISPECIALITY HOSPITAL MALAPUR CROSS ROAD DHARWAD - 580008 NOW REP BY ITS: MANAGING DIRECTOR DR. S.R. RAMANAGOUDAR 19. K.H. JITHURI HOSPITAL K.H. JITHURI HOSPITAL HOSU CROSS, HUBBALLI – 580021 REP. BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER DR. VENKATESH K. JITHURI 20. SHOBHA HOSPITAL SHOBHA HOSPITAL, GADAG 582101 NOW REP BY ITS: MANAGING DIRECTOR DR. N.S. BIRADAR 21. DR. GADAG HOSPITAL DR. GADAG HOSPITAL GADAG - 582101 - 5 - REP BY ITS: PROPRIETOR DR.SUNITA GADAG 22. VIVEKANANDA GENERAL HOSPITAL VIVEKANANDA GENERAL HOSPITAL HUBBALLI NOW REP BY ITS: PRESIDENT DR. KAMAL NAYAN K.MEHTA 23. ASHOKA HOSPITAL ASHOKA HOSPITAL, BEHIND AMRUTH THEATRE VIDYANAGAR, HUBLI 580021 REP BY ITS: MEDICAL PARTNER DR ASHOK V. BANGARASHETTAR 24. KERUDI HOSPITAL AND RESEARCH CENTRE KERUDI HOSPITAL AND RESEARCH CENTRE, BAGALKOT NOW REP BY ITS: MANAGING PARTNER DR. BASAVARAJ H. KERUDI 25. SHAKUNTALA NURSING HOME NOW KNOWN AS SHAKUNTALA MEMORIAL HOSPITAL & RESEARCH CENTRE, HOSUR NOW REP BY ITS: MEDICAL SUPERINTENDENT DR. VIJAY V. GADAGI 26. BASAPPA MULTI SPECIALITY HOSPITAL BASAPPA MULTI SPECIALITY HOSPITAL TURUVANUR ROAD CHITRADURGA - 577501 REP BY ITS: PROPRIETOR DR. RANGAREDDY S.B. 27. BHS LAKEVIEW HOSPITAL BHS LAKEVIEW HOSPITAL R.S. NO 73/7, CTS NO 11888 OPP. FIRST LAKE, GANDHINAGAR BELAGAVI - 590016 NOW REP BY ITS : MEDICAL DIRECTOR & CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER DR. VISHWANATH UPPALADINNI 28. HANJI HOSPITAL HANJI HOSPITAL, NO. 135 MANGALWAR PETH, TILAKWADI - 6 - BELAGAVI - 590006 NOW REP BY ITS: DIRECTOR ADMINISTRATION DR. ABHINANDAN M HANJI 29. VENUGRAM HOSPITAL PVT LTD VENUGRAM HOSPITAL PVT LTD NO.82 & 83, 2 ND CROSS, HINDU NAGAR NEAR 3 RD RAILWAY GATE BELAGAVI - 590006 REP BY ITS: DIRECTOR ADMINISTATION DR. SAYAK DANA 30. SPARSH HOSPITAL 29/P2, THE HEALTH CITY, HOSUR ROAD BOMMASANDRA INDUSTRIAL AREA BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560099 NOW REP. BY ITS: CHAIRMAN MR. SHARAN S. PATIL 31. BACC HEALTHCARE PVT LTD BACC HEALTHCARE PVT LTD. 7,EAST PART ROAD, KUMARA PARK EAST BANGALORE - 560001 NOW REP. BY ITS: VICE PRESIDENT DR. GAUTAM T. PRANESH 32. AGADI HOSPITAL AND RESEARCH CENTRE #35, H. SIDDAIAH ROAD, WILSON GARDEN, BANGALORE 560027 REP BY ITS: CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER DR. ANIL B. AGADI 33. NU HOSPITALS C.A.6,15 TH MAIN ROAD, 11 TH CROSS PADMANABHA NAGAR BANGLORE - 560070 REP BY ITS: CEO DR.AKSHAY DHAR 34. ANANYA HOSPITAL PVT LTD NO.389/44, 19 TH MAIN, RAJAJINAGAR 1 ST BLOCK BENGALURU, KARNATAKA 560010 - 7 - NOW REP. BY ITS: DIRECTOR DR M.J.RAJASHEKAR 35. SUGUNA RAMAIAH HOSPITALS PVT. LTD. 1A/87,DOCTOR RAJKUMAR ROAD 4TH N BLOCK, RAJAJINAGAR, BENGALURU KARNATAKA-560010 REP BY ITS: MANAGING DIRECTOR DR. R. RAVINDRA 36. RAVI KIRLOSKAR MEMORIAL HOSPITAL NO.19, 2 ND MAIN ROAD, PEENYA 1 ST PHASE BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560058 NOW REP BY ITS: MEDICAL DIRECTOR DR. J.C. NAGARAJU 37. PRISTINE HOSPITALS AND RESEARCH CENTRE NO.877, DR MODI HOSPITAL ROAD 2ND STAGE EXTENSION WEST OF CHORD ROAD, BENGALURU KARNATAKA - 560086 NOW REP. BY ITS: MANAGING DIRECTOR DR.HALGERE MALLIKARJUNA PRASANNA 38. SITA BHATEJA SPECIALITY HOSPITAL NO.8 AND 9, O’ SHAUGHNESSY ROAD LANGFORD GARDENS, BENGALURU - 560025 REP. BY ITS: MANAGING TRUSTEE DR.ARVIND BHATEJA 39. SRI SAI CLINIC AND MATERNITY OME 652, 46 TH A CROSS RD, 1 ST BLOCK RAJAJINAGAR BENGALURU KARNATAKA - 560010 REP BY ITS: PROPRIETRIX DR. (MRS) C PALANIAMMAL 40. PUNYA HOSPITALS INDIA PVT LTD 52, 80 FEET RING RD, A D HALLI BASAVESHWAR NAGAR, KHB COLONY BASAVESHWAR NAGAR,BENGALURU KARNATAKA – 560079 - 8 - REP BY ITS: MANAGING DIRECTOR DR. NAGARAJ B PUTTASWAMY 41. KALA HOSPITAL NO.1105, 5 TH CROSS ROAD NEAR SANJANA ICE CREAM TRIVENI RD, K N EXTENSION KAMLA NEHRU EXTENSION YESHWANTHPUR, BENGALURU KARNATAKA 560022 REP. BY ITS PROPRIETOR DR. H.R.KALAVATHY 42. BHAGWAN MAHAVEER JAIN HOSPITAL #17, MILLERS ROAD, CANTONMENT RAILWAY STATION ROAD KAVEREPPA LAYOUT VASANTH NAGAR,BENGALURU KARNATAKA - 560052 REP BY ITS: MEDICAL DIRECTOR DR M D MARKER 43. GUNASHEELA SURGICAL AND MATERNITY HOME 1, DEWAN MADHAVA ROAD OPP. M N KRISHNA RAO PARK NEAR BASAVANAGUDI POLICE STATION BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560004 REP. BY ITS PARTNER DR. RAJSEKHAR NAYAK 44. ANJAN NURSING HOME PVT LTD NO.138, AECS LAYOUT, SANJAYA NAGAR RMV EXTN., 2 ND STAGE, BENGALURU 560094 NOW REP BY ITS: MANAGER SRI R.S. IYENGAR 45. LAKSHMI NURSING HOME #567, CHOKKASANDRA T. DASARAHALLI, BANGALORE REPRESENTED BY ITS: PROPRIETRIX DR.MRS. MANGALA KEERTHI 46. ADITI MATERNITY AND GENERAL NURSING HOME 78, ARAKERE GATE, 1 ST CROSS - 9 - ARAKERE MICO LAYOUT BANNERGHATT ROAD BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560076 REP. BY ITS: DIRECTOR DR.PINAKI BISWAS 47. THE VENLAKH HOSPITAL #123, 5 TH MAIN ROAD CHAMARAJPET BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560018 REP. BY ITS: DIRECTOR DR.NARESH S GAEKWAD 48. MANJUSHREE NURSING HOME NO.20/70, ST. JOHNS ROAD OPP. RBANM ROAD, COMMERCIAL STREET BENGALURU - 560042 REP BY ITS: MANAGING DIRECTOR, DR.K.SOMNATH 49. YOGANANDA MULTISPECIALTY HOSPITAL 371, CJ VENKATESH DAS RD RK LAYOUT, 2 ND STAGE PADMANABHANAGAR BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560070 REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER DR CHNDRALEKHA JAGADISH 50. CHAN RE RHEUMATOLOGY AND IMMUNOLOGY CENTRE AND RESEARCH NO.149, 15 TH MAIN ROAD, WATER TANK ROAD TEACHERS COLONY, BASWESHWARA NAGAR, BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560079 REPRESENTED BY ITS: MEDICAL DIRECTOR DR. CHANADRASHEKARA S 51. DEVAGIRI HOSPITAL 2461, 24 TH CROSS ROAD, BANASHANKARI 2ND STAGE, OPP TO BDA PARK BENGALURU, KARNATKA – 560070 REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR DR. R.C. SUBHASH - 10 - 52. VINAYAKA HOSPITAL NO.110, STATE BANK OF MYSORE COLONY 1ST STAGE, 80 FEET ROAD BANASHANKARI, BENGALURU KARNATAKA - 560050 REPRESENTED BY ITS PARTNER DR M.G.ASHOK RAO 53. REPUBLIC HOSPITAL NO.5, LANGFORD GARDENS, BENGALURU KARNATAKA - 560025 REPRESENTED BY ITS: MANAGING DR.B.D.SHASHIDHAR 54. AMARIYOTHI NURSING HOME NO.491-C,CHINMAYA MISSION HOSPITAL ROAD OFF 100 FEET ROAD INDIRA NAGAR 1 ST STAGE BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560038 REPRESENTED BY ITS PROPRIETOR DR.P.S.SUNDEEP 55. FORTIS HOSPITALS LIMITED FORTIS HOSPITALS LIMITED 154/9, BANNERGHATTA ROAD, BENGALURU - 560076 NOW REPRESENTED BY ITS: ZONAL DIRECTOR DR PRABHAT KUMAR 56. M.S RAMAIAH HOSPITAL M.S RAMAIAH HOSPITAL BENGALURU - 560054 REPRESENTED BY ITS: CHIEF ADMINISTRATOR DR NARENDRANATH .V 57.