A Psychohistory of Ufos
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
the Skeptical Inquirer Quantum Theory and Psi: The Misuse of Science Philosophy and Parascience: Two Views Edges of Science / UFOlogy's Nonstandards Identical Twins / Pseudoscientific Beliefs VOL. !X NO. 1 / FALL 1984 $5.00 Published by the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal Skeptical Inquirer THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER is the official journal of the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal. Editor Kendrick Frazier. Editorial Board James E. Alcock. Martin Gardner. Ray Hyman. Philip J. Klass. Paul Kurt?.. James Randi. Consulting Editors Isaac Asimov. William Sims Bainbridge. John Boardman. John R. Cole. C. E. M Hansel. E. C. Krupp. Andrew Neher. James E. Oberg. Robert Sheaffer. Steven N. Shore. Managing Editor Doris Hawley Doyle. Public Relations Andrea Szalanski (director). Barry Karr. Production Editor Betsy Offermann. Office Administrator Mary Rose Hays. Computer Operations Richard Seymour (manager). Laurel Geise Smith. Typesetting Paul E. Loynes. Staff Joseph Bellomo. Stephanie Doyle. Ruthann Page. Alfreda Pidgeon. Cartoonist Rob Pudim. The Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal Paul Kurtz. Chairman; philosopher. State University of New York at Buffalo. Lee Nisbet. Executive Director: philosopher. Medaille College. Fellows of the Committee James E. Alcock, psychologist. York Univ.. Toronto; Isaac Asimov, biochemist, author: Irving Biederman, psy chologist. SUNY at Buffalo; Brand Blanshard, philosopher. Yale: Mario Bunge, philosopher. McGill University: Bette Chambers, A.H.A.; Milbourne Christopher, magician, author; F. H. C. Crick, biophysicist. Salk Institute for Biological Studies, La Jolla, Calif.; L. Sprague de Camp, author, engineer; Bernard Dixon, European Editor. Omni; Paul Edwards, philosopher. Editor. Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Antony Flew, philosopher. Reading Univ.. U.K.; Kendrick Frazier, science writer. Editor. THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER; Yves Galifret, Exec. Secretary. I'Union Rationaliste: Martin Gardner, author, critic; Stephen Jay Gould, Museum of Comparative Zoology, Harvard Univ.; C. E. M. Hansel, psychologist. Univ. of Wales: Sidney Hook, prof, emeritus of philosophy. NYU; Ray Hyman, psychologist, Univ. of Oregon; Leon Jaroff, Managing Editor. Discover; Lawrence Jerome, science writer, engineer; Philip J. Klass, science writer, engineer: Marvin Kohl, philosopher, SUNY College at Fredonia; Edwin C. Krupp, astronomer, director, Griffith Observatory; Lawrence Kusche, science writer; Paul MacCready, scientist/ engineer. AeroVironment, Inc., Pasadena. Calif.; David Morrison, professor of astronomy. University of Hawaii: Ernest Nagel, prof, emeritus of philosophy, Columbia University: James E. Oberg, science writer; W. V. Quine, philosopher. Harvard Univ.; James Randi, magician, author; Carl Sagan, astronomer. Cornell Univ.; Evry Schatz- man, President. French Physics Association; Thomas A. Sebeok, anthropologist, linguist. Indiana University; Robert Sheaffer, science writer; B. F. Skinner, psychologist. Harvard Univ.; Marvin Zelen, statistician. Harvard Univ.; Marvin Zimmerman, philosopher. SUNY at Buffalo. (Affiliations given for identification only.) Manuscripts, letters, books for review, and editorial inquiries should be addressed to Kendrick Frazier, Editor. THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER. 3025 Palo Alto Dr.. N.E.. Albuquerque, NM 87111. Subscriptions, change of address, and advertising should be addressed to: THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER. Box 229. Central Park Station. Buffalo. NY 14215. Old address as well as new are necessary for change of subscriber's address, with six weeks advance notice. Inquiries from the media and the public about the work of the Committee should be made to Paul Kurtz. Chairman, CSICOP. 3151 Bailey Ave.. Buffalo. NY 14215. Tel.: (716) 834-3222. Articles, reports, reviews, and letters published in THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER represent the views and work of individual authors. Their publication does not necessarily constitute an endorsement by CSICOP or its members unless so stated. Copyright CI984 by the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal. 3151 Bailey Ave.. Buffalo, NY 14215. Subscription Rates: Individuals, libraries, and institutions. $16.50 a year; back issues. $5.00 each (vol. I. no. I through vol. 2. no. 2. $7.50 each). Postmaster: THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER is published quarterly. Spring. Summer. Fall, and Winter. Printed in the U.S.A. Second-class postage paid at Buffalo. New York, and additional mailing offices. Send changes of address to THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER. BOX 229. Central Park Station. Buffalo. NY 14215. the Skeptical Inquirer Journal of the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal Vol. IX, No. 1 ISSN 0194-6730 Fall 1984 5 NEWS AND COMMENT AAAS Explores 'Edges of Science' / Young Scientists at AAAS / Comment from AAAS 'Edges' Chairman / Collective Meditation / Evolution in Texas Texts / 'Skipper Effect' / Bok Memorial Fund / Media and UFOs / New Skeptic Groups / SI Boost / In Brief 13 NOTES OF A PSI-WATCHER Koestler Money Down the Psi-Drain? by Martin Gardner 18 PSYCHIC VIBRATIONS Cayce and Health Faddists, John Keel's Mutants, and Paranormal Pets by Robert Sheaffer ARTICLES 24 Quantum Theory and the Paranormal: The Misuse of Science by Steven N. Shore 36 What Is Pseudoscience? by Mario Bunge 48 The New Philosophy of Science and the 'Paranormal' by Stephen Toulmin 56 An Eye-Opening Double Encounter by Bruce Martin 62 Natural Levels of Similarities Between Identical Twins and Between Unrelated People by W. Joseph Wyatt, Anne Posey, William Welker, and Carta Seamonds 67 Evidence for the Effectiveness of a Reading Program in Changing Beliefs in the Paranormal by Paul J. Woods 71 Pseudoscientific Beliefs of Sixth-Grade Students in the Charleston, S.C., Area by Aaron S. Adelman and Saul J. Adelman BOOK REVIEWS 75 Colin Wilson, The Psychic Detectives (Chelsea A. Manchester) 77 Otto Billig, Flying Saucers: Magic in the Skies (Michael R. Dennett) 79 SOME RECENT BOOKS 83 ARTICLES OF NOTE 88 FROM OUR READERS Letters from Catherine Clark, Timothy L. Gunn, Dana Richards, John P. Timmerman, Henry H. Bauer, Steuart Campbell, P. Naslin, Glenn T. McDavid, Hilary Evans, Charles J. Cazeau, George W. Earley, Antony Flew, Steve Bratteng, and Walter Hain. ON THE COVER: Illustration by Ronald Chironna © 1984. ILLUSTRATION: p. 25 by Ronald Chironna © 1984. PHOTOGRAPHS: pp. 3, 4, and 6 by Andrew Skolnick. News and Comment Exploring the Edges of Science at the A A AS: Nonconfrontational Views and Encounters ••THE EDGES of Science" it was much. You might theorize that a A called, and the half-day sym downed tree was caused by the weight posium at the annual meeting of the of an elephant who climbed and broke American Association for the Advance it. That would explain the broken tree. ment of Science (AAAS) in New York But you have now unexplained many City over the long Memorial Day week things already well explained by physics end was one of the best attended of the and physiology. meeting's several hundred sessions. The theories of Velikovsky can It wasn't clear whether the crowd explain the Bible, "but Velikovsky was attracted more by the relatively unexplains almost all of celestial exotic subject or by the presence on the mechanics and the conservation of platform of stars like Isaac Asimov. energy. The small amount of Arthur C. Clarke (a surprise guest), and explanation does not balance the large James Randi. not to mention (at a amount of unexplanation." slightly different position on the belief As for creationism, said Asimov. spectrum) the irrepressible UFOlogist it is far beyond the edges. "It explains J. Allen Hynek. nothing and unexplains everything!" In any event, the assorted hundreds In contrast, the edges of science heard a pretty good session, with some are characterized more by such things thing for nearly everyone, both in topic as lack of evidence (scientists have yet and approach. to discover any signs of extraterrestrial Asimov led things off with an intelligence, "but either way no serious informal yet elegant introductory dis unexplanation is involved") or an cussion. The edges of science are one almost total reliance on anecdotal evi thing, but what lies beyond the edges? dence (such as with UFOs). "where He proposed an "unexplanation" cri somehow you are always left with a terion. It is easy to make up a theory story." that explains everything, noted Isaac. The edges can also shift. They can Anyone can do it. Theories are cheap. either move "into the mainstream" The trick is to propose a theory that (meteorites or astronautics) or "fall off explains a lot without unexplaining too the edge" (the canals of Mars). ? THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER. Vol. 9 At Asimov Unexplanation criterion Clarke, at the invitation of sym could be kept secret lor even a week. posium chairman Roll Sinclair, popped Id alone <() or 40 years, said Arthur, in on the A A AS meeting between com "they don't know a damn thing about pleting the filming of his novel .''//" scientists" and beginning the filming of a new 13- Parapsychologisl Stanley Krippner parl l\ series. "'Arthur C Clarke's gave a plea that parapsychology, despite World of Strange Powers." He spoke all Us shortcomings, deserves to be mostly n| I I ON At one time, said properly investigated. He recounted Clarke, he took them seriously. "Now some of the case studies, observations. UFO's need a period of malign neglect " and psychological analyses of people The problem with IK) sightings,