Legislative Council

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Legislative Council 1188 LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL Wednesday 10 April 2002 ______ The President (The Hon. Dr Meredith Burgmann) took the chair at 11.00 a.m. The President offered the Prayers. APPROPRIATION (BUDGET VARIATIONS) BILL RACING LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (BOOKMAKERS) BILL Bills received. Leave granted for procedural matters to be dealt with on one motion without formality. Motion by the Hon. Michael Egan agreed to: That the bills be read a first time and printed, standing orders be suspended on contingent notice for remaining stages, and the second reading of the bills be set down as orders of the day for the next sitting day. Bills read a first time. COMMITTEE ON THE INDEPENDENT COMMISSION AGAINST CORRUPTION Membership The President reported the receipt of the following message from the Legislative Assembly: MADAM PRESIDENT The Legislative Assembly informs the Legislative Council that it has this day agreed to the following resolution— That Barry Robert O'Farrell be appointed to serve on the Committee on the Independent Commission Against Corruption in place of Michael John Richardson, discharged. Legislative Assembly JOHN MURRAY 9 April 2002 Speaker REGULATION REVIEW COMMITTEE Membership The President reported the receipt of the following message from the Legislative Assembly: MADAM PRESIDENT The Legislative Assembly informs the Legislative Council that it has this day agreed to the following resolution— That Kerry Arthur Hickey be appointed to serve on the Regulation Review Committee in place of Graham James West, discharged. Legislative Assembly JOHN MURRAY 9 April 2002 Speaker STANDING COMMITTEE ON STATE DEVELOPMENT Extension of Reporting Dates Motion by the Hon. Michael Egan agreed to: That the reporting date for the reference to the Standing Committee on State Development relating to Local Government Boundary Changes in Inner Sydney and Eastern Suburbs be extended to Friday 10 May 2002. 10 April 2002 LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL 1189 Motion by the Hon. Michael Egan agreed to: That the reporting date for the reference to the Standing Committee on State Development relating to Rhodes Peninsula be extended to Friday 31 May 2002. TABLING OF PAPERS The Hon. Carmel Tebbutt tabled the following papers: Law Reform Commission Act 1967—Report of the Law Reform Commission for the year ended 30 June 2001 Legal Profession Act 1987—Report of the Office of the Legal Services Commissioner for the year ended 30 June 2001 Ordered to be printed. BILLS UNPROCLAIMED The Hon. Carmel Tebbutt, according to sessional order, tabled a list of all legislation not proclaimed 90 calendar days after assent as at 9 April 2002. PETITIONS Local Government Boundary Changes Petition praying that the House conduct a public inquiry into the proposed local government boundary changes and ensure that a plebiscite takes place before any boundary changes are made, received from the Hon. Duncan Gay. Stem Cell Research Petition praying that the House support adult stem cell research and oppose the creation and use of embryos for stem cell extraction, received from the Hon. Duncan Gay. Freedom of Religion Petition praying that the House reject proposals to reform the Anti-Discrimination Act that would detract from the exercise of freedom of religion, received from Reverend the Hon. Fred Nile. PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS UNDER STANDING ORDER 18 Debate resumed from 9 April. The PRESIDENT: I will now hear debate on the point of order taken by the Minister on 19 March. The Hon. JOHN JOBLING [11.13 a.m.]: Madam President, thank you for taking the course of action you did and for allowing the House to debate this matter. As the Presiding Officer, it is imperative that you ensure that all the facts are before the House when you consider the point of order. The obtaining of an opinion is an important first step for members to consider the matter. We note that on this occasion an opinion has been obtained from Mr Knight, the Crown Solicitor. In considering the application of Standing Orders 18 and 19 the House must deal with a number of matters. The application of the standing orders was put forward by way of a point of order taken by the Leader of the House. The opinion that is before the House is just that: an opinion. It is the opinion of a learned person, but at this stage it is no more than an opinion relating to the application of certain standing orders. Standing Order 19 is very unusual. My research indicates that in the past 100 years that standing order has been used by this House on only two occasions to seek the production of papers. The first of those occasions was in 1905, when the House sought to have tabled all papers relating to the case of an imprisoned female child. The second occasion was in 1947 and 1948, when the House called for papers relating to the release from prison of Clifford Tasman Thompson. It is therefore apparent that the use of Standing Order 19 is quite unusual and that it is not called upon in haste. In his advice the Crown Solicitor notes that Standing Order 19 provides: 1190 LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL 10 April 2002 The production of Papers concerning the Royal Prerogative, or of Despatches or other Correspondence addressed to or emanating from His Excellency the Governor, or having reference to the Administration of Justice, shall be asked for only by Address to the Governor. The question to be asked is: What does Standing Order 19 mean? The House has an opinion before it that canvasses a number of issues but does not specifically draw what I believe to be firm conclusions. On the last occasion on which the Crown Solicitor offered advice to this House it was based on an 1842 opinion expressed in Tasmania. That advice was used by the current Leader of the House as the basis of the argument for non- production of papers. The advice was tested as an opinion—and I again stress that it was in opinion—in the case of Egan v. Willis, Evans, Cahill and Ors. Three courts found that the opinion was not correct, that it was flawed by reason of the passage of time and the many events that had transpired since the advice was provided. It is clear from the advice that the Crown Solicitor encountered a number of problems. He considers the application of Standing Order 19, and then deals with Standing Order 134, setting out the procedure by which an address to the Governor may be made. He also states that Standing Order 18, by contrast, provides that any papers may be ordered to be laid before the House and that the Clerk shall communicate any such order to the Premier's Department. The matter to be considered by this House is the interpretation of Standing Orders 18 and 19. In his advice the Crown Solicitor indicates that he found very little assistance in the historical material relating to Standing Order 19. The Crown Solicitor obviously had limited time to consider the matter, and therefore when considering his opinion one must question the depth of his research and whether the conclusions he draws are correct. When the Crown Solicitor refers to having not revealed an equivalent standing order for the Legislative Council in the compilation published in New South Wales Parliament in 1868, he is going back a fair way. He makes reference to Standing Order 26 and the order for papers to be communicated to the Colonial Secretary— which rather dates the validity of the historical record in this case. In his advising to us he concludes that Standing Order 19 appeared in the standing orders approved in 1895 and has remained in that form since then. As I said earlier, Standing Order 19 has, to my knowledge, been used only twice in the past 100 years. In his advising the Crown Solicitor indicates there is no equivalent of Standing Order 19 in the standing orders of the Legislative Assembly. Be that as it may, each House is a sovereign House, so no conclusion can be drawn from that fact. He says: There appears to be no precise equivalent in other jurisdictions, material requested by Address being restricted to matters relating to the Prerogative except in the Legislative Council in South Australia, which refers to both the Royal Prerogative and to Despatches and Correspondence. So, we are dealing with a standing order that is unique to this House. Therefore a great deal of care must be taken in the interpretation and understanding of that standing order and how it is to be applied. References are made in paragraph 3.2 of the advice to a quotation from the fourth edition of Erskine May, a somewhat dated volume, having been published in 1859, dealing with a practical treatise on the law, privileges, proceedings and the usage of Parliament. That edition of Erskine May states: PARLIAMENT, in the exercise of its various functions, is invested with the power of ordering all documents to be laid before it, which are necessary for its information. Each house enjoys this authority separately, but not in all cases independently of the Crown. It then refers to trade, finance, general and local matters, ordered directly or indirectly, and states that certain other matters in the exercise of the royal prerogative are obtained by addresses to the Crown. When one looks at the distinction between the two classes of returns, it seems from the advising that the principle is not always clear. This is indicated by the Crown Solicitor in his advising to the House. The question then is whether it applies to Treasury or whether it applies to matters that are to receive their orders from the Crown.
Recommended publications
  • From: To: Date
    Page 1 Simon Truong - Submission to North Ryde Station UAP Proposal From: "Mitch Geddes" <[email protected]) To: <[email protected]> Date: 51191201310:01 AM Subject: Submission to North Ryde Station UAP Proposal CC: <[email protected]>, <[email protected]>, "Jeff Salvestro-Martin" <jeff.salvestro-mafü[email protected]>, "Craig Chung" <[email protected]. au), " friendsofnorthryde" <fri endso fn orthry de @ä net. net. au> Attachments: DOPI_13051 5.pdf Attention : Director, Strategic Assessment Please see attached submission as an OBJECTION regards, Mitch Geddes BE(Hons), MAuslMM, JP Glades Bay Project Management & Engineering PO Box 3131, MONASH PARK LPO, NSW 21 1 1 [email protected] 0412 894 304 - 02 9416 1491 fi1e://C:\Documents and Settings\struong\Local Settings\TempU(Pgrpwise\519CA21... 2810512013 est.1999 ABN 62 485 017 638 DOP| 130515 15 May 2013 Director, Strategic Assessment NSW Department of Planning and lnfrastructure GPO Box 39 SYDNEY NSW 2OO1 Also by email: plan [email protected] Dear Sir/Madam, NORTH RYDE STATTON PRECINCT REZONING PROPOSAL (THE PROPOSAL) OBJECTION TO THE PROPOSAL ON MULTIPLE GROUNDS This proposal falls over on many grounds, but if for no other reason, it falls over on the question of traffic. The O'Farrell Government risks a dangerous precedent here with respect to the need for any traffic studies, for any reason, in the future. Notwithstanding both the overt and covert deficiencies in the Parsons Brinckerhoff report, if ever there was a traffic study urging "proceed with extreme caution, or indeed, don't proceed at all", it is fhrs traffic study.
    [Show full text]
  • Questions and Answers
    399 PARLIAMENT OF NEW SOUTH WALES __________ No. 30 __________ LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ____________________ SECOND SESSION OF THE FIFTY-SECOND PARLIAMENT ____________________ TUESDAY 4 APRIL 2000 (The Questions and Answers Paper published for the first sitting day in each week will contain, by number and title, all unanswered questions, together with questions to which answers have been received on the previous sitting and any new questions. On subsequent days, new questions are printed, as are questions to which answers were received the previous day. Consequently the full text of any question will be printed only twice: when notice is given; and, when answered.) Notice given on date shown 400 LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS Tuesday 4 April 2000 Publication of Question Answer to be lodged by Q&A No. 30 (Including Question Nos 299 to 307) 9 May 2000 401 LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS Tuesday 4 April 2000 9 NOVEMBER 1999 (Paper No. 19) *124 LOCAL GOVERNMENT—CULTURAL DIVERSITY—Dr Wong asked the Minister for Mineral Resources, and Minister for Fisheries representing the Minister for Local Government, Minister for Regional Development, and Minister for Rural Affairs— (1) What procedures have been put in place to ensure that councils co-ordinate services in accordance with the cultural diversity of the population? (2) What has been done by councils to encourage cross-cultural training to enable staff who work with people from culturally, linguistically and racially diverse backgrounds to develop the appropriate cross-cultural skills? Answer— (1) The Local Government (General) Amendment (Community and Social Plans) Regulation 1998 was introduced to promote a more inclusive community by ensuring that council services are responsive to community need and diversity.
    [Show full text]
  • NSDC Submission 20191119
    Northern Sydney District Council of Parents & Citizens Associations Submission: Schools at the Meadowbank Education and Employment Precinct Wednesday, 20 November 2019 Abstract The NSW Department of Planning, Industry and Environment has invited formal submissions on the State Significant Development Application for the new schools. In this submission the Northern Sydney District Council of P&C Associations (NSDC) outlines the probable requirement for the acquisition of additional land and the significant upgrade of Melrose Park Public School and Ermington Public School and the possible requirement for two additional primary schools within the Melrose Park precincts. NSDC identifies the requirement to build a new secondary school possibly for more than 2,000 students, ideally on the current site of Marsden High School, West Ryde. The NSW Government has announced that Marsden High School will be relocated to the new Meadowbank Education Precinct with capacity for 1500 secondary school students. The school will also include capacity for 120 students attending intensive English classes. In absence of demographic projections from the Department of Education, in conjunction with Marsden High School P&C Association, NSDC has performed a demographic analysis using a sophisticate demographic model based on ABS Census Data 2006-2016 for similar developments at Rhodes and Wentworth Point. This analysis has concluded that Meadowbank schools will be at capacity as early as 2023. The expansion of capacity at the Meadowbank campus addresses only the demographic growth resulting from the high density residential development at Meadowbank and Shepherds Bay plus demographic growth in existing suburbs in the eastern half of the current school catchment area.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2017– 18 Whatwe Do
    Annual Report 2017– 18 Whatwe do Our student scholarships address factors contributing to Support students who disadvantage: face social and economic disadvantage to achieve Students from low their full potential socio-economic through life-changing backgrounds scholarships. Indigenous students Provide professional Students from refugee development opportunities backgrounds to educators and school leaders to enable them to Students in rural and extend their leadership remote areas and teaching skills. Students living with a disability Enhance the value and reputation of Australia’s The Public Education Foundation is committed public schools, ensuring to helping break the every Australian has cycle of educational disadvantage and reducing access to a high-quality, inequality by supporting students and educators inclusive education. in Australia’s public education system. 2 PUBLIC EDUCATION FOUNDATION Contents Our Impact 2 Chair Report 3 Executive Director Report 4 Proudly Public Awards Night 5 2018 Public Education Foundation Scholarship Recipients 6 2017 Minister’s and Secretary’s Awards for Excellence 10 Scholar profiles 12 The Public Education Foundation Advocacy and Research 14 is a charity dedicated to providing life-changing scholarships to young people in Our People 15 public education, their teachers and principals. 2017-18 Financial Report 16 The Foundation is supported Board of Directors 20 by the NSW Department of Education and works in Donors & Supporters 21 collaboration with schools, communities, the private sector and the
    [Show full text]
  • ED088079.Pdf
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 088 079 CS 201 050 AUTHOR Watson, Ken, Ed. TITLE A. A. T. E. Guide to English Books, 1973. INSTITUTION Australian Association for the Teaching of English. PUB DATE 73 NOTE 100p.; Published for the Association by A. H. and A. W. Reed Pty. Ltd., New South Wales EDRS PRICE MF-$0,,75 HC-$4.20 DESCRIPTORS, *Booklists; Book Reviews; Composition (Literary); Drama; *Elementary Education; *English Education; *English Instruction; Language; Mass Media; Poetry; Prose; Rhetoric; *Secondary Education; Writing IDENTIFIERS *Australian Books ABSTRACT This annual publication lists and reviews books concerning teaching principles and practice, source books and course books, mass media, composition--writing--rhetoric, language and oral work, poetry, prose, drama, criticism, the retarded reader, and the migrant child. (LL) U S DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH EDUCATION & WELFARE N TIONAL INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION .. % PNO . Y NE ()F ROA: 4, ,,, 4, .4 4, NI J r$, A OP,YONS T f Dt, NoNI II S' , `r PkE N ' N .' ON NSTI"oif 01 F 'ON Po+1, CIP POt Min a A A Reading A Basic Guide for Parents and Teachers PAMELA McKEOWN The author considers in a practical manner the teaching of reading and also deals with the related problems of writing and spelling.Her study will be valuable for parents, prac- tising teachers and students.To be published shortly in cloth and paper. The Teaching of English in Schools 1900-1970 DAVID SHAYER This survey of English teaching in British schools since 1900 focuses on changes In classroom methods and in the teach- ing of English which have modified our school system.
    [Show full text]
  • Legislative Assembly
    New South Wales Legislative Assembly PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) Fifty-Sixth Parliament First Session Wednesday, 15 August 2018 Authorised by the Parliament of New South Wales TABLE OF CONTENTS Announcements.......................................................................................................................................... 1 South Coast Bushfires ............................................................................................................................ 1 Visitors ....................................................................................................................................................... 1 Visitors ................................................................................................................................................... 1 Members .................................................................................................................................................... 1 Legislative Council Vacancy ................................................................................................................. 1 Bills ............................................................................................................................................................ 1 Fair Trading Amendment (Short-term Rental Accommodation) Bill 2018 ........................................... 1 Returned ............................................................................................................................................. 1 Announcements.........................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Sydney Technical High School 2019 Annual Report
    Sydney Technical High School 2019 Annual Report 8141 Page 1 of 35 Sydney Technical High School 8141 (2019) Printed on: 1 June, 2020 Introduction The Annual Report for 2019 is provided to the community of Sydney Technical High School as an account of the school's operations and achievements throughout the year. It provides a detailed account of the progress the school has made to provide high quality educational opportunities for all students, as set out in the school plan. It outlines the findings from self–assessment that reflect the impact of key school strategies for improved learning and the benefit to all students from the expenditure of resources, including equity funding. School contact details Sydney Technical High School Forest Rd Bexley, 2207 www.sydneytech-h.schools.nsw.edu.au [email protected] 9587 5899 Message from the principal It has been a wonderful experience for 2019 to be relieving as Principal. I have been very grateful for the opportunity and I have worked industriously to continue the great work of our former principal, Jacqueline Lyons. I feel very privileged to work in such a great school and am very glad that I am able to motivate and challenge our students to develop their natural abilities and drive them to strive for their personal best. The school community suffered greatly with the tragic passing of our Year 7 student, but I think that the strength and resilience of the staff, the students and the community have allowed us to work together and support one another through the difficult times as well as supporting the family and our colleagues at Hurstville Public School.
    [Show full text]
  • ESHS Log 2017 Issue 4
    ENDEAVOUR SPORTS HIGH SCHOOL Taren Point Rd & The Boulevarde Caringbah NSW 2229 + 61 2 9524 0615 www.endeavour-h.schools.nsw.edu.au ISSUE 4 2017 ENDEAVOUR LOG Reports: • Extension Class • STEM • SKWAD • Library • Clontarf Principal Deputy Principal Deputy Principal • Mr James Kozlowski Ms Jocelyn Gooch Mr Ross Dummett TSP Athletics • TSP Cheerleading FEATURED ARTICLES • TSP AFL • TSP Tennis • TSP Hockey • TSP Netball • TSP Baseball • TSP Rugby League • TSP Rugby Union • TSP Football • TSP Swimming • TSP Cricket TSP Cheerleading • TSP Dance TSP Tennis TSP AFL • TSP Basketball DATES: 2017/2018 Term 4 Wed. 13 December Presentation Day Assembly Fri. 15 December Final day for students and TSP Hockey staff TSP Athletics Wed. 20 Dec. – Sun. 28 Jan. School Holidays Term 1 2018 Mon. 29 January Staff Development Day Tues. 30 January Yrs 7 11,12 students return Wed. 31 January Yrs 8, 9, 10 students return Coding with “Catch a Feast” SKWAD Click for 2017/2018 ESHS with Clontarf OZOBOT CALENDAR Message from James Kozlowski – Principal The Principal’s Year in Review - 2017 Dear Endeavour Family We end 2017 being able to reflect on a year where the successes exceeded even the most ambitious objectives. ACADEMIC SUCCESS Our commitment to academic excellence has been rewarded with some very impressive results, including our best NAPLAN scores on record. Our junior extension class program was expanded to accommodate this culture of success and we saw this desire for academic excellence filter throughout the year groups. QUALITY TEACHING We are endowed with a highly skilled and talented staff who are dedicated to adopting best practice.
    [Show full text]
  • Entire Bulletin
    NSW Association of Agriculture Teachers Dear members, 2018 has zoomed into term one with amazing speed. I hope everyone is travelling well and keeping the Ag education flag flying high and aiming for those blue ribbons! This year is setting out to be the busiest in years in Autumn 2018 Newsletter relation to changes in curriculum. The new Technology Mandatory syllabus would be in the forefront of all teachers and this is the biggest change in AG curriculum in nearly 20 years. NESA Presidents Message ........................................ 1 and DoE as planning to roll out a range of resources and workshops during the rest of the year. Your Meet the 2018 Executive ................................. 2 association is also planning a number of support PIEFA Conference .......................................... 5 workshops across the regions, so please watch out Cotton Tour ................................................. 5 for information coming out soon. OzHarvest’s New Program................................ 6 Very soon you will be receiving a survey regarding Social & Digital Media Policy ............................ 7 the expertise of members. The purpose of this is to Investigate Bees in 2018 .................................. 8 better assist all teachers by identifying the range of Telling Your Story ......................................... 9 knowledge and skills that we have a collective group Poultry Education Funding ............................... 9 that we can share with each other through mentoring of new teachers in regional areas. Careers @ Beef Week ................................... 10 UNE HSC Booster Days .................................. 10 We have made a number of improvements to the RACI Titrations Competition ........................... 11 website membership section and this has increased membership to the highest number of members in NSWAAT Conference 2019 .............................. 11 years. Thanks to you all for your support and if you April is Sugar Shake Month ............................
    [Show full text]
  • Legislative Assembly
    15516 LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Wednesday 27 June 2001 ______ Mr Speaker (The Hon. John Henry Murray) took the chair at 10.00 a.m. Mr Speaker offered the Prayer. BILLS RETURNED The following bills were returned from the Legislative Council without amendment: Corporations (Administrative Actions) Bill Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill Corporations (Ancillary Provisions) Bill HOUSING BILL Second Reading Debate resumed from 22 June. Mr HUMPHERSON (Davidson) [10.02 a.m.]: I lead for the Opposition on the Housing Bill. I will elaborate the Opposition's views on aspects of this bill. The bill proposes to consolidate the existing three Housing Acts into one Act. The objectives of the bill are to continue and expand the functions of the New South Wales Land and Housing Corporation, to merge the Home Purchase Assistance Authority into the corporation, and to dissolve the HomeFund Advisory Panel. The Opposition understands and appreciates those objectives and does not have any deep concerns about them. The revamped Land and Housing Corporation will have slightly redefined primary roles. Those primary roles will be to: provide public housing, including the provision of rental rebates; acquire and/or develop land for urban development or public purposes; make residential land available; promote orderly and economic urban development; manage the Home Purchase Assistance Schemes; and to act jointly or independently in providing housing and/or land, including to act as Landcom or as the Land and Housing Corporation. I understand that there are two primary changes in the bill. I thank the Minister for the time given to the Opposition to discuss those matters with his staff.
    [Show full text]
  • Legislative Council
    New South Wales Legislative Council PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) Fifty-Seventh Parliament First Session Wednesday, 29 May 2019 Authorised by the Parliament of New South Wales TABLE OF CONTENTS Business of the House .............................................................................................................................. 57 Conduct of Business ............................................................................................................................ 57 Motions .................................................................................................................................................... 57 Holocaust Remembrance ..................................................................................................................... 57 Documents ............................................................................................................................................... 57 Tabling of Papers ................................................................................................................................. 57 Rulings ..................................................................................................................................................... 58 Members Seeking the Call ................................................................................................................... 58 Notices ....................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • At Eastwood Plaza
    City of Ryde Media Release Thursday, 5 January 2006. COUNCIL SURVEY ASKS “WHAT MAKES RYDE TICK” Council is conducting a residents’ on-line survey during January to help produce a community snapshot and to gauge more accurately the feelings, aspirations and requirements of the people who live and work in the City of Ryde. Covering a wide range of issues, the on-line survey gives everyone the chance to comment on how they rate living in the area, the importance of various services and facilities provided, and what their vision for the future is. “Already, over 600 households in the district have responded to our Residents’ Survey,” said Council’s Acting General Manager, Kim Woodbury. “It’s a great way for people to express their likes, dislikes and views, in confidence, on a wide range of matters that affect them daily, from rates and rubbish, to the environment, employment or heritage issues. “It also provides Council with a report card on how the community rates our performance in managing the city’s resources, and will assist in our current and long-term planning. It also helps us to identify the kinds of services our community wants and needs.” The confidential, on-line Residents’ Survey (conducted by Taverner Research), takes about 15 minutes to complete and can be accessed on City of Ryde Website at www.ryde.nsw.gov.au (follow the prompts from the Home Page “Have Your Say”). Ends Media contact: Lee Kirkland, Media Officer, City of Ryde, T 9952 8083, M 0434 306 444 City of Ryde Media Release Tuesday, 10 January 2006 AUSTRALIA DAY CONCERT HAS SOMETHING FOR EVERYONE City of Ryde has begun preparations for the countdown to the Annual Australia Day celebrations at North Ryde Common.
    [Show full text]