The Marsi: the Construction of an Identity
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE MARSI: THE CONSTRUCTION OF AN IDENTITY by Inaki Sagarna Urzelai A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History Boise State University May 2021 © 2021 Inaki Sagarna Urzelai ALL RIGHTS RESERVED BOISE STATE UNIVERSITY GRADUATE COLLEGE DEFENSE COMMITTEE AND FINAL READING APPROVALS of the thesis submitted by Inaki Sagarna Urzelai Thesis Title: The Marsi: The Construction of an Identity Date of Final Oral Examination: 11 December 2020 The following individuals read and discussed the thesis submitted by student Iñaki Sagarna Urzelai, and they evaluated his presentation and response to questions during the final oral examination. They found that the student passed the final oral examination. Katherine V. Huntley, Ph.D. Chair, Supervisory Committee Erik Hadley, Ph.D. Member, Supervisory Committee Lee Ann Turner, Ph.D. Member, Supervisory Committee The final reading approval of the thesis was granted by Katherine V. Huntley, Ph.D., Chair of the Supervisory Committee. The thesis was approved by the Graduate College. DEDICATION For everyone who made my stay at Boise a marvelous and unforgettable experience. Anes, Amaias, Olatzs Miren, Mikel, Iker, Juan, Andres, Maria, Usue, Arantxa, Aintzane, Ander, Irati, Tim, Cristina, Sofia, Borja, Jon Ander, Ibai, Israel, Marta, Simon, Julia, Iñigo, Jon, John… The whole Basque Community cannot fail to appear in this long list, particularly, the entire team of the Basque Museum and the Basque studies professors, Nere and Ziortza, who deserve a very special acknowledgement. To this end, a last mention to all the students, either in the Euskera classes or at BSU that suffered my broken English. This is not the end though, I will be back for sure. Laister arte Boise. Last, but not least, I want to highlight a scholar to whom I owe a lot: Cesare Letta. My work may be read as a reaction against his postulates, and in a way, it is. However, this study would not be possible without all his previous work, which it is simply outstanding. The following thesis aims to offer a more nuanced approach to Marsian identity, but as he himself posed “la realtà storica non è mai semplice e i nostri sforzi per interpretarla raramente possono ricorrere con successo a linee nette, contorni definiti e tinte forti e unite.” iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENT A big thank you to the three members of my committee. Eric Hardley, Lee.Ann Turner and Katherine V. Huntley, who was a sedulous advisor. Without your guidance, this thesis would not be possible. v ABSTRACT Up until now Marsian cultural identity has been approached from an old-fashioned theoretical angle of autoromanizazzione (“self-Romanization” or “emulation”). This perspective was one response to the unsatisfactory explanation of the previous paradigm (“Romanization”) to assess the incorporation faced by pre-Roman people. Nonetheless, current scholars have found the “self-Romanization” approach untenable. This view changes the scope of the agency from Roman to Native in the assimilation process of the Italians in the Roman culture, turning the whole influence into the Native elites, but all of it has an irremediable ending of exactly the same cultural convergence. Besides, the concept is still a top-bottom approach and the knowledge of the final outcome of the process obscures our judgment, taking for granted cultural behaviors as Roman when those are not necessarily Romans or vice versa. This work aims to criticize the modern approach of the 1970s epistemology reassessing the Marsian identity in a new light reconsidering the degree of the Roman agency, as it was more than it was previously thought. Nonetheless, the high degree of the Native agency in the structuration of the Marsian ethnicity cannot be neglected, because Marsian identity was a malleable ethnic concept to channel collective supralocal efforts by indigenous elites. The work offers a new way of understanding the Marsian culture refracted through the imperialistic lens of Roman authors. Keywords: Marsi, Rome, Identity formation, Ethnography, Settlement pattern. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS DEDICATION ............................................................................................................... iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................................... v ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................... vi LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................ ix INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................... 1 Historiography ..................................................................................................... 4 Theoretical Framework ........................................................................................ 9 CHAPTER TWO: LOCATING THE MARSI ............................................................... 16 2.1 Ethnogenesis within mythology: a situational construct ................................ 16 2.2 Native Categories ......................................................................................... 25 2.3 Cultural Stereotypes ..................................................................................... 30 2.3.1 The Best Warriors .......................................................................... 31 2.3.2 Snake-charming: Beyond Roman fantasy ....................................... 33 2.3.3 Negative Stands: The Night Witches. ............................................. 37 2.4 Conclusion ................................................................................................... 40 CHAPTER THREE: THE MATERIAL CULTURE OF MARSICA .............................. 41 3.1 Socio-Political Organization of the Marsic Communities .............................. 41 3.2 Aristocracy and Gender in the Funerary Record ........................................... 47 3.3 Religion. The Major Deity of The Marsi. ...................................................... 56 vii 3.4 Conclusion ................................................................................................... 65 CHAPTER FOUR: MARSI OVER ROMAN SWAY.................................................... 66 4.1 Approaching the Sources ............................................................................. 66 4.2 The New View: From Roman Domination to Roman Presence. ................... 69 4.3 The 3rd Century: Hannibal and Roman Military cControl: ex formula togarum. .......................................................................................................................... 76 4.4 The 2nd Century: Integration or Segregation? ............................................... 79 4.5 Bellum Marsicum and the Creation of Tota Italia. ........................................ 83 4.6 Conclusion ................................................................................................... 87 CHAPTER FIVE: THE SETTLEMENT PATTERN IN MARSICA: FROM OCRES- NECROPOLIS TO THE MUNICIPIA .......................................................................... 89 5.1 The Rise of The Ocres-Necropolis Model .................................................... 90 5.2 The impact of the Roman presence: Alba Fucens. ............................. 99 5.3 Vici: Latin or Marsian? .................................................................. 105 5.4 The Aftermath of the Social War: The Municipalization. ................ 110 5.5 Conclusion ..................................................................................... 117 CONCLUSION: A NEW VIEW FOR THE MARSI ................................................... 119 REFERENCES ........................................................................................................... 124 APPENDIX A ............................................................................................................. 133 APPENDIX B ............................................................................................................. 135 viii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Map of Italy circa 300. Salmon, Samnites, 25. ........................................ 17 Figure 2 CN. GEL. Crawford, Roman Republican Coinage (Cambridge: Cambridge U.P., 1974): 265. .................................................................................... 18 Figure 3 Caso Cantavio inscription. Campanelli, Il tesoro, 145. ............................ 26 Figure 4 Angitia. E. Fernique, “Bronze representant Angitia” Gazette archéologique 8.1 (1883): 224 ................................................................ 35 Figure 5 Central Italian Iron Age sculpture map. Rafaella Papi, "Un framento inedito di scultura Italica in abruzzo," Quaderni dell´instituto di archeologia e storia antica 2 (Roma: Viella, 1981): 11. ........................... 42 Figure 6 Devil´s Leg. J. J. Basile. “The Capestrano warrior and related monument of the seventh to fifth centuries B.C.,” RAHAL, 26 (1993), 19. .............. 43 Figure 7 Capestrano Warrior J.J. Basile. “The Capestrano warrior,” 12. ............... 43 Figure 8 Map of the vici in Marsic area. Modified from Stek, Cult Places, 156. ... 45 Figure 9 Celano Paludi. D’ Ercole, If Fucino 2001, 170. ....................................... 48 Figure 10 Scurcola Marsicana. Accontia Ritualita, 355. .......................................... 49 Figure 11 Corvaro. V. Accontia, Ritualitá, 356. .....................................................