Homo Erectus - the First Expansion out of Africa - Homo Erectus Behavior - Fire? - Hunters Or Scavengers?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Out of Africa Emergence of the Genus Homo (after 2.5mya, shown in teal and blue) Members of the Homo genus have larger brains. Boyd & Silk (2014). Outline of Today’s Class: Out of Africa 1) Homo erectus - The first expansion out of Africa - Homo erectus behavior - Fire? - Hunters or scavengers? 2) Models for the emergence of modern humans - Multiregionalism - Out of Africa with Replacement - Out of Africa with Admixture 3) Homo heidelbergensis Homo erectus fossils are found outside of Africa starting at 1.8mya Boyd & Silk (2014). The earliest Homo erectus fossils outside of Africa are found at Dmanisi, Georgia (1.8 mya). Homo erectus spread quickly into East and Southeast Asia. The Site of Zhoukoudian in China Provides Clues About Homo erectus Behavior • In the 1920-30s, excavations of caves outside of Beijing uncovered dozens of Homo erectus fossils (referred to as “Peking Man”) as well as tools and animal bones. • Original fossils lost during WWII. Casts still survive. Stratigraphic profile of Zhoukoudian Locality 1 Fire at Zhoukoudian? • Did controlling fire help Homo erectus to cook food and live in colder climates? • Evidence for fire at Zhoukoudian: – Soils with black “ash” – Red fire-cracked earth – Burned animal bones • Re-analysis indicates that black soils were fine silt accumulated from standing water. Fire-cracked earth could be caused by natural Entrance to the Zhoukoudian Site Museum fires. Bones were burned after fossilization. • Claims that Homo erectus at Zhoukoudian controlled fire are not well supported. • There is debatable evidence that Homo erectus living elsewhere in Eurasia and Africa controlled fire. Hunters or Scavengers at Zhoukoudian? • Fossil accumulation in the cave was likely due to other predators (hyena den). • Hyenas also chewed Homo erectus bones. • Some animal fossils have cut marks on top of carnivore chew marks. There is no doubt that Homo erectus scavenged, but we lack direct evidence that they were sophisticated hunters. • There are cut marks on some Homo erectus fossils. Cannibalism? Boaz, N. T., et al. (2000). Large mammalian carnivores as a taphonomic factor in the bone accumulation at Zhoukoudian. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 19, 224-234. After Homo erectus, several species of archaic Homo emerged during the Middle Paleolithic Homo heidelbergensis, Neanderthals, and Denisovans are often called “Archaic Homo” or “Archaic Humans” Neanderthals Homo sapiens Denisovans (400-30kya) (200kya-present) (40kya) Europe and Middle East Africa first Asia Homo heidelbergensis (600-200kya) Africa, Europe, and the Middle East Homo erectus (2mya-150kya?) Africa and Asia. Europe? Model #1: Multiregionalism • AKA “continuity with hybridization.” Homo Homo sapiens Homo sapiens Homo sapiens • Homo sapiens evolved in multiple regions across the Old World. Homo Homo Denisovans • Fossil traits suggest constant gene flow between Nanderthals populations living in different regions. heidelbergensis • Explains intermediate forms of archaic Homo fossils with region-specific morphological features. th • Consensus model until the late 20 Century Homo erectus when it became possible to study DNA from living people. Model #2: Recent African Origins and Replacement “Out of Africa” • Homo erectus evolved into Homo heidelbergensis in Africa. Homo Homo sapiens Homo sapiens Homo sapiens • Homo heidelbergensis left Africa 400 kya and evolved into Neanderthals and other regional forms of archaic Homo. • Limited or no gene flow between regions. • Homo heidelbergensis in Africa evolved into modern Nanderthals Denisovans humans by 200-100kya. • Modern humans left Africa 100-60kya and displaced other Homo forms of archaic Homo. Regional traits in modern human populations appeared recently. heidelbergensis • Hominins outside of Africa went extinct without making significant genetic contributions to modern humans. Homo Homo erectus • Consensus model from the 1980s/90s through early 2000s due to modern genetic evidence. Most archaeological and modern genetic evidence supports the replacement/“Out of Africa” model: • Oldest modern human fossils are found in Africa. • Oldest archaeological materials associated with modern humans are found in Africa. • Modern mtDNA evidence supports African origins (e.g., Mitochondrial Eve). • Last major gene flow between African and non-African populations occurred 65- 95kya (Fu et al. 2013), which is consistent with a single wave of human migration out of Africa. BUT thanks to ancient DNA, we now know that the picture is more complicated: • Ancient DNA shows there was admixture between populations of archaic Homo. • Ancient DNA shows there was admixture between Homo sapiens and these other groups. • Fossil evidence that Homo erectus in Asia continued to evolve into other intermediate forms. Fu, Q., et al. (2013). A revised timescale for human evolution based on ancient mitochondrial genomes. Current Biology, 23(7), 553-559. A Revised Model for Human Origins: “Out of Africa with Admixture” 1. Homo erectus gave rise to Homo heidelbergensis in Africa and Western Eurasia. 2. Homo heidelbergensis gave rise to additional forms of archaic humans in Eurasia (Neanderthals and Denisovans). 3. There was some gene flow between the various forms of archaic humans outside of Africa. 4. Modern humans evolved from Homo heidelbergensis in Africa. 5. Modern humans replaced other archaic humans, but there was a low level of gene flow between humans and these other groups. 6. Some transitional forms of hominin that evolved directly from Homo erectus persisted in Asia. Qiu (2016) After Homo erectus, several species of archaic Homo emerged during the Middle Paleolithic Homo heidelbergensis, Neanderthals, and Denisovans are often called “Archaic Homo” or “Archaic Humans” Neanderthals Homo sapiens Denisovans (400-30kya) (200kya-present) (40kya) Europe and Middle East Africa first Asia Homo heidelbergensis (600-200kya) Africa, Europe, and the Middle East Homo erectus (2mya-150kya?) Africa and Asia. Europe? Homo heidelbergensis (600-200kya) Large brains. Skeletal features are very similar to Neanderthals and modern humans. New tool types. Developments in cognition and social organization. Cave site of Sima de los Huesos, Spain • Bones from over 30 individuals that are ancestors of European Neanderthals. • Evidence for care of disabled individuals. • Intentional burial? Oldest wooden spear, Schöningen, Germany (400kya) Stone Tool Industries Levallois Technique—Making Specialized Stone Tools for Different Tasks Stone Tool Industries Homo heidelbergensis Ancient DNA 430,000 year old bones from Sima de los Huesos: – Oldest hominin ancient DNA to date. – Mitochondrial genome indicates that they were more closely related to Denisovans than Neanderthals (Meyer et al. 2014). – Nuclear genome indicates that they were early Neanderthals (Meyer et al. 2016). – Conclusions based on mtDNA are often later contradicted by nuclear DNA because mtDNA provides a limited picture of ancestry and relatedness. – Most recent ancient DNA results raise questions about whether Homo heidelbergensis was the ancestor of all later hominins. Homo antecessor? Meyer, M., et al. (2014). A mitochondrial genome sequence of a hominin from Sima de los Huesos. Nature, 505(7483), 403-406. Meyer, M., et al. (2016). Nuclear DNA sequences from the Middle Pleistocene Sima de los Huesos hominins. Nature, 531(7595), 504-517. Next week…Neanderthals!.