MATCH REVIEW PANEL MINUTES 03/06/2019 - MATTERS CONSIDERED

Case Number: ON/837/19

Name: Micky Paea

Club and shirt Hull FC; 23 number:

Match: Hull FC v Catalans

Competition and Date: ; 30th May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Raising knee in the 7th minute (Whitley)

Decision: Issue caution

Details of Charge / Player raises knee into contact as ball carrier. Opponent body Reason for NFA: moves at the top of the contact which makes initial contact. Footage does not demonstrate contact is made with knee to opponent. Worthy of MRP Caution.

Rule – 15.1(a)

Detail – Strikes – knee - Raising knee in tackle

Caution

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/838/19

Name: Michael McIllorum

Club and shirt Catalans; 9 number:

Match: Hull FC v Catalans

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 30th May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 41st minute (Westerman)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player comes into contact on the lower buttock area of Reason for NFA: opponent as two other tacklers are at the top of contact.

Opponent makes reasonable approach to contact after opponent has turned in the tackle.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/839/19

Name: Micky Paea

Club and shirt Hull FC; 23 number:

Match: Hull FC v Catalans

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 30th May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Raising knee in the 54th minute (Baitieri)

Decision: Issue caution

Details of Charge / Player lifts leg to an excessive height. Initial contact on Reason for NFA: opponent’s shoulder from player’s shoulder. Player makes contact on the side of opponent’s thigh as knee comes down. Worthy of MRP Caution

Rule – 15.1(a)

Detail – Strikes – knee - Raising knee in tackle

Caution

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/840/19

Name: Danny Addy

Club and shirt Hull KR; 20 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: High tackle in the 3rd minute (Mamo)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player reaches into contact on opponent and makes contact Reason for NFA: initial contact over opponent’s shoulder and then to the head of opponent. Onfield penalty sufficient.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/841/19

Name: Anthony Maria

Club and shirt Hull KR; 34 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Late contact in the 9th minute (Patton)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player runs towards opponent as opponent kicks. Player Reason for NFA: pushes opponent. Player does not make contact with the head of opponent.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/842/19

Name: Tom Lineham

Club and shirt Warrington; 2 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: Referee; Temporary Dismissal

Details of allegation: High tackle in the 19th minute (Keinhorst)

Decision: Issue charge

Details of Charge / Rule – 15.1(a) Reason for NFA: Detail – Strikes – Other striking offences

Grade – C

Penalty Notice: 3 Match Penalty Notice

Case Number: ON/843/19

Name: Dec Patton

Club and shirt Warrington; 15 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: Referee; Temporary Dismissal

Details of allegation: Professional Foul in the 23rd minute (Addy)

Decision: Sin Bin Sufficient.

Details of Charge / Player steals the ball following a team warning. Sin Bin Reason for NFA: Sufficient.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/8484/19

Name: Jake Mamo

Club and shirt Warrington; 22 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 23rd minute (Addy)

Decision: Issue charge

Details of Charge / Rule – 15.1(i) Reason for NFA:

Detail – Defending player, in or after effecting a tackle, forcefully and unnecessarily grasps the head or neck of the tackled player

Grade – B

Penalty Notice: 1 Match Penalty Notice

Case Number: ON/845/19

Name: Mitch Garbutt

Club and shirt Hull KR; 14 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 46th minute (Akauola)

Decision: Issue charge

Details of Charge / Rule – 15.1(i) Reason for NFA: Detail – Defender uses any part of his body forcefully to twist, bend or otherwise apply pressure to the limb or limbs of an opposing player in a way that involves an unacceptable risk of injury to that player.

Grade – B

Penalty Notice: 1 Match Penalty Notice

Case Number: ON/846/19

Name: Ben Murdoch Masila

Club and shirt Warrington; 13 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Late contact in the 59th minute (Maguire)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player makes contact on opponent after ball is kicked. Reason for NFA: Opponent attempts to grip player’s head. Both player and opponent come together. Player and opponent do not throw punches. Onfield penalty sufficient.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/847/19

Name: Chris Hill

Club and shirt Warrington; 8 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Late contact in the 79th minute (Drinkwater)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player makes contact on opponent after opponent has kicked Reason for NFA: the ball. Contact is shoulder to shoulder. No contact with the head of opponent. Worthy of onfield penalty.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/848/19

Name: Weller Hauraki

Club and shirt Hull KR; 13 number:

Match: Hull KR v Warrington

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 31st May 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 79th minute (King)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player approaches contact and opponent takes himself to Reason for NFA: ground. Player has no grip around the head and neck of opponent. A number of players teammates and opponents bringing tackle to ground. Player moves feet back from opponent to allow opponents head through the contact.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/849/19

Name: Alex Walmsley

Club and shirt St Helens; 8 number:

Match: St Helens v Wakefield

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 1st June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 7th minute (Randall)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player comes into contact and has a tight but legitimate. grip Reason for NFA: Players attempts to create space for opponent however opponent pulls player towards opponent. Opponent has grip on player’s shirt and player cannot release grip as a result.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/850/19

Name: Dominic Peyroux

Club and shirt St Helens; 17 number:

Match: St Helens v Wakefield

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 1st June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Late contact in the 12th minute (Miller)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player makes contact on opponent after the ball is passed Reason for NFA: using a wrapping motion. Contact is made from player’s body to opponent’s. Footage inconclusive in terms of any contact with the head.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/851/19

Name:

Club and shirt Wakefield; 12 number:

Match: St Helens v Wakefield

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 1st June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Trip in the 13th minute (Taia)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player’s foot is extended towards opponent as player is Reason for NFA: stepped and reaching. Player makes contact with arms and holds contact whilst making contact with the foot.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/852/19

Name: Ryan Hampshire

Club and shirt Wakefield; 1 number:

Match: St Helens v Wakefield

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 1st June 2019

Report received from: Referee; Temporary Dismissal

Details of allegation: Professional Foul in the 27th minute (Knowles)

Decision: Sin Bin Sufficient

Details of Charge / Player steals ball after tackle is complete the delay quick play Reason for NFA: the ball in a try scoring position. Sin Bin Sufficient.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/853/19

Name: Jacob Miller

Club and shirt Wakefield; 6 number:

Match: St Helens v Wakefield

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 1st June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 30th minute (Grace)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player goes into contact with two other defenders. Opponent Reason for NFA: takes himself to ground as player appears to make some allowances. Footage does not demonstrate conclusive evidence.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/854/19

Name: Danny Richardson

Club and shirt St Helens; number:

Match: St Helens v Wakefield

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 1st June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Contact with the head in the 52nd minute (Jones Bishop)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player makes contact on head of opponent as opponent is Reason for NFA: starting to go to ground. Onfield penalty sufficient.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/855/19

Name: Adam Tangata

Club and shirt Halifax; 35 number:

Match: Bradford v Halifax

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 2nd June 2019

Report received from: Referee; Temporary Dismissal

Details of allegation: Late contact in the 14th minute (Lilley)

Decision: Sin Bin Sufficient

Details of Charge / Player makes contact with opponent just after the ball has Reason for NFA: been kicked. Player demonstrates legitimate wrapping motion as player dives into contact. Player makes a low approach and does not make contact with the head of opponent. Sin Bin Sufficient.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/856/19

Name: Adam Tangata

Club and shirt Halifax; 35 number:

Match: Bradford v Halifax

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 2nd June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 39th minute (Peltier)

Decision: Issue charge

Details of Charge / Rule – 15.1(i) Reason for NFA: Detail – Defender uses any part of his body forcefully to twist, bend or otherwise apply pressure to the limb or limbs of an

opposing player in a way that involves an unacceptable risk of injury to that player.

Grade – A

Penalty Notice: 0 Match Penalty Notice

Case Number: ON/857/19

Name: Ross Peltier

Club and shirt Bradford; number:

Match: Bradford v Halifax

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 2nd June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Throw in the 40th minute (Cooper)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player lifts opponent as tackle goes to ground. Actions of Reason for NFA: other defender contribute to opponent’s landing. Onfield Penalty Sufficient.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/858/19

Name: Jake Webster

Club and shirt Bradford; 3 number:

Match: Bradford v Halifax

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 2nd June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Contact in the air in the 46th minute (Tyrer)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player reaches into contact on opponent as both challenge Reason for NFA: for the ball. Player makes contact on the head area of opponent which is released immediately.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/859/19

Name: Jake Webster

Club and shirt Bradford; 3 number:

Match: Bradford v Halifax

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 2nd June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 46th minute (Tyrer)

Decision: Issue caution

Details of Charge / Player promotes arm into contact on opponent on the ground Reason for NFA: after the ball is dead. Applies a degree of pressure to the neck area of opponent unnecessarily.

Rule – 15.1(i)

Detail – Defending player, in or after effecting a tackle, forcefully and unnecessarily grasps the head or neck of the tackled player

Caution

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/860/19

Name: Adam Tangata

Club and shirt Halifax; 35 number:

Match: Bradford v Halifax

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 2nd June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 51st minute (Peltier)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player bumped off initial grip, takes both feet off as opponent Reason for NFA: brings leg through contact in running motion. Player does not swing or lunge into contact or have an effective grip on leg as opponent comes through contact. Player does not apply pressure against knee or ankle joint. Player drops bodyweight down to ground.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/861/19

Name: Dalton Grant

Club and shirt Bradford; 5 number:

Match: Bradford v Halifax

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 2nd June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 62nd minute (Saltonstall)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player grabs on opponent at waist, knees come through Reason for NFA: contact with momentum of tackle.

Penalty Notice: N/A

Case Number: ON/862/19

Name: Steve Tyrer

Club and shirt Halifax; 3 number:

Match: Bradford v Halifax

Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 2nd June 2019

Report received from: MRPR

Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 79th minute (Ryan)

Decision: NFA

Details of Charge / Player makes contact around the shoulders, legs extended Reason for NFA: behind with momentum of contact. Lands on side of opponent’s leg with the side of the body.

Penalty Notice: N/A