1004 SHORT COMMUNICATIONS

The Condor93:1004-1006 0 The CooperOrnithological Society 199 I

THE RECORD OF THE MYCTERZA (CICONIIDAE) IN ’

STORRS L. OLSON Department of VertebrateZoology, National Museum of Natural History, SmithsonianInstitution, Washington,DC 20560

Key words: Fossil : wetmorei; Dis- 129044) that is much too short, stout, and curved for sourodesmilleri; ; ;Nebraska; Mio- Mycteria. Instead, both specimens are of the Black cene. , Coragypsatratus (Bechstein). An extinct Pleistocenespecies of Wood , Mvc- Although the , Mycteria americana Lin- teria wetmoreiHoward, 1935, was described from the naeus,is the only extant resident speciesof stork north tar pits at Ranch0 La Brea. California. This was based of Mexico, referable to the genus Mycteria are on a highly diagnostic portion of a mandible and the scarcein Cenozoic deposits of North America, where proximal end of a tarsometatarsus.I examined these storksare more abundantly representedby extinct spe- specimens (LACM K3527, K3528) and concur with cies of suchas C. maltha L. Miller, and related Howard’s diagnosis that this is a larger than forms (e.g., Brodkorb 1963, Bickart 1990). Several M. americana, with the mandible much less curved. published North American fossil records of Mycteria In addition, the dorsalgroove of the mandible is broad- are erroneous or ambiguous; additional material re- er and deeper, and the lateral grooves appear deeper ported here shedsnew light on the history of this genus as well. To my knowledge, no one has questioned the in the New World. validity of M. wetmorei;its statusas a speciesdistinct Apart from two archeologicalrecords from Florida from M. americana seems fully justified. and Venezuela, Brodkorb (1963) listed only one fossil Additional material from the Pleistoceneof Florida record of M americana. This was based on a right is also best referred to M. wetmorei on the basis of humerus identified by McCoy (1963) from depositsof size.Three specimens(distal end ofleft ulna, UF 15592; Rancholabrean age in the Ichetucknee River,-Colum- distal half of right tarsometatarsus lacking middle bia County, Florida (seeWebb 1974:30 for the aae and trochlea, UF 15593; and distal end of right tarsometa- spelling of this locality). I re-examined this specimen tarsuslacking inner trochlea, UF 15594) are from the (then in the collection of Pierce Brodkorb with Florida Ichetucknee River and were reported conditionally Geological Survey number V4871) and found that it under the name M. americana by Campbell (1980), is actually from a Canada Goose Branta canadensis who acknowledgedthat they might be referable to M. (Linnaeus). This error was also noticed by Campbell wetmorei.The distal end of a left tibiotarsus(UF 14907) (1980: 121). but the correction itself was considerablv from the Aucilla River, JeffersonCounty, in the pan- confounded. In the footnotes to Campbell’s table i, handle of northern Florida, also of Rancholabreanage numbers 4 and 5 are reversed, the former applying to (Webb 1974:30), I have likewise identified as M. wet- Mycteria and the latter to Botaurus.Although no spec- morei. imen of Mycteria is attributed to McCoy in the table, These specimensare larger than the equivalent ele- the footnote statesthat “McCoy referred this specimen, ments in a modem seriesof skeletonsof Mycteria (Ta- a complete humerus, to Brunta canadensis,”whereas ble l), except the smaller tarsometatarsus(UF 15593) the opposite is true, the bone in question being from which showsevidence of the porousbone surfacechar- a goosebut identified by McCoy as a stork. acteristic of juvenile , thus possibly accounting Another recordattributed to Mycteria americanawas for its small size. The straightmandible ofM. wetmorei reported from Pleistocenedeposits in Little Salt Spring, is actually more reminisc&t of that in the three Old Florida (Clausen et al. 1979). My initial attempts to World speciesof Mycteria than the more curved man- borrow this material for verification were unsuccessful. dible of M. americana. In size, M. wetmorei exceeds Later, a good portion of my unanswered letter of in- all of the specimensof Mycteria examined, but is clos- quiry to Clausen( 14 February 1979) appearedin Hol- est to M. Zeucocephala(Table 1), although material of man and Clausen (1984:151-152), where the fossils the Old World species was insufficient to determine were then listed as “Cf. Mycteria SD.indet.” Not until the range of size variation. 1991 was I able to examine these bones-a scapula A much older stork fossil, described as a new genus (UF 129043) that lacksthe distinct knoblike coracoidal and species,Dissourodes milleri Short, 1966, was based articulation of storks, and the shaft of a humerus (UF on the distal end of a left tibiotarsus from the Crooks- ton Bridge local fauna of the Valentine Formation in Cherry County, Nebraska, and is late Middle (late Barstovian), approximately 12 million years old I Received 4 February 199 1. Final acceptance 21 (Becker 1987:39, 168). Short’s (1966) diagnosisof Dis- May 1991. sourodesis difficult to decipher, in part becauseof com- SHORT COMMUNICATIONS 1005

TABLE 1. Measurements(mm) of fossil and modem specimensof Mycteriu. Specimensof M. americana are from the collections of PB, LACM, and USNM; all other modem specimensare from USNM.

Distancefrom middle Distal width trochleato proximal end of Distal width of of tibiotarsus hallux scar lanOmelatarS”s Distal depth of ulna

M. wetmorei UF 14907 15.6 - - - UF 15594 - 38.1 - - UF 15593 - - 19.5 - UF 15592 - - - 15.8 M. americana 12.2-14.1 (13.2) 26.1-33.2 (30.2) 17.4-20.6 (19.0) 12.9-15.3 (13.9) (n = 31) (n = 26) (n = 26) (n = 36) M. (n = 4) 12.4-13.5 (12.8) 30.0-32.7 (31.1) 17.1-19.5 (18.3) 12.7-13.7 (13.0) M. cinerea (n = 2) 11.9-13.4 (12.6) 28.3-31.7 (30.0) 17.5-19.5 (18.5) 12.8-14.3 (13.5) M. leucocephala(n = 2) 13.2-15.1 (14.1) 32.4-36. I (34.2) 18.4-20.5 (19.4) 13.6-14.7 (14.1)

FIGURE 1. Distal ends of left tibiotarsi of storks in anterior (upper row) and distal (lower row) views: A, modem Ciconiuciconia (USNM 6050 12); B, castofholotype of Dissourodes(=Mycteria) milleri (USNM 23843); C, fossil specimen from Aucilla River, Florida, referred to Mycteria wetmorei (UF 14907); D, modem M. americann (USNM 500889). Arrow indicates the proximal incision of the external condyle characteristicof the genus Mycteriu. Note also in distal view (lower) the narrower intercondylar sulcusof Mycteria versus that of Ciconiu. Scale = 3 cm. 1006 SHORT COMMUNICATIONS parisons with numerous modem genera that are no For comments on the manuscript I am grateful to Jon- longer considered valid (see Kahl 1971, 1972, 1979). athan Becker, Kenneth E. Campbell, Jr., J. Alan Hol- Short consideredMycteria and Ibis (the latter now in- man, and David W. Steadman. cluded in Mycteria) to be peculiar and to differ from Dissourodesin having the intercondylar groove “V- LITERATURE CITED shapedanteriorly but sharplyshifting to a U-shape near the baseof the groove.” Perhapsthis refers to the char- BECKER,J. J. 1987. Neogene avian localities ofNorth acteristic shape of the intercondylar fossa in Mycteria America. Smithsonian Institution Press, Wash- causedby the marked incision of the proximomedial ington, DC. margin of the external condyle. A cast of the holotype BICKART,K. J. 1990. The birds of the late Miocene- of Dissourodesmilleri shows this feature to be present early Pliocene Big Sandy Formation, Mohave and well-developed,however (Fig. 1B). This cast agrees County, Arizona, p. l-72. In Recent advances in further with Mycteria, and differs from Ciconia (sensu the study of Neogenefossil birds. Om. Monog. 44. lato), in the narrower intercondylar sulcus,as seen in BRODKORB,P. 1963. Catalogueof fossil birds. Part 1 distal view (Fig. 1). (Archaeopterygiformesthrough Ardeiformes). Bull. In comparing Dissourodesmilleri with the tibiotar- Florida State Mus., Biol. Sci. 7:179-273. susreferred to Mycteria wetmorei(Fig. l), I could de- CAMPBELL.K. E.. JR. 1980. A review of the Ran- tect no significant differences in qualitative features cholabrean avifauna of the Itchtucknee River, except the more robust shaft in D. milleri. The mea- Florida. Contrib. Sci. Natur. Hist. Mus. Los An- surements of the Pleistocene fossil correspond very gelesCounty 330: 119-l 29. closelywith thosegiven by Short for D. milleri. If these CLAUSEN,C. J., A. D. COHEN, C. EMILIANI, J. A. fossils were of equivalent age, they might well be as- HOLMAN,AND J. J. STIPP. 1979. Little Salt Spring, signedto the samespecies. Considering the much great- Florida: a uniaue underwater site. Science 203: er ageof D. milleri, suchan action would be precipitate 609-614. - in view of the limited amount of fossil material. I can HOLMAN,J. A., AND C. J. CLAUSEN. 1984. Fossil ver- seeno justification, however, for separategeneric status tebrates associatedwith paleo-indian artifact at for D. milleri. Consequently the genus Dissourodes Little Salt Spring, Florida. J. Vert. Paleont. 4: 146- Short, 1966, may be regarded as a junior subjective 154. synonym of Mycteria Linnaeus, 1758, and its only in- HOWARD,H. 1935. The Ranch0 La Brea wood ibis. cluded speciesshould hence be known asMycteria mil- Condor 37:25 l-253. leri (Short), new combination. KAHL, M. P. 1971. Social behavior and taxonomic Unless Mycteria americana decreasedmarkedly in relationshins of the storks. Livina 10:15 l- size since the end of the Pleistocene,all fossilsof Myc- 170. - teria yet found in North America are referable to M. KAHL, M. P. 1972. A revision of the family Ciconi- wetmorei;there is thus no confirmed Pleistocene oc- idae (Aves). J. Zool. (Proc. Zool. Sot., London) currence for the Wood Stork. The fossil record may 167:451-461. eventually show that these two species co-existed in KAHL, M. P. 1979. Family Ciconiidae, p. 245-252. North America. On the other hand, it is also possible In E. Mayr and G. W. Cottrell, [eds.], Check-list that M. americana is a relatively recent immigrant of birds of the world. Vol. 1. 2nd ed. Museum of from that arrived after M. wetmorei Comparative Zoology, Cambridge, MA. became extinct at the end of the Pleistocene. McCoy, J. J. 1963. The fossil avifauna of Itchtucknee River, Florida. Auk 80:335-35 1. For accessto fossilsand recent comparative material SHORT,L. L. 1966. A new Pliocene stork from Ne- I am indebted to Pierce Brodkorb (PB), the Florida braska. Smithsonian Misc. Coll. 149(9):l-l 1. Museum of Natural History (UF), the Natural History WEBB,S. D., [ED.] 1974. Pleistocene mammals of Museum of Los Angeles County (LACM), and the Na- Florida. Univer. Pressesof Florida, Gainesville, tional Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian In- FL. stitution (USNM). Photographsare by Victor E. Krantz.