11-18-2014 Hearing Binder.Pdf

Board of

MESA COUNTY

COMMISSIONERS Colorado

AGENDA TUESDAY November 18, 2014

LAND USE 544 Rood Avenue, Public Hearing Room 9:00 a.m. Call Meeting to Order: Deletions from Agenda: Additions to Agenda: Approval of Minutes: 1. Land Use Hearing, October 14, 2014

LAND USE ITEMS

NOTE: Copies of Staff Report(s) for Land Use Items are available on the back table within the hearing room.

CONTINUED TO ITEM(S): NONE

WITHDRAWN ITEM(S):

**2014-0091 CPA DOUBLE CREEK ESTATES CONCEPT PLAN APPEAL Property Owner(s):Design/Engineering LLC Representative(s): David M. Kotz, PE, SGM, Inc Location: 1255 17 ½ Road Parcel #: 2697-052-00-038 Zoning: AFT Planner: Linda Dannenberger, (970)244-1771, [email protected] Request: Appeal of an administrative decision that determined the application incomplete for the Double Creek Estates Major Subdivision Concept Plan. **APPEAL HAS BEEN WITHDRAWN

CONSENT ITEM(S): The Consent Agenda is intended to allow the Board to spend its time on the more complex items. These items are generally perceived as non-controversial and can be approved by a single motion. The petitioners have agreed to all of the staff

**PLEASE NOTE: THERE IS LIMITED FREE PUBLIC PARKING ON THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF 6TH STREET AND WHITE AVENUE**

BOCC – Land Use November 18, 2014 Page 2 of 4

recommendations on these projects. The public or the Board Members may ask that an item be removed from the Consent Agenda for individual consideration.

NOTICE: If an applicant agrees to have a project placed on the Consent Agenda for the Mesa County Planning Commission and it is approved on that Agenda, the project is placed on the Consent Agenda for the Board of County Commissioners. If an applicant decides to remove the item from the Board Consent Agenda, the project will be referred back to the Mesa County Planning Commission and rescheduled for a new hearing date.

NONE

HEARING ITEMS:

PRESENTATION RULES: Due to the volume of items to be heard the following restrictions may be applied to help expedite the hearing process:

a) Where practical, presentations by staff and petitioners will be limited to 15 minutes or less. Petitioners are asked to not repeat presentation information that the staff has correctly presented. Please address the clarification to the staff's presentation, new information or new developments to the project, and the staff and agency review comments and recommendations.

b) Responses in favor or in opposition to the proposal will be limited to approximately 3 minutes each. We prefer only new information to be presented. A single speaker may be selected on behalf of organized groups.

1. 2014-0125 CUP VICTORY LIFE CHURCH, AMENDMENT TO CUP TO ALLOW SIGN Property Owner(s):First Assembly of God, Inc Representative(s): Rev. G. Robert Cook Jr. Location: 2066 Highway 6 & 50, Fruita 81521 Zoning: AFT Planner: Randy Price, 244-1759, [email protected] Request: To amend the existing Conditional Use Permit for a daycare facility to allow signage larger than that allowed in an AFT zone. Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions MCPC Recommendation: Approval with Conditions, 3-1

2. 2014-0146 CUP DEER CREEK (GOODWIN) WATER DISPOSAL FACILITY AMEND CUP TO CHANGE TO DAYS AND HOURS OF OPERATION Property Owner(s):Deer Creek Facilities, LLC Representative(s): Thomas Pool Location: 5180 Hwy 50, Whitewater 81527 (US Hwy 50 & Bridgeport Rd) Zoning: AFT Planner: Randy Price, 244-1759, [email protected] Request: To amend the existing CUP to permanently extend the hours of operation to 24 hours a day, 7 days per week. Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions MCPC Recommendation: Denial, 4-0 BOCC – Land Use November 18, 2014 Page 3 of 4

3. 2014-0136 VA STAHL VACATION OF RIGHT OF WAY Property Owner: Bruce Stahl Representative: John Curran Location: 3781 G 7/10 Road, Palisade, 81526 (37.8 Rd aka Main Street & G.7 Road) Zoning: AFT Planner: Christie Barton, 255-7191, [email protected] Request: To vacate a portion of 37 8/10 Road (also known as Main Street, Palisade) right of way north of the Government Highline Canal and south of G 7/10 Road. Access for adjacent properties is from other locations. Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions

BRIEFING(S): NONE

RESOLUTION(S):

1. 2014-0124 RZ APPROVAL OF A REQUEST TO REZONE THE HAYDEN INVESTMENTS LLC PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3208 SPRINGFIELD ROAD, GRAND JUNCTION FROM THE C-2 DISTRICT TO THE I-1 DISTRICT

2. 2014-0135 RZ APPROVAL OF A REQUEST TO REZONE THE AMICO PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3172 E½ ROAD, CLIFTON FROM THE PUD DISTRICT TO THE RMF-8 DISTRICT

3. 2014-0097 CUP APPROVAL OF A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR MINOR ENTERTAINMENT EVENTS FOR MOUNTAIN VIEW FARMS IN THE AFT DISTRICT UNDER THE USE TABLE OF SECTION 5.1 OF THE MESA COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE LOCATED AT 3165 B 1/2 RD

4. 2013-0187 CUP APPROVAL OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THE WESTERN SLOPE FLAGSTONE CAMEO QUARRY TO ALLOW THE USE OF RAPID CREEK ROAD FOR COMMERCIAL USE

ROAD PETITION(S): NONE

UNSCHEDULED BUSINESS: Please present your comments within ten (10) minutes.

ADJOURN

THE COMMISSIONERS MAY TAKE A LUNCH BREAK, IF THE MEETING IS NOT COMPLETE.

BOCC – Land Use November 18, 2014 Page 4 of 4

CERTIFICATION OF POSTING

On November 13, 2014 at 2:00 p.m., Stephanie Reecy did post the above AGENDA as public notice of the November 18, 2014 meeting. The official notice is placed on the East Entrance bulletin board at 544 Rood Avenue, Grand Junction, CO and a courtesy copy added to the Mesa County website at www.mesacounty.us/BoCCagendas/

______Stephanie Reecy

Minutes Approved: OCTOBER 14, 2014

Audio

CALL MEETING TO ORDER

At 9:02 a.m., Chair John Justman called to order a regular Land Use meeting of the Board of Mesa County Commissioners at the Mesa County Courthouse, Public Hearing Room, 544 Rood Avenue, Grand Junction, Colorado. Those present included Commissioner Rose Pugliese, Commissioner Steve Acquafresca, David Frankel, Acting County Attorney; Linda Dannenberger, Planning Division Director; and Lori Westermire, Clerk to the Board. Minutes prepared by Lori Westermire.

APPROVAL OF MINUTES (0:12)

August 26, 2014 September 9, 2014 September 16, 2014

STEVE ACQUAFRESCA MOVED TO APPROVE THE AUGUST 26, SEPTEMBER 9, AND SEPTEMBER 16 2014 MEETING MINUTES; ROSE PUGLIESE SECONDED, MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY, 3-0.

September 30, 2014 (Note: Steve Acquafresca was excused from this hearing)

ROSE PUGLIESE MOVED TO APPROVE THE LAND USE HEARING MINUTES ON SEPTEMBER 30, 2014; JOHN JUSTMAN SECONDED, MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY, 2-0.

LAND USE ITEMS CONSENT ITEMS (1:25)

1. 2014-0124 RZ SPRINGFIELD LOT 2 REZONE Property Owner: Hayden Investments, LLC Representative: Julie Hayden Location: 3208 Springfield Road, Grand Junction, 81503 (32 & Springfield Roads) Zoning: C-2 Planner: Christie Barton, Senior Planner

A request to rezone Lot 2 of the Springfield Estates from the General Commercial (C-2) zoning district to the Limited Industrial (I-1) zoning district. Staff Recommendation: Approval; MCPC Recommendation: Approval 4- 0.

2. 2014-0135 RZ VILLA WAY REZONE Property Owner: Daniel Amico Location: 3172 E ½ Road, Grand Junction, 81504 (Villa Way & E½ Road) Zoning: PUD Planner: Christie Barton, Senior Planner

Page 1 of 4

A request to rezone approximately 1.5 acres of land from Planned Unit Development (PUD) zone district to Residential Multi-Family – 8 units per acre (RMF-8). Staff Recommendation: Approval; MCPC Recommendation: Approval 4-0.

ROSE PUGLIESE MOVED TO APPROVE THE CONSENT AGENDA ITEMS ONE AND TWO ON THE OCTOBER 14, 2014 AGENDA; STEVE ACQUAFRESCA SECONDED, MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.

HEARING ITEMS (2:54)

1. 2013-0187 CUP WESTERN SLOPE FLAGSTONE, CAMEO QUARRY CUP AMENDMENT, RAPID CREEK ROAD ACCESS Property Owner(s): Rudolph Fontanari Representative(s): Trevor Grosse Location: 3998 Rapid Creek Rd, Palisade Zoning: AFT Planner: Randy Price, Senior Planner

A request to amend the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for mining to allow up to 5 gravel haul trucks per day from the Western Slope Flagstone, Cameo Quarry to use Rapid Creek Road as a haul route. Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions; MCPC Recommendation: Denial 3-1.

Randy Price entered into the record the Project Review, dated August 19, 2014 and revised October 3, 2014, the 2000 Land Development Code, the Mesa County Land Use Plan, a PowerPoint presentation as Exhibit A, and correspondence from Keith Corey, dated October 3, 2014, as Exhibit B. Mr. Price summarized the site location, the surrounding lands uses, zoning, project history, and the notification buffer. He described, the condition of Rapid Creek Road, the permitted number of trucks per day, access permits and easements along the road, safety concerns associated with the road and the one-lane bridge that crosses Rapid Creek, and plans for future maintenance to improve safety.

Mr. Price read the Conditions of Approval and the CUP criterion included in the Project Review on Pages 60- 62. Commissioner Acquafresca noted Condition No. 1 should reference Rapid Creek Road. Randy Price revised Condition No. 1 to include Rapid Creek Road.

Rudy Fontanari, Property Owner, 3316 E ¾ Road, Clifton; and Trevor Grosse, Owner Representative, 3305 E 3/4 Road, Clifton; provided additional project information and summarized the historic use of the quarry, specifics of the CUP, alternative access routes; and the ownership, use and restrictions of Rapid Creek Road.

Mike Meininger, Engineering Division Director, provided details of the condition of Rapid Creek Road and the one-lane bridge, explained sight distance and safety issues, summarized the location of pull-out areas on the road, plans for maintenance and tree removal along the road, and explained the need for roadway signage after maintenance. Jim Nall, Division Director, Mesa County Traffic Department, provided details regarding accidents along Rapid Creek Road.

David Frankel informed the Board that he evaluated the documentation entered into the record, confirmed his opinion that it is a public road, and discussed the basis for his opinion.

Page 2 of 4

Public Comments

Those providing public comments included: Larry Clever, General Manager Ute Water, 2822 Ridge Drive; Bennett Young, 840 Rapid Creek Road; Matthew King, 3989 Rapid Creek Road; Henry C. Higgins Jr., 0313 Remington Street, Rifle; Jim Sample, 3999 Rapid Creek Road; Emery Atchison, 3940 Rapid Creek Road; Carol Harrison, 860 Rapid Creek Road; Brett Fontanari, 825 Rapid Creek Road; Sharon Sample, 3999 Rapid Creek Road; and Frank Woodburn, 3598 G Road.

Public comments included: Historic and present uses of Rapid Creek Road, ownership of road, daily number of trucks using the road, current road standards, health and safety concerns, use of jake brakes, and wear-and- tear of the road.

Carol Harrison provided a PowerPoint presentation and video, which was entered into record as Public Comment Exhibit 1. The presentation and video are on file at the Mesa County Clerk and Recorder.

Commissioner Pugliese made a motion by reading the Review Summary into the record (Project Review, Pages 61 and 62), noting the project can meet or has met the applicable criteria of the code with Conditions of Approval, noting an amendment to Condition of Approval No. 1 as discussed: ROSE PUGLIESE MOVED TO APPROVE AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR MINING TO ALLOW UP TO 5 GRAVEL HAUL TRUCKS PER DAY FROM THE WESTERN SLOPE FLAGSTONE, CAMEO QUARRY TO USE RAPID CREEK ROAD AS A HAUL ROUTE; JOHN JUSTMAN SECONDED, MOTION CARRIED 2-1, STEVE ACQUAFRESCA OPPOSED.

The Board of County Commissioners took a recess at 11:43 a.m., and reconvened at 1:00 p.m.

2. 2014-0156 SPA APPEAL OF CHRIS’ GROOM ROOM MAJOR SITE PLAN Property Owner(s): Christine Haertling Appellants: John and Madelyn Gaarde, and Merlin Schreiner Location: 2382 N. San Miguel Drive, Grand Junction Parcel #: 2945-171-05-004 Zoning: RSF-4 Planner: Linda Dannenberger, Planning Division Director

A request to appeal an administrative decision to approve Project 2014-0105 SP, a major site plan application for a home occupation permit for a dog grooming business to be located in a 14’ x 23’ structure built alongside the south side of the existing garage. The owner is anticipated to be the only employee and there will be no retail sales or outdoor activities. Staff Recommendation: Uphold staffs’ administrative decision.

Linda Dannenberger entered into record the File 2014-0156 SPA, the original site plan file 2014-0105 SP, the Mesa County Land Development Code, the Mesa County Master Plan, the Project Report, a PowerPoint presentation as Exhibit A, a letter from Heather Lambeth of New Image Realty as Exhibit B, and public comment letters included as Exhibit C. Linda Dannenberger summarized the project location, zoning, site plan, the residential roads in the project area, and discussed the points of the appeal.

Page 3 of 4

The property owner, Chris Haertling, 2382 N. San Miguel Drive, provided additional details of the proposed project, explained the business plan, the anticipated operation of the proposed business, and parking for customers.

Public Comment

Public comments were provided by: John Gaarde, 2384 N. San Miguel Drive; Merlin Schreiner 2387 S. San Miguel Drive; and Madelyn Gaarde; 2384 N. San Miguel Drive.

Public comments included: Maintaining the residential character of the neighborhood, decline of property values, increased traffic in the neighborhood, safety of children and pedestrians, lack of sidewalks, zoning, traffic counts, and the proximity of the neighborhood to Scenic Elementary.

STEVE ACQUAFRESCA MOVED TO DENY THE APPEAL; ROSE PUGLIESE SECONDED, MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.

RESOLUTION (52:20)

2014-0155 CUP ESTABLISHMENT OF A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT BY RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, MESA COUNTY FOR THE GJ LAND COMPANY LLC (GRAND MESA EGGS) LOCATED AT 1133 & 1141 21 ROAD, FRUITA (Resolution on file at the Mesa County Clerk's Office; recorded in Book 5651, at Page 513, Reception No. 2704347; Resolution File No. 2014-222).

ROSE PUGLIESE MOVED TO APPROVE RESOLUTION 2014-0155; STEVE ACQUAFRESCA SECONDED, MOTION CARRIED UNANIMOUSLY.

ADJOURN

With no further business to come before the Board, Chair Justman adjourned the meeting at 1:28 p.m.

Sheila Reiner, Mesa County Clerk & Recorder

______Lori Westermire Chair John Justman Clerk to the Board

For complete details on any item, click on the audio link at the beginning of the document. Agendas, minutes and recorded webcasts can be found online at: http://www.mesacounty.us/commissioners/. Please note that listed recorded times are approximate.

Page 4 of 4

LAND USE ITEMS

November 18, 2014 9:00 A.M.

544 Rood Avenue Grand Junction, Co.

1 BoCC Rolling Calendar

November 18, 2014 Board of County Commissioner's Hearing - 544 Rood Ave - Hearing Room Project # Project Name Planner Status New BoCC 2014-0125 CUP Victory Life Church Signage Conditional Use Permit Randy OK 2014-0146 CUP Deer Creek Disposal Facility Amend Conditional Use Permit Randy OK 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation of Right of Way Christie OK 2014-0091 CPA Double Creek Estates Concept Plan Appeal Linda withdrawn

December 9, 2014 Board of County Commissioner's Hearing - 544 Rood Ave - Hearing Room Project # Project Name Planner Status New BoCC 2014-0149 VA Perry Private Vacation of Right of Way Linda OK

January 13, 2015 Board of County Commissioner's Hearing - 544 Rood Ave - Hearing Room Project # Project Name Planner Status New BoCC 2014-0182 RZ Snover Rezone Christie OK 2014-0158 VA Britton Vacation of Right of Way Christie OK

2 Index/ Location Map

3 INDEX MESA COUNTY COMMISSIONERS LAND USE HEARING NOVEMBER 18, 2014

HEARING ITEM(S):

1. 2014-0125 CUP VICTORY LIFE CHURCH SIGNAGE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT Pg 7

2. 2014-0146 CUP DEER CREEK DISPOSAL FACILITY AMENDMENT TO CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT Pg 37

3. 2014-0136 VA STAHL VACATION OF RIGHT OF WAY Pg 68

4 Location Map

1 3 ! !

BoCC Hearing Dates November 18, 2014

5 4

10 5 0 10 20 30 Miles PROJECT REVIEW

6 MESA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS Administration - Building - Engineering – Road and Bridge Traffic - Planning - Solid Waste Management

200 S. Spruce St. • P.O. Box 20,000 • Grand Junction, Colorado 81502-5022 Ph (970) 244-1636 Fax (970) 244-1769

PROJECT REVIEW October 15, 2014 (Revised November 4, 2014)

I. PRO2014-0125 CUP VICTORY LIFE CHURCH CUP AMENDMENT TO DAYCARE FACILITY TO ADD SIGN

Property Owner: First Assembly of God Inc c/o Victory Life Church Location: 2066 Highway 6&50, Fruita Parcel#: 2697-264-00-951 Zoning: AFT Planner: Randy Price, Senior Planner Request: To amend the existing Conditional Use Permit for a daycare facility to allow signage larger than that allowed in an AFT zone. Recommendation: Approval with conditions

II. SURROUNDING LAND USES AND ZONING:

The property is located within the AFT zoning district. The subject property is surrounded by a mixture of PUD and AFT zoning districts. The subject property is approximately 4,000 feet southeast from the city limits of the City of Fruita and approximately 2,300 feet northwest from the intersection of U.S. Highway 6 & 50 and 21 Rd.

Existing Land Use: The subject property is currently developed as a house of worship, an allowable use in the AFT zone. In 2011 Mesa County approved a CUP for the Victory Life Church (VLC) daycare facility, project number PRO2011-0225, BoCC resolution MCM2011-108. At that time signage was not addressed in the CUP application.

Future Land Use: The property is within the Fruita/Grand Junction Buffer Area, also known as the Cooperative Planning Area. This Area is the subject of an intergovernmental agreement, signed in 1998, between the Cities and Mesa County. Generally, the agreement requires that the City of Fruita and City of Grand Junction not annex any territory or extend any municipal utility services to the Buffer Area that are not already present without mutual consent of all parties. The intent of the agreement is to enhance the rural character of the area to provide a distinct separation between the cities of Fruita and Grand Junction.

III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION:

The applicant wishes to amend the CUP for the daycare facility to allow for a sign larger than the 24 square feet allowed for “noncommercial institutions” in an AFT zone. The applicant proposes a monument sign that is 25 feet in height and 12 feet wide. Mesa County Planning policy for signs in the AFT zone is that if an application is approved through the Conditional Use Permit process that signs included in the project details will be considered. Religious Assembly (churches) is allowed in all zoning districts in Mesa County but, there are no specific signage allowances for churches other than what is allowed in each zoning district. This application is reviewed as a non residential use and a free standing sign (Section 8.7.5, LDC) on a parcel with 1000 feet of frontage is allowed 750 square feet but not to exceed 300 square feet of signage. The maximum height of the sign is determined by the number of traffic lanes and Highway 6&50 at this location is 2 lanes wide and so the maximum height is limited to 25 feet. The applicant is proposing signage on an arch structure with an effective signage area of about 100 square feet.

IV. COMPLIANCE WITH MESA COUNTY CODE REQUIREMENTS:

Section 3.8.7 of the Land Development Code (2000, as amended) states that a Conditional Use Permit may be approved by the Board of County Commissioners after considering the following:

A. The proposed use is not significantly different from adjacent uses in terms of appearance, site design, operating characteristics (hours of operation, traffic generation, noise, odor, dust, and other external impacts) or, if the use is different, that any adverse impacts resulting from the use will be mitigated to the maximum extent practical and reclamation of the site will be adequate for appropriate future uses of the site where applicable.

Planning will require that the applicant remove the temporary signs located at the entrance of the church property. The white backlit portion of the top of the monument signs will not be bright enough to be glaring to traffic along highway 6&50. The message board portion of the sign will not flash or have messages that scroll. The messages will not be updated more frequently than 20 seconds to avoid distracting drivers.

This criterion can be met with conditions of approval.

B. Facilities and services (including sewage and waste disposal, recycling, domestic and irrigation water [where available], gas, electricity, security measures, police and fire protection, and roads and transportation, special fencing, and signage, as applicable) shall be available upon completion of the project to serve the subject property while maintaining adequate levels of service to proposed and existing development during regular, periodic, and peak usages.

This criterion has been met in the first CUP approval.

C. Access will be provided as necessary to prevent traffic hazards and to minimize traffic congestion in public streets and alleys.

This criterion has been met in the first CUP approval.

D. Adequate assurances of on-going maintenance have been provided.

This criterion has been met in the first CUP approval.

E. Any significant adverse impacts on the natural environment will be mitigated to the maximum extent practical, including whether soils and geologic suitability are adequate for the proposed use, and whether prevailing winds might cause adverse impacts on site and off-site.

The facilities for this proposed use are already existing, and there will not be any additional adverse impacts to the natural environment.

This criterion has been met in the first CUP approval.

F. There is a need for the use on a community wide basis.

The applicant indicates that there is a need to relay church name, schedules and services offered by the church.

This criterion has been met.

Section 3.1.17, General Approval Criteria, must also be considered for Conditional Use Permit requests:

A. complies with all applicable standards, provisions, and purposes of this Land Development Code;

It appears that this request complies or can comply with all applicable standards, provisions and purposes of the Land Development Code.

This criterion has been met.

B. is consistent with review agency comments;

This request is or can be made consistent with all review agency comments. All review agency comments have been attached to this project review.

This criterion can be met.

C. is consistent with applicable intergovernmental agreements (IGA) between the County and other entities.

This proposal is consistent with the Cooperative Planning Area Intergovernmental Agreement between Mesa County, the City of Fruita, and Grand Junction. Both municipalities were sent notices. Only the city of Fruita responded with comments. Those comments are included in the review agency binder under the review agency comments.

This criterion can be met.

V. REVIEW AGENCY COMMENTS:

All review comments received are a part of the hearing packet and the file.

VI. PUBLIC COMMENTS:

As of the date of this review one public comment has been received objecting to the CUP amendment; this email is included in the hearing binder.

VII. PROJECT RECOMMENDATION:

The Planning Division recommends approval of the amendment to the CUP for the Victory Life Church Victory Garden daycare facility CUP, to allow a sign as described in the application subject to the following conditions:

1. Conditions of approval in resolution MCM 2011-108 for the approval of the day care facility are still applicable.

2. The applicant shall remove the temporary signs located at the entrance of the church property. The white backlit portion of the top of the monument signs will not be bright enough to be glaring to traffic along highway 6&50. The message board portion of the sign will not flash or have messages that scroll. The messages will not be updated more frequently than 20 seconds to avoid distracting drivers and the message board will automatically dim at night.

The basis for this recommendation: The petition complies with or has the ability to comply with the criterion in Section 3.8.7A – F, and Section 3.1.17.A - C of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended).

Summary

Conditional Use Permit Criteria 3.8.7 Condition A. The proposed use is not significantly different from adjacent uses in appearance, site design, and operating characteristics or adequately mitigates adverse impacts Can be met 1, 2

B. Facilities and services are available Has been met

C. Access is provided to prevent traffic hazards and minimize traffic congestion Has been met

D. Adequate assurances of on-going maintenance

are provided Has been met

E. Significant adverse impacts on the natural environment have been mitigated to the extent practical Has been met F. A need for the use on a community-wide basis has been established Has been met

General Approval Criteria 3.1.17 A. Compliance with applicable standards and provisions in the Land Development Code Has been met

B. Consistency with review agency comments Can be met 1, 2

C. Consistency with applicable IGAs Can be met 1, 2

IX. MCPC RECOMMENDATION October 23, 2014 Recommendation to Approve with Conditions, 3 to 1

X. BOCC ACTION (11/18/14)

15 HEARING NOTICE

16 Victory Life Church Amend CUP Parcel/Notification Map 2014-0125 CUP October 3, 2014

Notification Buffer

AFT

LegendLegend

2697-264-00-951

2500 ft buffer Parcels GJ/Fruita Buffer "

0.45 0 0.45 0.9 1.35 1.8 17 Miles 2014-0125 CUP Victory Life Church Notification Table Amendment for Signage PARCEL_NUM OWNER MAILING CITY ST ZIP 2697-263-00-049 8 PENNY LLC 2258 WILLOW WOOD R GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81507 2697-351-04-006 ALEXANDER CAROL D TRUST 2070 BLUE WATER DR FRUITA CO 81521-9420 2697-262-00-019 AMOS EMMETT 2020 HIGHWAY 6 AND 5FRUITA CO 81521-9329 2697-351-04-003 ANDERSON DAVID G 2069 BLUE WATER DR FRUITA CO 81521-9419 2697-261-00-109 AUSTIN JEFFREY B 893 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-263-01-004 AZCARRAGA MARTIN PO BOX 2072 GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81502-2072 2697-261-00-110 BAKER JONATHAN G 2075 I RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-344-00-299 BARNES PATRICIA J 2015 TIARA CT GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81507-9788 2697-261-00-127 BERGEN RALPH ALLEN 868 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9113 2697-253-00-085 BISHOP SONYA J 2120 H RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81505-9745 2697-261-00-013 BLAIR RONALD JOHN 863 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9316 2697-261-00-146 BLICHFELDT JEFFREY E 857 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9316 2697-262-00-104 BRADLEY JAMES D 855 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9114 2697-262-06-001 BROWN LEROY C 2020 H 3/4 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-253-00-020 CAMPBELL SHERI V 848 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9315 2697-253-00-063 CARR CURTIS H JR 2108 H RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81505 2697-253-00-021 COGBURN RUSSELL F 850 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-261-00-012 COLLINS LISA 929 22 1/2 RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 815059365 2697-252-00-002 Confidential Owner 888 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-261-00-131 DATZ STEPHEN C 2073 I RD FRUITA CO 81521-9322 2697-264-00-078 DE PRIEST DAVID 2062 HIGHWAY 6 AND 5FRUITA CO 81521-9329 2697-263-00-142 DIVERSIFIED RESOURCES LLC 2045 RIVER RD FRUITA CO 81521 2947-142-00-922 DIVISION OF WILDLIFE 6060 BROADWAY DENVER CO 80216-1029 2697-262-00-100 EASTRIDGE LYNN C 867 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9114 2697-261-00-108 EDWARDS PATRICK T 891 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9316 2697-263-00-144 ENGELKE ROBERT O 2111 YELLOWSTONE RDGRAND JUNCTIONCO 81507-1021 2697-261-05-003 EQUESTRIAN CENTER OF MESA C2454 PATTERSON RD STGRAND JUNCTIONCO 81505-1212 2697-262-00-105 FARNSWORTH PHILLIP T 849 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9114 2697-264-00-951 FIRST ASSEMBLY OF GOD INC 2066 HIGHWAY 6 AND 5FRUITA CO 815219329 2697-264-00-064 GABRIEL GARY L 823 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-264-05-001 GALINDO FRANCISCO J PO BOX 263 FRUITA CO 815210263 2697-253-00-035 GARNER RICHARD E SR 2102 H RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81505-9745 2697-262-04-002 GARRISON BRET J PO BOX 883 GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81502 2697-253-00-114 GORDON ENGINEERING INC 629 1/2 26 1/2 RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81506 2697-351-00-946 GRAND VALLEY DRAINAGE DISTRPO BOX 969 GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81502 2697-264-00-125 GREEN MARK A 813 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-264-00-071 GRILLOS WILLIAM J 7816 ROUTE D JEFFERSON CITY MO 65109-8327 2697-261-00-106 HALLER LOREN 2058 H 3/4 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9127 2697-262-00-016 HBP PROPERTY LLC PO BOX 204 RANGELY CO 81648-0204 2697-263-00-039 HEJNY RALPH G FAMILY TRUST 592 STARLIGHT DR GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81504 2697-351-00-423 HERRERA FREDDIE LEE 2079 RIVER RD FRUITA CO 81521-9400 2697-262-00-075 HOULNE MICHELLE C 2029 I RD FRUITA CO 81521-9339 2697-262-00-055 HOWARD SHIRLEY A 1515 PTARMIGAN RIDGGRAND JUNCTIONCO 81506-5237 2697-362-24-002 IDEAL INVESTMENTS LLC PO BOX 1385 SAINT GEORGE UT 84771 2697-263-00-082 JENNINGS ROSEMARY K 847 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9114 2697-262-00-117 JENSEN JAMES M 871 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9114

Page 1 of 3 18 2014-0125 CUP Victory Life Church Notification Table Amendment for Signage 2697-262-00-018 JONES SUE 2022 1/2 HIGHWAY 6 ANFRUITA CO 81521-9329 2697-253-00-056 JORDAN LINDA L 832 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9315 2697-253-00-064 JUNAK EDWARD M LIVING TRUST826 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9315 2697-253-00-066 KAMPLAIN LYNN D 2108 1/2 H RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81505-9745 2697-261-01-001 KENNEY KIT M 890 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-8700 2697-262-00-116 KEY RONALD C 2043 H 3/4 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9121 2697-253-00-067 KING TIMOTHY A 824 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9315 2697-351-04-011 LAKE M LTD 2065 BLUE WATER DR FRUITA CO 81521-9419 2697-351-00-419 LAKE MIRAGE LTD 2065 BLUE WATER DR FRUITA CO 81521-9419 2697-262-02-001 LEWTON PATRICK F 887 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9117 2697-261-00-141 LICHLYTER TOM 895 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9316 2697-262-04-001 LOSTUMBO JOHN D 2031 H 3/4 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-261-00-037 LOVERIDGE J T AND LOVERIDGE A875 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-263-00-083 MARSH VICKIE LYNN 856 OURAY AVE GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81501 2697-362-00-040 MARTIN FAMILY TRUST 1026 19 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9381 2697-362-00-091 MARTIN FAMILY TRUST 1026 19 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-351-61-002 MONUMENT VIEW LAKE LLC PO BOX 132 AVON CO 81620-0132 2697-264-05-002 MOORE DAVID C 849 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9316 2697-362-00-092 MORRIS JOHNNIE E 909 22 RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81505-9309 2697-261-00-118 NEILSON EDWARD L 2065 H 3/4 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9128 2697-252-00-126 NORTHWEST GJ LLC 8061 CASTLE PINES AVE LAS VEGAS NV 89113-1204 2697-264-00-126 OEST KENNETH E 2098 HIGHWAY 6 AND 5FRUITA CO 81521 2697-264-00-077 OEST LIVING TRUST 2098 HIGHWAY 6 AND 5FRUITA CO 81521 2697-262-00-054 OEST TIM 2098 HIGHWAY 6 AND 5FRUITA CO 81521-9329 2697-264-00-087 OTTMAN NICK D PO BOX 756 FRUITA CO 81521-0756 2697-264-00-070 OWEN ROBERT J 827 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-253-00-030 POTTER HAROLD DEAN 2045 RIVER RD FRUITA CO 815219416 2697-261-01-002 QUARLES RALPH B 2053 I RD FRUITA CO 81521-9335 2697-253-00-033 RAFF JOHN H 808 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9315 2697-261-00-062 RALEY ERROL R 844 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9113 2697-261-00-002 RANNEY MICHAEL A 2079 I RD FRUITA CO 81521-9323 2697-351-00-420 REECE DALE R 2065 BLUE WATER DR FRUITA CO 81521-9419 2697-351-04-001 REECE DALE R 2768 COMPASS DR GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81506-8729 2697-264-00-122 REECE JERRY R 851 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9316 2697-262-00-089 RHODES EDNA LOUISE 2049 I RD FRUITA CO 81521-9339 2697-263-00-050 RODRIGUEZ HUGO 2036 HIGHWAY 6 AND 5FRUITA CO 81521-9329 2697-253-00-086 SCHREINER WILLIAM F III 2114 H RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81505-9745 2697-263-00-027 SEGER DAVID J 25539 W GAMBIT TRL WITTMANN AZ 853618743 2697-262-00-020 SHIFFLETT ROBERT W 2024 HIGHWAY 6 AND 5FRUITA CO 81521-9329 2697-262-02-002 SILLS KENNETH R 879 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9117 2697-362-00-089 SIXBEY INVESTMENTS LLC 2339 PROMONTORY CT GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81507 2697-261-00-107 SODERQUIST TY DAVID 880 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9115 2697-261-00-124 SPACH DAVID TIMOTHY 862 20 1/2 RD UNIT B FRUITA CO 81521 2697-261-00-113 SPARKS FRANK 2059 H 3/4 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9128 2697-263-00-924 STATE DEPARTMENT OF HIGHWA606 S 9TH ST STE 1 GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81501-7768 2697-263-00-084 STEED JOHN H 2323 H RD GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81505-9675 2697-253-00-025 STOGSDILL STEVEN R 842 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521

Page 2 of 3 19 2014-0125 CUP Victory Life Church Notification Table Amendment for Signage 2697-351-04-007 SUAREZ JUAN M 2075 RIVER RD FRUITA CO 81521-9400 2697-261-00-130 SUNDERMANN BRIGITTE 2070 H 3/4 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9127 2697-261-00-140 THEULLIER BORIS 2077 I RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-264-00-121 THOMPSON DONALD R 160 SUNDANCE DR GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81503 2697-351-04-010 THORNTON WILLIAM STACK 2071 BLUE WATER DR FRUITA CO 81521-9419 2697-253-00-022 TOMLINSON RICHARD GARY 844 21 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-253-00-029 US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATIO1920 NORTH STEMMONDALLAS TX 75207 2697-351-04-002 VALENTINE WILLIAM F 1342 JUNIPER DR ROCK SPRINGS WY 82901-6409 2697-262-00-088 VICKERS KATHERINE M 891 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521-9117 2697-262-03-006 WILLITS LLOYD E 2036 H 3/4 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-263-00-028 WILSON PEGEEN 2075 K RD FRUITA CO 81521-9046 2697-351-04-009 WIXOM ALAN 2028 ROOSEVELT CT GRAND JUNCTIONCO 81507-9572 2697-262-03-005 WOOLERY DONALD L SR 2027 I RD FRUITA CO 81521-9339 2697-261-00-123 YOUNG SHANNON C 860 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2697-264-00-086 YOUNGER D PAKE 846 20 1/2 RD FRUITA CO 81521

Page 3 of 3 20 MCPC MINUTES FROM 10-23-14 HEARING

21 MESA COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION October 23, 2014 PUBLIC HEARING MINUTES

Chairman Moreng called to order a scheduled hearing of the Mesa County Planning Commission at 6:06 p.m. Chairman Moreng led the Pledge of Allegiance. The hearing was held in the Public Hearing Room, Mesa County Administration Building at 544 Rood Avenue, Grand Junction, Colorado.

In attendance representing the Mesa County Planning Commission, were: Joe Moreng, Phillip Jones, Christi Flynn, and Chip Page.

In attendance, representing the Mesa County Planning Division, were: Linda Dannenberger and Randy Price. Kathy Kinsey was present to record the minutes.

There were twenty one (21) citizens present throughout the hearing.

Approval of Minutes 9-25-14 Motion: Commissioner Page moved to approve the minutes as written. Second: Commissioner Flynn Motion Approved 4-0

Continued Items None

Consent Items None

Hearing Items 1. 2014-0125 CUP VICTORY LIFE CHURCH, AMENDMENT TO CUP TO ALLOW SIGN Property Owner(s): First Assembly of God, Inc Representative(s): Rev. G. Robert Cook Jr. Location: 2066 Highway 6 & 50, Fruita 81521 Parcel #: 2697-264-00-951 Zoning: AFT Planner: Randy Price, 244-1759, [email protected] Request: To amend the existing Conditional Use Permit for a daycare facility to allow signage larger than that allowed in an AFT zone. Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions Board of County Commissioners Hearing Date: 11-18-14

Staff Presentation Randy Price entered into the record the Victory Life Church amendment to the CUP daycare to allow a sign, project file PRO2014-0125, the 2000 Mesa County Land Development Code, the Mesa County Land Use Plan and his PowerPoint presentation

22 labeled as Exhibit A. Mr. Price also entered into the record a handout that he provided to the commissioners that is titled the Cooperative Planning Agreement between Fruita and Mesa County and labeled this as Exhibit B.

Mr. Price explained that the request is to allow signage for the church and daycare that is larger than what is allowed in the AFT zone. The church was constructed in 2009, the property is on 33 acres and it is located between Grand Junction and Fruita in the cooperative planning area. He went on to explain that the property is surrounded by a planned unit development (PUD). Mr. Price provided more history about the church and showed several maps and photos showing the location of the property and the proposed sign. He explained that the applicant is proposing to amend the CUP in order to have a sign larger than that allowed which is a 2 foot square sign. He explained that the proposed sign is 12 feet wide and 25 feet high and part of it will be an archway with decorative stone and the top portion that is 10 feet by 5 feet will be back lit and in the middle of the sign, which is approximately 3 feet by 7 feet 9 inches, will be an LED display sign where messages can be changed remotely and below that it will say Victory Garden, which is the name of the daycare facility.

Mr. Price went on to show photos of the current signs on the property which are temporary and would be removed when the new sign is constructed. He also discussed the impacts of the sign which is brightness, having an LED flashing or scrolling sign that could distract drivers but they are willing to limit the brightness of the sign during the evening hours with light sensors and to have the scrolling message only change every 20 seconds to also avoid driver distractions.

The recommendation for this project is approval with conditions and Mr. Price said this has the ability to comply with the criteria in Section 3.8.7 A through F and Section 3.1. 17 A of the Mesa County Land Development Code. Mr. Price continued on to read the comment sent in by the City of Fruita, who is against this sign. He also read the conditions of approval.

Questions Commissioner Jones asked why the sign application that came through in 2013 was denied. Mr. Price explained that it was presented as a Sign Permit application and the Land Development Code doesn’t allow signage greater than 2 square feet in an AFT zone. Mr. Price discussed this with the applicant and suggested they amend the CUP for their daycare and apply for the larger sign with this type of application.

Chair Moreng inquired about the properties on the other sides of the church. Mr. Price stated that there is an irrigation pipe company, a facility that stores oil and gas trailers, a site that stored large tanks and there are a few residences west of the church. There are also some strip mall types of trade shops. Commissioner Flynn stated that there are other businesses that also have their signage along their properties. These other businesses were constructed prior to Mesa County’s Land Development Code in regards to zoning and creation of the buffer.

Chair Moreng asked what the purpose of the new sign is. Mr. Price explained that the church wants to advertise their daycare and also what time their church services are. Further discussion took place about other signage and billboards along that section of

23 the highway and they talked about this sign being a possible safety concern. It was also mentioned that there is a turn lane off of the highway that goes directly into the church and this sign would better direct people to that road.

Applicant Robert Cook 2528 Greystone Drive, Grand Junction Mr. Cook stated that he has been the senior pastor of the church since August of 2012. Pastor Cook explained that they are willing to be flexible and will change the design of the sign to please the community and so it doesn’t distract traffic nor detract from street appeal. He said he believes that there is a need for a sign this size due to the fact that the highway is about 100 feet away and it would be difficult to see a smaller size sign.

Public Comments Tom Groves, 1049 20 Road, Fruita Mr. Groves presented comments against the application to include statements about the buffer zone being under attack as it is and to allow this sign will let others do the same thing in the future. He also stated that he believes with too much growth the leach fields will fail and there will be a need to put in sewer. The commissioners stated that this application is only for signage at this point in time.

Roland Cole-659 Grand View Drive and Janet Rowland-611 Stan Drive spoke in favor of this sign application stating that it would be compatible with other signage in the area and with the speed limit of 55 miles per hour on the highway, a larger sign is necessary so people know where the road is to turn into the church. Ms. Rowland stated facts about the church already being there and discussed the intent of the buffer zone.

Applicant Rebuttal and Questions Chair Moreng inquired about also having a small sign showing where the road is to turn off to the church. Mr. Price stated that would need to be a Department of Transportation (DOT) approval. Pastor Bob stated that the current signs face to the south and it’s difficult for people coming from the east or west to see them. He said with the size of the new sign and the fact that it faces north and south it will be easier for people to see the turn lane which is right after where the sign will sit on the property.

Closed to public comment Motion: Commissioner Flynn made a motion for approval of 2014-0125 CUP Victory Life Church sign with the staff’s recommendations and to move this on to the Board of County Commissioners on November 18, 2014. Second: Commissioner Page

Commissioner Jones voted Nay. He stated that he is conflicted because he believes the sign is very tastefully done and there is a large amount of frontage on the highway but he doesn’t know why they should approve the sign now when it was denied in 2013 and the only change being the addition of a daycare. He also agrees with the objection by the City of Fruita based on the size of the sign. Motion: Approval with conditions, 3-1

24 REVIEW AGENCY COMMENTS

25 26 PRO2014-0125 - VICTORY LIFE CHURCH CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT Review Agency Comments Comments Due Date: 2014-10-03

User Review Date/Time Comment Agency Alan Clubb CODOT-REGION 9/16/2014 1) No Off Premise Advertising on LED sign. 3 4:27:38 PM 2) Minimum 50% dimming at night from day time setting. Darrell Bay MC BUILDING 9/19/2014 Mesa county building department has no objections to this project. DEPT 11:37:50 AM A building permit will be required. This is NOT a plan review or permit approval. FIRE MARSHALL FIRE LOWER 9/23/2014 Provide address identification per Section 505.1 of the Fire Code as FRUITA VALLEY 10:57:51 AM amended by the LVFD. Numbers to be sized to be readable from Hwy 6 & 50. Courtney MC CODE 10/1/2014 Mesa County Code Compliance Services does not have any open or Campbell COMPLIANCE 4:10:19 PM active case files pertaining to (2066 Highway 6 & 50). Code Compliance Services has not conducted a site visit, therefore should the assigned Planner find an apparent Code violation when they visit the property, please notify Code Compliance Services and we will investigate

27 CITY FRUITA CITY FRUITA 10/3/2014 As the County is aware, Fruita was opposed to the construction of 1:57:43 PM this urban land use (a large church) in the buffer area as it does not meet the intent of the Cooperative Planning Area (Buffer) Agreement nor does it meet Fruita's & the County's Master Plans for this area. As per the Agreement and Master Plans, development in this area should enhance rural character. It appears that Mesa County's laws limit signs in the AFT zone to 10 feet in height and less than 25 square feet in area. The applicants request a 25-foot tall sign with approximately 150 square feet of sign area including scrolling LED lights. Section 8.8 of the County's Land Development Code indicates that through the Conditional Use Permit process, a variance to the maximum total surface area of signs shall not be permitted, but the maximum sign allowance for the entire development or use may be aggregated and the total allowance redistributed. Allowing a taller and larger sign to advertise the church through a Conditional Use Permit process for a day care center at the church is inappropriate. A larger sign for the church should be granted through the variance process (Section 3.12 of the County's Land Development Code) or through a change to the County's Land Development Code to be fair to all other religious institutions and other property owners in the AFT zone. The City of Fruita does not support commercial development in the buffer area, including commercial signage. The tall and large sign, including the LED lights with moving copy as is proposed, is more appropriate in the commercial corridors of the County, not the area intended to retain its rural characteristics through the Cooperative Planning Area Agreement and the City and County' Master Plans.

28 PUBLIC COMMENTS

29 30 APPLICANT INFORMATION

31 32 33 34 35 PROJECT REVIEW

36 MESA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS Administration - Building - Engineering – Road and Bridge Traffic - Planning - Solid Waste Management

200 S. Spruce Street • P.O. Box 20,000 • Grand Junction, Colorado 81502-5022 Ph (970) 244-1636 Fax (970) 244-1769

PROJECT REVIEW October 15, 2014 (Revised November 4, 2014)

I. PRO2014-0146 GOODWIN CUP AMENDMENT Property Owner(s): Deer Creek Facilities LLC Representative(s): Thomas Pool Location: 5180 HIGHWAY 50 Parcel #: 3201-354-00-022 Zoning: AFT Planner: Randy Price, Senior Planner Request: To amend the existing CUP to permanently extend the hours of operation to 24 hours a day, 7 days per week.

Recommendation: Approval with Conditions

The Goodwin Solid Waste Disposal Facility (Deer Creek) is located 20 miles southeast of Grand Junction, 1 mile east of Highway 50 and 1 mile north of the Mesa/Delta County line. The facility is 96 acres in size and was first permitted is 1993 as a solid waste disposal facility accepting sand

1 37 trap and grease trap waste. The permit has been amended several times to change the types of waste received. In 2010 the permit was amended to add exploration and production waste from oil and gas operations. The CUP 2010-0200 approved 2 evaporation ponds approximately 3 acres in size each. The ponds have been constructed and have been operational for 2 years.

Aerial Photo with Locations of 2010 Approved Changes

2 38

II. SURROUNDING LAND USE The permit area is bounded by public lands administered by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to the north, south, and east and by private property and BLM property to the west. All property within the notification area is zoned Agricultural Forestry Transitional (AFT). The rural future land-use classification is Large Lot Rural Agricultural 35+ (LL R/A 35+).

Within the 2,500 ft. public notification area there is one residence owned by Thomas and Kathleen Panter. The residence is a yurt and is off the grid. It is powered by photovoltaic, propane and has an ISDS. The yurt is 1,200 feet from the western boundary of the permit area. The Panter residence was constructed in 2010. In 2010 the operator relocated the access road around Panter’s property. The road was relocated onto the surrounding BLM property. Prior to this, the access road crossed the Panter’s property on an easement.

Three miles to the northwest is another waste disposal facility approved by the BoCC (CUP 2010-0031) in 2010. The Indian Mesa facility has not yet been constructed. The land was purchased by Alanco the owners of the operators of the E&P waste portion of the Goodwin facility. They are currently in the final steps of receiving CDPHE approval for the Engineering, Design and Operation Plan (EDOP). The Indian Mesa facility will be located adjacent to the Department of Energy’s Cheney Uranium mill tailings waste disposal cell. The hours of operation are approved to be 24 hours a day and 7 days a week.

III. PROJECT DESCRIPTION:

In November of 2013 the BoCC approved a one year variance from the approved hours of operation from sunup to sundown, 6 days per week. The applicant requested this variance because wastewater truckers often operate 24/7 and to be competitive with other disposal facilities, the Goodwin Deer Creek facility had requested a permanent change to the hours of operation. TC Operating, the company that operates the oil and gas waste disposal portion of the facility is permitting the Indian Mesa facility, but access across BLM and general slowness of the wastewater disposal industry may delay the opening of the facility. The Indian Mesa facility is permitted for 24/7 operation since its haul route is not located near residences.

The hours of operation were set in the 2010 CUP as a condition of approval. The operator claims that business is going to the Danish Flats disposal facility located near Thompson Springs, Utah. That facility is open 24 hours, 7 days a week and this schedule is more desirable since waste haulers work 24 hours a day and make continuous round trips to the facilities.

During the summer of 2014, three electrically powered aerators were added to the east pond to remedy an anaerobic condition that had developed in late May 2014 due to the rising temperatures and biological oxygen demand from the nutrients in the pond. The pond turned anaerobic and odor complaints were received by CDPHE and Mesa County Health Department from residents on Purdy Mesa Road, Kannah Creek Road, Blue Sage Drive, a resident living ½ mile west of the facility and residents living across Highway 6&50 near Bridgeport Road. The first complaint was received during the fourth week of May. By June 12th, seven complaints were received. The facility treated the pond with chlorine and then peroxide this worked for a period of time before returning to an anaerobic condition. The facility worked out a treatment regime of adding peroxide every 4 days. This was not a long term solution and the facility petitioned the CDPHE to allow provisional use of aerators to circulate and add oxygen the east pond. During the period that the facility worked out a treatment schedule, there were periods that

3 39

the pond reverted to an anaerobic odor situation. Mesa County Environmental Health and Planning with CDPHE Solid Waste personnel conducted several inspections of the facility. The last inspection was to use a certified odor inspector using air sampling equipment. At that time the pond was not anaerobic and it was determined that odor levels were not outside the range that would be considered enforceable for an odor complaint. The east pond was the only pond experiencing a problem and new waste was not being added to the west pond. During this time E&P waste water was not being added to the west pond and that pond did not have the problems that the east pond experienced; this pond was only about 10% full. Additionally, a walnut shell pretreatment filter was installed to remove some of the organic material in the waste stream that contributed to the high biological oxygen demand.

IV. COMPLIANCE WITH MESA COUNTY CODE REQUIREMENTS:

Section 3.8.7 and Section 3.1.17 of the Mesa County Land Development Code were used to evaluate this application.

Section 3.8.7 of the Land Development Code (2000, as amended) states that a Conditional Use Permit may be approved by the Board of County Commissioners after considering the following:

Potential adverse impacts to operating 24 hours a day, seven days a week will be additional noise from nighttime truck traffic and off-loading liquid waste, also light pollution from lighting. To mitigate noise and visual impact, the applicant in the 2010 permit amendment moved the access road 1200 feet to the south of the Panter residence. Additionally, material excavated from the construction of the waste ponds was used to construct a >20’ high, 1000’ long berm on the west side of the ponds. The waste off-loading area was placed on the far east side of the permit area, 2,800 feet from the Panter residence.

Truck traffic on highway 50 may be a source of additional night-time noise as trucks traveling on highway 50 slow to turn into the facility access road. Truckers sometimes use “jake brakes” to supplement regular brakes. Jake Brakes can be noisy and to mitigate night-time noise pollution a condition of approval will be to prohibit truckers from using these brakes at night.

In order to mitigate the adverse impacts to the Panter residence, the change of hours of operation of the facility should not be permanent and should be limited to a period of two years and an administrative review conducted by the Division after one year. This will allow time for the Indian Mesa waste facility that was approved for 24 hours a day and 7 days per week, to become operational.

To mitigate nighttime pollution the facility is required to have full cutoff lighting (required in section 7.6.7 MCLDC) and non-essential lighting will be turned off when not needed.

This criterion can be met with conditions of approval.

4 40

Minimal services will be required for this facility. The area is sparsely settled partially due to the lack of any services. There is no potable water system, no sewer system, no irrigation water, no phone service, and no electrical network. Fire protection would be provided by the Lands End Fire Department and police protection by the Mesa County Sheriff’s department. Electrical needs will be provided by an on-site 50KW generator, with a hospital muffler to mitigate noise. Water for dust suppression would be trucked to the site. Portable toilets will serve sanitary needs, but an Individual Sewage Disposal System (ISDS) might be required per comments from Mesa County Environmental Health.

This criterion can be met with conditions of approval.

C. Access will be provided as necessary to prevent traffic hazards and to minimize traffic congestion in public streets and alleys.

A new access road was constructed to this facility in 2010 on BLM land. The current CDOT access permit for Highway 50, sets the maximum allowable trucks to 20 per day; any more would trigger the requirement for additional improvements to the Highway.

This criterion has been met.

D. Adequate assurances of on-going maintenance have been provided.

The Engineering Design and Operations Plan approved by the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment solid waste disposal permit outlines required monitoring, reporting and closure requirements for this facility.

This criterion can be met with conditions of approval.

The facility has been in compliance with the existing air emissions permit. The odor problem that the facility experienced this past summer seems to be under control and the operator conducts regular testing for dissolved oxygen to make sure the problem doesn't occur again. Roads are treated for dust suppression. The leachate collection system of the ponds is monitored for leakage per CDPHE requirements and there is an ongoing water monitoring program.

This criterion can be met with conditions of approval.

5 41

F. There is a need for the use on a community wide basis.

There is a need for wastewater treatment facilities to meet the demands for treatment of produced water as the oil and gas industry recovers in western Colorado. A shortage of sufficient treatment facilities has caused some producers to truck their water into Utah. Having a facility available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week helps to meet the needs of the oil and gas industry that is a vital part of the region's recovering economy.

This criterion has been adequately addressed by the applicant.

Section 3.1.17 General Approval Criteria must also be considered for Conditional Use Permit requests:

A. Complies with all applicable standards, provisions, and purposes of this Land Development Code;

It appears that this request complies or can comply with all applicable standards, provisions and purposes of the Land Development Code if all review agency comments and recommended conditions of approval are met.

This criterion can be met with conditions of approval.

B. Is consistent with review agency comments;

No concerns have been identified in review agency comments which could not be addressed by the review agency requests and the recommended conditions of approval.

This criterion can be met with conditions of approval.

C. Is consistent with applicable intergovernmental agreements (IGA) between the County and other entities.

This project is subject to MCA 97-18 between Mesa County and the Bureau of Land Management and MCA 2001-26 between Mesa County and the USDA Forest Service. These IGAs promote cooperation in land development review. Review requests were provided to the BLM, no comments have been received.

This criterion has been met.

V. REVIEW COMMENTS:

All review agency comments received are attached to this project report.

VI. PUBLIC COMMENTS:

At the time of the writing of the project review one written public comment had been received and this is included as part of the hearing binder.

6 42

VII. PROJECT RECOMMENDATION:

The Mesa County Division of Planning staff recommends approval of this amendment to the Conditional Use Permit subject to the following conditions:

1. The change to the hours of operation to 24 hours a day, 7 days a week will be restricted to a 2 year period starting with the resolution adoption if this application is approved. This will allow additional time for the Indian Mesa Facility to become operational. After one year an administrative review will be conducted to assure compliance with environmental regulations. 2. The facility shall use full cutoff light fixtures and turn off non-essential lighting when not needed. 3. Truckers will be prohibited from using Jake brakes for night-time deliveries on the access road and along the State Highway on the approach to the access road. 4. All review agency comments not in conflict with the conditions of approval shall be addressed. 5. The applicant, owner and operator shall not significantly deviate from the site plan and documents submitted with this application. Any modification or expansion of this facility, not including minor modifications as determined by the Planning Director, shall require an amendment of the Conditional Use Permit. 6. Conditions of approval of the prior Mesa County Board of County Commissioners resolutions shall still be applicable unless specifically amended in later BOCC resolutions. Prior resolutions are, MCM 96-140, MCM 97-129, MCM 99-134, MCM 2004-034, MCM 2004-073 and MCM-2011-109 and MCM-2012-049.

Basis for recommendation:

The petition demonstrates compliance or the ability to comply with with the criterion in Section 3.8.7A – F and Section 3.1.17.A – C of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended). Review Summary

CUP Approval Criteria: Condition#

3.8.7. A (compatibility with surrounding property) - can be met 1,2,3,5,6 3.8.7. B (facilities and services) - can be met 4,5 3.8.7. C (adequate access) – has been met 3.8.7. D (maintenance) - can be met 5,6 3.8.7. E (impacts mitigated) - can be met 1 - 6 3.8.7. F (community-wide need) - has been met

General Approval Criteria:

3.1.17. A (compliance with the Land Development Code) - can be met 1-6 3.1.17. B (consistent with review agency comments) - can be met 4 3.1.17. C (consistency with IGAs) – has been met

7 43

VIII. MCPC ACTION: October 23, 2014, Recommendation to Deny 4 to 0 IX. BOCC ACTION: (November 18, 2014)

8 44

HEARING NOTICE

45 Deer Creek Water Disposal Facility 2014-0146 CUP Parcel/Notification Map October 3, 2014

Notification Buffer

LegendLegend

3201-354-00-022

2500 ft buffer Parcels BLM Land "

0.55 0 0.55 1.1 1.65 2.2 46 Miles 2014-0146 CUP Deer Creek Water Notification Table Disposal Amend CUP PARCEL_NUM OWNER MAILING CITY ST ZIP 3229-093-00-914 BLM 2815 H RD GRAND JUNCTIO CO 81506 3201-354-00-022 DEER CREEK FACILITIES LL661 24 1/2 RD GRAND JUNCTIO CO 81505 3203-251-00-046 DUKES GARRY L 1538 DENT COUNTY ROAD ROLLA MO 654018653 3203-252-00-045 HUDSON BARBARA A 10277 E PINEWOOD DR PARKER CO 80138-7803 3203-254-00-036 PANTER KATHLEEN S 452 GRAND AVE DELTA CO 81416-2023 3201-364-00-023 WILTON EARLE AND SON 785 VALLEY VIEW DR CRAIG CO 81625-8501 THOMAS POOL 138 S. PARK SQUARE #203 FRUITA CO 81521

Page 1 of 1 47 MCPC MINUTES FROM 10-23-14 HEARING

48 MESA COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION October 23, 2014 PUBLIC HEARING MINUTES

In attendance representing the Mesa County Planning Commission, were: Joe Moreng, Phillip Jones, Christi Flynn, and Chip Page.

In attendance, representing the Mesa County Planning Division, were: Linda Dannenberger and Randy Price. Kathy Kinsey was present to record the minutes.

There were twenty one (21) citizens present throughout the hearing.

Approval of Minutes 9-25-14 Motion: Commissioner Page moved to approve the minutes as written. Second: Commissioner Flynn Motion Approved 4-0

Continued Items None

Consent Items None

Hearing Items 2. 2014-0146 CUP DEER CREEK (GOODWIN) WATER DISPOSAL FACILITY AMEND CUP TO CHANGE TO DAYS AND HOURS OF OPERATION Property Owner(s): Deer Creek Facilities, LLC Representative(s): Thomas Pool Location: 5180 Hwy 50, Whitewater 81527 (US Hwy 50 & Bridgeport Rd) Zoning: AFT Planner: Randy Price, 244-1759, [email protected] Request: To amend the existing CUP to permanently extend the hours of operation to 24 hours a day, 7 days per week. Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions Board of County Commissioners Hearing Date: 11-18-14

Staff Presentation Randy Price entered into the record the Goodwin Deer Creek Waste Disposal Facility amendment to the CUP, project file PRO2014-0146, the 2000 Mesa County Land Development Code, the Mesa County Land Use Plan and his PowerPoint presentation labeled as Exhibit A. Mr. Price entered into the record an additional exhibit that

49 Mesa County Planning Commission October 23, 2014 Public Hearing Minutes contains several letters of objection from the public that were received after the hearing binder was created. These letters were labeled as Opposition Exhibit 1.

Mr. Price explained the proposal and the location of the project. He showed maps and stated that there is one resident within the buffer area of the facility. He stated that the facility was originally permitted in 1993 for septic tank and grease–trap waste and in 2010 they received an amendment to add the disposal of liquid exploration and production wastes and the Exploration and Production Waste (E & P) facility was completed in 2012. He explained that there was also an amendment in 2013 to allow operations for 24 hours, 7 days a week for a period of one year and the applicant would like to continue those hours of operation and to make them be permanent.

Mr. Price went on to show photos of the site, maps of the property, and tanks, he also pointed out where the one resident lives in the area and where the haul route is. He stated that in May when the temperatures were rising that one of the ponds went anaerobic. The pond contains Exploration and Production Waste (E & P) and it’s meant to evaporate and there is also organic matter in the waste. He went on to explain that if the organic matter has enough oxygen it will break it down but if temperatures raise the bacteria doesn’t have enough oxygen and therefore it creates a sewer and asphalt type order. He stated there are two ponds and the eastern pond is the one that went anaerobic and therefore it turned black. The other pond is shallow and green with algae in it and it is a healthy pond.

Mr. Price explained that in mid-May he received a complaint from a resident in Kannah Creek and they asked about oil and gas operations in the area due to the smell that was similar to something burning. He referred the complaint to the County Health Department and they got involved. He went on to say that a site visit was done in late May and they noticed there was a very strong odor that resembled asphalt and was metallic and at that time the pond was black. The applicant tried to remedy the smell by using chlorine and peroxide, which worked for a period of time but the pond, went anaerobic again. Mr. Price went on to discuss the things that were done and how the pond acted and reacted to the chlorine treatments and when it’s not anaerobic it doesn’t smell. He stated that the applicants decided something different needed to be done to remedy the situation so they purchased equipment that would aerate the pond.

Mr. Price also stated that more complaints were received by Tom Orr with the County Health Department and he contacted the State Department to do an odor measurement. Additional explanation was given about testing the air quality using a certified nose called a nasal ranger that it is like a megaphone that goes over your nose and is a calibrated piece of equipment. Mesa County does not have this equipment so it has to be provided by someone in Denver and it takes time for people to do this testing. The majority of the complaints from people living in the area are that the smell is worse on Fridays, the weekends and in the evenings. These people live within 4 to 5 miles of the facility and they have said they have to close their windows at night because the smell is so bad. A test was done recently and it was found that the area didn’t exceed the odor standards and the pond was in an aerobic condition at that time.

50 Mesa County Planning Commission October 23, 2014 Public Hearing Minutes

Mr. Price went on to explain the conditions of the application, visual and noise impacts were discussed, the haul route was mentioned as well as the berm, full cut off lighting and he talked about details in Section 3.8.7 b, c, d & e of the code and that there is a need for this type of wastewater treatment facility on a community wide basis. He went on to read the conditions of approval.

Questions Commissioner Flynn asked how often the ponds are tested for odor. Mr. Price stated that the recent test was the second time it had been done and that testing would occur more often if the equipment was available locally. He also said that the applicant preforms water tests and provides that information to the county but doesn’t know how often those are performed. Further discussion took place about the wind blowing off of the Grand Mesa and causing the smell to blow down the valley and to the north west. Commissioner Jones asked what the difference is between now and a year ago regarding the smell. Mr. Price explained that it may depend on the type of waste they are taking in, it could be E&P Waste, return flow from fracking fluids which can have guar gum which is a thickener and is organic and can create a problem regarding breaking down the organic matter.

Applicant Thomas Pool 1650 Fillmore St., Denver He stated that also present with him are Willie Swanda, Operations Manager and Josh Gale of Goodwin Services for technical questions. Mr. Pool explained that the 24/7 operations are critical to their business and went on to state that they need these hours so that trucks can use the facility after they leave a well. He said there weren’t many times that they had to be open all through the night but those times do arise and they need to be available for the trucks. He went on to explain that when the odor issues arose last year that they tried to mitigate the issues right away using chemicals and quickly after that they added a lot of equipment to help with the smell and to avoid using the chemicals. He said it took time for the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) to get the equipment in place. He believes the odor that the people smelled was from the chemicals they were using. Mr. Pool explained all of the equipment that is currently in place and expressed that they are planning on staying in operation for the next 15 years. He would like the 24/7 hours to be permanent and this will allow them to deal with conditions of the ponds quickly if there are problems.

Questions Commissioner Jones asked if the odor issues were foreseeable. Mr. Pool stated that they didn’t know this would happen and didn’t see any issues with anaerobic problems the previous year but in the spring when the weather warmed up it happened very quickly. He stated that they have developed a protocol now and they can address it ahead of time. He said they now have employees checking this on a regular basis and they keep a log of that is required by the Engineering Design and Operations Plan (EDOP)

Mr. Pool explained that between the business itself and the civil engineers; have in

51 Mesa County Planning Commission October 23, 2014 Public Hearing Minutes

combination approximately 35 to 40 years of experience. He also stated that having the aeration is a critical part of eliminating the smell.

Further discussion took place with the commissioners expressing their disappointment with the company not having the expertise to see the potential for problems. Mr. Price stated that a lot of clean up goes on prior to things going into the pond and it decreases the amount of Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) that go into the pond. Mr. Pool stated that they carefully test what is loaded into the trucks before they come to the facility. They stay under the VOC emissions allowed which is 20 tons per year.

Chair Jones suggested that the two facilities in the area could share the dumping and when Goodwin was closed they could use the Danish Flats facility. Mr. Pool stated that he believes the producers would prefer to have everything going to one facility. He also mentioned that they can’t anticipate how many trucks could be coming in at night. Mr. Price stated that these applications do not have any limits on them but the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment Solid Waste Division reviews these plans and requires a bond to be placed for reclamation and clean up. Chair Moreng asked if a CUP holder doesn’t perform to regulations their CUP could be potentially pulled or cancelled. Ms. Dannenberger said that this could happen and would involve various agencies, not just the county.

A break was taken at 8:10 p.m.

Public Comments Public comments against the application were provided by Robert Sanders-39154 Bridgeport Road, Thomas Painter-5170 Highway 50, Jerry Cares-34971 Pronghorn Drive, Marc Coutu-39022 Bridgeport Road, Lindy Guinn-4240 Blue Sage Drive, Gwen Russell-38540 Bridgeport Road. Comments against the proposed project included: concerns regarding the potentially hazardous, sickening odor, what it is doing to them and their children when they are outside. The odor can last from 30 minutes to all night, it causes sore throats and itchy watery eyes. They also hear the noise from the equipment that is in place to try to minimize the smell, these are aerators and bubblers. Also mentioned was the truck noise taking place day and night, dust on the road that it is not being mitigated, and they are unable to have outdoor barbeques. These people are questioning if are they running the aerators at night since that’s when the smell is the worst. They also complained about how a rainstorm causes the smell to increase and there is also a smell that comes off of Deer Creek. One of the neighbors mentioned that most VOCs are cancer causing.

Willie Swanda Operations Manager of Alanco Mr. Swanda stated that they did diagnose the anaerobic issue prior to the complaint and the hydrogen peroxide was received in Grand Junction the next day. He explained that they have engaged an engineering firm in Grand Junction (HRL) and this firm has been assisting with the water analysis. Mr. Swanda explained that they could not anticipate the anaerobic condition because it’s not conducive to this type of pond. He said they

52 Mesa County Planning Commission October 23, 2014 Public Hearing Minutes dealt with this issue most of the summer but now have the bubblers and aeration equipment in place and if they have to shut the aerators off then they have to go back to chemical dependency. He stated that they are trying to get the pond back to a natural state which is a salt water pool.

Chair Moreng asked Mr. Swanda to address some of the other concerns raised. He asked if he was aware of the smell problems and that they were worse at night. Mr. Swanda said, yes, he was aware of this and he has gone out there at night but has not smelled this when he’s been there. The dust mitigations were also discussed and Mr. Swanda said it’s difficult to keep up with this as the water disappears on the dirt road very quickly and they don’t want to use Mag Chloride. He stated that they have been adding more gravel to try to keep the dirt compaction covered but they can’t continuously run water trucks up and down the road. Commissioner Flynn inquired about the ponds being lined. He stated that they were lined with 3 layers of liners and they were put in place before the water was added. He explained that there are also pumps in between the liners and they are monitored on a monthly basis to make sure they are functioning. He also stated that the aerators run all night part of the time but bubbler systems do not. They have a generator that runs 24/7 to keep the things moving so they can stay ahead of the anaerobic bacteria and not have to use the chemicals.

Applicant Rebuttal Thomas Pool addressed the complaints about the odor coming off of Deer Creek. He stated that there is no water leaving their facility that goes into Deer Creek and it seems that some kind of testing of the creek should be done. He stated that if they are allowed to be open 24/7 they can address all of the issues with no problem. Mr. Pool said he will check with the BLM and see if Mag Chloride is allowable on the roads.

Further discussion took place about the possibility of more set hours in the summer or having this facility closed at different times. The statement was made that they need to be open 24/7 for the business to survive and that the other facility in the area is closed on Sundays and holidays so trucks need to come to this facility and they can’t anticipate when trucks are coming down from the Rifle area.

Public Comments Closed

Mr. Price Randy addressed the question about landscaping in regards to the berm. He stated that here wasn’t a vegetation plan for the berm due to the soil content which is gravel and basalt. He also said that the maximum number of trucks is limited by the CDOT permit and that the applicant should keep records and monitor this. Ms. Dannenberger stated that if these records needed to be checked it would need to be an administrative review item.

Commissioner Page discussed the points that were brought forward from the people affected that live in this area. He stated that he has had a long standing issue with this and the element of responsibility that goes along with this application in regard to the chemicals used in these processes and that responsibility is on the company to show

53 Mesa County Planning Commission October 23, 2014 Public Hearing Minutes

how they are making this happen. He doesn’t support this extension because they are not taking care of what’s in the air and making it safe for the neighbors. Further discussion took place in regards to how advanced and progressive the oil and gas industry is and that things should be foreseeable but this isn’t the case and issues are not being taken care of in advance of them happening. The statement was also made that the county appreciates the money brought in by the business but they also believe that the property values in that area are being diminished.

Motion: Commissioner Flynn made a motion to deny 2014-0146 CUP Deer Creek Disposal Facility. Second: Commissioner Jones Motion: Denial 4-0

54 REVIEW AGENCY COMMENTS

55 56 PRO2014-0146 - DEER CREEK DISPOSAL CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT Review Agency Comments Comments Due Date: 2014-10-03

User Review Date/Time Comment Agency Robin Carns MC DEV 9/17/2014 Per the Mesa County Public Works/OWTS Regulations (6/30/2014) ENGINEER 7:35:19 AM each lot will be required to have a test pit plus 3 soil percolation tests (Section 3.17). RC Daniel Roussin CODOT-REGION 9/29/2014 I have no comments on the their operations; however, this project 3 8:28:04 AM will still need access applications. Their access permits have expired. Please have them re-apply for new access permits. Courtney MC CODE 10/1/2014 Mesa County Code Compliance Services does not have any open or Campbell COMPLIANCE 4:05:52 PM active case files pertaining to (5180 Highway 50). Code Compliance Services has not conducted a site visit, therefore should the assigned Planner find an apparent Code violation when they visit the property, please notify Code Compliance Services and we will investigate MC DEV MC DEV 10/3/2014 MC Development Engineering ENGINEER ENGINEER 8:57:40 AM No comments.

57 PUBLIC COMMENTS

58 59 October 23, 2014

Craig and Teri Polley 650 Divide Road Whitewater, CO 81527 970-241-3864

Mesa County Dept of Planning Attention: Randy Price PO Box 20,000 Grand Junction, CO 81502 970-244-1759

RE: PRO2014-0146 Deer Creek Disposal 24/7 Conditional Use Permit

As long time residents of Kannah Creek, we wish to take this opportunity to express our opposition to the application by Alanco Energy Services, Inc. Asking to amend the existing CUP to permanently extend the hours of operation to 24 hours a day, 7 days per week is premature. As residents of Kannah Creek located 5 miles from the facility, we would like to share with you our objection.

Since May, 2015 the ponds located at the facility have gone anaerobic several times (May thru October) giving off a smell that awakenster us in the middle of the night. Peroxide was added by Alanco to the pond early June, also aerators were set up using generators because there is no electricity to the facility. Since June, we have encountered this horrible smell several more times. I (Teri) was told, by Alanco the generators were replaced with upgrades. Since the replacement, the generators haven’t been able to keep up. As late as October 21, 2014, 2:01 am, we were awaken by this smell and neither the County, nor Alanco can account for it. As temperatures change from night to morning, the odor dissipates and becomes difficult to detect and pinpoint its source. We know this because, I (Teri) have talked with Randy Price and Tom Orr several times about this odor and they have tried to work with Alanco without success to eliminate the odor.

We believe the existing infrastructure necessary for the facility to perform the disposal process properly is inadequate and should be fixed to ensure functioning effectiveness before the Board considers granting this permit extension at a later time.

Thank you,

60 61 10/20/2014 Mesa County Mail - Alanco's 24/7 Land Use Permit

Randy Price

Alanco's 24/7 Land Use Permit 1 message

Ada Cooper Mon, Oct 20, 2014 at 3:04 PM To: "[email protected]"

Randy,

I am emailing regarding Alanco's request to obtain a permanent 24/7 land use permit at their Deer Creek facility located at 5180 HWY 50, Whitewater CO 81527. My family and I live at 39154 Bridgeport Road, which is about 1.5 miles from this facility. I strongly object to Alanco receiving this permanent permit, as the smell coming from this facility during the evening hours, and sometimes extending into the early morning hours is horrendous. We have small children that do not need to be breathing in the noxious chemical smell that invades our house as a direct result of their operations. In addition, I have a 14 year old with asthma that is negatively affected by this strong chemical odor. I strongly feel that until they become compliant and get this smell under control permanently, they should no longer be allowed to conduct business at the Deer Creek facility, or begin operations at their Indian Mesa site.

Best Regards,

Ada Cooper 970-208-4983

62 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ui=2&ik=3a64957206&view=pt&search=inbox&type=1492f6041e67cc8c&th=1492f6041e67cc8c&siml=1492f6041e67cc8c 1/1 63 64 APPLICANT INFORMATION

65 66 PROJECT REVIEW

67 MESA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS Administration - Building - Engineering – Road and Bridge Traffic - Planning - Solid Waste Management

200 S. Spruce Street • P.O. Box 20,000-5022 • Grand Junction, CO 81502-5001 Ph (970) 244-1636 Fax (970) 244-1769

PROJECT REVIEW November 6, 2014

I. 2014-0136 VA – STAHL VACATION OF RIGHT OF WAY Property Owner: Bruce Stahl Representative: John Curran Location: 3781 G 7/10 Road, Palisade, 81526 (37.8 Rd aka Main Street & G.7 Road) Adjacent Parcel #: 2937-091-00-090 Zoning: AFT Planner: Christie Barton, 255-7191, [email protected] Request: To vacate a portion of 37 8/10 Road (also known as Main Street, Palisade) Road right of way north of the Government Highline Canal and south of G 7/10 Road. Access for adjacent properties is from other locations. Recommendation: Approval with conditions

Location and Zoning Map:

Page 1 of 7

68 II. SURROUNDING LAND USES AND ZONING: The public notification area is 5,280 feet as required in Section 3.1.8 of the Land Development Code. Zoning within a 500-foot area:  Agricultural Forestry Transitional (AFT)  Town of Palisade annexed properties Land Uses within a 500-foot area:  Residential  Agricultural  Interstate I-70 Applicable Area Plans  Rural Master Plan o Future Land Use for this parcel is Rural Residential 5 o Town of Palisade Future Land Use is Agricultural Residential 2.5

III. PROJECT HISTORY AND DESCRIPTION: This right of way was granted as part of a deed recorded on April 2, 1906 at Reception Number 60082 (attached). No road has been built in the right of way, but a driveway has been created over time and is starting to be used by the general public as a public road. Drivers use this as a short cut between Bower Avenue (37 9/10 Road) and Elberta Avenue (37 3/10 Road). Property damage and dust problems to houses and peaches are causing problems for the adjacent property owners (Stahl and Cox).

Proposed right of way vacation:

Page 2 of 7

69 A bridge over the Government Highline Canal (constructed by the Bureau of Reclamation and managed by Grand Valley Water Users Association) at the Main Street alignment appears to have been removed sometime between 1994 and 1997. An existing bridge at Bowers Avenue (37 9/10 Road) is a two lane, 20 foot wide paved surface. County records show this as partly County maintained and partly privately maintained. A Conservation Easement was placed on the Cox property (Palisade Estates Subdivision) in 2009. The Palisade Estates Subdivision has been annexed into the Town of Palisade.

Location of shortcut route:

On October 6, 2014, Mesa County Planning met with Bob Levine of the Bureau of Reclamation; Mark Harris, Shirley Joslin and Kevin Conrad of the Grand Valley Water Users Association; Ron Quarles from the Town of Palisade; Bruce Stahl (applicant) and John Curran (applicants surveyor). The following is a summary of comments:  Grand Valley Water Users Association wants to keep cars off the canal road. They have worked with the Mesa County Sheriff’s Office, but it is difficult to catch trespassers. They don’t want to put up gates as it would slow down the ditch riders work on the canals.  The Bureau of Reclamation doesn’t want a bridge crossing the canal.  Town of Palisade has Main Street as a future connection on their Transportation Plan. The Town supports the vacation with the ability to obtain the right of way in fee simple without having to purchase it if the road is needed in the future.  Bruce Stahl says there are power poles in the middle of the 20’ wide right of way.  Bruce Stahl and Dave Cox have discussed this vacation and Mr. Cox has removed his objection to the vacation (see email attachments).

Page 3 of 7

70 IV. COMPLIANCE WITH MESA COUNTY LAND USE POLICIES AND MESA COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE. Section 3.10 Vacation of Rights-of-Way and Renaming of Streets The applicable criteria of Section 3.10 apply. This Code Section sets forth the following criteria for evaluating right-of-way vacation requests. Section 3.10.6.A The requested vacation will not:

(1) Create any landlocked parcels; This application will not create any landlocked parcels or lots. The right of way is located between the Government Highline Canal maintenance road and right of way dedicated as part of the Palisade Estates Subdivision (now placed in a conservation easement). Bruce Stahl has access from 37 9/10 Road and Dave Cox has access from 37 3/10 Road. This criterion has been met.

(2) Negatively impact adjacent parcels; This vacation should improve adjacent parcels. The Stahl property is currently suffering property damage from people crossing the canal road to the driveway through the Cox Orchard. The Cox orchards suffer from dust mites due to the dust caused by traffic going through this area. This vacation does not change the existing road layout or cause traffic issues. This criterion has been met.

(3) Restrict access to any parcel so that access is unreasonable or economically prohibitive; Initially Dave Cox protested this right of way vacation because he uses it to access his orchards. However, in discussion with Bruce Stahl, Mr. Cox has withdrawn his objection because the public is starting to use the driveway as a shortcut, and damaging the properties is a result. Mr. Cox farms property on both sides of the canal (see below), and has access at Elberta Avenue (37 3/10 Road). This application will not cause any restrictions to future access to adjacent property owners. It is intended to stop the public from travelling on these driveways. This criterion has been met.

Page 4 of 7

71 (4) Reduce the quality of public service to any parcel of land; No comments were received from any reviewing agency that would indicate there would be a reduction in the quality of public service if this request were approved. An irrigation easement is located as shown on the survey, and this will be required to be granted by deed if the right of way is vacated. This criterion can be met.

(5) Be inconsistent with any adopted transportation plan, including the Grand Junction/Mesa County MPO Transportation Plan; This proposed road vacation is on the Palisade Long Range Transportation Improvement Plan. While the Town of Palisade has identified the extension of Main Street sometime in the future, comments allow that it may be a long time in the future. The Town supports this right of way vacation, with a reservation on the deed for future dedication to the Town. This is a condition of approval. This criterion can be met.

(6) Affect the historic movement of livestock; This right of way is not used for livestock movement, and has no known historic movement of livestock associated with it. This criterion has been met.

(7) Create a circuitous alternate route for area residents or other members of the public; Dave Cox, a neighbor, uses this right of way for ease of access between properties he has in cultivation. The problem is that it is starting to be used by the public, to the detriment to the Cox orchards and to the Stahl property. This right of way is not built and is not open to the public. The Government Highline Canal is at the end of this right of way, and use of this canal maintenance road is considered trespassing.

The right of way for G 7/10 Road on the east end of this project was vacated in 1983 (file #C55-83), and the right of way on the west side of this project is through the Cox orchards. G 7/10 Road is not built and the Cox properties have a conservation easement on them. Dust from public access on this driveway is detrimental to the peach trees.

The alternate route for the public is to return to G 4/10 Road (First Street) and access both Bowers Avenue (37 9/10 Road) and Elberta Avenue (37 3/10 Road). The distance between G 7/10 Road and First Street is approximately ¼ mile. These roads are County or Town of Palisade maintained roads. This criterion has been met.

(8) Negatively affect utility access or utility distribution networks; or No utility companies have provided comments that this vacation will cause problems with utilities in the right of way. An existing irrigation pipe is located in the right of way proposed to be vacated, and an easement is required to be reserved on the deed. This is a condition of approval. This criterion can be met.

(9) Eliminate public access to public lands. This right of way is not located adjacent to public lands and does not provide public access for any land in the area. No public land is located adjacent to this vacation area. The Government Highline Canal is not public access for use of the canal road. Grand Valley Water Users Association works with the Mesa County Sheriff’s Office to reduce trespassing on the canal maintenance road. This criterion has been met.

Page 5 of 7

72 Section 3.1.17 General Approval Criteria must also be considered for Vacation of Right-of- Way requests: A. Complies with all applicable standards, provisions, and purposes of this Land Development Code; It appears that the proposed vacation of this right of way is consistent with all applicable standards, provisions, and purposes of the Land Development Code. The right-of-way will be reserved for the Town of Palisade if it is needed in the future. This criterion can be met.

B. Is consistent with review agency comments; There are no review agency objections to the proposed vacation. The Town of Palisade has requested wording on a deed that allows the Town to obtain the right of way in the future without additional payment if and when a road is needed to be built. This criterion can be met.

C. Is consistent with applicable intergovernmental agreements (IGA) between the County and other entities. The Town of Palisade was notified and comments are included in the Review Agency Comments sheet. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) was also notified but did not comment on the application. This criterion has been met.

V. REVIEW COMMENTS: All review agency comments received are included in the binder for this project.

VI. PUBLIC COMMENTS: No public comments have been received as of the date of this project review.

VII. PROJECT RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Division recommends approval of the request for a right of way vacation, with the following condition: 1. Require survey to be deposited and deed to be recorded with the following wording: a. The Town of Palisade reserves the right for a public roadway on land affected by the right of way vacation, and right of way will be granted for the benefit of the public when it is deemed necessary for connections consistent with the Town’s Long Range Transportation Improvement Plans. b. Reservation of an easement for the existing irrigation line

The basis for this recommendation is: The petition demonstrates compliance with Section 3.10.6.A (1 - 9) and 3.1.17 (A-C) of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended).

Review Summary Vacation of Rights-of-Way Approval Criteria 3.10.6.A: 1 - no landlocked parcels – has been met 2 - negative impact on adjacent parcels – has been met 3 - restrict access to any parcel – has been met 4 - reduce quality of services – can be met 5 - consistency with transportation plan – can be met

Page 6 of 7

73 6 – affect the historic movement of livestock – has been met 7 – create a circuitous route for area residents or the public – has been met 8 – negatively affect utility access – has been met 9 – eliminate public access to public lands – has been met

General Approval Criteria 3.1.17: A - compliance with the Land Development Code – can be met B - consistency with review agency comments – can be met C - consistency with IGAs – has been met

VIII. BOCC Action: (11/18/14):

Page 7 of 7

74 75 RECEPTION NUMBER 60082

The north five acres of the north half of the west half of Lot 2, in Section nine, in Township eleven South of Range Ninety Eight West of the 6th P.M. Also a strip of land Twenty feet in width off the west side of said west half of the west half of said Lot Two it being the intention to convey the north five acres of said first above described Tract exclusive of the west 20 feet herein conveyed for Road purposes.

76 HEARING NOTICE

77 Stahl Vacation of Right of Way Parcel/Notification Map 2014-0136 VA September 26, 2014

LegendLegend

1 mile Parcels Palisade "

AFT

AFT AFT BLM

0.8 0 0.8 1.6 2.4 3.2 78 Miles 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way PARCEL_NUM OWNER MAILING CITY ST ZIP 2937-091-05-004 137 EAST 4TH LLC 3214 E RD CLIFTON CO 81520 2941-031-05-019 424 PENDLETON LLC 3626 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-05-020 426 PENDLETON LLC 3626 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-05-026 434 PENDLETON LLC 540 20 1/4 ROAD GRAND JUNCCO 81507 2941-031-05-022 915 WILLIAM COURT LLC 706 S 9TH ST GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2937-092-03-002 ABBOTT DANNY LIVING TR913 WHITE AVE GRAND JUNCCO 81501-3444 2941-031-03-031 ACKERMAN MARILYN BETH1800 24TH AVE LONGMONT CO 805010924 2941-031-08-002 ADAIR ELIZABETH A 811 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8753 2941-022-00-092 ADAMS DANIEL J 3839 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-03-018 ADAMS WHITNEY 136 E THIRD ST PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-00-106 ADOBE STORAGE LLC PO BOX 781 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-053-85-464 AGUILAR MYRIAM 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 60PALISADE CO 81526-8734 2937-092-29-007 AIGNER FE VALE CRUZ PO BOX 122 PALISADE CO 81526-0122 2941-031-00-130 ALAMEDA ESTATES MHP L 3004 EMINENCIA DEL SUR SAN CLEMENCA 92673 7008-052-63-550 ALBERTS JAMES 105 RIVERSIDE DR UNIT 16PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-33-016 ALBERTS JAMES A 550 W FIRST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-32-005 ALBRIGHT SHIRLEY A 175 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9211 7008-051-45-917 ALCON ELOY M 105 RIVERSIDE DR TRLR 18PALISADE CO 81526-9692 2941-031-05-040 ALLYN COMPANY LLC 3406 D RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-05-043 ALLYN COMPANY LLC PO BOX 54 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-00-007 ALLYN PENNY 8284 HIGHWAY 133 CARBONDALCO 81623-9455 2937-092-25-008 ALMOND DON A 568 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-31-003 ALTLAND FAMILY TRUST PO BOX 400 PALISADE CO 81526-0400 2937-092-06-005 ALTRONN INVESTMENTS 2855 C 1/2 RD GRAND JUNCCO 81501 7008-054-68-476 ANDEM JUDITH 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 8PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-05-012 ANDERSON KATHLEEN 612 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-9238 2937-094-00-023 ANDERSON MALENA JOY PO BOX 609 PALISADE CO 81526-0609 2937-092-27-009 ANDERSON SANDRA L 552 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-9718 2937-091-00-065 ANDREWS RICHARD A 727 38 2/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8763 2937-092-41-001 ANGRY GNOME LLC PO BOX 87 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-13-002 ANOIA GREGORY A JR PO BOX 173 PALISADE CO 81526-0173 2937-081-10-002 APLANALP MISTY L 603 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-8736 2941-032-16-006 ARMSBY GARY 819 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526 7008-095-94-034 ARREDONDO MARCO 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 15PALISADE CO 81526-8797 7008-288-80-911 ARTHUR P PFLASTER FAMI1280 20 RD FRUITA CO 81521 2937-092-10-019 ASHURST FLOYD RAY 234 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8778 2937-092-16-015 ASPY CLINT A PO BOX 1476 PALISADE CO 81526-1476 2937-093-33-007 ATCHISON CHARLES E 626 33 RD CLIFTON CO 81520 2941-032-19-010 ATKINSON RAYMOND DIXO874 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-03-004 ATKINSON SHAD 827 IOWA AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-18-003 AUSTIN ALYSSA LANEL 1516 N 7TH ST GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2941-032-17-006 AUSTIN NEAL WILSON 259 CONVENTRY PL UNIT 4GRAND JUNCCO 81503 2937-092-18-011 BACHMEIER GABRIEL 135 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526-9757 2937-092-24-002 BAGLEY LUKE A JR 540 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9784 2937-081-10-006 BAILEY LINDA 611 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-18-001 BAKER ANGELA SUE 832 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526

Page 1 of 25 79 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 7008-054-59-760 BAKER KAREN PO BOX 1080 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-077 BALAK COLLEEN 321 TROYER AVE PALISADE CO 81526-9749 2937-093-32-018 BALDWIN JENNE K 593 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8740 2941-022-00-019 BALL BONNIE J 686 38 3/8 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9318 7008-053-20-907 BARANWAY JOHN B PO BOX 158 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-22-009 BARBER DAN PO BOX 1213 PALISADE CO 81526-1213 2937-081-15-002 BARBER DANNY A PO BOX 1213 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-29-022 BARBER DARWIN E PO BOX 558 PALISADE CO 81526-0558 2941-032-08-007 BARBER DAVID L 830 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9616 2937-102-00-111 BARBER TIMOTHY P 3876 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-09-001 BAREFOOT GEOFFREY D 3733 1/8 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-8613 7008-130-72-286 BARKER PHIL 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526-8654 7941-031-21-007 BARNEWALL FAMILY TRUS679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9605 2941-032-18-010 BARTELT ASHLEY SUE 843 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-143 BARTLETT TIMOTHY R 749 BLISS DR PALISADE CO 81526-9202 2937-081-09-001 BASKIN JEREMIAH R 625 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526 7008-288-83-541 BAUDER RICK 676 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-24-004 BAUER REX A 526 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9784 2941-021-05-001 BEAVER WESLEY E 3867 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-9349 2937-093-29-014 BECK PAMELA FAMILY TRUPO BOX 130 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-288-82-651 BECKWITH BILLY L 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526-8654 2937-092-40-002 BECKWITH EDWARD JR 758 37 9/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-093 BECKWITH KIRK E 755 37 9/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9777 2937-091-00-103 BECKWITH NANCY A 758 37 9/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9755 2937-092-32-002 BEERENDS BARBARA S 203 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9706 2941-032-01-009 BEILMAN JOSEPH J JR 823 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9618 2937-092-05-004 BELL ALICE T PO BOX 604 PALISADE CO 815260604 2937-092-04-002 BELL JUDITH V FAMILY TRU2175 STANDING ROCK DR GRAND JUNCCO 81507 2937-103-00-113 BELL PRESCOTT D 3460 F 3/4 RD CLIFTON CO 815208423 2941-032-10-018 BELLHOUSE CAROL PO BOX A LEADVILLE CO 804611017 2937-092-32-010 BENNETT JAMES R 120 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9709 2937-093-32-002 BENSON MERRITT A 313 W SIXTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-27-001 BERGMAN KENNETH G PO BOX 277 PALISADE CO 81526-0277 2937-092-28-003 BERNSTEIN STEPHANIE 527 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-03-015 BERTRAM ROSALIE JEAN PO BOX 15 PALISADE CO 81526-0015 2937-102-00-011 BIKKI LESLIE P PO BOX 63 PALISADE CO 81526-0063 2937-091-00-096 BILBO JOHN 3827 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-03-026 BILLAC BAMBI LYNNE PO BOX 3106 BASALT CO 816213106 2941-032-00-133 BINGGELI FRED A 3743 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-8613 2937-094-00-003 BISHOP DONNIE L 1382 46TH ST LOS ALAMOSNM 87544 2937-094-00-004 BISHOP DONNIE L PO BOX 268 PALISADE CO 81526-0268 2937-092-32-006 BISHOP KAREN D 2800 S MADISON ST DENVER CO 802106536 2937-092-00-951 BISHOP OF PUEBLO ST ANN535 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-06-008 BLACKMAN VICTOR G 3360 E 1/4 RD CLIFTON CO 81520 2937-094-02-027 BLATTER CHRIS S PO BOX 1305 PALISADE CO 81526-1305 2937-094-01-004 BLEDSOE DANNY L PO BOX 114 PALISADE CO 81526-0114 2937-052-00-914 BLM 2815 H RD GRAND JUNCCO 81506

Page 2 of 25 80 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 7008-288-81-301 BOBSON LAURA ROZELLA 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-26-011 BOCKMAN RUTH ANN 532 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9702 2937-092-04-007 BODDY NATHAN PO BOX 1279 HAMILTON MT 598401279 7008-289-12-141 BODENSCHATZ DAVID H 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9610 2937-093-29-008 BOESCH GARY U 672 CANYON CREEK DR GRAND JUNCCO 81507-9594 2937-093-29-004 BOOTH ROBERT D PO BOX 386 PALISADE CO 815260386 7008-288-90-761 BOREN RENEE 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 65PALISADE CO 81526-9723 7008-069-94-008 BORGARDT DAVID 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 20PALISADE CO 81526-8798 2937-091-02-001 BOSCH HAROLD 3121 CYNTHIA LN GRAND JUNCCO 81504 2937-033-00-045 BOSKO THOMAS J PO BOX 603 PALISADE CO 81526-0603 7008-289-03-394 BOWEN EILEEN 131 N BOWER UNIT 50 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-07-002 BOWERS JEREMY 843 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9618 2937-091-00-016 BOWERY FIELD LLC 745 37 9/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-03-012 BOWMAN'S BOTTOM LLC PO BOX 788 PALISADE CO 81526-0788 2937-092-26-012 BOYDSTUN WILLIAM C 3404 F RD CLIFTON CO 81520-8431 2937-092-41-004 BRACKEN GEORGE B PO BOX 310 PALISADE CO 815260310 2937-092-05-008 BRACKETT CHANSE RAY 9722 COUNTY ROAD 204 DE BEQUE CO 816309724 7024-051-98-863 BRADFORD KIMBERLY J PO BOX 1060 PALISADE CO 81526-1060 2937-092-14-016 BRANDSTOETTNER THOMAPO BOX 302 PALISADE CO 81526-0302 2937-093-31-004 BRANDSTOETTNER WALTEPO BOX 476 PALISADE CO 81526-0476 2937-091-08-001 BRAUN VALERIE 439 COUNTRYSIDE LN GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5105 2937-092-31-009 BRENNAN JAMIE K 155 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-022-00-118 BRICKEY RONALD G 683 38 3/8 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9319 2937-092-10-004 BRIGHAM ARTHUR J 152 VICTORIA DR PALISADE CO 81526-9717 2937-081-00-076 BRIGHAM JOAN-CAROL PO BOX 1137 FRISCO CO 804431137 2937-092-10-010 BRIGHAM THOMAS KENT 115 VICTORIA DR PALISADE CO 81526-9716 2937-094-00-011 BRINKERHOFF PEGGY MAY3591 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8724 2941-032-15-008 BRITT E CHRISTOPHER 838 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526-8403 2941-031-05-082 BROCK FAMILY TRUST LLC 816 TAHITI DR GRAND JUNCCO 81506-1744 2937-093-28-003 BROWE DONALD PO BOX 1175 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-053-42-374 BROWN BETH ANN 327 W 8TH ST UNIT 18 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-06-025 BROWN DUNCAN J 193 EDLUN RD GRAND JUNCCO 81503-2217 2937-091-06-028 BROWN DUNCAN J PO BOX 1154 GRAND JUNCCO 81502 7008-052-18-010 BROWN EMILIE J 317 W 8TH ST TRLR 7 PALISADE CO 81526-8673 2941-032-00-152 BROWN JO & ERNEST TRU PO BOX 906 VAIL CO 81658 2937-092-25-018 BROWN JONATHAN M 577 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9712 7008-053-84-672 BROWN JUDY 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 34PALISADE CO 81526-8799 7008-054-80-876 BROWN LAURA 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 43PALISADE CO 81526-8799 2937-081-15-001 BROWN RICHARD W 733 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-05-005 BROWN ROGER E SR LIVINPO BOX 216 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-23-005 BROWN SHELBY E 212 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-14-011 BROWN TINA M PO BOX 3 ECKERT CO 814180003 7008-052-78-122 BROWNE DEBRA 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 55PALISADE CO 81526-8734 2937-092-23-001 BROWNKORBEL ROBERT E 790 CLAREMONT DR MORGAN HI CA 95037-4003 2937-081-00-168 BRUCE LYNN HERMAN AND757 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2941-021-00-006 BRUNO DANETTE M PO BOX 6 PALISADE CO 81526-0006 2937-092-22-010 BUCKMASTER LOUIS H 225 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526

Page 3 of 25 81 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2941-032-01-006 BUECHLE EDWARD L 826 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-10-006 BULLA CHARLES ROBERT 816 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2937-093-39-001 BUNTE BONNIE PO BOX 367 PALISADE CO 81526-0367 2937-093-30-017 BURDICK GERALDINE L PO BOX 126 PALISADE CO 81526-0126 2937-033-00-918 BUREAU OF RECLAMATION2764 COMPASS DR STE 10 GRAND JUNCCO 81506-8755 2937-092-16-018 BURGESS KEVIN PO BOX 194 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-28-007 BURKE SHAWN R 160 SMITH AVE PALISADE CO 81526-9705 2937-044-00-059 BURKHARD MICHAEL T 3784 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8731 2937-054-00-062 BURNETT JAMES T 3696 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8727 2937-091-06-015 BURNS CORY L 154 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9729 7008-288-81-443 BURRELL GREG 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 40PALISADE CO 81526-8799 2937-092-10-003 BURRIS LEVY E JR 5411 COUNTY ROAD 346 SILT CO 81652-9672 2937-091-03-028 BUSHA AMELIA ANNE PO 144 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-28-002 BUTTERS CODY MARIE PO BOX 84 PALISADE CO 815260084 2937-093-38-010 C & F FOOD STORE INC 140 S 17TH ST GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2937-094-02-009 C AND G PROPERTIES LLC 728 381/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-05-007 C MAE LLC PO BOX 158 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-102-00-092 CAMERON THOMAS K 3939 1/2 G 2/10 RD PALISADE CO 815268765 2937-054-00-060 CAMILLETTI DOUGLAS D 41380 N HIGHWAY 13 CRAIG CO 81625-8001 2937-092-25-016 CANO MATTHEW JAMES 559 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-10-002 CARBAJAL ANGELA I 808 ELBERTA AVE UNIT 16 PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2937-094-02-026 CARDELL WILLIAM R PO BOX 308 PALISADE CO 81526-0308 2937-092-03-001 CAREI DARIN 518 28 RD UNIT 202A GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2941-031-07-001 CARLSON SHARON A PO BOX 1957 EVERGREEN CO 80437-1957 2941-032-16-029 CARLSON WILLIAM L 865 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-054-00-063 CARMACK DONNA G 3698 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8727 7008-364-03-202 CARP JOHN W 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 3PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-05-010 CARPENTER JEFFREY L 608 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-8736 2937-092-10-007 CARPENTER PATRICK L 127 VICTORIA DR PALISADE CO 81526-9716 2937-092-27-011 CARRUTH WAYNE H 1408 PONY TRAIL CT FRUITA CO 81521 2941-031-14-001 CARRUTHERS SUSAN E 8375 BROKEN WILLOW LNPORT RICHEYFL 346686812 2937-092-10-026 CARSTENS MARY DAWN 218 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8778 7008-055-18-952 CARTER GEORGE R 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 38PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-32-005 CARTON CRAIG THOMAS PO BOX 1451 PALISADE CO 81526-1451 2937-091-10-001 CASABONA THOMAS PO BOX 136 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-01-008 CASABONA THOMAS A 827 LOGAN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-06-010 CASETTA MARK PO BOX 1457 PALISADE CO 81526-1457 2937-093-35-001 CASEY MARY E PO BOX 336 PALISADE CO 81526-0336 2937-054-00-087 CASTER STEVEN 3718 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8729 7008-053-75-000 CASTRO VASQUEZ JOSE OV131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 2 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-33-001 CATHER KELLIE L PO BOX 907 PALISADE CO 81526-0907 2941-032-12-002 CD & M CORP 134 N 6TH ST GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2937-092-31-002 CHACON TOMAS C 202 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9707 7008-107-95-329 CHAMPLAIN HARRY 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 18PALISADE CO 81526-8798 2937-081-05-009 CHAPMAN ERNEST W 606 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-19-017 CHARLESWORTH TRENT WPO BOX 1234 PALISADE CO 81526-1234 2941-032-15-007 CHASE LAURIE 1834 GRAND AVE GLENWOOD CO 81601-4112

Page 4 of 25 82 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-103-00-114 CHILD AND MIGRANT SERVPO BOX 1038 PALISADE CO 81526-1038 2937-092-00-010 CHRISTENSEN RANCH PARTPO BOX 40 GRAND JUNCCO 81502-0040 7008-289-20-441 CHRISTIAN DESSIE M PO BOX 1251 PALISADE CO 81526-1251 2941-032-13-002 CHRISTOPHER JOAN REVO828 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8400 2941-032-17-003 CISNEROS CARLOS WILLIAM825 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 815268667 2941-032-17-010 CISNEROS HENRY ALEXAND447 1/2 DORIS RD GRAND JUNCCO 81504 2941-032-15-027 CLAPP MATTHEW P 852 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526-8402 2937-102-00-012 CLARK FAMILY ORCHARDS 3901 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-102-00-055 CLARK HARRY E PO BOX 405 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-15-003 CLARK JACOB O 824 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-05-003 CLARK MAXINE 605 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-9200 2937-091-00-039 CLARK STACI M 3901 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8772 2937-092-14-026 CLARK TOMMIE JOAN PO BOX 405 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-24-001 CLEMENT CHRISTINE C 548 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9784 2937-092-23-006 CLIFFORD MARY D 7110 OLIVE ST COMMERCE CO 80022-2167 2937-091-04-019 CLINTON KEITH R TRUSTEEPO BOX 323 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-23-003 CLUGSTON THOMAS C 126 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9734 2937-093-32-012 COES AUTOMOTIVE LLC PO BOX 1361 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-00-020 COLE DALE G 235 N 7TH ST GRAND JUNCCO 81501-3401 2937-044-01-002 COLE DENNIS VAUGHAN FAPO BOX 1496 PALISADE CO 81526-1496 2937-091-01-002 COLE JAMES A PO BOX 191 PALISADE CO 81526-0191 7008-289-10-581 COLE SINDEY PO BOX 1026 PALISADE CO 81526-1026 2941-032-15-002 COLE STEPHEN R PO BOX 1001 ASPEN CO 81621 2937-092-16-021 COLGLAZIER JOYCE L PO BOX 670 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-00-178 COLLARD GINGER L 3733 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-022-00-024 COLLARD WILLIAM D 275 31 3/4 RD GRAND JUNCCO 81503-9603 2937-092-41-003 COLORADO PALISADES LLCPO BOX 1533 PALISADE CO 81526-1533 2937-094-00-928 COLORADO STATE HIGHW606 S 9TH ST STE 1 GRAND JUNCCO 81501-7768 2937-043-00-055 COLORADO WEST INDUSTRMOSER ROAD C12 FALKLAND BFC VOE1WO 2937-092-24-012 Confidential Owner 521 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-28-010 Confidential Owner PO BOX 1692 CRAIG CO 816261692 2937-054-00-095 CONFRE PROPERTIES LLC 3745 PIAZZA WAY GRAND JUNCCO 815066000 2937-093-28-006 COOK CHERYL 222 W SIXTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-33-004 COOK FRED 120 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526-9756 2937-102-00-057 COON DUANE 3843 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8706 2937-092-15-003 COOPER BILL W PO BOX 673 PALISADE CO 81526-0673 2937-092-05-002 COOPER JEANNIE P PO BOX 608 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-10-021 COOPER SANDRA J 204 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8778 2937-091-00-042 COPE RACHEL 2500 17TH ST UNIT 507 DENVER CO 80211 2937-092-16-009 CORBIN DAVID L PO BOX 1344 PALISADE CO 81526-1344 2937-081-00-160 CORDOVA BOBBY 728 37 1/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9741 2937-092-25-005 CORINGRATO MARIO A JR 590 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9713 2937-091-04-007 COULTER HOLDINGS LLC PO BOX 18851 DENVER CO 80218 7008-053-87-332 COURTNEY LISA 676 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9686 2937-044-01-003 COX BRIAN J 3824 HIGHLINE CANAL RD PALISADE CO 815269792 2941-022-00-002 COX BRIAN J 712 ROUNDUP DR GRAND JUNCCO 81507 2941-032-15-001 COX CARLOS E JR PO BOX 2422 GRAND JUNCCO 81502

Page 5 of 25 83 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-092-00-070 COX DAVID LAWRENCE 756 37 8/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-16-011 COX JESSE V TRUSTEE PO BOX 435 PALISADE CO 81526-0435 2941-031-08-003 COX JOHN J JR 813 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-00-071 COX JOHN JENNINGS JR PO BOX 2 PALISADE CO 81526-0002 7008-289-13-081 CRADIT PAUL D 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9605 2937-091-03-016 CRAIG THOMAS B PO BOX 1132 PALISADE CO 81526-1132 2937-092-22-003 CRAWFORD FIVEPLEX LLC 202 NORTH AVE UNIT 127 GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2937-092-06-009 CRIM ASHLEY L PO BOX 534 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-05-027 CRIM RICK D 440 PENDLETON ST PALISADE CO 81526-8656 2937-093-32-003 CROY ERIC A PO BOX 271 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-25-004 CRUMP GARY M PO BOX 1385 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-31-006 CUNNINGHAM ROGER DAL112 LAKEHILL LN MARS PA 160462036 2941-022-03-001 CUNNINGHAM TRENTON L3861 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8706 2941-032-15-005 DAMKOWITCH THOMAS M19 WALNUT ST LEXINGTON MA 02421 2937-093-29-015 DANIELS JENNIFER L 370 W SIXTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-24-006 DANIELS LARRY D 512 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-26-004 DANNELS VIRGINIA N 574 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9702 7008-054-33-322 DAVIS LINDA S 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 6PALISADE CO 815268640 2937-092-27-018 DAVIS MICHAEL A PO BOX 57 PALISADE CO 81526-0057 2937-092-06-001 DAVIS PROPERTIES-POST O1957 S 120 W OREM UT 84058-7413 2937-091-06-013 DAVIS ROBERT N 132 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9729 2941-032-00-155 DAVIS WESLEY 3373 F RD CLIFTON CO 81520 2937-092-30-002 DAY ARTHUR F 163 SMITH AVE PALISADE CO 81526-8741 2941-032-17-012 DEAL DONALD GUY 879 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 7008-288-91-621 DEAN ERIC K 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 26PALISADE CO 81526-8798 7008-053-01-552 DECKER DOLORES 2719 H RD GRAND JUNCCO 81506 2941-022-00-117 DECKER JAMES A 5304 JIM DENT WAY LAS VEGAS NV 891496494 2937-092-27-003 DELAHANTY CHERYLE M 579 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9725 2937-092-05-014 DELAVAN LIVING TRUST 3885 N RIVER RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-28-001 DELEON JEANIE MARIE 163 ANDERSON AVE PALISADE CO 81526-9218 2937-092-35-002 DENNEY STEVEN D 123 IOWA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-9793 2937-094-02-033 DENNIS & JANICE SPECK 19PO BOX 214 PALISADE CO 81526-0247 2937-092-04-008 DENNIS ROXANNE PO BOX 743 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-31-017 DENNISON JENNIFER 107 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-29-013 DIAL BRUCE E 495 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-9710 7008-289-11-023 DIAZ EMMA M T 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 4 PALISADE CO 81526-8799 2937-092-32-008 DICKE THOMAS L 132 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9709 2937-092-17-003 DIDONATO RANDY J 611 N 1ST ST GRAND JUNCCO 815012233 2937-091-06-011 DIEBOLD MARK R PO BOX 113 PALISADE CO 81526-0113 2941-031-08-012 DIFFENDAFFER BLAINE E PO BOX 633 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-01-008 DIGREGORIO ANTHONY WPO BOX 1537 PALISADE CO 81526-1537 2937-094-00-037 DINER JESSICA A 3826 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-05-009 DIXON DOROTHY L PO BOX 1123 PALISADE CO 81526-1123 2937-091-00-033 DODD JASPER A 3374 G RD CLIFTON CO 81520-8142 7008-055-93-522 DOMINQUEZ ISRRAEL 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 49PALISADE CO 81526-8734 2937-081-05-002 DONNAHIE KAREN S 415 EMERALD CIR HENDERSONNV 890028302 2937-092-14-014 DONOVAN RORY M PO BOX 87 PALISADE CO 81526-0087

Page 6 of 25 84 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-092-18-007 DORNBERGER JOHN H 518 N 26TH STREET GRAND JUNCCO 81501 7008-055-61-201 DORRIS RICHARD A PO BOX 3693 GRAND JUNCCO 815023693 2941-032-16-008 DOTY WENDELL M III PO BOX 1510 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-16-007 DOTY WENDELL MARLIN II PO BOX 1467 PALISADE CO 81526-1467 2937-093-29-006 DOWLING DELBERT D PO BOX 1326 PALISADE CO 81526-1326 2941-032-16-004 DREWER THERESA 813 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-10-016 DUNCAN E STANLEY 3827 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-9347 2937-092-14-017 DUNN WILLIAM J 574 36 5/8 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9315 2937-092-34-001 DUSTY OLD BOOKS LLC PO BOX 1467 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-01-001 DUTTON EDITH PO BOX 235 PALISADE CO 81526-0235 2937-093-29-005 EASTHAM MELINDA J PO BOX 315 PALISADE CO 81526-0315 2937-092-29-014 EATON JONATHAN A 593 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8740 7941-031-21-002 EATON THEORDORE R 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9605 2937-093-30-002 ECKMAN COLLEEN 2942 MARGARET DR GRAND JUNCCO 81503-3427 2941-032-15-025 EDEL RENEE E 844 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526-8403 2941-031-00-123 EDSON DENNIS 610 ROOD AVE GRAND JUNCCO 81501 7008-288-91-031 EDWARDS DAVID W 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 3PALISADE CO 81526-8655 2937-094-04-002 EDWARDS MARK D PO BOX 1206 PALISADE CO 81526-1206 2937-093-34-011 EHRNRITER VINCENT SCOTPO BOX 535 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-12-011 EIELSON DANIEL D PO BOX 355 PALISADE CO 81526-0355 2937-081-09-003 ELKINS JERRY R AND ELKIN621 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-00-034 ELLETSON DALE C 3832 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-9344 2937-081-00-114 ELLIS CYNTHIA 3697 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8728 2937-091-05-001 EMB INVESTMENTS LLC PO BOX 3139 GRAND JUNCCO 81502 2937-092-00-024 ENDRES BARBARA A 418 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8783 2937-091-05-008 ENDRES MARY L PO BOX 294 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-007 ERMAN JAMES F 3688 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9750 2937-092-16-019 ERN VENTURES LLC 3611 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8711 2937-081-08-006 ERVEN JOHN C 624 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-19-003 ERWIN SHELBY MALYN 816 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-09-002 ESTES EUGENE D 3733 1/4 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-8613 2937-092-33-006 ETZKORN MECSHELLE 132 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526-9756 2937-092-33-005 EVANS GAIL M 126 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-103-00-068 EVANS ROBERT L 716 38 3/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9776 7008-342-12-001 EVERETT WILLIAM PO BOX 4386 GRAND JUNCCO 81502 7008-053-51-058 FABBRI GARY JAMES 105 RIVERSIDE DR UNIT 11PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-14-028 FABRICIUS TERESA E PO BOX 1185 PALISADE CO 81526-1185 2937-091-00-075 FALCON INVESTMENTS CO PO BOX 2353 COLORADO SCO 80901 2941-032-08-006 FALLER ROBERT L 832 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9616 2937-092-12-007 FARMER GLEN E 3611 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8711 7008-010-51-678 FARR GENE G PO BOX 1313 PALISADE CO 81526-1313 2937-091-00-102 FAVIER ERIC J 754 37 8/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-16-020 FAY ALICE PO BOX 553 PALISADE CO 81526-0553 2941-032-15-026 FAY RANDE 848 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-09-004 FERGUSON DALE R 2938 BRAND CT GRAND JUNCCO 815045360 7008-051-03-901 FERRERE NANCY M 131 N BOWERS UNIT 2 PALISADE CO 815268797 2941-032-07-004 FICKEN DEBBIE L 419 MESA DR RANGELY CO 816483124

Page 7 of 25 85 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-092-29-008 FIFIELD WANDA 537 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8740 2937-092-16-013 FILAN TROY S PO BOX 283 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-27-959 FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH OF PO BOX 206 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-35-981 FIRST CHURCH OF THE NAZPO BOX 327 PALISADE CO 81526-0327 2937-091-00-086 FISCH EDWIN J TRUST PO BOX 1168 PALISADE CO 81526-1168 2937-093-29-021 FISHER CHANCE E 390 W SIXTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-31-003 FITZGIBBONS GLENN A 196 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-084 FITZNER VERDIAN LEE LIVI347 TROYER AVE PALISADE CO 81526-9749 2937-092-29-012 FLANAGAN THOMAS F 505 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8740 2937-091-00-071 FLETCHER JAMES L PO BOX Q PALISADE CO 81526-0436 2937-091-08-002 FLETCHER JIM AND FLETCH610 SILVER MOUNTAIN DRGRAND JUNCCO 81504 2937-102-00-090 FLETCHER JIM AND FLETCH3455 G RD CLIFTON CO 81520 7941-031-21-006 FLORYANCIC WILLIAM J PO BOX 297 PALISADE CO 81526-0297 2937-091-00-971 FOOD BANK OF THE ROCKI10700 E 45TH AVE DENVER CO 802392906 2937-094-00-029 FOWLER CLAY W 712 38 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9747 7008-053-95-472 FOX BERNICE A 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526-8654 2937-094-01-007 FOX JEANNE M PO BOX 1187 PALISADE CO 81526-1187 2937-092-10-006 FOX RICHARD L 139 VICTORIA DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-38-009 FOX SHAWNA M PO BOX 1375 PALISADE CO 81526-1375 2937-092-27-004 FRAZIER RONALD K 573 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9725 7008-053-94-882 FRITH CHANDLER R 105 RIVERSIDE DR UNIT 12PALISADE CO 81526 7008-289-13-231 FRPARK HOMES LLC 3032 I-70 BUSINESS LOOP GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5722 2941-031-10-002 FRUITA CONSUMERS COOP1650 HIGHWAY 6 AND 50 FRUITA CO 81521-2042 2937-092-12-006 FUNK JAMES R 1166 17 RD FRUITA CO 815212032 2937-092-15-005 G 2 PROPERTY SERVICES LL678 POPLAR CT GRAND JUNCCO 81507 2937-092-08-002 G&L BRACKEN FAMILY TRUPO BOX 310 PALISADE CO 81526-0310 7008-055-69-161 GAFFNEY JOYCE B 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 3PALISADE CO 81526-8640 2937-081-00-102 GAITHER JOY E 3695 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8712 2937-081-00-103 GAITHER ROY MERRILL 3699 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8712 7008-053-29-893 GALLEGOS EUGENE D 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 53PALISADE CO 81526-8734 2937-092-24-008 GALLEGOS MANUEL A 545 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9785 7008-054-12-664 GALLEGOS MARIA LA LUZ 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 3 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-32-004 GALVAN JOSE A 181 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9211 2937-094-01-002 GAME MICHAELA A PO BOX 451 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-289-22-022 GARCIA AMILCAR NOE PO BOX 848 CLIFTON CO 81520 2937-092-28-005 GARDNER SHANNON D 3048 BOOKCLIFF AVE GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5692 2937-103-00-112 GARLICH JOHN D 5501 AZTEC CT BOULDER CO 80303-4000 7008-288-73-373 GARNAND ROBERT L 676 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9686 2937-092-05-952 GATES OF DELIVERANCE P PO BOX 433 PALISADE CO 81526-0433 7008-297-05-073 GAYNOS THEODORE 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526-8655 2941-031-08-001 GEARHART ROLAND W 809 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8753 2937-094-00-009 GEORGE KENNETH L 3418 F RD CLIFTON CO 81520-8431 2941-031-00-010 GERSTBERGER DALE F 19295 COUNTY ROAD 55 MOFFAT CO 81143 7012-053-79-975 GIBBONS DARLENE 131 N BOWER UNIT 13 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-03-016 GIBSON 2004 TRUST 869 IOWA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-9683 2941-031-03-019 GIBSON MARJORIE ANN PO BOX 1075 CEDAREDGE CO 814131075 2937-091-00-089 GIBSON SHIRLEY A 315 TROYER AVE PALISADE CO 815269749

Page 8 of 25 86 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 7941-031-21-014 GIBSON WILLIAM RICK 679 BRENTWOOD LN UNIT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-12-004 GIDEON CLARENCE P 323 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8782 2937-092-12-008 GIDEON KEN PO BOX 312 PALISADE CO 81526-0312 2937-092-14-025 GIESE ADAM P S PO BOX 263 PALISADE CO 81526-0263 2937-092-14-021 GIESE JAMES W PO BOX 86 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-289-11-773 GIFFORD JENNIFER 1808 J 2/10 RD FRUITA CO 815219396 2937-093-29-003 GILMAN THEA CHASE 1870 NANCY AVE LOS OSOS CA 93402 7008-051-21-931 GIMM DEBORAH G 105 RIVERSIDE DR TRLR 5 PALISADE CO 81526-9691 2937-093-30-015 GINGERICH LUKE PO BOX 610 PALISADE CO 815260610 2937-092-00-073 GIOVANNI GENE PAUL PO BOX 52 PALISADE CO 81526-0052 2937-093-30-008 GISLER LORI A PO BOX 151 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-32-001 GLASS GERALDINE E PO BOX 566 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-16-014 GLEASON RICHARD J PO BOX 1304 PALISADE CO 81526-1304 2937-093-31-011 GOLDEN STEVEN O PO BOX 446 PALISADE CO 81526-0446 2941-032-10-007 GOLEC WALTER 818 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2937-092-27-017 GOODMAN RICHARD R 576 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-14-012 GOWER MELISSA PO BOX 518 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-31-951 GRACE BAPTIST CHURCH PO BOX 1110 PALISADE CO 81526-1110 2937-093-34-002 GRACE Y ROBERTS LIVING PO BOX 326 PALISADE CO 81526-0326 2937-092-22-011 GRAHAM TAMMIE K 219 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9783 7008-288-90-031 GRANAT ROGER L 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-09-001 GRANAT ROGER L 810 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8400 2941-031-00-946 GRAND VALLEY IRRIG CO 688 26 RD GRAND JUNCCO 81506 2937-092-05-001 GRAY KIM E PO BOX 153 PALISADE CO 815260153 7008-007-03-004 GRAY LENARD W 676 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-01-003 GRAY TIMOTHY M 824 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9616 7008-015-97-009 GREGORY AUDREY 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 44PALISADE CO 81526-8799 7008-288-83-061 GRIFFIN HOMER 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526-8655 2941-032-13-001 GRIFFIN RODNEY 830 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8400 2937-093-38-004 GRIGGS MARLYS PO BOX 453 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-115 GRISE SHARLENE M 3699 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8728 2937-092-31-013 GRUMLEY JOAN GARZA 589 SERANADE ST GRAND JUNCCO 81504-4215 2937-091-03-033 GUEST HARVIE L 3838 CABALLO CT PALISADE CO 81526-9323 2937-091-04-021 GUIN SALEM PO BOX 174 PALISADE CO 81526-0174 2937-093-32-007 GUNTHER RICK A PO BOX 1236 PALISADE CO 81526-1236 2937-094-00-032 GURNEY MARION DANIEL 3345 W KAUFMAN ST PARIS TX 75460-5345 2937-092-25-013 HAAS CINDERA L 549 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9712 2937-091-02-005 HAAS DAVID A PO BOX 1052 PALISADE CO 81526-1052 2937-092-14-015 HABERKORN ALICE 337 W FOURTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-27-001 HAFFER ALEX M 495 CORONADO CLIFTON CO 81520 2941-022-00-081 HALE ROBERT C 3803 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-9346 2941-021-00-005 HALL AARON R JR 3851 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-9349 2937-093-33-010 HAMMER TERENCE L 1111 Q RD MACK CO 81525-9780 2937-093-30-001 HAMPTON MARY FAYE PO BOX 718 PALISADE CO 81526-0718 2941-032-16-001 HANAHAN BRIAN 805 MONCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 815268401 7008-054-99-812 HANEY KATHLEEN 724 HEMLOCK DR GRAND JUNCCO 81506 2937-091-04-022 HANNA MICHAEL A PO BOX 202 PARKER DAMCA 922670202

Page 9 of 25 87 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-091-02-008 HANNA PATRICIA S PO BOX 564 PALISADE CO 81526-0564 2941-031-03-014 HARGER LARRY D 9637 OLATHE ST COMMERCE CO 800227122 7008-107-96-089 HARKREADER KEVIN 209 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-32-001 HARKREADER THERESA V 209 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9706 2937-091-06-031 HARLOW TAMARA K 2644 1/2 CHESTNUT DR GRAND JUNCCO 81506-8390 2941-031-05-041 HARMON JAY C 2699 HAVEN HILL CT GRAND JUNCCO 815068662 2937-102-00-005 HARPER MICHAEL T 3871 N RIVER RD PALISADE CO 81526-7701 2937-092-14-024 HARPER SCOTT 1280 S UTE AVE STE 10 ASPEN CO 81611-2259 2941-032-10-003 HARRELL WILLIAM ROSS II 810 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 7008-288-62-301 HARRIS SUSAN KAY 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526-8654 2937-092-31-014 HARRISON JENNIFER A 125 SHADY LN PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-24-013 HARTMAN ANGELA 517 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9785 2937-054-00-081 HAUSER MATTHEW 3702 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-30-010 HAWKENSEN GURNIE G PO BOX 1066 PALISADE CO 81526-1066 2941-032-16-026 HAWKINS DIANTHA RUTH PO BOX 1330 GLENWOOD CO 816021330 2941-032-16-028 HAWKINS TANYA L 861 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526-8402 7008-054-96-914 HAWLEY CUSTER JR 819 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-10-008 HAWLEY JAMES DOUGLAS 819 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2937-094-02-034 HAYES GLENN D PO BOX 7 PALISADE CO 81526-0007 2937-091-02-009 HAYHURST KIM R PO BOX 977 PALISADE CO 81526-0977 2941-022-03-002 HAYS PERLE H 684 38 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-19-021 HAYWORTH ANNETTE F PO BOX 1022 PALISADE CO 81526-1022 2941-032-01-007 HAYWORTH CATHERINE A 826 1/2 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9616 2941-032-07-005 HAYWORTH TIMOTHY J 837 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9618 2941-032-10-013 HEARLSON FAMILY TRUST 809 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 815268811 2937-084-00-078 HECTOR JENIFER K 702 37 1/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-23-011 HEERMANN JENNA 31714 WHISKEY HILL LN STEAMBOAT CO 80487 2937-092-08-001 HELIG THOMAS LEO 237 W FIRST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-00-007 HELLER WILLIAM B 3838 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-05-079 HENDERSON LAWRENCE R2855 PINEHURST LN GRAND JUNCCO 81503-2299 2937-091-06-040 HENDRICKSON J & J PROPE7395 HEITER HILL RD EVERGREEN CO 80439 2941-031-09-006 HERLAND SHANE M 820 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8400 2937-081-00-121 HERMAN BILLIE 753 BLISS DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-00-049 HERMAN BILLIE L 414 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 7008-169-02-012 HERMAN BRUCE L 757 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-111 HERMAN BRUCE LYNN TRU757 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-13-005 HERMAN JENNIE C PO BOX 712 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-052-29-716 HERMAN PRODUCE 3784 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 7008-053-89-263 HERNANDEZ JOSE MANUE PO BOX 1108 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-27-002 HERRANZ MARCO 585 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9725 2937-092-15-004 HERRERA JULIAN G PO BOX 1367 PALISADE CO 81526-1367 7008-053-89-665 HERRERA PAULA M PO BOX 1367 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-26-003 HICKMAN CARMEN E 580 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9702 2941-031-05-005 HICKS DANIEL J TRUSTEE PO BOX 204 DELTA CO 81416 2937-091-06-027 HICKS MARY ANN 5824 OAK ST ARVADA CO 800044739 2937-081-08-001 HICKS MICHAEL J 626 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-9238 2937-092-04-005 HIGMAN RUBY M PO BOX 710 PALISADE CO 81526

Page 10 of 25 88 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-081-10-003 HILKEY STANLEY ALAN 605 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-8736 2937-092-34-005 HILL BEN D 1204 N 7TH ST STE 200 GRAND JUNCCO 81501-3074 2937-093-33-009 HILL ETTA J PO BOX 69 PALISADE CO 81526-0069 2937-081-00-139 HILL JEFFREY C 733 37 1/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8749 2937-092-04-004 HINCHLIFFE MARK 168 VAQUERO RD CARBONDALCO 81623-9719 2937-054-00-075 HINES EDWIN WAYNE PO BOX 155 PALISADE CO 81526-0155 2937-091-00-041 HINTON DARIN L 606 RAMBLING RD GRAND JUNCCO 81507-2608 2937-081-10-001 HIX ANITA M 735 37 3/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 7008-289-00-094 HNYLANSKI STEVE J SR 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 36PALISADE CO 81526-8799 2937-092-29-010 HODGE LYNNE M PO BOX 40827 GRAND JUNCCO 815040827 2937-054-00-086 HODSON RICHARD E 3716 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8729 7008-055-19-194 HOECKER AUGUST 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-00-110 HOFFMAN ANTOINETTE F PO BOX 781 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-13-007 HOLLAND KIMBERLY H PO BOX 1758 BASALT CO 816211758 2937-081-00-140 HOLLETT-KNOB VICKIE 735 37 1/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-04-010 HOMEFRONT GROUP INC 734 TULIP DR GRAND JUNCCO 81506-1836 2941-032-00-092 HORN CIRRUE H 3727 1/2 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-08-004 HORN SANDRA SUE 2308 GARMISCH DR UNIT VAIL CO 816574259 2937-091-11-002 HORTON LINDA D 760 37 8/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9740 2937-091-00-046 HOUSTON LISA M 720 38 2/10 RD PALISADE CO 815268762 2937-092-16-006 HOUSTON TAMI PO BOX 491 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-34-003 HOWARD CHAD PO BOX 1151 PALISADE CO 81526-1151 2937-092-31-007 HOWARD JEFFREY W 163 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-8790 2937-093-29-020 HUBBARTT E KAY 820 NORTH AVE GRAND JUNCCO 81501-3104 2937-091-06-029 HUBBARTT RODNEY R 126 BACON CT APT 5 PALISADE CO 81526-8757 2937-091-06-018 HUFF ANTHONY TERRELL 155 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9767 2941-032-17-004 HUFF LISA LYNN 833 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 815268667 2937-092-14-010 HUFF SHARON K PO BOX 322 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-10-014 HUGHES DAN L PO BOX 848 CARBONDALCO 81623-0848 2941-031-05-017 HUGHES DAVID J TRUSTEE 2191 I RD GRAND JUNCCO 81505-9357 2941-032-10-015 HUGHES MARIAN 805 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2941-031-05-016 HULINSKY MICHAEL JOHN 952 IOWA AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-15-006 HULL DAVID O 204 W 1ST STREET PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-28-007 HULLINGHORST ROBERT S 7301 MOUNT MEEKER RD LONGMONT CO 80503-8643 7008-143-96-136 HULVEY SHIRLEY J 105 RIVERSIDE DR TRLR 2 PALISADE CO 81526-9691 2937-091-04-005 HURD JANET L PO BOX 1450 PALISADE CO 81526-1450 2941-032-17-008 HUTCHINS LEWIS DEMOST863 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-04-006 HUTCHINS NINA 418 MAIN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-05-004 HUTCHINSON WILLIAM R 607 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-9220 2937-094-00-033 HYSELL DEBORA A 3816 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-07-006 INMAN JERRY R 835 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9618 2937-091-06-019 INMAN LYLE E 145 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9767 2941-031-05-004 IOWA FOURPLEX LLC 202 NORTH AVE UNIT 127 GRAND JUNCCO 81501 7051-050-22-110 ISBELL PAMELA J 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 24PALISADE CO 81526 7008-054-20-078 IZUMI HIROYUKI 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526-8654 2937-092-09-002 IZUMI HIROYUKI PO BOX 1406 PALISADE CO 81526-1406 2941-031-05-080 J & J MTN PROPERTIES LLC7395 HEITER HILL RD EVERGREEN CO 80439

Page 11 of 25 89 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2941-032-00-069 J C & KENNEDY REAL ESTAT3719 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-26-005 JACKSON TERESA J 568 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9702 2937-092-00-072 JACOBSON HALVOR G 528 MOCKINGBIRD LN GRAND JUNCCO 81503-1117 2937-092-16-012 JAKE AND CAROLYN STONE5600 COUNTY ROAD 100 CARBONDALCO 81623-8811 2937-093-41-002 JAMAR PROPERTIES LLC 30481 NATIONAL FOREST BUENA VISTACO 81211 2937-092-16-016 JAMES WILEY BARGER ANDPO BOX 1111 PALISADE CO 81526-1111 2941-031-03-028 JANE CLEVINGER FAMILY T995 23 RD GRAND JUNCCO 81505-8610 2937-093-33-006 JANSSON FAMILY TRUST 216 S RIDGE CT PARACHUTE CO 81635-9222 2937-093-34-016 JANUS SETH C 540 W EIGHTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-17-013 JARVIS JOSHUA DANIEL 883 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 7008-289-10-793 JEFFERS CARL WAYNE 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 815269610 7008-288-81-882 JENCO RHODA J 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526 7008-083-99-081 JENSEN CAROL 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 3PALISADE CO 81526-8655 2937-092-22-005 JESKE LAURIE KAY 209 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9783 2937-092-22-002 JESSUP JOHN S 734 TULIP DR GRAND JUNCCO 81506-1836 2937-093-40-001 JJR HOLDINGS LLC 170 TZ TRL GRAND JUNCCO 81503-9606 7008-051-48-954 JOHNS EDWARD L 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 39PALISADE CO 81526-8799 7008-288-81-672 JOHNSON MARILYN PO BOX 537 CLIFTON CO 81520 2937-093-35-007 JOHNSON RUSSELL L PO BOX 802 PALISADE CO 81526-0802 2937-092-05-011 JOHNSON SHERRI L PO BOX 650 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-078 JOHNSON TIMOTHY W 329 TROYER AVE PALISADE CO 81526 7008-052-90-666 JONES MARJORIE 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 52PALISADE CO 81526-8734 2937-102-00-006 JONES MATTHEW M 3867 N RIVER RD PALISADE CO 81526-7701 2941-032-07-008 JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N10790 RANCHO BERNARDOSAN DIEGO CA 92127 2937-091-06-007 JUDIS MARK A 102 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-32-011 JULIE A DIERS REVOCABLE 3652 G 4/10 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-01-005 KAIN MARY CATHERINE PO BOX 524 PALISADE CO 81526-0524 2937-092-28-014 KAME LANTON 3195 HILL AVE APT 1 GRAND JUNCCO 81504-7127 2937-092-16-010 KARLS DEBRA S 5 ASPEN VILLAGE ASPEN CO 81611 7008-279-94-195 KASKA LISA J 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 5 PALISADE CO 81526-8797 2937-093-30-003 KEEGAN SEAN D PO BOX 529 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-289-22-463 KEENAN CINDY 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-11-002 KEENAN THOMAS B 803 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2941-032-07-001 KELLER ROBERTA 22400 RCR 56 STEAMBOAT CO 80487-9441 2937-054-00-028 KELLEY ADA M 3704 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8729 2937-091-00-027 KELTNER KRAIG S 1111 HORIZON DR UNIT 31GRAND JUNCCO 81506 2941-032-00-089 KEMPTON THOMAS G ANDPO BOX 525 EAGLE CO 81631-0525 2937-091-03-017 KERKEL JASMIN G P O BOX 1055 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-288-00-361 KESSENICH THOMAS C PO BOX 142 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-18-008 KESTER JOHN CRAWFORD 2645 CHESTNUT DR GRAND JUNCCO 81506-8327 2937-093-32-020 KEY ROSE ANN PO BOX 428 PALISADE CO 81526-0428 2937-092-07-003 KEYS ROBERT J PO BOX 444 MESA CO 81643-0444 7008-289-00-401 KING SUSAN ANNE 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-03-008 KISSELL BEVERLY L PO BOX 605 PALISADE CO 81526-0605 2937-092-10-023 KISSELL JAMES A 376 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-05-007 KITTEL ROBERT R 602 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-8736 2937-092-14-009 KLEMENIC JOHN PO BOX 478 PALISADE CO 81526-0478

Page 12 of 25 90 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-091-06-002 KNOWLES KIRK PO BOX 4768 GRAND JUNCCO 81502 2937-094-04-003 KOCHEVAR PAULA B 2290 PAWNEE DR GRAND JUNCCO 81507-1359 2937-091-06-017 KOLISCH TRAVIS AUSTIN 165 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-31-006 KOPPENHAFER JANICE V PO BOX 1455 PALISADE CO 81526-1455 7008-288-02-821 KOVALCIK ALFRED L 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526-8654 7008-288-22-883 KOVALCIK ALFRED L 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526-8655 2937-093-34-010 KRAAI ERIC T PO BOX 4812 GRAND JUNCCO 815024812 2937-091-06-042 KRENEK MICHAEL ROY 103 BACON CT UNIT 6 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-27-005 KRIEGSHAUSER DUSTIN RAPO BOX 493 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-15-004 KRUEGER DONALD A 826 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526-8401 2937-092-25-003 KRUEGER MICHAEL 12510 ROOSEVELT LN APT ENGLEWOO CO 801127028 2937-091-00-110 KUEBER DONNA 758 37 8/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-00-096 L L WEST PROPERTIES LLC 3477 GRAND VALLEY CANACLIFTON CO 81520-9712 2937-081-07-002 LANCASTER LAURA 615 W FIRST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-07-003 LANCASTER RYAN W 3715 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 7008-052-10-477 LANDSBERGER STEPHEN 846 PR 1121 CLYDE TX 79510 7008-055-46-553 LANG HAROLD D 105 RIVERSIDE DR UNIT 8APALISADE CO 81526-9691 2941-031-03-023 LANGELLA VINCENT S 820 IOWA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-8638 2941-032-00-161 LANSDOWN LEILA R 3700 S WESTPORT AVE UNSIOUX FALLSSD 57106 2937-093-28-005 LARSON JUDITH L PO BOX 1174 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-09-004 LASLEY MARY 816 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8400 2941-032-16-010 LASLEY RONALD W PO BOX 758 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-167 LATE AFTERNOON ORCHARPO BOX 1467 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-32-011 LATHAM KATHY 114 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-09-007 LATHAM ROBERT T 822 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8400 2941-032-19-009 LAUDERDALE MICHAEL DY 864 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-25-017 LAURITA NICOLETTE 569 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-04-023 LAW ROBERT I PO BOX 4600 AVON CO 81620-4600 2937-091-00-088 LEASURE DAVID M 311 TROYER AVE PALISADE CO 81526-9749 7008-288-81-583 LECHNER BETTY 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 59PALISADE CO 81526-8734 2937-094-02-019 LEE ALICIA 589 S MAIN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-03-021 LEGARRE PAOLA 3555 E RD PALISADE CO 81526-9558 2937-093-32-004 LEIGH JORDON B 576 NORTHGATE DR GRAND JUNCCO 81505-6954 7008-166-05-045 LEONARD MARY PO BOX 325 PALISADE CO 81526-0325 2937-091-03-007 LEVINE LUANN D 16868 W 67TH PL ARVADA CO 80007 2937-093-32-006 LEVINE RANDI PO BOX 113 CLIFTON CO 81520 2937-033-00-032 LEWIS JERRY MACK 3842 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-13-011 LEWIS KREAT A 2426 I RD GRAND JUNCCO 81505 2937-093-35-012 L'HOMMEDIEU SUSAN PO BOX 782 PALISADE CO 81526-0782 2937-093-32-021 LICATA MARIO LOUIS 1000 WILDWOOD DR FRUITA CO 81521-8600 2941-032-19-002 LICATA ROBERT J PO BOX 1062 CLIFTON CO 81520-1062 2937-081-08-003 LIDDICOAT RICK H 618 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-9238 2937-091-03-014 LINCOLN ANNA ROSEMAR PO BOX 244 PALISADE CO 81526-0244 2937-091-04-013 LINCOLN CURTIS HART PO BOX 543 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-106 LINCOLN LAND COMPANY PO BOX 299 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-013 LIND EDWARD JR PO BOX 474 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-05-015 LINDSAY EDITH 946 IOWA AVE PALISADE CO 81526

Page 13 of 25 91 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-092-32-009 LINDSAY PAMELA M 126 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-10-028 LINKEM PAULA ANNE 140 VICTORIA DR PALISADE CO 81526-9717 2937-092-28-010 LISTER LYNDA K 520 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8739 7008-054-16-321 LLOYD CLINTON 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 4 PALISADE CO 81526-1029 2941-031-03-015 LOGAN WILLIAM D 632 S MESA ST FRUITA CO 81521-2967 2937-092-25-020 LOGSDON GRACE E 570 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8785 2937-092-16-004 LONCARICH TRELAWNY TIMPO BOX 541 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-40-003 LONE-SHARK INVESTMENT2546 COUNTY ROAD 308 DURANGO CO 81303-6731 2937-081-05-005 LOPEZ JOSEPH M 609 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-9220 7008-288-92-051 LOVATO ALBERT F 105 RIVERSIDE DR TRLR 17PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-18-006 LOVATO JULIE ANN 870 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 815268666 7008-288-12-721 LOVELACE CONNIE E PO BOX 1454 CRAIG CO 816261454 2937-092-01-003 LOZANO LINDA 135 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-9714 7008-052-01-026 LUBIN ANTHONY 37064 GRANDVIEW MESA CRAWFORD CO 814158900 2941-032-06-002 LUDLAM J&K FAMILY TRUSPO BOX 419 PALISADE CO 81526-0419 2937-092-25-001 LUDWIG BRANDON 159 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-17-002 LUTZOW CHRISTIAN ORION832 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-03-027 LYONS JOHN 75-256 MALULANI DR KAILUA KON HI 967402080 7008-053-24-085 LYONS RICHARD E 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 1PALISADE CO 81526-8654 2941-031-08-014 LYONS ROY 836 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-178 MAC PAC VENTURES LLC 607 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-07-001 MACKS SHADOW MTN MOPO BOX 1442 PALISADE CO 81526-1442 7008-288-92-065 MAESTAS BILL PO BOX 516 MESA CO 81643 2937-093-40-004 MAEZ BENA 2656 HEMLOCK CT GRAND JUNCCO 81506-1411 7008-054-08-957 MAHAN CAROL 105 SHADY LN UNIT 8B PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-08-005 MAHAN MICHAEL J PO BOX 1273 PALISADE CO 815261273 2941-032-17-011 MAHEUX RAE KAREN 877 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 7008-053-38-652 MALDONADO MANUEL G 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 27PALISADE CO 81526-8798 2937-092-27-016 MANCUSO MARC 3836 G RD PALISADE CO 815269344 2937-103-00-078 MANCUSO MARC 3836 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-03-006 MANNING ANGIE M PO BOX 1074 PALISADE CO 81526-1074 2937-091-03-009 MANUEL CHERYL L PO BOX 1287 PALISADE CO 81526-1287 2941-032-00-084 MARINO GERALDINE L TRU3725 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-8613 2941-031-08-005 MARSHALL JAMES E 817 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8753 2937-092-19-019 MARSHALL WILLIAM E PO BOX 1124 PALISADE CO 81526-1124 2937-081-00-072 MARTIN AARON PO BOX 112 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-29-013 MARTIN CURTIS W PO BOX JJ PALISADE CO 81526-0899 2937-091-03-026 MARTIN DEANNA M 514 AMERICAS WAY UNIT BOX ELDER SD 57719 7008-288-81-671 MARTIN MARTHA N 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 29PALISADE CO 81526-8798 2941-032-18-004 MARTINEZ BROOKE 854 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-01-001 MARTINEZ DANIEL J 3747 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-31-015 MARTINEZ GARY R TRUST 119 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-34-004 MARTINEZN EDWARD C 502 W 8TH ST PALISADE CO 81526-8630 2937-093-32-010 MARTINO LAWRENCE A JR PO BOX 1239 PALISADE CO 81526-1239 2941-032-17-009 MARTSOLF KRIS MARIE 871 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 815268667 7008-289-20-421 MARVEL CATHALEEN M 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 69PALISADE CO 815269723 7008-288-91-198 MASCARENAS CAROLYN S 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526-8655

Page 14 of 25 92 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-091-03-011 MASSICOTTE KENNETH 3411 C RD PALISADE CO 81526-9537 2937-092-10-025 MATHEWS RICHARD H PO BOX 632 PALISADE CO 81526-0632 2937-092-24-007 MATTESON FAMILY MATT382 1/2 CLIFF ROSA CT GRAND JUNCCO 81507-6214 2937-091-00-034 MATTHEWS PHILLIP JAY 6128 SONGBIRD CIR BOULDER CO 80303-1476 2937-081-08-007 MAURER EDWARD E 32933 SE 43RD ST FALL CITY WA 980248734 2937-092-28-009 MAYROSE GEORGE R 514 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8739 7008-072-13-001 MCALLISTER III W PATRICK674 BRENTWOOD DR PALISADE CO 81526 7008-316-98-325 MCALLISTER STEPHANIE 674 BRENTWOOD DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-27-014 MCALLISTER W PATRICK 674 BRENTWOOD DR PALISADE CO 81526-8644 2941-031-09-008 MCCABE MISHCHA M 824 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-33-002 MCCANN JAMES L PO BOX 5 PALISADE CO 81526-0005 2937-092-25-006 MCCRAY JEFFERY S 584 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9713 2937-092-07-006 MCDONALD HILTON PO BOX 39 DE BEQUE CO 81630-0039 2937-091-05-003 MCDONALD MICHAEL P PO BOX 207 PALISADE CO 81526-0207 2937-093-32-015 MCELLEY BART R 3869 G RD PALISADE CO 815269349 2937-094-00-038 MCEVOY ADAM W PO BOX 82 PALISADE CO 81526-0082 2937-094-04-004 MCEVOY R MICHAEL PO BOX 924 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-31-011 MCFARLAND JANE A 145 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 815268790 2937-092-28-002 MCKENNA JODI 533 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-131 MCLAUGHLIN MICHELLE 3684 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9750 7008-104-04-041 MCLEAN FARMS LLC 727 37 3/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8738 2937-081-00-183 MCLEAN MICHAEL L 607 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-179 MCLEAN WILLIAM L JR PO BOX M PALISADE CO 81526-0410 2937-092-25-012 MCMANUS BRIAN D 1640 CAPE HOPE AVE NE ASAINT PETERFL 337027042 2937-094-02-003 MCNEESE DOROTHY N PO BOX 202292 DENVER CO 80220-8292 7008-289-12-174 MCPHERSON JACQUELINE 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9610 7008-350-10-001 MELENDREZ GEORGE 3781 GRANADA UNIT 32 PALISADE CO 81526 7941-031-21-003 MELENDY THOMAS WAYN 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 815269605 2937-091-04-014 MELGARES MICHAEL J 514 31 RD GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5727 7008-288-83-132 MERINO VASQUEZ ANGELI131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 58PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-03-007 MERLINO ALBERT J PO BOX 205 PALISADE CO 81526-0205 2937-103-00-038 MERZ URSULA 5501 AZTEC CT BOULDER CO 80303-4000 2941-031-03-933 MESA COUNTY PO BOX 20000 GRAND JUNCCO 81502-5024 2937-044-00-946 MESA COUNTY IRRIGATIONPO BOX 970 PALISADE CO 81526-0970 2937-092-03-991 MESA COUNTY PUBLIC LIB443 N 6TH ST GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2937-093-27-013 METZ VIOLA LA RENE LIVINPO BOX 233 PALISADE CO 815260233 2937-092-16-003 METZGER SUSAN C PO BOX 1217 PALISADE CO 81526-1217 2937-092-31-001 MEYERS JANET ANN 208 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-04-001 MIGONE ELIZABETH SUZANPO BOX 9 PALISADE CO 81526-0009 2937-091-06-037 MIHM DAVID JOSEPH 227 CLIMAX DR DILLON CO 80435-8441 2937-091-00-032 MIKKELSON DEL L EST 12714 W PAINTBRUSH DR SUN CITY WEAZ 853752532 2937-054-00-035 MILLANG WAYDE D 3728 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8729 2937-091-03-029 MILLENSTED AVRIL D 3563 E 1/2 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-10-009 MILLER DAVID B 817 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2937-092-25-015 MILLER ROBERT G 557 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9712 2937-091-02-007 MILLS FAMILY TRUST PO BOX 26 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-28-008 MINK TIMOTHY ALLEN PO BOX 64 PALISADE CO 81526-0064

Page 15 of 25 93 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-093-38-003 MITCHELL ANTHONY E PO BOX 234 PALISADE CO 81526-0234 2937-091-06-024 MITCHELL HAROLD JR 2302 RIO GRANDE MONTROSE CO 81401 2937-092-14-019 MOHR KIM E PO BOX 482 PALISADE CO 81526-0482 2941-032-16-002 MOLLMAN DIANA RUTH R105 MID VALLEY NEW CASTLECO 81647 2937-092-10-011 MONROE THOMAS J 404 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8783 2937-093-36-002 MONTGOMERY JAMIE M 1112 W VIA LE PAZ DR FRUITA CO 81521-3054 7008-287-82-863 MONTOYA RAUL 514 HORN BAKER CT CLIFTON CO 81520-7857 2937-092-04-001 MOORE DUANE H PO BOX 759 PALISADE CO 81526-0759 2937-091-06-026 MOORE JANET M 5429 2000 RD DELTA CO 81416-9539 2937-092-25-021 MOORE TIMOTHY ILLIAN PO BOX 414 PALISADE CO 81526-0414 2937-093-34-005 MORARIO LEAH 3446 F 3/4 RD CLIFTON CO 81520-8423 7941-031-21-005 MORRIS DONALD E 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9605 2941-031-00-121 MORRIS JOHN G 3151 SNOWBERRY CT GRAND JUNCCO 81506-4149 2941-031-03-029 MORRIS JOHN G JR 3151 SNOWBERRY CT GRAND JUNCCO 81506-4149 2941-031-02-015 MORRIS MAX E PO BOX 186 PALISADE CO 81526-0186 7937-091-00-023 MORRIS RYAN 920 IOWA AVE APT 6 PALISADE CO 815269644 7008-053-49-077 MORRIS WILLIE 317 W 8TH ST TRLR 30 PALISADE CO 81526-8675 7008-288-20-831 MORRISON NANCY K 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 3PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-06-014 MORSE GLEN R 164 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9729 2941-032-01-002 MOSHER MICHAEL J PO BOX 1445 PALISADE CO 81526-1445 2937-081-07-001 MOSS RALPH D 3719 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9751 2937-093-29-019 MOSSBERGER TONIA J 626 33 RD CLIFTON CO 81520-8168 2937-093-30-009 MOUNTAIN ROBERT 4640 WILDCAT CT COLORADO SCO 80916-2589 2937-103-00-037 MUELLER JOHN T 3840 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-9344 2937-092-29-009 MULLIKEN RICHARD L 529 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8740 2937-033-00-010 MULLIN BEVERLY 3872 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8733 7008-053-86-893 MULLIN DAVID 317 W 8TH ST UNIT 20 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-033-00-025 MULLIN JAMES G 3868 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-033-00-026 MULLIN JAMES G 3872 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8733 2937-091-00-064 MULNIX BRETT HARRIS 3826 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9752 7008-289-10-222 MURPHY ANNA R 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 54PALISADE CO 81526-8734 2937-092-04-012 MURPHY PATRICK J PO BOX 404 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-00-035 MYERS DAVID J 17772 COUNTY ROAD 204 DE BEQUE CO 816309706 2937-092-26-002 MYERS HAROLD WAYNE 586 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9702 2937-054-00-047 NAPOLEON ANTHONY 3722 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-14-027 NARENKIVICIUS JOSEPH PO BOX 1316 PALISADE CO 81526-1316 2937-092-18-015 NASH NEIL L 159 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526-9757 2941-032-08-008 NASH TRAVIS A PO BOX 40351 GRAND JUNCCO 815040351 2937-092-06-002 NAU ANDREW S 1908 N COUNTY ROAD 23 BERTHOUD CO 80513-9510 2941-031-00-118 NEEDHAM DARRELL E 909 IOWA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-8657 2941-032-16-009 NELSON NATHAN R PO BOX 5133 EAGLE CO 81631 7008-053-61-412 NELSON PAUL L 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 5PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-00-086 NESTLER JOSHRT C 3725 1/2 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-8613 2937-044-00-060 NEW PALISADE COAL AND 9000 WETHERBEE CIR SHERWOOD AR 72120-4256 2941-032-16-011 NEWBURY LESLIE S 619 PASEO RD CARBONDALCO 81623-9742 2937-093-35-002 NICHOLS LAURA M 105 RIVERSIDE DR UNIT 14PALISADE CO 81526 2937-102-00-107 NICHOLSON DEBBIE K 4277 COLUMBINE DR VAIL CO 81657

Page 16 of 25 94 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-092-16-001 NIELSEN WILLIAM E PO BOX 392 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-054-00-059 NIGHTINGALE JOY J 3690 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8727 2937-092-26-007 NILSEN HAROLD C 556 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9702 2937-092-26-006 NILSEN STEPHEN C 564 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9702 7008-052-68-250 NILSON CAROL A 101 SHADY LN UNIT 20 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-052-20-469 NOBLES GLEN H 105 RIVERSIDE DR TRLR 9APALISADE CO 81526-9691 2937-091-02-003 NORSWORTHY COREY D PO BOX 1262 PALISADE CO 81526-1262 2941-032-16-024 NORTHROP ELEANOR M 843 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526-8403 2937-093-32-008 OBERLY CAROL J 3370 F 5/8 RD CLIFTON CO 81520-8117 7006-050-04-257 OBRIEN PAT 3781GRANADA DR UNIT 42PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-31-010 O'CONNELL MARGARET M 149 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-8790 7008-289-20-492 ODELL TERRI ELLEN 679 BENTWOOD DR UNIT PALISADE CO 81526 7008-284-95-498 ODNEAL LINDA 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 28PALISADE CO 81526-9723 7008-112-08-031 ODNEAL WES 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 24PALISADE CO 81526-8798 7008-289-22-551 ODNEAL WES 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 24PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-130 OLESEN JUDITH D 3687 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8728 7006-057-85-694 OLREE DOYLE PO BOX 1126 PALISADE CO 81526-1126 2941-031-05-042 OLSON ERIK D 224 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 815269782 7008-288-77-504 OPSAL JEANINE N 105 RIVERSIDE DR PALISADE CO 81526-9691 2937-092-18-003 OPSAL PAMELA E 468 W FIRST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2941-022-00-948 ORCHARD MESA IRRIGATIO668 38 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-32-017 ORCUTT SHELLY J PO BOX 558 PALISADE CO 81526-0558 2941-032-19-006 OSBORN DANIEL AARON 838 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-19-004 OSBORNE DAWN LYNNE 822 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-05-011 OSBORNE PAUL L 610 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-8736 2937-092-28-012 OSWALD JAMES L 532 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8739 2937-092-16-008 OTTE THEO C PO BOX 124 PALISADE CO 81526-0124 2937-091-04-015 OXFORD HARRY O PO BOX 213 PALISADE CO 81526-0213 7008-052-10-564 PA PARK HOMES LLC 3032 I-70 BUSINESS LOOP GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5722 2937-094-01-003 PAGEAU CRAIG G PO BOX 42 PALISADE CO 81526-0042 2937-094-00-008 PAHLER CHRISTOPHER 706 38 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-08-001 PAISLEY RICHARD K JR 842 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9616 2941-031-00-102 PALEKONA PROPERTIES LL 6755 MIRA MESA BLVD STSAN DIEGO CA 92121-4311 2937-084-00-951 PALISADE CHRISTIAN CHUR3702 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-00-122 PALISADE HOLDINGS LLC 600 W 8TH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-946 PALISADE IRRIGATION DISTPO BOX 266 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-102-00-946 PALISADE IRRIGATION DIST777 35 3/10 RD CLIFTON CO 81520 2937-091-07-055 PALISADE MOBILE HOME P131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 24PALISADE CO 81526-8798 2937-091-04-954 PALISADE UNITED METHOPO BOX L PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-41-002 PALISADE VINEYARDS LLC PO BOX 1533 PALISADE CO 81526-1533 2937-084-00-144 PALISADE WINERY PARTNE3708 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-9603 2937-084-00-122 PALISADES NATIONAL BANPO BOX 10 PALISADE CO 81526-0010 2937-091-00-047 PANKOW ARTHUR C 3829 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8706 2937-081-08-002 PANTEL ERNEST LEO & ATH616 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-9238 7008-039-12-001 PAPARK HOMES LLC 3032 I 70 BUSINESS LOOP GRAND JUNCCO 81504 2941-031-04-015 PAPARK SPACES 3032 I-70 BUSINESS LOOP GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5722 2937-091-08-010 PARADIS THOMAS 604 RICO WAY GRAND JUNCCO 81506-8221

Page 17 of 25 95 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-093-29-007 PARKER DONALD A PO BOX 576 PALISADE CO 81526-0576 7008-053-33-985 PARKER GERALD A 105 RIVERSIDE DR TRLR 10PALISADE CO 81526-9691 7008-055-13-378 PARRA ELIGIO 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 8 PALISADE CO 81526-8797 2937-102-00-066 PATMAN KARINA 910 FAIRWAY DR VAIL CO 81657-3707 2941-031-05-018 PATTERSON SHERRYL F 422 PENDLETON ST PALISADE CO 81526-8656 2941-031-08-010 PATTERSON TYLER 829 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 7008-289-11-581 PATTON SANDRA L 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 63PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-34-004 PD LANGEVIN LLC 570 MAXWELL DR GRAND JUNCCO 81504-7039 7008-053-58-379 PEACOCK ROBERT D 104 SHADY LN PALISADE CO 81526-9693 2937-091-03-001 PEARSON MARY M PO BOX 1101 PALISADE CO 81526-1101 2937-092-26-017 PEED RAYMOND LEE PO BOX 1131 PALISADE CO 81526-1131 2937-092-14-013 PELLOWSKI CARA M PO BOX 756 PALISADE CO 81526-0756 2937-092-16-007 PELLOWSKI JAMES J PO BOX 176 PALISADE CO 81526-0176 7008-126-03-068 PEREZ FRANCISCO 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 4 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-130-05-039 PERRY DAVID 676 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9687 7008-289-22-401 PERUSEK EDITH R 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9610 2937-081-09-002 PESCI FAMILY TRUST 623 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-9238 2937-092-27-015 PETERS ALANS E 588 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-9718 7008-289-20-212 PETERSEN DONALD G 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9610 2937-092-32-007 PETERSON MARVIN 138 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 7008-053-29-904 PETTERSON GALE 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 25PALISADE CO 81526-8798 2937-081-05-006 PETTIT ANN TRUSTEE PO BOX 1507 PALISADE CO 81526-1507 2941-032-13-003 PFEIFFER KARL W 683 LINCOLN DR PALISADE CO 81526-9647 7008-134-96-126 PFENNINGER SHARON A PO BOX 1957 EVERGREEN CO 80437 2937-033-00-061 PHILLIPS JANET K 561 32 1/2 RD CLIFTON CO 81520-7765 2937-092-08-004 PHILLIPS VIRGINIA PO BOX 146 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-14-023 PIKE BOBBI JO PO BOX 589 PALISADE CO 815230589 2937-092-29-011 PIKE JEFFREY 513 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8740 2937-092-28-006 PINDER MARIA E 509 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9701 2937-092-14-020 PINGLETON TONY C PO BOX 742 PALISADE CO 81526-0742 2937-092-18-009 PLUHAR JASON 123 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-15-001 PLUMB CHAPIN T PO BOX 1307 PALISADE CO 81526-1307 2937-092-00-038 POKRANDT JAMES E 1010 COLORADO AVE GLENWOOD CO 81601 2937-092-12-010 PONY-UP VENTURES LLC 3611 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8711 2937-081-00-036 POPE ROBERT L 3685 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8712 2941-031-05-084 POPP WALTER E 324 31 1/2 RD GRAND JUNCCO 81503-9633 7008-052-10-628 PORTELL TAMMY L 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 6 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-28-004 PORTER DARYL C 521 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-087 PRAGER KARL D 349 TROYER AVE PALISADE CO 81526-9749 2937-081-10-005 PRATT ERIC J 609 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-8736 2937-091-00-076 PRATT SHAWN 106 E FIRST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-02-003 PREE CAROLYN L 3780 GRANADA DR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-16-025 PRESSLER CAROLYN N 5746 SAINT JAMES PL CINCINNATI OH 452396309 2937-092-13-006 PRINSTER ERIC J PO BOX 554 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-29-001 PRINSTER PATRICIA L PO BOX 1433 PALISADE CO 815261433 2941-032-18-005 PROBERT BRANDAN MICH 862 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 7008-106-96-087 PRUITT CECELIA ANNE 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 1 PALISADE CO 81526-8797

Page 18 of 25 96 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 7008-289-12-751 PSENDA JANICE C PO BOX 412 PALISADE CO 815260412 2937-032-00-001 PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY550 15TH ST STE 1000 DENVER CO 80202-4256 2941-022-00-114 PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY1800 LARIMER ST 12TH FLODENVER CO 80202 7008-289-20-551 QUEAL CALVIN P 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9610 2937-092-03-004 QWEST COMMUNICATION1801 CALIFORNIA ST STE 4DENVER CO 80202-2607 7008-289-22-452 RAFF SONJA LEE PO BOX 105 PALISADE CO 81526-0105 2941-032-19-007 RAMOS ERICA DENISE 846 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-25-011 RAPER TROY S 533 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9712 2937-092-04-016 RASMUSSEN BRET REED 130 W FIFTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-05-005 RASMUSSEN SONYA LYNN PO BOX 282 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-010-10-385 RAWLINGS DONNA M 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 6PALISADE CO 815268654 2941-032-16-003 RAWLINS-CARDELL TERI PO BOX 308 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-18-010 RAYA CAROL SUE 1348 CRAWFORD RD MODESTO CA 95357 2937-092-03-006 REBA INC LLC PO BOX 1436 PALISADE CO 81526-1436 2937-092-14-029 REED BILLIE M PO BOX 65 PALISADE CO 81526-0065 2937-092-06-007 REED BRICE C PO BOX 464 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-18-007 REED KATHERINE LOUISE 869 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-12-009 REESE-FELLMAN MAGGY PO BOX 1148 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-14-002 REID TRUST PO BOX 2752 GRAND JUNCCO 81502 2937-093-36-004 REID WAYNE PO BOX 284 PALISADE CO 81526-0284 2937-093-28-001 REIMER GREGORY S 3629 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-8702 7008-309-99-317 REINER JOSHUA ALLEN 676 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-26-010 REINIER ANNE M PO BOX 1308 PALISADE CO 81526-1308 2937-092-19-016 RENTIE GORDON JOSEPH PO BOX 465 PALISADE CO 81526-0465 2937-092-10-008 RENZI DALE 655 ELIZABETH CT GRAND JUNCCO 81507-9441 2937-092-33-013 REVIS BARRY J 144 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526-9756 7008-052-77-108 REYNOLDS ANNA L 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 4 PALISADE CO 81526-8799 2937-094-00-030 RGW ASSOCIATES INC 2087 BROADWAY 81507 2937-092-04-015 RHEIN JASON A PO BOX 523 GRAND JUNCCO 815020523 2937-092-27-014 RICHARDS MICHAEL 582 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-10-002 RICHARDSON CASEY J 163 VICTORIA DR PALISADE CO 81526 7008-052-04-658 RICHMOND J D 327 W 8TH ST UNIT 12 PALISADE CO 81526-8671 2937-092-10-016 RICKARD BRADLEY K 320 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8780 2941-032-18-002 RICKARD SAMANTHA ANN 840 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 815268666 2937-091-00-094 RIDDELL-BROSIG LLC 121 S BOWER AE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-24-005 RINALDO MICHAEL J 5620 FOSSIL CREEK PARKWFT COLLINS CO 80525 2937-081-00-173 RISH RONALD P 745 BLISS DR PALISADE CO 81526-9202 7008-356-12-001 RIVER FOREST PROPERTIES674 BRENTWOOD DR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-00-043 RIVER FOREST PROPERTIES674 BRENTWOOD DR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-05-056 RIVER MEADOWS LLC PO BOX 2041 GRAND JUNCCO 81502-2041 2937-091-00-019 RMF VENTURES LLC 745 37 9/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-10-005 ROBINSON ALAN SHAWN 814 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2937-093-33-008 ROBINSON MATTHEW 619 LINCOLN AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-00-039 ROBSON FAMILY REVOCAB728 38 1/2 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-050 ROCCO DALE ALAN PO BOX 983 PALISADE CO 81526-0983 2937-091-00-051 ROCCO STEPHANIE M PO BOX 983 PALISADE CO 81526-0983 2937-091-04-998 ROCKY MOUNTAIN CONFE407 PINTAIL AVE GRAND JUNCCO 81504

Page 19 of 25 97 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-093-40-002 RODEBAUGH JASON D W 5745 EVERGREEN LN NEW LISBONWI 53950 2937-092-33-015 RODGERS CHRISTOPHER 540 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8785 2937-093-29-002 ROME PHILLIP A PO BOX 968 PALISADE CO 81526-0968 2941-031-09-003 ROMEO KATHLEEN 814 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-33-017 ROMERO DEVIN A 114 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-15-008 ROMERO-SANCHEZ PAULINPO BOX 1255 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-04-013 RONEY HOWARD 3699 VALLEY VIEW RD GLENWOOD CO 81501 7044-050-76-362 ROPER THOMAS 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 1 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-23-004 ROSS LINDA L 204 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9782 2937-081-05-008 ROTEN DANIEL R 2915 DRACO CIR UNIT 34 MONUMENTCO 80132 2937-092-10-027 ROTEN ELIZABETH H 362 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8781 2937-093-34-015 ROWE ANTHONY C 3628 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8721 2937-092-27-006 ROY DAVID ANDREW 563 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9725 2941-032-17-005 ROYSTER JESSE RIGEL LHO 841 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-02-024 RUDOLPH JACALYN PO BOX 1204 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-06-033 RUIZ JESUS 2984 PINYON AVE GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5477 7008-289-02-881 RUMSEY RICHARD L 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-18-004 RUPP RICHARD E 476 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-9761 2937-092-25-007 RUPP VALENTINE TRUSTEE 576 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9713 2941-032-11-001 RUSSELL B CHERIE 3735 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-8613 2937-093-40-003 RUTH KENNETH C PO BOX 96 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-40-005 RUTH KENNETH C PO BOX 96 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-15-006 RUTH VICKIE M 446 W FOURTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-102-02-001 RYAN TIMOTHY E 763 GARFIELD DR PALISADE CO 81526-9766 2941-022-00-115 SAIMS THOMAS J 695 38 1/2 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9381 7008-276-00-230 SALAZAR SOTERO N 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 28PALISADE CO 81526-8798 7042-050-33-219 SAMORA BOB 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 76PALISADE CO 81526-9723 2937-093-35-009 SAMUELS DEBORAH L PO BOX 1044 PALISADE CO 81526-1044 2937-092-25-022 SAUER BRUCE D PO BOX 426 PALISADE CO 81526-0426 2937-092-14-018 SAWYER MICHAEL J 317 W FOURTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-35-008 SCHAAPHOK WILL 41 CR 1788 FARMINGTONM 87401 2941-032-07-003 SCHAEFER EVE G 841 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9618 2941-032-08-003 SCHAEFER GREGORY J 3778 SHASTA ST APT C SAN DIEGO CA 921096762 2941-031-08-007 SCHENCK SCOTT 821 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-00-942 SCHOOL DISTRICT 51 2115 GRAND AVE GRAND JUNCCO 81501-8007 2937-092-28-013 SCHUCKMAN RUSSELL M 829 W MAIN ST GRAND JUNCCO 81501-5603 7008-289-22-521 SCHWERTFEGER FAYE A 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9610 7008-289-01-833 SCIGILANO BAMMA 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 14PALISADE CO 81526-8797 2937-092-29-004 SCOTT DENNIS T 569 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8740 2941-032-17-001 SCOTT JOHN J JR 821 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-044 SCRIBNER ROBERT R 3810 G 2/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-02-010 SCRIBNER RONALD 900 PENNSYLVANIA ST DENVER CO 80203 2937-092-26-015 SCRITCHFIELD BERTON G PO BOX 1308 PALISADE CO 81526-1308 2937-092-08-003 SECRETARY OF HOUSING A4400 WILL ROGERS PRKWYOKLAHOMA OK 73108 2941-031-03-030 SEEBERG TIM P 5607 WILLIAMSON PL FORT SMITH AR 729168415 2941-031-05-087 SELBY MICHELLE 2989 D RD GRAND JUNCCO 81504-8631 7008-289-20-443 SELIGMAN KIA 3032 I-70 BUSINESS LOOP GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5722

Page 20 of 25 98 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 7008-289-11-775 SELIGMAN STANLEY 3032 I-70 BUSINESS LOOP GRAND JUNCCO 81504-5722 2937-081-08-004 SERIANI MICHAEL P 620 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-9238 2937-092-18-016 SHAFER PENNY S 147 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526-9757 2937-081-00-037 SHAFFER PHILIP E 3693 G 4/10 ROAD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-042-00-011 SHAW HARRY E 6701 E 50TH AVE STE B COMMERCE CO 80022-4622 2941-032-00-167 SHAW LESLIE L 3715 G RD PALISADE CO 81526-8613 2937-092-29-005 SHEPHERD ROBERT 10930 THUNDERHEAD DR COLORADO SCO 809259518 2937-092-30-001 SHERIDAN STELLA 157 SMITH AVE PALISADE CO 815268741 2937-091-06-012 SHIEL PENNY S 123 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9767 2937-092-05-010 SHINGLETON ANTHONY EUPO BOX 777 PALISADE CO 81526-0777 2937-092-31-004 SHUMAN HEATHER L PO BOX 664 PALISADE CO 815260664 2941-031-08-011 SHUMAN ROBERT E 1000 N 9TH ST STE 2 GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2937-091-04-012 SILVERFOX LLLP 275 THOMAS RD CARBONDALCO 81623 2941-022-04-002 SIMPKINS MERRILYN K 677 38 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9311 2937-091-03-012 SIPE MONTE SURVIVING C 13712 GIMBERT LN SANTA ANA CA 92705 2937-093-34-012 SKIPPER KATHERINE DIANEPO BOX 314 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-36-001 SKIPPER KELTON 107 W SIXTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-164 SLACK ALAN ROY 3711 G 4/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9751 2937-092-28-008 SLACK RYAN 7032 COUNTY ROAD 2 RANGELY CO 816489765 2941-032-10-010 SLAGLE RONALD 815 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2941-031-05-081 SLAYTON NANCY R 3417 GRAND AVE GLENWOOD CO 81601-4495 2937-092-14-022 SLINEY JENNIFER S PO BOX 72 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-06-009 SMALLWOOD MICHAEL 122 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-22-006 SMITH DEBRA COLLEEN 213 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 815269783 2937-094-02-021 SMITH DONALD L 3032 BOOKCLIFF AVE GRAND JUNCCO 815045607 2941-032-16-012 SMITH FAMILY TRUST 3154 KAY ST GRAND JUNCCO 815046454 2937-091-05-002 SMITH JAMES C PO BOX 646 PALISADE CO 81526-0646 2937-092-16-002 SMITH MATTHEW M PO BOX 644 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-054-55-002 SMITH STEPHEN PO BOX 160 GRAND JUNCCO 815020160 2937-094-01-009 SMITH SURVIVOR A TRUSTPO BOX 298 PALISADE CO 81526-0298 2937-093-30-013 SMITH THOM D PO BOX 997 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-04-003 SMV PALISADE LLC 45 BROADWAY STE 390 NEW YORK NY 10006-3007 2937-081-05-001 SNOW MICHAEL G 601 W FIRST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-30-007 SOLOMON JAMES B PO BOX P PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-26-001 SOMERVILLE JAMIE 592 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-02-001 SOMOGYI THEODORE J PO BOX 698 PALISADE CO 81526-0698 2941-031-03-002 SOUTHERLAND RAY C PO BOX 1374 PALISADE CO 81526-1374 2937-091-00-058 SOUTHERN PACIFIC TRANS1400 DOUGLAS ST STOP 16OMAHA NE 68179-1001 2937-092-06-006 SOWLE SLADE J 3363 G RD CLIFTON CO 815208143 2937-102-00-067 SPAID CHASE E 3870 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-34-013 SPANO ROSEMARIE L 8360 W 59TH AVE ARVADA CO 80004 2937-092-26-013 ST JOHN WILLIAM C 520 MILEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-25-014 ST MARTIN ANTHONY 551 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9712 2937-084-00-050 STACK GEORGETTE L 841 RAPID CREEK RD PALISADE CO 81526-9402 2937-091-00-090 STAHL BRUCE E 3445 F 3/4 RD CLIFTON CO 81520-8425 2937-091-06-043 STALLINGS SHARON 103 BACON CT UNIT 5 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-27-010 STANSBERRY KENNETH D 558 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-9718

Page 21 of 25 99 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 7008-289-21-565 STARK WILIAM A 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 47PALISADE CO 81526-8799 2937-092-29-006 STEELE DEBRA R 553 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-04-011 STEELE JACKIE M 2980 B 1/2 RD GRAND JUNCCO 81503-2366 2941-032-08-004 STEELE KEN 1356 N SCHOONER LN ANAHEIM CA 928011780 2941-032-10-012 STEELE PATRICK J 811 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2937-092-24-015 STEFFEN JOHNALU 505 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9785 2937-081-08-005 STEHMAN JERRY A 622 MOSS WAY PALISADE CO 81526-9238 2937-092-18-017 STEPHENSON DAVID R 141 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526-9757 2937-102-00-056 STERLING JAMES H 3847 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8706 2937-092-16-017 STETSER SAMUEL PO BOX 1025 CARLTON OR 971111026 2937-092-19-008 STEVENSON GEORGIA PO BOX 354 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-054-97-731 STIVERS CHARLOTTE J 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-03-008 STOCKER JOSEPH T 1878 K RD FRUITA CO 81521 2937-094-00-040 STONE JOSEPH R 710 38 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9747 2937-092-12-003 STORY BRIAN A 341 W FIRST ST PALISADE CO 81526 7008-052-31-097 STOUT HAZEL M 600 SW NANCY CT GRESHAM OR 970306481 7008-176-96-158 STRAHL MAURY 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 3PALISADE CO 81526-8640 7008-289-12-831 STUDT PRISCILLA 679 BRENTWOOD LN UNIT PALISADE CO 81526 7008-288-01-052 STURGILL CLYDE W II 327 W 8TH ST UNIT 28 PALISADE CO 81526-8671 7008-054-06-772 SULLIVAN SHILO 131 N BOWER AVE UNIT 4 PALISADE CO 81526-8797 2937-092-06-004 SUMMY LYNNETTE 3857 PUERTA VISTA CT PALISADE CO 81526-9359 2937-092-06-008 SUNDMACHER ALLEN F PO BOX 158 FRUITA CO 815210158 2937-091-00-045 SWAIK JOHN 3812 G 2/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9724 2937-092-10-009 SWAIN LESTER P PO BOX 573 PALISADE CO 81526-0573 2937-092-02-008 SWEENEY ROBERT F 22095 E CHESTNUT PL AURORA CO 800167234 2937-092-09-001 SWENDIG RICHARD J 142 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-9715 2937-092-24-011 SWETT LESLIE J 525 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9785 2937-093-31-005 SWETT MACK L PO BOX 1249 PALISADE CO 81526-1249 2941-031-03-018 SYDNES MARY E TRUSTEE PO BOX 602 DESERT HOT CA 92240-0602 2937-092-18-018 TALBOTT JERRY W 153 MAJESTIC CT PALISADE CO 81526-9757 2937-092-10-001 TALLANT TAMMY 164 VICTORIA DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-00-073 TALLEY DEWAYNE 721 37 1/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8749 7008-181-94-119 TALLEY MARGARET R FAM3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 9PALISADE CO 81526-8654 7008-053-29-663 TAPIA CARLOS 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 66PALISADE CO 81526-9723 2937-092-25-002 TASKER JOHN D 8596 GYPSY HILL TRAIL RENO NV 89523 7044-050-23-823 TAYLOR DONALD L PO BOX 562 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-050-60-336 TAYLOR DOROTHY 317 W 8TH ST TRLR 19 PALISADE CO 81526-8674 2941-032-12-001 TAYLOR MARSHALL FREDE 460 RIO VISTA RD GUNNISON CO 81230-4129 2937-103-00-065 TAYLOR MICHAEL 3868 G RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-03-005 TEAMBALL LLP 0701 WESTBANK RD GLENWOOD CO 81601 7941-031-21-008 TEETSEL RAYMOND 679 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526-9605 2937-054-00-077 TEN-ACRE FARM LLC 733 HORIZON DR GRAND JUNCCO 81506-3906 7008-052-39-587 TENNANCOUR RAY G 105 RIVERSIDE DR UNIT 6 PALISADE CO 81526-9691 2937-092-02-011 TERRY ROGER D PO BOX 760 PALISADE CO 81526-0760 2937-092-31-005 THIESSEN MURRAY D 346 32 1/2 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9503 2941-032-10-011 THOMAS DORIS L TRUST 813 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2937-091-01-006 THOMPSON AARON 635 N 3RD ST GRAND JUNCCO 81501-2419

Page 22 of 25 100 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 7008-053-64-697 THOMPSON CHRIS PO BOX 22 PALISADE CO 81526-0022 2937-093-00-003 THOMPSON DUSTIN L 843 21 RD FRUITA CO 815219316 2937-092-10-015 THORNTON JEFFREY DOUG340 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8781 2937-091-06-039 THREET DAMON P 103 BACON CT APT 3 PALISADE CO 81526-9736 2941-032-07-009 TICE DEANNA S 3130 CATHY LEE PL GRAND JUNCCO 81504-6026 2937-091-00-074 TIM WEDEL LLC 3815 N RIVER RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-094-00-005 TIPPING ROBERT M PO BOX 27 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-08-009 TIPTON DANIEL W 825 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8753 2941-032-18-008 TOPAI CODY ALEXANDER 861 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-01-942 TOWN OF PALISADE PO BOX 128 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-19-018 TOWNS RONALD E PO BOX 615 PALISADE CO 81526-0615 7941-031-00-103 TRACY RICHARD L 103 SHADY LN PALISADE CO 81526-9693 2937-092-24-003 TRASK RICHARD K 532 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-08-013 TRAVIS MARC A 835 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-09-002 TREDWAY DAVID D 3864 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 8152689752 2937-044-00-058 TROXEL SUEANN 1710 ROBB ST UNIT 101 LAKEWOOD CO 802152681 2937-093-27-951 TRUSTEES OF FIRST BAPTISPO BOX 206 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-22-001 TUCKER CYNTHIA L 1815 MIDLAND AVE GLENWOOD CO 81601-4041 2937-093-35-011 TULLENERS MICHELLE PO BOX 82 CARBONDALCO 81623 7008-213-97-207 TULLIO SARAH 317 W 8TH ST UNIT 31 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-00-042 TURCOTTE ROBIN A 675 BRENTWOOD DR PALISADE CO 81526-8645 2941-031-09-005 TURNER GEORGE E 818 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-00-023 TURNER ROBERT V 154 E 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-9722 2937-092-03-009 TWEEDY DANA J PO BOX 475 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-19-008 ULIBARRI MISTY DEANN 856 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 7008-010-25-742 UNDERWOOD THOMAS E 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 7 PALISADE CO 81526-9723 2937-033-00-914 UNITED STATES OF AMERIC445 W GUNNISON AVE GRAND JUNCCO 81501 2937-092-32-003 VALDEZ DENISE HARDRICKPO BOX 279 PALISADE CO 81526-0279 2937-091-03-024 VALENTINE JAYNE F PO BOX 1555 PALISADE CO 81526-1555 2937-092-31-012 VANCLEAVE DORIS E 137 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-8790 2937-091-03-022 VANLANDINGHAM JOHN P641 35 1/2 RD PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-32-012 VANVALKENBURGH BETTY PO BOX W PALISADE CO 81526-0440 2941-032-08-005 VARNER GAIL A 834 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9616 2937-084-00-051 VAUGHN MAX 704 37 1/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-9741 2937-092-25-019 VEATCH DENNIS 578 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8785 2941-032-10-004 VERSLUIS PETER M 812 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2941-032-08-002 VICKERS STEWART R 840 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9616 2937-092-28-011 VINCENT LONNIE D 526 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8739 2941-022-04-001 VINELANDS LLC 5501 AZTEC CT BOULDER CO 80303-4000 2937-084-00-123 VINTNERS CROSSING LLC PO BOX 1327 PALISADE CO 81526-1327 2937-094-02-025 VIRTUE V'ETTA 4 MAVERICK LN ROLLING HILCA 90274-5230 2937-092-24-009 VOGT JEAN L 61925 FALCON RD MONTROSE CO 81401 2941-031-00-126 VOLUNTEERS OF AMERICA 7530 MARKET PLACE DR EDEN PRAIR MN 55344-3636 2937-043-00-051 VOORHEES DAVID H 3758 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8731 2937-091-06-016 VOORHEES HAROLD M 144 DAVIS CIR PALISADE CO 81526-9729 2937-092-25-010 VOORHEES PAMELA D 552 CICERO DR PALISADE CO 81526-9713 2937-092-27-005 VOORHEES SHIRLEY JEAN 567 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9725

Page 23 of 25 101 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 2937-093-35-005 VOSS LINDA M PO BOX 1178 PALISADE CO 81526-1178 2937-093-41-001 W H J LLC PO BOX 730 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-19-011 WADE MELANIE VIRGINIA 884 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-04-014 WALDEN LINDA 15877 GYPSUM CREEK RD GYPSUM CO 81637-9743 2937-094-01-001 WALDVOGLE NATHAN E PO BOX 375 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-081-06-002 WALKER BRUCE A PO BOX 363 PALISADE CO 81526-0363 2937-092-00-057 WALKER DAVID R 588 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8785 2937-102-00-106 WALKER ELEANOR L 3847 N RIVER RD PALISADE CO 81526-7701 2937-091-06-034 WALKER MATTHEW 320 ROCK BRIDGE DR WINDSOR CO 805506153 2937-081-06-001 WALKER NANCY PRISCILLA PO BOX 363 PALISADE CO 81526-0363 2937-092-29-003 WANGSNES LISA L 577 ROSA ST PALISADE CO 81526-8740 7008-289-22-524 WARD SUSAN 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 2PALISADE CO 81526-8655 2937-094-01-006 WARD TROY E 152 E FIFTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-35-001 WARE TONY 398 W 1ST ST PALISADE CO 81526-8781 2937-093-36-003 WASHINGTON BETH Y 131 W SIXTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-01-015 WASHINGTON LUCILLE R 847 MOUNT ULLA HWY MOORESVIL NC 28115-7942 2937-091-00-104 WASHKOWIAK SCOTT PO BOX 301 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-05-006 WASILEWSKI LEONARD PO BOX 786 PALISADE CO 81526-0786 2937-092-15-002 WATERHOUSE DAVID EUG PO BOX 1346 PALISADE CO 81526-1346 2941-032-18-009 WATKINS TYLER REED 851 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-05-039 WATSON DAN 3187 HIGHVIEW RD GRAND JUNCCO 81504 7941-031-00-007 WATSON JAMES T 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 7PALISADE CO 81526-8654 7941-031-21-004 WATTENBERG BARBARA 12421 RACING ST HENDERSONCO 80640 2937-093-31-010 WEAR CHARLES S 419 W FIFTH ST PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-02-013 WEBER ERNEST W 52110 AMBER RD DELTA CO 81416 7008-052-67-641 WEBER SHANNON K PO BOX 88 MESA CO 816430088 2937-091-00-079 WEDEL TIMOTHY P 3813 N RIVER RD PALISADE CO 81526-7703 2937-033-00-055 WEIDNER CHARLENE A 3830 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8733 2941-031-02-002 WEISEL ALAN M 3778 GRANADA DR PALISADE CO 815269633 2937-092-26-016 WELKER MICKY JOE 498 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-16-005 WELLS FARGO BANK NA 3476 STATEVIEW BLVD FORT MILL SC 29715 2937-091-05-009 WENDT CHARLES W TRUSTPO BOX 75 MIDPINES CA 95345-0075 2941-031-03-006 WENTZEL JULIA LYNN PO BOX 1072 PALISADE CO 815261072 2937-092-31-016 WESLEY SHIRLEY A 113 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526-8789 2937-092-12-012 WEST RONALD 12034 BEAR PARK RD CONIFER CO 80433-7514 2937-092-40-001 WEST RONALD PO BOX 159 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-288-81-881 WHEELER MARJORY L 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 4PALISADE CO 81526-8640 2937-093-29-010 WHITE CARL F PO BOX 4403 GRAND JUNCCO 81502-4403 2941-031-02-014 WHITE JOHN R PO BOX 819 PALISADE CO 81526-0819 2937-092-24-010 WHITE RANDEL E 529 CRAWFORD LN PALISADE CO 81526-9785 2937-093-29-009 WHITE RAYMOND ARNOLDPO BOX 353 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-034-00-035 WHITE RICHARD TRUSTEE 3888 G 7/10 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8733 2937-091-08-008 WHITING LAND LEGACY 140 WHITING RD WHITEWATECO 81527-9600 2937-093-28-004 WHITMORE BRIAN A PO BOX 1190 PALISADE CO 81526-1190 2937-091-03-013 WIDEGREN REX PO BOX 281 PALISADE CO 81526-0281 2937-033-00-041 WIDGER WALTER E PO BOX 1483 PALISADE CO 81526-1483 7008-054-95-994 WILKE IRIS I 3781 GRANADA DR UNIT 4PALISADE CO 81526

Page 24 of 25 102 2014-0136 VA Stahl Vacation Notification Table of Right of Way 7008-276-97-282 WILLARD PAUL B 131 N BOWER AVE TRLR 74PALISADE CO 81526-9723 2937-092-31-008 WILLARD PAUL B 159 SUNSET CIR PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-02-001 WILLIAM A COWLES III AN688 BRENTWOOD DR PALISADE CO 81526-8677 2937-092-26-014 WILLIAMS CHERRY J 514 MILLEMAN ST PALISADE CO 81526-9702 7008-112-99-122 WILLIAMS CYNTHIA A PO BOX 1452 CRAIG CO 81626 7008-051-66-008 WILLIAMS JIM 676 BRENTWOOD DR UNITPALISADE CO 81526 2937-102-02-002 WILLIAMS LAURIE K 3879 N RIVER RD PALISADE CO 815267701 2941-032-07-007 WILLIFORD MATTHEW R 833 LOGAN ST PALISADE CO 81526 2941-032-16-027 WILMA J HARBIN LIVING T 857 MONTCLAIR DR PALISADE CO 81526-8402 2937-092-09-003 WILSON MARCELLA K 122 W FIRST ST PALISADE CO 81526 2937-102-00-030 WILSON ROBERT W 3869 G 1/4 RD PALISADE CO 81526-8706 2937-093-31-009 WILSON WALTER D PO BOX 1229 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-10-002 WINANS SCOTT PO BOX 1551 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-054-00-030 WINE COUNTRY PROPERTY733 HORIZON DR GRAND JUNCCO 81506-3906 2941-032-10-001 WINTER JULIE A 806 ELBERTA AVE PALISADE CO 81526-4200 2941-032-17-007 WOLD KEVIN 857 CABERNET DR PALISADE CO 81526 2937-093-32-016 WOLF THOMAS F PO BOX 717 PALISADE CO 81526 7008-288-72-701 WOLFE LEONARD E REVOCPO BOX 1182 PALISADE CO 81526 2937-091-04-008 WOLL DAVID A PO BOX 40 PALISADE CO 81526 2941-031-00-005 WOOD DONALD R 1370 M 1/2 RD LOMA CO 81524-9728 2937-091-02-002 WOOD LAFE C PO BOX 307 PALISADE CO 81526-0307 2941-031-00-176 WOODACRES EAST LLC 1370 M 1/2 RD LOMA CO 81524 2937-092-19-022 WOODS GARY G PO BOX 602 PALISADE CO 81526-0602 2941-032-19-005 WOOLEN CRYSTAL YOLAND828 VINEYARD AVE PALISADE CO 81526 2937-092-22-004 WOOLLEY SUSAN 823 VINE ST ASPEN CO 81611-3269 2941-031-08-008 WOOLMAN ALFRED A 823 LINCOLN CT PALISADE CO 81526-8753 7008-135-95-346 YORK BECKY JO 105 RIVERSIDE DR UNIT 15PALISADE CO 81526 7008-054-18-795 YORK THOMAS J 317 W 8TH ST TRLR 13 PALISADE CO 81526-8674 2937-092-13-041 YOUNG DALE B 1289 CORONADO ST LOMA CO 81524 2937-092-13-042 YOUNG ERNEST D PO BOX 1306 PALISADE CO 81526-1306 2937-102-00-105 YOUNG JAMES CHRISTOPH2662 SACOMA CT GRAND JUNCCO 81506 2937-092-25-009 ZEMKE CONNIE L 3897 HIGHWAY 6 AND 24 PALISADE CO 815269738 John Curran 4544 County Rd 320 Rifle CO 81650

Page 25 of 25 103 REVIEW AGENCY COMMENTS

104 105 106

PRO2014-0136 - STAHL VACATION OF RIGHT OF WAY Review Agency Comments Comments Due Date: 10-20-2014

User Review Date/Time Comment Agency KEVIN WILLIAMS IRR GV 8/26/2014 GVDD wants to make sure that GVWUA is aware of the application. DRAINAGE 10:53:11 AM We have no further comment. PERRY RUPP UT GV RURAL 9/3/2014 GVP Review Comments POWER 12:52:03 PM 1. The project is not in the Grand Valley Power service area.

JIM DAUGHERTY WATER UTE 9/9/2014 • The District has a 36” transmission main and easement adjacent 4:29:47 PM to the subject property. • The District at all times shall have the right of ingress and egress by a reasonable route to said easement/right of way. • All fees and policies in effect at time of application will apply. If you have any questions concerning any of this, please feel free to contact Ute Water.

RON QUARLES CITY PALISADE 9/11/2014 The Town of Palisade does not support the right of way vacation 11:49:50 AM for the section of 37 8/10 Road as requested. Long Range Transportation Recommendations in the Palisade Comprehensive Plan include the future alignment of G 7 /10 Road eastward from Elberta Avenue (37 3/10 Road) to a terminus at a future connection with River Road, before it curves northward towards the River Road Bridge across the Colorado River. The 37 8/10 Road (Main Street) alignment is identified in the plan to include a future extension across the Highline Canal to a connection with the G 7/10 Road. Preservation of the existing right-of –way at this location is consistent with the recommendations of the Comprehensive Plan.

Thank you for the opportunity to review this request. Ron Quarles KATHLEEN OZGA US BUREAU OF 9/11/2014 The Bureau of Reclamation supports this vacation request, but REC 1:18:39 PM would like more time to review and provide more detailed comment. The Grand Valley Water Users Association should also be a review agency for this proposal, as they are Reclamation's managing entity for the Highline Canal. Reclamation would like to have the road vacation include the roadway from the north canal ROW to the south canal ROW, in other words to include in the vacation any part of the road that falls within the canal corridor. MARK BARSLUND IRR 5-2-1 DRAIN 9/22/2014 The 521 has no comment. AUTH 10:16:45 AM KATHLEEN OZGA US BUREAU OF 10/8/2014 The Bureau of Reclamation does not oppose this vacation request. REC 6:49:51 AM We believe that vacating the ROW will eliminate most of the unauthorized use of the Government Highline Canal operation and

107 maintenance road on the north side of the canal. MARK HARRIS IRR GV WATER 10/9/2014 The Grand Valley Water Users' Association (GVWUA) strongly urges USERS 7:41:29 AM the Mesa County Commissioners to grant Mr. Stahl's request to vacate the roadway easement on his property. This so called road is not maintained by the County or the Town of Palisade and is the continued cause of increasingly contentious trespass issues on the Stahl property and on the fee title property on which the Government Highline Canal O&M maintenance road, used by GVWUA, is located. Christie Barton 10/16/2014 From Kevin King, ROW Surveyor: I defer to Palisade planning as 4:33:03 PM their jurisdiction supersedes the Counties in this location. Christie Barton 10/20/2014 From Ron Quarles, Palisade Community Development Director: The 4:11:25 PM 37 8/10 Road (Main Street) alignment is identified in the Long Range Transportation Improvements Plan to include a future extension from the center of Town across the Highline Canal to a connection with the G 7/10 Road that will extend east and west. An existing water line also extends within the alignment of the road right-of-way. If the Right-of-way is vacated, as requested, the Town of Palisade will require an easement be retained to ensure access to the water line at all times. Although it is the preference of the Town that the right-of-way be preserved, if the right-of-way is vacated, the Town requests the following note be added to the survey: The Town of Palisade reserves the right for a public roadway on land affected by the R.O.W. vacation, and right-of-way will be granted for the benefit of the public when it is deemed necessary for connections consistent with the Town’s Long Range Transportation Improvement Plans.

108 HWY 6

Figure 6-1 LONG RANGE TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENTS

Consider Realigning G 7/10 at Elberta to I70 EB OFF create 4-Leg Intersection I70 Provide connectivity I70 between Collectors HICKMAN

35 8/10 G 7/10 Road HIGHLINE CANAL G 7/10 RIVER G 7/10 DAVIS MILLEMAN ROSA Main St. 37 1/4 Road Proposed New G 4/10 Road MAJESTIC (Toyer Ave)

Roads GARFIELD CICERO

FIRST IOWA

G 4/10 BLISS G 7/10 Road HWY 6 G 4/10 3/10 36 MOSS SECOND

37 3/10 37 New Connector 39 3/8 39 G 3/8 THIRD G 1/4 G 2/10 37 1/10 Road FOURTH

39 1/8

FIFTH 3/8 38

35 3/10 35 35 8/10 35

36 1/10 36 WHITE LILY SIXTH 35 6/10 35

G 37 1/10 37 FRONTAGE G 3/4 38

ELBERTA

Consider Western Proposed Frontage 39 roadway to Highway 6 RODEO

35 Roads (North & South New or existing R-O-W. 36 F 3/4 36 1/4 of Railroad Tracks) IOWA

LOGAN Study Alternatives F 3/4 Restricts driveways for Railroad Grade WILLIAM Separation

Highway 6 38 1/4

GRAND VALLEY CANAL 39 FRONT Proposed New 38 35 1/2 35 36 1/4 Road Road North of Proposed Canal Legend Extension F 1/4 CABALLO

Long Range TransportationSOBRE EL RIO Improvements 37 1/4 37

HORSE MOUNTAIN F Collector Roads (may need improvements) F F

New Routes 36 109 36 5/8 36 Additional Road Alternatives to consider NO PUBLIC COMMENTS

110 APPLICANT INFORMATION

111 Narrative - 3781 Road ROW Vacation

This road vacation will eliminate 191.54 feet of road frontage that Dan Cox and Bruce E. Stahl have along 37 8/10ths Road (aka Main Street, Palisade) which is a dead end road that no longer serves any useful purpose. Any useful function of this portion of Main Street, Palisade disappeared with the demolition of the bridge that was used to cross the Government Highline Canal.

The impact this road vacation will have on the general area will be a positive one. The general public is starting to use the Canal Road and this small portion of 37 8/10ths Road as a general through fare. The Canal Company does not like having the public using their Right of Way as a Road. This has the potential of creating some liability issues for them. The Canal company has even erected a lot of No Trespassing signs on their Right of Way. What this traffic does is create a lot of dust in the area. This dust has a tendency to permeate peoples houses and settle on the fruit trees. This dust settling on the fruit trees attracts dust mites. This causes the farmer to have to spray for dust mites which is one of the most expensive pesticides on the market. Vacating this portion of the 37 8/10ths road will eliminate the dust problem along with any liability issues that the Canal Company might incur with the public utilizing their maintenance road.

This vacation will not have any affect on utilities supplying services to the area including underground irrigation lines. This vacation also won't have any affect on the access to lots 6 and 7 of Palisade Heights Subdivision which has been historically achieved from 37 9/10ths Road (aka Bowers Avenue). Dan Cox off to the West of Main Street Palisade will still have his historic access from G 7/10ths Road which is a 45' Right of Way. Dale R. and Betty L. Ferguson, Don Cox's predecessor’s in chain of title, dedicated the northerly 25 feet of the NE 1/4 of the NW 1/4 of Section 9, Township 11 South, Range 98 West to Mesa County for road purposes on April 19, 1995, cementing Dan Cox's access. ( See Book 2143, Page 215 Reception 17146381). Also the Road Proclamation adopted by the County Commissioners of Mesa County on Tuesday, March 11th, 1890 and recorded at 4:00 O’clock P.M. on August 7, 1957 at Reception No. 700396 also establishes a Right of Way on G 7/10 this Road, Dan Cox’s historic access.

112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 RESOLUTIONS

137

RESOLUTION NO. ______Planning Department No. 2014-0135 RZ

APPROVAL OF A REQUEST TO REZONE THE AMICO PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3172 E½ ROAD, CLIFTON FROM THE PUD DISTRICT TO THE RMF-8 DISTRICT

WHEREAS, Daniel Amico, Sr. sought approval to rezone an approximately 1.5 acre parcel located at 3172 E½ Road, Clifton from a Planned Unit Development (PUD) District to the Residential Multi-Family-8 units/acre District (RMF-8) within the County of Mesa, State of Colorado and shown on attached Exhibit "A" and more particularly described on attached Exhibit "B" and

WHEREAS, the staff recommendation was contained in a staff report dated September 15, 2014, and

WHEREAS, the Mesa County Planning Commission recommended approval at the September 25, 2014 Planning Commission public hearing, and

WHEREAS, the public hearing duly noticed was held before the Mesa County Board of County Commissioners on October 14, 2014.

NOW, THEREFORE, THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF THE COUNTY OF MESA FINDS AS FOLLOWS:

THAT public notice requirements of Section 3.1.8 of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended) have been met.

THAT a rezoning of an approximately 1.5 acre parcel located at 3172 E½ Road, Clifton from a Planned Unit Development (PUD) District to the Residential Multi-Family-8 units/acre District (RMF-8) meets the applicable Approval Criteria for Rezonings (Zoning Map Amendments) of Section 3.4.7 and the General Approval Criteria of Section 3.1.17 of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended). The rezone is consistent with the Grand Junction Comprehensive Plan, an element of the Mesa County Master Plan.

THAT this request is in accordance with the health, safety and welfare of the residents of Mesa County.

Page 1 of 3 138

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS IN THE COUNTY OF MESA, STATE OF COLORADO:

THAT the request for a rezone from a Planned Unit Development (PUD) District to the Residential Multi-Family- 8 units/acre District (RMF-8) located at 3172 E½ Road, Clifton is approved.

PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS ____ DAY OF ______, 2014.

______John Justman, Chair Board of Mesa County Commissioners

ATTEST:

______Sheila Reiner Clerk and Recorder

Page 2 of 3 139 Exhibit A Location Map

Exhibit B Legal Description Beginning South 0 degrees 18' 04sec E 1028.57 feet from Northeast Corner SW¼ NE¼ Section 10 1S 1E S 73 degrees 06' 55sec W 214.20 feet N 0 degrees 15' W 330 feet N 89degrees 44' 56sec E 204.99ft S 0 degrees18' 04sec E 268.87feet to Beginning & W 5 feet Of Lots 15a Thru 17a & 18b & S 33.23feet of Lot 14a Clifton Village Sub Sd Sec 10

Page 3 of 3 140

RESOLUTION NO. ______Planning Department No. 2014-0124 RZ

APPROVAL OF A REQUEST TO REZONE THE HAYDEN INVESTMENTS LLC PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3208 SPRINGFIELD ROAD, GRAND JUNCTION FROM THE C-2 DISTRICT TO THE I-1 DISTRICT

WHEREAS, Julie Hayden of Hayden Investments, LLC, sought approval to rezone an approximately 3.6 acre parcel located at 3208 Springfield Road, Grand Junction from a General Commercial (C-2) District to the Limited Industrial District (I-1) within the County of Mesa, State of Colorado and shown on attached Exhibit "A" and more particularly described as follows: Lot 2, Springfield Estates; and

WHEREAS, the staff recommendation was contained in a staff report dated September 15, 2014 and amended October 6, 2014, and

WHEREAS, the Mesa County Planning Commission recommended approval at the September 25, 2014 Planning Commission public hearing, and

WHEREAS, the public hearing duly noticed was held before the Mesa County Board of County Commissioners on October 14, 2014.

NOW, THEREFORE, THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF THE COUNTY OF MESA FINDS AS FOLLOWS:

THAT public notice requirements of Section 3.1.8 of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended) have been met.

THAT a rezoning of an approximately 3.6 acre parcel located at 3208 Springfield Road, Grand Junction from a C-2 District to the I-1 District meets the applicable Approval Criteria for Rezonings (Zoning Map Amendments) of Section 3.4.7, and General Approval Criteria of Section 3.1.17 of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended). The rezone is consistent with the Grand Junction Comprehensive Plan, an element of the Mesa County Master Plan.

THAT this request is in accordance with the health, safety and welfare of the residents of Mesa County.

Page 1 of 3 141

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS IN THE COUNTY OF MESA, STATE OF COLORADO:

THAT the request for a rezone from a General Commercial (C-2) District to the Limited Industrial (I-1) District located at 3208 Springfield Road, Grand Junction is approved.

PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS ____ DAY OF ______, 2014.

______John Justman, Chair Board of Mesa County Commissioners

ATTEST:

______Sheila Reiner Clerk and Recorder

Page 2 of 3 142 Exhibit A Location Map

Page 3 of 3 143

RESOLUTION NO. ______Planning Division No. 2014-0097 CUP

APPROVAL OF A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR MINOR ENTERTAINMENT EVENTS FOR MOUNTAIN VIEW FARMS IN THE AFT DISTRICT UNDER THE USE TABLE OF SECTION 5.1 OF THE MESA COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE LOCATED AT 3165 B 1/2 RD

WHEREAS Jeri and Robert Prescott, the owner, sought approval for Conditional Use Permit to conduct minor entertainment events for no more than 4 events per month, for up to 150 guests, with a maximum of 21 events per year in the Agricultural, Forestry Transitional (AFT) District at 3165 B 1/2 Road as shown on attached Exhibit “A” and more particularly described on attached Exhibit “B” Legal Description, and

WHEREAS, the attached Exhibit “C” is the site plan for the proposed use, and

WHEREAS, the staff recommendation was contained in a staff report dated August 18, 2014 and revised September 8, 2014; and

WHEREAS, the Mesa County Planning Commission recommended approval (4 to 3) of this project at the August 28, 2014 Planning Commission public hearing; and

WHEREAS, the public hearing duly noticed was held before the Mesa County Board of County Commissioners on September 16, 2014 and was approved unanimously by the County Commissioners.

NOW, THEREFORE, THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF THE COUNTY OF MESA FINDS AS FOLLOWS:

THAT public notice requirements of Section 3.1.8 of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended) have been met.

THAT the Conditional Use Permit to conduct minor entertainment events for no more than 4 events per month, for up to 150 guests, with a maximum of 21 events per year in the Agricultural, Forestry Transitional (AFT) District at 3165 B 1/2 Road meets the applicable Approval Criteria for Conditional Use Permits (Section 3.8.7), and the General Approval Criteria (Section 3.1.17) of the Mesa County Land Development Code 2000, as amended, and that is consistent with the Mesa County Master Plan.

THAT this request is in accordance with the health, safety and welfare of the residents of Mesa County.

Page 1 of 6 144 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS IN THE COUNTY OF MESA, STATE OF COLORADO:

THAT the request for a Conditional Use Permit to conduct minor entertainment events for no more than 4 events per month for up to 150 guests, with a maximum of 21 events per year in the Agricultural, Forestry Transitional (AFT) District at 3165 B ½ Road is approved with the following conditions:

1. All review agency comments not in conflict with the following conditions of approval shall be addressed. The applicant shall comply with the conditions of approval for the access permit. Soils test showing that the road will handle the weight of the emergency vehicles. Show no parking areas, guest cannot park on the access road (signage). Turning around area needs to be dimensioned to show compliance with the fire code. The tree overhang must not conflict with the height of the emergency vehicles.

2. If signage is requested in the future, the applicant shall request a sign permit and signs shall be limited to no more than six square feet, in keeping with provisions for bed and breakfast standards in a residential area.

3. The grass area utilized for guest parking shall be maintained and preserved. The parking area will be watered after the event to maintain vegetation for dust suppression.

5. The applicant, owner, and operator shall adhere to the noise limit requirements of Colorado Revised Statutes Section 25-12-103. The applicant shall purchase a sound meter and conduct random sampling during events. The operator shall, at his or her own expense, conduct sound testing as necessary to demonstrate compliance with the above referenced Statutes. Other measures or methods to minimize noise, such as additional berming, structural screening, or relocation of the noise source, and landscaping may be required to minimize the noise impacts. The barn shall be insulated and entertainment limited to the inside of the barn and speakers pointed north away from Madison Acres.

6. Site lighting shall be unobtrusive and no flood lights will be used on the site. Lighting must be at a minimum, full cutoff and in accordance with Section 7.6.7 of the Mesa County Land Development Code.

7. Events are limited to no more than 4 events per month and hours of amplified entertainment shall not go beyond 10pm and the event will end at 10:30pm. Maximum of 21 events per year with no more than 150 guests per event.

8. Reflective markers, lawn lighting or string lighting shall be placed along the driveway to show the edge of the driving surface during the night time hours.

9. If existing restrooms in the residence are used for events, the applicant will have an engineer certify that the system can handle the anticipated load. The applicant must

Page 2 of 6 145 work with the Building Department to provide non-discharging portable restroom facilities for all events.

10. A commercial site plan shall be submitted prior to the first event to ensure compliance with the conditional use permit.

11. A Transportation Impact Fee is required prior to commercial site plan approval.

12. The applicant, shall consistently comply with all applicable provisions of the Mesa County Land Development Code

13. The applicant shall not significantly deviate from the site plan and documents submitted with this application including the project narrative.

14. Any modification or expansion of this facility, not including minor modifications as determined by the Planning Director, shall require an amendment of the Conditional Use Permit.

15. All required licenses and permits to serve alcohol shall be obtained.

16. Food served at the events shall be catered and not prepared on-site. The business preparing/serving the food must hold a current Colorado Retail Food Establishment license. Liquor license will be required if alcohol is to be served.

17. The fuel tank outside the barn shall be removed.

18. Screening along the south boundary will be installed to mitigate headlights, noise and dust.

PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS ______DAY OF ______, 2014.

______John Justman, Chair Board of Mesa County Commissioners

ATTEST:

______Sheila Reiner Clerk and Recorder

Page 3 of 6 146 EXHIBIT A LOCATION MAP 2014-0097 CUP Mountain View Farms at 3165 b ½ Road

Page 4 of 6 147

EXHIBIT B LEGAL DESCRIPTION 2014-0097 CUP Mountain View Farms at 3165 b ½ Road

Page 5 of 6 148 EXHIBIT C SITE PLAN

2014-0097 CUP Mountain View Farms at 3165 b ½ Road

Page 6 of 6 149 RESOLUTION NO. ______Planning Department No. 2013-0187 CUP

APPROVAL OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THE WESTERN SLOPE FLAGSTONE CAMEO QUARRY TO ALLOW THE USE OF RAPID CREEK ROAD FOR COMMERCIAL USE

WHEREAS, Rudy Fontanari sought approval to amend the Conditional Use Permit for gravel extraction in the Agricultural, Forestry, Transitional (AFT) District and shown on the attached Exhibit "A" and more particularly described on attached Exhibit "B", LEGAL DESCRIPTION; and

WHEREAS, the staff recommendation was contained in a staff report dated August 19, 2014, and updated October 3, 2014; and

WHEREAS, the Mesa County Planning Commission recommended denial of this project at the September 25, 2014 Planning Commission public hearing; and

WHEREAS, the public hearing duly noticed was held before the Mesa County Board of County Commissioners on October 14, 2014.

NOW, THEREFORE, THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF THE COUNTY OF MESA FINDS AS FOLLOWS:

THAT public notice requirements of Section 3.1.8 of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended) have been met.

THAT the amendment to the Conditional Use Permit to allow commercial vehicles from the Western Slope Flagstone mining operation to access to Rapid Creek Road in the Agricultural, Forestry, Transitional (AFT) District meets or can meet the applicable approval criteria for Conditional Use Permits (Section 3.8.7), and the General Approval Criteria (Section 3.1.17) of the Mesa County Land Development Code (2000, as amended), and is consistent with the Mesa County Master Plan.

THAT this project is in accordance with the health, safety and welfare of the residents of Mesa County.

NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS IN THE COUNTY OF MESA, STATE OF COLORADO:

THAT the request to amend the Conditional Use Permit to allow commercial vehicles from the Western Slope Flagstone mining operation to access to Rapid Creek Road is approved with the following conditions:

1. On Rapid Creek Road all commercial truck trips associated with the quarry are limited to 5 round trips per day for five days per week, the owners’ and employees’ use of commercial trucks to commute to and from the quarry. This condition of

Page 1 of 8 150 approval supersedes Condition #3 in Mesa County BoCC of County Resolution MCM 95–103. 2. Prior to using Rapid Creek Road as an access road for commercial trucks, Western Slope Flagstone shall obtain approval of a CDOT access permit for the intersection of Rapid Creek Road and Highway 6. Haul traffic will not use North River Road and will only use Highway 6. 3. Hours of truck traffic on Rapid Creek Road shall be limited to between 6:00 am and 7:00 pm as specified in the Land Development Code, Section 5.2.13.H, Mining and Extractive Uses hours of operation. 4. The requested 5 days per week to use commercial haul trucks on Rapid Creek Road shall be specified as Monday through Friday for enforcement purposes.

PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS ____ DAY OF ______, 2014.

______John Justman, Chair Board of Mesa County Commissioners

ATTEST:

______Sheila Reiner Clerk and Recorder

Page 2 of 8 151 Exhibit A

Page 3 of 8 152 Exhibit B

Page 4 of 8 153

Page 5 of 8 154

Page 6 of 8 155 Page 7 of 8 156

Page 8 of 8 157