Agenda and Notes of the Meeting of the Rta Kottayam Dated 22/02/2018

Home , Changanassery, Chemmannar, Edamattom, Erattupetta, Kappadu, Karukachal

AGENDA AND NOTES OF THE MEETING OF THE RTA KOTTAYAM DATED 22/02/2018.

Item No. 01 G1/15041/2018/K

Agenda- To consider the application for the grant of fresh regular permit to SC KL 15 9918 to operate on the route ERATTUPETTA – MELADUKKAM via, Teekoy, Adukkam and Addl trips as ERATTUPETTA – KAIPPALLY via Poonjar, ERATTUPETTA – THALANADU, via Teekoy, ERATTUPETTA – MANKOMBU SCHOOL via, Moonnilavu, ERATTUPETTA – ADIVARAM via, Poonjar as Ordinary Service from the date of issue.

Applicant-The Managing Director, KSRTC, Thiruvanamthapuram.

Notes- Registered Owner of SC KL 15 9918 has applied for the grant of a fresh regular permit to operate on the route ERATTUPETTA – MELADUKKAM via, Teekoy, Adukkam and Addl trips as ERATTUPETTA – KAIPPALLY via Poonjar, ERATTUPETTA – THALANADU, via Teekoy, ERATTUPETTA – MANKOMBU SCHOOL via, Moonnilavu, ERATTUPETTA – ADIVARAM via, Poonjar as Ordinary Service from the date of issue.

TIMINGS Dept To Via From Arr. Time Kms Time 08.50 Erattupetta Theekoy Meladukkam 09.25 14 09.30 Meladukkam Theekoy Erattupetta 10.05 14 10.15 Erattupetta Poonjar Kaippally 10.55 14 11.00 Kaippally Poonjar Erattupetta 11.40 14 11.45 Erattupetta Theekoy Thalanadu 12.15 12 12.25 Thalanadu Teekoy Erattupetta 12.55 12 14.00 Erattupetta Poonjar Adivaram 14.40 14 14.50 Adivaram Poonjar Erattupetta 15.30 14 15.40 Erattupetta Theekoy Thlanadu East 16.15 13 16.35 Thalanadu Erattupetta Mankombu School 17.45 23 18.00 Mankombu School Moonnilavu Erattupetta 18.30 10 154

Hence RTA may hear the applicant and take a decision.

Item No. 02 G1/7298/2018/K

Agenda-To consider the application for the grant of fresh regular permit to SC KL 41 J 7175 / another suitable vehicle to operate on the route AMBIKA MARKET – NEREKADAVU FERRY via, Bund Road, Edayazham, Ullala, Thottakam School, Vaikom & Madiyathara School as Ordinary Service.

Applicant- Sri. Siby Joseph, Perayil [H], Ambika Market, Vechoor, Vaikom dtd 20/01/2018.

Proposed Timings Ambika Market Bund Road Vaikom Nerekadavu A D A P D A P D A D 5.30am 5.35 6.07 6.24 7.24 7.19 6.47 6.30 7.26 7.31 8.03 8.20 8.52 8.35 9.32 9.00 10.00 10.32 11.22 11.17 10.45 11.50 11.55 12.27 1.12 1.07 12.35 1.50 1.55 2.27 2.44 3.40 3.08 2.51 3.43 4.15 5.17 4.45 5.20 5.52 6.09 7.29pm[Halt] 7.24 6.42 6.25

Notes- This is an application for the grant of a of a fresh regular permit to SC KL 41 J 7175 / another suitable vehicle to operate on the route AMBIKA MARKET – NEREKADAVU FERRY via, Bund Road, Edayazham, Ullala, Thottakam School, Vaikom & Madiyathara School as Ordinary Service.

The enquiry report of MVI Vaikom revealed the following.

1. Total distance of the route : 22 Kms. [Daily Mileage of 220 kms]

2. Intra/ Inter District route : Intra District.

3. Details of Virgin Portion : Yes. 1.2 kms from Madiyathara to Nerekadavu Jn.

4. Details of Road Fitness certificate : Not Received.

5. Details of Overlapping : Total overlapping is 900 meter ie, 4.09 % of the total route length [22 km] which is within the permissible limit.

1) Route portion of 900 meter from Vaikom KSRTC to Ring Road objectionably overlaps on Ernakulam – Thekkady notified Scheme 42/2009 Trans dtd 14/07/2009.

6. Details of Vehicle produced : KL 41 J 7175 / another suitable vehicle owned by the applicant. 7. Details of Concurrence :N A.

8. Necessity, recommendation if any : Enquiry officer reported that in the proposed route AMbika Market to Vaikom town is well served sector and Vaikom to Nerekadavu sector is ill served sector. The proposed permit offers 12 trips and it will provide better conveyance to travelling public and students in the above sector to Vaikom Town. The proposed permit offer 8 trips to the ill served sectors and if all trips extended to ill served sector, it will be more beneficial to travelling public. The major portion of the route length is Ambika Market – Vaikom where STU’s are conducting service, hence their objection may be considered.

9. Court Direction, if any : Nil.

10. Other relevant points : There is no direct time clash noticed. However timings may settled after conducting Timing conference. 11. Type of road : Madiyathara Jn to Nerekadavu jn 1.2 kms is virgin. [Municipal Road] Fitness may be obtained from concerned authority. All the route length is single line road and Heavy vehicles are conducting service in the sector.

RTA may hear the applicant, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No. 03 G1/10951/2018/K

Agenda-To consider the application for the grant of fresh regular permit to SC KL 24 C 4696 / another suitable vehicle to operate on the route MUNDAKAYAM – ERUMELY via, Pulikkunnu, Kannimala, Peruthodu with two cut trips between Mundakayam - Pulikkunnu as Ordinary Service.

Applicant- Sri. P S Binu,Pazhoor, Palampra P O, Kanjirappally dtd 31/01/2018.

Proposed Timings Mundakayam Pulikkunnu Erumely A D A D A D 6.27am 7.00 7.52 7.19 7.55 8.28 9.11 8.40 9.23 9.56 11.23 10.50 11.37 12.10 1.18 12.45 1.30 1.48 2.10 1.52 2.15 2.48 3.58 3.25 4.00 4.18 4.45 4.27 5.00 5.33 6.25 5.52 6.35 7.08 8.13pm[Halt] 7.40

Notes- This is an application for the grant of a of a fresh regular permit to SC KL 24 C 4696 / another suitable vehicle to operate on the route MUNDAKAYAM – ERUMELY via, Pulikkunnu, Kannimala, Peruthodu with two cut trips between Mundakayam - Pulikkunnu as Ordinary Service.

The enquiry report of MVI Kanjirappally revealed the following.

1. Total distance of the route : 13.45 Kms.

2. Intra/ Inter District route : Intra District.

3. Details of Virgin Portion : Nil

4. Details of Road Fitness certificate : N A.

5. Details of Overlapping : Total overlapping is 150meter ie, 1.12 % of the total route length [13.45 km] which is within the permissible limit.

1) Route portion of 150meter from Mundakayam Bus Stand to COSWAY Jn. objectionably overlaps on Ernakulam – Thekkady notified Scheme 42/2009 Trans dtd 14/07/2009.

6. Details of Vehicle produced : KL 24 C 4696 / another suitable vehicle owned by the applicant. 7. Details of Concurrence :N A.

8. Necessity, recommendation if any : Enquiry officer reported that if the permit is granted, it will beneficial to the public and students who live in this area. The said permit is more beneficial to the Sabarimala pilgrims in Sabarimala Season. 9. Court Direction, if any : Nil.

10. Other relevant points : There is no direct time clash noticed. However timings may settled after conducting Timing conference. 11. Type of road : Entire road has sufficient width for stage carriage service.

RTA may hear the applicant, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No.04 G1/1758/2018/K

Agenda-To consider the application for the grant of fresh regular permit to SC KL 35 B 4025 / another suitable vehicle to operate on the route PONKUNNAM – ETTUMANOOR via, 1st Mile, Thachapuzha, Neyyattussery, Elampally, Anickadu, Pallickathodu, Kooropada, Lakkattoor Jn., Puthukulam, Ayarkunnam, Thiruvanchoor, Poovathummoodu, Peroor as Ordinary Service.

Applicant- Sri. Philip C John, Chirackal [H], Lakkattoor P O, Kottayam. dtd 11/01/2018.

Proposed Timings Ponkunnam Pallickathodu Ayarkkunnam Ettumanoor A D A P D A P D A D 6.45am 7.17 7.20 7.50 8.50 8.20 9.55 9.25 8.53 10.05 10.35 11.07 11.10 11.40 1.10 12.40 2.25 1.55 1.23 2.40 3.10 3.42 4.12 5.05 4.35

Notes- This is an application for the grant of a of a fresh regular permit to SC KL 35 B 4025 / another suitable vehicle to operate on the route PONKUNNAM – ETTUMANOOR via, 1st Mile, Thachapuzha, Neyyattussery, Elampally, Anickadu, Pallickathodu, Kooropada, Lakkattoor Jn., Puthukulam, Ayarkunnam, Thiruvanchoor, Poovathummoodu, Peroor as Ordinary Service.

The enquiry report of MVI Kottayam revealed the following.

1. Total distance of the route : 37 Kms. [Daily Mileage 222 kms]

2. Intra/ Inter District route : Intra District.

3. Details of Virgin Portion : Nil

4. Details of Road Fitness certificate : N A.

5. Details of Overlapping : Total overlapping is 400 meter ie, 1.08 % of the total route length [37 km] which is within the permissible limit.

1) Route portion of 150meter from Peroor Jn. to Ettumanoor objectionably overlaps on Kottayam – Kattappana notified Scheme 42/2009 Trans dtd 14/07/2009. 2) Route portion of 50 meters from Ponkunnam to Ponkunnam Bus Stand Objectionably overlaps on Kottayam – Thekkady and Ernakulam – Thekkady scheme 42/2009 Trans dtd 14/07/2009.

6. Details of Vehicle produced : KL 35 B 4025 / another suitable vehicle owned by the applicant. 7. Details of Concurrence :N A.

8. Necessity, recommendation if any : Enquiry officer reported that if the permit is granted, it will beneficial to the public and students who live in this area. 9. Court Direction, if any : Nil.

10. Other relevant points : There is no direct time clash noticed. However timings may settled after conducting Timing conference. 11. Type of road : Satisfactory

RTA may hear the applicant, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No.05 G1/2218/2018/K

Agenda-1) To peruse the Judgment in WP[c] No 42129 of 2017 of Honorable High Court of Kerala.

2.To reconsider the application for the re issue of a 04 months Temporary permit U/S 87(1) c of MV Act to SC KL 05 V 2963 to operate on the route S N Puram - Kottayam Via Kooroppada, Lakkattoor, Kothamangalapady, Poothirickal, Oravackal, Manrcadu and Kanjikuzhy in the vacancy of a defaulted service.

Applicant- Smt. Suma Lalu, Pareparambil,S N Puram P O,Kottayam.

Notes- On 04/08/2001, Smt. Suma Lalu was applied for the grant of fresh regular permit/04 months TP to operate on the route S N Puram - Kottayam Via Kooroppada, Lakkattoor, Kothamangalapady, Poothirickal, Oravackal, Manrcadu and Kanjikuzhy in the vacancy of a defaulted service to his vehicle KL 05 D 3060.The regular permit application submitted by the applicant has rejected by the RTA Kottayam held on 07/08/2007 stating that the applied route objectionably overlaps for a distance of 08 Kms from Kottayam to Manarcadu on the notified Ernakulam-Thekkady and Kottayam-Thekkady Scheme. There after the applicant had been operated on this route on the strength of TP issued U/S 104 of MV Act with his various vehicle. Later application for the re issue of TP U/S 104 of MV Act submitted by the R/O of SC KL 05 V 2963 has been rejected by the RTA Kottayam held on 16/11/2013 stating the following reason.

“Heard. This is an application for the re issue of 04 months TP U/S 104 of MV Act in respect of SC KL 05 V 2963 to operate on the route S N Puram-Kottayam.As per Judgment of Honorable High Court of Kerala in WA No.1943/2012 and 1957 of 2012 dated 23/08/2013, wherein the Division Bench has pointed out that on the basis of Judgment of Honorable Supreme Court in UP State RTC Vs Sanjitha Bhanu & others(2005 KHC1697 & 2005(10) SCC 250),that the private stage carriage operators have no right to claim any grant of stage carriage temporary permits on the notified route or portions thereof. It has ordered that once the scheme is in force and the overlapping is permitted only to a certain extent, it is not possible to grant temporary permit based on the proviso to Section 104 of the MV Act. The benefit of the proviso to section 104 can be granted only in instances where there is no scheme and where no permits have been issued in such route. The proviso to section 104 cannot have any independent application and it is subject to the scheme framed by the Govt.in nationalized routes.

In this case the applied route is of 22 Kms. 08 Kms of the route portion from Kottayam to Manarcadu overlaps on the notified Ernakulam-Thekkady and Kottayam-Thekkady Scheme. KSRTC vehemently objected the grant. Hence rejected.”

Then the vehicle has been operating on this route on the strength of temporary permit issued by the RTA Kottayam dated 14/08/2014. On the expiry of that temporary permit applicant produced a copy of the Judgment of the Honorable HC of Kerala in WPC No.35478/2014 dated 30/12/2014, in which it is ordered to re issue TP for 04 months, within one week from the date of production of the order, subject to preferential claim, if any. In order to comply the order within the time frame, Sy, RTA granted TP for 04 months to SC KL 05 V 2963 which is valid up to 21/05/2015. There after the vehicle has been operating on the strength of Temporary permit granted by the RTA Kottayam U/S 87(1) c of MV Act. Existing TP covered with the vehicle issued as per the decision of the RTA dated 25/07/2017 is valid till 29/12/2017. On 25/10/2017, the petitioner submitted an application for the re issue of a 04 months Temporary permit U/S 87(1) c of MV Act, from the date of expiry of the existing TP. MVI Kottayam reported that no necessity U/S 87(1) c of MV Act. Meanwhile the Division Bench of the Honorable High Court of Kerala has pronounced a Judgment in W.A.No.993 of 2017 dtd 15/06/2017 and in WP[c] No 30359/2017 (S) dtd 17/10/2017 clearly ordered that no temporary permit shall be granted U/S 87[1][b] and [c] of MV Act. The said application was placed before the RTA Kottayam, and the RTA considered the application at sitting dtd 30/11/2017 took the following decision in vide ORDER NO G1/117461/2017/K DTD 30/11/2017. “Heard the learned counsel represented the applicant. Considered the application for the re issue of 04 months TP U/S 87(1) C of MV Act to SC KL 05 V 2963 to operate on the route S N Puram - Kottayam Via Kooroppada, Lakkattoor, Kothamangalapady, Poothirickal, Oravackal, Manrcadu and Kanjikuzhy in the vacancy of a defaulted service. KSRTC vehemently objected the grant. Moreover, Judgment dtd 17/10/2017 in WP[c] No 30359/2017 and WA No 993/2017 dtd 15/06/2017 of Division bench of Honorable High Court of Kerala ordered that not to grant temporary permit U/S 87[1][a], [b] [c] of MV Act. Hence the application for temporary permit for 4 months U/S 87 [1][c] to SC KL 05 V 2963 to operate on the above route is rejected”

On 09/02/2018 a judgment in WP[c] No 42129/2017 of Honorable High Courtof Kerala has been received. In which the Honorable single Judge finds that the request made by the petitioner for re-issue of temporary permit requires re-consideration at the hands of 2nd respondent [RTA Kottayam], and the said respondent has to pass a reasoned order, taking note of the law laid down by this Court in the decisions referred to supra. In this result, the writ petition disposed of, setting aside Ext P2 Order [Decision of RTA Kottayam dtd 30/11/2017] of the 2nd respondent, dated 30/11/2017 and the said respondent is directed to re consider the matter with notice to the petitioner and also to the KSRTC, taking note of the law laid down by this court in the decisions referred to supra. A decision in its regard shall be taken, as expeditiously as possible, at any rate within a period of three weeks from the date of receipts of a certified copy of the judgment.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant peruse the judgment and take a decision.

Item No-06 G1/15081/2017/K

Agenda:-1.To peruse the Judgment dtd 02/12/2016 in WP[c] No 20524/2012 of Honorable High Court of Kerala. 2.To consider the request for issue granted fresh regular permit by the RTA Kottayam dtd 22/05/2012 on the route Paruthumpara – Kottayam via, Chozhiyackadu, Parackalkadavu, Nalkavala, Devalokam, Kanjikuzhy, Collectorate, Logos Jn., Old Bus Stand, and return through Kanjikuzhy, Devalokam, Nalkavala, Parackalkadavu, and Chozhiyackadu to leased S/C KL 05 S 9792.

Applicant:-Smt. Sheeja Thomas, THakadiyelparambil, Channanickadu, Kottayam dtd 05/12/2017.

Notes:- Smt. Sheeja Thomnas, Thakidiyelparambil, CHannanickadu, Kottyam had filed an application for the grant of regular permit on the route Paruthumpara – Kottayam, which was placed before the RTA Kottayam dtd 09/07/2008. The Honorable High Court of Kerala vide Judgment in Wp[c] No 5616/2008 dtd 17/03/2008 had ordered to grant the permit. In the light of the judgment, the RTA considered the application as vide Item No 15 and granted regular permit applied for subject to settlement of timings. The decision of the RTA dtd 09/07/2008 was communicated to the applicant on 30/09/2008. But the while typing the decision the Item No 15, decision of item No 17 was typed and communicated to the applicant as follows. “Heard. 1.Perused. 2.Adjourned. The Secretary RTA is directed to enquire and report violation of scheme any after the modification of route.” RTA Kottayam dtd 22/05/2012 was rectified the mistake happened and granted regular permit on the route Paruthumpara – Kottayam subject to settlement of timings. The decision of the RTA Kottayam dtd 22/05/2012 was communicated to the applicant and the grantee has requested that she needs more time for the production of current records for obtaining the regular permit granted to her. This request was considered by the RTA Kottayam dtd 21/07/2012 granted extension of time for producing current records as per Rule 159[2] of KMV Rules for a period of 4 months from 18/06/2012. Another operator in this sector Smt. Sindhu George, Vakkaparambil [H], Kollad P O, Kottayam has filed a WP[c] No 20524/2012 before Honorable High Court of Kerala on 03/09/2012. The Honorable Court dismissed the case on 02/12/2016 as follows. “The writ petition is filed by a stage carriage operator having a regular permit till 24/08/2016 on the route Paruthumpara – Kottayam. She has approached this Court aggrieved by Ext P6 decision of the RTA Kottayam dtd 22/05/2012. Considering the fact that the regular permit issued to the petitioner has already expired and also taking note of the fact that the remedy of the petitioner is to seek settlement of timings if the petitioner has any other grievances, this court is of the view that the writ petition shall be dismissed leaving open all the issues. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.” On 05/12/2017 Smt. Sheeja Thomas stated that the regular permit was not issued since the Honorable Court was issued a stay. Hence she has requested to issue regular permit on leased vehicle KL 05 S 9792 after settling the timings. But no records ie, RC, IC, CF of S/C KL 05 S 9792 was produced. A lease agreement executed is also produced. S/C KL 05 S 9792 is 48 seated stage carriage with a registration date of 03/02/2005 owned by Sri. Anilkumar, Kurisinchira [H],Pulikkuttissery, Kottayam. The RTA Kottayam dtd 30/11/2017 taken a decision in vide item No 102 that the age limit for the stage carriages in applying and grant fresh regular stage carriage permits as 8 years for Ordinary stage carriages. In this case, the offered vehicle has 13 years of age now.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant, peruse the judgment and take a decision.

Item No-07 G1/15262/2017/K

Agenda - To consider the request of RTA Idukki for the concurrence for the grant of Fresh Permit in respect of stage carriage KL-38-D-2149 for operating on the route Karimkunnam – Koothattukulam Via Purappuzha Health Centre, Kodikuthy, Kuninji, Chennaparampu, Kundur Mana Jn., Poovakkulam, Karamala, Mangattuthazham L P School Jn., as Ordinary Service.

Ref; Proceedings of the RTA Idukki dtd 13/10/2017.( Item No.05).

Notes:-

RTA, Idukki has requested concurrence of this RTA for Fresh Regular Permit in respect of stage carriage KL-38-D-2149 operating on the route Karimkunnam – Koothattukulam Via Purappuzha Health Centre, Kodikuthy, Kuninji, Chennaparampu, Kundur Mana Jn., Poovakkulam, Karamala, Mangattuthazham L P School Jn., as Ordinary Service since.

Enquiry report submitted by the MVI, Uzhavoor reveals the following.

1. Route length in Kottayam District : 3.3 km from Choozhikkara – Manjinikkarappady via, Moolakkattu Kavala and Poovakkulam School Jn..

2, Virgin portion if any :From Choozhikkara to Moolakkulam Kavala 1.00 kms is virgin. Road Fitness may be obtained from the competent Authority.

3, Details of overlapping : Nil.

4, Details of width of the road : Width of the road from Choozhikkara to Moolakkattu Kavala seen comparatively less, which are sufficient for one side travel of Heavy Vehicles only.

5, Other relevant Points : The portion from Choozhikkara to Moolakkattu Kavala is virgin with comparatively less width and it can be develop by the concerned authority with the sufficient width for two way traffic of Heavy Vehicles by clearing the edges of the existing roads. Fitness certificate of the roads in this Virgin portion [1 km] may be obtained from the concerned competent Authority. The proposed route is passing through the area of Ordinary common public and it will decrease the efforts of the citizens both physically and economically.

Hence RTA may peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-08 G1/15265/2017/K

Agenda - To consider the request of RTA Idukki for the concurrence for the Renewal of Permit in respect of stage carriage KL-27-5818 operating on the route Changanacherry – Nedumkandam Via Karukachal, Ponkunnam, Mundakayam, Kuttikkanam, Elappara, Puliyanmala, Pampadumpara as LSOS

Ref: Proceedings of the RTA Idukki dtd 13/10/2017.( Item No.07).

Notes:- RTA, Idukki has requested concurrence of this RTA for the Renewal of permit in respect of stage carriage KL-27-5818 operating on the route Changanacherry – Nedumkandam Via Karukachal, Ponkunnam, Mundakayam, Kuttikkanam, Elappara, Puliyanmala, Pampadumpara as LSOS. Enquiry report submitted by the MVI, Changanacherry reveals the following.

1. Route length in Kottayam District : 54.5 kms (Chanaganacherry to Mundakayam via, 14TH Mile, Ponkunnam, Kanjirappally and 26TH Mile)

2, Virgin portion if any : Nil

3, Details of overlapping : 54.5 KM.

Overlapping Scheme/Notification No Violation if any Whether Distance Objectionable 24 km from Trivandrum – Thekkady via CHRY Yes Yes Changanacherry to 23861/TB3/66PW dtd 10/10/1966 14th Mile and CHRY – CHRY Circular GO[MS] 146/67/PW dtd 20/07/1967 18 km from 14th Trivandrum – Thekkady and CHRY – Yes Yes Mile to 26th Mile CHRY Circular and Kottayam – Thekkady and Ernakulam – Thekkady 26929/TB3/66/PW dtd 12/10/1996 12.5 km from 26th Trivandrum – Thekkady via CHRY Yes Yes Mile to and Kottayam – Thekkady, Mundakayam Ernakulam – Thekkady. Bridge

4, Details of width of the road : CHRY – Kurisummoodu lies in Municipal Limit. Kurisummoodu lies in double lane traffic. Kurisummoodu to Mundakayam is in double line traffic.

5, Other relevant Points : Nil.

Hence RTA may peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-09 G1/15261/2017/K

Agenda - To consider the request of RTA Idukki for the concurrence for the Renewal of Permit in respect of stage carriage KL-33-E-1720 operating on the route Changanacherry – Murikkassery Via Karukachal, 14th Mile, Ponkunnam, Mundakayam, Kuttikkanam, Elappara, Puliyanmala, Pampadumpara as FP. Ref: 1.Proceedings of the RTA Idukki dtd 13/10/2017.( Item No.07). 2. RTA Idukki dtd 13/10/2017 granted Variation of permit as Changanacherry – Kattappana as LSOS.

Notes:- RTA, Idukki has requested concurrence of this RTA for the Renewal of permit in respect of stage carriage KL-33-E-1720 operating on the route Changanacherry – Murikkassery Via Karukachal, 14th Mile, Ponkunnam, Mundakayam, Kuttikkanam, Elappara, Puliyanmala, Pampadumpara as FP. Enquiry report submitted by the MVI, Changanacherry reveals the following.

1. Route length in Kottayam District : 54.5 kms (Chanaganacherry to Mundakayam via, 14TH Mile, Ponkunnam, Kanjirappally and 26TH Mile)

2, Virgin portion if any : Nil

3, Details of overlapping : 54.5 KM.

4, Details of width of the road : CHRY – Kurisummoodu lies in Municipal Limit. Kurisummoodu lies in double lane traffic. Kurisummoodu to Mundakayam is in double line traffic.

5, Other relevant Points : RTA Idukki dtd 13/10/2017 has granted Variation of permit as Changanacherry – Kattappana as LSOS following to the insertion of Rule 2[oa] in KMV Rules 1989.

Hence RTA may peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-10 G1/1145/2018/K

Agenda - To consider the request of RTA Idukki for the concurrence for the Renewal of Permit in respect of stage carriage KL 69 8494 operating on the route Chemmannar - Kottayam via Udumbanchola, Nedumkandam, Balagram, Puliyanmala, Kattappana, Kuttickanam, Mundakayam Ponkunnam, 14th Mile, Pampady as LSOS

Ref: Proceedings of the RTA Idukki dtd 04/04/2017.( Item No.29).

Notes:-

RTA, Idukki has requested for concurrence of this RTA for Renewal Regular Permit for operating on the route Chemmannar - Kottayam via Udumbanchola, Nedumkandam, Balagram, Puliyanmala, Kattappana, Kuttickanam, Mundakayam Ponkunnam, 14th Mile, Pampady as LSOS. Enquiry report submitted by the MVI, Kottayam reveals the following.

1. Route length in Kottayam District : 52.6 kms (Mundakayam Bridge to Kottayam via, 14TH Mile, Ponkunnam, Kanjirappally and 26TH Mile)

2, Virgin portion if any : Nil

3, Details of overlapping : 52.6 KM. from Mundakayam Bridge to Kottayam objectionably overlaps on Trivandrum – Thekkady via CHRY 23861/TB3/66PW dtd 10/10/1966 and CHRY – CHRY Circular GO[MS] 146/67/PW dtd 20/07/1967 Kottayam – Thekkady and Ernakulam – Thekkady 26929/TB3/66/PW dtd 12/10/1996 schemes.

4, Details of width of the road : Mundakayam Bridge to Kottayam is in double line traffic.

5, Other relevant Points : Nil.

Hence RTA may peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-11 G1/140870/2017/K

Agenda - To consider the request of RTA Idukki for the concurrence for the Variation Permit in respect of stage carriage KL-05-AK-2920 operating on the route Pachady – Ambika Market as LSOS as Nedumkandam – Kottayam via, Rajakkad, Kattappana, Elappara, Mundakayam, Ponkunnam as LSOS

Ref; Proceedings of the RTA Idukki dtd 13/10/2017.(Item No.36).

Notes:-

RTA, Idukki has requested concurrence of this RTA for Variation of regular Permit in respect of stage carriage KL-05-AK-2920 on the route Pachady – Ambikamarket as LSOS for operating as Nedumkandam – Kottayam via Rajakkad, Kattappana, Elappara, Mundakayam, Ponkunnam as LSOS ie, curtailment of the route from Pachady to Nedumkandam and Kottayam to Ambika Market via Kumarakom.

A detailed enquiry report may be called for from the MVI Kottayam.

Enquiry report submitted by the MVI, Kottayam reveals the following.

1. Route length in Kottayam District : 76kms (Mundakayam Bridge to Ambika Market]

2, Virgin portion if any :Nil

3, Details of overlapping : 0.2 KM.

The route portion from Mundakayam Bridge to Kottayam [52.5 km] objectionably overlaps on Kottayam – Thekkady & Ernakulam – Thekkady scheme GO[MS] 146/67/PW dtd 20/07/1967 and Changanacherry – Changanacherry Circular scheme. and 26929/TB3/66/PW dtd 12/10/1966.

4, Details of width of the road : Not mentioned in the report by MVI

5, Other relevant Points : Curtailment portion from Kottayam to Ambika Market [23.5kms]. The proposed Curtailment does not affect the passengers, since sufficient services, both KSRTC and Pvt services available in the curtailing portion.

Hence RTA may peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-12 C1/10607/2018/K

Agenda:-To consider the application for renewal of permit in respect of S/C KL 05 Q 1801 on the route Kodungoor – Pala Via, Chamampathal, Thekkethukavala, Ponkunnam , Koorali, Vanchimala, Paika,and Kadayam as ordinary service for a further period of 5 years from the date of expiry [Permit issued after 14/07/2009].

Applicant –Sri. Biju Thomas, Moloparambil House, Thodanal P.O, Poovarany, , Kottayam

(a)Regular permit valid up to :01/05/2018

(b)Date of filing the application :30/01/2018

(d) Permit No :5/1319/2013

Notes:- S/C KL 05 Q 1801 conducts regular stage carriage serv ice on the route Koungoor – Pala Via, Chamampathal, Thekkethukavala, Ponkunnam , Koorali, Vanchimala, Paika,and Kadayam as ordinary service on the strength of regular permit valid up to 01/05/2018 .The permit holder has applied for renewal of regular permit for a further period of 5 years from the date of expiry [ Permit No.5/1319/2013]

Details of route as follows

1. Total distance of the route : 38.8 Kms 2. Intra/Inter district route : Intra district route 3. Details of concurrence : Nil 4. Details of Overlapping : 1.500kms in Kottayam – Kattappana scheme

and 100Mts in Ernakulam – Thekkady Scheme

From Pala Jun. to Ponkunnamto Ponkunnam BS

5. Violation if any :-NIL 6. Whether objectionable overlapping :-No 7. Inter mediate points in the overlapiing Portion :- Kottaramattom B S to Muncipal Complex jn. Pala and Pala Jn .PNKM to Ponkunnam B S 8. Details of HPA and NOC from the finance Co.:-Nil 9. Court Directions if any :-Nil 10. Other relevant Points :-This permit is issued after 14/07/2009. Total over lapping is 1.600Kms ie , 4.1 % of total route length [38.8KM] which is below Less than 5% and is under permissible limit.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant, Peruse the file and take a decision . Item No-13 C2/119041/2017/K

Agenda: To consider the application for renewal of permit in respect of S/C KL 34 A 5609 on the route Chenappady - Thevaruppara via, Pallippady, Anjillippa, Kanjirappally, Anakkal, Kappadu, Pinnakkanadu, Thidanadu, Erattupetta, Teekoy Panchayathupady, Njandukallu as ordinary service for a further period of 5 years from the date of expiry.[permit issued after 14/07/2009]

Applicant – Sri. T K Abdul Salam, Thenammackal house, Kanjirappally P O, Kottayam

(a) Regular Permit valid up to :08/11/2017

(b) Temporary Permit valid up to :08/03/2018 [u/s 87[1][d]]

(d) Date of issue : 09/11/2012.

Notes: S/C KL 34 A 5609 conducts regular stage carriage service on the route Chenappady - Thevaruppara via, Pallippady, Anjillippa, Kanjirappally, Anakkallu, Kappadu, Pinnakkanadu, Thidanadu, Erattupetta, Teekoy Panchayathupady, Njandukallu as ordinary service on the strength of regular pemit valid upto 08/11/2017 and temporary permit valid upto 08/03/2018 u/s 87[1][d]. The permit holder has applied for renewal of regular permit for a further period of 5 years from the date of expiry. [ Permit No. 5/3551/2012] Details of the route as follows.

1.Total distance of the route :38.4 kms.

2.Intra/Inter district route : Intra district.

3.Details of concurrence : N.A.

4.Details of Overlapping : Petta Jn. to Kanjirappally Bus Stand -300 Mts. [Ernakulam - Thekkady Scheme Total overlapping – 300 Mts.

5. Details of HPA and NOC from

finance company : Nil.

6. Court direction if any : Nil

7. Other relevant points : This permit is issued after 14/07/2009. Total

overlapping is 0.3 km. i.e, 0.78 % of total length

[ 38.4 k.m] which is under permissible limit.

Hence, RTA may hear the applicant, peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-14 C3/49538/2017/K

Agenda:- 1. To reconsider the application for renewal of permit in respect of S/C KL-33-D-7535 on the route Kumily - Medical College Via Periyar, Kuttikanam, Mundakayam, Kanjirapally, Ponkunnam,14th Mile, Pampady, Kottayam, & Ghandinagar as LSOS for a further period of 5 years from the date of expiry.

Applicant:-Sri. Vitty Thomas,Kondodickal[H],Umbidy.P.O,Changanacherry

a. Regular permit valid up to : 26/06/2017 b. Date of filing application : 28/04/2017 c. T.P. u/s 87(1) d : 26/02/2018 d. Permit issued on : 27/06/1998[Saved Permit]

Notes:-S/C KL-33-D-7535 is conducting regular stage carriage service on the route Kumily - Medical College – Details of the route as follows.

1. Total distance of the route : 119 kms 2. Intra/Inter district route : Inter district [in Kottayam Dist-61 km Idukki Dist-58 kms] 3. Details of concurrence : Concurrence received from RTA, Idukki and granted in supplementary Item No.10 Order No.G/4310/2016/ID dtd 13.10.2017

4. Details of overlapping : Gandhinagar To Kumaly at a distance of 117 km overlapping Ernakulam –Thekkady Scheme 5. Details of HPA and NOC from Finance company : Nil

6. Court direction if any : No

7. Other relevant points : This permit issued prior to 14/07/2009.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant, peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-15 C1/ 54398/2017/K

Agenda:- 1.To Re consider the application for variation of regular permit in respect of KL 05 AE 3285 as LSOS on the route CHERTHALA - KALOOR BUS STAND VIA, KIAPUZHAMUTTU, ALUMMOODU, GANDHINAGAR, MEDICAL COLLEGE, MG UNIVERSITY,ATHIRAMPUZHA, ETTUMANOOR, KANAKKARI, KURUPPANTHARA, CEYLON JUNCTION, THALAYOLAPARAMBU, KANJIRAMATTTOM , PUTHENKAVU, TRIPUNITHURA,VYTILA, PALLIMUKKU, JETTY & MENAKA AS FAST PASSENGER . Variation of permit as CHERTHALA –KALOOR BS by converting the service as LSOS

Applicant:-Sri.Thankachan Valel, Nattassery, S H Mount P.O, Kottayam (a) Regular Permit valid up to :25/06/2016 (b) Date of filing application :31/05/2016 (c) Temporary permit valid up to :25/02/2018 (d) Permit No :05/103/1991 [Saved Permit] Existing Timings CHERTHALA KAIPUZHAMUTTU KOTTAYAM THALAYOLAPARAMBU VYTILA HUB A D A P D A p D A P D A D 4.25AM 5.05 6.15 7.16 10.36 9.56 8.46 7.45 10.38 11.13 11.20 12.30 01.31 4.17 3.16 5.30 4.20 5.35 6.43 6.15 7.15 7.43HALT

Proposed Timings CHERTHALA KAIPUZHAMUTTU KOTTAYAM THALAYOLAPARAMBU VYTILA HUB A D A P D A P D A P D A D 4.25 5.05 6.15 7.16 9.56 8.46 7.45 10.36 10.38 11.13 11.20 12.30 1.31 5.30 4.20 3.16 6.43 6.15 5.35 7.15 7.43 [halt]

Notes:- S/C KL 05 AE 3285 conducts regular stage carriage service on the route CHERTHALA-KALOOR BUS STAND VIA, KIAPUZHAMUTTU,ALUMMOODU, GANDHINAGAR, MEDICAL COLLEGE, MG UNIVERSITY,ATHIRAMPUZHA, ETTUMANOOR, KANAKKARI,KURUPPANTHARA, CEYLON JUNCTION, THALAYOLAPARAMBU, KANJIRAMATTTOM , PUTHENKAVU, TRIPUNITHURA,VYTILA, PALLIMUKKU, JETTY & MENAKA AS FAST PASSENGER with a valid regular permit up to 25/06/2016 and settled set of timings. [The permit is issued before 09/05/2006 as fast passenger. While the permit expired on 25/06/2016There after the permit is not renewed since GOP No 73/12 dtd 16/7/2013 the private operators are permitted to operate their higher class service till the expiry of their respective permit .The permit holder submitted application for renewal of permit and variation of the permit as LSOS instead of Fast Passenger vide reference 5/63714/2016 k dated 04/06/2016.Which is placed before the RTA held on 01/09/2016 and as per the order ,since the permit is inter district route in which route portion 32 kms in the total route length lies in Ernakulam district and 8 kms in Alapuzha district. Hence it is adjourned .Consideration of application for variation is also adjourned .As per the decision of the RTA held on 02/02/2017 distance less than 50 kms do not need concurrence Hence the permit holder requested to renew the regular permit and also requested to re consider the application for variation of regular permit as CHERTHALA – KALOOR BS by converting the service as LSOS .Hence the application for conversion of class of service as LSOS is reconsidered in the RTA held on 30/11/2017 and is adjourned with directing the applicant to submit proposed timings and list of stops . Now the applicant produced the proposed timings and lists of stops

1.The enquiry report of MVI Kottayam, reveals the following facts: Total distance of the route 104.7 kms[Kottayam-64.7kms, Ernakulam 32kms, Alappuzha 8 kms]

2.Intra/ Inter district route: Inter district

3.Details of concurrence :NA

4.Details of Overlaping :46.3kms overlaps on EKM –THEKKADY scheme 2.6kms

On KTM –Neendoor Scheme

5.Details of HPA and NOC from : Having HPA and NOC Produced Finance company

6.Court direction if any : nil

7. Other relevant points : This permit is issued prior to 9/05/2006.Now the vehicle is conducting service on the strength of a 4 months temporary permit issued as per GO[MS]No 45/2015dtd 20/8/2015 .The validity of permit up to 25/02/2018

Hence RTA may hear the applicant , peruse files and take a decision in this matter .

Item No-16 C2/56019/2017/K

Agenda. To consider the adjourned application for variation of permit in respect of S/C KL 05 Z 4866 on the route Kottayam - Kattappana via, Mulakkuzha, Pakkil, Chingavanam, Kurichy Out Post, Eera, Kainady, Parakulam, Njaliyakuzhy, Thottakkad, Pampady, 14th Mile, Kanjirappally, Mundakkayam, Kuttikkanam and Elappara LSOS as Kurichy Outpost – Kattappana LSOS by curtailing the route portion from Kottayam to Kurichy Out Post to limit route length within 140 k.m in the light of 2[oa] of KMV Rules, 1989.

Applicant:- The Managing Director [Rahul Tom],Kondody Motors Pvt Ltd, Kodimatha, Kottayam

EXISTING TIMINGS

Kottayam Kainady Chingavanam Pampady Ponkunnam Mundakayam Kattappana

A D A P D A P D A P D A P D A P D A D

6.50am 7.30 8.25 9.37 9.38 10.10 10.50 11.00 1.15

5.20 4.40 2.25

6.50 5.57 5.26

7.15 6.55

8.05pm 7.25

PROPOSED TIMINGS

Kurichy Kainady Chingavanam Pampady Ponkunnam Mundakayam Kattappana

Out post

A D A P D A P D A P D A P D A P D A D

07.14 a.m 7.30 8.25 9.37 9.38 10.10 10.50 11.00 1.15

5.20 4.40 2.25

6.50 5.57 5.26

7.15 6.55

07.41 halt 7.25

(a) Regular Permit valid up to : 24/10/2011 [The R.P shall be continued to be valid till the Disposal of MP No.273/12 in MVAA No.73/ 2012 of Hon’ble STAT, Ernakulam] (b) Date of filing application : 16/05/2017

Notes:-

S/C KL 05 Z 4866 conducts regular stage carriage service on the route Kottayam - Kattappana via, Mulakkuzha, Pakkil, Chingavanam, Kurichy Out Post, Eera, Kainady, Parakulam, Njaliyakuzhy, Thottakkad, Pampady, 14th Mile, Kanjirappally, Mundakkayam, Kuttikkanam and Elappara as Limited Stop Ordinay Service with a valid regular permit and settled set of timings in vide order No C3- 19378/2004/K dtd 10/08/2007. [Pt No 5/104/2000].

Consequent to the insertion of 2 [oa] of KMV Rules 1989 as per G.O[P] No.06/2017, dated 15/03/2017, permit holder submitted an application for variation of permit Kurichy Out Post to Kattappana by curtailing the route portion from Kottayam to Kurichy Out Post.

The matter was placed before RTA at its sitting on 25/07/2017 and took the following decision.

“Heard The learned counsel represented the applicant. Considered the application for variation of regular permit in respect of S/C KL 05 Z 4866 on the route Kottayam - Kattappana via, Mulakkuzha, Pakkil, Chingavanam, Kurichy Out Post, Eera, Kainady, Parakulam, Njaliyakuzhy, Thottakkad, Pampady, 14th Mile, Kanjirappally, Mundakkayam, Kuttikkanam and Elappara as Kainady – Kattappana by curtailing the 1st trip from Kottayam to Kurichy Out Post and in the last trip from Kurichy Out Post to Kottayam and changing the halting place from Kottayam to Kurichy out post.. Perused the file and enquiry report. As per the application it is not clear that whether the applicant is intended to limit the route length up to 140 kms as prescribed in the rule 2(oa) in the KMV Rules, 1989 and in obedience with GO(P) No 8/2017/Tran dated 23/03/2017 by curtailing the route length. Secretary RTA is directed to obtain specific remarks from the applicant conducting a hearing and place before next RTA. Hence adjourned.”

As per the decision of RTA, Kottayam, the applicant was appeared and heard on 08/12/2017 and stated that he was intended to limit the total route length within 140 k.m as prescribed in the rule 2[oa] in the KMV Rules , 1989. As per the enquiry report of MVI ,Kottayam

1. The distance of existing route : 147 km

2. Intra/Inter district route : Inter district.

3. Distance in each district if the route is inter district: Kottayam -86 kms, Alappuzha-3 kms,

Idukki-58 kms

4. The distance of curtailment : 10 KM

5. The distance after Variation : 137 k.m

[a] Variation : nil

[b] Curtailment :Kottayam – Kurichy Out Post [10 kms.]

[c] Extension : Nil.

6. Distance of Variation : N A

7. The details of overlapping on varied portion: N A

8. Details of virgin portion and road fitness certificate: No

9. Whether the existing timings will be changed or not: The time change only in the curtailed portion.

10. Distance of variation on other districts : Nil.

11. Details of concurrence : N.A.

12. Necessity U/R 145[6] and 145 [7] of KMV

rules, feasibility and recommendations etc. : Nil

13. Court direction if any : Nil

14. Other relevant points if any : Enquiry officer reported as follows

The curtailment of trip on morning and evening may affect the public. Variation is necessary to limit the route length upto 140 km for limited stop ordinary service.

Hence the RTA may peruse the report of MVI, file and take a decision.

Item No-17 C3/123731/2017/K

Agenda :- To Consider the application for variation of permit in respect of S/C KL-33-8159 on the route PONKUNNAM—CHANGANASSERY Via Thekkethukavala, Poovathukavala, Manimala, Vellavoor, Kulathoormoozhy, Nedumkunnam & Karukachal as Ordinary Service Variation of permit as PONKUNNAM-- CHANGANASSERY Via Thekkethukavala, Muttathukavala, Chamampathal,Kanam CSI Church, Pazhukkakulam, Pathanad Jn, Mundanthanam, Kulathurmoozhy, Nedumkunnam & Karukachal and Thengana as Ordinary Service Ie, 1. by curtailing the route portion from Muttathukavala to Kulathoormuzhy via Manimala 2. deviating from Muttathukavala to Kulathoormuzhy via Chamampathal, Kanam CSI Church, Pazhukkakulam, Pathanad Jn, Mundanthanam.

Applicant:- Sri. Sony Kurian,Pullamkalam[H], Mamood.P.O,Changanacherry

(a) Regular Permit Issued On : 29/04/1997[Saved Permit]

(b)Regular permit valid up to : 28/04/2022

EXISTING TIMINGS

Ponkunnam Manimala Kulathoormoozhy Karukachal Changanacherry A D A P D A P D A P D A D 6.05 7.00 6.30 7.20 7.50 8.15 8.50 9.25 11.03 10.28 9.53 11.35 12.10 12.45 3.06 2.36 2.11 1.36 1.01 3.20 3.50 4.15 4.40 5.15 5.50 7.42[Halt] 7.07 6.32 PROPOSED TIMINGS

Ponkunnam Kulathoormoozhy Karukachal Changanacherry A D A P D A P D A D 6.05 7.00 7.20 8.15 8.50 9.25 11.03 10.28 9.53 11.35 12.10 12.45 3.06 2.11 1.36 1.01 3.20 4.15 4.40 5.15 5.50 7.42[Halt] 7.07 6.32

Notes:- S/C KL-33-8159 is covered by regular permit on the route PONKUNNAM—CHANGANASSERY -Via Thekkethukavala, Poovathukavala, Manimala, Vellavoor, Kulathoormoozhy, Nedumkunnam & Karukachal As Ordinary Service has applied for variation condition of regular permit As PONKUNNAM-- CHANGANASSERY- Via Thekkethukavala,Muttathukavala, Chamampathal, Kanam CSI Church, Pazhukkakulam, Pathanad Jn, Mundanthanam, Kulathurmoozhy, Nedumkunnam & Karukachal and Thengana As Ordinary Service Enquiry conducted trough JRTO ,Kanjirappally reveals the following 1. The distance of existing route : 52 Km [ Distance after variation 53.8 kms]

2. Intra/Inter district route : Inter District [KTM- 48 kms & ALPY- 4 kms]

3. Distance in each district if the route is inter district: Kottayam & Alappuzha District

4. The distance of curtailment : Yes , 16.8 kms in the present route from Muttathukavala to Thazhathu Vadakara 5. The distance of extension : 17 kms 6. The details of overlapping : Not Specified 7. Details of virgin portion and road fitness certificate: Nil

8. Whether the existing timings will be changed or not: No Changed 9. Distance of variation on other districts : Not Specified 10.Nature of service after Extension : Moffusil 11. Details of concurrence : N/A 12. Necessity U/R 145[6] of KMV rules, feasibility and recommendations etc.: The proposed variation very helpful for the travelling public ,many educational institutions and Harijan settlements are there. 13. Court direction if any : Nil 14. Other relevant points if any : Enquiry officer reported that enough services are operating through the present route ,hence paucity of travel not arise.

Hence the RTA may peruse the report, file and take a decision.

Item No-18 C3/135952/2014/K

Agenda.1. To reconsider the application for variation of permit in respect of S/C KL 38 C 7203 on the route Anakkayam - Kottayam Via Thodupuzha, Pala, Ayarkunnam, and Manarcadu with cut trip between Thodupuzha and Kottayam in the noon Thodupuzha-Kottayam by curtailing the route portion from Thodupuzha to Anakkayam in the light of the Judgment of Honorable STAT M.V.A.A No.214/2015 .(Adourned Item No.137 dtd 24.03.2015 & Rejected Item No.60 dtd 14.05.2015 )

EXISTING TIMINGS

Anakkayam Thodupuzha Pala Kottayam

A D A P D A P D A D

35 Minutes 70 minutes 70 Minutes

6.45 7.20 8.30 8.37 9.47

11.55 10.45

1.17 12.07

1.31 2.41 2.42 3.52

6.12 5.02

7.24 6.14

8.10(halt) 7.35

Applicant:- Smt. Anees John, Neerolickal House, Purapuzha P O, Thodupuzha, Idukki

(a) Regular Permit Issued On : 26/10/2001 [Saved Permit] (b) Regular Permit valid up to : 25/10/2021 (c) Date of filing application : 17/11/2014 Enquiry Report of Joint RTo, Thodupuzha dtd 12/12/2014. 1. The distance of existing route : 73Km [ Distance after variation 59km]

2. Intra/Inter district route : Inter district

3. Distance in each district if the route is inter district: Distance covered on Kottayam District is 48 KM from Kottayam to Nellappara & Idukki District 25 Kms from Nellappara to Anakkayam. 4. The distance of curtailment : Thodupuzha – Anakkayam [Total distance of curtailment 14 km] 5. The distance of extension :NIL 6. The details of overlapping : The existing route overlaps by 48.4 Kms from Kottayam to Manarcad and Kidangoor to Thodupuzha 7. Details of virgin portion and road fitness certificate: Nil 8. Whether the existing timings will be changed or not: No change in the existing portion 9. Distance of variation on other districts : 14 kms under the jurisdiction of Idukki 10. Details of concurrence : Concurrence Rejected from RTA, Idukki in Item No.46,Order No.G/3884/2017/ID dated 13/10/2017[Reason for rejection is there is no adequate travelling facility on this route . Hence curtailment of the portion from Thodupuzha to Anakkayam will adversely affect the passengers .Also a representation from Smt. Renuka Rajasekaran Councilor,Ward No.3 Thodupuzha Muncipality is received against the issuance of this concurrence] 11. Necessity U/R 145[6] of KMV rules, feasibility and recommendations etc.: The proposed curtailment portion is an ill served one and the curtailment will very adversely affect the travelling facility of the general public.

12. Court direction if any : Nil

13. Other relevant points if any : Enquiry officer specifically reported that the curtailment request is an ill served one and curtailment will very adversely affect the travelling facility of the general public. The enquiry officer also reported that the application for curtailment couldnot be recommended since there is no urge of travelling public. There is only one trip in the existing permit between Thodupuzha and Anakkayam which is an ill served area. It seems that the benefit of the curtailment is only for the permit holder . All these facts considered the RTA and decided Vide Order No.C3/135952/2014/K dated 14.05.2015 as follows ”Heard Sri. I Dinesh Menon, learnt counsel represented the applicant Smt. Anees John. Considered the application for regular variation of permit in respect of Stage Carriage KL 38 C 7203 operating on the route Anakkayam-Kottayam. Enquiry officer specifically reported that the curtailment portion is an ill served one and curtailment will adversely affect the travelling public.The enquiry officer also reported that the application for curtailment couldnot be recommended since there is no urge of travelling public. The applicant failed to establish the necessity under Rule 145 (6) of KMV Rules 1989 to grant variation. On the above mentioned facts the application for variation of permit in respect of stage carriage KL 38 C 7203 is hereby rejected.” Against this order the permit holder filed the Honorable STAT and as per the Judgment in M.V.A.A No.214/2015 as follows “The appeal is allowed and the impugned order passed by the first respondent is set aside, The first respondent shall reconsider the application for variation of permit made by the appellant after obtaining concurrence of the Regional Transport Authority of the region in which curtailment of service is sought by the appellant”

Hence the RTA may peruse the report, file and take a decision.

Item No -19 C1/104023/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 34 2979 KODUNGOOR –PALA from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Mathew , Chumappunkal house, Poovarani 2. Sri. Jibin Thomas, Padinjatedathu house, Chirakadavu, Ponkunnam Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 34 2979 Sri . Mathew , Chumappunkal house, Poovarani permitted to operate service on the route KODUNGOOR –PALA with a valid regular permit up to 07/05/2018 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on enquiry, it is found that

1. The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant. 2. The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage. 3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees. 4. The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2). 5. The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-20 C1/129647/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 05 T 803 PALA – KODUNGOOR from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.Jobi Mathew, Palaparambil House, Anickadu P.O, Kottayam 2. Sri. K K Raveendran, Varalppallil house, Anickadu P.O, Kottayam Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 05 T 803 Sri Jobi Mathew, Palaparambil House, Anickadu P.O, Kottayam permitted to operate service on the route PALA –KODUNGOOR with a valid regular permit up to 01/11/2021 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-21 C1/131120/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 67 A 2472 KOTTAYAM – ERNAKULAM from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.Tom Joseph, Chirayil House, 6th Mile, Muttuchira P.O, Kottayam 2. Sri. Jaimon Joseph, Koottumalakunnel house, Manjoor P O , Kottayam Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 67 A 2472 Sri. Tom Joseph, Chirayil House, 6th Mile, Muttuchira P.O, Kottayam permitted to operate service on the route KOTTAYAM – ERNAKULAM with a valid regular permit up to 18/08/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on enquiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-22 C1/54522/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 34 C 2656 NJADUKALLU-RANNI- ITTIYAPPARA from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.ABUDL SALAM , THENAMMAKKAL HOUSE, KANJIRAPPALLY , KOTTAYAM 2. Sri. HARISH KUMAR , THURUTHIYIL HOUSE, KIDANGOOR ,KOTTAYAM Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 34 C 2656 Sri. ABUDL SALAM , THENAMMAKKAL HOUSE, KANJIRAPPALLY , KOTTAYAM permitted to operate service on the route NJADUKALLU-RANNI- ITTIYAPPARA with a valid regular permit up to 30/11/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-23 C1/137076/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 33 B 3232 CHENAPPADY – ERATTUPETTA from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.MUHAMMED YOOSAF, CHIRAKKUZHY MANZIL , PONKUNNAM,KOTTAYAM 2. Sri. HABEEB KARIM, MADATHIL HOUSE, ANAKKALLU P.O, KANJIRAPPALLY,KOTTAYAM Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 33 B 3232 Sri MUHAMMED YOOSAF, CHIRAKKUZHY MANZIL , PONKUNNAM,KOTTAYAM permitted to operate service on the route CHENAPPADY – ERATTUPETTA with a valid regular permit up to 06/10/2019 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on enquiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-24 C1/60055/2016/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 36 C 1080 KOTTAYAM- PIRAVAM from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.TOMYCHANDY, VALIYAPARAMBIL HOUSE, THIRUVANPADY P.O, KADUTHURUTHY. 2. Sri.ARUNKUMAR,MUTHIRAKALAYIL HOUSE, PERUVA P.O,KOTTAYAM Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 36 C 1080 Sri . TOMYCHANDY, VALIYAPARAMBIL HOUSE, THIRUVANPADY P.O, KADUTHURUTHY permitted to operate service on the route KOTTAYAM – PIRAVAM with a valid regular permit up to 28/07/2018 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-25 C1/131139/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 35 G 1917 KAIPUZHAMUTTU –ERNAKULAM -KALOOR BS from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri. SHYJU MATHEW, KALLIDANTHIYIL HOUSE, ATHIRAMPUZHA P.O,KOTTAYAM 2. Sri.JAIMON JOSEPH, KUTTMALAKUNNEL HOUSE, MANJOOR P.O, KOTTAYAM Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 35 G 1917 Sri . SHYJU MATHEW, KALLIDANTHIYIL HOUSE, ATHIRAMPUZHA P.O,KOTTAYAM permitted to operate service on the route KAIPUZHAMUTTU – ERNAKULAM -KALOOR BS with a valid regular permit up to 09/11/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on enquiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-26 C1/131139/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 35 A 1589 PONGANTHANAM – ERNAKULAM from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.DAVIS GEORGE , MADAN HOUSE, ANAPPARA, ANGAMALY. 2. Sri.JAIMON JOSEPH, KUTTUMALAKUNNEL HOUSE, MANJOOR P.O, KOTTAYAM Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 35 A 1589 Sri . DAVIS GEORGE , MADAN HOUSE, ANAPPARA, ANGAMALY permitted to operate service on the route PONGANTHANAM – ERNAKULAM with a valid regular permit up to 14/09/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the Secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-27 C1/131127/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 36 A 2178 VAIKOM- KOTTAYAM- ERNAKULAM from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.TOM JOSEPH, CHIRAYIL HOUSE, 6TH MILE , MUTTUCHIRA P.O, KOTTAYAM . 2. Sri.JAIMON JOSEPH, KUTTMALAKUNNEL HOUSE, MANJOOR P.O, KOTTAYAM Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 36 A 2178 Sri . TOM JOSEPH, CHIRAYIL HOUSE, 6TH MILE , MUTTUCHIRA P.O, KOTTAYAM permitted to operate service on the route VAIKOM-KOTTAYAM- ERNAKULAM with a valid regular permit up to 06/07/2019 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-28 C1/131133/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 67 A 2152 KOTTAYAM- ERNAKULAM from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.JIMMY JOSEPH,CHIRAYIL HOUSE , . 6TH MILE , MUTTUCHIRA P.O, KOTTAYAM . 2. Sri.JAIMON JOSEPH, KUTTMALAKUNNEL HOUSE, MANJOOR P.O, KOTTAYAM

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 67 A 2152 Sri . JIMMY JOSEPH,CHIRAYIL HOUSE , . 6TH MILE , MUTTUCHIRA P.O, KOTTAYAM permitted to operate service on the route KOTTAYAM- ERNAKULAM with a valid regular permit up to 21/05/2021 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-29 C1/128251/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL -44- 8199 AYARKUNNAM –PAMPADY from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.REJI, KANNITTAYIL HOUSE, AMBALAKADAVU , KOTTAYAM 2. Smt. KANAKAMMA, PULLATTU DINESH BHAVANAM,PARAMPUZHA P.O,KOTTAYAM

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 44 8199 Sri . REJI, KANNITTAYIL HOUSE, AMBALAKADAVU , KOTTAYAM permitted to operate service on the route AYARKUNNAM- PAMPADY with a valid regular permit up to 24/7/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on enquiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-30 C1/107720/2016/K

Agenda:- 1.To peruse the Order in MVARP No. 26/2014 dtd 21/12/2017

2.To reconsider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 39 J 767 KOTTAYAM- ERNAKULAM from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1.Smt.USHASUDHAKARAN, MANCHAKATTIL HOUSE, THIRUVANKULAM P.O, ERNAKULAM

2. Sri. JAIMON JOSEPH, KUTTMALAKUNNEL HOUSE, MANJOOR P.O, KOTTAYAM

Notes:- The permit holder of S/C KL 39 J 767 Smt. USHASUDHAKARAN, MANCHAKATTIL HOUSE, THIRUVANKULAM P.O, ERNAKULAM permitted to operate service on the route KOTTAYAM- ERNAKULAM with a valid regular permit up to 20/10/2018 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit and placed before the RTA held on 02/02/2017 same is adjourned till the disposal of MP No 79/2014 IN MVARP No 26/2014 filed before Honable STAT Ernakulam .Now the permit holder produced the Order in MVARP No. 26/2014 dtd 21/12/2017.Which directs the following

‘’ In this case parties are governed Under the Hindu Sucession Act. The Hindu sucession [Kerala Amendment] Act 2015 [Act 17 of 2016] inter alia would show that any property inherited by a female from her predeceased son shall devolve, not upon the order heirs of the predeceased son shall devolve, not upon the other heirs referred to in sub –section [1] in the order specified therein, but upon the heirs of the predeceased son from who she inherited the property .Judged by the above standards , the petitioner ha s no legal right to claim any right over the permit or the bus originally belonged to the third respondents husband .The 3rd respondent and her daughters , who succeeded to the vehicle and permit, are the legal heirs in accordance with the provisions under the Hindu Succession Act. In paragraph 2 of revision petition , the petitioner admitted that Sudhakaran was registered owner an d permit holder in respect of the stage carriage KL 05 R 6212[ New Reg .kl 39 j 767], which was covered with a regular permit to operate on the route Kottayam – Ernakulam . Sudhakaran died on 22/12/2010. His mother also died on20/12/2013. There is no meaning in cotending that the petitioner who was in possession of the vehicle and who had 1/4th share in the estate of the permit holder and whose suit for partition has been pending is entitled to get the permit in his name. The order passed by the RTA granting the renewal of permit in favor of the 3rd respondent is strictly I in accordance with law. There is no illegality, irregularity or impropriety in the impunged order. The revision petition is devoid of any merit and is liable to be dismissed. In the result, the revision petition is dismissed .’’

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant. 2 The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage. 3 The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees. 4 The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2). 5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision Item No-31 C2/109424/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 07 BH 4343 on the route Muvattupuzha - Kottayam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Mathai K I, S/o Mathew Isahak, kariyancheriyil house, Mudavoor P O, Punnoppady, Muvattupuzha

2. Sri. Sheela, W/o Subramanian, Pulimoottil house, South Marady, Muvattupuzha Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 07 BH 4343 Sri Mathai K I, S/o Mathew Isahak, kariyancheriyil house, Mudavoor P O, Punnoppady, Muvattupuzha permitted to operate service on the route Muvattupuzha - Kottayam with a valid regular permit up to 07/05/2021 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1. The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant. 2 The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage. 3 The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees. 4 The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2). 5 The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-32 C2/ 127890/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 05 Q 5306 on the route Kottayam - Ponganthanam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Achukutty Cherian, Puthenparambil house, Vakathanam P O, Changanacherry

2. Sri. Mathew John, S/o Yohannan, Kollarattu house, Vakathanam, Changanacherry Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 05 Q 5306 Sri Achukutty Cherian, Puthenparambil house, Vakathanam P O, Changanacherry permitted to operate service on the route Kottayam - Ponganthanam with a valid regular permit up to 27/01/2023 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-33 C2/ 13421/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 34 B 6014 on the route Kottayam - Elamkadu from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Alphy Benny, Pothiyittel house, Pakalomattam, Kuravilangadu, Kottayam 2. Sri. Dalvin Kuriakose, S/o Kuriakose K V, Puthuparambil house, Pampady P O, Kottayam Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 34 B 6014 Sri Alphy Benny, Pothiyittel house, Pakalomattam, Kuravilangadu, Kottayam permitted to operate service on the route Kottayam - Elamkadu with a valid regular permit up to 17/04/2018 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-34 C2/ 131113/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 63 D 4280 on the route Pallikkadavu – Ernakulam Kaloor from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.Davis George, S/o Vareed, Madan House, Anappara P O, Angamaly 2. Sri. Jaimon Joseph, Koottumalakunnel house, Manjoor P O, Kurppumthara Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 63 D 4280 Sri Davis George, S/o Vareed, Madan House, Anappara P O, Angamaly permitted to operate service on the route Pallikkadavu – Ernakulam Kaloor with a valid regular permit up to 25/04/2021 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-35 C2/ 131126/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 63 D 3593 on the route Thiruvalla – Ernakulam Kaloor B S from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.Davis George, S/o Paulo Vareed, Madan House, Anappara P O, Angamaly 2. Sri. Jaimon Joseph, Koottumalakunnel house, Manjoor P O, Kurppumthara Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 63 D 3593 Sri Davis George, S/o Paulo Vareed, Madan House, Anappara P O, Angamaly permitted to operate service on the route Thiruvalla – Ernakulam Kaloor B S with a valid regular permit up to 19/06/2021 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-36 C2/ 131135/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 40 K 4595 on the route Thiruvarppu Temple – Ernakulam Kaloor B S from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri.Binoy M Jacob, S/o Jacob, Mattakkattil house, Vilangu P O, Kizhakkambalam, Ernakulam 2. Sri. Jaimon Joseph, Koottumalakunnel house, Manjoor P O, Kurppumthara Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 40 K 4595 Sri Binoy M Jacob, S/o Jacob, Mattakkattil house, Vilangu P O, Kizhakkambalam, Ernakulam permitted to operate service on the route Thiruvarppu Temple – Ernakulam Kaloor B S with a valid regular permit up to 16/01/2021 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-37 C2/ 135787/2016/K

Agenda: To consider the application for condonation of delay in effecting transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 05 AF 3699 on the route Kottayam - Ambayathodu from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd .

Ref:- Decision of RTA, Dated 02/02/2017

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Shaji Kuruvilla, Susamma Vilasom, Kumarakom, Kottayam 2. Sri.Biju N M, S/o Mathai, Nellikkakudy, Kelakom P O, Kannur

Notes:-

As per the reference cited above, the following decision was taken by RTA,Kottayam at its sitting on 02/02/2017 vide Item No.55.

“Heard The learned counsel represented the transferor and the transferee. Transfer of permit in respect of the Stage Carriage KL 05 AF 3699 on Kottayam - Ambayathodu via, Medical College, University, Ettumanoor, Pala, Marangattupally, Kuruvilangadu, Kuruppunthara, Kaduthuruthy, Peruva, Neerpara,Tripunithura,Vyttila, E.K.M, Kaloor, Edapally, Koonammavu, N Paravoor, Guruvayoor, Kunnamkulam, Edapal, Kottackal, Kozhikode, Quilandy, Vadakara, Mahi, Thalassery, Koothuparampau, Mattannoor, Eritty, Keelakom and Kottiyoor Temple is allowed as applied for, subject to clearance of all government dues,if any.”

The applicants were failed to produce current records of the S/c KL 05 AF 3699 in time. The permit holder informed that the production of current records were delayed due to the delay to obtain the clearance certificate from KMTWWF Board. The clearance certificate from KMTWWF Board was issued on 07/02/18 in favour of s/c KL 05 AF 3699 and also produced the same on 08/02/2018 in this office. He also requested to condone the delay to produce the current records of the vehicle and effect transfer of permit as per the earlier decision of RTA in this matter.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-38 C2/ 64070/2016/K

Agenda: To consider the application for condonation of delay in effecting transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 36 6882 on the route Velloor Railway Station - Kottayam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd .

Ref:- Decision of RTA, Dated 01/09/2016

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Suresh, Ilavumkuzhiputhenpura house, Nechoor, Piravom 2. Sri.Mohanan M T, Moothedathu house, Mevalloor P O, Vaikom Notes:-

As per the reference cited above, the following decision was taken by RTA,Kottayam at its sitting on 01/09/2016 vide Item No.89.

“Heard The learned counsel represented the transferor and the transferee. Transfer of permit in respect of the Stage Carriage KL 36 6882 on the route Velloor Railway Station – Kottayam is allowed as applied for, subject to clearance of all government dues,if any.”

The applicants were failed to produce current records of the S/c KL 36 6882 in time. The permit holder informed that the production of current records were delayed due to the delay to obtain the clearance certificate from KMTWWF Board. The clearance certificate from KMTWWF Board was issued on 26/12/2017 in favour of s/c KL 36 6882 and also produced the same on 11/01/2018 in this office. He also requested to condone the delay to produce the current records of the vehicle and effect transfer of permit as per the earlier decision of RTA in this matter.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-39 C2/ 67525/2011/K

Agenda: To consider the application for condonation of delay in effecting transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 05 U 4425 on the route Punnathura - Kottayam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd .

Ref:- Decision of RTA, Dated 20/08/2011

Applicants:- 1. Sri. N V Ramesh, Ayodhya, Punnathura West, Ettumanoor 2. Sri.K R Gopidas, Kuttiyil house, Sreekandamangalam, Athirampuzha Notes:-

As per the reference cited above, the following decision was taken by RTA,Kottayam at its sitting on 20/08/2011 vide Item No.62.

“Heard. Allowed transfer of permit subject to clearance of government dues and production of NOC from the financier if applicable.”

The applicants were failed to produce current records of the S/c KL 05 U 4425 in time. The permit holder informed that the production of current records were delayed due to medical treatment of his wife and that arise a financial crisis to the transferee. The applicants were heard on 12/02/2018. He also requested to condone the delay to produce the current records of the vehicle and effect transfer of permit as per the earlier decision of RTA in this matter.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-40 C2/ 12805/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 35 A 4383 on the route Pala - Ponkunnam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Smt.Deepakumari, Arackaparambil house, Idamattom P O, Pala

2. Sri. Akhil A S, S/o Soman, Anakkallil house, Erathuvadakara, Vellavoor, Kottayam Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 35 A 4383 Smt.Deepakumari, Arackaparambil house, Idamattom P O, Pala permitted to operate service on the route Pala - Ponkunnam with a valid regular permit up to 17/10/2021 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-41 C2/ 12766/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of leased S/C KL 38 5758 on the route Kallara -Kottayam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Thomas Mathew, Pathiyil house, Koodalloor P O, Kottayam

2. Sri. Shiby Kurian, Pazhempallil house,Vallikkadu, Ettumanoor P O, Kottayam Notes:-

The permit holder of leased S/C KL 38 5758 Sri. Thomas Mathew, Pathiyil house, Koodalloor P O, Kottayam permitted to operate service on the route Kallara -Kottayam with a valid regular permit up to 30/10/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item N-42 C2/ 72251/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 05 AG 5970 on the route Ernakulam Kaloor - Cherthala from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Saji Joseph, Thottichirayil house, Kumarakom P O, Kottayam

2. Sri. Jaimon Joseph, Koottumalakunnel house, Manjoor P O,Kuruppumthara Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 05 AG 5970 Sri. Saji Joseph, Thottichirayil house, Kumarakom P O, Kottayam permitted to operate service on the route Ernakulam Kaloor - Cherthala with a valid regular permit up to 23/04/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-43 C2/ 145/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of leased S/C KL 35 F 4577 on the route Eranakulam Kaloor Bus Stand – Kottayam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Sri. Joseph J Pemala, Pemalaedathundathil house, Athirampuzha P O

2. Sri. Shaiju Mathew, Kallidanthiyil house, Athirampuzha P O, Kottayam Notes:-

The permit holder of leased S/C KL 35 F 4577 . Sri. Joseph J Pemala, Pemalaedathundathil house, Athirampuzha P O permitted to operate service on the route Eranakulam Kaloor Bus Stand – Kottayam with a valid regular permit up to 29/06/2018 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on equiry, it is found that

1.The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant.

2.The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3.The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4.The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2).

5.The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-44 C1/153106/2015/K

Agenda:-1.To reconsider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-34 513 PONKUNNAM- CHERUVALLY TEMPLE from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the

2.Deciison of RTA Dated 08/02/2016

Applicants:- 1. Sri.M C MICHAEL ,MANNAMPLAKKAL House, Mannarkayam , Kanjirappally,Kottayam 2. Sri. Siju P D, Pichakappallil house, Chirakadavu, East P.O,Kottayam Notes:-

As per the reference cited above, the following decision was taken by RTA, Kottayam at its sitting on 08/02/2016 vide item No.73

“Heard the permit holder. He is requested for the adjournment of the application . Hence adjourned .”

The permit holder was absent in the meeting held on 08/02/2016 . Now the permit holder requested to reconsider the application .

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision

Item No-45 C1/12799/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 35 H 1676 PALA - MANNADISSALA from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

Applicants:- 1. Smt.. Deepa Kumari .K P, Arackalparambil ,Edamattom P.O, Pala 2. Sri. Akhil S, Anakkallil house, Earathuvadakkekara P.O,Manimala Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 35 H 1676 Smt. . Deepa Kumari .K P, Arackalparambil ,Edamattom P.O, Pala permitted to operate service on the route PALA -MANNADISSALA with a valid regular permit up to 22/02/2018 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. Both the applicants were heard by the secretary RTA and on enquiry, it is found that

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-46 C3/131117/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-63-D-9089 on the route Cheepunkal – Ernakulam Kaloor from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1. Sri.Davis George, Madan House,Anappara.P.O,Elavanthy,Angamaly 2. Sri.Jaimon Joseph,Koottumalakunnel[H],Manjoor.P.O Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-63-D-9089 Sri.Davis George permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Cheepunkal – Ernakulam Kaloor with valid regular permit up to 21/06/2019 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The matter was enquired through MVI, Kottayam. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam on 14/02/2018 , on enquiry it is found that

2. The vehicle is now under control and possession of the 1st applicant. He intends to sell the vehicle to the 2nd applicant. 3. The 2nd applicant is intended to purchase the vehicle from the permit holder and he is financially sound to maintain stage carriage.

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

4. The application for transfer of permit is not violates the provisions of (a) &(b) of S.81(4] of MV Act 1988,KMV Rule 145(1,i]&178(2). 5. The joint application for transfer of permit is genuine and bonafide

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-47 C3/131148/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-63-D-9083 on the route Pallikathodu – Ernakulam Kaloor from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1.Sri.Davis George, Madan House,Anappara.P.O,Elavanthy,Angamaly 2. Sri.Jaimon Joseph,Koottumalakunnel[H],Manjoor.P.O Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-63-D-9083 Sri.Davis George permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Pallikathodu – Ernakulam Kaloor with valid regular permit up to 21/06/2019 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The matter was enquired through MVI, Kottayam. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam on 14/02/2018, on enquiry it is found that

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-48 C3/9353/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-05-U-8997 on the route Thalayolaparambu – Ullala from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1.Sri.Vinod,Pavithra Nivas,Maravanthuruthu,Vaikom 2.Sri.Manumon.T.G,Thekkeparambil[H],Kulayattikara.P.O,Kanjiramattom

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-05-U-8997 Sri.Vinod permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Thalayolaparambu – Ullala with valid regular permit up to 10/08/2021 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The matter was enquired through MVI, Kottayam. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam dated 30.01.2018 on enquiry, it is found that

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-49 C3/10465/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-05-AN-8309 on the route Vaikom – Kottayam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1.Sri.George Joseph, Plavuvachathil Kombinayil[H],Kothanalloor.P.O 2.Sri.James, Kollamppillil[H],Mulakkumlam,Vaikom

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-05-AN-8309 Sri.George Joseph permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Vaikom – Kottayam with valid regular permit up to 22/05/2018 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The matter was enquired through MVI, Kottayam. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam dated 09.02.2018 on enquiry, it is found that

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-50 C3/12650/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-05-P-8008 on the route Changanacherry – Kottayam from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1.Sri.Shijo Thampi,Ampalakadavil[H],Kurichy,Changanacherry 2. Sri. Sibi Kurian , Thyparambil[H],Mariyappally.P.O,Kottayam

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-05-P-8008 Sri. Shijo Thampi permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Changanacherry – Kottayam with valid regular permit up to 27/01/2023 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The matter was enquired through MVI, Kottayam. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam dated 06.02.2018 on enquiry, it is found that

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-51 C3/131117/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-04-AB-8947 on the route Kainady – Perunnai from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1.Sri.Manish.P.M,Pullathussery [H],Kainady,Neelamperoor,Alappuzha 2. Sri. Saju,Neduvoppil,Era,Neelamperoor[G/P],Kuttanadu

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-04-AB-8947 Sri.Manish.P.M permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Kainady – Perunnai with valid regular permit up to 17/12/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The matter was enquired through MVI, Kottayam. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam dated 11.12.2017 on enquiry, it is found that

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-52 C3/9935/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-34-E-7897[Pre.Reg.No- KL-05-X-7661] on the route Kuzhimavu – Elamkadu from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1.Sri.Jose, Nadaykkal[H],Mundakayam,Kanjirappally 2. Sri. Rajeev N Plappally, Kadampanattu Madom,Chenappady.P.O

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-34-E-7897[Pre.Reg.No-KL-05-X-7661] Sri.Jose permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Kuzhimavu – Elamkadu with valid regular permit up to 24/07/2019 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam on 30.01.2018. The matter was enquired through JRTO, Kanjirappally , it is found that

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-53 C3/89384/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-07-BS-8006 on the route Ambika Market – Ernakulam Kaloor from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1.Sri.Thankachan, Valel House, S.H.Mount.P.O,Kottayam 2. Sri. Jaimon Joseph, Koottumalakunnel[H], Manjoor.P.O,Kottayam

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-07-BS-8006 Sri.Thankachan permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Ambika Market – Ernakulam Kaloor with valid regular permit up to 18/08/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The matter was enquired through MVI, Kottayam. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam dated 17.08.2017 on enquiry, it is found that

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-54 C3/12379/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL-17-6789[ Pre.Reg .KL-05-X-8495]- on the route Medical Colleage – Vadavathor from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd applicant.

Applicants:- 1. Smt.Cinnamma Punnoose,Thamarathu[H], Pazhavangadi.P.O,Ranni 2. Sri.Bennichan,Kalapurackel,Poovanthuruthu,Kottayam

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL-17-6789[ Pre.Reg.KL-05-X-8495]- Sri.Jose permitted to operate stage carriage service on the route Medical Colleage – Vadavathor with valid regular permit up to 01/08/2020 along with the second applicant have jointly applied for the transfer of permit. The applicants appeared before Secretary RTA , Kottayam on 14.02.2018. The matter was enquired through MVI,Kottayam ,on enquiry , it is found that

3. The proposed transfer of permit is not defeat the interest of the employees.

Hence the RTA may hear the applicants, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-55. C1/40792/2017/K

Agenda:1. To consider the application for transfer of permit [Death] in respect of S/CKL 36 C 3289 on the route THALAYOLAPARAMBU-KURAVILANGADU

Applicant: Sri. PAULSON CHERIAN, THEKKEVEETTIL HOUSE, MEMURY P.O, MANJOOR , KOTTAYAM Dtd 18/04/2017

Notes:- Stage carriage KL 36 C 3289 has a valid regular permit up to 27/02/2019 on the route THALAYOLAPARAMBU-KURAVILANGADU.The permit holder Sri. PAILE KUNJU CHERIAN, THEKKEVEETTIL , MEMURY P.O, MANJOOR expired on 05/01/2017 and the death was intimated to this office in time. An application for transfer of ownership [ death] submitted on 18/04/2017 by Sri. PAULSON CHERIAN the successor of the vehicle .He has Produced legal heirship certificate issued by the Thahasildar Vaikom .Smt.Theyyamma Cheriyan and Sri . Paulson Cherian are the leagal heirs of the deceased permit holder .

The legal heirs were heard by the Secretary RTA Kottayam on 31/07/2017and the other legal heir has given consent to transfer the permit to the name of Sri. PAULSON CHERIAN. Genuiness of the application was also enquired through JRTO Uzhavoor and the same is reported to be genuine

Hence RTA may hear the applicant and take a decision

Item No-56 C3/12726/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for transfer of permit (death)in respect of S/C KL-05-AD-9865 on the route Pulickalkavala – Kottayam following the demise of the permit holder.

Permit Holder :-Sri. T.C.Jacob, Thannickal[H], Vadavathoor.P.O,Kottayam

Legal Heir :-Sri.Joseph Jacob,Thannikal[H],Vadavathoor.P.O,Kottayam

Notes

Stage carriage KL-05-AD-9865 has covered a regular permit up to 25.03.2019 on the route Pulickalkavala – Kottayam. The permit holder Sri. T.C.Jacob, Thannickal[H], Vadavathoor.P.O, Kottayam was expired on 04.04.2014 and the death was intimated in this office in time. The applicant Sri. Joseph Jacob Produced the will return by late Chacko Jacob, Thannickal[H], Vadavathoor.P.O,Kottayam dated 26/07/2013 and it was probated as L A O P No.19/2015 by the Honorable District Judge Kottayam and also produced the copy of the will. In the 3rd para of the will the testator clearly mention that his SC KL- 05-AD-9865 and its permit should go to his son Sri. Joseph Jacob .

Hence the RTA may hear the applicant, peruse the records and take a decision.

Item No-57 C1/5/138502/2017/K

Agenda: 1.To peruse the Judgment in WPC No 41937of 2017 dtd 16/01/2018

2.Consider the application for transfer of permit in respect of S/C KL 05 P 2187on the route Pala – Kanjirappally from the name of the 1st applicant to the name of the 2nd

3.To consider the actions taken on the regular permit of S/C KL 05 P 2187 on the route Pala – Kanjirappally for unauthorized change of possession of the vehicle without prior sanction of the RTA

Applicants 1. Sri. Baby Antos, Parayil House, Edamaruku P.O, PALA

2. Sri.K S Shereef, Kunnakkattu house, Erattupetta, Kottayam

Ref:- 1.Decision of RTA held on 30/11/2017 [Item No 101]

2. Judgment in WPC No 41937of 2017 dtd 16/01/2018

“The Petitioner Sri. Baby Antos is the basic permit holder. There is some disputes relating to the possession of vehicle and permit. However, the issue related to the transfer of permit and unauthorized change of possession of the vehicle KL 05 P 2187 covered by a valid regular permit without prior sanction of the RTA is clear violation and take appropriate action on regular permit. Therefore the secretary, RTA is directed to place the above matter for the consideration of RTA held on 30/11/2017 and take the following decision 1.Call original or certified copies of all the sale agreements executed with regard to the sale of vehicle between Sri. Baby Antos and Smt. Rency Noby and Sri. Noby Jose and Sri. Jojo Antony, Sri. Jojo Antony and Sri. K S Shereef etc and ascertain the authenticity of the documents and place the matter in the next sitting of this authority without fail. 2.Directed to conduct a detailed enquiry on allegation with regard to the unauthorized change of possession of vehicle and issue show cause notice to the permit holder if the unauthorized possession of the vehicle is evidenced in the original documents submitted by the objector and enquiry conducted. 3.As there is an order of the Honorable High Court to consider the application for the replacement of the vehicle subject to outcome of the OS No 201/2014 pending with Munsif Court Pala, this authority is of opinion that, it is not proper to dispose the application for the replacement during the pendency of the above suit. Hence adjourned.

Mean while on 14/12/2017 the application for transfer of permit has been submitted by the applicants and they were heard on the same day itself .Both of the applicant stated that the disputes among them regarding the possession of the vehicle and permit is compromised .

JRTO PALA has submitted interim report regarding the unauthorized possession of the vehicle and which reported that the case OS No 201/2014 is still pending before the Hon .Munciff Court Pala .In this circumstances , the permit holder has produced a Judgment in WPC No 41937of 2017 dtd 16/01/2018 , which directs to consider and pass appropriate orders on Joint application for transfer of permit made by the petitioners along with the matter already placed before the said authority regarding cancellation of the said permit with notice to the petitioners and after affording them an opportunity of being heard. A decision in this matter shall be taken, strictly in accordance with law as expeditiously as possible at any rate , within a period of one month from the date of production of a certified copy of this judgment . Also the report from JRTO Pala about the transfer of permit application it is reported that the disputes among the applicant and the pending case regarding the same is compromised and the cases were dismissed .

Hence RTA may hear the applicant peruse the file and take a decision in this matter

Item No-58 C3/3682/2017/K

Agenda:- To take action against the Permit holder of SC-KL-05-W-7799 on the route PNKUNNAM - KOTTAYAM on the incident happened at SIavaji Nagr that the crew of the vehicle absconded by stopping dangerously the vehicle at the middle of the road without going to Lakkattoor MGM NSS HSS.

Ref:- 1.Complaint of students forwarded by the Principal MGM NSS HSS Lakkattoor 2. Letter & Copy of FIR received from SI of Police , Pampady dtd 30.10.2017 3.Report received from MVI,Kottayam

Notes:

Stage carriage bearing Registration number KL-05-W-7799 was issued with regular stage carriage permit on the route PNKUNNAM-KOTTAYAM up to 13.03.2018.

AS per the letter of Sub Inspector of Police Pamapdy, on 30/10/2017 at 9.30am, the driver and the conductor of the vehicle KL 05 W 7799 on the route Ponkunnam – Kottayam was absconded by stopping dangerously the vehicle at the middle of the rod at Sivaji Nagar. There are 40 odd students and other passengers were as the passengers at that time. A crime case was registered as 1628/2017 U/S 283 IPC and 120[b] of KP Act r/w 34 IPC, and produced the vehicle before Honorable Court now keeping at Pampady Police custody. He has also reported that so many complaint was previously received at Pallickathodu Police Station against the crew of this bus for misbehavior of staff of this vehicle. Hence he has recommended action against the violation of permit condition against the permit holder of this vehicle.

The MVI ,Kottayam submitted a detailed report which states that the initial permit was issued on 14.03.2003 to SC KL-05-K-8979. The Stage Carriage KL-05-W-7799 was started service in this route from 05.02.2007 onwards. Certificate of fitness continuously issued and No mechanical defect of the vehicle noticed. The out of 2 kms only a distance of 900 meters is steep. On enquiry this vehicle can conduct service up to MGM NSS Higher Secondary School without alighting students at the bottom of the steep. The act of the crew is punishable U/R 213 of KMV Rules 1989. The permit holder has not exercised effective supervisions over the work of his employees, hence violated the conditions stipulated under sub sections 2 and 3 of KMV Rules 153.

On the basis of the report, Secretary RTA issued show cause notice to the permit holder of SC KL-05- W-7788 on 03.11.2017.The permit holder appeared before the Secretary RTA on 11.11.2017 and give an explanation for the reason of permit violation. The permit holder states that the vehicle is usually conducting service by alighting students at the bottom of the steep. On 30/10/2017, the students got angry and tried to assault the staff. So the crew was went away from the place by stopping the vehicle.

Hence RTA may peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-59 C2/7451/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for surrender of regular permit No 5/1812/2016 in respect of S/C KL 34 3895 on the route Erattupetta – Chenappady- Thampalakkad.

Applicant:-Abdul Salam T K, Thenamackel house, Pattimattom, Kanjirappally . Dtd 20/01/2018.

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 34 3895 on the route Erattupetta – Chenappady- Thampalakkad via Thidanadu, Pinnakkanadu, Kalaketty, Kappadu, Anakkullu, Kanjirappally, Kurisinkal, Anchilippa and Pallippady as Ordinary Service has requested to surrender the regular permit vide No 5/1812/2016 valid up to 10/07/2021 for cancellation. Surrender of Permit without prior intimation was compounded and collected Rs.3000/- vide receipt no.5/11789/2018,dated 02/02/2018. The applicant was heard by Secretary, RTA on 20/01/2018 and accepted the request.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant and take a decision.

Item No-60 C2/139962/2017/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for surrender of regular permit No 5/1000067/2006 in respect of S/C KL 05 AB 3699 on the route Pala – Ernakulam Kaloor Bus Stand.

Applicant:-K C Mathew, Kunnathoor house,Mevalloor P O, Vaikom . Dtd 18/12/2017.

Notes:-

The permit holder of S/C KL 05 AB 3699 on the route Pala – Ernakulam Kaloor Bus Stand via Marangattupally, Kuruvilangadu, Kuruppunthara, Kaduthuruthy, Thalayolaparambu, Kanjiramattom, Puthenkavu Thrippunithura and Vytilla as Ordinary Service has requested to surrender the regular permit, vide No 5/1000067/2006 valid up to 13/08/2016 and shall be valid till the disposal of M.P.No.104/16 of Hon’ble STAT, Ernakulam, for cancellation. Surrender of Permit without prior intimation was compounded and collected Rs.5000/- vide receipt no.5/139964/2018,dated 18/12/2017. The applicant was heard by Secretary, RTA on 18/12/2017 and accepted the request.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant and take a decision.

Item No-61 C3/4765/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for surrender of regular permit No 5/1013/2006 in respect of S/C KL-05-V-9046 on the route Kuzhimavu – Erumely .

Applicant:- Sri.Prakash.M.R, Mathiyath[H],Poonjar South.P.O Dtd 15.01.18

Notes-

The permit holder of S/C KL-05-V-9046 on the route Kuzhimavu - Erumely Via, Koruthode, Panackachira, Mundakkayam, Pulikkunnu and Kannimal with cut trip to Plappally Via Koottikkal,Mathumala & 6 Acre Colony has requested to surrender the regular permit vide No 5/1013/2006 valid up to 16/03/2021 for cancellation. Surrender of Permit without prior intimation was compounded and collected Rs.5000/- vide receipt no.5/1767/2018,dated 15/01/2018. The applicant was heard by Secretary, RTA and accepted the request.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant and take a decision.

Item No-62 C3/893/2018/K

Agenda:- To consider the application for surrender of regular permit No 5/1024/2016 in respect of S/C KL-38-B-9705 on the route Pampavally – Kanjirappally.

Applicant:- Sri.Kunjumon, Puthuparambil, Pambannar.P.O, Peermade Dtd 04.01.18

Notes-

The permit holder of S/C KL-38-B-9705 on the route Pampavally-Kanjirappally Via Mookkenpetty,Kuzhimavu Koruthode, Panakkachira, Vandanpathal, Mundakkayam, Paingana, Vellanady, Kooramthookku, Koovappally,Mannarakkayam and Kurisunkal with an additional trip to Mookkenpetty Via Kottaramkada and Paschima as ordinary service has requested to surrender the regular permit vide No 5/1024/2016 valid up to 20/04/2021 for cancellation. Surrender of Permit without prior intimation was compounded and collected Rs.5000/- vide receipt no.5/669/2018,dated 03/01/2018. The applicant was heard by Secretary, RTA and accepted the request.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant and take a decision.

Item No-63 G1/2387/2018/K

Agenda:-Implementation of traffic system in Vaikom Town for stage carriages operating through Delavakulam Bus Stand.

Ref:- 1. Order No G1/5326/2001/K dated09-10-2001 of RTA, Kottayam 2. Order No G1/8531/2013/K dated16-11-2013 of RTA, Kottayam 3. Decision taken by Vaikom Traffic Regulatory Committee during 01-06-2016, 21-04-2017, 09-05-2017. 21-06-2017 and 29-06-2017 4. Meeting conducted on 16-06-2017 in the presence of MLA Vaikom 5. Representation from Taluk Residents Association’s Apex Council Vaikom dated 18-08-2016, 4-7-2017 6. Representation from Kottayam District Private Bus operators ssociations Vaikom Unit dated 20-06-2017. 7. Representation from All Kerala Bus operators Forum Kottayam District Unit Vaikom dated 22-06-2017, 7-7-2017 8.WPC No 21514/2017 before Hon’ble High Court of Kerala and Interim order dated 30-06-2017. 9.Order No G1/8420/2017/K dtd 25/07/2017 of RTA Kottayam. 10.Decision of RTA Kottayam dtd 30/11/2017.

Notes:- RTA, Kottayam held on 9-10-2001 approved the Dalavakulam Bus stand at Kizhakkenada, Vaikom. In order to implement some traffic reforms in Vaikom Town and for start functioning of Delavakulam Bus stand, the Traffic regulatory Committee Vaikom submitted recommendations before the RTA held on 16-11-2013 a decision was taken but not implemented. So many decisions were taken by the RTA & Traffic regulatory committee Vaikom in this matter. AT last, the Traffic Regulatory Committee held on 29-06-2017 examined the representations from various organizations and scrutinized the matters relating to the implementation of the traffic reforms as follows.

1. All stage carriages coming from Ernakulam, Kottayam side should proceed through the link road and halt at Dalavakulam stand after alighting passengers in the various stops at Thekke Gopuram, Padinjare Gopuram, Kacherikavala, KSRTC, Valiyakavala. Stage carriages having only passing time shall continue their service from Dalavakulam stand. 2. Stage carriages coming from Vechoor, Alappuzha, Cherthala, Kaipuzhamuttu should operate through Padinjare Gopuram, Kacherikavala Old Stand, Valiyakavala, Link road to Dalavakulam stand and those vehicles having no passing time should continue their service. 3. Stage carriages coming from T.V Puram should operate through Kacherikavala, Old stand Valiyakavala, link road and parking at Dalavakulam stand. Those vehicles having no passing time should continue service with destination board, and others should run one round service for the convenience of passengers. 4. All buses should operate through Dalavakulam Bus stand including KSRTC, Ordinary, FP, SFP and other higher class services. 5. New bus stop is to be considered at Dalavakulam Stand for all classes of KSRTC services. 6. No entry is allowed for stage carriages and goods vehicles through link road from south to north. 7. One way system to be insisted between Kacherikavala to Thekke Gopuram except 2&3 wheelers.

RTA Kottayam at its sitting dtd 31/01/2017 took the following decision in vide Order No G1/8420/2017/K. dated 25/07/2017 the above proposal was accepted but directed Chairman Trafeic Advisary committee vaikom to report any variations needed in the proposed system after hearing all the objectors. The above decision was communicated to Joint RTO Vaikom and directed to submit report on the direction contained in the decision of RTA and Joint RTO Vaikom submitted a report that Chairman of Traffic Regulatory Committee Vaikom was convened a meeting on 12/10/2017 and discussed the matter in detail. There were 14 Participants in the meeting and no new proposals / suggestions were arrived at. While considering the matter by the RTA Kottayam dtd 30/11/2017, same objectors including Municipal Councilor Vaikom raised their contention against the new traffic reforms. Hence RTA Kottayam once again directed Chairman Traffic advisory committee Vaikom to report if any variations needed in the proposed system after hearing all the objectors and hence Adjourned. Joint RTO Vaikom submitted a detailed report in this regard as follows.

“In Compliance to the direction, meeting was held on 15.01.2018 with due notice to the objectors, the members of Vaikom municipal council, various residence associations and other interested public. In the meeting there were 70 participants from different sides and the objections/ suggestions etc raised have been heard and examined.

While examining the issues raised against the present system with effect from 01.07.2017, the outcome are as follows,

1. In general, Every participant in the meeting strongly wanted to operate all S/C’s including KSRTC bus through Dalavakulam Bus stand 2. There were representations from seven municipal counselors, that the coming buses from Ernakulam side shall operate through Vadakkenada and to halt at Dalavakulam. The reason put forward is for the convenience of the students of Govt. School and Govt. Offices situated at Vadakkenada. The private operators Association also made this proposal as it is economically benefitted. 3. The other matter is to provide waiting time for private buses at old bus bay and to implement the RTA decision dated 16.11.2013. 4. Another representation is that there is fall in daily business among the shop situated at Vadakkenada since the introduction of traffic system with effect from 01.07.2017. 17 municipal councilors, representatives of various residents associations and others have stated that the present system of S/C operation, touches or passes through every centers of the town and convenient to the travelling public. They strongly put the request to continue the existing system as it is the only solution in Vaikom town with the existing facilities.

The demerits and new proposal to the existing system have been examined in detail and following facts revealed.

The matters and circumstances of the introduction of present traffic system in Vaikom is due to the non compliance of the decision of RTA Kottayam held on 16.11.2013. Prior to 01.07.2017, the private S/C’s did not enter Dalavakulam bus stand and parked unauthorizedly at road sides, making inconvenience to the road users and other vehicles. At that time, there were lot of complaints against the private buses and by the introduction of present system of operations, all private S/C’s are halting and starting trip from Dalavakulam Bus stand and thereby any complaint can easily be pursued by taking immediate action.

On examining the matters related to the students of higher secondary school, the following facts are revealed. The earlier bus stop at Vadakkenada was benefited to the passengers from Thalayolaparambu, Chembu areas, while the passengers from Vechoor, Moothedathukavu, Vazhamana etc earlierly used the same Westnada bus stop. It is also a fact that during the evening time, for return journey the passengers belonging to Thalayolaparambu, Chembu used the Valiyakavala / Westnada as Bus stop as it was one way through Vadakkenada. The distance from the school to Valiyakavala, East Nada, West nada Bus stops are equal and due to the introduction of present system they can easily access the nearby Dalavakulam Bus stand.

In the case of stopping of buses at old bus bay there is no restriction for a stop in the old bus bay without providing waiting time.

The present situation after introduction of present traffic system with effect from 01.07.2017

1. Dalavakulam Bus stand is functioning very effectively. Some arrangement has to be made in the bus stand including the installation of destination board to different places inside the bus stand. 2. In the present system anyone get the facility of travelling to all places from Dalavkulam Bus stand. 3. The passengers can reach to education institutions, Offices, Hospitals etc easily from Dalavakulam Bus stand. 4. Reduced traffic congestion in Valiyakavala and also between the portion Valiyakavala- link road 5. The present system is highly benefited to the pilgrims to Vaikom Temple as their vehicles can be parked through the left side of the road from Valiyakavala to Vadakkenada without any disturbances.

After final approval of present traffic system, necessary parking area, speed breaker etc… can be provided at Vadakkenada for the better management of vehicles during festival season.

For these above stated circumstances RTA may peruse the reports, consider the matter and may give final approval to the present traffic system, already implemented and running smoothly with effect from 01.07.2017”

RTA may take a decision in the light of the report.

Item No-64 G1/2751/2017 K

Agenda-To consider the request for the sanctioning of stop for LSOS, Fast Passenger buses of KSRTC at Pattithanam Rationkada Jn. Bus Stop.

Ref:-Request from Sri. Zacharias Kuthiraveli, District Panchayath President, Member Kuravilangadu Division.

Notes- Vide reference cited, sanction bus stops at Pattithanam Rationkada Jn for LSOS and Fast Passenger buses to KSRTC. A detailed enquiry has been conducted through MVI Vaikom regarding the matter and he has submitted a detailed report as follows.

Pattithanam Rationkada Jn is situated in between Retnagiri Jn. and Vembally Jn. Majority of the busses are LSOS, FSLS and FP of KSRTC. But only a few ordinary services of KSRTC are stopping at Pattithanam Rationkada Jn at morning and evening time at present. More over many religious institutions are situating at this place and this highly populated area also. Hence there is much travelling difficulty is existing in this region. Hence recommended that if stop allowed at Pattithanam Rationkada Jn for LSOS, Fast Passenger vehicles of KSRTC, will reduces the travelling difficulty of the travelling public of Pattithanam Rationkada Jn region.

Hence RTA may hear the concerned take a decision

Item No-65 G1/801/2018/K

Agenda:- To peruse the decision taken by STA on i)permits issued for conducting stage carriage service on inter regional routes need not be countersigned on renewal to be valid in other regions and ii) grant of renewal of permit without insisting concurrence from sister RTAs.

Ref:- Decision of STA dtd 14/06/2017 in D2/10389/STA/2014 in vide Departmental Item No 3.

Notes:- STA Thiruvanmthapuram at its sitting dtd 14/06/2017 in vide Departmental Item No 3 took the following decision.

It is decided to grant renewal of permit without insisting concurrence from sister RTAs. The Secretary RTA shall obtain detailed route enquiry and ascertain that there is no variation in the existing route along with the feasibility of the renewal application before placing it in the concerned RTAs.

In view of the above decision of the STA Thiruvanamthapuram, RTA may take a decision.

Item No-66 5/135359/2017

Agenda:-1)To consider the request to condone the delay in submitting the permit renewal application in respect of A/R KL-05-AN-4318.

2) To consider the application for the renewal of permit in respect of A/R KL-05-AN-4318.

Applicant:-Sri. Shereef, Karathora [H], Kummnam P O, Thiruvarppu, Kottayam.

Permit valid up to : 02/12/2017

Date of filing application : 06/12/2017

Notes:-

A/R KL-05-AN-4318 was covered with a regular permit No-5/2198/2007, valid up to 02/12/2017. On 06/12/2017 the permit holder applied for the renewal of its regular permit for a further period of 5 years from the date of expiry.

Application was belated one. Applicant has stated that he could not submit the application in time since he was under treatment and requested to condone delay in filing the application in time. He has produced a medical certificate issued by Dr. P R Kumar, MBBS, MD, Grace Medical Centre, Aimanam.

The vehicle is having HPA. No C/R/LAR is pending. Remitted Rs 2000/- as compounding fee vide Rt No 5/135360/2017 towards permit less operation.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-67 5/142628/2017

Agenda:-1)To consider the request to condone the delay in submitting the permit renewal application in respect of A/R KL-05-N-21.

2) To consider the application for the renewal of permit in respect of A/R KL-05-N-21.

Applicant:-Sri. Surendran K K, Kandasseril [H], Veloor P O, Kottayam.

Permit valid up to : 25/11/2017

Date of filing application : 21/12/2017

Notes:-

A/R KL-05-N-21 was covered with a regular permit No-5/2292/2007, valid up to 25/11/2017. On 21/12/2017 the permit holder applied for the renewal of its regular permit for a further period of 5 years from the date of expiry.

Application was belated one. Applicant has stated that he could not submit the application in time since he was under treatment and requested to condone delay in filing the application in time. He has produced a medical certificate issued by Dr. R V Ajith, BAMS, MD, Dist. Ayurvedic Hospital, Kottayam.

The vehicle is having No HPA. No C/R/LAR is pending. Remitted Rs 2000/- as compounding fee vide Rt No 5/142628/2017 towards permit less operation.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No-68 5/139298/2017

Agenda:-1)To consider the request to condone the delay in submitting the permit renewal application in respect of A/R KL-05-AE-8122.

2) To consider the application for the renewal of permit in respect of A/R KL-05-AE-8122.

Applicant:-Sri. Shefi Naoshad, Thundiyil, Padi Post Office, Meenadam, Kottayam.

Permit valid up to : 01/11/2017

Date of filing application : 15/12/2017

Notes:-

A/R KL-05-AE-8122 was covered with a regular permit No-5/2119/2007, valid up to 01/11/2017. On 15/12/2017 the permit holder applied for the renewal of its regular permit for a further period of 5 years from the date of expiry.

Application was belated one. Applicant has stated that he could not submit the application in time since he was under treatment and requested to condone delay in filing the application in time.

The vehicle is having HPA and NOC from the HP company has been produced. No C/R/LAR is pending.

Hence RTA may hear the applicant peruse the file and take a decision.

Item No –69

Erratum.

Item No-70

Any other item permitted by the Chairman, RTA

Item No- 71

Next RTA Meeting date.