The Skeptical Intelligencer

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Skeptical Intelligencer THE SKEPTICAL INTELLIGENCER The Quarterly Magazine of ASKE THE ASSOCIATION FOR SKEPTICAL ENQUIRY Vol 16, 2013, Number 4 (Winter) Incorporating the Skeptical Adversaria: the ASKE Newsletter ________________________________________________________________________ Edited by Michael Heap To access a pdf copy of this issue, please contact the Editor at [email protected] . If you are an ASKE member and would like a paper copy sending, again email the Editor. CONTENTS Guidelines for Authors Regular features: From the ASKE Chairman 1 Of Interest 16 Logic and Intuition 2 Upcoming Events 19 Medicine on the Fringe 3 Logic and Intuition Answers 20 Language on the Fringe 4 About ASKE 21 The European Scene 16 Stop press 21 Articles: Bigfoot Talk: Claims regarding the ‘language’ of cryptids. Part 2: The data by Mark Newbrook 7 Book reviews and commentaries Strange Linguistics: A skeptical linguistic looks at non-mainstream ideas about language by Ray Ward 13 Skeptical Intelligencer , Winter 2013 GUIDELINES FOR AUTHORS The Skeptical Intelligencer welcomes formal and List multiple references in date order: e.g. informal contributions on any subject within the ‘...a number of studies have thrown doubt on ambit of the Association for Skeptical Enquiry this claim (Zack, 1986; Al-Issa, 1989; (ASKE). Erikson, 1997)...’ Formal articles should be aimed at the • In the case of electronic material, give the intelligent layperson, and authors should take author and the date the material was accessed particular care to define or explain unusual terms on line or concepts. Equations, statistics or other • Place Internet addresses URLs in angle numerical and symbolic tools may be employed brackets: e.g. <http://www.nothing.org> whenever required. Articles should be as A complete list of references in alphabetical succinct as possible, but may be of any length. order of authors’ surnames should be given at the Authors of contributions to the Skeptical end of the article. The list should be compiled Intelligencer should be take care to ensure that using the following conventions: texts are temperate in tone and free of Articles : Smith, L.J. (1990) An examination of vituperation. They should also ensure that astrology. Astrological Journal , 13 , 132-196. arguments are either supported by express • Books : Naranjo, X. (1902) The End of the evidence/arguments or identified as speculative. Road . London: University of London. ‘Do not pretend conclusions are certain that are • Chapters : Griff, P. (1978) Creationism. In D. not demonstrated or demonstrable.’ (T.H. Greengage (ed.) Pseudoscience . Boston: Huxley). Chapman Publishers. Before being accepted for publication, • Electronic material : Driscoe, E. Another submitted texts will be reviewed by the Editor look at Uri Geller. <http://www.etc.org>. and any appropriate advisors. Where Accessed 21 April 1997. improvements or changes are desirable, the Unless otherwise agreed or indicated, all editorial team will work with authors and make original material published in the Skeptical constructive suggestions as to amendments. Intelligencer is copyright by the Association for Authors should submit an electronic, double- Skeptical Enquiry. spaced copy of their article or letter. For further information contact the editor, Dr. When referring to another work, authors should: Michael Heap at [email protected] . • Cite only the surname, year, and (where appropriate) page number within the main text: e.g. ‘...according to Hyman (1985: p. 123), the results of this test were not convincing...’ or ‘...according to Bruton (1886; cited in Ross, 1996)...’ Skeptical Intelligencer , Winter 2013 FROM THE ASKE CHAIRMAN Michael Heap Why are rates of recorded crime read a journal paper on the theory, a next to nothing about epigenetic falling? pile of which he had left by the inheritance but it struck me that this is In October this year I attended a entrance. The theory is: testosterone is the kind of process that someone could symposium on falling crime rates and reduced in obese men; low testosterone easily run away with into all sorts of their probable causes (note 1) . For level in men is associated with reduced places where it has little business. about the last 10 years or more crime tendency to criminal activity; the Epigenetic inheritance and criminal generally (and most kinds of crimes) incidence of obesity is rising; hence behaviour? Sure enough, a Google has been falling in the UK whereas it crime will fall. search reveals what seems to be a had been constantly rising prior to that, The symposium did not address respectable field of scientific study. particularly from the 1960s onwards. several other explanations that have How influential will this become in our One possible cause suggested most been put forward in recent years: criminal justice system? Let’s see. recently (but not discussed at the abortion having a disproportionate Reduced street lighting and symposium) is the manipulation of the culling effect on prospective criminals crime figures by the police, either by not prior to birth; the phasing out of leaded Sometimes an action will not have the recording crimes at all or by petrol; longer prison sentences obvious effect that one would predict – downgrading the seriousness of (inmates tend to be repeat offenders hence the need for good evidence. In recorded offences (note2) . Skeptics but they can’t offend while they’re in September the Shropshire Star (note 4) will not be incredulous in the face of jail); and robust (zero-tolerance) reported that 854 people, mainly from this allegation; where it is policing methods. Some explanations the north of Shrewsbury had signed a advantageous to them, say to of rising or geographical differences in petition asking Shropshire Council to demonstrate improved performance or crime rate don’t fare too well - e.g. reverse a policy which had so far seen to meet targets, people will adjust the unemployment and inequality. around 5,000 street lights switched off data accordingly, even unconsciously. __________________________ between midnight and 5.30am. The Despite this, criminologists in the main petition was prompted by a burglary in agree that the fall in crime is genuine: Each speaker had his own the locality. Residents wanted the it has been reported in very many favoured explanation and lights back on to deter crime and help countries and is apparent in victim presented data that seemed to people feel safer in their homes. surveys as well as crimes recorded by convincingly support it. However, a report advised councillors the police. __________________________ to keep the policy, which will The symposium revealed a Maybe there is not just one eventually be extended to 12,600 street phenomenon that is of interest to explanation and maybe some of the lights throughout Shropshire. The skeptics: each speaker had his own contributing factors are very subtle and report said that in northern favoured explanation and presented Shrewsbury, the number of crimes data that seemed to convincingly difficult to measure. Predicting the behaviour of a single human being is reported between April and June 2012 support it. For one speaker it was hard enough, so predicting the – when lights were on all night – was increased security: as the number of behaviour of thousands of interacting 11. In the same period in 2013 when offences of a particular category rises, humans is pretty impossible (cue for the lights were off, there were 10 so do security and preventative efforts reported crimes. so that the rising trend is eventually economists to comment). reversed (‘crime is self-limiting’). This Keep an eye on epigenetics Notes theory seems to work best for vehicle At the beginning of December the 1. http://www.shef.ac.uk/polopoly_fs/1. theft and burglary. Another explanation media were excited by a study in the 270173!/file/MLRProgramme.pdf was low inflation – that is, crime rises journal Nature Neuroscience (note 3) 2. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/ukn with inflation because of the greater which reported that the fear response ews/crime/10511503/Fall-in-crime- demand for stolen goods, and hence conditioned to an olfactory stimulus in overstated-says-expert.html more acquisitive crime and more mice before conception may be 3. http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal violence associated with it. A transferred to the next generation and /vaop/ncurrent/full/nn.3594.html questioner from the audience, even the one afterwards, seemingly by 4. http://www.shropshirestar.com/news/ interestingly an economist, promoted the process of epigenetic inheritance environment/2013/09/28/street-lights- an endocrinological explanation and (changes in gene expression without switch-on-appeal-faces-refusal/ invited the audience and speakers to changes in the DNA sequence). I know 1 Skeptical Intelligencer , Winter 2013 LOGIC AND INTUITION Designing Psychological Experiments Designing an experiment to test a explanations for any positive results picture, studies that for two minutes, prediction based on some hypothesis observed. In the field of experimental and so on until she has looked at all concerning human psychology is parapsychology, the reports of five pictures separately. deceptively difficult (this may well be extraordinary positive findings have In another room, the other true of other disciplines). Partly owing often been discredited because the participant is informed about what her to this, the psychological research experimenters have overlooked some twin sister is doing and she is also literature is notoriously adversarial; simple way in which, for example, shown the five pictures. For each of the proponents of one particular theory information supposedly conveyed two-minute intervals that her twin will publish the results of an telepathically could have been sister is studying one of the pictures, experiment they have conducted that communicated by more obvious ways, she has to think about her and guess purports to support their theory and even those that involve cheating. which of the pictures she is looking at.
Recommended publications
  • SKEPTICAL INQUIRER Vol
    SKEPTICAL INQUIRER Vol. 18. No. 4 THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER is the official journal of the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal, an international organization. Editor Kendrick Frazier. Editorial Board James E. Alcock, Barry Beyerstein, Susan J. Blackmore, Martin Gardner, Ray Hyman, Philip J. Klass, Paul Kurtz, Joe Nickell, Lee Nisbet, Bela Scheiber. Consulting Editors Robert A. Baker, William Sims Bainbridge, John R. Cole, Kenneth L. Feder, C. E. M. Hansel, E. C. Krupp, David F. Marks, Andrew Neher, James E. Oberg, Robert Sheaffer, Steven N. Shore. Managing Editor Doris Hawley Doyle. Contributing Editor Lys Ann Shore. Writer Intern Thomas C. Genoni, Jr. Cartoonist Rob Pudim. Business Manager Mary Rose Hays. Assistant Business Manager Sandra Lesniak. Chief Data Officer Richard Seymour. Fulfillment Manager Michael Cione. Production Paul E. Loynes. Art Linda Hays. Audio Technician Vance Vigrass. Librarian Jonathan Jiras. Staff Alfreda Pidgeon, Etienne C. Rios, Ranjit Sandhu, Sharon Sikora, Elizabeth Begley (Albuquerque). The Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal Paul Kurtz, Chairman; professor emeritus of philosophy, State University of New York at Buffalo. Barry Karr, Executive Director and Public Relations Director. Lee Nisbet, Special Projects Director. Fellows of the Committee James E. Alcock,* psychologist, York Univ., Toronto; Robert A. Baker, psychologist, Univ. of Kentucky; Stephen Barrett, M.D., psychiatrist, author, consumer advocate, Allentown, Pa. Barry Beyerstein,* biopsychologist, Simon Fraser Univ., Vancouver, B.C., Canada; Irving Biederman, psychologist, Univ. of Southern California; Susan Blackmore,* psychologist, Univ. of the West of England, Bristol; Henri Broch, physicist, Univ. of Nice, France; Jan Harold Brunvand, folklorist, professor of English, Univ.
    [Show full text]
  • The Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine
    Consultation report The use and promotion of complementary and alternative medicine: making decisions about charitable status Introduction The Commission ran a public consultation on this subject between 13 March and 19 May 2017, as part of our review of how we decide whether organisations that use or promote complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) therapies are charities. Our review is not about whether complementary and alternative therapies and medicines are ‘good’ or ‘bad’, but about what level of evidence the Commission should require when making assessments about an organisation’s charitable status. We would like to thank everyone who took the time to take part. This report sets out a summary of the responses received. The consultation We received over 670 written responses, far in excess of the number usually received for a Commission consultation. We also held two discussion events at our London office for organisations with a particular perspective on the issues under consideration. The majority of responses received were from individuals apparently writing in a personal capacity, but we also received over 100 submissions from people representing, or connected with, organisations with an interest in the consultation. The names of those organisations are set out in the annex to this report. The responses varied widely in length, detail and content. Given the welcome and exceptionally high level of engagement with the consultation, it has taken longer than initially anticipated to analyse the responses. However, we are grateful for the high level of engagement; the responses have helped further our understanding the breadth and complexity of the CAM sector.
    [Show full text]
  • Flat, Hollow &Doomed +Skeptics &Religion, Psychic Detective, MTHFR
    SKEPTICISM . SCIENCE . SOCIETY Vol 38, No 1. March 2018 The Earth Flat, Hollow & Doomed +Skeptics & Religion, Psychic Detective, MTHFR Australian Skeptics . www.skeptics.com.au Skeptic_Cover_Mar18.indd 1 8/03/2018 11:14 pm The Skeptic March 18 Skeptical Groups in Australia NSW VIC Australian Skeptics Inc – Eran Segev Australian Skeptics (Vic) Inc – Chris Guest www.skeptics.com.au GPO Box 5166, Melbourne VIC 3001 PO Box 20, Beecroft, NSW 2119 Tel: 1 800 666 996 [email protected] Tel: 02 8094 1894; Mob: 0432 713 195; Fax: (02) 8088 4735 [email protected] Skeptics’ Café – Third Monday of every month, with guest speaker. Clyde Hotel, cnr Elgin and Cardigan Sts, Carlton. Meal Sydney Skeptics in the Pub – 6pm first Thursday of each from 6pm, speaker at 8pm sharp.($4 contribution). More details month at the Occidental Hotel, York Street in the city, near on our web site www.skeptics.com.au/vic Wynyard Park (meeting second floor) Dinner meetings are held on a regular basis. Ballarat Skeptics in the Pub http://facebook.com/groups/3978112230309544 Hunter Skeptics – John Turner Tel: (02) 4959 6286 [email protected] Geelong Skeptics Society Occasional social meetings at the Cricketers Arms Hotel, Cooks Contact: James Rolton [email protected] Hill. Those on the contact list will be sent details in advance. Online group: See Facebook for details. Currently meeting at 12.30 on third Sunday of each odd-numbered Hosting the Annual Surf Coast Summer Skepticamp (February) month. Gippsland Skeptics in the Pub Blue Mountains Skeptics Interested parties contact Mark Guerin or Martin Christian Power See Facebook for details.
    [Show full text]
  • Psychic Experiences Explained
    SKEPTICAL INQUIRER Vol. 16PSYCHI No. 4 C EXPERIENCES EXPLAINED The Scientist's Skepticism The Paranormal's Popularity Self-Help Books/Ghost Lights Published by the Commute Investigation of Claims of the PParanormaa an l THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER (ISSN 0194-6730) is the official journal of the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal, an international organization. Editor Kendrick Frazier. Editorial Board James E. Alcock, Martin Gardner, Ray Hyman, Philip J. Klass, Paul Kurtz. Consulting Editors Isaac Asimov, William Sims Bainbridge, John R. Cole, Kenneth L. Feder, C. E. M. Hansel, E. C. Krupp, David F. Marks, Andrew Neher, James E. Oberg, Robert Sheaffer, Steven N. Shore. Managing Editor Doris Hawley Doyle. Contributing Editor Lys Ann Shore. Business Manager Mary Rose Hays. Assistant Business Manager Sandra Lesniak Chief Data Officer Richard Seymour. Computer Assistant Michael Cione. Production Paul E. Loynes. Audio Technician Vance Vigrass. Librarian, Ranjit Sandhu. Staff Leland Harrington, Jonathan Jiras, Atfreda Pidgeon, Kathy Reeves, Elizabeth Begley (Albuquerque). Cartoonist Rob Pudim. The Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal Paul Kurtz, Chairman; professor emeritus of philosophy, State University of New York at Buffalo. Barry Karr, Executive Director and Public Relations Director. Lee Nisbet, Special Projects Director. Fellows of the Committee James E. Alcock, psychologist, York Univ., Toronto; Isaac Asimov, biochemist, author; Robert A. Baker, psychologist, Univ. of Kentucky; Barry Beyerstein, biopsychologist, Simon Fraser University, Vancouver, B.C., Canada; Irving Biederman, psychologist, University of Minnesota; Susan Blackmore, psychologist, Brain Perception Laboratory, University of Bristol, England; Henri Broch, physicist, University of Nice, France; Vern Bullough, Distinguished Professor, State University of New York; Mario Bunge, philosopher, McGill University; John R.
    [Show full text]
  • Multicultural Pseudoscience 1991 CSICOP Conference Classical Debunkers Science and Common Sense Spook Hill Illusion
    SKEPTICAL INQUIRER Vol. 16, No. 1 FdlM991/$6.25 NEAR-DEATH EXPERIENCES In or Out of the Body? Multicultural Pseudoscience 1991 CSICOP Conference Classical Debunkers Science and Common Sense Spook Hill Illusion Published by the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal THE SKEPTICAL INQUIRER is the official journal of the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal. Editor Kendrick Frazier. Editorial Board James E. Alcock, Martin Gardner, Ray Hyman, Philip J. Klass, Paul Kurtz. Consulting Editors Isaac Asimov, William Sims Bainbridge, John R. Cole, Kenneth L. Feder, C. E. M. Hansel, E. C. Krupp, David F. Marks, Andrew Neher, James E. Oberg, Robert Sheaffer, Steven N. Shore. Managing Editor Doris Hawley Doyle. Contributing Editor Lys Ann Shore. Business Manager Mary Rose Hays. Art Valerie Ferenti-Cognetto. Chief Data Officer Richard Seymour. Computer Assistant Michael Cione. Typesetting Paul E. Loynes. Audio Technician Vance Vigrass. Librarian, Ranjit Sandhu. Staff Lynda Harwood (Asst. Public Relations Director), Leland Harrington, Sandra Lesniak, Alfreda Pidgeon, Kathy Reeves. Cartoonist Rob Pudim. The Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal Paul Kurtz, Chairman; philosopher, State University of New York at Buffalo. Barry Karr, Executive Director and Public Relations Director. Lee Nisbet, Special Projects Director. Fellows of the Committee (partial list) lames E. Alcock, psychologist, York Univ., Toronto; Isaac Asimov, biochemist, author; Robert A. Baker, psychologist, Univ. of Kentucky; Irving Biederman, psychologist. University of Minnesota; Susan Blackmore, psychologist. Brain Perception Laboratory, University of Bristol, England; Henri Broch, physicist. University of Nice, France; Mario Bunge, philosopher, McGill University; John R.
    [Show full text]
  • Enciclopedia Del CICAP ’ Enciclopedia.Qxd 22-07-2009 11:21 Pagina 4 Enciclopedia.Qxd 22-07-2009 11:21 Pagina 5
    CopertinaEnciclopedia.qxd 17-01-2014 11:00 Pagina 1 Enciclopedia.qxd 22-07-2009 11:21 Pagina 3 MISTERIL enciclopedia del CICAP ’ Enciclopedia.qxd 22-07-2009 11:21 Pagina 4 Enciclopedia.qxd 22-07-2009 11:21 Pagina 5 Massimo POLIDORO presenta MISTERIL enciclopedia del CICAP ’ A cura di Stefano Bagnasco, Andrea Ferrero e Silvano Fuso Enciclopedia.qxd 22-07-2009 11:21 Pagina 6 Massimo Polidoro presenta: Misteri. L’enciclopedia del CICAP A cura di Stefano Bagnasco, Andrea Ferrero e Silvano Fuso Hanno collaborato alla redazione e revisione dei testi: Sara Benatti, Giovanna Caputo, Roberto Labanti, Valentina Paggi, Enrico Scalas Hanno collaborato alla stesura delle voci: Piero Angela, Simone Angioni, Luca Antonelli, Paolo Attivissimo, Stefano Bagnasco, Massimo Biondi, Lucio Braglia, Mauro Carta, Riccardo Cattania, Claudio Cocheo, Gianni Comoretto, Fran- cesco D’Alpa, Sergio De Santis, Armando De Vincentiis, Enrico Scalas, Andrea Ferrero, Silvano Fuso, Marcello Garbagnati, Luigi Garlaschelli, Francesco Grassi, Roberto Labanti, Lisa Maccari, Roberto Manzocco, Alessandro Marenco, Lorenzo Montali, Marco Morocutti, Claudio Nobile, Crescenzo Pinto, Massimo Polidoro, Gian Marco Rinaldi, Maurizio Rondanini, Enrico Speran- za, Mariano Tomatis, Alberto Vecchiato, Max Vellucci, Florian Zenoni, Alessandro Zocchi Supplemento al n. 84 di Scienza & Paranormale Bimestrale scientifico - Sped. in abb. postale 45% Art. 2 comma 20/B legge 662/96 Filiale di Padova © 2009 CICAP Tutti i diritti riservati Tutti i testi contenuti in questo volume sono stati realizzati appositamente per esso o estratti dal- le pubblicazioni del CICAP: Scienza & Paranormale, gli Atti dei Convegni e il sito ufficiale del Comitato www.cicap.org. Nel caso di pubblicazioni esterne è stato chiesto il permesso, dove pos- sibile.
    [Show full text]
  • Conspiracy Theories Ten Years Later
    SI July August 2011_SI JF 10 V1 5/25/11 12:20 PM Page 1 2012 Doomsday Pseudoscience | What Is Acupuncture? | Popper vs. Kuhn | Women in Science Vol. 35 No. 4 | July/August 2011 THE MAGAZINE FOR SCIENCE & REASON Conspiracy Theories Ten Years Later The Top Theories A Bestiary of ‘Truthers’ Jesse Ventura’s Conspiracies ‘Messages’ from the 9/11 Dead Published by the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry SI July August 11_SI new design masters 5/25/11 12:15 PM Page 2 AT THE CEN TERFOR IN QUIRY –TRANSNATIONAL Paul Kurtz, Founder Joe Nickell, Senior Research Fellow Richard Schroeder, Chairman Massimo Polidoro, Research Fellow Ronald A. Lindsay, President and CEO Benjamin Radford, Research Fellow www.csicop.org Bar ry Karr, Ex ec u tive Di rect or Richard Wiseman, Research Fellow James E. Al cock*, psy chol o gist, York Univ., Tor on to Thom as Gi lov ich, psy chol o gist, Cor nell Univ. Lor en Pan kratz, psy chol o gist, Or e gon Health Mar cia An gell, MD, former ed i tor-in-chief, Wendy M. Grossman, writer; founder and first editor, Sci en ces Univ. New Eng land Jour nal of Med i cine The Skeptic magazine (UK) Robert L. Park,professor of physics, Univ. of Maryland Kimball Atwood IV, MD, physician; author; Sus an Haack, Coop er Sen ior Schol ar in Arts and Jay M. Pasachoff, Field Memorial Professor of Newton, MA Sci en ces, professor of phi los o phy and professor Astronomy and director of the Hopkins Steph en Bar rett, MD, psy chi a trist; au thor; con sum er of Law, Univ.
    [Show full text]
  • SPECIAL REPORT Informed Perspective Yeti DNA Not a a Skeptic’S Prehistoric Bear Near-Death Experience Do We Really Want INTRODUCTORY PRICE U.S
    Balles Prizes | FDA Homeopathy Hearing | UFO Conspiracies | Clever Hans | Skeptical Curse Removal the Magazine for Science and Reason Vol. 39 No. 4 | July/August 2015 ADVERLYING: Disliking Advertising from an SPECIAL REPORT Informed Perspective Yeti DNA Not a A Skeptic’s Prehistoric Bear Near-Death Experience Do We Really Want INTRODUCTORY PRICE U.S. and Canada $5.99 to Believe in UFOs? Scott Joplin’s Published by the Center for Inquiry in association with the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry Skeptical Black Opera Ronald A. Lindsay, President and CEO Massimo Polidoro, Research Fellow Bar ry Karr, Ex ec u tive Di rect or Benjamin Radford, Research Fellow Joe Nickell, Senior Research Fellow Richard Wiseman, Research Fellow Fellows www.csicop.org James E. Al cock*, psy chol o gist, York Univ., Tor on to Mur ray Gell-Mann, pro fes sor of phys ics, San ta Fe In sti tute; James E. Oberg, sci ence writer Mar cia An gell, MD, former ed i tor-in-chief, No bel lau re ate Irm gard Oe pen, pro fes sor of med i cine (re tired), New Eng land Jour nal of Med i cine Thom as Gi lov ich, psy chol o gist, Cor nell Univ. Mar burg, Ger ma ny Kimball Atwood IV, MD, physician; author; David H. Gorski, cancer surgeon and re searcher at Barbara Lor en Pan kratz, psy chol o gist, Or e gon Health Newton, MA Ann Kar manos Cancer Institute and chief of breast surgery Sci en ces Univ. Steph en Bar rett, MD, psy chi a trist; au thor; con sum er ad vo cate, section, Wayne State University School of Medicine.
    [Show full text]