Future-Talk, Finance, and Christian Eschatology
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Trading Futures: Future-Talk, Finance, and Christian Eschatology The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:37925648 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use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`*&'=!Q$&=&'!)%!;.!&S(&'+)0!'&)#&'M!:$+4&!(3&!8&'.!?&=$++$+=!*6!;.! .&)'%!)%!)!;)%(&'U%!%(5#&+(!)(!a&'I$+%!:43**0!*6!23&*0*=.C!`*&'=!3)%!&+4*5')=&#!;&! ! 8$! H$(3!5+;)(43&#!=&+&'*%$(.M!2'50.C!;.!#&8&0*,;&+(!)%!)!%43*0)'!$%!$+#&?(&#!(*!3$%! %5,,*'(M!! "%!>!0**I!?)4I!$+(*!(3&!=&+&)0*=.!*6!(3&!$+(&'&%(%!(3)(!?'*5=3(!;&!(*!(3$%! #$%%&'()($*+C!>!'&4)00!H$(3!=')($(5#&!`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a&)'0!-)''*%C!B)%%$&!7*5(TC!"#'$b+!R;;)+5&0!