Appendices

General Code Decision Requested Submission No. To reinstate Appendix C, site of ecological significance of the operative plan 1135/1 To make additions to Appendix C, site of ecological significance (from the operative plan), using any recent data which can 1135/2 strengthen Appendix C values, and in such a manner that can be accurately assessed and described using legal lot numbers as the starting point for recognition of a/that site Retain appendices 1-6 Heritage 2641/16 Amend the Appendices 1 to 6 (Heritage) index to include the ‘name of feature’ or similar identification information. 2641/63 Amend Appendix 1 to 6 (Heritage) to ensure all heritage items are assessed against the relevant evaluation criteria and are 2641/64 allocated the correct 'category' including R11/39, R11/123, R11/124, R11/125 - Headland pa, . This applies particularly to heritage items rolled over from the operative plan. Supports the inclusion of appendices 13, 14, 15 in the Plan, in particular appendix 15. 366/1 Include as an appendix a set of environmental and design principles that apply to comprehensive management plans (eg. Far 618/134, 1101/19, 1284/17, North District provisions, rule 12.9.2) 1286/114, 1287/47, 1288/165, 1289/24, 2721/14, 2878/115

A1 – Heritage schedules for the inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1 Heritage items and archaeological sites on Waiheke should / must not be included in the Plan, until the following key points are 294/1 considered, determined and clarified: 1. Proof applying to all sites as to what there is in the way of archaeological findings in comparison to Incas in South America, Greece, Egypt, Rome, 2. Carbon dating and identification of any actual findings by qualified and certified independent archaeologists. 3. The indigenous people should have the most important say in heritage and spiritual values of any site.

A1a – Schedule of archaeological sites – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1a Take appropriate action to remedy the shortcomings identified regarding gaps in the listing of sites of archaeological significance 298/4, 380/4, 568/4, 586/4, 628/4, eg Okoka Bay 634/4, 636/4, 646/4, 665/4, 673/4, 696/4, 706/4, 731/4, 736/4, 748/4, 802/4, 819/4, 828/4, 837/4, 844/4, 850/4, 858/4, 871/4, 889/4, 893/4, 902/4, 925/4, 928/4, 957/4, 1011/4, 1055/42, 1123/4, 1152/4, 1204/4, 1216/4, 1232/4, 1291/4, 1375/4, 1637/4, 1638/4, 1639/4, 1640/4, 1641/4, 1642/4, 1643/4, 1644/4, 1645/4, 1646/4, 1647/4, 1648/4, 1649/4, 1650/4, 1651/4, 1652/4, 1653/4, 1654/4, 1655/4, 1656/4, 1657/4, 1658/4, 1659/4, 1660/4, 1662/4, 1663/4, 2124/4, 2131/4, 2133/4, 2278/4, 2283/4, 2463/4, 2561/4, 2675/4, 2679/4, 2684/4, City District Plan – Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 1

Code Decision Requested Submission No. 2691/4, 2695/4, 2706/4, 2710/4, 2780/4, 2782/4, 2791/4, 2826/4, 2830/4, 2842/4, 2994/4, 3009/4, 3011/4, 3025/4, 3061/47, 3513/4, 3536/4, 3561/4, 3569/4, 3573/4, 3589/4, 3628/4, 3786/4, 3806/4, 3814/4, 3817/4, 3836/4, 3838/31 A1a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/1 archaeological sites on Browns Island in appendix 1a and amend the maps accordingly:

Browns Island – Archaeological sites

DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location R11/124 2679755 6483782 Headland Pa Eastern coast R11/127 2679530 6483800 Stonefield garden system SE of central cone R11/1092 2679400 6484250 Stonefield garden system SE of central cone R11/1095 2679620 6483950 Stonefield garden system E of central cone R11/1500 2679000 6484200 Midden & Stoneworking NW Flat R11/1570 2679237 6484208 Stone enclosure S of central cone A1a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/2 archaeological sites on in appendix 1a and amend the maps accordingly:

Motuihe Island – Archaeological sites

DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location R11/148 2682930 6486712 Headland Pa-Mangoparerua Headland R11/151 2684514 6486383 Headland Pa- Te Rae o Kahu Northern coast R11/872 2683755 6484705 Flaking floor & midden Southern coast R11/876 2683620 6485264 Open settlement Orchard Bush R11/1890 2684029 6484840 Flaking floor & midden Southern coast R11/1891 2683995 6484819 Flaking floor & midden Southern coast R11/1784 2683100 6487000 Quarantine Station Headland A1a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/3 archaeological sites on in appendix 1a and amend the maps accordingly:

Archaeological Sites DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location R10/23 2679500 6491800 Headland Pa Western coast R10/48 2681400 6493400 Archaic midden Sandy Bay R10/51 2681000 6492700 Headland Pa Administration Bay R10/108 2680700 6491800 Ridge Pa Behind Pig Bay R10/115 2679700 6490350 Headland Pa Causeway R10/214 2679800 6490100 Headland Pa Causeway R10/337 2681500 6494100 Headland Pa North of Sandy Bay

Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 2

Code Decision Requested Submission No. R11/144 2679900 6489800 Ridge Pa Islington Bay R11/146 2681100 6488300 Headland Pa Emu Bay R11/147 2681100 6487800 Headland Pa Emu Point R11/218 2682500 6489000 Headland Pa Otahuhu Point A1a Immediate reinstatement of the recognition of the Historical significance of the church site at 131A Church Bay Road. 2620/1 A1a Amend appendix 1a of the Plan to provide for the protection of all archaeological sites of significance. In particular those on Ponui, 2641/31 Motuihe, Pakihi, Rangitoto, Motutapu, the Noises, Browns Island (Motukorea) and Karamuramu. A1a Amend Appendix 1a of the Plan to provide reference to the NZAA site numbers. 2641/33 A1a That once archaeological surveys and or excavations have been done on each of these specific sites that they be reassessed for 721/4 inclusion or not within the scheduled archaeological site. A1a That more effort is made to specify the exact middens, pits and terraces instead of including a large area of land that does not 721/1 have any of these features. A1a Opposes the gaps in the listing of sites of archaeological significance eg Okoka Bay. 709/9, 3354/4, 3832/4 A1a Seeks a heritage classification for the Pa site (pit and terracing) on Crosby Reserve (50 Fairview Crescent, Rocky Bay). 3176/1 Reference planning maps sheet 15, map 2. A1a Retain Appendix 1a in a manner that is consistent with the lists contained in the Auckland Regional Plan: Coastal, subject to 3521/146 amendments sought elsewhere in this submission. A1a The following item should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1a of the Plan: 2641/29 R10/1012, R10/692, R10/690, R10/687 – Delaware Rd . A1a The following item should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1a of the Plan: 2641/30 S11/1382 - Oneroa Headland pa, Waiheke A1a.3 Amend 3.0, Appendix 1a to state the following or similar: 2641/28 As noted in section 7.8.1, all archaeological sites are protected by the provisions of the Historic Places Act 1993. An authority is required from the NZHPT prior to damaging, destroying or modifying any archaeological site, whether the site is scheduled within this Plan or not. A1a.3 Amend Appendix 1a - 3.0 Notes and disclaimers to highlight (i.e with bolding or underlining) the last sentence: 3521/148 "All archaeological sites in New Zealand are protected by the New Zealand Historic Places Trust, whether listed or not".

A1b – Schedule of buildings, objects, properties and places of special value – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1b That the council re-assess the bach community (including bach 108) for category A listing in appendix 1b. 952/3 A1b Inclusion of the outhouse / long drop in the buildings scheduled for protection on Rangitoto. 1005/2 A1b Subject to full consultation with owners, schedule buildings / structures that represent the remnants of old maritime culture, namely 298/7, 380/7, 568/7, 586/7, 628/7, the old wrecks – the Rahiri is in the ARC’s jurisdiction but others such as the Patiki at the Causeway. The old boatsheds, especially 634/7, 646/7, 673/7, 731/7, 736/7, the Matiatia Kayak Sheds, and those at Oneroa, Mawhitipana Bay, and Rocky Bay. The remnants of the old wharves eg on the 748/7, 828/7, 850/7, 889/7, 893/7, Esplanade, end of Wharf Rd etc. The old public buildings namely the old Post Offices in Oneroa, and Ostend [ Wharf Rd ] 925/7, 957/7, 802/7, 837/7, 706/7, and the community halls at Oneroa (MORRA), Blackpool, Surfdale, Ostend including the ORRA Hall, Palm Beach. Shops such as 819/7, 844/7, 858/7, 871/7, 902/7, the Oneroa Fruit & Vege Shop and Jewellers, the old butchers shops at Oneroa and Surfdale. The Beach Shops at Little Oneroa, 928/7, 1011/7, 1123/7, 1152/7, Rocky Bay, Palm Beach, . The special / significant places and buildings such as the Alison Homestead and Coach house 1204/7, 1216/7, 1232/7, 1291/7, – Matiatia, Janet Frame’s cottage (If it still exists), the Red Cross (Oneroa), the Red Shed (Palm Beach), and the Library and 1375/7, 1636/7, 1637/7, 1638/7, Artworks. Examples of the old baches and cottages. 1639/7, 1640/7, 1641/7, 1642/7, 1643/7, 1644/7, 1645/7, 1646/7, 1647/7, 1648/7, 1649/7, 1650/7, 1651/7, 1652/7,1653/7, 1654/7, Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 3

Code Decision Requested Submission No. 1655/7, 1656/7, 1657/7, 1658/7, 1659/7, 1660/7, 1662/7, 1663/7, 2124/7, 2131/7, 2133/7, 2278/7, 2283/7, 2463/7, 2561/7, 2675/7, 2679/7, 2684/7, 2691/7, 2695/7, 2706/7, 2710/7, 2780/7, 2782/7, 2791/7, 2826/7, 2830/7, 2842/7, 2994/7, 3009/7, 3011/7, 3025/7, 3061/50, 3513/7, 3536/7, 3561/7, 3569/7, 3573/7, 3589/7, 3628/7, 3786/7, 3806/7, 3814/7, 3817/7, 3836/7, 3838/6 A1b Reconsider the decision not to schedule the former Kissling homestead, Woodside Bay in Appendix 1b 2056/1 A1b Include appendix 1b at Rangitoto wharf: 2070/1 1. Prison Camp and 5 court tennis court 2. Running green and old BBQ picnic area 3. Stone arches old men’s toilet 4. Swimming pool and changing sheds and retaining sea walls and boat ramps 5. Kiosk area and water tanks 6. All existing tracks and paths 7. Mountain water tank and caves, Islington Bay 8. C.M Base – yankee wharf – paths and roading around old bach areas. Hall and tennis court areas, tracks to Bolder Bay and those around McKenzie Bay and quarries. A1b Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/8 buildings, objects, properties and places of special value on Motuihe Island in appendix 1b and amend the maps accordingly: Buildings, objects, properties and places of special value Description of site Location Water tower (HMNZS Tamaki) On main headland Wharf shed (HMNZS Tamaki) Near wharf WWII gun emplacements On main headland and on narrow neck Cemetery (1870-1918) On main headland A1b Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/9 buildings, objects, properties and places of special value on Motutapu Island in appendix 1b and amend the maps accordingly: Buildings, objects, properties and places of special value Description of site Location Motutapu Outdoor Education Camp Administration Bay 6 inch Gun Battery Hill above Administration Bay Battery Command Post Hill above Administration Bay Battery Observation Post and Radar Room Hill above Administration Bay Emu Observation Post Hill above Administration Bay Engine Rooms Hill above Administration Bay Plotting Rooms Hill above Administration Bay Miniature Range Hill above Administration Bay Plotting Room building Hill above Administration Bay Underground Plotting Rooms Valley south of hill above Administration Bay Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 4

Code Decision Requested Submission No. Above Ground Wireless Room Hill above Administration Bay Billy Goat Point Searchlight Station Northern point of island Pill Boxes (17) Around main gun battery and main camp US Navy Magazines Western side of island just north of causeway Home Bay Wharf Home Bay Reid Homestead Home Bay Reid Family Grave Site Home Bay A1b Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/10 buildings, objects, properties and places of special value on in appendix 1b and amend the maps accordingly: Buildings, objects, properties and places of special value Description of site Location Bach 80 Islington Bay Fire Command Post Summit Wireless Room Summit RDF Station Summit WAAC’s Guard Room Summit Engine Room Summit Fortress Observation Post Subsidiary cone NE of Summit Fire Command Post Camp structures Just below summit Searchlight Emplacement Islington Bay 12 pounder Gun Emplacements Islington Bay Observation Post Islington Bay Controlled Mine Base Islington Bay A1b Schedule Hangaura (Church Bay) urupa (map ref 3.28 under the operative plan) and church site in appendix 1b. 2549/3 A1b Schedule Okoka Bay (being the place of residence of Wiremu Hoete of Ngati Paoa, about 1835-1845) in appendix 1b. 2549/4 A1b That Scouts bach/site at Rangitoto be included in appendix 1b 2580/4 A1b That bach 58 Walton Cox/Trainer be included in appendix 1b 2580/5 A1b The inclusion in Appendix 1b of the outhouse/longdrop associated with bach 58, Rangitoto. 2599/1 A1b Inclusion of ramp way directly in front of bach 58, Rangitoto in appendix 1b. 2599/2 A1b Recorded in Appendix 1b that bach 58 was built prior to 1930. 2599/3 A1b The interiors of all Rangitoto baches should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1b 2641/45 A1b Bach 80, Islington Bay, Rangitoto should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1b 2641/46 A1b Kissling Homestead (former), Waiheke should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1b 2641/47 A1b Old Onetangi Hotel, Waiheke should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1b 2641/48 A1b Te Huruhi Native School, Waiheke should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1b 2641/49 A1b Amend Appendix 1b of the Plan to provide for the protection of all buildings, objects, properties and places of special value. In 2641/50 particular those on Ponui, Motuihe, Pakihi, Motutapu, Browns Island (Motukorea), Pakatoa and Karamuramu A1b Re-evaluate the historic value of the Homestead at Woodside Bay using council’s own criteria as listed in A3 2652/1 A1b As a result of the re-evaluation, replace the homestead at Woodside Bay on the list of protected buildings in the Plan 2652/2 A1b Schedule Wilson Park (Rangitoto) 2877/5 A1b Schedule the prison camp (Rangitoto) 2877/6 A1b Schedule causeway and wharves (Rangitoto) 2877/7 A1b Schedule bach 45 2877/8 A1b Schedule bach 57 2877/9 Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 5

Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1b Schedule bach 80 2877/10 A1b That the interiors of all the baches be included in the Plan 2877/11 A1b Seeks amendments to “absentee” baches on Rangitoto that may otherwise not be correctly listed. 2877/16 A1b Consider for scheduling the controlled mine base at the entrance to Islington Bay. 2877/17 A1b Consider for scheduling the “Pill Boxes” along Motukorea Channel on the Rangitoto foreshore. 2877/18 A1b Schedule the interiors of all baches on Rangitoto. 2879/1 A1b Designate Wilson Park, Rangitoto and water tanks as a historic area. 2883/1 A1b To schedule all objects, artefacts, structures associated with the era of the prison camp and work force as areas of special interest 2884/1 on Rangitoto. A1b To schedule the summit track from Rangitoto wharf to the summit built prior to 1900 as an area of special interest. 2884/2 A1b To schedule both wharves at Islington Bay & Rangitoto built prior to world war 1, or what is left of them as buildings of special 2884/3 interest. A1b To scheduled the causeway at Islington Bay to Motutapu built by bachholders for the second world war as a building of special 2884/4 interest. A1b Include Bach 58 “on the rocks” in the heritage area (appendix 1b) on Rangitoto. 2885/1 A1b Include Bach 45 in the heritage area (appendix 1b) on Rangitoto. 2886/1 A1b Include Bach 80 in the heritage area (appendix 1b) on Rangitoto. 2887/1 A1b That the rock archway to the previous men’s toilet at Rangitoto wharf be scheduled. 986/1, 992/1, 993/1, 994/1, 995/1 A1b All the paths on Rangitoto to be scheduled and all roads. 987/1, 988/1, 989/1, 990/1, 991/1 A1b Seeks the inclusion (scheduling) of the outhouses / long drops within the Rangitoto bach community. 387/2 A1b Subject to full consultation with owners, schedule buildings / structures that represent the remnants of old maritime culture, namely 1055/45 the old wrecks – the Rahiri is in the ARC’s jurisdiction but others such as the Patiki at the Causeway. The old boatsheds, especially the Matiatia Kayak Sheds, and those at Oneroa, Mawhitipana Bay, and Rocky Bay. The remnants of the old wharves eg on the Esplanade, end of Wharf Rd etc. The old public buildings namely the old Post Offices in Oneroa, Surfdale and Ostend [ Wharf Rd ] and the community halls at Oneroa (MORRA), Blackpool, Surfdale, Ostend including the ORRA Hall, Palm Beach. Shops such as the Oneroa Fruit & Vege Shop and Jewellers, the old butchers shops at Oneroa and Surfdale. The Beach Shops at Little Oneroa, Rocky Bay, Palm Beach, Onetangi. The special / significant places and buildings such as the Alison Homestead and Coach house – Matiatia, Janet Frame’s cottage (If it still exists), the Red Cross (Oneroa), the Red Shed (Palm Beach), and the Library and Artworks. A1b Schedule the changing sheds and toilets at Rangitoto wharf. 389/2 A1b That bach 93 on Rangitoto be preserved 1126/1 A1b The bach community of Rangitoto to be placed on schedule B under the new Plan. 980/1 A1b Subject to full consultation with owners, schedule buildings / structures that represent the remnants of old maritime culture, namely 696/7 the old wrecks – the Rahiri is in the ARC’s jurisdiction but others such as the Patiki at the Causeway. The old boatsheds, especially the Matiatia Kayak Sheds, and those at Oneroa, Mawhitipana Bay, and Rocky Bay. The remnants of the old wharves eg on the Esplanade, end of Wharf Rd etc. The old public buildings namely the old Post Offices in Oneroa, Surfdale. A1b That the bach community on Rangitoto be listed. 491/1 A1b All sites (baches and structures on Rangitoto) to be within category B. 495/1 A1b Wish to see a list of all currently empty bach sites included and protected in the appropriate appendices of the plan. For example, 501/2 currently there exists a body of useful historical and planning information together with strong family interest in Rangitoto baches numbers 71 (Franklin), 72 (Fairey), 75 (Briggs), 79 (Price), 92 (Crocker) and 93 (Davis). A1b Schedule the kiosk previously known as Gemmells bach 80 (Rangitoto). 524/1 A1b A historical type of village at Islington Bay involving all the baches being faithfully rebuilt as true to original and ‘caretaken’ by the 1126/2 original family descendants where possible (including baches 71, 72, 75, 78, 79, 92, 93, and 114). A1b That the bach community on Rangitoto be listed in Appendix 1b. 952/2 Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 6

Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1b The inclusion of the outhouses / long drop in the schedule of protected buildings on Rangitoto 969/2, 970/2 A1b Support and endorsement of an Islington Bay (Rangitoto) historic village with DOC who currently control the island. 262/1 A1b The inclusion (scheduling) of the Islington Bay bach community on Rangitoto as having special value and character that come 264/1 under sections 7 and 8 of the HGMPA. A1b Schedule the changing sheds and toilets at Rangitoto wharf. 388/2 A1b Add bach 72, including the original bath, bottom step of path to house, steps to boatshed site and the boatshed concrete which 1034/1 block) at Islington Bay, Rangitoto to appendix 1b. A1b Accordance of heritage status to appropriate houses within the proposed Omiha (Rocky Bay) conservation area. e.g house in 154/4 Pohutukawa Avenue built for S. Henderson and G. Buddle; two houses in Omiha Road built by R. Beadnall; house built for F. Gregory in Omiha Road; A. O’Brien’s cottage in Glenbrook Road; A. Gouk’s cottage in Glenbrook Road. A1b Remnants of bach site 100 (Horner) and its steps to be scheduled (on Rangitoto). 145/2 A1b The cultural and heritage provisions of the Plan need to include the existing chapel and the ex-army accommodation block on 947/24 Rotoroa. A1b For Rangitoto Wharf, seeks its inclusion in the Plan (appendix 1b). 141/1 A1b The inclusion of the Islington Bay Settlement Community within appendix 1b. 965/1 A1b Re-evaluate the historic value of the Homestead at Woodside Bay using councils own criteria. 3080/1 A1b As a result of the historic re-evaluation of the homestead at Woodside Bay replace the homestead on the list of protected buildings 3080/2 in the Plan. A1b That each bach site on Rangitoto be preserved 3075/1 A1b Retain Appendix 1b that is consistent with the lists contained in the Auckland Regional Plan: Coastal, subject to amendments 3521/147 sought elsewhere in this submission A1b Western Te Huruhi (site of Piritahi Marae) is a place of special cultural heritage value on Waiheke that needs to be scheduled. 3578/1 A1b.2 Supports the methodology for identifying heritage items (in appendix 1b, section 2.0) as so far as it goes. 709/4 A1b.2 Supports and seeks retention of the methodology for identifying heritage items as so far as it goes in Appendix 1b Section 2.0, Key 1055/37 to reasons for scheduling buildings, objects, properties and places of special value. A1b.4 Amend the diagrams in appendix 1b – Schedule of buildings, objects, properties and places of special value – inner islands, by 2097/2 deleting any of the letters ‘p, q, r, s’ or ‘P, Q, R , S’ where they appear in the list of ‘Reasons’ under the diagrams.

A1c – Schedule of conservation areas – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1c Amend Appendix 1c of the Plan to include a Rangitoto Baches conservation area. 2641/54 A1c That consideration be given to scheduling Heritage areas for the bach communities of Rangitoto Wharf, Islington Bay/Gardiner's 2877/4 Gap and Beacons End/Mackenzie's Bay. A1c To include all objects and artefacts associated with the bach communities on Rangitoto island in a protected heritage area. 2880/1 A1c To include all objects, structures and artefacts associated with the bach community at Mackenzie Bay (Beacon End in a protected 2881/1 heritage area). A1c To include all objects and artefacts associated with the bach communities in Islington Bay area in a protected heritage area. 2882/1 A1c Te Aroha Avenue in Hekerua Valley, Waiheke be re-defined from an ‘unformed road’ to a ‘conservation area’. 496/1 A1c Include the foreshore of, and dwellings adjacent to Arran Bay as a conservation area. 154/3 A1c Favours the idea of a historical village at Islington Bay, Rangitoto with all of the baches being faithfully rebuilt as true to the original 3075/2 and caretaken by the original family descendants wherever possible.

A1d – Schedule of sites of ecological significance – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1d That Appendix 1d be amended to include the Three Sisters Rocks as a site of ecological significance. 2518/2 Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 7

A1d To re-instate the sites of ecological significance at Wilma Road lots 487 to 511 DP 26969. 1154/1 A1d To reinstate Lot 1 DP67008 as a site of ecological significance (SES 10) as it is currently recorded within Appendix C of the 1139/2 operative Plan. A1d Seeks an appendix that identifies those properties that have ‘over title’ a conservation covenant 482/1 A1d That streams and wetland sites that have been omitted from plans and from sites of ecological significance be included, through 3061/73 consultation with the community and interested parties (eg Forest and Bird’s wetland group). A1d The index to the maps of sites of ecological significance (appendix 1d) is inadequate as it does not give the name or site of 3061/68 ecological significance number to each feature.

A1e – Schedule of geological items – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1e.4 Amend the legend at the beginning of item 4.0 Diagrams of scheduled geological items, in appendix 1e - Schedule of geological 2097/3 items - inner islands. After the third entry in the legend, include new entry showing ‘S201’ superimposed on an aerial base. The text to accompany this is ‘GPS point - coordinates for significant boulders, recorded by GPS in the field’.

A1f – Schedule of Maori heritage sites – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1f Take appropriate action to remedy the shortcomings identified regarding the lack of Maori heritage sites in the Plan. For example 298/1, 380/1, 568/1, 586/1, 628/1, the corner of Te Huruhi Bay including the site of Piritahi Marae stands out as an obvious example of a Maori heritage site area. 634/1, 646/1, 665/1, 673/1, 696/1, 706/1, 731/1, 736/1, 748/1, 802/1, 828/1, 837/1, 844/1, 850/1, 858/1, 871/1, 889/1, 893/1, 902/1, 925/1, 928/1, 957/1, 1011/1, 1055/39, 1123/1, 1152/1, 1204/1, 1216/1, 1232/1, 1291/1, 1375/1, 1636/1, 1637/1, 1638/1, 1639/1, 1640/1, 1641/1, 1642/1, 1643/1, 1644/1, 1645/1, 1646/1, 1647/1, 1648/1, 1649/1, 1650/1, 1651/1, 1652/1, 1653/1, 1654/1, 1655/1, 1656/1, 1657/1, 1658/1, 1659/1, 1660/1, 1662/1, 1663/1, 2124/1, 2131/1, 2133/1, 2278/1, 2283/1, 2463/1, 2561/1, 2675/1, 2679/1, 2684/1, 2691/1, 2695/1, 2706/1, 2710/1, 2780/1, 2782/1, 2791/1, 2826/1, 2830/1, 2842/1, 2994/1, 3009/1, 3011/1, 3025/1, 3061/44, 3513/1, 3536/1, 3561/1, 3569/1, 3573/1, 3589/1, 3628/1, 3786/1, 3806/1, 3814/1, 3817/1, 3836/1 A1f The urupa at Matiatia is identified as a Maori heritage site in appendix 1f-schedule of Maori heritage sites-inner islands and on 2108/1 sheet 1 map no. 2 of the Proposed Hauraki Gulf District Plan A1f Schedule Hangaura (Church Bay) urupa (map ref 3.28 under the operative plan) and church site in appendix 1f. 2549/2 A1f Schedule urupa at Okoka Bay in appendix 1f. 2549/5 A1f Schedule Te Wharau urupa at Park Point in appendix 1f. 2549/7

Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 8

Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1f Investigation of the extent of the Urupa and of the location of other burials on the Hart farm property and when that investigation 2620/2 has been completed definition of an area including the Church site, Urupa and burials as a Maori Heritage Area. A1f Amend Appendix 1f to provide for the protection of identified Maori heritage sites. 2641/57 A1f Amend Appendix 1f to include Te Whau wahi tapu area (NZHPT registration ref: 7230) as a Maori heritage site. 2641/59 A1f Opposes the lack of Maori heritage sites in the Plan. For example the corner of Te Huruhi Bay including the site of Piritahi Marae 709/6, 3354/1, 3832/1 stands out as an obvious example of a Maori heritage site area. A1f Amend Appendix 1f to include explanatory text that explains the huge significance to Maori of the numerous archaeological sites 3521/150 scheduled elsewhere in the Plan.

A1g – Schedule of trees – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1g To have the kauri tree at 24 Hauraki Road, Palm Beach, Waiheke scheduled in appendix 1g 482/3 A1g To have those trees that were on the Waiheke County Council significant tree register included as scheduled trees in appendix 1g 482/2 A1g To have the stand of taraire on the seaside at the beginning of Cory Road, Waiheke scheduled in appendix 1g 482/4 A1g Add the puriri/pohutukawa tree at Kennedy Point Road to the tree register (appendix 1g) 1245/10 A1g Add the Kauri Grove within the Onetangi Reserve to the tree register (appendix 1g) 1245/11 A1g Remove Phoenix Palms from the list of scheduled trees. 562/5, 657/5, 745/5, 866/5, 930/5, 1025/5, 1164/5, 3616/5, 3649/5 A1g To protect any Cupressus macrocarpa worthy of protection by the Scheduling of any individual Cupressus macrocarpa considered 1174/3, 1184/3, 1277/3, 2647/3, worthy of protection (if there are any) under Appendix 4 section 6 of the proposed Plan (rather than by general protection). 3613/3 A1g That the taraire stand at 6 Giles Road, Palm Beach continue to be protected as scheduled trees under the proposed Plan, as they 2/1 are under the operative Plan. A1g Remove Phoenix palms and Norfolk pines from the list of scheduled trees 863/5

Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 9

A2 – Heritage schedules for the outer islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A2 Withdraw Appendix 2 of the notified District Plan and all consequential and related sections and paragraphs, in respect of Great 1349/2, 1382/2, 1419/2, 1446/2, Barrier Island, with the intention of consulting with residents and landowners on the island to produce a heritage plan for Great 1477/2, 1497/2, 1500/2, 1506/2, Barrier Island which has wide support from the residents and landowners. 1555/2, 1934/2, 1965/2, 1969/2, 1985/2, 2147/2, 2163/2, 2171/2, 2176/2, 2198/2, 2208/2, 2257/2, 2275/2, 2314/2, 2342/2, 2349/2, 2361/2, 2406/2, 2416/2, 2422/2, 2473/2, 3640/2, 3684/2, 3756/2, 3763/2

A2a – Schedule of archaeological sites – outer islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A2a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/4 archaeological sites on in appendix 2a and amend the maps accordingly: Archaeological sites DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location S8/3 2696510 6550773 Headland Pa-Tirikakawa Tirikakawa S8/4 2695127 6552095 Headland Pa-Parihakoakoa Parihakoakoa S8/5 2696619 6551842 Headland Pa Hamilton track S8/73 2695600 6551320 Garden system Te Waikohare Stream S8/74 2695773 6551401 Headland Pa Hamilton track S8/116 2696600 6551010 Garden system Tirikakawa Stream S8/121 2697863 6550213 Headland Pa Awaroa S8/126 2698292 6550128 Headland Pa Southern coast S8/132 2695100 6554900 Stonework complex Te Hue S8/133 2695100 6554900 Stonework complex Te Hue S8/138 2695685 6551488 Garden system Te Waikohare S8/303 2696945 6550515 Headland Pa Lamb Bay A2a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/5 archaeological sites on in appendix 2a and amend the maps accordingly: Archaeological sites DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location T9/130 2734200 6540500 Headland Pa Tryphena T8/8 2733800 6552200 Headland Pa Awana S8/295 2721450 6566950 Headland Pa Miners Head S8/316 2721497 6564542 Tuahu Stone Ahuriri S9/36 2723300 6547900 Ridge Pa Wairahi S8/292 2728300 6561300 Stonework complex Whangapoua T8/50 2730900 6555100 KTC tramway Great Barrier SF S8/397 2727623 6550720 KTC tramway & associated sites Great Barrier SF S9165 2726450 6549850 KTC tramway & associated sites Great Barrier SF T8/101 2730950 6554550 KTC tramway & associated sites Great Barrier SF T8/102 2730365 6554937 KTC tramway & associated sites Great Barrier SF T8/103 2730032 6552998 KTC tramway & associated sites Great Barrier SF T8/71 2737200 6536400 Stonework complex Cape Barrier Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 10

Code Decision Requested Submission No. T8/73 2736900 6536000 Stonework complex Cape Barrier S8/100 2723100 6556000 Warren Homestead Akapoua S8/19 2725400 6560400 Ridge Pa Great Barrier SF S8/33 2721600 6553250 Headland Pa Kiwiriki Bay S8/34 2727600 6556700 Ridge Pa S8/35 2726980 6556480 Ridge Pa Okiwi S8/49 2722200 6554500 Headland Pa Kaiarara Bay S8/56 2722709 6551678 Stone enclosure & chimney Kiwiriki Bay S9/1 2725400 6547800 Headland Pa S9/2 2725600 6546900 Headland Pa Whangaparapara S9/18 2725800 6548200 Hilltop Pa Whangaparapara T8/2 2733734 6556087 Headland Pa T8/5 2734041 6555906 Archaic midden Harataonga T8/6 2734686 6556015 Ridge Pa Harataonga T8/12 2733474 6556464 Headland Pa Harataonga S8/64 2721500 6552620 Headland Pa Wairahi A2a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/6 archaeological sites on Kaikoura Island in appendix 2a and amend the maps accordingly: Archaeological sites DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location S8/433 Hilltop Pa Mount Overlook S8/437 Headland Pa Bradshaw Cove S8/424 Stonework complex Western ridge A2a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/7 archaeological sites on Rakitu Island in appendix 2a and amend the maps accordingly: Archaeological sites DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location T8/57 2734861 6561274 Headland Pa Arid Cove T8/84 2734408 6560423 Headland Pa Shag Bay A2a A comprehensive study be undertaken to produce a further Planning Maps that shows all known archaeological sites as currently 2547/6 recorded by ARC and the Archaeological Association. A2a Amend Appendix 2a of the Plan to provide for the protection of all archaeological sites of significance. 2641/32 A2a Amend Appendix 2a of the Plan to provide reference to the NZAA site numbers. 2641/34

A2b – Schedule of buildings, objects, properties and places of special value – outer islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A2b Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/11 buildings, objects, properties and places of special value on Great Barrier Island in appendix 2b and amend the maps accordingly: Buildings, objects, properties and places of special value Doc ref Easting Northing Description of site Location S8/338 2723050 6560750 SS Wairarapa graves Onepoto S8/280 2728846 6562074 SS Wairarapa graves Whangapoua S9/48 2725200 6548100 Sawmill site Whangaparapara S9/117 2725350 6547720 Whaling Station Whangaparapara S9/46 2728200 6549100 Oreville Stamping Battery Oreville

Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 11

Code Decision Requested Submission No. Harataonga Homestead Harataonga Harataonga Settlers Graves Harataonga A2b Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/12 buildings, objects, properties and places of special value on Kaikoura Island in appendix 2b and amend the maps accordingly: Buildings, objects, properties and places of special value DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location S8/398 Observation Post Bradshaw Cove S8/402 Military bunkers & barracks Bradshaw Cove A2b Amend Appendix 2b of the Plan to provide for the protection of all buildings, objects, properties and places of special value. 2641/51 A2b Amend Appendix 2b to note in the first paragraph the hugely incomplete nature of this schedule. 3521/152 A2b That when the variation or plan change is introduced to the plan (see clause 7.4.4) that The Old House built by George Blackwell 3713/1 at 12 Medland Road, Tryphena be identified as a new heritage item & added to the list in appendix 2b (plan attached to submission).

A2d – Schedule of sites of ecological significance and sensitive areas – outer islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A2d Remove all listings in Appendix 2d, Scheduled sites of ecological significance and sensitive areas – outer islands, which are not 1405/19, 1406/19 supported by a proper assessment. A2d Use of GIS (sic) as the primary positioning and identification methodology is therefore opposed and the Plan should revert to 3061/43 traditional legal descriptions (lot and deposited plan numbers) as per Appendix C in the Operative Plan. A2d.3 Delete Appendix 2d Section 3.0 Sensitive areas - outer islands. 1309/1, 1363/1, 1496/1, 1502/1, 1509/1, 1890/1, 1899/1, 1954/1, 2167/1, 2188/1, 2249/2, 2266/1, 2312/1, 2350/1, 2354/1, 3632/1, 3670/1, 3690/1, 3734/1, 3759/1, 3797/1

A2f – Schedule of Maori heritage sites – outer islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A2f Amend Appendix 2f to provide for the protection of identified Maori heritage sites. 2641/58 A2f Amend Appendix 2f to include explanatory text that explains the huge significance to Maori of the numerous archaeological sites 3521/151 scheduled elsewhere in the Plan

A2g – Schedule of trees – outer islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A2g The Pohutukawa trees that line the northern bank of the Awana Stream, to be designated as Heritage Trees. 2547/5

A4 – Criteria for scheduling heritage items Code Decision Requested Submission No. A4 Withdraw Appendix 4 of the notified District Plan and all consequential and related sections and paragraphs, in respect of Great 1349/3, 1382/3, 1419/3, 1446/3, Barrier Island, with the intention of consulting with residents and landowners on the island to produce a heritage plan for Great 1477/3, 1497/3, 1500/3, 1506/3, Barrier Island which has wide support from the residents and landowners. 1555/3, 1934/3, 1965/3, 1969/3, 1985/3, 2147/3, 2163/3, 2171/3, 2176/3, 2198/3, 2208/3, 2257/3,

Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 12

Code Decision Requested Submission No. 2275/3, 2314/3, 2342/3, 2349/3, 2361/3, 2406/3, 2416/3, 2422/3, 2473/3, 3640/3, 3684/3, 3756/3, 3763/3 A4.1 Consider amendments to 1.0 of appendix 4 to address concerns raised regarding: the rating system being slanted towards the 2641/61 typical larger and more complex sites; the fact that visual assessments cannot be made accurately for many sites, the grouping (e) of sites; the need for (g) setting to provide for higher protection of last remnant sites; and the lack of consideration of Maori cultural values. A4.1 Amend in Appendix 4 the Criteria for scheduling archaeological sites to refer not only to community association with and public 3521/153 esteem for (Criterion J) but also to ancestral relationships held by Maori. A4.2 Add a criterion that will give priority to scheduling buildings that the community wants safeguarded. Ensure that since some of 298/6, 380/6, 568/6, 586/6, 628/6, these buildings are in private ownership, that owners are fully consulted and that they have real options prior to those buildings 634/6, 646/6, 673/6, 696/6, 706/6, being scheduled. 731/6, 736/6, 748/6, 802/6, 819/6, 828/6, 837/6, 844/6, 850/6, 858/6, 871/6, 889/6, 893/6, 902/6, 925/6, 928/6, 957/6, 1011/6, 1055/44, 1123/6, 1152/6, 1204/6, 1216/6, 1232/6, 1291/6, 1375/6, 1636/6, 1637/6, 1638/6, 1639/6, 1640/6, 1641/6, 1642/6, 1643/6, 1644/6, 1645/6, 1646/6, 1647/6, 1648/6, 1649/6, 1650/6, 1651/6, 1652/6, 1653/6, 1654/6, 1655/6, 1656/6, 1657/6, 1658/6, 1659/6, 1660/6, 1662/6, 1663/6, 2124/6, 2131/6, 2133/6, 2278/6, 2283/6, 2463/6, 2561/6, 2641/62, 2675/6, 2679/6, 2684/6, 2691/6, 2695/6, 2706/6, 2710/6, 2780/6, 2782/6, 2791/6, 2826/6, 2830/6, 2842/6, 2994/6, 3009/6, 3011/6, 3025/6, 3061/49, 3513/6, 3536/6, 3561/6, 3569/6, 3573/6, 3589/6, 3628/6, 3786/6, 3806/6, 3814/6, 3817/6, 3836/6, 3838/5 A4.4 Deletion of Appendix 4 Section 4.0 pending a review of criteria for scheduling sites of ecological significance to be conducted by 629/1, 1313/1, 1347/1, 1413/1, the Community Board in consultation with residents, owners and recognised authorities. Inclusion of a set of criteria which have 1450/1, 1478/1, 1494/1, 1504/1, community agreement as represented through the Community Board. 1516/1, 1557/1, 1585/1, 1892/1, 1964/1, 2169/1, 2181/1, 2213/1, 2219/1, 2254/1, 2277/1, 2366/1, 2374/1, 2420/1, 2447/1, 2494/1, 3645/1, 3672/1, 3735/1, 3761/1

A6 – List of threatened and unusual plant and animal species Code Decision Requested Submission No. A6.1 That the introduction to Appendix 6 be amended as follows: "This appendix contains lists of threatened plant and animal species 2514/1 Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 13

Code Decision Requested Submission No. thought to be on the islands as at June 2006. The lists also include plant and animal species that are not threatened, but which are of particular importance or interest. Species that are only found on islands that are entirely Department of Conservation estate have not been included..." A6.2 That the schedule of threatened and unusual plant species contained in 2.0 of Appendix 6 be amended to include all plant species 2514/2 identified in the Stanley et al 2005 study, and included in the list of threatened and extinct species. A6.2 • That the following plant species be included within the schedule of threatened and unusual plant species contained in 2.0 of 2514/3 Appendix 6 Ipomoea cairica (Pouwhiwhi) Cyperus insularis – gradual decline A6.3 That 3.0 Threatened and unusual animal species of Appendix 6 be amended to include the following: 2514/4 Scientific Name Common Name Threat Status Frogs and Reptiles Hoplodactylus granulatus Forest gecko Not threatened Hoplodactylus maculates Common gecko Not threatened Cyclodina aenea Copper skink Not threatened Oligosoma smithi Shore skink Sparse Shendodon punctatus Northern tuatara Sparse Invertebrates Paranephrops zealandicus Koura Gradual decline Geodorcus ithagnis Mokohinau stag Nationally critical beetle Deinacrida heteracantha Giant weta Nationally endangered Birds Gallirallus austalis greyi North Island weka Nationally endangered Apteryx mantelli North Island brown Serious decline kiwi Philesturnus carunculaturs Saddleback Range restricted rufusater Callaeas cinerea wilsoni Kokako Nationally endangered Acanthisitta chloris granti Rifleman Gradual decline Mohoua albicilla Whitehead Not threatened Pelagodroma marina maoriana White faced storm Not threatened petrel Freshwater fish Galaxias argenteus Giant kokupu Gradual decline A6.3 That the reference to the “Great Barrier Skink” in 3.0 Threatened and unusual animal species of Appendix 6 be amended to the 2514/5 “Chevron Skink”.

A7 – List of designations Code Decision Requested Submission No. A7.1T A notice of requirement for designation ought to be created to encompass the pump stations that service the Owhanake 519/2 Wastewater Treatment Plant, and the surrounding land (at the Matiatia Wharf and at Oneroa adjacent to Beach Parade) required for their operation and maintenance and added into Table A7.1, Designated sites. Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 14

A8 – Lists for hazardous facilities and contaminated land Code Decision Requested Submission No. A8.3 Delete the words "or may have" from the first sentence in 3.0 (appendix 8) 1223/2 A8.3 Change the title of 3.0 of appendix 8 to: List of contaminated land 1223/1 A8.3 Auckland City to arrange and pay for an inspection to justify their identification of any land they believe to be potentially 1223/5 contaminated A8.3.1 Remove 3.1 of appendix 8 from the Plan including any reference to it on the maps 1223/3 A8.3.1 Show on the Plan (re, appendix 8 section 3.1) the date a property has been cleared of the tag "contaminated land" and continually 1223/6 update by amending records accordingly A8.3.1 Rewrite 3.1 of appendix 8 to show only identified contaminated land 1223/4 A8.3.1 Amend the table in 3.1 List for inner islands, of appendix 8 - Lists for hazardous facilities, by adding an additional row immediately 2102/2 after the entry for 8 Tahi Road, with the following information in the appropriate columns: 'Tahi Road, 10, Waiheke, CT1333/46, Lot 8 DP14355, not investigated' A8.4 Amend the first sentence in clause 4.0 List of classifications for common substances, of appendix 8 - Lists for hazardous facilities 2102/1 and contaminated land, by amending 'table 8.1' to read 'table 9.1'

A10 – Sections 7, 8 and 9 of the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park Act 2000 Code Decision Requested Submission No. A10 Include the definitions from the HGMPA 2000 in the appendices of the proposed Plan and other relevant criteria. 2296/1 A10 Amend Appendix 10 to include Section 10 of the HGMPA, which establishes Section 7 and 8 as a New Zealand Coastal Policy 3521/154 Statement in Appendix 10. A10 Amend appendix 10 to include also Sections 10 & 32 of the HGMPA 2000. 3715/27

A11 – Sustainable design guidelines for the islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A11 That the Plan facilitates and promotes the provision of sustainable technologies, as mandated by the community, which provide for 1136/3 sustainable management, and enhancement of, air, soil and water qualities above and beyond their present conditions. A11 Delete appendix 11 and replace it with a greatly reduced schedule of technical references to specific features or guidelines which: 1315/1, 1343/1, 1373/1, 1377/1, i. Comply with the council’s current policies; 1385/1, 1392/1, 1425/1, 1451/1, ii. Broadly meet council’s current goals 1455/1, 1464/1, 1495/1, 1501/1, 1560/1, 1574/1, 1917/1, 1943/1, 1949/1, 2178/1, 2224/1, 2244/1, 2269/1, 2307/1, 2331/1, 2414/1, 2442/1, 2455/1, 2469/1, 2743/1, 2853/1, 3633/1, 3674/1, 3752/1, 3779/1 A11 Provide references to external guidelines and sources for environmentally sensitive building design and practice. 1315/2, 1343/2, 1373/2, 1377/2, 1385/2, 1392/2, 1425/2, 1451/2, 1455/2, 1464/2, 1495/2, 1501/2, 1560/2, 1574/2, 1917/2, 1943/2, 1949/2, 2178/2, 2224/2, 2244/2, 2269/2, 2307/2, 2331/2, 2414/2, 2442/2, 2455/2, 2469/2, 2743/2, 2853/2, 3633/2, 3674/2, 3752/2, 3779/2

Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 15

Code Decision Requested Submission No. A11 Publish appendix 11 as a separate publicity document which is cross-referenced back to relevant sections in the Plan. In this way 1315/3, 1343/3, 1373/3, 1377/3, this document can be kept up to date, and be used as a relevant resource without the regulatory overtones they acquire by 1385/3, 1392/3, 1425/3, 1451/3, inclusion in the Plan. 1455/3, 1464/3, 1495/3, 1501/3, 1560/3, 1574/3, 1917/3, 1943/3, 1949/3, 1959/2, 2178/3, 2224/3, 2244/3, 2269/3, 2307/3, 2331/3, 2414/3, 2442/3, 2455/3, 2469/3, 2743/3, 2853/3, 3633/3, 3674/3, 3752/3, 3779/3 A11 Delete Appendix 11 1959/1 A11 Delete appendix 11 from the plan relating to Great Barrier Island. 2528/1 A11 That council alter all the content of Appendix 11, section 1 to include: 1181/1 1 A clean and direct recognition by council of the fact of peak oil and climate change as the central and urgent core of sustainability in our lifetimes and beyond. 2. A mandate of leadership from council to approach each and every objective addressed by the Plan through the primary question of “what actions on our parts now will reduce a citys burning of fossil fuels, prepare us to face the challenges of a fossil- fuel fee economy and future, and prepare us for the coming natural hazards inherent in climate change. A11 Appendix 11 should be placed in the first part of the Plan. 1181/2 A11 That council should decide to amend Appendix 11 dealing with Sustainable Management to include a clear and cautionary 1182/1 acknowledgement of “Peak Oil” as the probable major challenge in our lifetime and a challenge without precedent in human history. A11 That the public has more education easily available about alternative possibilities for toilets that are easier on the environment as 1206/5 they do not use and then make toxic large quantities of drinking water. This water might need to be more available for gardens in the advent of climate change or peak oil as food becomes a priority, than be simply just flushed away causing more problems with septic tanks overflowing and causing problems on our beaches A11 That a new appendix 11 is written to replace the current one: 551/1 The new appendix should be of practical use in achieving sustainable outcomes in, but not limited to, the following areas: - climate change, incorporating: embodied energy in building materials and energy use over the lifetime of the building as well as the overall use of the land (eg growing edible produce reduces reliance on fossil fuels to grow and transport food to the home from where it is grown). - water collection, storage, use, re-use/recycling and disposal. The new appendix should incorporate the recommendations of the Sustainability Focus Group insofar as they are consistent with this submission. All the provisions of the new appendix should be addressed as part of an Assessment of Environmental Effects (AEE) by all applicants seeking to undertake major building work. There should be incentives offered for more sustainable applications and disincentives for less sustainable ones. The incentives should be either financial (increased or decreased fees) or in terms of development scope (increased or decreased).The incentives or disincentives should be detailed within the new appendix. Rules which would result in a less sustainable or neutral outcome for a particular site may be disregarded without penalty when an application is made relating to that site, provided that an appropriate rationale is given in the AEE. A11 Remove appendix 11 in total. 455/1 A11 Remove appendix 11 completely. 453/1 A11 That the provisions within Appendix 11 remain as non-statutory guidelines with respect to Great Barrier Island. 1405/6, 1406/6 A11 Seeks the inclusion of a section on climate change (in appendix 11), which seems to have been left out. 365/2 A11 That a recommendation be included in the appendix 11 that all new housing have a minimum of 10,000 gallons water storage to 365/1 protect the future availability of ground water for all. Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 16

Code Decision Requested Submission No. A11 The cessation of any mention of appendix 11 in regard to Great Barrier. 70/1 A11 An alternative to a sustainability appendix is to include a new part 14 headed ‘Sustainable management systems and methods’ 3061/18 setting out the various provisions in the Plan designed for that purpose in relation to each resource area eg tools and systems to achieve integrated and sustainable management of water resources A11 Appendix 11 must be upgraded to an enforceable, holistic, and credible sustainability provision that will have similar legal status 3406/2 as other parts of this plan. A11 Remove appendix 11 - sustainable design guideline for the islands 3501/14 A11.5 The Plan must encourage the generation of electricity on the island 2700/1 A11.5.4 Amend the first bullet point of clause 5.4 under the heading Modern wood-burning stoves, to state: is the best option. 3130/1, 3135/1 A11.6 Need to stop stormwater (with pollutants) gushing onto beaches and scouring them 2701/1 A11.7 Amend Appendix 11.7 - Wastewater to ensure that the material is relevant to the wastewater issues of the Hauraki Gulf Islands 3521/155 and consistent with the Proposed Auckland Regional Plan, Air, Land and Water and with current design recommendations in ARC Technical Publication TP58 (2004).

A12 – Oneroa village design guidelines Code Decision Requested Submission No. A12 Rewrite of appendix 12 so it doesn’t conflict with the commercial 1 (Oneroa village) land unit and certainty is created for land 603/5 owners. A12 Retain appendix 12 but include provision of public access to views of the beach and ocean from the buildings. 1250/42 A12.3 That the area behind Ocean View Road on Kuaka Street be used for larger scale developments that need larger floor areas by 604/1, 606/1 nature of their operations and would not be appropriate on street front of Ocean View Road. A12.6 Requests strengthening the wording of the actions in Appendix 12 Section 6.0 to be stronger than the encourage as current usage 1055/54 of the existing upgraded service lanes is not completely as intended and all instruments for achieving the desired outcome should be utilised. A12.6 Seeks inclusion of: “Servicing and parking is encouraged via off-street service lanes and parking areas with pedestrian linkages to 1055/53 shops. It is hoped that eventually service lanes and parking areas will have the appearance of the public realm – with planting, seating, lighting, and paths connecting safely and conveniently with retail on Ocean View Road in Appendix 12 Section 6.0.”

A13 – Planting guide Code Decision Requested Submission No. A13 Amend Appendix 13 to clarify why additional species of indigenous vegetation species in the list of species suitable for wastewater 3521/159 disposal areas (that do not appear in ARC Technical Publication TP58) have been included in the guide or alternatively identify any species included in this appendix that differ from those in ARC Technical Publication TP58 TS G-1 as possibly being inappropriate for wastewater disposal areas. A13 figures Amend the figure numbers in appendix 13 - Planting guide as follows: 2102/3 • Renumber figure 1 as figure A13.1 • Renumber figure 2 as figure A13.2 • Renumber figure 3 as figure A13.3 • Renumber figure 4 as figure A13.4

A14 – List of plant pest species Code Decision Requested Submission No. A14 Include the pest species listed in rule 19.2.2.1 in the proposed Regional Pest Management Strategy 2007 - 2012 as an appendix to 3607/2 the plan A14 Insert a new Appendix 14a based on Table 11.1a of the Proposed Auckland Regional Pest Management Strategy 2007. 2506/4 Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 17

A14 The plant ageratina adenophora, known as Mexican Devil weed be added to the list of plant pests in appendix 14. 314/1 A14 To identify Cupressus macrocarpa (and Pinus Radiata) particularly in Landform 1 but also Landforms 6 and 7 as plant pests 1174/4, 1184/4, 1277/4, 2647/4, (ideally listed in Appendix 14) and for ACC to offer encouragement and incentives for their planned removal and replacement with 3613/4 appropriate NZ native trees. A14 Amend Table 1 Plant pests in appendix 14 - Plant pests, by inserting the following two entries, in alphabetical order: 2102/4

Scientific Name Common Name Erica baccans Berry Heath Psoralea pinnata Daily pine

A14 Amend appendix 14 - Plant pests, by adding the following sentence to the note which appears at the end of the appendix 2102/5 (immediately after table 1): 'Erica baccans (berry heath) and Psoralea pinnata (Dally pine) do not appear in either of these documents but have been added to the list as they are particular plant pest species on Great Barrier'

A15 – Guidelines for working in the vicinity of trees Code Decision Requested Submission No. A15.1 Paragraph 2 of 1.0 Introduction should read: “Trees have an important cultural role as well as a vital ecological and environmental 1208/9 importance, given their ability to mitigate the present excess carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, which will cause climate change”. Figure A15.4 Amend the figure number App15.4 Tree function diagram, in appendix 15 - Guidelines for works within the vicinity of trees, so that 2102/6 the figure number is changed from figure App15.4 to figure A15.4 A15.3.1 Amend clause 3.1 Above ground damage, of appendix 15 - Guidelines for works within the vicinity of trees, so that the references in 2102/7 the last sentence (immediately before clause 3.1.1) are changed from 'Figures 5 and 6' to 'Figures A15.5 and A15.6'

Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 18