Appendices General Code Decision Requested Submission No. To reinstate Appendix C, site of ecological significance of the operative plan 1135/1 To make additions to Appendix C, site of ecological significance (from the operative plan), using any recent data which can 1135/2 strengthen Appendix C values, and in such a manner that can be accurately assessed and described using legal lot numbers as the starting point for recognition of a/that site Retain appendices 1-6 Heritage 2641/16 Amend the Appendices 1 to 6 (Heritage) index to include the ‘name of feature’ or similar identification information. 2641/63 Amend Appendix 1 to 6 (Heritage) to ensure all heritage items are assessed against the relevant evaluation criteria and are 2641/64 allocated the correct 'category' including R11/39, R11/123, R11/124, R11/125 - Headland pa, Motukorea. This applies particularly to heritage items rolled over from the operative plan. Supports the inclusion of appendices 13, 14, 15 in the Plan, in particular appendix 15. 366/1 Include as an appendix a set of environmental and design principles that apply to comprehensive management plans (eg. Far 618/134, 1101/19, 1284/17, North District provisions, rule 12.9.2) 1286/114, 1287/47, 1288/165, 1289/24, 2721/14, 2878/115 A1 – Heritage schedules for the inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1 Heritage items and archaeological sites on Waiheke should / must not be included in the Plan, until the following key points are 294/1 considered, determined and clarified: 1. Proof applying to all sites as to what there is in the way of archaeological findings in comparison to Incas in South America, Greece, Egypt, Rome, 2. Carbon dating and identification of any actual findings by qualified and certified independent archaeologists. 3. The indigenous people should have the most important say in heritage and spiritual values of any site. A1a – Schedule of archaeological sites – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1a Take appropriate action to remedy the shortcomings identified regarding gaps in the listing of sites of archaeological significance 298/4, 380/4, 568/4, 586/4, 628/4, eg Okoka Bay 634/4, 636/4, 646/4, 665/4, 673/4, 696/4, 706/4, 731/4, 736/4, 748/4, 802/4, 819/4, 828/4, 837/4, 844/4, 850/4, 858/4, 871/4, 889/4, 893/4, 902/4, 925/4, 928/4, 957/4, 1011/4, 1055/42, 1123/4, 1152/4, 1204/4, 1216/4, 1232/4, 1291/4, 1375/4, 1637/4, 1638/4, 1639/4, 1640/4, 1641/4, 1642/4, 1643/4, 1644/4, 1645/4, 1646/4, 1647/4, 1648/4, 1649/4, 1650/4, 1651/4, 1652/4, 1653/4, 1654/4, 1655/4, 1656/4, 1657/4, 1658/4, 1659/4, 1660/4, 1662/4, 1663/4, 2124/4, 2131/4, 2133/4, 2278/4, 2283/4, 2463/4, 2561/4, 2675/4, 2679/4, 2684/4, Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 1 Code Decision Requested Submission No. 2691/4, 2695/4, 2706/4, 2710/4, 2780/4, 2782/4, 2791/4, 2826/4, 2830/4, 2842/4, 2994/4, 3009/4, 3011/4, 3025/4, 3061/47, 3513/4, 3536/4, 3561/4, 3569/4, 3573/4, 3589/4, 3628/4, 3786/4, 3806/4, 3814/4, 3817/4, 3836/4, 3838/31 A1a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/1 archaeological sites on Browns Island in appendix 1a and amend the maps accordingly: Browns Island – Archaeological sites DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location R11/124 2679755 6483782 Headland Pa Eastern coast R11/127 2679530 6483800 Stonefield garden system SE of central cone R11/1092 2679400 6484250 Stonefield garden system SE of central cone R11/1095 2679620 6483950 Stonefield garden system E of central cone R11/1500 2679000 6484200 Midden & Stoneworking NW Flat R11/1570 2679237 6484208 Stone enclosure S of central cone A1a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/2 archaeological sites on Motuihe Island in appendix 1a and amend the maps accordingly: Motuihe Island – Archaeological sites DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location R11/148 2682930 6486712 Headland Pa-Mangoparerua Headland R11/151 2684514 6486383 Headland Pa- Te Rae o Kahu Northern coast R11/872 2683755 6484705 Flaking floor & midden Southern coast R11/876 2683620 6485264 Open settlement Orchard Bush R11/1890 2684029 6484840 Flaking floor & midden Southern coast R11/1891 2683995 6484819 Flaking floor & midden Southern coast R11/1784 2683100 6487000 Quarantine Station Headland A1a Undertake the relevant assessments under the criteria contained in Appendix 4, and on that basis include the following identified 2503/3 archaeological sites on Motutapu Island in appendix 1a and amend the maps accordingly: Archaeological Sites DOC ref Easting Northing Description of site Location R10/23 2679500 6491800 Headland Pa Western coast R10/48 2681400 6493400 Archaic midden Sandy Bay R10/51 2681000 6492700 Headland Pa Administration Bay R10/108 2680700 6491800 Ridge Pa Behind Pig Bay R10/115 2679700 6490350 Headland Pa Causeway R10/214 2679800 6490100 Headland Pa Causeway R10/337 2681500 6494100 Headland Pa North of Sandy Bay Auckland City District Plan – Hauraki Gulf Islands Section – Proposed 2006 Summary of decisions requested - relating to Appendices Part 1 to 16 Page 2 Code Decision Requested Submission No. R11/144 2679900 6489800 Ridge Pa Islington Bay R11/146 2681100 6488300 Headland Pa Emu Bay R11/147 2681100 6487800 Headland Pa Emu Point R11/218 2682500 6489000 Headland Pa Otahuhu Point A1a Immediate reinstatement of the recognition of the Historical significance of the church site at 131A Church Bay Road. 2620/1 A1a Amend appendix 1a of the Plan to provide for the protection of all archaeological sites of significance. In particular those on Ponui, 2641/31 Motuihe, Pakihi, Rangitoto, Motutapu, the Noises, Browns Island (Motukorea) and Karamuramu. A1a Amend Appendix 1a of the Plan to provide reference to the NZAA site numbers. 2641/33 A1a That once archaeological surveys and or excavations have been done on each of these specific sites that they be reassessed for 721/4 inclusion or not within the scheduled archaeological site. A1a That more effort is made to specify the exact middens, pits and terraces instead of including a large area of land that does not 721/1 have any of these features. A1a Opposes the gaps in the listing of sites of archaeological significance eg Okoka Bay. 709/9, 3354/4, 3832/4 A1a Seeks a heritage classification for the Pa site (pit and terracing) on Crosby Reserve (50 Fairview Crescent, Rocky Bay). 3176/1 Reference planning maps sheet 15, map 2. A1a Retain Appendix 1a in a manner that is consistent with the lists contained in the Auckland Regional Plan: Coastal, subject to 3521/146 amendments sought elsewhere in this submission. A1a The following item should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1a of the Plan: 2641/29 R10/1012, R10/692, R10/690, R10/687 – Delaware Rd Waiheke Island. A1a The following item should be considered for inclusion within Appendix 1a of the Plan: 2641/30 S11/1382 - Oneroa Headland pa, Waiheke A1a.3 Amend 3.0, Appendix 1a to state the following or similar: 2641/28 As noted in section 7.8.1, all archaeological sites are protected by the provisions of the Historic Places Act 1993. An authority is required from the NZHPT prior to damaging, destroying or modifying any archaeological site, whether the site is scheduled within this Plan or not. A1a.3 Amend Appendix 1a - 3.0 Notes and disclaimers to highlight (i.e with bolding or underlining) the last sentence: 3521/148 "All archaeological sites in New Zealand are protected by the New Zealand Historic Places Trust, whether listed or not". A1b – Schedule of buildings, objects, properties and places of special value – inner islands Code Decision Requested Submission No. A1b That the council re-assess the bach community (including bach 108) for category A listing in appendix 1b. 952/3 A1b Inclusion of the outhouse / long drop in the buildings scheduled for protection on Rangitoto. 1005/2 A1b Subject to full consultation with owners, schedule buildings / structures that represent the remnants of old maritime culture, namely 298/7, 380/7, 568/7, 586/7, 628/7, the old wrecks – the Rahiri is in the ARC’s jurisdiction but others such as the Patiki at the Causeway. The old boatsheds, especially 634/7, 646/7, 673/7, 731/7, 736/7, the Matiatia Kayak Sheds, and those at Oneroa, Mawhitipana Bay, and Rocky Bay. The remnants of the old wharves eg on the 748/7, 828/7, 850/7, 889/7, 893/7, Esplanade, end of Wharf Rd etc. The old public buildings namely the old Post Offices in Oneroa, Surfdale and Ostend [ Wharf Rd ] 925/7, 957/7, 802/7, 837/7, 706/7, and the community halls at Oneroa (MORRA), Blackpool, Surfdale, Ostend including the ORRA Hall, Palm Beach. Shops such as 819/7, 844/7, 858/7, 871/7, 902/7, the Oneroa Fruit & Vege Shop and Jewellers, the old butchers shops at Oneroa and Surfdale. The Beach Shops at Little Oneroa, 928/7, 1011/7, 1123/7, 1152/7, Rocky Bay, Palm Beach, Onetangi. The special / significant places and buildings such as the Alison Homestead and Coach house 1204/7, 1216/7, 1232/7, 1291/7, – Matiatia, Janet Frame’s cottage (If it still exists), the Red Cross (Oneroa), the Red Shed (Palm Beach), and the Library and 1375/7, 1636/7, 1637/7, 1638/7, Artworks.