Statements of Significance for Shortlisted Chinese Canadian Historic Places
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Chinese Canadian Historic Places Statements of Significance for Shortlisted Chinese Canadian Historic Places Left: Chinese miner’s flume at Quesnel Forks (1897) flume at Quesnel Chinese miner’s Left: D-07983 Archives B.C. near North gold Bend (c.1897) for Washing Right: E-00382 Archives B.C. Left: Sam, a vegetable vendor in Vancouver (c.1900) Vancouver in vendor a vegetable Sam, Left: B-03625 Archives B.C. Department Richmond Fire (1943) Harry Hing, Right: H-05788 Archives B.C. 31 July 2015 Revised 04 October 2016 submitted by: Denise Cook Design Birmingham & Wood Architects and Planners Liz Crocker, Salt Frog Chinese Canadian Historic Places Statements of Significance for Shortlisted Historic Places Chinese Canadian Historic Places Statements of Significance for Shortlisted Historic Places Table of Contents Introduction . 3 Statements of Significance 1 Chinese Canadian Cemeteries . 5 2 Kamloops Chinese Cemetery . 7 3 Cumberland Cemetery . 9 4 New Westminster Historic Chinese Cemetery . 11 5 Chinese Canadian Community Hubs and Clusters . 13 6 New Westminster Chinatown . 16 7 Coal Creek Park (Chinatown), Cumberland . 19 8 Chinese Businesses and Residences in Alert Bay . 21 9 Nelson’s Chinatown and Sing Chong Laundry . 24 10 Quesnel Forks . 26 11 Nam Sing Ranch, Quesnel . 28 12 Ahbau Creek, Ahbau Lake and Ahbau Bridge , near Quesnel . 30 13 D’Arcy Island Chinese Canadian Leprosy Quarantine Station . 32 14 Joss House, Lytton . 34 15 Arrandale, Mill Bay and Nass Bay Canneries . 36 16 Commando Bay, Okanagan Lake . 39 17 Tod Inlet, Vancouver Island . 41 18 Lord Strathcona School, Vancouver . 43 19 Gold Rush Landscapes in Nlaka’pamux Territory: Browning’s Flat and Rip Van Winkle Flat, Fraser River . 45 20 Dominion Immigration Building, Victoria . 48 21 Chinese Market Gardens at Musqueam Reserve #2 , Vancouver 50 2 Chinese Canadian Historic Places Statements of Significance for Shortlisted Historic Places Introduction The Chinese Historical Wrongs Consultation Final Report recommended legacy initiatives to help British Columbians understand the impacts of these historical wrongs and the achievements of Chinese Canadians. It was recommended that historic places be inventoried, and from that a legacy initiative to formally recognize significant historic places under section 18 of the Heritage Conservation Act has been developed. A public nomination process was held, and 138 nominations representing 77 places were received for consideration for recognition. On April 2, 2015, a volunteer evaluation team made up of the members of the Legacy Initiatives Advisory Council (LIAC) Historic Places working group and board members of the Chinese Canadian Historical Society of British Columbia (CCHSBC) reviewed the 77 places that were nominated by the public. The purpose of the meeting was to create a shortlist of places, organized by level of significance, to put forward to the Minister responsible for Heritage with a recommendation that places with provincial significance should be considered for formal recognition. The evaluation process followed a values-based model, ensuring that the evaluators reviewed the nominated places based on how they represent the overarching heritage values of the Chinese Canadian community in British Columbia. Evaluation was guided by a historical context statement and thematic framework that provided a summary of the history of the role of Chinese Canadians in the development of British Columbia. In total, 19 historic places were selected to be recommended to Minister Thomson for formal recognition. These places are: 1. Cumberland Chinese Cemetery 2. Kamloops Chinese Cemetery 3. New Westminster Historic Chinese Cemetery 4. Nelson Chinatown/ Sing Chong Laundry, Nelson 5. New Westminster Chinatown 6. Chinese Business & Residences, Alert Bay 7. Coal Creek Park (Chinatown), Cumberland 8. Quesnel Forks 9. Nam Sing Ranch 10. Ahbau Creek, Lake & Bridge 11. Darcy Island 12. Lytton Joss House 13. Arrandale, Mill Bay and Nass Harbour Canneries 14. Commando Bay 15. Tod Inlet 16. Gold Rush Landscapes, Fraser Canyon 17. Dominion Immigration House 18. Lord Strathcona School 19. Chinese Market Gardens at Musqueam Reserve #2 3 Chinese Canadian Historic Places Statements of Significance for Shortlisted Historic Places Statements of Significance – documents identifying the heritage values of each historic place – are included in this report. These statements were developed through historic research and consultation with members of the Chinese-Canadian community. The Statements of Significance provide rationale on why each place is considered to be significant at a provincial level and worthy of consideration for recognition. Historic Place Typologies for Recognition The nomination process also revealed that British Columbians see strong value for Chinese Canadian heritage in two types of places around the province. Both cemeteries and Chinatowns – or community “hubs” or “clusters” – received multiple nominations from communities all over B.C. In order to be able to understand the significance of each individual nominated place falling under these two types, it is important to understand their values as distinct groups. Overarching Statements of Significance are provided for both typologies in this report. 4 Chinese Canadian Historic Places Statements of Significance for Shortlisted Historic Places 1 Chinese Canadian Cemeteries Historic Place Chinese cemeteries, the burial sites of Chinese migrants and Chinese Canadians who died in British Columbia, are represented both by Chinese sections within cemeteries for the broader population and separate grounds used strictly for Chinese community burials. These cemeteries can be found all across B.C., in large cities, small communities and sites of former Chinese Canadian occupation. They range from famous Chinese Canadian sections in large cemeteries such as Mountain View Cemetery in Vancouver, Ocean View Cemetery in Burnaby, and Harling Point Cemetery in Victoria to small cemeteries and plots in smaller towns such as Ashcroft, Salmon Nanaimo Chinese cemetery. Arm and Quesnel. Some have elaborate headstones, others small in-ground markers, (courtesy of the nominator) and some show evidence of remains disinterred several years after burial and repatriated to China. Values As a group or type, Chinese Canadian cemeteries are highly significant everywhere in B.C. for their historical, aesthetic and scientific values, and are the physical embodiment of the spiritual, social and cultural practices of the people who created and used them. Offering table at Wild Horse Creek Chinese An enduring aspect of most early settlements, cemeteries play a significant role cemetery. (courtesy of the nominator) in commemorating the contribution of Chinese Canadians to the province, and for their representation of the spiritual values associated with Chinese Canadian culture in B.C. While in larger cities cemeteries may be part of a substantial Chinese Canadian community, in smaller towns they are often significantas the only historical reminder of the Chinese Canadians who lived and worked there. Chinese Canadian cemeteries are important for representing complex traditional burial practices in Chinese culture. The concept of ancestor worship honours the sacrifices and memories of deceased relatives, through visiting grave sites and providing provision for the journey to the afterlife. They often show evidence of remains interred seven to ten years after burial and None Gau gravesite in the Stanley Chinese repatriated to China, a common practice at the time for Chinese migrants. The cemetery. (courtesy of the nominator) cemeteries symbolize the traditional custom of visiting the graves of ancestors, relatives or close friends during the Double Ninth Festival, or the Qing Ming Festival, which also marks the middle of spring and a sacred day of the dead. Chinese Canadian cemeteries often have high aesthetic value through their adherence to feng shui principles, being in harmony with one’s environment and the link between the Yin and Yang worlds. These intricate principles insist on certain spatial orientation and placement within a landscape, such as a large wooded mountain behind the cemetery, an open, south-facing aspect to the of the sun, and the presence of a flowing body of water, all of which reflect the deeper spiritual values behind the location and design of these burial places. Chinese cemetery at Yale. (courtesy of the nominator) 5 Chinese Canadian Historic Places Statements of Significance for Shortlisted Historic Places Chinese Canadian Cemeteries Often symbolic of the discrimination practiced against Chinese Canadians, these cemeteries can reflect harmful societal values outside the Chinese community. Chinese Canadians were often excluded from established pioneer cemeteries or placed in segregated sections. This exclusion, and the physical removal of Chinese headstones, create an erroneous history of the past, one where only European pioneers shaped communities. Some Chinese cemeteries were entirely disregarded and were re-developed or covered by new construction, showing the minimal regard held for the spiritual and cultural practices of the Chinese community. Where Chinese cemeteries remain intact below new development, they have significant scientific value for archaeologists investigating past physical and cultural burial practices. Today, these cemeteries play a significant role in commemorating the contribution of Chinese Canadians to the province, embodying reverence for those buried