A Geographical Study of the United Nations Peacekeeping Force in Cyprus, 1964 - 1984
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Durham E-Theses A geographical study of the united nations peacekeeping force in Cyprus, 1964 - 1984 Grundy - Warr, Carl E. R. How to cite: Grundy - Warr, Carl E. R. (1984) A geographical study of the united nations peacekeeping force in Cyprus, 1964 - 1984, Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/7842/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk 2 cs. c A GEOGRAPHICAL STUDY OF THE UNITED NATIONS PEACEKEEPING FORCE IN CYPRUS. 1964 - T984. by CARL E.R. GRUNDY = WARR. The copyright of this thesis rests with the author No quotation from it should be published without his prior written consent and information derived from it should be acknowledged An M.A. Dissertation submitted to the University of Durham for the Degree of Master of Arts. December T984. I h MAR 2003 Figures 0:1 and 0:2 show Turkish mosques in the Greek Cypriot quarter of the old walled city of central Nicosia. Figure 0:2 illustrates the two main religions of Cyprus - a small mosque and Christian church located around 8 October Square only fifty metres from the Green Line. Before the inter- communal troubles of December 1963 - August T964 the two communities lived side-by-side in many parts of the island. There are numerous physical reminders of this in southern Cyprus where it is not unusual to find a Turkish mosque in close proximity to a Greek Orthodox church. r Pi<3 0:1 - 7' -Y i 0 IU •••• i ABSTRACT. The main aim of this study is to examine the role of the United Nations Peacekeeping Force in Cyprus in relation to fundamental changes to the human and political geography of the island. The political background to these changes is given some analysis but the major focus of the study is on the spatial aspects of intercommunal conflict, and the problems created for civilian life by artificial ethnic barriers, barbed wire- fences, sentry-posts, roadblocks, and other physical lines symbolizing the separation of the Greek and Turkish Cypriots0 After a brief description of the situation prior to Independence, the centrifugal forces dividing the two communities and resulting in the formation of Turkish Cypriot enclaves are discussed. In the light of these major changes U.N.P.I.CYP. had to cope with many complicated practical difficulties on the ground relating to the separate de facto territorial control of certain parts of the Republic of Cyprus by the Turkish Cypriots. This study stresses the economic and humanitarian duties of what is basically a military peacekeeping force. In carrying out these duties there are many linkages between the non-military tasks of U.N.F.I.CYP. and the human geography of the island,, Finally, the period since the forming of the de facto partition line between the two communities is considered in detail, and particular attention is given to U.N.F.I.CYP.*s activities between the two Forward Defence Lines of the National Guard and Turkish Army, i.e. in the U.N.- controlled Buffer Zone. The study then attempts to draw some conclusions regarding the likely future role of U.N.F.I.CYP., and to highlight the problems posed by the political deadlock between the two communities. There is also a short conclusion on the geography of peacekeeping, which is based entirely on this detailed case study. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS. I would like to express my gratitude to the following people for their help in my preparation of this work. To both my supervisors — Mr Michael P. Drury for his encouragement, practical criticism, and for his knowledge and love of Cyprus. And to Dr. Gerald H. Blake for his friendly support and concern at every stage of the dissertation. I am also indebted to Mr J.D. Norton, lecturer in Turkish and Director of the Centre for Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies, 1982-'83, whose kind assistance is most appreciated. To all members of U.N.F.I.CYP. who generously cooperated with me during field research in April 1984. Special thanks to Mr Stephen Whitehouse, U.N.P.I.CYP. Spokesman; Mr Gary S. Brown, Station Commander, Australian Federal Police ( Aust.civ.pol. ); Lt. Colonel Ferdinand Pelzer, Chief Humanitarian Officer ( U.N.F.I.CYP. ); Sgt. Major Jones, Second Battalion, The Royal Anglian Regiment ; and David Baylis, Operations Officer, British Contingent, Sector Two : To Mr George Karouzis, Head of the Land Consolidation Service; Mr Andreas I. Aristides, Extension Service, Department of Agriculture; and Mr Gregory Theophanides, Administration Officer, Ministry of the Interior, Government of Cyprus. To Antonis Y. Antoniadis and his family for their kindness and warmth, making my visit to Cyprus both memorable and enjoyable. To Richard N. Schofield, Jon Mitchell, Rosemary Stone, Klaus Dieter- Kreher, and Chng Kin Noi for their help in various ways during the latter stages of the dissertation and for their friendly encouragement. Finally, special thanks to my father for introducing me to Cyprus and to my mother for her constant support. iii D CONTENTS D Page Abstract i Acknowledgements « ii Contents iii CHAPTER ONE : AIMS. APPROACH. AND INTRODUCTION TO THE CYPRUS PROBLEM. D Section One: Aims and Approach 1 D Section Two; The Cyprus Problem 5 (ii): The Geopolitical Dimension 9 D Intra - Regional Level 9 D The Super-Power Level 13 The Colonial Level 14 Footnotes and References 17 CHAPTER TWO : CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS AND THE GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF GREEK AND TURKISH CYPRIOTS .. 20 ( i): The Independence Constitution... 20 (ii) : Was there any geographical basis for bicommunalism and partition ? . .0.0.0 22 Footnotes and References 37 D CHAPTER THREE : THE SPATIAL ASPECTS OF INTERCOMMUNAL CONFLICT AND THE FORMATION OF TURKISH D CYPRIOT ENCLAVES 39 Section One: The Outbreak of Intercommunal D Violence 39 Section Two: "Confrontation Lines" and !• 43 Enclaves 43 ( i): The "Green Line" 0 45 (ii): Guenyeli - Aghirda Enclave .... D (iii) : Refugee Movements and Enclave 52 Formation in Other Districts .„ (iv): The Turkish Quarters of D Famagusta, Larnaca, and Paphos. 58 ( v): The Battle for Tylliria and the Kokklna Enclave 59 iv Section Three; The Extent of Turkish Cypriot Territorial Control, and the Arrival of U..N.F.I.CYP. 60 Section Four! U.N.F.I.CYP. and the Political Geography of Cyprus. 1964 - '74 65 Footnotes and References 71 CHAPTER FOUR : PEACEKEEPING IN PERSPECTIVE 74 Section One; What is Peacekeeping and What is a Peacekeeping Force ? 74 Section Two; U.N.F.I.CYP.Vs Mandate ....„...„ 78 U.N.F.I.CYP. and the Use of Force 82 Section Three; U.N.F.I.CYP.'s Composition and Deployment 82 Physical Geography and Force Deployment ...... o 85 Political Geography and Force Deployment 86 Section Four; U.N.F.I.CYP.'s Freedom of Movement 95 Footnotes and References 97 CHAPTER FIVE : PEACEKEEPING IN PRACTICE : U.N.F.I.CYP.*s FIRST DECADE. 100 Part One Section One; Political Background. August 1964 to November 1967 100 Section Two; U.N.F.I.CYP.'a First Phase. 1964 to November T967 102 (i): Pacification Activities ....... 102 (ii): Normalization Activities 111 Economic conditions of the two communities 112 Economic Blockade 113 Freedom of Movement 115 Civilian Services 118 Agriculture 120 Industry and other economic activity 122 V U.N.F.I.CYP. measures to 123 assist refugees Part Two Section Three: Political Background. November 1967 to July 1974 T25 Section Four: U.N.F.I.CYP.'s Second Phase. November 1967 to July 1974 .... 127 (i): Pacification Activities 129 (ii): Normalization Activities 132 Separate economic development . 132 Freedom of Movement 0 134 Civilian Services 136 Agriculture 137 Industry and other economic activity 138 The refugee problem, 1968 - '74 138 Some Conclusions : T968 to 1974 and the role of the United Nations 140 Footnotes and References 143 CHAPTER SIX : THE THIN BLUE LINE AND THE "ATTILA LINE" .. 149 Section One: The Demographic and Economic Consequences of Partition .... 150 The Turkish 'Peacekeeping Operation1 or 'Invasion' 151 Demographic consequences and U.N.F.I.CYP.'s position after the August 16th cease-fire .... 156 Economic consequences 164 i) The Greek Cypriot South ... 166 ii) The Turkish Cypriot North . 171 Section Two: U.N.F.I.CYP. after the partition 175 ( i): Pacification Activities, 1974- 1984 . 177 (ii): Humanitarian and Economic Activities, 1974 - 1984 ...,0o 180 The promotion of economic activity in the U.N. Buffer Zone 182 I vi I Section Three; Case Study - U.N.F.I.CYP. Sector Two: BRIT.CON, 186 Section Four: Some conclusions concerning I U.N.F.I.CYP.'s second decade .. 191 193 I Footnotes and References CHAPTER SEVEN : CONCLUSION : POLITICAL IMPASSE AND I U.N.F.I.CYP. TWENTY YEARS ON ....<, 197 The Geography of Peacekeeping . 211 I Footnotes and References ....» 2T4 I Some notes on primary sources 216 I BIBLIOGRAPHY 217 225 I I Order MAPS . FIGURES. AND TABLES. Page I 1. Fig. 0:1 Photograph of a Turkish mosque in the Greek sector of central Nicosia ..<,...